Questions answered this episode: I’m part of a conservative Catholic group on Facebook. I was surprised to find that many Catholics there believe NFP is contraceptive except in the gravest circumstances. When I questioned this philosophy, they said that the fact that God gave them each of their many children is that it would've been sinful if they had abstained during those fertile times. This didn’t sit right with me. I've always felt that NFP gave me and my husband a profound respect for my body, our fertility, and spacing our family in a way that is respectful of everyone’s needs. I think it's responsible to abstain when you know you cannot take care of another baby. What are your thoughts? I am in college and I've never dated. However, I'm trying to build my bank of knowledge so I can be as ready as I can when God entrusts a woman to me. That said, my question is about the metaphors you used in your Jordan Peterson & Ben Shapiro reaction video. I don't understand how one can dive into your spouse’s soul and find undiscovered treasures during sex. How can one do that without using words. How is that possible outside of prayer? I am a 31 year old mother of two beautiful girls and wife to a loving husband. I've struggled with porn and masturbation for many years. Recently I’ve grown deeper in my Catholic faith; doing my best to purify my heart further by diving into my hidden thoughts. I find myself daydreaming and thinking about other men more from emotional fantasy, than from physical attraction. I want to stay mentally faithful to my husband. How can I as woman battle the temptation to have unfaithful thoughts? Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: Are you ready for marriage? Check out Next Step: A Course for Discerning Marriage 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here 🌟 For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Well, hello everybody. Hi, podcast listeners. Thanks for joining us again. I have that 1980s song in my head. It's the final countdown. Guess why Wendy. No idea. No idea because it's the final
countdown to our 300th episode, which is next week because this is episode 299. OK, I don't actually even know this final countdown song. I'm totally out of the. Loop of this sorry. You'll have to play it for me later. I know there are people out there who can hear it and see the guy with that long curly hair. Yeah, I think the name of the band was Europe. OK. Oh, the 80s hair bands. Oh, my word. That was a phenomenon. Kind of exciting.
Did you have a did you like any of those guys with the big hair in the 80s was like. It was almost like it was a requirement. If you're going to be a rock star, you have to have some amazing hairdo. Like there's no normal hairdos allowed for rock stars. So I don't know. I just saw it as like almost like the uniform you got to have it. Yeah, I, I it's funny now. Like, I saw this documentary recently of Jon Bon Jovi and he, he's one of those 80s big hair
icons. And he was, I thought, in an appropriate way, kind of poking fun at himself and just accepting, like, a lot of people kind of roll their eyes at their youthful stupidity. But Jon Bon Jovi was like, well, that was the thing then, You know, You know, everybody looks back at their high school yearbook and it's like. Oh no. Yeah, and he but he had a peaceful acceptance. Sometimes I look back at stupid things I did and I kind of beat myself up about it. I cringe a little. But I I actually learned a
little something of self acceptance from Jon Bon Jovi of all people. Good. How about that? That's really good. Thank you, Jon Bon Jovi. Yeah, we all need to learn to accept ourselves growing through life, don't we? It's important. It is a challenge. Well, that said, do you have updates for us on the TOB Institute? Yes, here is an opportunity for growth and self acceptance and going through life and taking next steps and maturing. I've mentioned this on previous
episodes, but it bears mentioning again because we're always getting new listeners. We have a program that our dear friends and colleagues at the TOB Institute, Ross and Elizabeth Busby put together called Next Step. And if you're not aware of it, you should be. That's why I'm telling you about it. It is designed for dating couples who are trying to discern should we get engaged and be married. And it's taking very seriously John Paul the Second's kind of
map for how we prepare for married life. So it's based on John Paul the Second's teaching. It's been I've really enjoyed in my travels, people will come up to me and say, could you please thank Ross and Elizabeth because we went through the Next Step program and it really, really helped us. So whether you are a dating couple or not, certainly, you know, people, maybe family members, friends who are dating and they're just wondering it's,
it's hard in the world today that that we are not trained typically the way we're raised to make commitments. We're afraid of commitments and there's reason for that. I get it. The commitments can be scary. Next Step is designed to to really enter into a proper time of discernment as a dating couple to see if you're called to make that next step. So if you're a dating couple, please check out the link below. If you know dating couples and want to help them in their process of discernment, please check that link below. It's an excellent program
integrating theology of the body into that discernment. I love that. I love that you are reminding our podcast listeners about that. I think they're really going to benefit from it. Yeah, it's it's a great program are. You ready for a question from a patron? I am. Let's do it. This is from Amy I. Still have that Europe song in my head. Put it up. Lord, please focus, focus. Here we go. This is from Amy. I'm thinking of Amy. She's a real person out there and I want to Amy, I want to
speak to Amy's heart, so. Amy says. Dear Christopher and Wendy, I'm part of a conservative Catholic forum on Facebook. There I was surprised to learn that many Catholics believe practicing natural family planning is contraceptive, except under the gravest of circumstances, such as the mother would die if she got pregnant again. When I questioned this philosophy, they said the fact that God gave them each of their
many children is proof it would have been sinful to have abstained during those fertile times. This does not sit right with me. I've always felt NFP has given my husband and me a profound respect for my body, our fertility, and spacing our family in a way that is respectful of everyone's needs. I think it's responsible to abstain when you know you can't care for another baby right now. What are your thoughts? Amy, bless you.
I am so sorry that you have been subjected to this nonsense. It is so painful to me when good hearted people like yourself when I encounter that these wrong headed people have have have really like gotten in there and troubled your conscience. You can fall off the boat and the boat here is the church. You can fall off the boat on the left and on the right and these
people have fallen off the boat on the right. Gosh darn it, it really the reason it gets under my skin in a particularly aggravating way is because it passes itself off as holiness. It is not. It is not. In fact, oftentimes, and I'm not here to jump into somebody's heart and assign with some kind of certainty. I can't read people's hearts,
but I do in the work that I do. I hear all kinds of stories, all kinds of stories, and it has come to my attention on various occasions that what's really going on in some of these situations is lack of self mastery. In other words, they don't abstain because they can't abstain or at least one of them in the marriage can't abstain. I remember this one married couples coming to my mind where
the wife came to me in, in serious, seriously difficult circumstances. They had many young children very close together. And for her, her psychological sanity, she was pleading with her husband, please to abstain, please, we need to abstain. And he, they didn't abstain because he couldn't abstain. And you know that then they, oh, they must be super Catholic because look at all their kids. They must be following the church's teaching.
No, they are not following the Church's teaching because the Church invites us to self mastery. Love is impossible without self mastery. So I just hold that out as one example that sometimes, again, I'm not making blanket statements, but sometimes what's behind this supposed virtue is lack of virtue. And let me just put it plainly, it is always, always lack of
virtue to be more Catholic than the Church, right? We can trust the Church and our mother. The Church has not said that you have to be on your deathbed or something in order to justly abstain and use natural family planning. There are many occasions. In fact, John Paul the Second tells us you might have a moral obligation to refrain from intercourse and and not bring
another life into the world. This this idea. And let me just point out the the false logic in one who says it was clearly God's will that we have this child because this child exists. Therefore if we had abstained, it would not we would have been sinning. That is not sound logic. It is sound logic to say we know it was God's will for this child to exist because he does, because that child would not exist if God didn't will it.
But what is what is lacking in that vision of things is the mystery. And we, we just have to honor that word mystery of how God's will interacts with our freedom. We have to reverence that word mystery because it is a mystery and we can't. We can't really make a a logical sense of how it all works chronologically, but God's will
interacts with our freedom, right? And it is, it is, it is foolishness for you and me, Wendy, to look back at our discernment where we believed it was right for us to abstain, to avoid another pregnancy and think, Oh my gosh, we really screwed up God's will because there are, there are children who don't exist because we didn't come together when you were fertile in 1998.
There are children who don't exist. Well, guess what? They don't exist. There are not children who don't exist because they don't exist. And this is this is the mystery of how God's will interacts with our freedom. Let's put it this way. Here's another example on the other side of the coin. Is it God's will for every child that is conceived to be conceived? We have to say, we have to say yes. Is it God's will that women be?
I hate the words so I'll spell it RAPED. No. No, no, no one would have to conclude that. If you're going to go with that straight logic, one would have to well, it was God's will for this child to exist, therefore it was God's will for this woman to be RAPEDD. No, it was not. No, it was not. No, it was not. So I, I get zealous here because we're so stupid sometimes.
I'm stupid too. We're all stupid sometimes. And we're stupid when we, when we fail to trust Mother Church and what she holds out to us. And I've heard, I've heard well known Catholic personalities out there who say things like natural family planning. Nope. We use supernatural family planning and what's being said
there is, you know, it's wrong on so many levels. I don't even want to get into. It's just, it's just wrong on so many levels and it puts burdens on people's consciences. That is wrong on so many levels. Trust, Trust my dear sister, Trust Amy in the wisdom of the church and don't go on those forums where people are falling off the boat on the right.
Don't go on those forums. Don't if you're susceptible to their to their mistakes and errors, then don't don't expose yourself to it. Trust mother church. And I just want to connect the dot with my, my previous statement about, you know, the illogic of we know it's God's will that this child exists. Therefore it has to be God's will that this woman was RAPEDD. No, no, no, no. Let me connect the let me connect the dots here. You can't say. You can't say. We know it was God's will for this child to exist.
Therefore we know it was God's will that we came together on that night. It might have been, in fact, it might have been your moral duty to abstain. It might have been your moral duty to abstain because your wife came to you, wigged out with five kids under the age of seven, begging you for a break in the spacing of the children, and you, because you couldn't control yourself, engaged in an
unloving act. So don't tell me that that logic is not sound. It might have been God's will for you to abstain, and you didn't. And guess what? This is the loving God we have. Even when we act contrary to His will, He is ready and willing to bring about the most stunning miracle of creation, the creation of another human life, so he can bring good out of our bad choices. But we cannot claim that because
a child came to be that, that that is proof that we should have come together on that occasion. We just can't. That is not sound theologic. Theologic. It's not sound. Yeah, Christopher, I, I really share a lot of the concerns you're all the concerns you're expressing there. And I think it's so important to help people to recognize the, the the call to love is it it goes to these deep places in our
our hearts and we have you have these barriers to allowing the Lord's light in. And some of them, this patron Amy encountered in this group. I love what she said about natural family planning that it has given her and her husband a profound respect for her body, their fertility and spacing their family in a way that is respectful of everyone's needs. So such a good simple summary of beautiful benefits to embracing
the church's, embracing the church's teaching that our marital union is always to be open to life. When we use natural family planning to avoid pregnancy, we don't stop being open to life. And I think people also confuse that phrase with desiring a pregnancy. That's not the same. It's it's open to life in that we aren't acting against the way God made our union as the light
source of new life. So I think in that you're open to the lives of new family members, you're open to what is good for the lives of those already in your family. And that is so beautiful. And I absolutely agree. I mean, just to reiterate, there are many sinful behaviors that bring new life into the world. And the very people on this forum would not therefore conclude that fornication,
adultery, you know, in vitro fertilization are all morally good because new life comes from it. So they, they're being totally inconsistent in their thinking. And that should be quite obvious to them. If you wanted to reply to somebody who said that, that that is so obvious that that's not a, a sensible connection to make. But yes, Amy, I thank you for just bringing this up and bringing this to people's attention. And if you're somebody who's never heard this this way and maybe felt like you were like
really following God by just never questioning whether you should abstain. I just want you to know that we aren't saying here that we just don't love you just as much as we love Amy or any other listener. We love your heart and its journey and hope that you can as you maybe wrestle with this answer that you experience at a mercy that you are where you are. And the Lord is just through the fact that you're hearing this
calling you to a deeper understanding of what it means to be responsible parents in in a new way as as spouses, as mother and father. And I hope that it actually blesses your heart to hear this and and understand what the Lord has more. Yeah, we're all thick at some level, or in the more crass way I put it, we're all stupid here at some level. We're we're hardened of heart
and that hardness of heart manifests in so many ways, and it often disguises itself as righteousness and holiness. And we know where that goes with the whole Pharisaical dimension of, you know, the gospel and where Christ was so directly confrontational with those who hid their vice behind supposed virtue. And we just have to be so careful about that. And we can really trust the church. I'll just add this. Is it possible to use natural family planning with the wrong
mentality? Yeah. Yeah. Could you bring a kind of a sort of contraceptive mentality to the to the practice of natural family planning? You could. Yeah. Is that in keeping with the church's vision and teaching? No. What the church calls us to is virtue. JP 2 is so clear here that the practice of natural family planning makes sense only as a practice of virtue and what the Church says in terms of what is just reason to avoid a child.
We, the couple alone. This is JP 2's words. The couple and the couple alone are responsible to ensure that their motivation is not selfishness and that that selfish motivation is either in am I abstaining out of selfishness or am I engaging in the marital act out of selfishness? Either way, we can, we cannot, we must not be motivated by selfishness. Guess what? We're all going to see selfishness in our hearts and we can open that up and trust the
Lord's going to love us there in our selfishness, in our pride, in our stupidity, in our hardness of heart. That's the bad news. We all suffer from those things. The good news is we're all loved right there and we can grow and be purified. So let's just say yes to that calling, and let's trust the church along the way. I have one more thing to say. Yeah, I'm thinking about these families who do have many children, as Amy noted. And I just want to encourage listeners who have the opportunity to help in some way any of these families to discern
whether that is something the Lord is calling you to that with this understanding that not to be judgmental of people who have many children and. Or judgmental of those who just have one or two. Right, yes, to to have a heart of mercy and trusting the Lord is at work in our all of our journeys. But I just want to encourage people to recognize that, that it could be a calling to help people. And I I don't want you to
hesitate to do that. And I, I want to comment just one more thing too, which is Amy's kind of exposition that that litany she gave of the benefits. And it's not so much the benefits of natural family planning, it's the benefits of self mastery and respect for fertility and, and times of abstinence. So you've heard me say this so many times, Wendy. Maybe some listeners have heard me say it many times. It bears repeating. My counsel to couples is even if
you do not have a reason to be avoiding a pregnancy, you should nonetheless be working regular times of abstinence into the rhythm of your married life. Obviously, it doesn't need to be during the fertile time, but nonetheless you should be working times of abstinence into the rhythm of your married life. Why? Because abstinence is where we learn to exercise self mastery so that we can say no in order to bolster the true freedom of our yes.
Because if you can't say no, your yes means nothing. Amen. Thank you Amy for sharing your heart. We hope what we shared has helped you. Yes. Our next question is from a listener named Jackson. Hey, Jackson. Hey, Mr. W, thank you for your incredible work. Your content has helped me pursue chastity as a young man very much. I am in college and I've never dated. However, I'm trying to build my Bank of knowledge so I can be as
ready as I can be when God entrusts a woman to me. That being said, my question is about the metaphors you described during your Ben Shapiro Jordan Peterson reaction video. I do not understand how one can dive into your spouse's soul and find beautiful undiscovered treasures during sex. How can one do that without using words? How is it possible outside of
prayer? Thank you and God bless you. Bless you Jackson I you're paying attention that's fun he's so he's referencing a YouTube video and I'll just throw this out to all our podcast listeners. If you are not aware of what we're doing on YouTube, give, give it a look. We're, we're, we've put a lot of time and energy and resources into our YouTube channel and there's some real, real treasures there that you can share with others. So he's referring to some reaction video I did and I think I have a, a memory of it.
I was watching some what, what do you say? Ben Shapiro and, and Jordan Peterson and they were talking about, if I remember correctly, you know, what makes sex satisfying or something. And, and I, I brought up this image, which I, I talk about on occasion. And I, I love that Jackson is just acknowledging these are, these are metaphors, right? We're talking about profound, deep spiritual mysteries. And the only way you can access
those mysteries with words is through imagery, through poetry, through metaphor. So let me just share the metaphor and then I'll, for those who aren't aware of it, and then I'll, I'll answer Jackson's question more specifically. The metaphor I say is, is the marital embrace is meant to be an experience of true intimacy. Intimacy. What does that word mean? It it comes from the Latin Intus, which means the
superlative of that which is within. In other words, intus, the superlative means the the most within the inmost, the deepest and genuine intimacy is happening only in as much as we are sharing our hearts, our our inmost. Now I'll I'll add this as an important qualifier. The deepest most in most in most is for God and God alone. And that means, Wendy, there are
places in your heart that are just between you and and Jesus and there are places in my heart that are just between me and Jesus. But there is a level of the heart just above that that is meant to be opened up to your spouse. And that's the level of intimacy I'm I'm talking about here. And so isn't it funny we use this, the word intimacy, as a euphemism for sex, right?
I want to be intimate with you tonight. Or they were intimate with each other. Well, were they really? It's possible to open your body and never open your heart. And that is a contradiction in which we often live. And it causes us great, great sorrow, great suffering to, to, to have that contradiction between body and heart or body and soul, where I'll I'll give you my body, but I'm not giving you my heart. I'm not because you're going to hurt me.
You're going to wound me. I'm not going to open to you. That's that's a contradiction. Hard to live with and deeply wounding. But in a more integral reality, which takes time in any marriage to get really naked in the sense of exposing your heart. This is what I say. I say the husband's mission is to go deep sea diving because his wife's heart is like a deep ocean and there are treasures in there that he will discover that she doesn't even know are there.
And I also say, guys, you can't go swimming around in your wife's ocean if she doesn't open it up to you because that would be a violation if you started poking around in there and she didn't open it up to you. And then the reverse image, as I say, ladies as wives, your mission in life is to go spelunking, cave exploring, because your husband's heart is like a deep cave and there are ever deeper caverns to discover in there. And there are treasures, Wendy, that you've discovered in those caverns of my I didn't even know
those caverns were there. But this is this is an attempt. And it's just an attempt. It's not a perfect image, but it's an attempt to put words, to give a metaphor to an experience of true intimacy. Where I where, where, where places of the heart get opened up and you feel the welcome presence of your loved one there. Like, I don't know how else to put it in words.
Like, there are times. Yeah, I that metaphor is the best I can do. There are, there are caverns. Some. Here's another metaphor I'll use. You've heard me say this, Wendy. I feel like my chest just got split open. Like, like, and this is a loving image. I don't mean it in some like murderous way, but like Wendy, you just took an axe and like, like, like my, like my chest was this chunk of wood and you took this, this axe And like, I don't know if anybody out there chops wood, but you know, when you chop wood and you can, you can you get that nice like whack and
you hear the innards of the log, like cracking starts to crack all and you're like, yes, Bill, your treasures. It's going to open up to me like that's the image. I chop a lot of wood. We we live on a wooded property. So I chop a lot of wood and I love that thwack and you hear that and it opens up and that you get the smell of the inner core of the, the, the wood. That's another image like Wendy, you have this Wendy Thwack. And if anybody wants to know about the Wendy Thwack, listen to episode one of our podcast
where I talk about the way Wendy cracks an egg. Thwack. The Wendy Thwack. You have this loving Wendy Thwack that cracks my heart open like a chunk of wood or like an egg or something. And the yolk comes out or the the inner secrets of the tree crack open and spill their their their contents again, metaphor, metaphor. It's the only way to access these places. But Jackson then asks the question, can you read it again about can you? Is there any way to enter these places without prayer?
How can one do that without using words? How is it possible outside of prayer? Yeah, well, it's not possible outside of prayer. This is where marital union. I'm going to use JP 2's expression. He says conjugal union in some way becomes liturgical. Liturgical. What does that mean? It becomes worship of God. What does that mean? It becomes prayer. What is prayer? Prayer is nothing other than
opening the contents of our hearts to the Lord and and the marital embrace is meant to be all of those things. The marital embrace is meant to be an offering of our bodies not only to one another, but to the living God. Offer your bodies in living sacrifice. This is your spiritual act of worship. Saint Paul says, yeah, that applies to the marriage bed. We are offering our bodies not only to one another, we're offering them as a spiritual act of worship to the living God.
It's it's liturgical in that sense, we are, we are entering into the, the liturgical mystery of Christ, the bridegroom saying to his bride, this is my body given for you and, and the bride saying, Amen, let it be done to me, Amen. And, and what happens we in the liturgy, the the representation of Calvary and what happened at Calvary? Christ's heart was pierced, was split open, and its contents
poured out. In other words, the cross is the invitation to an astounding intimacy with the living God. Where his heart, he goes first, He opens first. He pours out the contents of his heart to us, and he's inviting us to open to him. He stands at the door and knocks, and if we open to him, he will enter and Sup with us,
dying with us. He never barges in. He knocks, He knocks the lover. In the song of songs, which is ultimately Christ, he says Open to me, my love, my dove, my beautiful one, open to me, open to me. You are garden enclosed, my sister, my bride, open to me. Those are metaphors not only of of the marital union, but of that opening of the heart into profound places of into me.
See, which is kind of a clever way of talking about intimacy right into me. See, it happens through prayer and it happens through the liturgy. And the liturgy is prayer and the marital union is meant to be liturgical. So when all that comes together, prayer, liturgy, the Sacramento mystery of the marital embrace, when all that comes together, metaphor is all you got to to to try to put into words what happens when hearts open and you
discover treasures of the other. And we're we're when, when we when we don't open our hearts, all we got is the merely physical dimension. And sex becomes boring very quickly and then you, you look for physical varieties and things get kinky and funky really, really fast. But if you are on that true journey of into me, see, you are never bored with one another because there's always more discover. There's always more depth to the
wife's ocean and there's always new caverns to the man's cave. And if you're on that journey, you, you're excited about that journey. And every level of new intimacy demands a new vulnerability. And you have to work through fears and issues. And it's not an easy journey. Yeah, scary. And I'll close with this, and then I'll toss it to you, Wendy. Another possible route of the word intimacy, it could also come from the Latin intimeray,
which means be not afraid. Be not afraid. I have to say one more thing because I think it's important to connect these dots. True human intimacy will happen only in as much as we are in that journey of intimacy with the Lord. Opening our hearts to the Lord and knowing we're loved there is what enables us to take the risk of opening our hearts to to one another. So I thought that was important to say.
You said so many good things and I, like you, appreciated Jackson's like trying to imagine what could this mean? You know, when he's hearing you say this in a video and like, wait, I don't get it. And I don't I don't know how anybody could get it because I just don't think it makes sense. I just like his honesty about that. And I want to say just as you did, because he's he kind of almost gave the answer, how is it possible outside of Prairie kind of like hinted at the truth.
I also want to say that that deepening of revelation in the marital union corresponds to a deepening revelation that includes words in our journey of our relationships. So he says, how's that possible without using words? You may not necessarily be using words during your marital union, although it's not like it's forbidden to speak to one another. But that's that's a totally
separate question. But the point being that in our relating with one another, I don't want to say it only corresponds in One Direction because it corresponds in two directions. So the the first, maybe more obvious direction would be the more we talk with one another about what it is like to be me and what it is like to be you and what your story is and what my story is, and know one another more and more through that literal communication with
words. Then that can lead and lend itself toward deeper receptivity to unspoken realities of the other. In our union, that is absolutely true. In that direction, it is also true. And this is what I want to share with Jackson, even in as so important that the wordless, heartfelt openness to the gift of another who is a mystery that
you can experience during marital union also causes a deepening of that curiosity and that interest and desire to share words with one. Another said Wendy. Yes, it. Definitely goes both ways. And the body itself, JP 2 says, has a language. It's spoken without words, but the words that correspond to the
language of the body, when it is spoken truthfully are the words of the wedding vows. I, I give myself to you freely. I give myself to you totally. I give myself to you faithfully. And yes, we are open, open to life. We are open to receiving children lovingly from God. These are the promises we make at the altar. Have you come here freely to give yourself wholeheartedly? Do you promise to be faithful until death? Do you promise to receive children lovingly from God?
We say yes, yes, yes, yes. And the marital embrace, if we're speaking the language of the body, truthfully becomes that language spoken with the body. In other words, the words of the wedding vows are made flesh in the marital embrace, or at least they are meant to be. That is the entire logic of the theology of our bodies. We are meant to speak that kind of love because this is the love
that God speaks to us. He loves us freely, totally, faithfully, and fruitfully. The whole marital mystery is the key to understanding the biblical story. God wants to marry us. That's the covenant promise. That's the grace, that's the gift of Christ. When Christ says this is my body given for you, that those, them, there are marital promises. That's the wedding commitment. That's the, that's the commitment of the bridegroom to the bride. The Eucharist, as JP 2 says, is
the sacrament of the bridegroom and the bride. They're all those elements, marital intimacy, intimacy with the Lord, liturgy, prayer, all of them come together and take us on a lifelong and beyond this lifelong journey into eternity. Eternity will be the intimacy of the communion of Saints participating in the communion of the Trinity.
Infinite, eternal intimacy. Wow, Lord, prepare us, help us to become the men and women we are meant to be so that we can participate in that kind of intimacy. And even as I say it like wow, I got a lot of work to do. There's a lot of lot of stuff for that I need. I'm, I am not yet ready for the communion of Saints. Lord, prepare my heart for that kind of intimacy. That's what marriage is supposed to do. Prepare you for heaven. I love it. So do I. Our next question is from a
listener named Vic. Hi, Vic. I'm a 31 year old mother of two beautiful girls and wife of a loving husband. I've struggled with porn and masturbation for many years. Recently I've grown deeper in my Catholic faith and I'm doing my best to purify my heart further. Diving deep into my hidden thoughts. I often find myself daydreaming and thinking about other men.
More from an emotional fantasy than from physical attraction, although that can play a part in it. A deep part of me desires attention and any man that lingers his eyes on me a bit too long or consistently follows me on social media seems to validate me and peaks my attention. I feel I have a deep insecurity about my worth and get excitable when I'm validated in my physical appearance, even though I try to avoid being immodest.
I don't know how to solve this dilemma. I love and want to stay mentally faithful to my husband. How can I, as a woman, battle against the temptation to have unfaithful thoughts? Wow, I am so moved by her honesty. I am so moved by her awareness of her own heart. I just want to hold this.
This level of honesty is what is absolutely required to to become the men and women we are created to be. It is absolutely required. That kind of stark, bold, courageous honesty about what is really going on in our hearts and man, that that is already evidence of a lot of interior work and. A lot of grace. A lot of grace, Yes, A lot of grace. I mean, yeah. And you can't do that interior
work without grace. So Victoria, and by the way, I think your name is a prophecy. You are on the path of victory already, Victoria and the victory is coming your way and you can hope in it and trust in it, but it it it is, it is so evident that you are already opening your inmost that what's what? That's what we were talking about in the previous answer. You are already opening your
inmost to the Lord because these movements that you describe with such awareness and and and knowledge of your own heart. How did she said at one point, I'm trying to open my inner thoughts and desires. How did she say that? I'm doing my best to purify my heart further, diving deep into my hidden thoughts. There it is, diving deep into your hidden thoughts. That's Jesus diving deep into your hidden thoughts. I don't think you can get to
this place of of knowledge of your inner thoughts, which you have already evidence without grace. And that grace is Jesus. So I, I just feel like doing a little victory dance for Victoria right now because there are major victories already underway here. And I think Wendy, your sense in that too, just in the way she she worded that question. But let me let me zoom in on on this. I was taken in a particular way, struck in a particular way by your desire for attention and
and how a man who might linger too long looking at you gives you a sense of validation that is a window into a very, very tender sacred zone of your heart. Vic now it it it, it's the desire is what I want to validate and and bless and affirm where you're taking it at
your own admission is in need of correction. But we can only overcome 1 misdirected passion with a stronger, rightly directed passion, right? What is sin? Sin is a misguided attempt to satisfy a genuine human desire. Your desire to be seen, your desire to be known, your desire to be affirmed, your desire to
be validated. Those are doorways into profound, and I'll use this word also, mystical intimacy with Jesus, the kind of profound mystical intimacy that the Saints describe as nuptial union with the Lord. This is Pope Benedict the 16th. He says when the Christian
prays, the Christian is seeking nuptial union with the Lord. This is JP two. We have a duty, he says, to show the modern world the depths of intimacy to which prayer can lead. It leads us, he says, through many painful purifications. Through those purifications we come to experience, says John Paul the Second, the ineffable
joy of union with the Lord, a union described by the Saints as nuptial union. Nuptial union. I invite you, Victoria, in the very same way you have opened up your heart to us in in the way you've worded your question. And I'm sure there are details that you didn't include for the sake of propriety, which is, as the word would indicate is
appropriate. But there are there are fantasies in your heart. There are desires in your heart. There are longings in your heart that can and should be opened to Jesus. And just as you experience them, you don't need to pretty them up. Whatever you she mentioned some level of fantasy she has about men or she could you could you read that again? Because I think this might be the.
I find myself daydreaming and thinking about other men more from an emotional fantasy. There it is. There it is. Daydreaming and thinking about other men from an emotional fantasy, from an emotion. What does she? Is that what she said? From an yeah, an emotional, Yeah, not so much a physical, but a more of an emotional fantasy. Take all of those daydreams. Take all of those fantasies without censoring them and give them to Jesus. Open them to Jesus. Write them in a letter to Jesus.
Even if they were attached to a particular man, Maybe it's some neighbor down the street, or maybe it's some guy you noticed at the grocery store. Whatever it might be, say Jesus, this man stirred my heart in this way. And here's what happened, and here's what I felt, and here's the Daydream that it took me on. I opened this content of my heart to you, Lord, and in opening it now listen, Now
listen for the Lord's voice Prayer, JP 2 says, is meant to be a dialogue of love that leads us to vibrate at the Spirit's touch. He says when we open the contents of our heart to the Lord. Here's a quote from the Catechism. We, we, we are called in prayer to let our masks fall, to present ourselves to the Lord as we are.
Now here's the kicker, In order to be purified and transformed, I'm not saying present this to the Lord, These things going on in your heart because they're, they're wonderful just as they are. Present them to the Lord so that he can purify them and transform them. What does that look like? Well, it's hard to put these things into words. But if sin is a misguided attempt to satisfy a genuine human desire, well, the fruit of
purification of our misguided desires is that now our desires become less and less misguided and more and more properly directed at what we're really desiring. And I I can say this with utmost certainty, Victoria, what you are really desiring in all of these daydreams and fantasies, what you are really desiring is to know to know Christ the Lord,
to know him in that in the nuptial, in the in the sense of those mystical nuptials. This is eternal life. Jesus says to know the living God. This is what God says through the prophet Hosea. I will betrothe you to me infidelity and you will know the Lord. In fact, Victoria, I would invite you to enter in prayerfully to that verse from the prophet Hosea. I believe it's chapter 2.
I I'm not certain about that. Maybe chapter 4 verse there's a 2IN there somewhere. I don't know, but just Google it. It's it's I will betroth you to me forever and you will know the Lord. That's what you're looking for. That's what you're looking for as you present these misguided desires, as you open them up, as you experience them to the Lord. Journal it out, write it out, write it out in a letter to Jesus. Pour your heart out to the Lord without censoring anything, even if it gets uncomfortable. The Lord is not scandalized by
any of it. He knows what you're really looking for, and He knows how to bless and affirm the genuine desire underneath the misguided attempts to satisfy it. And this is the good part. He knows how to satisfy that genuine human desire. He knows how to bless and affirm you as a woman. He knows how to bless you and affirm you as a bride. He knows how to bless and affirm you as a mother. He knows how to bless and affirm you as a person made in the image and likeness of God. He knows how to kiss those most tender needs and desires of your
your heart. If we don't learn how to take these tender, intimate yearnings of our heart to the Lord, we have two options. Crush your heart or take them in misguided directions. I don't like either one of those options. Both end in neurosis and destruction of our humanity and the lives of others too. The only path forward is to learn the the treacherous path of opening it all to Jesus and letting Him purify and redirect
those desires to what we're really looking for. Yeah, I, I feel just such a desire as you started out to, to affirm this journey that Victoria's on because she is talking at at first about having a history with porn and masturbation. And my sense is that she's not not engaging in those anymore and she's looking at now what is still going on in her journey, going deeper with the Lord and.
Can I say a word about that? I think this is important to say that masturbation will be the fruit of of having either misdirected those desires in a consistent way or crushing our our desires, repressing them. It, it either way, it, it ends in a, in A and, and masturbation is a kind of neurotic behavior and that's not said to scold or shame anybody.
And and even if she were still falling into that sin, nonetheless, that is a window into these same tender yearnings and desires that can be rightly directed. Yes, Yeah. I think what I'm just sensing, what I was going to say is that it's so beautiful how this speaks of a healing process. Yes, yes. She's on, she's on it. Because, you know, there's a certain outwardness or I don't know quite how to say that
there's a physical activity of looking at porn, of masturbation. That is a certain level that that speaks of things in the heart and has I, I really see the Lord is taking her on this journey to understand more and more just the genuine state of her heart that that was contained in those activities that was there. It was hidden underneath. And now she's able to see them more and, and to be able to see them is a gift.
And it's a gift to all our listeners to have you explain that those dynamics within of, of longing for attention to be sure of your worth, all of that, like, Oh yes, it's so real and honest. So thank you so much for sharing that. And I, I just feel like a gratitude to the Lord for already bringing you this far. And I think everything you said, Christopher is, is about just trusting that the Lord wants to bring her further and further.
And I, what I just see is, is the way that continually encountering the Lord. And I think of the woman at the well and, and the woman caught in adultery and their profound encounters with the merciful, knowing, loving gaze of Jesus in those encounters. That that is transformative, that that that repeatedly just continually bringing to the Lord these dynamics. It, it is part of the healing
journey where the, you could, can look forward to in the future when you experience similar things that used to lead you into a, an emotional and you know, a fantasy that you will eventually experience just the Lord's love and mercy for you right there. And that will be freedom for you. And I, I can see that down the road of this journey. And I'm so excited for you 'cause it's coming. And it's, it's like, so it's all
about like the Lord's incarnation, like came into the human experience to set us free. He came in, he came in and he wants to let you have you let him into you in an ever more deep way for the deeper and deeper freedom. It's it's so beautiful. And there's the prophecy of her name. Victoria. The Lord will bring to completion the work He has begun in you. Victoria, be not afraid.
And since we've answered three questions, guess where we are? What stage of our podcast? It's the final countdown, the loop. It came around again. Thank you everybody for listening. If you are blessed today by this episode, please hit that share button. If you know someone else who you think, whom you think would be blessed by it, hit that share button. Keep the questions coming. That's what makes this podcast possible. We love you all. You are a gift and by His grace,
may we all. Become what we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...