Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Foolish for not chasing marriage?, Is our intimacy a sin, Are my natural arousals sinful? | ACW360

Nov 24, 202550 minAudio

Questions answered this episode: I’m a 24-year-old single woman who has never dated. I want to be married, but it’s a passive desire - I’m content and open if something comes my way. I don’t ache for marriage the way others do, and I don’t feel called to chase it. People tell me I’m wasting my twenties and question if I even want a family. I do want marriage, just no one has interested me yet. I don’t think God is asking me to hunt for a spouse. Does that make sense, or am I being foolish? My husband and I have used NFP for 20 years, but during my fertile times he tempts me daily for intimacy. I resist for a few days but usually cave once a month, leading to intercourse where only I climax. It’s very hard to stop, and I’m always the one trying, which leaves me feeling guilty. I love our intimacy but resent his lack of restraint. A priest once told me confessing this monthly means it’s mortal sin, but I can’t find why. Can you shed light on this? I struggle with unwanted arousal around my fiancée - holding hands, hugging, sitting close, even certain voice inflections. Sometimes there’s slight discharge without erection or intent. I feel terrible afterward and replay everything to see if I consented. A priest and therapist have both told me it’s natural and I lack culpability, but I still worry because I’ve read that near-complete pleasure can be gravely sinful. I’m trying to understand if these involuntary reactions are sinful. Please help a confused brother in Christ. Resources: ⁠⁠Course Schedule JPII Legacy Foundation Website Good News About Sex & Marriage Love & Responsibility YouTube Series --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Welcome everybody to another episode. We're happy you're with us today, wherever you are. Yes. Where are we? I think that Dead Space just meant we didn't even know we were here. We've just had a fun experience.

This week on November 18th, we were celebrating. What were we celebrating? Our 30th anniversary. Our 30th wedding anniversary and I think I've crossed a threshold. I said to you the other day, Wendy, the threshold of realizing how old we are. I I mean you may be exaggerating it in your mind now. It might have been like, you know, not realizing it and now

over realizing it well. I'm not sure the thing that did it for me, and I shared this with you the other day, We went back to our old church where we got married 30 years ago and we invited the priest who said our wedding to come celebrate Mass for us, which he agreed to do. We're so happy he did. And seeing him after so many years, we hadn't seen him, gosh, since, what, 1997? I don't know. Yeah, something like that. And seeing him after so many

years was certainly a marker in the passage of time. But standing up on that altar where we stood 30 years ago and exchanged wedding vows and looking out at the church, which was empty this time, the pews we're so worn down. Like, in 1995, that was a pretty new church. It was. Yeah. And now it's not so new. And the pews are all kind of just, you know, normal wear and tear. The the varnish wears off on the pews.

And I was like, look at those pews. Like, oh, my gosh, those pews have really aged. And then I'm thinking, wait a minute. Have we? That means we have too. It just puts things in perspective. The the anniversaries, birthdays, those kind of markers, especially significant ones like 30 is a pretty big one. It just puts life in perspective. And I'm so grateful to the Lord. I'm so grateful to you, Wendy, for your yes to me over all of

these years. You had chosen a reading from CYRAC for our anniversary Mass and I, I had originally thought, let's just do the readings we had at our, at our wedding. And you said, no, no, no. We need something that reflects what we've been through in the last 30 years. And I'm very glad you, you thought that cause CYRAC too is about, well, you. You share. Yeah, it's about, it's about knowing that serving the Lord includes a lot of trials and and all the reasons to persevere and

continue to trust the Lord even in the midst of those trials. I do love that reading. Yeah. And, and I stood up to read that. And when I read it, I, I just choked up. I couldn't I could barely read it because of how meaningful it was with all that we've been through and to see the Lord's faithfulness to us through so many trials and Joyce, they're they're it's all mixed up. If there's any married couple out there listening to us today or married person and you're

going through a particular trial, keep going, keep going, keep going. It's worth it. It's worth it. Amen. Do you have any updates for us by the way, from the Toby Institute? I want to put in a word about 3 upcoming courses in the new year. These are three in person courses. One is the writings of John Paul the Second on gender, marriage and family. These are the additional

writings of John Paul the Second beyond his theology of the body, beyond love and responsibility. These are papal writings, for example, Letter to Families familiar as Consortio from 1981, his letter to women on the dignity and vocation of women. There's so many writings of John Paul the second in addition to his theology of the body where he applies it. And, and we needed a course here at the institute devoted just to that. Bill Donahue will be teaching that in early January, so check out the link for that.

I will be teaching Theology of the Body Level 1 in Australia, Sydney, Australia the third week of of January. We begin on January 18th to the 23rd. You can check out the link for that as well. If you are from that part of the world or you want to travel to that part of the world to take a TOB one, check that out. I love going to Australia, although it's a long ass flight. I have to say please pray for me everybody that I get upgraded.

I fly enough that I often get these free upgrades. So please pray people, I'm I'm serious. Like it's the a 15 hour flight from Los Angeles to Sydney when you get upgraded. It's the difference between looking forward to it and dreading it. So I'm serious. Please people, please pray for me. I'm praying for that. And I get an upgrade, moving right along. And then at the end of February, the team from Living Waters, the Desert Stream ministry and their Living Waters program is the

right way to say it. The team from Desert Stream headed by Andrew Comiskey is coming to Black Rock Retreat Center in Pennsylvania to lead the sexual integration and redemption course. And this of all our offerings, this is where we're really applying the theology we learn very practically into our lives. There's a lot of small group work on this course. There's, yes, there's presentation and lecture, but it's, it's much more going into

the small groups and journeying with five or six other people, with a team leader who knows exactly what he or she is doing to, to guide us in the, the groups of course are separated by 6 and, and it's an opportunity to open up the wounds and let the light in. I, I took this course myself many years ago and it was life changing and all of our students who have taken it have said as much. It is a life changing experience. So check the link in the show notes if any of those courses

are of interest to you. We also have a whole slate of online offerings. If you can't travel to in person courses, check out our online offerings. And as always, if money is an issue, please apply for a scholarship. Our scholarship fund through the foundation that John Paul the second Legacy Foundation. We as much as we are able to offer scholarships, we will do so. And if you want to help us in that regard, we started the foundation just over a year ago

and our goal in 2025 was to raise money for 900 scholarships. We are at the 500 mark. So thank you to everyone who's contributed. We believe in these last weeks of 2025, we can hit that 900 mark. Cause a lot of a lot of giving to nonprofits happens at the end of the year. So, if you are in a position at the end of your year you're looking to offer some donations to a worthy cause, would you please prayerfully consider helping us fund scholarships to

our courses and programs? We would be so grateful and the link is there. Awesome, you ready now for a question from a patron? Let's do it. This is from a patron named Julia. Hello Julia. Thank you so much for your support of our mission. We're so grateful to you, Julia. I'm a 24 year old single woman and have never gone on a date. I've always wanted to be married but it is more of a passive desire as I am quite content. I know so many who feel the

desire to get married so strongly they ache. I've never felt like this. I have no desire to pursue a relationship but rather am happily living my life and I'm open to a relationship if that comes my way. I've been told that I'm being reckless and wasteful by not spending my 20s actively trying to find my spouse. I've been questioned about if I really even want to have a family if I'm not husband hunting.

Jesus has not proposed and I know I do want to get married, just no one has piqued my interest yet and I don't think God is asking me to go out of my way. Does that make sense or do you think I'm being foolish? Julia, I think you're living in a place of grace. That's how I hear what Wendy just read to me. You, you are in a place of it seems like peace, acceptance,

contentment, living your life as it's presenting itself to you, open to the possibility of a a man coming into your life. I, I mean, if you were to say to me, I have no desire for marriage, no desire to pursue a calling or vocation at all. If there was something dead in your heart that would raise a concern to me. But I don't hear anything dead in your heart. I hear a, a peaceful acceptance

and a certain level of detachment and trust. And, and I say, praise God, you, you are free from an anxiety and a burden that a lot of young people carry. And, and I, I think it can come that when it gets so heavy, that burden, I have to find a spouse. I have to find a spouse. I have to find a spouse or I'm not going to be happy. I'm not going to live life to the full if I don't find somebody. That can be a cause of concern,

that can be a sign of a lack of trust. That can be a sign of a lack of contentment, a lack of peace. So don't let anybody put that on you. You are free from that. Thanks be to God, you're free from that. Don't let anybody put their anxiety on you here. Maybe what's going on there? Maybe it's other people who have had that anxiety and because you don't, you're like a mirror to them. Like, Gee, why did I? Why was I so stressed out or why

am I so stressed out? And why isn't she stressed out? And instead of looking maybe at a an opportunity to grow themselves, they want to plop their anxiety on you. To which I say phooey to that. Just praise God that you're in a place of relative peace and acceptance and trust and move forward one one day at a time, one step at a time, the Lord will unveil his will for your life. That's my take on it. What are you feeling, Wendy? Yeah, I I feel similarly. I had that almost the same exact

thought about the people saying you're being foolish or why aren't you're wasting your life or those kinds of worries. It kind of reminds me of some things I've seen. Maybe I'm thinking particularly of Downton Abbey for those who have watched it, but this expression like, oh, she'll lose her bloom, like, and that didn't mean lose your virginity or something. It meant lose your youthful attractiveness or something. And like, oh, you'll, you'll

miss your chance. I remember just hearing that expression in more than one place and, and that kind of being a sort of quote, UN quote wisdom that people, you know, would share at some time in, in history anyway, it, it reminded me of that and that kind of just attention to the dynamics of different stages of life and what things typically happen at certain ages, that kind of thing. But I, I feel similar, very similarly to you, that there is

a gift here in a, in a peace and a contentment. And I, we're all, you know, complicated human beings. And there are things, you know, under the surface in our hearts that the Lord wants to shine light on and help us to grow in. And there's nothing that Julia is saying here that makes me think she's not open to that, you know, open to the Lord shining his light into her story and enabling her.

I think the key that we see in our understanding of theology of the body is to to reverence your own femininity and recognize that the greatest joy comes from being a gift in some way. And that does not exclude single people at all. In fact, it is so beautifully motivating in single life to relish the opportunities to be a gift and also to receive gifts.

You know, there are, there are many things that a person might want to pursue physically, intellectually, spiritually, that there's a certain freedom to pursue in the single state that can bring great contentment and joy to giving of yourself to those worthy things and receiving those worthy things. So you know that just that organizing principle of life of receiving your own life as a gift. Other people, including men in your life as a gift being a gift

to others like this is a contented way to live and a light in the world and the Lord you know as you are pursuing closeness to him in all of this will continue to grow you and just shine a light on your path that you are, It seems quite open to following. So I, I do, I trust that that is genuine goodness in your heart. And when you encounter those

worrying comments from others, certainly it's an opportunity to pray for them in their anxieties that they might be, as Christopher said, kind of projecting onto you. Julia, be at peace girl and and be a light. I think you are a light. I'm I'm reminded we just had last weekend here at BlackRock Retreat Center in Pennsylvania. We had 140 young single people at a a a new event we were Co presenting with the Humanum project.

Shout out to Brendan McCauley from the humanum project. We had 140 young people, 70 women, 70 men looking for love, looking to find, who knows, God willing, perhaps someone to date, someone to marry it. That was the whole purpose of the event, to just have a kind of mixer and opportunity for young single people to hear some good talks, have some speed dating sessions where they got to meet lots of different people. And it was very interesting for

me to be in that room. You could just feel that beautiful and, and I want to say holy, sacred energy of desire, of desire for love, of desire for union, of desire to find your life's path. And that is a beautiful, holy, awesome thing. That energy, that yearning, that desire. But because it's so powerful, it can, it can go off the rails. It can it can lead to anxiety.

It can lead to real like the carrying of a, a of an undue burden. And and Julia, I just want to say, I think you are a light. Keep shining that light. And if there's any single person out there who feels that that beautiful, sacred yearning for to discover your calling and vocation has turned into an anxiety and a burden, I just invite you to surrender that burden to Jesus. His yoke is easy. His burden is light.

Jesus, please, you know the burdens we all carry. You know how something holy and sacred can become a source of anxiety in us when it gets twisted up or mixed with our fears and lack of faith or lack of trust. And Lord, you know everything about us. We just, we give our hearts to you. Please shine your light. Amen. Amen. Our next question is from a listener named Elizabeth. Hello, Elizabeth. My husband and I have been married 20 years with four kids.

Congratulations. And have always used NFP. He is a practicing Catholic but to be honest, he's not pursuing the Lord as much as I am. We've fallen into a pattern for the past few years where during my fertile times, my husband will tempt me daily to be intimate with him and though I resist for a few days, I usually cave one day a month. This leads to intercourse but with only me climaxing and not

him. It is very difficult to stop after a certain point and I'm always the one trying to stop it, which leaves me feeling guilty. As a wife, while I love our intimacy, I resent my husband for repeatedly tempting me until I cave instead of exercising restraint. I once asked a priest in confession as I have to confess this monthly and he told me it was a mortal sin, but I can't find that explanation anywhere. Can you shed some light on this? Bless you Elizabeth, bless you.

I just want to lift you up to the Lord's tender, merciful love. You know, obviously in the church's teaching, terms like mortal sin have their place. These are important distinctions the church makes and, and when the church says something is a mortal sin, it's saying it's serious matter and unconfessed. This is this is very dangerous for our souls because it's a, it's a when it is serious

matter, when it is freely chosen and we know the reality of it, it cuts us off from the life of grace. That's what the church means by by mortal sin. And yet that word, that phrase, mortal sin, it can be like, Oh my gosh, I'm under God's wrath. I'm under his condemnation. Thank you God for his mercy. What we have is always, in every situation, the opportunity to repent.

And I'm so glad you are going to confession regularly and I'm so sorry that you are enduring this from your husband. It does not come from a place in his heart of of love, of tenderness, of acceptance of your circumstances. It comes from a place of lack of self mastery, lack of honoring the beauty and splendor and dignity of the marital act. Lack of honouring the mystery and beauty of fertility.

And I'm so sorry you are enduring that your husband is in a a painful place because anyone who is not master of his desires is is in pain. The only path to real freedom, the only path to real love, is to be master of our desires. The only path to authentic happiness is to be master of our desires, right? The culture holds out a big line about sexual freedom, but the culture does not know what true

freedom is. In the culture, it means do whatever you want, whenever you want without ever saying no. It means don't ever master your desires. No, no, no, no. Sexual freedom is not the liberty to indulge my compulsions. It is liberation from my compulsion to indulge. Only such a person can be a free gift. Your husband has a compulsion here that he is not free from, and that ends up exactly where you are, in a place of real

resentment because you feel that lack of freedom on his part. And that's wounding to you and it's wounding to him. So, Elizabeth, let me try now to address the specific moral question you are asking. And in order to do that, I have to, to rewind here and and talk about the purpose and the nature of sexual climax. The purpose of sexual climax is, and here I'm I want to speak specifically about male climax,

then female climax. The male climax is what consummates the marriage so long as the male climax happens. I'm going to say this delicately so that the male seed is planted in the garden. A seed expelled in any other manner does not consummate a marriage, only that act by which the couples engage in the union. That is per SE designed by God

for the generation of children, that is genital intercourse and the giving of seed, the seed planted in the garden. Again, to put it delicately, this is what consummates the marriage right In times of abstinence, in times when a couple have a legitimate reason to avoid a pregnancy. There is nothing wrong with tenderness, with closeness, with affection, with nakedness, with intimate kisses and touches, so

long as spouses know their limits and are not seeking climax apart from the act of intercourse. Now in this situation, what you have described, it sounds like there is a level of intercourse. There's a a penetration, but there's not the giving of seed and and knowing in advance that there will not be a consummated act, it would not be

appropriate. It is not appropriate for the woman to be pursuing sexual climax. So the pursuit of sexual climax when it's willful, intentional, and with done with full knowledge, that would be in a serious way contrary to God's plan for marital love and affection. I think what I would hold out to you as a possibility as a married couple would be a time

of closeness in your times of abstinence that both of you know in advance is not leading to intercourse and is not leading to sexual climax. Different couples have different levels of sensitivity here, and this requires great tenderness, great and open communication so that we're not pushing one another beyond a threshold where climax becomes inevitable. But this delicate task given to married couples of learning the

way of appropriate non climactic affection. This is a task that can be carried out and it is really worthy of marital love, truly worthy of marital love. If, if listeners out there are, are, are looking for more of the nitty gritty, so to speak, may I recommend that you read my book, Good News about Sex and Marriage, where I get into the nitty gritty details. I, I think just for the sake of

this context, the podcast format, I've probably said as much as might be appropriate. What? What do you want to add here, Wendy? Yeah, I, I, I think that's beautiful, all that you said. I I sense in a particular way that there's a certain complexity to this situation in that abstinence can feel like a separation for some couples. And I can imagine there's

something about his pursuit of her in those times of abstinence that that she appreciates. She feels affirmed by his desire for her. That's my imagination. Of course, I'm not in their heads and hearts, but and yet the fact that it is not presented in a way that takes into account her whole being not presented, it doesn't come

across in a way that says it is so important to me that you feel loved. You know from the husband towards the wife that he's kind of intentionally and knowingly creating this excessive sexual tension. And there's something so frustrating about that because the line between that which feels positive and affirming, and that which feels like I could weep angry tears for this

woman in, in the way that he's crossing this line with without regard for her full humanity. That there's some, as you said, there's some lack of self mastery, that it means a certain use of the person. And it's complicated because he's not climaxing, so it it kind of adds a weird twist to the. Story. And I feel the frustration of that.

And I really do think this couple is in a place where there could be tremendous beautiful growth that would happen by confronting it head on. And it it doesn't have to be an angry thing. It can be truly, this has been a problem for us and we need to talk directly about it. We can't keep skirting around it and playing like teenagers or something. We have to be the mature adults that we are in this area and really find ways to truly love

one another. And I do think that it could evolve in stages where there could be a time of just and needing to have a firm, you know, plan in place of just a certain not expressing those marital affections for a cycle or two to kind of refocus and allow for the wife in a

particular way to feel that her integrity is being respected. That could be opportunities for really good conversation and prayer and that eventually, as you're saying, they could develop ways of expressing affection. That is genuinely a blessing for both of them. And believe me when I say this to all our listeners, that is a tricky balance to find. And yet it is so helpful, so helpful to get in touch with those genuine, deep, intimate

questions of how to love one another. And it bears tremendous fruit in your union when you do unite in the marital embrace because of that trust that is built by communicating and submitting your desires to the genuine love for the other and knowledge of that person's good. It comes to my mind to to add a few more clarifying statements here because I'm imagining questions multiplying in our

listeners minds, especially if this teaching is new to you. I, I want to say a word about the way we are are educated to think of sexual climax in our culture. We have a paradigm of masturbation in the culture that the the experience of climax is for me and, and most people, you know, they're exposed to pornography at a young age, They start masturbating at a young age and their whole psychosexual development when it comes to arousal and climax is about me.

And this is utterly contrary to God's design, which is sexual. Climax is about communion, life giving communion that images the life giving love of God. And, and if we could just rest in that my climax is not my own. My climax is for the sake of communion. Communion is an expression of

communion. And yes, there is joy in it that is mine, but the it's the joy of loving the other. It's the joy of pouring myself out for the other. That is a very different kind of interior conditioning of, of the mind, the heart, the body. Then the paradigm of masturbation. It's the paradigm of marriage. It's the paradigm of self gift. It's the paradigm of Holy Communion, and when we rest in that paradigm, the Church's

teaching that husband or wife should not be experiencing climax in isolation begins to make beautiful sense. And it begins to make beautiful sense why a a man's climax has to be within the garden of his wife because that's where the life giving communion happens. I'll add one more thing, 'cause somebody out there might be thinking about it. Well, if, if marital tenderness and closeness and affection is appropriate, that doesn't lead to climax, would it be OK for

the spouses in a time of abstinence to engage even in an act of coming together, penetration that did not lead to climax for either of them. Well, the Church has a document in which this was addressed in the 1950s or 60s. And and while that church document did not outright condemn the practice, it did offer serious caution about recommending such a practice for for what are obvious reasons,

that it could lead to a climax that was not a free gift of oneself. So there are real pastoral sensitivities in all of this. And again, if if what we're saying here in the context of this podcast needs more explanation for you, there are clear and illuminating explanations of these matters in my book Good News About Sex and Marriage. Our next question is from a listener named Ed. Hello, Ed.

Peace be with you. I have a rather thorny question regarding a potential sin against impurity. I'm a bit of a scrupulous guy regarding these matters, mainly due to remorse for sins of my past life and possibly pride, and I find myself going to confession over and over again due to this issue. My issue always has to do with unwanted arousal when around my fiance. This can be caused by simple things like holding hands, hugging briefly when she leans against me while watching a

movie, when I hear a certain voice inflection, and so on. I don't mean to be explicit, but sometimes I find there is some discharge even without ejaculation or even erection. I do not try to have these reactions on purpose. I then feel really terrible and start replaying my actions in my mind, trying to see if I consented or if I had knowledge of what was happening. I've talked to both a priest and a rehab therapist and they've cancelled me.

That it's natural and that I lacked culpability. But I still feel bad because I've read in some places that acts which cause complete or near complete pleasure can potentially be gravely sinful. Please help a confused brother in Christ who is struggling. Ed, thank you for your honesty, brother. I love you. You're a good man. You're looking for the truth. You want to be holy. And I think the real problem

here is not lust or impurity. The real problem here is scruples. And my my pastoral advice for you is to confess your scruples. And it can, it can come from a a place of fear that I'm not lovable as a human being. It can come from a place of fear that I'm not lovable unless I'm perfect. And that would be perfectionism, right? Yes, we are called to be perfect

as your heavenly Father is perfect. But there is a major difference between perfectionism and the road to perfection, right? The perfectionist, and I know this because I'm a recovering perfectionist. The perfectionist thinks I'm only going to be lovable when I get there, when I make it, when I'm perfect. The road to perfection recognizes I'm loved right here, right now, in all of my complex, broken, wounded, sinful, mixed up, messed up humanity. I'm loved right here.

And that love compels me on my journey and draws me, woos me into the mystery of God and His life. Scruples are a tremendous block from living the freedom for which Christ has set us free. I would be concerned, my brother, if there was no bodily reaction when this woman you

love and are going to marry was close to you. I would be concerned if there was no bodily reaction when when she held your hand or kissed you or held you or you sat next to her watching a movie. All of these things are a sign your body is speaking to you. The reaction of your body is an invitation to recognize, Wow. I am designed by God in my whole being, body and soul, to be a gift to this woman. And so rather than reacting with fear, Oh my gosh, my body's

reacting. I've done something wrong. I got to go to confession rather. Wow. Look how God has made me. I am fearfully and wonderfully made. My fiance is just sitting next to me as we're watching this movie and the the warmth of her presence. My body is responding and it's telling me I am called to be a life giving gift to her. I don't have to follow that right now. It would be inappropriate to follow this right now, but that's what my body is telling

me. So I'm going to put my whole self at the service of this divine call to be gift to her. I'm going to learn right in this very moment, as my body is being stirred, I'm going to, with an act of will and with an openness to divine grace, I'm going to pray a prayer like this. Lord, thank you for the beauty of my fiance. Thank you for her warmth and closeness. Thank You that my body is reacting. Thank you that I am designed in your image and likeness to be a

gift to her. Lord, I I surrender this reaction to You. I open it to your working of grace and I ask you to teach me how to order all of my arousal, all of my desire, all of my drive and yearning and affection towards everything true, good and beautiful so that I can image you truly as a free, total, faithful, fruitful gift to this woman who's called to be my wife.

Do you see, brother, how how different that is from oh crap, my body's having a reaction. I got to go to confession. No, your body is designed by God to be a gift. And and if you don't believe me, believe John Paul the second, let me read from him. This is from love and responsibility. This is what he says. Experience confirms that sensual reactions continue to reverberate in the body even when they encountered the explicit opposition of the will, he goes on.

We cannot demand of ourselves either that we experience no sensual reactions at all or that they cease immediately upon asserting our will against them. In practicing the virtue of self mastery, it is important to know that there is a difference between not willing and not feeling. Therefore, he continues, when analyzing the structure of sin,

one must not exaggerate the significance of sensual reactions in the stirrings of our bodies. Spontaneous sensual reactions and carnal reflexes are not themselves a sin and do not become a sin unless the will leads the way, right? So any speaking here of, of experiences obviously, where one should not be following one's sensual reactions, and you are in such a situation where you

are not yet married, you are not free yet to express the consummate expression of marital love. You are not free yet even to express those things, those experiences of affection that are meant to lead to the consummate expression of marital love. There is a place in an engaged relationship, especially for closeness, for tenderness, for affection, for intimate holding and kissing, that is, can be and is meant to be beautiful and wonderful and free and pure. For an engaged couple like

yourself, and your body will well have those kind of sensual reactions. You can and must, with God's grace and through your own choice and decision, put those reactions at the service of authentic love. To demand that your body not have any reaction or to demand that they cease as immediately as you say. I'm not going to follow that. It's just not human, my brother. And you are loved right in your humanity.

You are loved right there. And you can learn with God's grace to put all of those reactions of your body at the service of love. And you're going to be married soon enough. And that that's what married life is all about, putting those. It's not that, oh, now I can have all these reactions and just follow wherever they want to go. No, no, no, no, no, no. We must learn through the virtue of self mastery, especially in married life, how to put those reactions at the service of love.

If we think pre marriage means just shutting them down and turning them off and then once I'm married I can just let them loose. We don't know what chastity is. Chastity is the virtue that enables us in whatever our state in life, Married, single, consecrated, celibate, to put all of our sensual reactions and emotions at the service of authentic love according to the appropriate state of our lives.

Ed, I hope what I'm saying is helpful to you. If you want to go deeper, I recommend a series of videos that Matt Frat and I did on love and responsibility. You can get them on YouTube if you really want to go the distance. I'd urge you to take the Love and Responsibility course, the TOB 1, the TOB 2. Just jump in, brother. Start taking these courses and start entering into the freedom for which Christ has set us free. That's really good.

Just a thought I have for Ed in the midst of his honesty about things going on inside his heart. I I noticed that toward the beginning he said some of this scrupulosity comes from remorse for sins of my past life and possibly pride. So I hear like I have such a tenderness toward both of those comments that he made the remorse for sins and pride and just to the honesty of him

sharing both of those things as just the reality of who he is, who the Lord is looking on with love. And I hope you're seeing the Lord's gaze of love on your heart. And as you share those, you know, just very sensitive human realities with us and with our listeners. Thank you for your honesty about that. I think that one of the ways I, if I were your fiance, would love to have you handle those

experiences would be for you to just tune into your heart a little bit. Your, your body's kind of telling you something about your mind and heart there, You know, it's, it's telling you something about a desire to be closer to your fiance, to be affirmed like that. The inflection of the voice. I thought that was such a sweet observation you made, Ed, that. Even I felt so. Too, the sound in her voice can trigger that.

Like there's a certain hopefulness in that. There's a certain just honest vulnerability going on there. I I think all that is so beautiful and I, I would pray for you, Ed that that you would in knowing like this is a physical reality that rather than feeling threatened or alarmed by it, as Christopher said, like it's a good thing. You know it. It would be concerning if it weren't there, if you could like allow the Spirit, the Holy

Spirit in you to show you like what is, is there a particular reason why that sound of voice of her voice touched your heart? Like your body's telling you your heart is being touched. So just like to learn just a little bit more and whether you're called to share something of that so that your fiance can know you more. And I don't mean share necessarily about the physical reaction, but about the heart

thing that is going on in you, what what you're feeling in her presence. Also to take that physical, those physical reactions as as a call to get to know her heart better. Because truly, like we have deep mysteries within each of us. You know, the, the man and the woman. And if if a physical reaction is causing your brain to spin on its own concerns and worries,

like she may even feel that you're not fully present to her anymore. And, and allowing that physical response to inspiring you a curiosity about her, about anything about her to know her more. It it draws you into the being fully more fully present to the mystery of her person, which is is what generates a beautiful marital union, that desire to genuinely know the other person

more deeply. So those are some. Well said, Wendy, I'm so glad you brought that up. Yes, the the whole purpose of our Constitution with all of our emotions and sensual excitability is to bring about an authentic communion of persons. And in this fallen world, our, our affections and our sensual excitability can go in wrong directions. And this invitation that Wendy and I are holding out to Ed to,

to find peace here. Obviously this is not some license to, you know, indulge sensual excitability in a disordered way. You're, you're not saying that you're experiencing sexual climax. If that had happened, obviously your will was engaged in a way that that took you in a in a wrong direction. Right. There is there is need for for prudence and and caution here. But let me also quote from John Paul the second in this regard. He says this prudence and

caution, however, most certainly does not go to show that sensual excitability is in itself morally wrong. I'm quoting here again, as I did previously, from Love and Responsibility. And then listen to this. This is one of my favorite lines ever from JP 2. Listen, Ed, listen, brother, this is for you. Because he's describing you in exuberant and readily roused. Sensuality is the stuff from which a rich, although

difficult, personal life may be made. Why? Why difficult? Because we have to learn, as I've been saying, to put that excitability at the service of the dignity of the person. This is what Wendy was Speaking of as well. He goes on to say a readily roused and exuberant sensuality may become a factor. This is exactly your point. Wendy may become a factor making for a fuller and more ardent love. Right, that interpersonal

connection. But such a love, JP 2 concludes, will obviously be the result of sublimation. What does sublimation mean? It means lifting it up, making it sublime, right? Attaching that sensual reaction in your body to the dignity of your fiance. Raising that sensual reaction, JP 2 will say, raising our reactions to the level of the dignity of the person such that

I am free to be a gift and I can rejoice in being that gift. Ed, you're on that journey. You are on that road. Keep going, brother, and whatever guilt is haunting you from your past, open those memories. Open those painful experiences to the light and mercy and forgiveness and healing of the Holy Spirit. Let the Lord pour oil on those wounds, brother. Those those wounds don't just go away, right?

Forgiveness is one thing. I'm sure you've confessed all of this stuff. Forgiveness is one thing, but interior healing is another. The healing of those memories is another aspect of our journey that we all have to go on. And you may, Ed, be a good candidate. In fact, I think you are, for that sexual integration and redemption course that we're offering here at the end of February 2026. So maybe look into that. It will help you to be a gift. And that, of course, is always our ending note in the show, that each of us, each of us is

called to be the gift that God made us to be. And there is grace for each of us, flowing from the death and resurrection of Christ, to enable us. To become what we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is

helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode