Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Why Do Men Have Nipples, The Beautiful Girl Never Chose Me, How Do I Share Christ Without Being That Guy | ACW376

Mar 16, 202655 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: Is there any insight through the lens of theology of the body as to why God gave male humans and male mammals nipples? It has always baffled me. When I was 14, I watched the first person I ever loved choose my best friend instead of me, right in front of my eyes. This event seared into my body a story, or perhaps a lie, which is: the most beautiful one will never choose me. Since then, I've been obsessed with finding the perfect girl and somehow convincing her to love me. As you can imagine, this has led to several failed dating relationships that all followed the same pattern of initial infatuation, disillusionment, and finally separation. I recently went back to confession for the first time in several years, and after telling the priest this story, he counseled me to meditate on the doctrine of election - that God, the most beautiful one, has already chosen me. I am so thankful for God's love, but I can't help feeling it is insufficient to meet this need and heal my wound. After all, didn't God choose me purely out of His own grace and love rather than because of anything in me that was desirable or beautiful? How then can I trust that I am worthy of love? As a disciple of Christ, I feel a desire to take his call to evangelize more seriously. I love my faith and want others to taste and see its beauty too. However, I’m not sure of the best approach. I have some secular coworkers, and the lifestyle they talk about seems so out of touch with the gospel. I’m not sure how to relate it to them without coming across as a goody-two-shoes. How can I go about spreading the word in situations such as those and shining the light of Christ? Resources: The Ballad of Wallis Island Trailer Course Schedule 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Hey everybody, welcome to another episode. Wendy, I'm happy to be with you. Thanks, my love. I'm happy to be with you, Christopher. Thank you. One way or another, our audience is going to laugh that we're having a brain fart.

About. About whether or not we've already commented on this movie that we wanted to comment on today. Because if we have commented on this movie already, they're going to think they already talked about that. And if we haven't, they're going to think, well, they're having a brain fart anyway because they can't remember if they've already talked about it. So one way or the other, deal with our we're in our 50s, we have brain farts and we're having one now. I'm sure we've had repeat banned topics. That's what we call our little open. Conversation. We're Banting.

Right. We've also repeated a question answered the same question. You told me that only recently. Yes, so. And how did you learn that? We repeated a question the. Person who submitted the question came to a course at BlackRock and told me you've answered my question on two different episodes. The same question. It's the very same. It wasn't resubmitted. It wasn't, it wasn't resubmitted. It was the same question that we answered twice and we didn't even catch it. So the people are paying attention. There you go. Well, the movie we wanted to tell you about. Or maybe we've already told you

about it. We can't remember it. Tell them about it. Yes. So you are the one who found out about it. And so I don't know how you learned of, I mean. Our son Isaac told me to watch. It How did he learn? Of it from a girl he knew it at college. OK, it's called the Ballad of Wallace Island. The Ballad of Wallace Island, correct? Yes, and it's set in England and. Some island off the coast, right? Yeah. Guess what the island's called?

I think it's called Wallace. I think it's called Wallace Island, yeah. So yeah, what do you want to say about that movie? You know, I like music. Music is a big part of my life and I knew I was going to like this movie within the 1st 30 seconds because it starts with this guy putting a record, a record on his record player, putting the needle down. Just hearing the needle just taps something deep in me because that's what I grew up listening to records and then use the Pamerick Pamera, the

Pamerick cans. I think you mean the camera pans. I think I mean the camera pans around his room and you see all these records with the same artist on them, CDs with the same artist on them, cassette tapes with the same artist, and one of the album covers has a whale in a certain shape on it. And then you the camera pans out and you see his sweater that has what's the how do you? I was about to say woven in, but knit, knit, knit into his sweater is the very whale from the cover.

And you can tell he had this sweater custom made. So you know, immediately this is a die hard fan of what is a fictitious music group because it's a movie. But right away I'm like, OK, this is going to be good. This is about a guy who's just die hard into this music. And then I don't want to say too much because it'll give too much away, but just to encourage you to go watch this movie. He he, he is wealthy independently.

You learn how, which is funny. He's a very quirky guy, lovable in his quirkiness. And we all need to know we're loved in our quirkiness. And that's part of the theme of the movie that I really appreciate it. He's a very lovable guy and all his endearing quirkiness and he spends this fortune. He has a big chunk of it to to have a private concert and to reunite this musical duo that he's such fans of to reunite them to come to Wallace Island

where he lives. And he's paid their, the necessary fees, which is a lot of money to have them do this private concert and how it unfolds. And the tension between these two musicians who it used to be a, an item that's male and female. They used to be an item and they, their music kind of brought them together. And then they broke up and now she's married to somebody else and they're dealing with all that tension and the way it unfolds it, it was just human

and good. What, what were your, some of your thoughts about it? What? What did you like? Yeah, I loved all the people. It was not a huge cast and so you spent a lot of time with this small cast and felt like you slowly got to know them and each one got to love them and that was just a beautiful experience. Yeah, and they, they go through good life lessons there. There's people who are familiar with my teaching, know how I talk about the three choices we have with our desire. Well, this musician, there's

been stuff in his heart that he's been repressing for a long time, and then it gets bubbled up, comes up and out again, and then he thinks he needs to indulge it and he learns there's another way, the third option. He enters into it and it's quite good. It is beautiful. Yeah, so if you're looking for a good movie, check it out and. Now I would love to know if you have any updates for us from the TOB Institute. Well, many of our listeners may not be aware that we have recently started offering our

online courses in a new format. Oh. Yeah. We traditionally have offered our online courses in a two week format. You have to take it for these two weeks and we're trying, we're trying to recreate kind of the the classroom feel as much as we could. Everybody's taking it now and we'd have the live Q&A's and such, but we got a lot of requests and we experimented with one course offering it in an on demand format, meaning you don't have to take it just

during these two weeks. And it works so well that we are extending it to all of our online courses. You don't have to take it in a given two week chunk. You have four months at your leisure to take the course in your own time and your own way and your own availability. And we've already gotten really, really good feedback. People are really blessed by it. And it's just a new way to get the message out there. So check out our list of online courses that are coming your way soon. You can click the link. And this is just, I say it all

the time. I'm going to say it again. We never want money to get in the way. We run a theological institute. It takes money to run it. So it's not like we can just give our courses away to everybody. But if you are in financial need, we have a scholarship program through the generosity of our patrons. So a big, big shout out to all our patrons out there. Thank you, patrons, for supporting this work, enabling us to to build up our scholarship funds to enable students to take our courses who

couldn't otherwise afford them. If you are not yet a patron and you want to add to our scholarship fund, could you please click that link and learn more about it? That's all I have to say about that for now. I love all that and I have a question for you from. From a patron. Thank you, patron. Is this a named patron or a no, No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. An an anonymous patron. That's all folks. This is from a named patron named Kelsey. Kelsey, thank you for your

support. Thank you for believing in our mission. Truly, we can't do this work without you. And I'm just going to say, Kelsey, we have some exciting things for our patron community on the horizon. We're working on some exciting things. They're going to unfold as the year goes on here, so stay tuned. Here is Kelsey's question. Is there any insight through the lens of theology of the body as to why God gave male humans and

male mammals nipples? Kelsey, I love you. I love that you're asking this question. She says. It has always baffled me. Kelsey, you're the kind of person I'd want to have over to dinner because we'd have some this, the fact that you even entertain this question and then submit it to the podcast and say this is a worthy question. I wonder if if the West's have ever thought about this. It just makes me smile and it makes me think I want to have a beer with you.

OK, I have pondered this question. I do believe there are principles from theology of the body that shine a light on it, but I'm not going to share it with you. Next question. Oh. Come on now. I'm sorry, I couldn't resist, I thought, because I could feel her getting all excited, and then I just had to pull the rug out just for a minute. And, you know, I like to do that sometimes or a lot. OK, so Kelsey, here's here's the light that shines that I think can shine.

Shine some insight. Does that make any sense? Shine some insight? I don't know. I'm mixing. No, whatever you everybody knows what I mean. So I'm just going to March right along. John Paul the second says that woman is the model and the archetype of the whole human race. Now he actually says this in Moliere's Dignitatum. But Mulier's Dignitatum, his letter on the dignity and vocation of women, is an extension of its theology of the body.

And what does that mean? Woman is the model and the archetype of the whole human race. Well, what does the theology of a woman's body teach all of us about being human? Woman's body is made to open, to receive the outpouring of the love of the bridegroom, of the seed of the bridegroom, the life giving potency of the bridegroom, to conceive that love within her through this new

life, to conceive new life through that love, better way to put it, and to give birth to that new life. Remember, this is not just biology, this is theology. And in the spousal analogy, God is always the bridegroom. Humanity is always the bride. God is always the bridegroom, humanity is always the bride. This is not arbitrary. It cannot be the other way. Why?

It is the Bridegroom who gives the seed, and it is God who pours out the love, who initiates the love. God creates outside of himself, right in the reproductive process. The male is the one who generates life outside of himself. It is the woman who generates life within herself. This is the very classification of what makes one a male and what makes 1A female. The male generates outside

himself. The female generates within herself. God in his eternal being is not male or female. As the Catechism says, there's no place for the difference of the sexes within the Godhead. However, in the spousal analogy, God is Bridegroom and humanity is bride, because God uses the created order. Indeed, he designed the created order to communicate the mystery of his relationship with his own creation.

So stamped right into the male female distinction and the call to holy life giving communion is an image of the relationship between the Creator and the creature and the call to holy life giving communion between the Creator and the creature. God initiates the gift. This is love. Not that we first love God, but that He first loved us. And in this imagery, this means He is always the Bridegroom.

Humanity is always the bride. So whether you are male or female in your relationship to the Creator, in spousal terms we are all bride. We are all feminine. This means that femininity is foundational to our humanity. It is, it is, it is the pattern of what it means to be human. And we see this not only theologically in the spousal

analogy, we see it biologically in our chromosomes, right? X is the chromosome that male and female share, right? If you throw in AYA, female is XX. Throw in that funky Y chromosome and we get a divergent from the norm, The norm if you will, of the creature. The norm of humanity is femininity.

And here we can say Aristotle had it exactly backwards. Aristotle, in his confused philosophy, believed that a female was a deformed male. Well, in a sense, and please hear my qualification in a sense, in a sense that Y chromosome, Aristotle didn't know anything about chromosomes. You throw in that Y chromosome and what would have been the clitoris becomes the penis. What would have been labia close

up and become the scrotum. Guys, little insight into your anatomy. Have you ever wondered what that line down the middle of your scrotum is? Well, that's where what would have been labia did not become labia because of that funky Y chromosome that got thrown in there. And those would have been labia sealed, connected together. And that's why you have that line down the middle of your scrotum and what remains of that

whole X chromosomal feminine fundamentality. We still have the nipples, but if the Y chromosome is not in there, excuse me, if the Y chromosome is in there, those nipples do not develop into breasts at puberty, although some guys might remember around the age of 12 or 13, their nipples got a little funky, little like a hard nub in there or something. That also Harkins back to the

common denominator of our humanity, which is the X chromosome. That's the biological explanation, but the theological explanation is in relation to God. We're all feminine guys. Don't let that mess with you. Don't let it make you think that's a some threat to your masculine identity. It is not. It's our human identity before God. And, and just remember, this gentleman, the most perfect male ever is Jesus Christ. And from all eternity he is receptive to the love of the

Father, receptive to the love of the Father. That's what the spousal analogy being bride indicates, receptive to the love of the Father. If the bridal thing throws you off, you've heard me say this before, here's another analogy. It'll take you to the same place. Jesus is the quarterback. You're the wide receiver. Go get yourself wide open, receive what the quarterback wants to throw you, and make the touchdown. You can take that as your analogy. If the bridal thing wigs you out, it's going to take you to the same place. Yeah, I I really think you

explained that really well. And I feel like like the years of having explained that concept of that is in Muliera's Dignitatum about the feminine being, the image of the human being in relation to God. You, you explained it so well. And I've known you for a while, you know, and I've, I've heard you, you know, way back when in the early days. And I can just hear all the experience as a teacher that we

are benefiting from there. That just clarity and just that feeling that one gets of kind of awe and wonder for God's like his thoughts are not our thoughts, right? And he but he gives us little glimpses of his thoughts through these reflections, and that this exciting it. Is exciting can I just add this that I just want to say you know these are my musings everybody. This is not I'm not quoting verbatim other than that one line from JP two woman is the

model and the archetype of the whole human race. I'm just, I'm just as you're saying, Wendy, I've been reflecting on that for a long time. So these are my reflections. These are my musings. This is not some magisterial statement. I'm not quoting some magisterial document here. I'm just sharing what I, what I think shines a light on this, this question. So take it for what it's worth. Yeah, and and to me also musing, scientists have way more to say on this than I do. I'm not a scientist, but I, I

also sense a certain like the nipple is not just on there like some it, it's the exit point of a gland. Yes, yes. And, and men and males have the gland as well. Not in a functional form, but it is there or I shouldn't say not in a functional form. I don't know if it has any function at all. That's part of what I'm thinking about is that we associate this part of a woman, her mammary glands, with her nurturing and

her bond that she forms with those she nurtures. And I think there's something just right about that. Men also do nurture and form bonds, and there's something in that aspect of their body that confirms. That confirms that. Points to it, yeah. Yeah, that's just another little. Yeah. And isn't it interesting? We are scientifically, we are named our species. Yeah, We are named mammals after the mammary glands we have.

We are the kind of animals that have mammary glands. And and that's where we get the word Mama, right? The most affectionate term you have for your mother, the breast, is so integral to motherhood that the most affectionate term we have to call our mother is breast. Mama. Mama Amazing. Yeah, Are you ready for another? Question, no I'm not because I wanted to add this too. Oh sorry.

If you want a theology of the body lesson, just think of the function. The biological function of the mammary gland is to transform blood into food. If that's not ringing some theological and Eucharistic bells. I don't know what will, but I'm just throwing that out for people to ponder. Take it to prayer and and because of how holy and sacred

the female body is. Blessed is the womb that bore him. Blessed are the breasts from which he sucked milk. That that line in Scripture. John Paul the Second says in his Theology of the Body that that line from Scripture is like a eulogy to motherhood, to femininity in its particularly, particularly sacred creative form. Right. Blessed is the womb that bore him. Blessed are the breasts from which he sucked milk. That in a, in a, because it's so sacred.

This is my point. The enemy is after the womb and the breasts. This is what gets profaned by pornography in a very particular way. We have to allow those profaned ideas to be untwisted and profane. Profanum means to remove from the sacred space to take out of the temple. Contemplate means to see it within the temple. So contemplate. Contemplate that Scripture.

Blessed is the womb that bore him. Blessed are the breasts from which he sucked milk, and it it will redeem what has been profaned by our pornographic culture. That's just one thing I wanted to say before we moved on. Our next question is from a listener named Noah. Hi, Noah. When I was 14, I watched the first person I ever loved choose my best friend instead of me, right in front of my eyes. Oh, this event seared into my body.

A story, or perhaps a lie, which is the most beautiful one, will never choose me. Since then, I've been obsessed with finding the perfect girl and somehow convincing her to love me. As you can imagine, this has led to several failed dating relationships that all followed the same pattern of initial infatuation, disillusionment, and finally separation. I recently went back to

confession for the first time in several years and after telling the priest this story, he counselled me to meditate on the doctrine of election, that God, the most beautiful one, has already chosen me. I am so thankful for God's love, but I can't help feeling it is insufficient to meet this need and heal my wound. After all, didn't God choose me purely out of His own grace and love, rather than because of

anything in me that was desirable or beautiful? How then, can I trust that I am worthy of love? Noah my brother, you are a deep soul. Your very ability to articulate what you have shared here is the fruit of much self reflection and what I would call a a proper

self knowledge and that is a work of grace. People don't arrive at this, this self knowledge without grace being operative and that is beautiful. Your return to the sacrament of confession is obviously a tremendous work of grace. And I'm so glad that this priest, this was a wise priest who had you reflect on your own election being chosen. Every person is wanted, is

chosen. How? How can I make such a statement? Because you wouldn't exist. Your very existence proclaims that you have been desired. You are known. You are chosen to exist. And I'm. I'm struck by the comment. Yeah. I mean, he didn't say it this way, but the way I'm hearing his comment about but God kind of has to love me. How did he put it? Yeah. Didn't God choose me purely out

of his own grace and love rather than because of anything in me that was desirable or beautiful? Yeah, I, I there's something deep in the heart bubbling up here, and I'm reminded of the scene from that was a Disney movie, The Incredibles? Was that a Disney Pixar or something? When? Who was the villain? What was the villain's name in that? I can see him. Yeah, vector.

I don't know his name. I don't know if it was, I can't remember. Anyway, he was the he was a kid. Oh, oh, oh, right. Yeah. Remember, he was a kid and then he grew up. He had the orange spiky hair and he had the the syndrome, syndrome, yes, syndrome. Wendy pulled it out, Syndrome says. If everybody's special. Nobody. Is nobody is. And I think, I think maybe Noah is tapping that place, that same

place in the heart that Syndrome became a villain because he was tossed aside or something by by Mr. Incredible. Is that his name, Mr. Incredible? And you know, it wasn't, it wasn't a malicious thing. If I recall the movie correctly. It was just like Mr. Incredible had something to do and he felt kind of not loved or acknowledged or seen. And and this resentment built in his heart and became a villain. And he just wanted to be seen as

special and and known and acknowledged and loved. And Noah, you're wound again. This is this is the light of the Holy Spirit on your heart, your ability to trace this back to that very painful experience when you were young of seeing the girl you had feelings for. Choose your best friend instead of you. The Lord is shining His light on

the story of your life here. You didn't just on your own. Remember that the Lord is bringing that memory to your attention. Why? To bring about your healing, brother. And you're on that journey already. You're on the journey of healing. The Lord wants to show you the root of a lie in your life that you've believed that is bearing bad fruit.

The root of the lie, you took it into your soul. I'll never be chosen. Beauty's not going to choose me. The woman that I once not going to choose me. I'm not chosen. I'm rejected. I'm not worthy. That's the root of a lie that has borne bad fruit. And you're already aware of that bad fruit. These, the string of, of failed relationships. You are making all these connections, brother, and it's not you making them. It's the Holy Spirit shining a light on the story of your life.

And the Holy Spirit reveals these things from our lives not to shame us or scold us, to heal us so that we can bear good fruit in our lives by going back to those bad roots and replacing the lies with the truth. And again, this is the wisdom of that priest, having you reflect on your election. You are chosen. And it's not just some generic

choice. God has to love me because he's God and I'm his creature. And there's nothing really lovable about me. I'm just his creature and he has to love me. And so he loves me. And OK, I'll accept that. Bland, generic love from God. Jesus loves me. This I know, for the Bible tells me so. Land generic love from God. That's a good line. It is not a bland generic love

from God. It is personalized. John Paul the Second has a way of putting this in his theology. The body, he says each and every one of us is called to a unique and unrepeatable relationship with God. Your relationship with God, Noah, is entirely unique and

unrepeatable. Ponder that word. Contemplate that word unrepeatable. It means it cannot be repeated. It means you are the only one who has the relationship with God that you have. And God has the relationship with you, with no one else. Because it's with you, it is unrepeatable. Because you are unrepeatable, there is no other you, and the

love God has for you is infinitely only the love he has for you, for you. Yes, God's love is universal. He loves everybody. But there's this principle in Catholic theology about how to hold together the universal and the particular in order for God's love to be universal.

And that's if we're just holding the universal, and that's all we're reflecting on. It does end up in this bland generic God loves everybody, there's nothing special about me, blah. That's the universal love of God without holding together with it the particularity of God's love. If we zoom in only on the particularity and don't hold it together with the universality, we can begin to get an ego about us as if I'm the I'm I'm the best thing in the universe and

and God loves me and only loves me because of how great I am. Holding the universal and the particular together is critical and I'm going to try to make this as short as possible. This beautiful story of a priest friend told me this story some years ago that he, he's teaches at a college and a student of his at the beginning of the year said, father, why do you think that Jesus was born at this time, you know, 2000 years ago and in that place, you know, the Holy Land, Jerusalem, What,

what, why then? And the, the priest tried to, you know, give us nice answer about the confluence of cultures in Jerusalem and Greek and Jewish culture. And and you know, the this was the perfect time because of the Roman rule. And, you know, and the kids like, Nah, I don't think that's, I don't think that's, I think there's something deeper. Some weeks later, the same kid comes to the priest and says, Father, why do you think Jesus died on this day? And on a cross, he could have been, you know, executed any, any other day and in any other

way. And you know, father goes on about the vertical and horizontal meaning of the cross beams and da, da, da, da, da and tries to give this fancy answer. He's no, no, no. There's something more to it. At the end of the year, the student came back to him and said, Father, I think I, I think, I know, I've been reflecting on this all year and I think I know why Jesus came at that particular time at that particular place. And I think I know why he was executed on that day and chose to be nailed to that cross. And Father was all ears.

He's what, what did you what, what do you conclude? What did you learn? And this college student says to save the good thief. And my priest friend was just blown away by this answer, as I was when I heard him tell me that story. That's how particular God's love is for you, Noah. That's how much he loves you.

Jesus's love is that particular, and I do believe that college student had the exact proper answer, the exact right answer. That's why Jesus came 2000 years ago. That's why he was executed that day and on that cross to save the good thief. That's how particular his love is. And it has to be that particular in order to be universal. And that particularity and universality flows from the very nature of a trinitarian God.

That would take way too long for me to unpack that. But a non trinitarian God is not a God who is love, is not a God who loves universally, and is not a God who loves particularly. You need a trinitarian God for there to be a universal and a particular love. Yes, His love is universal and he loves everybody. But he loves you, Noah, because you are lovable as you are. Ask him to show you what makes you lovable.

Ask Him to show you why he loves you and he'll start telling you things about you that he loves. And you'll, you'll, you'll, you'll wonder at it. You'll marvel at being known. You are known, brother. You are seen. You are chosen. One more thought. Bring the Blessed Mother into this place in your heart as well. Because you were rejected by a girl, she chose somebody else. And yes, we need to know the

love of God in that place, but you also need to know the love of the feminine in that place. You need to know the love of Mary in that place. And so I hold that out to you. Open that wound in your heart to Mary. She being already perfectly divinized. What God is by nature. Mary is because she is full of grace. She has been divinized. She's not divine by nature. She's a human person. She's human by nature, but just as God was humanized, God's plan

for humans is to be divinized. And Mary is the first human to be divinized. And because she's divinized, she shares the divine love, the divine particularity of love for you, Noah. And I invite you to open that place of, of rejection where that lie got in that that where the root of that lie is that has borne really bad fruit. Bring that feminine dimension in, Bring Mary into that. Let her come into that and let her show you that she has chosen

you. And that's going to bear really, really good fruit for you, brother. Yeah, I think sometimes there's this expression, self sabotage, you know, I feel that a little bit here in that there's such a grace being poured out that's really brought Noah to this place of going to confession and hearing something so profound that's really so the truth that can set him free.

And yet there's this voice saying, I don't think that does it for me, you know, and that's, that's that kind of why is that voice there trying to somehow protect you, holding on to a different plan for making things right in your world somehow, you know, wanting to kind of have that. Yeah, control, you know, and it's hard to give up that

control over what maybe you've decided would be the thing that makes it better. And, and here's the word of truth that's coming to you and saying look at the effects of you're trying to control. And so you hear that voice and you, you come to the font of grace and, and there's another voice, Noah. Truly you are chosen. You are. And that other voice says.

Yeah. These things are stubborn in us. Sometimes they are. And it's OK even to look at. Well, why? Like, why is that still there in me? Why do I still feel that like desire to say, no, that's not going to do it for me. Go ahead and ask that question as well. You're on a journey within. So like God can shine light on all these things. I, I sense the power of

revisiting that very memory that he began his question with, with inviting Jesus and the Blessed Mother to be present in that moment and really to experience their true love. Within that memory is, is a powerful form of prayer that can bring genuine healing and freedom. So Christopher and I have shared about that before and I, I truly

believe that is a great help to any of us who have a very painful memory that kind of replays and sets us up for interpreting things in a certain way that we know isn't helpful. And I think also you mentioned like asking the Lord how and why does he love Noah? I mean, Noah, you could make it a daily habit, like just write down one thing that you realize today. God loves this about me.

It it could build and build into really a genuine concept of yourself that isn't informed by that lie or the anxious need to fix that broken place, but actually allows you to see yourself as God sees you. And that is a beautiful gift. Yeah, I just have a picture of you, Noah, on that day, kind of in my mind's eye, that fateful day when this girl chose

somebody else right in your presence and Jesus and Mary were there. They were there. Ask them where they were and what they were thinking in that moment when that lie entered your heart. Be not afraid, brother. This is the path you're on it. This is the journey. Keep going. Our next question is from a listener named Tassiana. Tassiana. Hi, Tassiana. Dear Christopher and Wendy, as a disciple of Christ, I feel a

desire to take his call to evangelize more seriously in my life. I love my faith and I want others to taste and see the beauty of it too. However, I'm not sure exactly what the best approach would be for that. I have some secular Co workers and the lifestyle they talk about seems so out of touch with the gospel, I'm not sure how to relate it to them without coming across as a goody 2 shoes. How can I go about spreading the

word in situations such as those and shining the light of Christ? Bless you Tatiana, I I feel your genuine heart of love for your Co workers and also the conundrum. How do I, how do I witness to these people who seem so far from the gospel without appearing, you know, holier than thou? Well, take a page out of Jesus's

book. The very reality of the incarnation is that he Stoops to our level, not to stay there, not to commit the sins or enter into the sinfulness that we've entered into, but to meet us there, to encounter us there. He takes the initiative. He comes to our level in order to invite us to His level, and His level is nothing short of

the height of Trinitarian ecstasy, bliss, and joy. So when I say in applying this analogy, I'm going to say stoop to their level, I don't mean it in the sense of entering into their attitudes or embracing their sinfulness, but be the first to go in their direction without embracing the sinfulness that they embrace, but to meet them there. What does that mean? I think Christians, often times

we, we don't know how to evangelize or we come off as holier than thou because we're shouting at people from a distance. We're saying, Hey, look how awesome it is over where I am. You guys are so screwed up. If you would just come over to where I am, you'd be better off. No, we, we have to, I'm I'm struggling to put this in words because it could come off the wrong way. And I, I want to say again, I'm not saying when I say stoop to their level, not in the sense of committing their sin, but to to

enter into conversation when they're talking about XY and ZI don't know what they're talking about. Maybe they're talking about the the guy they just picked up at the bar the night before and had a one night stand with them and you're like, oh, you wouldn't have run the other way. How do I enter into a conversation there? Well, when I say stoop to their level, I'm not saying buy into their sin. I'm saying enter into that conversation maybe with yeah, what is it that's so alluring

about the attractiveness of a man and the idea of getting him in bed? And what are we really after when we when we take that approach, when people do that? What have you ever thought more about a deeper longing of the heart? What? I mean, OK, we get that thrill. We seduced the guy, We're in bed with them. We have a physical climax that brings us some semblance of pleasure and happiness. Some semblance of it. But man, in my life I've

experienced things like that where I it tastes good going down, but then it leaves just a bitter after taste and I'm more lonely than I ever was. Does that really ever satisfy? Does a one night stand, a a, a hookup ever really reach me in the places in my heart that I'm really looking to be seen and known and affirmed? I mean, gosh, doesn't sex make us so vulnerable? We're opening our bodies to another person. And if we're a unity of body and soul, gosh, we're opening places in our hearts to somebody we

just met. Can aren't we stupid to open those places in our hearts to somebody? Gosh, to do that to, to, to, to, to open your body, but not opening your heart. But gosh, then you're just rupturing your body and your soul. And isn't there a name for that rupture of body and soul? Isn't that called death? I wonder if that's why we just feel miserable. It feels good at first, but then we feel miserable after. That's my experience anyway. I'm just play acting here like I'm trying to enter into the to the role of what I mean when I say being willing to stoop to

their level, not stoop into their sin, but to meet them in that place and then gently, lovingly, mercifully invite a deeper reflection, invite a, a, a deeper penetration into their hearts and get them thinking. Because you know, usually they're having these conversations with other people who are just affirming the debauchery and and it's going

unchallenged. When, when you can show them you're not there to condemn them, you're not there to shame them. You have similar experiences and they've caused you to wonder. They've made you think about bigger things. You're meeting them there and then you're you're inviting them higher. You're inviting them to think and you might put just a little seed in there, a little seed that grows. Or to go with another metaphor, you might put a little grain of sand in there that that aggravates and agitates in a

good way that that creates a Pearl over time. That would be just some some thoughts for you as to how to to begin conversation and enter in without being, you know, holier than thou. Tassiana, I, I love that example that Christopher gave. And I, I also know that we like, I don't know if I could even do that.

And here I am. I'm, I'm on a podcast about theology of the body. So I, that's not to say you shouldn't, because it may be exactly the answer to that feeling you have in your heart of wanting this desire to evangelize. And so I, I just want to say that like there, there are different personalities that have would take different approaches and many of our listeners would do well to take the very approach Christopher just said, but that's, there's nothing that guarantees it to go

well. I guess that's the point I want to make it. And so then that's OK. Like Jesus said, they rejected me and they will reject you. Like there is something to be OK with that as well. And to trust that the sincerity of really seeing the person and caring about the person will pay off, you know, at some point and someone will remember and know like she was different.

And, and that actually gave me hope, even though I couldn't tell her that at the time. There's so many ways that we may not see the immediate fruit of our attempts to, you know, make that connection and, and bring the Lord to people who desperately need him. I, I could also see there being other ways of just kind of, as you know, the people you work

with, you're not going to come across as a goody 2 shoes if that's not your heart. And I think that was part of what Christopher was getting at. It's like Jesus wasn't a goody 2 shoes at all. It's not his heart and we want his heart. And so he he saw the beauty and goodness that he had created in every human being and those who were steeped in sin, like by just loving the goodness that he

knew was there was a revelation. You know, I think of the woman at the. Well, yeah. Yeah. Or the people gathered at Matthew's house, the Pharisees and, and the tax collectors and all, you know, he, he saw the good that he created there and, and was comfortable with them because he trusted that there is that goodness. And that that piece of his heart, that piece within his heart that just emanated from

him is the opposite of an anxious, avoiding goody Tushu's heart. And I, I know that that's not something that's just automatic. Sometimes we have to look at our own attitudes and the ways we maybe have judged people or failed to see them as good and beautiful. And you know that the struggles and the the things going on in their lives are just revelations of maybe something that's gotten

very twisted, but that God has a good plan. So I think some of that looking at our own attitudes and, and coming to a deeper place of genuine care and genuine belief and the goodness that God placed in each person that comes across. And then whatever ways we reach out within those relationships, including exactly what Christopher said or including offers to pray for someone if it

feels right in the circumstance. Oh, your mother's sick. Wow, I'll be praying for her. You never know to what degree like those, just if they're delivered in a genuine, loving, sensitive to the person way, they can really make a difference and proclaim that God loves them by the way that you love them. I'm reminded of some painful learning experiences I've had. You'll remember this story,

Wendy. Years ago, we were still living in Denver. I was in secure in the security line at the airport, and there was a guy right next to me. You know, we're kind of in a tight space and he's putting stuff in his bin. I'm putting stuff in my bin. And he had this Maxim magazine, which is basically soft porn for men. And I, I, it was right there and he saw me see him put it in the bin. And I didn't want to say nothing about it. I am, I'm like, well, what do I say?

And I said, I said, I said, how'd you like it if your mother was on the cover of that magazine? Do you remember the story? And he says, how'd you like it if my fist went right through your face? And I was like, that was not the right thing to say. And then interestingly, several months later, I found myself on an airplane and somebody sitting right next to me. I'm on the window seat. He's the middle seat. He had another one of these Maxim magazines.

And I'm like, oh, Lord, oh God, how do I learn from my past mistake? But I can't. I just wanted to, I have to say something. I felt delayed to say something, but it wasn't going to be how'd you like it if your mother was on the cover of that? And I said, I said, isn't that woman beautiful? And he said, yeah, she's hot. And I was, I was like trying to steer the I was like, I didn't, I wanted to, I wanted to talk about what is feminine beauty, right?

I was trying to trying to get the conversation. See her as a person. See her as a person. See her as a person. And anyway, he fell asleep and I didn't get to have a conversation with him. But while he was sleeping on this several hour flight, I ended up writing him a long letter and his Maxim magazine was right there on his trade table. And I, while he was asleep, I slipped my letter into his Maxim magazine and, and my letter was all about the true beauty of

woman and why we're really attracted to woman's body wherever that guy is out there. I don't know if he wrote, read my letter and maybe he threw it away and I had no impact on him. And maybe the guy who wanted to punch me in the face has actually come to Christ because I put a little Pebble in his shoe that aggravated him and, and made him what? I don't know. I'm not, what do I know? But I'm just saying there that we can learn. We, we should, we should, if we're feeling called to say something, it's better to say something and make a mistake and

learn from it than just to walk away out of fear. Just just say, Lord, guide my words. Oh, I'm going to open my mouth. I, I want your love to flow through me. And even if you make a mistake and the guy wants to punch you in the face like it happened to me, you can learn from that and, and pray for him. So Lord, wherever that guy is who wanted to punch me in the face, I, I lift him up to you and I lift up all those women on those magazine covers and I lift up Tatiana to you and her Co workers. And thank you for Noah and his

question today. And thank you for Kelsey and her question. And thank you everybody who submits questions to us. If you were blessed by what you heard today, would you hit that share button? Make a gift of this episode to somebody, become a gift to somebody because that's what you are. You're a gift, Wendy. You're a gift and I'm a gift. And everybody's special. Let's become what we. Are let's become what we are. I'm thinking of Bob the tomato. Your God made you special and he loves you very much. It's. True.

Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors when you're going through serious difficulty. A list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode