-This episode is sponsored by Truthly- Questions answered this episode: I am a single man in my twenties and have committed to reserving sex for marriage. People often try to dissuade me by bringing up “sexual compatibility,” telling stories of couples who waited and later divorced because they weren’t compatible in the marriage bed. I struggle to respond since I can’t speak from experience about what sexual compatibility or good sex really means. My gut tells me there’s something selfish in this reasoning, yet every married couple hopes sexual intimacy will be wonderful for both spouses. So what is sexual compatibility, and is it really possible for a man and woman to be sexually incompatible? I am a young woman with a fantastic boyfriend. When we kiss, it usually lasts for only a second, but I’ve found myself wanting a kiss from him that is longer and more intimate. I also have this desire when it comes to being held by him or cuddling. Thankfully, we both love theology of the body and desire to grow in chastity in our relationship, but I’m not sure how prudent these desires are because I don’t want to use him for physical pleasure. Is it okay for me to want these things from him even though we aren’t married? Can they be done in a chaste way? Having had unchaste experiences with men I’ve dated in the past makes me feel as though I’d be tainting my current relationship by doing these things, and the feelings that arise feel more like lust and crossing a boundary. I recently came across your work and have been listening to your podcasts and interviews incessantly. It is truly life-changing material. You’ve referenced a few times a retreat where a priest asked you to perform various exercises to help stir up your desires so that you could really learn how to pray. What were those exercises? I haven’t been able to find them through all the listening I’ve been doing. Resources: Word Made Fresh Podcast on YouTube Word Made Fresh Podcast on Spotify Colorado Ski Retreat with Christopher --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? Join our Patron Community! --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 List of trusted counselors & psychologists *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Our faithful listeners know that I've been of late sharing with you guys an app called Truthly. Truthly. We've entered into a partnership with Truthly. I believe in what they're doing. They believe in what we're doing. And our audience who is familiar with asking questions about the Catholic faith, you guys should really know about this app called Truthly. TRUTHLY faithful to the Magisterium, rooted in
scripture, thinking with the mind and heart of the Church. You can go on truthfully and ask any question about the Catholic faith and you'll get an Orthodox answer using all the technology of artificial intelligence and putting it to very good use. I've been using Truthfully just to poke around and see what kind of answers they come up when when I type in certain questions and I've been impressed. I've been impressed. They're doing good stuff and I think it is definitely worth our just shouting out to our audience and say give it a try.
You can get a 7 day free trial by just going to wherever you get your apps, the Google Play Spot if you're an Android person, or go to the App Store on the iPhone and learn more about what the good folks are doing at Truthfully. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners.
Hey everybody. So happy to be with you again. Very happy to be with you again. Here we are. I have something funny to share with you guys. Sometimes in the morning I I don't know, I have this little just time where I tend to read articles that I find that just interest me. I often come downstairs and you are there looking at your news feed and I, I, I think this is very interesting about you, the things that you click on and. Yeah, yeah. Well, it's interesting.
I I subscribe to like a summary of article or summary of news that you can click links to read more. So, you know, a lot of it I'm just reading the summaries of, but certain things do interest me, and this one I clicked on today. It interested me in part because I thought it would be interesting to you. To me. Yeah, yeah. I I thought you would like to know about it and I was seeing if it was something I should send to you. Here let me sum it up. Sex in space.
Well, that wasn't the title of the article, but that was definitely an element of it. And I just, I don't know, sometimes I do forward the articles to people that I think would be interested. I didn't forward this one too, but I did share with you about it. I'm going to tell our listeners about it. Really. It was actually looking at like, what are the real questions about this whole push to either, you know, colonize the moon or colonize Mars? Like these are real things that people are working out details on. Yeah, it seems like science
fiction to me, but but it is it, it does raise these questions. And I I did when you shared with me. I found it quite interesting. Well, because there are some real unknowns about human reproduction in a low gravity environment, really. Sex and space. Yeah, like, for real. Like, it really has been very little studied. In fact, I learned that most female astronauts that have like spent time on a space station take medicine to repress suppress their hormonal cycles
that they haven't even had. Why? Menstrual periods? What? Just for convenience of you know you're on this. Well, yeah. How? How Well, yeah. How would you even have menstrual flow if you're in zero gravity? We don't know the answers. We don't know the fascinating. Yeah, of course. How? Yes. What? Without gravity. It would all just. Stay in the uterus. How? I mean, there are contractions, but gravity's part of it for sure. So yeah, it is. There are so many questions. The little bit of study that was
mentioned in this article was done on rats. Pregnant rats were sent into space. This was many years ago, like 1980s or something. Pregnant rats in space, yes, sounds like a an again, science fiction, but. I know there they were and they they were compared to other rats at the very same level, you know, point in pregnancy when they returned, their pregnancies were being monitored. Their rat pups were monitored
and you know, even though they only spent a few days in orbit, they already showed significant differences in their ability to Orient themselves their their development of their vestibular systems. Fascinating. Like the inner ear stuff. Yeah, fascinating isn't? That amazing. So it was like a whole subject that really is a huge question that hasn't been answered, and I was. Like I don't how we we are made for planet Earth. I, I, I know people are
exploring these things, but I just how does that even happen? How do you how do you live on Mars? How do you live on the moon? I don't think it's going to work. But anyway, yeah, I'm glad I live on planet Earth where we are Earthlings, right? That's what we are. That's true. I don't think we're ever going to be anything other than Earthlings. But interesting. Thank you for sharing that. That is quite fascinating stuff. It reminded me of a unit I had in my college astronomy class where the teacher was going on about what would what would it
be like to have sex and 0 gravity. That's weird thought, but yeah, I don't, I, I never mind. We'll go there. Let's moving right along. Let's move along now. Right along. It's funny. We laugh because it's just sort of wacky. Yeah. So thanks, Lord, for the little chuckle. OK. Moving on to a any updates on the TOB Institute? That's what I'm interested in
now. Yeah, Here are a couple things to share. We have, I think a lot of our listeners probably don't know this. We have a new podcast offering at the TOB Institute, both in audio and video format, called Word Made. Fresh. Word made fresh, kind of like that play on words. And what we're trying to do is make the word, which is the good news of the gospel, fresh by
looking at things that people are already dealing with in culture, music, movies, food. We're just trying to give our listeners Sacramento eyes and ears and sense of of reality. And it's presented by yours truly, along with Bill Donaghy, my esteemed colleague at the institute, and Mike Mangioni, my esteemed colleague at the institute.
It's two theologians, Bill and yours truly, and one artist, the musician Mike Mangioni. And we've had a, gosh, I don't know, 8 or 10 episodes so far. And you can watch it on YouTube if you like the video version or listen on Spotify or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can check out the link below. And I'm shouting out again for the ski retreat. Young people who do things usually book really late for such events.
I remember last year when we did the ski retreat, like 15 people signed up in the last 10 days or something. Oh my goodness. But guys, now is the time. Now is the time. We're getting down. We're getting down. To those last days. So final shout out. I might have one more week to shout out to you guys. Maybe. Yeah, we're getting down to the wire. So if you want to come on the ski retreat, check out all the details in the show notes. Would love to have you. Yeah, beautiful. But now's the time.
Yes, please. When's the time, Wendy? It's now. It's now. OK, and now I have a question for you from a listener a a patron. In fact, this is from an anonymous patron who says I am a single man in my 20s and I've committed myself to reserve sex for marriage. People who want to dissuade me from this very commonly bring up the idea of sexual compatibility. He put that in quotes. They tell stories of couples
that waited until marriage just to find out that they are not quote UN quote compatible in the marriage bed and ended up divorcing after some years trying to figure it out unsuccessfully. I find it hard to respond to these arguments since I can't speak from experience what it might mean to be sexually compatible or what good sex or bad sex really means. He put all those things in quotes. My gut is telling me that there is something selfish with this way of reasoning.
But on the other hand, every married couple will wish for sexual intercourse to be something wonderful for both spouses. So what's up with quote, UN quote, sexual compatibility? Is it possible that a man and a woman really turn out to be, quote, sexually not compatible? God bless you brother. I want to affirm all of your gut instincts. I'm so glad you put all of those things in quotes. Good sex, bad sex, compatibility, sexual compatibility, incompatibility.
Let me just say it frankly, it comes from a utilitarian paradigm. What does that mean? The utilitarian paradigm is I'm in it for my pleasure, I'm in it for my experience, I'm in it for what I get out of this. And the utilitarian paradigm is utterly opposed, diametrically opposed to the proper paradigm for all sexual relations.
What is that paradigm? Love. Love. You were going to say something when you there. What just. Self gift. Self gift. It's the same idea. This is my body given for you. This is the new commandment Jesus gives us that summarizes everything. Love one another as I have loved you. How did he love us? The total sacrificial gift of himself. I will never leave you. I will never forsake you.
I am. I am here for you. I've come so that you might have life, that you might have it to the full I, I am. I am with you to the end of the age. I will never forsake you. I will never leave you. What we're talking about here, what is at stake here, is the dignity of what a person is. A person is not some thing that you use to get what you want out of this person. What you're treating as a thing.
A person is not something. A person is someone. Things are dispensable, replaceable, and repeatable. People who are familiar with this show have heard me use this terminology before. But persons are indispensable, irreplaceable, and unrepeatable. Your your iPhone breaks, you throw it away or you trade it in for another one, right, because it's dispensable, it's replaceable, it's repeatable.
You can get a million of the very same model are stored at the Amazon warehouse, right? Because things are dispensable, replaceable and repeatable. When when you when you come into a sexual relationship, when you come into a human relationship with this idea that there's something in it that I want to get out of this for me. On the one hand, I want to be honest and recognize that of course, in human relationships we want there to be something for us.
And there's nothing wrong in and of itself with a hope that I'm going to be blessed by this relationship and I'm going to benefit from this relationship and there will be rewards for me in this relationship. But the benefits and the rewards are the benefits and the rewards of learning how to love. When I treat another person as just a a thing for me to get my benefits and rewards, especially sexual favors or sexual
pleasures, I'm not learning how to love. I'm learning how to use. And using here is the opposite of love. To treat a person as a means to an end, to approach a relationship from that utilitarian paradigm. This is where the notion of sexual compatibility comes into play. And when I come with that attitude, if you don't give me what I want, if I'm not pleased by how you behave in bed, I will
dispense with you because I treat you as a thing. You're dispensable. I will replace you with somebody else who gives me what I want because I treat you as a thing. And I think you think of you as replaceable. I will compare you to other things because you are repeatable in my mind. But if I treat that other person as a person who has a dignity that makes that person indispensable, then whatever we face in our relationship, sexual
struggles, health struggles, financial struggles, emotional struggles, psychological struggles, whatever we face, you are indispensable. I am not going to dispense with you. You are irreplaceable. I can't throw you away and replace you with somebody else because you're a person who's indispensable and irreplaceable. And I'm not going to compare you and measure you against what the culture is saying sex is supposed to be. And you're not giving it to me. And, and, and therefore I'm
going to I'm, I'm just going to treat you as something to be dispensed, replaced and repeated. It's a totally different paradigm when you have two persons who know what it means to be persons and are utterly committed to upholding the dignity of the other as a person. The very notion of sexual compatibility is incompatible with that notion of the person,
because you are choosing to love this person in good times and bad, in sickness and health, come what may. I am yours until death. I'm totally yours and you are totally mine. That is what the dignity of the person demands. And guess what? Not just the dignity of the other person, but your dignity
demands that. Do you want to be treated as a thing that is dispensable, that is replaceable, that is repeatable, that is measured against some societal standard of what makes, quote, good sex UN quote? Well, what does good sex, quote, UN quote mean in the culture? It means I'm getting titillated in the way I want to get titillated. And if I'm not, you're the problem and I'm throwing you away and I'll just use somebody else to get what I want. What is good sex In the true
meaning of both of those words? Good and sex put those words together in their true meaning. And what is good sex? What makes sex good is the sincere, free, total, faithful, fruitful gift of yourself to the other. Good times, bad trials, difficulty, struggles, health, sickness, financial flourishing, and financial strife.
Whatever comes, I'm yours. You're mine. We're learning how to love. I receive you, I accept you, I bless you, I honor you. Sexual compatibility means two people, a man and a woman, who have chosen to give themselves to each other. Good times and bad trials and smooth sailing. I'm yours, you're mine. We're in this together with God's grace, we're going to make it the whole way to the marriage of the lamb that lasts forever.
That's what makes, I don't even want to say sexually compatible. I want to say maritally compatible, right? Sexual compatibility in the in, if we're going to use any phrase here that makes any sense must mean marital compatibility. And this is something you cannot experiment with, right? When when people use analogies like, well, you're not going to buy a car without taking it for a test drive, are you? They think they're so clever. Oh, I got you now.
Well, excuse me, but that is bullshit ski. A person is not a product to buy and try out. A person is not a product to experiment with and see if you like it and throw it away if you don't. A person is a person and sexual relations are not some abstract, titillate me kind of reality. It's it's two persons learning how to love in the sincere gift of self.
And when you know what is at stake, when you know how vulnerable you are truly making yourself in the sexual act, the only way you can be as vulnerable as the sexual act demands you be vulnerable, is if the other person has promised and pledged before God and everybody you know, all your friends and family. I will never leave you. I will never forsake you. It's the only way you can go where sex is meant to take you to the true vulnerable, naked
total gift of yourself to another person. Marital compatibility is what is required. And marital compatibility means I know this person means what he or she says when he or she says I will never leave you or forsake you. We're in this forever together. Only there, only in that reality, can sexual relations become marital relations, and marital relations become the
secure reality of a man and a woman, a husband and a wife, making them as vulnerable as love demands they make themselves. That's what I have to say about that. It's really important stuff. It's really confronting the two just utterly different concepts of what it is that we are doing. And when we bring that worldly concept of, you know, well, if you're going to be married and
you're going to be faithful, then you better be sure you like it because this is all you're getting. Like that kind of worldly fear is coming out of a whole notion of seeking my own pleasure and wanting the other person to have pleasure too. But you know, it's still on a very surfacey level. It's not about the call of the gift of the whole life of the the willingness to be called to
sacrifice for this other person. That is expressed by experiencing not just pleasure, but profound, deep, as you said, vulnerability. And I think that in the culture, people kind of numb themselves to the vulnerability that is truly present there because it feels so dangerous to experience vulnerability. But but the when we understand,
as you often say, what we are communicating is our promises to one another, our lifelong gift of ourselves to one another. Yes. Do we also absolutely want to learn how to please one another in the marital embrace? Of course we do. Of. Course we do, yeah. But we, we get the bigger picture, and we know grace is happening, and that's what we're
there for. And the people who are giving this warning have no clue of any of the realities, the profound power of a husband and wife promising their whole selves to one another, open to God's grace. They have no clue. Yeah. They they reduce it to anatomical titillation. Yeah. And I'm so sorry. And I know that this can be a painful thing. And I feel like it maybe comes from a painful place in the
people saying that they want to sort of justify their own decisions that they have made. And so they they're threatened maybe by this young man having committed himself to a different path. And they, they frame it as a warning, but it's actually the fact that they feel, you know, confronted. Yes, Well said, Wendy. I think you're right. I think you're right, brother. Stand on your convictions. There will be trials. There will be struggles. There will be many, many, many
sacrifices to make in learning how to love. But you are worth it, and so is the woman. God willing, you're called to marry. And everyone listening, please, no. You are worth the real deal. You're worth the real deal. You're worth that sacrifice. Life ain't easy. Learning how to love ain't easy. But Oh my gosh, to to surrender because it's hard. And to buy into that utilitarian mentality is to reduce yourself to a thing and to treat others
as things. And we are not things. We are persons. Pleasure is not the highest principle here. The dignity of the person is the highest principle here. If you have pleasure on top in your pyramid of values, then you are going to sacrifice the dignity of the person in order to get your pleasure. But if you have the dignity of the person at the top of your pyramid of values, then you'll be willing to sacrifice your pleasure to uphold the dignity of the person.
And guess what? In the long run, that is so much more pleasurable in a broad sense of the word, because it's it's it's upholding the true dignity of the person, and that alone can bring the fulfillment for which we earn. Everything else is a shallow, shallow, pitiable and pitiful counterfeit to what we really want. I'm finding myself drawn to a little part of this question
that we didn't. Speak about. And it was about people who divorce over struggles in their marriage bed. And I, I just wanted to pause and just for a moment on that and to say, first of all, that as much as we are, you know, trusting the Lord has a good plan. It is a really painful reality of this broken world that there are divorces that there are many and they're always painful. And it is probably every divorce
that includes suffering in the marriage bed, in that that is the expression of your relationship. If your marriage is falling apart, there is suffering on many levels of your experience, including in your marriage bed. And I know that that is a very painful reality and I just wanted to acknowledge that we don't. It's easy, I guess for outsiders with the frame of reference of
kind of, well, sexual compatibility is sort of this notion that they are holding onto. They, they could read the story of someone's divorce as confirming that notion. My sense of it is that their struggles in their marriage bed may have been a place where they were called to grow. They were called to seek grace and help. That maybe they didn't
experience That is one possibility. Another is just that the struggles in the marriage bed were part and parcel of a whole bunch of struggles in their relationship. Hate struggles is maybe even not a strong enough word, but very painful sufferings. And I, I want to acknowledge that that is very, very hard. And some of our listeners have experienced those kinds of things and maybe heard themselves in that little portion of the question and thought, well, what about me?
And I, I want you to know that this teaching that we are sharing theology of the body is so helpful and healing. It's so helpful to make sense of this fallen world, to recognize that what we experience as a Pope Jean Paul the Second calls our historical experience where we are living in a fallen world with all its woundedness. We aren't experiencing all of
these things perfectly as God intended them to be, and it's painful. And that understanding that and experiencing the tremendous goodness of God's plan, not only in creating us but in redeeming us is so healing. For those who have experienced either those terrible struggles and are still in a marriage or those who've experienced a divorce as well, like, please don't feel like there's nothing here for you. This is so for you. It's a balm ABALM on our on our wounds and and the wounds so
often come from that utilitarian attitude we're talking about. JP 2 says in his book Love and Responsibility that overcoming that utilitarian attitude in the marriage bed and learning how to honor the dignity of the other as a person in the marriage bed is the internal problem, the internal struggle of every marriage. That's the struggle to overcome
that utilitarian attitude and learn how to love as Christ loves in the marriage bed. That's the internal problem of every marriage. So every marriage struggles with this. Every marriage suffers here. Every marriage is desperately in need of divine grace to breakthrough what Christ called the hardness of our hearts, to enable us to learn step by step, through painful trials, through painful purifications, what it really means to love one another
in the marriage bed. And that is the struggle of every marriage. That's the struggle of our marriage. It's the struggle of every marriage. We can testify to the struggle and we can testify to the reality that grace is real and it is present at every stage of the struggle. And it's not like you overcome that struggle and then you arrive and then you're living marriage as it's supposed to be. We're going to be battling our fallen humanity till the day we die. Thanks be to God, we grow, we
progress, we we make progress, we we learn. But there's always more purifications ahead of us between here and eternity. None of us lives this perfectly, but God's grace is real and mercy is real and we can learn how to love in and through it. But Oh my gosh, to, to, to enter into marriage having solidified and, and believed that utilitarian approach, that Oh yeah, good thing we tried out sex before we got married and we found out we're compatible. You don't you honestly, honestly that such a couple is not ready
for marriage because they don't know what marital love is calling them to. They don't know what the marriage bed is. They don't know what marital love is. They're treating each other in that utilitarian way and they think that's the right thing. So we don't have to be perfect when we get married. But JP 2 says we have to be mature enough to continue maturing. And if we are not mature enough to continue maturing, we're not ready to get married. Lord, help us. Help us to be. The men and women are called to be. Please, Lord. Our next question is from an
anonymous listener. I am a young woman with a fantastic boyfriend. When we kiss, it usually lasts for only a second, but I have found myself wanting a kiss from him that is longer, more intimate. I also have this desire when it comes to being held by him or cuddling. Thankfully, we both love theology of the body and desire to grow in chastity in our relationship, but I'm not sure how prudent these desires are
for us because I don't want to use him for physical pleasure. Is it OK for me to want these things from him even though we aren't married? Can they be done in a chaste way? Having unchaste experiences with men I've dated in the past makes me feel as though I'd be tainting my current relationship by doing these things, and the feelings that arise feel more like lust and that I'd be crossing a boundary. Bless you, dear sister.
Thank you for your your honesty. Again, I just feel the privilege of being invited into these questions people's real, real lives. I I want to answer this question first, she said. Can an extended kiss, can an extended embrace be done chastely? The answer to that is yes. Want to say that first. Can it be done chastely? Yes, yes. However, I, I also, the final line of your question shifted my
response a little bit. Can you read her final line again, Wendy? The feelings that arise feel more like lust and that I'd be crossing a boundary. OK, So I think you need to pay attention to that in your heart. Now, it may be that you're being scrupulous. It may be that you're assigning A lustful motive to something that might not be a lustful motive. But I would have to have a more extensive conversation with you to give you my perspective on that.
I don't want to insist that I know it's a lustful intention, but I do want to affirm that you are correct in wanting to examine the motivation of your heart, because that's where chastity comes from. Too often we we've been taught, and I can remember when I was in high school and Catholic High School, a teacher writing all kinds of behavior on the chalkboard. It's from eye contact to holding
hands to kissing to hugging, to a longer kiss, a longer hug. This was all in one column and it had acceptable at the top of that column. Then on the other column it had unacceptable. And it started with, I think French kissing and going down from there. OK, OK, OK, OK. There, there, there. I get so frustrated with, with reduction of, of chastity to you can't diagram chastity on blackboard 'cause it's a matter
of the heart. Let me put it to you this way. Of course, I would say there's nothing inherently wrong with eye contact, but you could have eye contact that was full of lust. And if you just said, well, it was on the column that was acceptable. So eye contact is fine. You could say the same thing about holding hands. You could say the same things about kissing and embracing if you just say what was in the acceptable column. So this is fine, but what is motivating it? Similarly, let's take a married couple who are obviously allowed to engage in marital
intercourse, but you can't just check the box and say we're allowed to do it. You also have to look at what's going on in your heart if if you're motivated by using your spouse and as an object for your selfish pleasure, that is unchaste, even if you're doing it within marriage, simply getting married does not make your lust acceptable. And so we can see in both cases, either you know, like holding hands is fine or the marital act is fine 'cause we're married or holding hands is fine. We're a dating couple and we
love each other. Well, what's the motivation behind it? You, you have to look at what's going on in your heart right now also. It's not only what's going on in your heart because if you, if you believed we're, we're not married, but in our hearts, we really love each other. And so it's fine for us to have sexual intercourse because we've examined our hearts and we don't find any lust there. Well, guess what? You're not examining your hearts closely enough and you're justifying lust, right? So again, what is really needed
here is not just what you can diagram on a blackboard of acceptable or unacceptable behaviors. What is needed here and I'll hear I'll quote from John Paul. The second is deep knowledge of the interior movements of our hearts. And he says this is a science which cannot only be learned by reading books or I will add, by listening to podcasts because here it is a a knowledge of a deep understanding of what's going on in your heart.
He says deep in the heart we learn how to distinguish what on the one hand bears only the sign of lust and what on the other hand bears that perennial very good attraction and desire of a man and a woman for each other. And he says, although these internal movements of the heart can sometimes be confused with one another, and here's being very realistic, sometimes we might Is that lust? Is that a genuine love?
I'm not so sure. He says, yes, sometimes they can be confused with each other, those movements of the heart. But he goes on to say, but we are called by Christ to acquire a mature evaluation of the inner movements of our hearts. And then he concludes this is a task that can be carried out by God's grace, and it is truly worthy of our dignity that we carry out this task, that we learn to discern the inner
movements of our hearts. So those are my words of encouragement to you, my dear sister. You're already in the practice of examining the motives of your heart. And if you find mixed motives in there, welcome to the human race, right? We have wheat and weeds growing in us all the time. The Catechism says all of us until the end of time, we'll find the good weed of the gospel and those weeds of sin intertwined in our lives that shouldn't stifle us.
Suppose you are you're in that gentle kiss with your boyfriend and you feel that stirring. I would love for him to hold me longer and kiss me longer. OK, right in the moment, you can train your heart to say, Lord, I, I know I'm made-up of wheat and weeds. Where are the weeds here? Meaning the lust where I'm in this for a selfish reason because it's going to feel good and it's going to, I'm going to get some pleasure out of it. And I, I might be have this
utilitarian attitude of using him to get that pleasure. And I know that's not a good motive. OK, that's not a good motive. You recognize it. You open that up to the Lord and you say, Lord, show me where the weed is. I genuinely care for this man. I love his kisses. I love kissing him. I want to tell him how good he is. I want to affirm his unique role in my, in my life. I want to affirm his unrepeatable dignity as a as a man and as a human being. And my kiss can tell him that
and his kiss can tell me that. And I want him to tell me that. Well, guess what? That's good wheat. That's good wheat. And, and as we mature, as we grow in discerning those movements of our hearts, and it takes both of us on that journey together, it is possible to say with an extended kiss exactly that. You might still notice some of the weeds in there. But you, I'm not going to water them. I'm not going to water those weeds. I recognize they're in me. I'm not going to water them. I'm going to water this good wheat. And I'm going to tell him with my kiss, and I'm going to
receive from his kiss this affirmation of the dignity of our persons. Is that possible? Absolutely. If it's not love is not possible. And there's no magic trick that when you get married that suddenly makes it what you do in the bedroom, an affirmation of the dignity of the person. We have to be trained in living that dignity throughout every course of our lives, throughout every chapter of our lives. We have to be trained in the appropriate way to our stage and state in life how to express that or refrain from expressing
because we're not in the right place. That's that's the pilgrimage, that's the journey. Something that was coming to me too was sometimes we've had questions from listeners where they're maybe saying how surprised they are by how arousing very simple expressions of affection are for them. And I just want to encourage this listener to be open to the thought of.
Not only considering her own heart, but his, you know, what are his past experiences or what is he cautious about or what is he experiencing that maybe he's not ready to talk about yet. I don't know how far they are into their relationship that that just honors that the progress of their affection needs to correspond not only to wheats and wheat growing in her heart, but also his journey. And so as much as, you know, we kind of get these impressions maybe from movies that somehow
in the perfect relationship, nobody has to say anything directly with words. We just know in in the real world, we do have to communicate about things. And if something seems like it's not time to communicate about it, then maybe just let it be for a time and and trust that when it you're ready to talk about it together, it will it will be a blessing because as she said, he's a fantastic boyfriend. So I love that for both of them. Good words, Wendy, Words of wisdom.
Our next question is from a listener named Sam. Hi, Sam. Christopher, I recently came across your work and I have been listening to your various podcasts and interviews incessantly. It is truly life changing material. Bless you, Sam, bless you. Bless you. You've referenced a few times a retreat where a priest asked you to perform various exercises to help stir up your desires so that you could really learn how to pray.
What were those exercises? I've not been able to find them through all the listening I've been doing. Gosh, Sam, I have never been asked that question. I, I share that story pretty regularly, as you know, as you've been seeing in interviews and such. But over the years, I, I've never been asked that question and I don't even know if I can recall specifically what the exercises were. But I, I do remember in a kind of general way, this was a long time ago.
It was like 2008 or something, so many years ago. But the general direction of the exercises was to reflect on certain memories, memories of unfulfilled desires. That was the specific approach. And, and he had like a series of questions to kind of stir, stir those memories. But I, I couldn't remember what those questions were for the life of me. But the direction of the questions all were kind of probing questions, such as
recall a time in your life where you really desired something. You set your heart on something and we're disappointed. Something like that. And what the kind of things that came back to me. I remember I, I was really into BMX in the 80s, BMX bicycles and I saved up all my money for this BMX bike and finally got the bike. I'm so excited to have the bike and it got stolen.
You know, that was something that came up and then this girl that I asked out, I had to get up the nerve to ask her out. She was, as they say, in the high school hierarchy. She was out of my league. And I got up the nerve to ask her out. I called her up, she said yes. And then I was so excited about that. And then the next day, she ignored me in the hallways and wouldn't talk to me and reneged. I finally confronted her, like, why aren't you talking to me? What's going on? I thought we were going to go out on a date. Nope, Nope. I, I just said yes because I
didn't know what else to say on the phone. You know, things like that, those disappointments in life and they just stacked up one after the other, these disappointments, these desires I had, I set my heart on something I didn't get what I wanted and I was disappointed. And, and with it came up all this rage and anger that I have so many unfulfilled desires. And it exploded like a volcano. And the, the retreat director had insisted that whatever got
stirred up in my heart, I not censor it. And so, OK, he said not to censor it. So I let it out. And it came out as rage, rage at God. And I went to confession right away. And I, I like, yeah, some nasty, nasty stuff was coming up and out of me. And the priest told me I didn't need to confess that I got honest with God. I needed to confess that I hadn't been honest with God. I needed to confess that that I'd been wearing all these religious masks to try to
impress God as if God doesn't already know what's deep down in my heart. And, and he said, now you're learning how to pray because prayer is an exercise of desire. Prayer is feeling what we really feel and learning how to open that up to God. And, and he said I in fact, in my anger, in, in the why, that the, the rage was really connected with the why God, why have you abandoned me? Why did you leave? Give me all these desires and then just leave me to wallow and feeling unfulfilled.
And he said I was, whether I knew it or not, I was praying in union with Jesus on the cross. That that prayer, my God, my God, why have you abandoned me? It was a life changing moment in my life. And yeah, I would say I really did take a giant leap on that retreat in learning how to pray. Prayer is not just saying prayers. Prayer is an exercise of desire. Prayer Here I'll quote from Pope Benedict the 16th. He says prayer the fathers of
the Church tell us, properly understood, is nothing other than becoming a longing for God, becoming a longing for God. My colleague Bill Dunny, he recently sent me this beautiful quote from Saint Thomas Aquinas. Thomas says in this life no one can fulfill his longing, nor can any creature satisfy man's desire. Only God satisfies.
He infinitely exceeds all other pleasures. That is why man can rest in nothing but God. Learning that and learning how to redirect our desire towards the divine. That's the life of prayer. And it doesn't lessen our appreciation for the good things of this life, like bicycles or going out on a date with somebody you, you, you admire or or a bowl of ice cream.
It doesn't lessen our appreciation for those things. It increases it because we are learning how to delight in the pleasures of this life in the right way without investing ultimate fulfillment in them. When we invest ultimate fulfillment in certain things, not to have them is utterly crushing. But when we know that our ultimate fulfillment rests in God, then as Saint Paul says, whether there's plenty or whether I'm I go without, I'm at peace because I'm not placing ultimate fulfillment in the
pleasures of this world. I can learn to rejoice in the pleasures of this world as little foretaste of the ultimate delight of heaven without investing my fulfillment in them. That is true freedom, and that's what an exercise in getting in touch with our desires is meant to lead us toward authentic freedom. Something I'm wondering, as you shared that story, I feel like you've probably returned to some of those unfulfilled desires again at other times in prayer that may be on that retreat.
What came up was that rage, but that in other times of maybe revisiting the stolen bike or the rejection by that girl, I think you've also kind of seen other learned other things about your heart. I think almost like getting that rage out was a step, correct? And that that there's been more to learn about yourself and about the Lord contained in those significant memories that that have returned to you at
different times in your journey of prayer. And I think it's important to know that too, that you're not just visiting these painful things just to be in pain. Wendy I gosh, yes, yes, that is so important. And I, I could, I could share 11 experience that that bike thing did come back to me many times in prayer. And and I had an image one time in prayer as I was entering into that pain and disappointment of, of that guy who stole my bike.
And I'm assuming it was a guy and, and I, I walked up to him and it was just a grace. I had worked through it enough. I mean, I had to work different stages of my prayer work through some anger towards that guy, but I got to a place in my heart and my prayer where in in this place of prayer, I I confronted him or he he I saw him stealing my bike and I said, do you need my bike? Do you like my bike? Do you want my bike here?
You don't have to steal it. I'll I'll, I'll give it to you if you just talk to me about it and say, Hey, I really like your bike. Here, have it, have it. I, I'm not invested in this bike as my ultimate fulfillment anymore like I was as a kid, like I had a, an attachment to it that was not healthy. And I've worked through that. And so I, I was detached and detachment doesn't mean you don't still like things. It just means you're not investing your, your happiness in it. And so I was free to say, do you need a bike?
Are you, are you are you can't you afford a bike? You're stealing my bike. I mean, I'm, I'm happy if you just tell me you're you're in need here. Like you would like to have my bike. It's my gift to you. Here. Take it. I just thank the Lord for that. That's such a grace. Freedom, freedom. It's, it is a total grace. It's a total grace. And, and similarly, you know what, that girl who initially said yes, she'd go out with me and then said, no, I had to work through stuff there. And yeah, there was a lot of anger and feelings of rejection and all that stuff.
But I got to a point of realizing, you know, she's part of this whole high school hierarchy as well. And she was afraid of rejection, too. You know, if she went out with me, she wouldn't be able to hang out with the cool girls anymore or whatever it was. And so I had, I had compassion for her. She's caught in the same lies that I was caught in and dealing with the same wounds that I was dealing with. And we all want to be accepted and by our group of friends, and we're all in this shitty situation together where we
don't know what it means to be human and we don't know that we're lovable as we are. And we're trying to prove ourselves and be cool or be, you know, win people's approval or whatever. And I was playing the same game. I thought it would boost my status if I went out with her. You know, it was, there's crap in my heart. There was crap in her heart. There was good things in my heart. There was hopefully some good things in her heart. We're messed up. We're confused. I was able to have compassion and release her and not hold that against her. You know that. And that comes from prayer that
that I don't know how else, how else you get to that place other than praying through it. So you are so right, Wendy. Prayer is not just getting the anger out. That is one step in the process. It's usually the the cork that that has to come out, that has to pop so the you can get to the deeper places in prayer. It's reminding me of, and I wish I could tell you the exact place, but in the Gospels I think it's Nathaniel, that Christ, when Jesus calls him to
be his apostle, he says to him, I saw you under the fig tree, right? Or something like that. I saw you under the tree. Saw you. Under the tree. And it's always just struck me that that was included in the gospel. Like it kind of just speaks to the Lord knowing our story. We don't know what was going on in his heart when he was under the tree. The Lord knew. And and yeah, just that intimacy with the Lord that is so such a
beautiful experience in prayer. And it's what you're describing in some of those things is, is that he knows your heart and wants to show it to you because he loves you. Yeah, and those memories are very important to our story, and the Lord knows them. And just as you're saying, when he he wants to come in to all those painful memories and bring healing between here and the beatific vision, he wants to redeem everything, absolutely everything in our story.
What a marvelous, beautiful hope. Yes, that's why it gave me so much joy to hear you tell those that's so beautiful. Sam, thanks for that question. Yes, and thanks everybody who sends us questions. Please keep sending them. And if you have a question that we have not been able to answer, you've heard me say this before and I'll, I'll keep sharing it. Try Truthfully. Truthfully's doing some good work. Their platform is designed to answer your questions about the Catholic faith and let us know how it goes. We want to know if Truthfully's working out for you.
They're a sponsor of our show and, and we're giving, giving them a, a, a try ourselves and we believe in what they're doing. I think they're doing good work, but we want to hear from you. How are you experiencing truthfully? Also, if you were blessed by today's show, could you please hit that share button and share it with people you know? This is how we expand our audience. With your help, we'd be very grateful. You are a gift to us. We we are blessed to know that we are also a gift to you. It's good to live as the gift that we're called to be.
And Wendy, I'm totally stealing your Thunder and your line. Where do you. Yeah. Where do we go from there? Didn't really work out that time. Become what you are. Let's. Become what we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors.
If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...