Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Is God a Mother?, Can Modesty and Muscle Coexist?, Facing Marriage Without Fear | ACW333

May 19, 20251 hr 9 minAudio

Questions answered this episode: Can we call God “Mother” without being heretical? Is my friend’s bodybuilding lifestyle and public modesty truly compatible with Christian witness? How do I prepare for marriage without becoming anxious about its challenges? Resources: JPII Legacy Foundation Website ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. Questions answered this episode: --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- ⁠Submit your question here!⁠ --- 🎥 Check out our ⁠⁠⁠YouTube Channel⁠⁠⁠ 📚 View our ⁠⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠⁠ to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 ⁠⁠GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE⁠⁠ by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ ⁠⁠Join us on one of our pilgrimages!⁠⁠ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠ ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello. Hello everybody. This is Juan, producer of the podcast. I just wanted to give you a heads up. We are changing our podcast host so you will stop seeing new episode updates in the Ask Christopher w.com website. The podcast will still be available on major streaming platforms, but no longer on the website. So if you want to submit a question, just go to the show notes and you will find a link there to do so. God bless. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast.

Hey, Wendy. Yes. Remember last episode when the whole world knew who the Pope was, but we didn't? Right, you predicted that. What happened? Guess what? What? That's now we're now we're in the loop. Leo the 14th. Here we are, yes. It's a new day. It's a new era. And and of course, the whole world's already been talking about it for a long time, but we haven't talked about it yet on this podcast because of the

timing of our recordings. And I'm still like, I've watched a lot, a lot of videos, as you know. Yeah, interviews with his brothers, interviews with teachers he had interviews with friends from the neighborhood outside Chicago just to get a flavor for this Pope and his life and his humanity. And I'm still, I'm still baffled, I'm still processing that we have an American Pope

who speaks American English with with with obviously with ease because it's his native language. I like I can't. I still Popes are always foreign popes Popes English, if they even speak English, it's always with a thick accent. It's it's. I'm I'm struck by you saying this because you are a, a communicator through words. That's your whole passion, that's your good personality, that's your life. And I'm just struck in a new way as you're saying that the sense

of that as a, as a gift to you personally to hear his words in English and, and know that he's saying what he he absolutely means. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, there's no no issue in translation. There's no clunkiness with the the accent. It it's a gift to my heart and it. Is. It's really it's it's well, it's homey. Yeah, right. She comes from our homeland. And I, I feel like, I feel

probably like what the Polish people felt like when JP 2 was elected or the German people felt when Benedict was elected or the the Argentinian people felt when when Francis was elected. Like there's like he's one of us. It's it's a hard thing to put into words. There is this beautiful teacher of his. She must be in her late 80s because she taught him when he was in the Theological Union in

outside Chicago after after his college years, So 19, the late 70s. So you know he was. It was his Augustinian seminary formation. So he he he was in his what he would have been in his early 20s she. She was a nun in a she. Was a nun in a scripture professor, so she must now be in her late 80s, I would think. And she was just overwhelmed with with awe and wonder that that she said, I, I taught the

scriptures to the Pope. I I taught the Holy Father how to read the Bible. It's just overwhelming. It was beautiful. She had such a tender heart about it all. Yeah. What amazing times, amazing times. And I'm, I'm hopeful, I, I think we're going to get the, and I've said this on many YouTube videos already. So if you've seen me on YouTube talk about it, forgive the repeat here. But I, I, I really think we're going to get the best that Francis gave us his care for the

poor, his concern for the marginalized, which was so important to Francis and is so important to the heart of Jesus Christ. And it should be important to every Catholic. I think we're going to get the best of what Francis gave us in those aspects and others, but with with more precision and clarity, which we need about Catholic teaching. He's a Canon lawyer. He's a mathematician. He's precise in his words. Everything he's said so far publicly has been with a

prepared text, which is which is helpful. It demonstrates he he likes precision. He likes he likes to to know the words ahead of time that he's going to be using. I hope he goes off the cuff too on occasion. I just hope it doesn't become an occasion for lack of clarity, which we know was was something of a a notable point of the last pontificate. I'll just leave it at that. Thank you, Lord, for Pope Leo the 14th. We ask grace and blessing upon

Him in his humanity as he seeks to lead the Church. Lord, you have put quite the responsibility on his shoulders. All we join our prayers with all the prayers of people from all around the world who are are lifting up our new Holy Father. Thank you. Thank you for preparing him to be the successor of Peter. Yes. And what are your updates for us from the TOB Institute? The update I have is actually an an invitation to our listeners.

If you have been blessed by our work here on this podcast or any other ways that the theology of the Body Institute has blessed you, we we are in need of your help. We are in a situation where we need to make some new hires and we need to increase because of inflation. Everybody is facing that. We need to increase the salaries that we already pay our employees. We, we're in a, we're in a bit of a tight financial spot at the

institute. And I don't say that lightly, but I, I am saying it because it is a reality. And we need to, to rely on the people who believe in what we're doing to help us continue what we're doing. So if you have not yet become a patron of, of our mission and work, could you please prayerfully consider that? And there's a link in the show notes to become a patron. We, we really are in, we're trusting Lord, he's going to

provide, but how he provides is through people who believe in what we're doing. So if you're not yet a patron, would you please prayerfully consider becoming a patron? And furthermore, if you are a person of means and you believe in what we're doing, we have set up a foundation to receive larger gifts and they are tax deductible gifts. And that foundation supports our scholarship funds. It supports getting theology of the body out in a global way,

regardless of people's ability to pay. So if you are are able to support our foundation, our our real long term goal at the Saint John Paul, the second legacy foundation is to ensure that the theology of the body gets passed on not only to the next generation, but the next generation and the next generation. We, you know, people of, of my generation, our generation, Wendy, we're the first recipients of John Paul's gift. And I, I often think of of, you know, in the day of Saint Thomas

Aquinas, the, the students, the people who first received Aquinas's gift and saw how important was for the future of the Church that they ensured financially and otherwise that the teaching got passed on to the next generation and then the next generation until it became part of the fabric of the Church. I truly believe that John Paul the Second's theology of the body, if the legacy goes on to the next generation and the next, if that legacy is passed on a few 100 years from now, it's going to be part of the

very fabric of the way the Church understands herself in a similar way to the way Saint Thomas Aquinas became part of the very fabric of the church's understanding. But that's going to take an endowment to make that happen. That's going to take millions of dollars to make that happen. And that's why this foundation exists to raise that money, to raise that endowment to ensure the legacy of John Paul the Second reaches the next generation, the next, the next, the next. So please, if, if you, if you want to contribute to that, please go to the link in the

show notes for the Saint John Paul the Second Legacy Foundation. And that money will be put to very, very good use. We're, we're looking for small donors and big donors. If you're a person of means, we need some millionaires to come alongside us and help make this happen. So if you're out there listening right now and you are a person of means and you can support us with a small, medium or large donation at the foundation, we would be so, so grateful and we would, we will put it directly

to use in ensuring that the legacy of John Paul the second continues. Absolutely. Are you ready for a question? I am ready for a question from a patron. OK, this is from a patron named Rafael. Rafael, thank you so much for your monthly support, and I hope you're taking advantage of the exclusive formation that we offer our patrons. If you haven't been to your website, your portal there in a while, check it out. And I don't, I don't know why, Raphael, I'm gonna, I'm just gonna point you in the direction

of the retreat that I did with Father Timothy Gallagher, integrating St. Ignatius teaching with John Paul the Second's theology of the body. I, I don't know why. I just feel led to say Raphael. Check it out. That's awesome. Thank you, Holy Spirit. I hope it was maybe. Maybe I just pulled it out of my, you don't know. Well, here's the question, OK? I've been a loyal listener of your podcast from the very first episode until now.

Wow. And only God knows how deeply blessed I've been through your ministry. That's awesome. I've never doubted about becoming a patron. Well, thank you, brother. Recently I had a bit of a debate with one of my professors. If God created us male and female, in his image and likeness, then that means everything truly masculine reveals something about who God is, but doesn't fully capture Him. And the same goes for everything

truly feminine. Amen. Amen. Amen. It reflects something of God, but doesn't exhaust him either. Amen. So if that's the case, and if fatherhood and motherhood aren't just extra roles we take on, but are actually essential to who men and women are, in other words, every man by nature is called to be a husband and father, and every woman is called to be a wife and mother, then here's my question. Let me just add, I would say

just a little nuance to what he just said. In one way or another called the every man is called to be a husband and a father in one way or another. Every woman is called in one way or another to be a wife and a mother. That is, that is true, but with it just needs that little qualifier. The question is, can we say that God is also a mother? Would saying that be heretical? Love, love this question. Raphael, I love your thinking. I love the theological math you

are doing. So I I'm pulling out the catechism here and I know exactly where to go. This is Catechism 370. And Raphael, what you just said in part of what you were explaining about how, how did he say the something that perfections of masculinity or the masculinity and its fullness and femininity and its fullness are found in God? Everything truly masculine reveals something about God but doesn't fully capture him. Same. For truly so listen, listen to

this Raphael. This is Catechism 370. This is very important language. In no way is God in man's image. He is neither man nor woman. God is pure spirit in which there is no place for the difference between the sexes, but the respective perfections of man and of woman reflect something of the infinite perfection of God, those of a mother and those of a father and husband.

Boom, kaboom, there it is. Now I'm also going to read from Catechism 239 to begin addressing this question of can we rightly call God Mother? Here's what the Catechism says. 239 by calling Godfather. The language of faith indicates 2 main things. Number one, that God is the first origin of everything and the transcendent authority over everything. Now.

Now why is that properly fatherhood and not motherhood? That God is the first origin of everything. Theology of the body, right? Look at the very anatomy of the marital act. Human fatherhood comes from the giving of the seed. Human motherhood comes from the receiving of the seed. The origin of that seed of life

is within the potential father. That's not just biology, that's theology. Our bodies here as male and female, are revealing something about who God is and who we are right in the relationship between God and humanity. God is always masculine and humanity is always feminine. It can't be the other way around. If we're talking about the relationship between God and

humanity, we cannot say, well, the that the role of bridegroom and bride are interchangeable. Well, God could just as well be the bride and humanity. Humanity could just as well be the bridegroom. Humanity could just as well be the masculine, and God could just as well be the feminine. No, no, no, that's that. That is not communicating properly the relationship between the creator and the creature. See here's here's where we get tripped up within the relationship of creatures, male and female, you and I, Wendy, we are both equally creatures.

I am not divine in any sense of the term. I am just as much a creature as you are a creature. But God has written into the creature relation creaturely relationship between you and me as male and female, as husband and wife. He has written into that relationship an analogy that reveals the Creator creature relationship, and God here reveals Himself as Father, as

Bridegroom, in order for us to understand properly who He is and who we are in creaturely relationship to our Creator. God is the first origin of everything and the transcendent authority. This is what we mean first and foremost in biblical revelation. This is what biblical revelation means in calling godfather. And then it says at the same time, this indicates the goodness and loving care that

God has for all his children. Now listen to this. This is getting into can we call godmother? Catechism 239 continues God's No, I was about to say paternal, but the actual word is God's parental. Tenderness can also be expressed by the image of motherhood, which emphasizes God's eminence. So fatherhood emphasizes God's

transcendence. Motherhood emphasizes God's eminence. Why? Again, look at the theology of our bodies. The the father is the one who generates life outside of himself. The mother is the one who generates life within herself. And so fatherhood is an image of transcendence from the perspective of the child, right?

The father is outside of the act of generation, whereas motherhood for the child. It's such a mystery. I'm pausing here just to ponder the mystery myself. It's such a mystery for the for the child. Motherhood reveals imminence, closeness, presence, intimacy. Right. So let me read this again from the catechism. God's parental tenderness can

also be expressed by the image of motherhood, which emphasizes God's eminence, the intimacy between Creator and creature. The language of faith thus draws on the human experience of parents, who are in a way the first representatives of God for man. But this experience also tells us that human parents are fallible and can disfigure the face of fatherhood and motherhood. We ought therefore to recall that God transcends the human

distinction between the sexes. He is neither man nor woman, He is God. He also transcends human fatherhood and motherhood, although he is their origin and standard. No one is Father as God is Father. There's really precise and really important language in this section of the Catechism. And when it says God's parental tenderness can also be expressed

by the image of motherhood, it gives a footnote 62 and it cross references Isaiah 6613. And that's about the, the, the breasts of the New Jerusalem where we will all find comfort in, in drinking from the abundant breast of the New Jerusalem as an image of heaven. And it's references Psalm 131, verse 2. I don't know that off the top of my head, but I, I can imagine it's a, a reference to the

tenderness of God as mother as, or using motherhood would be a more specific way to put it, using motherhood as an image of the tenderness of God. And I make that distinction because God has revealed himself not merely through the image of fatherhood. Rather, God has revealed himself as Father. He also reveals himself through

the image of motherhood, but he does not reveal himself as mother. Right? This is a key distinction. The image of motherhood certainly reveals beautiful qualities about God, absolutely, as we just quoted from the Catechism. But God does not reveal himself as mother, He reveals himself as

Father. Why? Because motherhood is the proper creature leeway of participating in the fatherhood of God, right? Mary is perfectly revealing the fatherhood of God. How? Through her motherhood, through her motherhood, she reveals the fatherhood of God. Through her motherhood she

reveals not that God is mother, but rather her motherhood reveals the fatherhood of God. Right Motherhood, mother, mother, being mother. Let me put it that way. Being mother is proper to the creature. Being father is proper to the Creator. This is why Jesus says call no man on earth your father.

I am only father. Analogously, Wendy, you are not mother Analogously, you are mother. You are what motherhood is you. You motherhood is proper to the creaturely way of participating in generation, right? I am father only analogously to God the father. Motherhood is a proper creaturely reality. See, if we were to say that God has revealed himself as Mother,

guess what? We lose. We lose the transcendence of God. And because Mother creates from within, if God is Mother, then all of creation, if you stay with that sense of God as Mother, all of creation becomes divine, All of creation becomes God you. And if this this is inevitable, a, a, a theology of God as Mother inevitably ends in

pantheism where you start, start worshipping creation itself because motherhood is properly creaturely and God has revealed himself as Father, because God is transcendent to his creation. So are the qualities of motherhood found in God. Can motherhood be used as an image to reveal beautiful mysteries of God? Yes, yes, and yes. Has God revealed himself as mother? No, he has revealed himself as father.

I mean, I could write a doctoral dissertation on why this is the case. We don't have time for a doctoral dissertation on the podcast, so I'm going to have to leave it there. But please dig into those catechism references and do the follow the cross references in the catechism because in the margins of the catechism, when you're reading a certain paragraph, it has other paragraph numbers to go to. To look at the cross references, look up at all those cross references. Look up the the scriptures that are cross referenced through the footnotes. It'll take you on a beautiful journey. I am just a little bit in awe.

I'm not a theology student and as you're answering this question, I'm finding myself like 30 years ago in the back seat of a car where you're sitting in the front seat with a fellow theology student. I think it was Osvaldo. Osvaldo, if you're listening. Hello. You're talking about these very things, these differences of of like especially that kind of wrestling in yourselves as men with the idea of being analogously father versus a, a

woman becoming. What's your word for that? True, you're not analogously a mother. You're. Truly a mother. I'm, I'm back there going like furrowing my brow like, wow, this is complicated and it is. But I, I appreciate that there is, you know, a lot of deep reflection about deep truths that is behind that. And also that your experience as a man is different than my experience as a woman. And there's something like deep inside that can receive that in

your heart. You can, you can hear that and not fight it. You can hear it and say, OK, that I understand it. It speaks to my heart and my experience in some way. So that's like powerful and profound to me. And I, I think, you know, you've really, you know, he asked a very theological question and you've given the theology, I hope in a way that least, you know, will speak to many of our listeners. I. Hope it sparked some reflection. I know it's, for me, it's just exciting and it jazzes me.

But but I know I'm, I'm dealing with some theological categories and truths here that can, that can be confusing and, and it just came to me as you were talking. Wendy, maybe this would add a point of clarity. Do you mind if I share this now? But hold on to your thought, 'cause I know it's important. Jesus never called God his mother. Mary is his mother, right? Jesus always called God, his father.

He always called God his father. He never called God his mother. He called Mary his mother. Because motherhood is properly creaturely. Motherhood is proper to the creature. Motherhood is the proper creaturely way of participating in in God's fatherhood. Now does do I participate in God's fatherhood as a man? Absolutely but but but not in the same.

It goes back to what Jesus is saying. Call no man on earth your father. He never says. He never says and never would say. Call no woman on earth your mother. He would never say that because motherhood is proper to the creature. It is proper to the order of the earth. Fatherhood is proper to the order of heaven and God. And I participate in God's fatherhood only by analogy. You can call me father. My children can call me father only by analogy. Our children do not call you

mother by analogy, Wendy. They call you mother by by your, your proper identity. I, I don't, I don't know how better to say it than that right now. Yeah. Oh, I loved that you knew those quotes from the Catechism to share. That's really helpful to us. And I was struck by the contrast of the word transcendence and the word imminence. And I think in that we find like that there is something,

something of motherly imminence in in God. Yes, and that's exactly what the Catechism is saying. Right. And so that is deeply consoling to our hearts. Yes, yes. And we can receive that consolation, yeah. Yes, yes, we, we, we should drink in all the truths that motherhood is a beautiful image of God's imminence, tenderness, closeness, intimacy. We should drink that in as

something motherly that flows directly from God. But we mustn't identify God as mother, because that's to blur the distinction of the Creator and the creature. Analogously, we should not identify the creature as Father because that also blurs the distinction of the creator and the creature, which is why again, Jesus says call no man on

earth your father only can I claim fatherhood analogously, it it's juicy stuff. I hope I haven't confused people press into the Catechism and, and what it, what it says and, and there's especially I'm just going to say this because it's important. I'm not going to read this quote from the Catechism 'cause it would take too long. But go, go to let me find the number. It's Catechism 202779. Go to Catechism 2779 where it

talks about our need to purify our images of fatherhood and motherhood in order to understand properly who God is 'cause we all do it. We project our own wounded experiences of fatherhood and motherhood onto God, and when we do that, we get a very skewed image of God. It goes the other direction. We shouldn't project our images of our own or earthly parents onto God. Rather, we should. We should measure our earthly parents in light of God's perfection as Father, as Father,

and in his motherly qualities, and then seek God's mercy to forgive our own earthly parents for the skewed notions we have of God that come through their own woundedness. And you and I, Wendy, we've been through that with their own kids and still need to go through it with our kids. How our own broken humanity skews in our children their perception of God. I think we'll leave it at that. Bless you, Raphael, for that really fun question. I enjoyed answering it, at least I hope I did give some helpful

food for thought for our listeners. Hello. Hello everybody. This is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on tour this year. We're going to places like New Mexico, Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Illinois, and also other countries like Ecuador and Brazil. We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our events schedule in the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Peace. Our next question is from a listener named Helen. Hello, Helen. Hey Christopher and Wendy, I first want to say how deeply grateful I am for your podcast

and the work that you do. I love every episode. I grew up Protestant, attending a Christian School. I had a best friend with whom I was extremely close. We considered each other accountability partners, a trusted person to whom we confess our dirty sins and try to encourage. We deeply love each other as sisters in Christ. That's beautiful. I became a Catholic about two years ago. Our lives have taken very different paths.

What used to unite us, school, sports, music, hanging out simply aren't there anymore. Not only that, but my views on topics like birth control, drunkenness, and purity in general have drastically changed to the point where it's hard to have any kind of casual conversation with her and other friends because they talk about those things a lot. I'm now a practicing Catholic who's constantly striving to live a holier life. I think much more deeply about

things I used to never consider. I have a husband and two kids, while she says she never wants kids. This leads me to my question. My friend is now a competitive figure bodybuilder. This involves extreme dieting and exercise as well as posing in very little clothing and high heels in front of an audience and judges. She also has social media where she posts pictures of her body and also promotes a a Bible study that she put together.

She's told me that she's trying to bring Jesus into a dark space, but I feel like she's almost defiling Jesus by showing her body to the world. I have questions. What does TOB say about purposefully reducing your body fat to the point of no longer having periods? This is something I would have never thought twice about before, but I'm troubled by it now. Also, I feel deeply in my heart that what she's doing is immodest and after a time of prayer and discussion with other

trusted people, I have confronted her about posting it on social media. She seemed to take it well, but she considered she continued posting the same things. She claims it's just a body and it's for a sport so it's OK. How can I approach this further? I feel like I'm being holier than thou, especially because I used to think the same way she does and I'm still working through my own beliefs on modesty and what that means for me.

Practically, I feel like I'm losing a close friendship that I've had for most of my life. I'm the first Catholic in my family and friends, so I've lost other relationships. I just don't know how to approach these conversations with people who are Christians but don't understand the true meaning of our bodies. Bless you, dear sister Helen. Gosh, these are tender, tender places in your heart and sensitive and painful. I feel your love.

I feel your love for your dear friend. I truly do. I, I feel you. You're, you're wanting to navigate this with, with fidelity to what is true because you have come to a deep conviction in your own life that the truth heals and sets people free. And I think you're, you're wrestling with her very different values regarding the

body. And it's painful to you to see because you've experienced new freedoms, new appreciation of your own femininity, new appreciation of the gift and mystery of fertility, which is integral to the theology of our bodies. It reveals something essential of the mystery of God. Infertility should not be something we rejoice in. It should be something that is

sad to us and and some of the most bitter suffering I've encountered in people's marriages in this ministry over the decades we've done it is is the suffering of infertility. But what that reveals when people are suffering because they're infertile, unable to conceive, the suffering reveals their proper appreciation of the gift of fertility. That's why it hurts so much when when someone is like she said,

your friend said, I don't want to be a mother. And she's living in such a way, eating in such a way, exercising in such a way that that she has literally become incapable of motherhood in her present state because she's not cycling. She has such little body fat in in, in her being as a woman, her body as a woman. She's lost her menstrual cycle. When a woman cycles, this is a sign of health.

This, this is a healthy, functioning woman's body. When you're in the years of fertility, it is healthy to be cycling. If you are not cycling, something has gone wrong. So you are right, Helen, to have alarm bells like something is not right, you are right, something is not right, that is right. And then the question becomes how, how do I love my friend? How do I navigate my conviction that she's doing something that

is not good for her and it's not good for others? That she has bought into a a paradigm, a vision, a story about the human body. That is not a good story. That is a story that leads people astray. This the story that says use your body to get attention. Use your body in such a way that you know you're promoting a a message that is not true to what womanhood is.

You, you the alarm bells that are going off in you. I want to affirm you are not crazy to have these alarm bells going off. The question of can a woman pursue a certain sport that demands a certain level of fitness? Yes, yes a woman can. But if the fitness required for that sport ends up nullifying her very womanhood, her body as a woman ends up being physically

unhealthy. And if you're doing something to your body that cancels out your cycle, you're doing something that is is unhealthy for your body as a woman. So that is not a sport that is good for a woman to to do that to her body. So, so yes, your concern, your concerns are valid. So the question becomes, Helen, how? How do you share your convictions without coming across as holier than thou?

Can I say something about that actually? Yeah, yeah, please. I was just hearing that particular, I don't know, hesitance in Helen. I feel like I'm being holier than thou, especially because I used to think the same way. I just feel like that maybe sort of a, an accusing voice that you're imagining. If I try to share this from my heart, my friend remembers when I used to think more like her and she might use that

accusation, Well, aren't you being holier than thou or something as a, as a defense to not let what the truth that you're sharing penetrate her heart? And so I think you're almost like taking that into yourself and saying, well, she might accuse me of that. Maybe it's true. And yet the whole idea of being holier than thou is kind of just a, I don't know, it's like a way of negating the, the progress that grace has allowed you to

make in your life. And, and it's, it's not in any way coming from a, a desire to, I don't know, kind of make your friend feel inferior that you want to talk about these things. It's. A wanting to share something that upholds her dignity and goodness and allows that to be a true force motivating her choices in her life, her dignity, her goodness, the ways that God created her to be a

gift to others that she's kind of, it's gotten so twisted. And so instead of being a gift that lifts up the hearts of others, it it feeds as Christopher, you put it so well when you're just talking there earlier about the, the, the false story of, of our bodies that it's promoting. So I just wanted to like respond to that particular concern that

Helen has and just kind of go in a little bit deeper into like, where is that coming from? And can you recognize that that's not your true heart, that you, you are not desiring that your friend would feel inferior in any way to you. So I just, I just wanted to mention. I am so glad you shared that, Wendy. I was sensing something very similar, but I wouldn't have been able to articulate it as well as you just did. That, that holier than thou is an accusation. That's, that's coming from an, an unholy spirit that wants to

shut this conversation down. And it's a barrier. It's a barrier to true communication and, and love and, and Wendy and I can sense your heart here, Helen, the great love you have for your dear friend. And, and it's, it's love that she's looking for, but she's looking for it in a misguided way. Could you imagine having a conversation with her in which you affirm what she's really looking for? Right? What's she really looking for?

She wants her body to be seen, known, and affirmed as good. That's what she wants. That's what everybody wants. That's what everybody wants. We want our humanity, which is revealed in and through our human bodies. We want our humanity to be seen to be affirmed. We want to be told our humanity, our bodies are good, right?

God looked at everything he made. He looked at our creation as male and female and he said, behold, it is very good. It's very good. That's what she desires, that's what she's after. But she has bought into a very distorted vision and story about how she will receive the love and affirmation of her body that she desires right. The God looking at his creation

and saying it's very good comes in the context of our creation as male and female in the call to be fruitful and multiply. Somewhere along the line, an enemy's voice got in her mind and heart and and told her that it's not good for her to be a mother. That's a lie. That's a lie. The enemy is after the image of God revealed through our bodies, and it is the call to fatherhood

and motherhood that in a very particular way reveals this image of God. It's not the only way the image of God is revealed to us, but it's a very particular and shall I say potent way that the image of God is revealed in US. And the enemy has been after her femininity in this direct sense. He's, she's been after her cycle, he's been after her fertility. He wants her to, he wants to shut it down and he wants to promote in her mind and heart a, a, a path to affirmation of her body that actually negates the

true beauty and dignity and goodness of her body as a woman. A, a woman who posts pictures of herself in, in barely nothing for all the world to see, does not know the true beauty, the true dignity, the true splendor, the true sacredness, the true goodness of her feminine body. And that is not a judgement on her as a person. It's it's a statement of truth

that she doesn't know, and she's looking in the wrong place for the affirmation of her body. She's looking in the wrong direction to be told she's lovable and beautiful and good. She's looking to the wrong voices for affirmation. She's looking for the affirmation of the voices on social media. She's looking for the affirmation of judges on a panel who are scrutinizing every last inch of her body. She's looking in the wrong

places for affirmation of her body. Her desire for affirmation of her body is beautiful and good. But where she's looking for that affirmation, she's looking for love in all the wrong places, looking for love in too many faces. And you can affirm and bless the desires underneath all of this and you through your own love and your own witness and your own growth and holiness, which does not mean holier than thou, right?

It, it, it, it holiness is leading you to love her more. And love speaks truth. It speaks truth with compassion, with understanding, with tenderness. But it speaks truth. It speaks truth to set people free. She's in chains. She's in chains. And your ability to speak truth in love. And just before you speak to her, pray Lord, give me your love for her. Help me to see her as you see her, right? Think of the way Jesus looked at the sinful woman who, who comes

running into Simon the Pharisee's house, right? And, and Simon the Pharisee's indignant, right? He's that holier than thou attitude, right? If he were a prophet, he would know what kind of woman this is, right? That's this, this air of superiority. What is true holiness? Jesus is the truly holy one in this situation. And what's his approach? He says, Simon, do you see this woman? And the scripture says Jesus is

looking intently at the woman, but he's talking to Simon. Simon, do you see this woman? No, Simon's holier than thou superior attitude blinded him in his crippled him, blinded him. He couldn't see. He was crippled in his ability to see her. It's Jesus's holiness that allowed him truly to see that woman, to see what she had been looking for in all the wrong places and to offer her exactly

what she had been looking for in all the wrong places. You can do that too, Helen. You can look at your friend with those eyes of Christ and with compassion you can see her. And in seeing her, she might put up her defenses, she might reject what you're saying, she might you, she might even accuse you of this or that. But if you look at her with eyes of love, she will never forget the look of love she saw in your eyes, and it will haunt her in a good way.

Be not afraid. Yeah. And I just want to encourage you, Helen, in all that we're sharing. It's it's meant to minister to your heart and the way that your friend's story has brought up just questions for your own story. It is also meant to help your friend like they're both true, but but you don't have control over how your friend receives and responds to things shared in love. And and there's also just that element of surrendering her to

the Lord in your prayer. That is so important that we don't, you know, give you the wrong impression that somehow if you get this all right, that this will be perfectly understood. Now you know by your friend and there's there's a certain part that just has to say, OK, here's where my heart is and in my love for her. I I have this to say this way to respond to her, but but also trusting in like her freedom and allowing the Lord to work in her

life in part through you, in part through others, and to to surrender that story to the Lord. Well said, Wendy. And and I'll just add one final point. I don't think there's an urgency here for you to speak. I think the door will open in due time and I think you will recognize when the door opens that it's the time to speak What, what is on your heart. If you force the door open, if you force the conversation, it it probably won't won't go well. So just wait on the Lord for him

to open the door for the conversation to happen in, in his timing, in His way, organically and, and, and naturally and, and peacefully. Amen. Our next question is from a listener named Isabel. Hi, Isabel. Hi Christopher and Wendy, my boyfriend and I have been seriously dating for about a year. Bless you guys. And I found out about your podcast because he listens weekly. As we continue to discern marriage, I've started to do a lot of reading and listening to

Catholic sources such as your podcast that teach about marriage. This has been fruitful for me, but I have found that the more I hear heartbreaking stories about the suffering couples experience in marriage, the more I become anxious about similar bad things happening to me or my future husband. I'm struggling to reconcile the idea of mentally preparing for the unknown trials of marriage while not letting anxiety take over my mind.

I find myself trying to lessen my excitement for marriage because I hear over and over that marriage is so hard. Do you have any advice for me? I want to take marriage very seriously, but I also want to believe the CS Lewis quote that man is more himself, Man is more man like when joy is the fundamental thing in him and grief the superficial. Bless you, Isabel. Bless you, Isabel.

Bless you, Isabel. Bless you, Isabel. Bless you, Isabel. Bless you, Isabel I She's just a young woman confronting life. You know, I I wanted to include this question, I think because in my heart I have wondered that about our very podcast at times, Like is this a, is this a burdensome for some younger listeners to be hearing some, you know, struggles of people in different parts of their

journey? Yeah. So I should kind of put words to something that's been an unconscious question of mine. I'm just being honest about that as well. Yeah, I get all of it. I get all of it there. And there's no, there's no sparing anyone. The fact this is factum, this is fact that life funnels us towards the mystery Calvary.

It just does. And what Isabel is wrestling with is what every human being wrestles with. That fact life funnels us towards Calvary, and Calvary is is is the mystery of suffering writ large. It's the mystery of all human suffering concentrated in its

most condensed, plain form. It's all the horrors that have been dished out throughout all the centuries of human history. It's all that every human being has ever suffered in concentrated form right there, born in the body of Jesus Christ. But here's the good news. And this is the source of our joy.

This is the source of our true joy. Not that suffering doesn't exist. That's false joy. That's pretend, that's make believe. That's that's the ostrich with its head in the sand, right. Joy is not the absence of sorrow. Joy, true joy comes from and this is just as much a fact, a factum that that funnel that

leads us to the cross does not end there. That funnel keeps going through the cross into glory, into transfiguration, into glorification. And the very thing that gets glorified is our suffering. It's not that we're only suffering. It's not all that gets glorified. All our humanity gets glorified. But what shines in a particular

way on the other side of of Good Friday, Easter Sunday, namely, what shines on Easter Sunday, is the glory revealed through the transfigured wounds of Christ's resurrected body. The joy comes from not a false promise that you won't suffer. The joy upon which the entire Christian life is based and Christian marriage. The joy upon which we can build

our entire lives as a solid foundation. This is the rock upon which we are to build our lives that Jesus talks about. The rock upon which we are to build our lives is Christ, and Christ is the crucified and resurrected Messiah, the crucified and resurrected. 1 He is Adam, meaning all humanity. He is Adam who has borne all of humanity's suffering and come out the other side dancing, dancing with a glorified resurrected body.

And if you live marriage as God designed it to be, it will. I can't spare you this. I can't pretend it's not going to happen. It is going to happen. It's going to funnel you towards the cross, but through that cross, it will pop you out the other side in glory, in glory. And you will say, as Christ says and every St. says and every person who's been through the cross and come out the other side has said, it's worth it. It's worth it, It's worth it,

It's worth it. It's absolutely worth it. We have two of our children already married and we have one more getting married next month. And, and what I want to say to each and everyone of I can't spare them the sufferings, they're coming, but it's worth it. It's worth it. Wendy, you and I, we know 30 years of marriage, almost 30 years of marriage, there has been a lot of suffering. And, and we would both say, and

we both say it to each other, we give our yes every day 'cause we have seen that it's worth it. We have seen what the Lord has done with it. We're not in our glorified bodies yet, but the Lord and His graciousness gives us little taste of glory even here. And we have a track record that we can look back and we can say, yes, we have. We have felt those thorns in our skulls. We have felt those nails through our hands. We have felt discouraging. We have felt the Lance through the side in learning how to love, love one another as I have

loved you. Dear Isabel, dear Isabel, life, life funnels you to the cross. But why did Christ endure the cross? For the joy set before him, Christ endured the cross. I've been looking for a detour my whole life. I have not found 1 and I have become convinced that there is not a detour around the cross. The joy that I want, the joy that you want, Isabel, the joy

that every human being wants is on the other side of that cross, and the cross is the path to the joy. What must that joy be that Saint Paul could say? I consider all the sufferings of the human race from the beginning of time to the end of time as nothing compared to the glory. What is the joy that awaits us that could lead St. Faustina to say she got she got

a a vision of the different degrees of glory in heaven. And she said, Lord, give me one more degree of glory in heaven, and I will endure all of the suffering of all of the martyrs combined. What madness and insanity is that? What did she see that would lead her to utter such madness and insanity that she would say, I would bear all the suffering of all the martyrs combined to have one more degree of that joy, one more degree of that glory, one

more degree of that bliss. For the joy set before him, Christ endured the cross. Be not afraid, Isabel. Be not afraid. Be not afraid. Don't place your hope in the false promise that you won't suffer. Place your hope in the promise, sure as a solid rock, that all of your trials, all of your sufferings, all of your sorrows, they themselves will be transformed into joy. They themselves will be redeemed. They themselves will shine with

glory. And it's not just and it's not just the cross, then the then the joy. No, the Lord in his tenderness and mercy gives us taste of joy all along the way. The agony and the ecstasy is all kind of intertwined. It's, it's all combined. It's all, it's all in there. And and the the agony carves us out to experience more of the joy. I'll, I'll end my reflection here. And then Wendy, I know you have thoughts you want to share, Teresa Vavillis says. That the Lord teaches us courage

in the prayer of agony, because we need even more courage to endure the prayer of ecstasy. What kind of ecstasy awaits us? Something that makes all the agony totally worth it. Totally worth it. I I love just your really illuminating what is meant by those words. The Paschal mystery because it's, it's, it's Christ's

suffering, death and resurrection in history. But it's so central. We live it in our lives. We experience it at every Mass, like Paschal mystery, and you were just kind of laying that out. So yeah, this is that that. Is this correct? So that that's really powerful. And I just want to acknowledge something to Isabel and to our listeners that when we were engaged and in our early years of marriage, we did have a

certain hope, expectation maybe that that somehow we were going to not suffer because of kind of being more in touch with God's plan. So I just want to acknowledge that that kind of youthful misperception is in our story as well. Yes, it is. So and that that was part of our suffering to go through that re, you know. Adjustment, yeah, yeah.

So I just want. To Yeah, But I also want to say this about the questioners and the people who send, you know, their story to us. A couple things I want to say about that one is that I I am utterly convinced that the experiences we have in life where we feel maybe something like abandoned by God in that we unconsciously or consciously

have this feeling that because God loves us. Well, if you love us, you'll give me this and that which I long for, you know. And so if, if this and that are not happening, there's like a feeling of where are you, You know, Lord, like, don't you love me? What what's going on here? That those times in our lives are pivotal moments where our faith is tested and where grace is abundantly available. But the evil one knows our

vulnerability and and so there are many people who have been in times of suffering that were opportunities of grace and they they went a different direction. You know, they listen to the wouldn't it be easier? Wouldn't you feel better if you know so many people who have sterilized themselves? You know, that was that moment of suffering and questioning that they, they, their faith was tested and they they didn't open

to the grace available, you know, and the and evil 1 was there and ready with this easy fix, this easy answer. That's just one type of example. There's so many in our lives in every human story where so we can be afraid, we can kind of get stuck on the fear of if I suffered that, that would overwhelm me. I wouldn't, I would fail the test. Oh, God, don't test me. That way. Those kinds of fears can come up in US. And, and I hope that by

listening to our podcast over and over again, you start to get the sense that, wait a minute, those moments, God is there. God is ready to help. He is ready to rescue us from drowning and, and sometimes the very experience of putting your question in into words and submitting it on our podcast is that moment of faith where you're saying, OK, this is so

hard. But I, I, I believe there's help from the Lord. And even if we don't get that question on our podcast, I really believe that the people who've taken the time to to just put it out there, they're already opening their hearts to grace and Lord is going to enter into that. It's already a prayer. It already is. It absolutely is. So Isabel, I know it. It is. It's natural to hear about some really hard things and be

afraid. Like that's natural. That's that's OK and you don't have to listen for a time. You know, you, it's not like I think everybody needs to listen to our podcast. If if that fear is great, but but what you can do is like, let that sink in. Grace is there, the Lord is there. The Paschal mystery in our lives is a reality that we all experience and God is always faithful.

He cannot be unfaithful. So I, I hope that that, that some of that just kind of illuminates what like a fundamental message of this whole podcast is as why are we listening to people's stories of, of different sufferings? Because they maybe they need help to recognize the grace that's available or to to sort through the confusing messages that are coming at them at a time of crisis. Like to trust that the Lord will be there for you in your times

of need is so essential and has been like it is why we're still married 30 years later. Because we've believed it, we've seen it, we've believed it, we've seen it over and over again. Amen. Well, yeah, the the the Paschal Mystery podcast, this is what this is. It is because that that is the answer to all of our questions. It in fact, if if you are

receiving an answer to a trial or a suffering in your life that that does not take you through the cross, you know where that message comes from. What did Jesus say to Peter when Peter said you don't have to go to the cross? Get behind me, Satan. The cross is our salvation. The cross is our salvation. Follow me, Jesus says follow me. This is the way. This is the way to all the joy you desire. This is the path through the cross, not around the cross, through the cross.

And there, and I'll just end with this. There's a great lesson in the three people who were crucified that day. The guy in the middle, we all know him. He's Jesus. The guy on the one side, the the one criminal wants to be saved from the cross. The guy on the other side realizes, no, I'm going to be saved through the cross. The one guy says, if you're the son of God, save yourself and us. In other words, get us off this cross. And the other guy says, have you

No Fear of God? This man's done nothing, and yet he's here unjustly. Something's going on. This has got to be some. This is the Savior, and this is part of how He's going to save us. Remember Me. Remember Me when you enter your Kingdom. You know what JP 2 says about that criminal? He's the first canonized St. canonized directly by Jesus himself. Don't desire to be saved from the cross. Desire to be saved through the cross.

Lord. Lord, you know, You know how I have resisted the cross in my life. Forgive me. Teach me, teach me, teach us all, Lord, how to embrace the crosses you send us as the path to our glorification, as the path to all the joy we yearn for and desire. Amen, Amen. Amen. This is the gift He has for us. It does involve the cross, but it leads to glory. This is the gift that you are to the world.

The witness to how the Lord brings flowers out of our wounds. That's the gift that we are, and the grace is always there. To become what we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W. It's brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors.

If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode