Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

The Man’s Seed & Pregnancy, Why the Eucharist Awakens a Desire for Marriage, When a Fiancé’s Sexual Past Breaks Your Heart | ACW374

Mar 2, 202651 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: I understand that the only place for a man’s seed is the woman’s garden, but what about during pregnancy? Since it’s not possible for the couple to conceive another child, I’m not sure if or why it would matter. I’ve always had a special devotion to Jesus in the Eucharist and knew from a young age that it is truly His body, blood, soul, and divinity. I receive Him with great joy, awe, and delight, but sometimes after Communion I feel an ache in my heart for an earthly spouse. By God’s grace, I’ve remained chaste for 38 years and would joyfully give my virginity to my future spouse if God wills marriage. Why might this desire arise after receiving the Eucharist? My fiancé and I were taking one of our pre-Cana classes together when the topic of sexual intimacy in the past came up. I asked if he had ever had sex, assuming that because we’re both Catholic, we had both saved ourselves for marriage. He told me he had sex with several women in his past, deeply regrets it, and is now re-waiting for marriage with me. This broke my heart, and I’m still healing. How can I regain trust and heal from this? Resources: ⁠Event Schedule⁠ ⁠Good News About Sex & Marriage⁠ --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠⁠ --- ⁠Submit you question here!⁠ --- 🎟️ ⁠Event Schedule⁠ 📚 ⁠⁠⁠Course Schedule⁠ 🏔️ ⁠Pilgrimages⁠ 🧠 ⁠⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Our faithful listeners know that I've been. Of late. Sharing with you guys an app. Called truthly Truthly. We've entered into a partnership with Truthly. I believe in what they're doing, they believe in what we're doing and our audience who is familiar with asking questions about the Catholic faith. You guys. Should really know about this. App called truthly TRU. THLY faithful to the Magisterium, rooted in scripture, thinking with the

mind and heart of the church. You can go on truthfully. And ask any. Question about the Catholic faith and you'll get an Orthodox answer using all the technology of artificial intelligence and putting it to. Very good use. I've been using. Truthfully, just to. Poke around and see what kind of answers they come up when when I type in certain questions. And I've been impressed, I've been impressed. They're doing good stuff and I think it is definitely worth our just shouting out to our audience and say give it a try,

you can get A7. Day free trial by. Just going to wherever you get your. Apps the Google Play spot. If you're an Android person or go to the App Store on the iPhone and learn more. About what the good folks are doing at truthfully. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Welcome everybody to another

episode. Yes. Hi listeners. This is the Ask Wendy W podcast hosted by Christopher W It should be. I'm happy to host and happy for you to answer. We had a really fun couples getaway. We don't do that very often. We should do it more often. It was really nice. It was. Tell him. Tell him why you took me to this special place. Oh. Yeah, it. Was your Christmas gift to me. It was it was a beautiful place. I had been there myself a few

years ago with my friends Mary Ellen and Andrea. If you're listening, shout out love you. And when we were there, I said to them, Oh, Christopher would love this place. And I mean, it was beautiful setting, just peaceful. The I don't know the right feel. That's a hard thing to capture. But one of the things that was so special about it was that there were a number of buildings, old log hewn log buildings Christopher loves.

Those love, love, love old log buildings, old barns, old cabins. We live in a 200 plus year old hand hewn log cabin tucked in the woods here in Pennsylvania. And this was the other side of Pennsylvania towards Pittsburgh. And there are a lot of old log homes, 202 hundred, 5300 years old out there. And this property where we stayed, this what's is what is it a lodge?

Is it a? It's? Called. Yeah, Oh, yeah. Oak Lodge, they had moved a lot of these old buildings to that property. They take them apart and then they reassemble them. And they had built a gorgeous Chapel using these old logs. It was one of the most beautiful buildings I've ever been in. But that's not exactly what we wanted to share with you. A little tidbit anyway. But when we were in Western Pennsylvania, we visited 2 museums and we'll tell you about the other one maybe in our next

episode. But right now we just wanted to share very moving experience. We went to the memorial of Flight 93 from 911. And if you don't know the story here, maybe if you're from outside the US, you might not know this history, but I'm sure you've heard of 9/11. Obviously, when the terrorists flew into the World Trade Centers with two planes and flew into the Pentagon. But there is a fourth plane that was hijacked and passengers were

forced to the back of the plane. And they called loved ones and learned about these three other planes, two of which flew into the World Trade Centers and the one that flew into the Pentagon. And they realized, Oh my, we are, Oh my, how do you even say, Oh my, in this situation? It's more than an, Oh my, we're on a suicide flight. These people are going to kill us all. They're going to kill themselves and kill us. And they realized they were headed for Washington, DC. And four men, four or five men

stormed the cockpit after the terrorists had killed the pilots and taken it over to, to prevent them from crashing into probably the White House or, or the Capitol building. And this plane went down in a field in western Pennsylvania. There's a museum there now. And it was really moving. What, what were some of the things that spoke to you in particular, Wendy? It was yeah, I the very first thing that got me just really to the core was just that they had

the unfolding news reports playing there. And so because we lived through it, it certainly brought me back there to that day. And just the the confusion about what was going on and then the unfolding realization of the incredible amount of just casualties and deaths from the whole attack. That was that was the first thing that really got my heart. And then and learned so much

about the flight itself. And yeah, the the people in the area who were impacted by this crash. It was, it was really moving and so much heroism. The part of the exhibit that really moved me, and I know it moved you too, was listening to a few of the recorded messages when people called from the airplane, some of them, you know, where their loved ones were not home and they got

recorded on an answering machine. And we listened to three of them. It was remarkable how calm they were telling their loved ones this is goodbye. One was saying, here's the combination to my safe in the closet. And you would, you know, you would think they'd be bawling or emotionally out of control, but they were pretty calm and collected and saying goodbye to their loved ones.

It was very moving. Well, and even there like certainly some of the people, you know, their voices cracked as they, as they said things like tell my children, I love them. But the the way in which being in that situation, just kind of focus them in on what is most important. Like whatever they were about on that airplane wasn't what was most important anymore.

And that I think that has that impact on all of us to think about what is most important. Yeah, if you want to learn about the events of that Flight 93, there's a movie, Hollywood movie called Flight 93, a dramatization of what happened. And it's it's really worth watching. Amazing what those people lived through. Yeah. So having shared that, which was by the way, you know, obviously it's a sober topic, but I think for me and Christopher, there was also just a some beauty

about being there together and about just the shared experience, even though it was an experience of. Tragedy. Utter tragedy. And sadness that that was also a gift for us to have that shared experience. Anyway, I'd love to know if you have any updates from the Toby Institute to share now. I do. This is the last call for anyone who wants to come with us on the ski retreat. We are leaving a week from today, meaning from when this

episode will be posted on March 2nd. We're leaving, going to Colorado on March 9th, March 9th to the 13th. There's still some spots available if anybody wants to join us. We're going to be skiing in the Rocky Mountains. We're going to be staying together in this awesome chalet on the mountainside. Just our group is going to be staying in this place. We're going to be sharing all our meals together, staying in the same place, skiing in the day and reflecting on John Paul's teaching in the evening. I also wanted to mention if you want to bring us the theology of

the Body Institute, that is, and yours truly, even to your area for an event. We have a model that if you implement our promotional plan, it won't cost you a thing because it supports our ministry through ticket sales. And we get the message out in a big way to your community, to your parish, to your university, whatever the situation may be. So we're going to have a link in the show notes to our events and

how you can apply to have us bring one of our events to your area. Check it out. All right. Are you ready for a question from a patron? Let's do it. This is from an anonymous patron. Hi Christopher and Wendy, thank you so much for everything you are doing to spread the joy of theology of the body. I attended your TOB One course a few summers ago and have been so incredibly blessed by your ministry. I have a question about chastity in marriage.

I understand that the only place for a man's seed is the woman's garden, but what about during pregnancy? Since it's not possible for the couple to conceive another child, I'm not sure if or why it would matter. Yeah, I understand that question and I'm so glad you're asking it and I am happy to address it. It's a matter in this situation as it would be say for a couple past child bearing years.

It's a matter of fittingness, right There is the the Latin word is destinatus. There is a destiny for the seed. The seed is designed clearly. This is God's given design. The seed is designed to be as you tastefully put it. And that's probably language you heard me use. These are such delicate matters. You know, when you start talking, you know, in anatomical terms, you can lose some of the

the delicacy. Not that there's not also a place to talk about the anatomy of it all, but I prefer the poetic language that I've gathered from the Song of Songs. You're a garden enclosed my sister, my bride, the and the bridegroom longs Pines to enter the garden to plant his seed in the garden. That's the destiny of the seed. And also, we're not just talking about some gemits here. We're not just talking about some kind of animalistic

biological process, right? Human biology is exactly that, human. It refers to the dignity of the persons, right? JP 2 says that sexuality is by no means merely biological, but concerns the innermost being of the person as such. And we are designed anatomically, biologically, for a union that enables the true

and sincere gift of oneself. Right. This is my body given for you for a man to pursue, and that's the keyword willfully pursue. The pouring forth of his seed in any other manner no longer becomes the sincere gift of himself as God designs it. It becomes merely the selfish pursuit of pleasure. Now, even planting one seed in

the garden can also be done in a way that is nothing but the selfish pursuit of pleasure. There's no guarantee that it won't be a selfish pursuit of pleasure in the garden, but there is a guarantee that if it's not planted in the garden, it will be a selfish pursuit of pleasure. The only possibility of making the genuine, sincere gift of oneself, one's whole being, to the other in the Marriage Act is

to pursue the Marriage Act as God designed it. Otherwise, what you're pursuing is just an act of masturbation. When, when, when sexual climax is pursued apart from the true communion of persons as God designs, which is marital intercourse. It's this proper the classification of that act the selfish pursuit of an orgasm that has that is not as God designs is the classification

for that as mutual masturbation. So we don't want just to mutually masturbate each other. We, we want to learn the art of the sincere gift of self. So it's an argument from design and fittingness. How has God designed our bodies to experience sexual climax? And the design here is not just isolated pleasure, but the design is meant for the

communion of persons. Now here, because again, the anatomy is different in a man and a woman and and if you have a lot of more questions, I'm not going to get into everything here. I know what about this what read my book good news about sex and marriage, where I get into all the nitty gritties as Nacho Libre says. Let's talk about the nitty gritties. What nitty gritties were we talking about? I I got I got thrown off into Nacho land. What? Oh yes, the the anatomical

difference of male and female is such that the ideal, the design of God which is evident is that the female climax would also be experienced during the natural act of intercourse. However, it is not a moral fault if the woman does not experience climax during intercourse, so long as it is in the context of a completed act of intercourse. And completed act of intercourse

means the seed is planted in the garden. That is what consummates the marriage. Nothing else consummates the marriage. The giving of seed in any other manner is not the consummation of the marriage. It is not the marital act. And what we are after here is the renewal of our marital commitment that can only be expressed bodily in its consummate way, through the giving of seed in the garden. Ideally, the woman would experience climax during that

penetration. If that does not occur, nothing is amiss if the husband and wife help the woman, the wife, to experience climax even after penetration in order to also bring her to the fullness of joy, which is God's plan. And because there's no giving of seed there, it's not a masturbatory act. It's in the context of when I say no giving of seed, I'm talking about the man's giving a

seed. But the woman has no seed to give, right? She is the kind of being who reproduces within herself. The male is the kind of being who reproduces outside of himself and inside the woman. That's why the seed belongs there. Even if you know you're already pregnant, you're not going to conceive or after childbearing years. Wendy and I are after childbearing years. We know that our acts of intercourse are not going to result in a child. Nonetheless, we are still designed for acts of intercourse and not some other way of my

experience in climax. I hope I've clarified everything that needs to be clarified in this context. I got to get got a little lost there myself, Did I? How did I do there, Wendy? Found this very topic illuminating over over the years of just pondering it. I don't I don't think it's surprising that people have questions about it. I think we've just grown up in grown up or you know, we are in constantly exposed to culture

that has such a different attitude toward our bodies and sexual pleasure that it does take steps along the journey to really come to that place of what I feel in this it. It captures a sense of aligning our our hearts with God's plan for our bodies in a in a deep place in a deep place in our hearts where we have a certain awe and wonder for the goodness

of how he's made our bodies. We have this also awe, as you said it, human biology is always human and an awe for the call to communicate profoundly with one another and and the holiness of that that kind of it. It is a, a gradual conversion of our hearts to that full desire for as you said, that's what

consummates a marriage. And, and that very reality that we want every time that we are coming together, that we're experiencing this full activation of our sexual powers. That it would be not just a an activity that we enjoy, but a meaningful communication of both of our love for one another and our openness to God's grace. All of which includes and is

just beautifully expressed by that sense of receiving from the Lord the way He's made us and rejoicing in it. Well said Wendy, and This is why this show should be called the Ask Wendy West Show. Not at all. No, that that was very well put Wendy. It it is a journey. I remember my own journey in this regard. I was in my early 20s just trying to figure out. How did God make us?

Why did he make us this way? What does it all mean? What is the sexual act? And I realized I had been shaped and formed in this regard in an entirely secular slash masturbatory mindset, and I had to be really converted. I had to open these deep places in my heart, in my mind, the way I had thought, the way I was formed, the the, the how my own sexual sin impacted that and and shaped me in or misshaped me.

And I had to be reshaped. I had to be reformed. I had to be untwisted. I had to be set aright and and coming to see the fittingness of what the sexual act is and what John Paul calls the language of the body and how we speak that language truthfully. The man can only in in sexual climax. Let me say it that way. In sexual climax, the man can only speak the language of his body truthfully by having his climax part take part in the

garden. To put it delicately again for the sake of clarity and to make the necessary distinctions, a woman in the natural course of events. The ideal is she would also experience climax in that context, in that experience of the full marital act within the overall context of that act. If she does not experience climax during penetration, there is nothing amiss in the husband and wife helping the wife to experience that climax, so long

as it is part of the overall context of a gift of seed in the garden. Please read my book Good News About Sex and Marriage, where I get into those specifics in a more detailed and thought out way that I think you'll find enlightening. Our next question is from a listener named Catherine. Hi, Catherine. I've always had a special devotion to Jesus in the Eucharist. From a very small age I already knew it was truly Him. Body, blood, soul and divinity.

What a gift. I always anticipate receiving my beloved Jesus with great joy before I receive Him in the Eucharist, and I'm filled with awe and wonder and delight after I receive Him. But every once in a while, I feel an ache in my heart, specifically after receiving communion for an earthly spouse. Praise God, I am not ashamed to admit that by His grace, He's preserved me from falling into sexual sin for all 38 years of my life.

If God does will that I marry one day, I'm blessed to give my virginity to my future spouse and not be ashamed of it. Jesus has satisfied me with His love countless times, but sometimes this ache for communion with another comes up after receiving the Eucharist. I've asked holy priests about why this could be, but they had no answer. What are your thoughts on this? Catherine, I love you, I love your heart, I love your person, I love what's going on in you.

This is beautiful, this is mystical, this is holy, this is sacred, and it's all intertwined. You are experiencing in your mind, in your heart, in your body. You are experiencing Ephesians chapter 5 verses 31 to 32. For this reason, a man will leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two will become one flesh. This is a great mystery and it

refers to Christ and the church. Catherine, you are swimming deeply in this great mystery and I want to make some connections here that maybe you haven't made. I, I, I don't know, but there is a direct link between your chastity and your devotion to the Eucharist, your encounter with Christ, your bridegroom in the Blessed Sacrament. That grace you know, of yearning for Christ in the Eucharist, of

anticipating it, of going to Mass excitedly, of receiving the Lord with anticipation and joy, and and then the stirring of your heart in receiving your true bridegroom for an earthly bridegroom. Your body, your mind, your heart knows it's been trained like with muscle memory in your devotion to Christ and the Eucharist. Your whole body person has been trained and shaped and formed

such that your yearning for a bridegroom, both in the the earthly sense and in the heavenly sense are intertwined and interconnected in your experience of receiving Christ, the bridegroom in the Eucharist. This is beautiful. This is holy. This is sacred. You are you are a a living experience. You, you, yourself, your Your life is a living testimony of

Ephesians chapter 5. Your your life is a testimony of what John Paul the Second calls the marriage of marriages, the communion of communions in Ephesians chapter 5, where Saint Paul links the Holy Communion of husband and wife in marriage with the Holy Communion of Christ in the Church in the Eucharist. John Paul the Second says it is

of special merit to Saint Paul that he made this link and established these two marriages, the marriage of man and woman, the marriage of Christ and the Church. He he married these two marriages. He made of these two communions 1 Great Communion. He made of these two sacraments the Eucharist and Marriage. 1 Great Sacrament. He made of these two marriages 1 Great marriage, the Union, the link, the, the, the, the, the,

the, the togetherness of, of these two sacraments, Sacrament of Marriage and the sacrament of the Eucharist. They are so together that these two marriages have become one marriage. And that is why so beautifully, Catherine, This is why you are experiencing what you're experiencing when you experience it. And it is your purity of heart, maintained in your devotion to

the Eucharist, that makes what you are experiencing here something holy. Does the Lord want to fulfill your desire for an earthly husband? I do not know, I do not know. But this I do know. This I do know, and you can take it to the bank. The Lord wants to satisfy your desire for the ultimate marriage, right? The marriage of a man and a woman is temporary. The marriage of Christ in the

Church is eternal, but there is nothing shameful in your desire that you experience in receiving Christ in the Eucharist. There's nothing shameful about your recognizing I have a desire for union with an earthly husband. That is your normal and natural state as a woman. My encouragement to you would be, as you experience that, just continually open that up to Christ in the Eucharist. Christ, your true bridegroom, Catherine, you are you are a

living testimony to what John Paul the Second teaches, that the Eucharist is the sacrament of the bridegroom and of the bride. This is a sign that you are integrated as a woman. This is a sign that your body and your soul are are working in unison, that the deepest mystical part of you is is rooted in the the womanly part of you. And that is an integral

experience of a deep and profound and great mystery. Yeah, I wondered in Catherine, having just asked a few priests about it and then asking us about it, if if she was concerned that somehow she shouldn't be feeling that desire at that time. Like if she thought, well, I've just received the deepest love into me, so why is there this

longing for this human love right in this moment? And I feel like you were answering a lot of that in your answer, but I just wanted to acknowledge that I, I kind of am hearing that under the, you know, between the lines in a sense, or, you know, that, that there's a concern that is this just why would I, does it say something that I'm not fully experiencing Christ's love for me?

And I, I feel like in a way, because you are so recollected, I, well, I mean, that's how you describe yourself anyway, as being really present to the mystery. And that's recollected as one way of describing that, that perhaps those times when that ache comes up, the Lord is, is saying he wants to explore that with you. He wants you to have permission to share with his heart that you

have that desire for a husband in there. And that that he's fine with that. Like to not be concerned that somehow he would think, well, am I not enough for you? He knows how he made you and he knows that desire in your heart. So if if kind of resolving that concern that this is somehow wrong, which Christopher was so eloquently saying it's the opposite of wrong. I just, I hope that also it will lead to a deeper sharing and

even and inviting the Lord to show you more about your own desire for a husband that that would deepen your bond with the Lord and also your own knowledge of yourself and your ability to pray even more deeply for his will in your life. I think it's also, Catherine, an invitation to bring deeper levels of your humanity to Christ, your bridegroom. And the scripture I would invite you to pray into is from the Song of Songs, which I quoted earlier, where the bridegroom is

knocking at the door and he says, open to me, my love, my dove, my beautiful one, for my head is wet with dew, open to me, open to me. I believe Christ, your bridegroom is, is knocking and he is, he is wanting to enter into deeper mysteries of your, your bridal humanity, your, your call to be a bride to the Lord. I don't, I'm not saying that

like I know you're called to be a nun or a consecrated virgin. I have no idea what the Lord's calling is on your life in that regard. But all of us, if you are a baptized Christian in one way or another, we're all called to, to, to that bridal reality. And guys, don't let that freak you out. It just means we are receptive to the love of God. All of us as creatures, we are receptive to the love of God. So, Catherine, I think something beautiful is unfolding. I hear the Lord inviting you deeper. Be not afraid open to Him.

Our next question is from an anonymous listener. My fiance and I were taking one of our pre cana classes together and the topic of sexual intimacy in the past came up. I asked him if he ever had sex before just to clarify what I thought the answer would be. I just figured because both of us were Catholics that we both were saving ourselves into marriage. He told me that he has had sex

before with several women in his past but he deeply regrets not waiting and he is re waiting for marriage with me. This really broke my heart and I'm still continuing to heal. How can I regain the trust that I feel was broken because this information was withheld from me for so long? And how do I heal? Bless you, dear sister, Bless you dear sister. Your pain is holy and is worthy

of great reverence. And I just want to reverence that place of deep pain in your heart. It's also very instructive. Our pain is evidence of the goodness of God's plan because when God's plan is rejected, it pains us, US, it wounds us. It's like a knife in the heart

and not just a knife in the heart. It can get in there and then start carving and we can just feel like we're, we're being butchered, like our hearts are being butchered. And yes, they in a, in a real way, they, they are. That's what happens to our hearts when when we and those we love act outside of God's plan. That pain is real, and there's no way out of that pain on your

own. My dear sister, my dear sister, the only way, the only path of healing is to open that pain to Christ's pain and, and to recognize in fact, that you are so united with Christ in that pain, that your pain is Christ's pain. And that's why I say that pain is sacred and worthy of reverence because it is Christ's

pain. This is what Christ was bearing on the cross. He was bearing on the cross the pain of your fiance's sexual sin. He was, He was, if what we believe about the cross is true, that Jesus was bearing in his body, in his heart, in his mind, the rupture, the pain, the butchering of of that sin.

And He has invited you, astoundingly, to be in union with him in knowing that pain and in knowing it, in offering it to the Father, in redemptive love for him, for your fiance. This is how love works. This is how redemption works.

This is how healing works. And if you're a long time listener of our podcast, anyone out there who has been listening a long time, you know, one of my go to passages in the catechism, I just can't do this show without often referring to Catechism 2843. It's in the Catechism section on the Our Father in which the Catechism is reflecting, forgive

us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us. Your fiance has trespassed against you. And, and there's, it's not only the pain of the sin he committed, which I'm sure is the lion's share of it, but also, as you said, the pain that he withheld this for so long. And I would invite you to just show him a tender mercy in the

fact that it took this long for him to bring that into the light. There's a fear, of course, that that he had sinned so grievously that how could he be loved there? How could he be loved there? And the only way he will heal is by knowing he is loved there by Jesus and by you. And loving him there does obviously does not mean approving in any way of what he

did or sweeping it under the rug or pretending it wasn't a big, a big deal or trying to forget it. And this is where the Catechisms, 2843, the Catechism's wisdom is so important. The Catechism says it is not in our power not to feel or to forget when someone has wounded us. Forgive and forget is, is a myth. It's not in our power. It's not possible in our humanity.

It's simply not possible. But the Catechism says the heart that offers itself and offers that pain to the Holy Spirit, the Holy Spirit transforms the pain into compassion and the sting of the memory gets turned into intercession. That's how you heal, by learning to feel that pain, the sting of that pain, both the pain of what he has done and the pain of his withholding that from you to offer that pain.

In union with Jesus's pain, opening and opening it all to the Holy Spirit, so that in the Holy Spirit it gets presented to the Father. In the power of the Trinity, you in union with Jesus and in union with Jesus opening to the Holy Spirit and an opening to the Holy Spirit. All of it gets presented to the Father and the Trinity does what the Trinity does. Trinity does best, redeems it all, redeems it all, redeems it all.

And I, I, I don't want to paint a picture as if it all happens in a flash. This can take years, it can take decades, it can take a lifetime. The Lord can also heal in very specific, deep ways and very specific moments. There's great progress we can make, but don't be surprised, this is a mistake Wendy and I made early in our relationship. We experienced beautiful, powerful, profound healings in,

in really deep wounds that we were carrying when we came together in our relationship, and not the least of which was my sexual sin. And you had your own sin that you brought to the table, but it was not as dark as, as mine, as we both know. And the, the, the mistake we made in experiencing that healing was kind of like a, a, Oh, good. We kind of, you know, washed our

hands and were like, Oh, thank you, Lord, for that healing. Now we can move on because we're healed. And then it became really painful as the years went on and we realized, whoa, whoa, whoa, gosh, there's more healing to do there. We thought we were healed, and there was a beautiful healing that happened, but the wounds caused in our hearts by sin go really, really deep.

But here's the good news. The cross goes ever deeper. Where sin abounds, grace abounds all the more. As you've been speaking to this anonymous listener, I've just been praying for their relationship in my heart as you've been speaking and really feeling all the things that she shared. And I'm sure there's much she didn't share, but both that shock of learning after being

already engaged and thinking she knew the answer because no other thing had ever been indicated. Just the way that kind of hits a person in such a a powerful and painful way. But I also see like just beautiful graces that they were going through this marriage preparation together, that this

very topic, which is so sensitive, was brought up in some way through the instruction that they were receiving. I find myself believing that as the topic came up, her fiance knew he needed to say this. Yeah, I feel it too. And I believe that's a grace. That's the Holy Spirit at work that he would know. I have to tell her. That's a good sign. That's a good sign.

You can take that to the bank. That's a good sign. That is that the Holy Spirit is at work in his heart and enable enabling him to overcome that incredible fear, which I think you you named that as you were speaking to her. Just that understandable fear in her fiance's heart. Yeah. So I just feel like staying right there in the graces of that knowing the truth. And it doesn't mean that it's easy to know how to move

forward. And that's part of why she submitted this question. But if you can go back to that memory and not only see your pain of feeling betrayed and confused and just hurt, if you can also see grace at work in that moment, I think that can allow you to take a deep breath and say, Lord, I trust you. You are at work. Almighty God, you are at work. You care about me, you care

about my fiance, you care about our relationship, and you're here with us. Like the gift of that is profound. And it can be hard to see when because pain can create this big dark cloud that causes a lot of confusion. And I speak from experience there to recognize that the Lord is piercing through and piercing is painful, but it is needed and beautiful.

So I, I just want to continue to lift you both up in my heart, just each of you looking at your relationship with new eyes and new tears to shed. Hopefully in time those tears will draw you together, that the new ground on which you stand will be firmer and more obvious to you, how much you need the Lord every step of your relationship.

As Christopher was saying, this is a process that involves both individual prayer and more communication and praying together and going to confession and experiencing the graces that the Lord has for you there. All of those things and others as the Lord will provide them for you. You're in our hearts and we're praying for you. Just one more thought I want to add.

She had asked, how do I rebuild trust when I've been so wounded? And I want to invite you to recognize, just as Wendy was saying, how much grace was at work in your fiance's sharing this with you, imagining how difficult that was for him to share it and why it's understandable that for up till now he hadn't shared it. But here's the opportunity right

there of in the feeling of being betrayed, there's a paradoxically, there's also the opportunity to hope entrust that you can trust him, that he shared this with you. He entrusted this deep shame, this deep regret, this deep wound. He opened it to you. He said, here are my wounds and I know they wound you. His willingness to do that, that is a sign.

That is a sign of hope. That trust is already opening up. He trusted you with a deep and dark, painful, shameful reality in his life. This is this is a broken man, obviously, but a, a, a man who wants to have his life in the light doesn't do it perfectly, but he wants it. And I would invite you also, if there is temptation to want to condemn him, to wag a finger or

or scold or, or, you know, we have places in our humanity that are really messed up. And it can just come from we don't know what to do with our pain. But it's also an opportunity for you to look at the bedrock biblical truth that you are just as in need of mercy as he is. You know, we can say, well, I didn't commit those sins.

Well, as soon as we go in that direction, we are forgetting that the ground is level at the foot of the cross. We are all desperately, desperately broken, desperately sinful creatures desperately in need of a Savior. That's the truth of the matter. And when we realize that, we can learn to love other people in their brokenness. If we think we are superior, then we end up holding ourselves

above others and looking down at others. And that is not a ground, that is not a foundation on which to build a marriage. The both of you at the foot of the cross, looking up to Jesus in the blood and water pouring out of his heart upon both of you in your need, that's where you build a marriage. That's where marital love comes from. That's where the sacrament comes from. Be not afraid. It's not going to be an easy Rd. The cross is never easy, but as

we embrace it, it leads to glory. It leads to glory. There's no way to glory other than through the cross. And This is why you should rejoice, because the Lord is opening the mystery of His cross to you. Bless you dear sister, we will be praying for you. We ask all of our listeners, please to pray for this couple and thanks for entrusting your questions to us. Everybody keep them coming. We're grateful that you are part of this international. I just learned actually, Wendy, something like 90 countries tune

into our podcast. So thank you international family listening to Wendy and me share our hearts as you have shared yours with us. And we want to thank our sponsors sponsor, which is truthfully, they're doing us a great favor by sponsoring our show. They're helping us out a lot. If you have questions that you want to see what answers, you can find it. Truthfully, it is a platform that I think is really worth checking out. Until next time, everybody, we love you, we bless you, we ask for your prayers.

And how do we end the show, Wendy? You're a gift. That's right, yeah. And then? And then go ahead. Wait, you did my part. I did go ahead. Become what Wendy says you should become. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is

helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode