Joyfully Surrender to a Crying Infant, Is God In Vulgar Art, & Trading Pornography For True Intimacy. | ACW380
1 hr 2 minAudio
Questions answered this episode: I’m a first-time mom to an almost six-month-old, and motherhood is both the most beautiful and difficult thing I’ve ever done. I struggle with knowing what it means to lay down my life as a parent. In other relationships, we’re taught to set healthy boundaries and ensure our needs are met, but in motherhood, even my basic needs - sleep, exercise, seeing friends - feel like sacrifices. The other night, a failed attempt at extra sleep left me frustrated with God, my baby, my husband, and myself for not sacrificing more joyfully. I genuinely love my daughter, but how do I truly learn to joyfully surrender? Why does the Lord ask so much of me? I know Christopher has mentioned in the past that music and movies can be a pathway to feeling the Lord’s love and grace. But what about movies and music that are vulgar or sexually explicit? Is this holy in its own way, or is it something that should be avoided? In a YouTube video, I heard Christopher distinguish between "being gay" and experiencing same-sex attraction. I began to understand that my sexual dimension doesn't define my whole person, yet that "something more" has become invisible due to pornography. I mostly feel desire, longing, and conflict. I felt that if I fought my inclinations, there would be nothing left of me; need for love and pleasure became so intertwined I couldn't distinguish them. I viewed my lack of a physical partner as proof I’m unworthy of love. After much pain, I’m asking if there’s another way to fill this void - one that seeks deep, soulful closeness rather than just pleasure. Resources: U2 Scars Song Course Schedule --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? Join our Patron Community! --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 List of trusted counselors & psychologists *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Hey everybody, thanks for tuning in to be with us today. We're hay to be with you. We are. I'm hay to be with you, Wendy. Thanks, I'm hay to be with you too, Christopher. Thank. You thank you and I just said something there. I said I'm hay to be with you. Who you did?
And that reminds me of something which is a little a song that's gotten in your head recently and you've been humming around the house. And I think our listeners would be. Interested. Yeah. It's not just in my head. It's kind of in my bones. Go for it. You too. Anybody who knows me and knows my love of music knows I've been following this band since the early 80s, which was a long time ago. This year, 2026. You Too is celebrating 50 years together as a band. That's pretty crazy.
But they haven't put out an album since 2017 and just a month and a half ago I think they put out a new EP which means not a full album but like 6 songs. And to my surprise, they just put out another EP for Easter called Easter Lily, which is 5 or 6 songs. And when the, when the EP came out a couple, a month and a half ago, whatever, I listened to it once and I'm like disappointed
They, they just get sometimes a little political. And I just, that's not what I turned to music for. But this new EP, Easter Lily, it's the most spiritually explicit collection of songs they've put out since 1982's album October. And it's basically an extended meditation on Easter and the crucifixion and the resurrection. And the song that's getting in my, my mind and my heart and my bones is called Scars.
And it's, it's about the wounds of Christ and our wounds. And don't cover your scars. They're your scars. They, they make You Beautiful. And he talks about putting your hand in the side of Christ and realizing this is where life and goodness and beauty comes from. And it's really, it's, as you said, I've been humming it and singing it. It's in my mind, it's in my heart, it's getting in my bones. It's, it's really ministering to me. It's helping me to look at some of my own scars that I'd rather
forget or bury or or pretend aren't there or wish weren't there, and just coming to terms with my own wounds in a new way. And, and letting Jesus's wound minister to my wounds and let the blood and water flowing from his open side just come into my own open wounds. And this is where redemption comes. Don't cover your scars. Don't cover your scars. Yeah, check out that song. We'll have a link to it in the show notes.
We'll put a link there that has a link to the lyric video and yeah, I think you'll really be blessed by it. There's they did get one lyric wrong in the lyric video though. Oh, really? It says put your hand on my side in the lyric video, but what he's singing is put your hand in my side. Very, very important distinction there. Yeah, well, I'm excited just to see you in that special place of being blessed by a new song and
experiencing God's work in your heart through it. It's really happy for me. To see that. Thanks, Wendy. I've been journeying with this band for 40, what, 40? Well, 44 years, 45 years. That's just a long time to be journeying with the band, and I'm so grateful to these guys, even though they do get a little funky and political. Whatever. OK, fine, Bono, do your political thing. But thank you for putting out this EP with very beautiful
music that I'm loving. That's awesome. Hey, do you have any updates for us from the TOV Institute? That would have been a good thing to think of before we hit record. Yes, we have. We have a whole slate of summer courses coming up, and I just found out this is even more aggressive than last year. Last year, June, TOB one, do you remember this? We had our biggest course ever with 140 people crammed into
that classroom. Well, it's only April and we already have 80 registered, and that means it's going to sell out probably again at 140. And I mean, yeah, I mean, sell out is like we used to say sell out was 80. Well, we're already at that old sell out mark. So we're going to we're going to get as many as we can in, in terms of the the classroom is not so much the problem as the beds at this retreat center. So we will we will fit as many
as we can. But if you are interested in coming to TOB one June 14th to the 19th, now is your time to sign up because the spots, the beds will be taken. So click that link in the show notes. We also have The Way of Beauty taught by Bill Donaghy in July, superb course just looking at all of creation and how God reveals himself through beauty. Bill is a superb teacher. And then I will be teaching TOBTO B2 in August.
And I knew when I designed these courses way back in the like 2004 and five, I started writing the curriculum for the TOB Institute and I knew it would take 230 hour courses to unpack John Paul's catechesis. That's why we have TOB 1 and TOB 2. And I wondered, should we do just the first half in TOB 1 and the second-half in TOB 2? And I thought, no, I really need to give the whole overview in TOB one, but I can't do all of it.
I just, I'll give the overview, but there's going to be a lot of blank spaces. So we go back in TOB 2 and fill in those blank spaces and one of the blank spaces left from TOB 1 is John Paul's amazing reflections on the song of songs. We spend a, a, a whole day in TOB 2 looking at the song of songs. Whereas in TOB one we spend about 20 minutes looking at the song of songs. In TOB 2. We, we dive deep and if, if that's of interest to you, make sure you take TOB one first. You can't take TOB 2 if you
haven't taken TOB 1. You can either take it in person or online and then come be with me for TOB 2 in the first week of August. We also have the Marion Mystery course that I love to teach coming in November, November 1st to the 6th. And if we sell out of TOB One, which we will for June, we also have TOB One Live taught by Bill Dunahy in October. So that's the slate of courses for the rest of the year. Those are the in person courses.
We are always offering the online courses. You can check all that out in the show Nuts. Awesome. All right, now it's time for a question from a patron. Are you? Ready. I am ready. Very good. This is from an anonymous patron. Thank you so much for this your podcast. I am a first time mom to an almost 6 month old. Motherhood is simultaneously the most beautiful and the most difficult thing I've ever done. Yep, sounds pretty right. I'm struggling with knowing what
it means to lay down one's life as a parent and particularly a mom. In other relationships, we're taught to put up boundaries for what is healthy for us and make sure our needs are being met. However, in motherhood it feels like even what I think I need sleep, not to have someone clinging to me when I'm trying to eat, some sort of exercise, to see friends, etcetera is being asked to be sacrificed.
Just the other night I was able to go to bed super early in hopes of catching up on some long-awaited and needed sleep, but instead I ended up having a harder night than previous nights. I grew frustrated and angry, as I often do. Angry that God didn't just allow me to actually rest so I would be functioning better, and then frustrated that I feel entitled to receive things from him. Angry at my baby who should have slept well after I spent the day catering to her nap so she wasn't overtired.
Angry at my husband who seems to never be frustrated like me, and angry and frustrated at myself for not joyfully sacrificing for my child. I sometimes want to say I didn't sign up for this. And then I remember the vow I made on my wedding day to be open to children. Yes, you did sign up for this. I do not resent my daughter and I genuinely love her so very much, but how do I really learn to say this? Is my body given up for you and
mean it? How do I joyfully surrender? Why does the Lord ask so much of me in being a mother? Bless you, dear person. I feel so close to this person and I'm sure you do too Wendy and I know our pattern on the show is for me to go first and then for you to say what you want to share and I will go first just because that's our pattern. But I'm going to keep it brief and, and punt this one to you, Wendy, because you've, you've
lived this directly as a mother yourself. Everything she's saying is so familiar. Everything she's saying is so human. I love her honesty. I love her just putting it out there as it really is, as she's really feeling it. That's prayer. That's that's real prayer. When we're honest about what's going on in our hearts and we open it up to the Lord. And I, I, I hear her in presenting this question to us. I also hear her presenting it to the Lord and, and there are a lot of, there are a lot of, I
don't know, impressions we get about prayer that we're supposed to be pious and put on a religious mask in order to please God. But the Catechism says prayer is where we let our masks fall and we present ourselves to God as we really are, allowing him to love us as we really are in order to transform us into who he is calling us to be.
And that, my dear sister, is exactly what I see unfolding in your life. You are being challenged like every mother or father will be challenged. It's a particular challenge for a mother, no doubt, with a young infant because of breastfeeding and just the the normal realities written into a woman's body that are not written into a man's body, that those early days of nurturing come largely,
not exclusively, but largely from and through the mother. You are being stretched, and that stretching is good. It's painful, but it's good. You're letting your masks fall. You're not pretending things are other than what they are. You're feeling those frustrations, You're opening them up. I, I invite you to continue opening them, them up to the Lord, open them up in a prayer
journal, write a letter to the Lord about your frustrations and all that you feel, or just voice them as you feel them. I, I, I get the sense you're already doing that. So I just want to encourage you to stay on that path. And again, I'll quote the catechism. I'll repeat it. It's so, I think, fitting for what you are experiencing. Prayer is where we let our masks fall, to present ourselves to the Lord as we really are, so that we can be loved by Him as we really are.
You are loved in this place, my dear sister, and you cannot give what you do not have. The Lord wants to teach you how to love as He loves. So how does He, how do we learn to love as he loves by letting that love come in. Let the Lord love you there so that that love can flow out of you more and more to your child. And I'll also throw this out that let the blessed Mother, mother you here so that she can
teach you more how to mother your child without resenting it. It's, it's always going to hurt, right? But we can get to a place where we don't resent that it hurts, that we're more at peace with the reality that it hurts. We shouldn't pray the herd away 'cause love hurts it. It demands sacrifice, Love one another as I have loved you. How did Christ love us? It it was suffering that that so
poignantly expressed his love. He gave up his flesh, his blood, and this is written right into a woman's body. This is the profundity of a woman's body. She, she, she's designed in her body to transform blood into food. That's the very function of the breast to transform blood into food. That outpouring is a bleeding. It's a bleeding and, and, and
it's Eucharistic, which means it's sacrificial. And I can, I can say this from our perspective in life where we are now having grandkids and, and our kids are grown. It's all worth it. It's all worth it. It's all I, I do. I do have some PTSD from the whole experience. There's no doubt about that. There were 15 years of, of, of very little sleep and, and, and
just demand upon demand upon demand. But I can, I can look at that period of, of life and see how it moulded me and shaped me and taught me and now I'm perfect so. Oh. Please, the the joke is, is just to say we never arrive at perfection in this life. We are, we are always only just
becoming what we are called to be. JP 2 puts it this way. He says love never is. It is always only just becoming. And so of course you love your daughter as you, as you've expressed so honestly, but that love is, is in need of becoming. And that's nothing to be surprised about. That's just life. And I said I was going to be short and I haven't been, so I'll stop punting to you, Wendy, mother of five.
You know, I was just looking for questions last night, knowing that we were going to be recording today and I, I read this question and thought I just felt it like on my heart. Oh, I need to put that one first in our, our next session, just because I, I feel the, the pain that this patron is in and so many of our listeners can relate to this kind of pain. And I, I feel like in my heart, I, I see the graces at work.
I, I hear her, she's asking how can I joyfully surrender? And I feel like that's a beautiful desire. I feel like God might be doing something else right now. And it might be helpful if if I just point out what some things I see going on that might come before the joyful surrender or you might be doing some aspect of a joyful surrender that's that's already going on. But one of the things I'm just
aware of is that for me, I have a hard time identifying what my expectations are of something until it doesn't happen. And that sort of record scratch as we used to experience when we were kids, you know, you're that's like the the music's going. And then it's not that feeling of like, oh, I wasn't expecting this. Then I start to look at, well, what was I expecting?
Similarly, I have a hard time knowing what my needs are until they go unmet. And in my case, I can have my needs go unmet for an unduly long amount of time and it's not good, right? So the graces I'm seeing just right here in your yes to motherhood. Yes, you said it on the altar. You were asked in in front of that gathering of people who came there with joy in their
hearts to celebrate your marriage. And you were asked if you would accept children lovingly and bring them up. And you said I will. And they were there. They were gathered there to celebrate even that, you know, they, many of them know the call of parenthood and the challenges. And yet it's worth celebrating. So when you remember that you said yes at your wedding, remember also that it was a joyful yes surrounded by others who've also given their yes.
But sorry that I got slightly off track from what I wanted to say, which is just that as you're looking at your life right now and the struggles that you're having, I feel like this incredible grace that you're receiving is knowing yourself in new ways. And you're you've articulated some of those needs, you know, in your question. And I'm sure it's not a, you know, exhaustive list of the things that you're needing that are not happening.
But I don't think it is entirely wrong to say we have some boundaries even as mothers. And I think that was part of an earlier part of your question was kind of maybe getting the sense that I'm not supposed to have any boundaries at all. And I do think you're you're, but stirring in a lot of this anger. We get angry when somebody steps on something where we have a right to and takes away our
autonomy, our ability to choose something for ourselves. So like that, there's a lot of that going on right now and you're like trying to learn, well, what is the new path? How? How can I have some of these meet needs somewhat met, you know, for sleep, for peacefully eating without someone physically needing you at that moment, for time with friends, for exercise. And each one of them like is a, it's a gift that you're
recognizing those as a needs. And I don't think that there's something I can say to you that will allow all those needs to be suddenly met to the extent that it would feel the best. But I think in parenthood, we're, we're kind of in this bit of a dance with all the good that we desire to give our children and the need to be filled. So we have that good to give and how to find ways to have that
being filled in our lives. And some of what you're sharing about is the need to be filled. I will say to you honestly and truly, I did not get enough sleep and I did not function well without sleep. And I think that I was in sometimes in my life as a mom of young children, almost a little zombie ish from the lack of sleep. And I can sort of laugh at that now, but I also feel some yeah, pain and shame and and grief over it.
You know, like I kind of lost part of myself in that lack of sleep. So I can really relate to that. And one thing that I did experience as restorative in that time of lack of sleep for me was to have some kind of massage. And Christopher would often just see me looking, oh gosh, I'm if I could have seen my own face as he saw it, I know he saw my neediness, my weariness just
come behind me when I'm sitting at the table and just rub my shoulders. And oh, the consolation of that, just that rubbing my shoulders, just the touch that it released something for me that was a stress that I think is supposed to be released by sleeping, but I wasn't doing enough sleeping. And so that it's simple and it doesn't fix everything, but it's something. And it's something you can tell your husband, you know, this, I am struggling.
Could you set aside something that you're maybe busy with to tend to me, you know, in a in some way, whether that's the way that most blesses you, I can't say. But but that ability to know yourself and to speak up and say, gosh, I have tried so hard to get more sleep. It's not working. And so this is what is a consequence of that. I need to know that it's OK with you. This is to your husband that I
can't be a certain way or do certain things because I'm not getting the sleep I need. And if I know from you that's OK, then then I can have some peace about that because I really am not able to do everything I thought I should or wanted to be able to do. So that's part of my advice too, is to recognize the gift of knowing yourself and then to look for different ways, especially to communicate with your husband, but also other people in your life about those
needs. You know what? Is there somebody that can stay with the baby for 30 minutes so you can go for a jog like and would that refresh you? Would that make a difference? The little things that can make a difference when we are in tune with our needs are part of our giving ourselves joyfully. And I think over the years of growth and parenting that we've experienced, we've had different
kinds of periods where we just kind of felt called to pay attention, you know, pay attention to how you're feeling about this situation right now and, and take some action. Take some action to bring about a change. I can remember this is going to sound. I don't know if people are going to love me very much for saying this, but I'm going to be honest. Christopher used to, for a period of time in our parenting, he used to keep the kids on a Sunday afternoon so I could have prayer time, which is beautiful. And I would go take prayer time
and I needed it. But there were times when I thought, I'm just going to go and cry. That's all I'm going to do. Can somebody keep the kids so I can do something fun? I mean, I needed the prayer time, but I, you know what I'm saying? Like I also wanted something fun in my life and that was hard and, and there were limits on what was available to me. But I'm just sharing like honestly, like it is not easy. And I, I just want to affirm again and again, you've received
an incredible gift in your marriage, in your baby and in your knowing yourself. And I don't think you are called necessarily to have everything stay the same, but somehow you become joyful about it. I think you're actually called to have some things change in your life and some things just to let go of. That's kind of what I was hinting at when I said talking to your husband about, well, I'm
not going to be able to do this and that that I wish I could and I'm not going to be able to do it. And, and I need you to be OK with that and be OK with me crying about it too, because sometimes I just have to cry. And all of that is just part of the real journey of letting things go. And it's the, the moments when you just pause and see how much you just love that baby and love that she turns to you when you pause and recognize the gift of
that bond. Those moments of joy wouldn't be there without all your sacrifice. So I hope that that's made some sense. I, I, I don't know if you have any. I just think. What you've shared, Wendy, is just so beautiful because it's so honest. And you were doing exactly, you were showing by example exactly what I was teaching from the Catechism about letting our masks fall, being honest, knowing we're loved right there.
And you zoomed me back to that time in our lives. And I am certain now more than ever that I do have PTSD. But I'm also certain as I see our own kids having kids and I'm like, oh, you have no idea what you're getting into. I'm also certain it's all worth it. It's all worth it. And it is such a blessing and it is not something to be taken for granted. And we know that in one part of our hearts, like there are those
who are longing to be where I am. I'm not saying that to put a guilt trip on anyone. Like, we are where we are, you know, and that's OK just to know. Like there's no blessing in this life that doesn't also demand something of us. And we're just growing step by step. We can't take giant leaps forward, even though sometimes I would feel like that. Like, mother, may I please take a giant leap forward? I'm struggling with these baby
steps. And the good news is we're loved in and through all of it. Unconditionally loved in and through all of it. Yes, yes. So I I want to say, yeah, like you should have some boundaries, so that's OK. Yeah, I'm so glad you. I knew you were going to bring all that up so I didn't have to say any of it. You did beautifully, Wendy. Thanks for sharing all that. And bless that dear Mama. Yes, and all dear Mamas out there. And all dear Papas. I.
Have another question for you? This is from a listener named Lauren. Hi, Lauren. Hi Christopher and Wendy. I'm a fellow Pennsylvanian. I live in Pennsylvania Dutch Country in southern Northumberland County in a beautiful place called the Mahantango Valley. I don't know if I have. No idea where that is. Mahantango. Valley, I need to look on a Pennsylvania map. If you ever get up this way, you'll see that it is a slice of heaven on earth. It must be north of us.
My question is about media, namely music and movies. I know Christopher has mentioned in the past that music and movies can be a pathway to feeling the Lord's love and grace, but what about movies and music that are vulgar or sexually explicit? Is this holy in its own way, or is it something that should be avoided? Great question. I, I never tire of speaking into this topic because it's, it's an important one, very important.
And I don't hear a lot of great wisdom out there. I hear often 2 extremes that I don't think do justice to the issue. And those two extremes are, well, if it has anything unholy in it, don't watch it. That's the one extreme. And the other extreme is, oh, don't worry about it, whatever. Just watch whatever you want. Just, you know, it's all fine. Get, you know, don't make such a big deal out of this stuff. Those are two extremes that don't do justice. The the truth of the matter.
Jesus told us that the wheat and the weeds grow together in our own lives, in the lives of others, in works of art, in music, in movies. You will always find wheat and weeds and there's no guarantee that just because it's slapped with the label Christian music for example, that you aren't going to find weeds in there. I remember 1 fellow follower of
Christ with whom I was talking about these topics and he said something to the effect that I've been to so-called Christian concerts where it was pretty evident that there are some pretty big egos involved. And it had the label Christian, but didn't feel that way in the you went to the concert and you didn't really get the sense that the Lord was being glorified by it all. And then on the other hand, at a
secular concert where the singers themselves didn't have any professed faith, but they were open to grace and grace was flowing and there was some powerful movement of the Holy Spirit at a so-called secular concert. I've had similar experiences. My my point here is, is it's simply not a Catholic position to to say Christian music only.
In other words, explicitly Christian. Everything in this world is worthy of a song, a movie, a story because God made everything in this world. A song about your love for for nature, a song about your love for a cup of coffee, a song about a a pained or broken relationship. A song about lovemaking can be
tasteful. And if you oh, you should never sing a song about lovemaking. Oh really? Gee, have you read the song of songs in the Bible? It's it's, it's a love song. It's a song about marital love, about erotic love. And, and the greatest Saints and Mystics have have found that to be their favorite book in the Bible. The Saints have written more commentaries on this erotic love song than any other book in the
Bible. I remember hearing Bono again, to quote from my, you know, these this rock band I've been following for 40 whatever years that that he says the problem with Christians today is that if if a band put the song of songs to music, you couldn't sell it in a Christian music store. And and I thought, yeah, well, that's that's pretty telling. And and another thing I remember Bono saying was you you don't have to put a sign on a tree that says made by God because if
you have eyes to see, you already know it's made by God. Wow. In other words, we don't have to slap the label. This is Christian music or this is a Christian movie. Anything human is worthy of Christ because Christ took on our humanity, right? The Incarnation in its very essence is the wedding, the
coming together of the sacred and the secular of that which is of heaven and that which is of earth to yes, to purify that which is of earth and raise it to the heavenly level, not to leave it as it is. But guess what? We can take that very principle of incarnation and redemption with us into our appreciation of art, and we can allow the very principle of incarnation and redemption to transform a song,
for example. And I, I've said this before on this podcast, I say it to my students all the time, a profound experience in my life. Profound. I mean, Deep has been allowing the Lord into secular music to untwist what might be twisted up in there, to untwist what might be twisted up in there. And yeah, there's a lot of
twisted up stuff out there in in music. And I'm not saying that anybody and everybody in any stage of the Christian life should just be Willy nilly indiscriminate in the art they expose themselves to. No, I am not saying that at all. Above all else, my advice is this Christian, know thyself, right? If you OK, here's an example. I'll just put one out there. The movie Titanic. There are plenty of weeds in
that movie, right? There's a sex scene, for example, in that movie unmarried couple. And it it's just, it's just gratuitous. It doesn't need to be in there. It's it's a distraction. It's inciting lust. I don't like it. I wish it wasn't in there. Does that mean you should never watch that movie? Well, I don't know who you are or what your issues are, what your struggles are. Christian, know thyself. There's plenty of wheat in the
movie Titanic. There's a lot of good wheat. There's a lot of weeds. One who has journeyed with Christ some some way and and has attained some level of equilibrium and is not swept away by his passions or enticed by by lust as he or she might once have been at a a a earlier stage of his or her journey, can watch Titanic and Fast forward
through that scene without it being a big deal. But there are others who might watch that movie and well, here comes that scene. OK, OK, I'm going to and fall into an occasion of sin that could be an occasion of sin. The very watching of the movie because of where you are in your journey. So there's no blanket statement that can be made that would be Christians can never watch XY and Z movies because I mean, you can say that about some things.
You shouldn't ever obviously be watching pornography, but but there are, they're going to be, they're going to be whatever art you turn to, they're going to, whether it's from a so-called Christian source or secular source, you're going to find in both instances, both wheat and weeds. You know what a lot of the weeds you're going to find in so-called Christian art. You're going to find bad art. You're going to find bad storytelling. You're going to find very poor acting. You're going to find very poor songwriting.
Not across the board, but often times. And those, make no mistake, those are weeds. What determines art is not just the lyric, it's the, the, the what determines a good song. It's not just the lyric, it's the, it's the composition, it's the, the craft. It's the singing, it's the musicianship. And and a lot of what passes for Christian music I can't even stomach because it's bad musicianship, bad craft.
I can't do it. I can't do it. So I'm I'm rambling now, but but the point is this Christian know thyself, wheat and weeds. Learn how to discern. If you know the weeds are going to get you in trouble, by all means don't go down that path. But in not going down that path, also have the courage to say, Lord, there are weeds in my heart that are getting watered by watching this and, and I need your help, Lord, to learn how not to water these weeds.
I need your help, Lord, to water the wheat in my own heart. And the more I'm watering the wheat in my own heart, the more that wheat is flourishing in my own heart, the less I'm going to be swept away by encountering weeds in the art of movies and music. And, and the Lord can really use this stuff. The the Lord can really use movies and music to teach us very important things and take us to very important places in our hearts.
Art is the language of the heart. And we need art in our lives, and we need to be discerning in what we're exposing ourselves to. I think one of the things I take away from some of what you're saying is sort of this image of almost like a conversation like like the artist and the art that was made by the artist is is part of the conversation. And then then our own hearts and minds that are interacting with it are the other part of it.
And it each conversation is unique to us, like who we are. And when you say like, Christian, know thyself, like just that sense of there's, there's not an absolute, you know, yes or no. She did ask, is art music that's vulgar or sexually explicit? Is it wholly in its own way or something that should be avoided? And I I get, I think there's beautiful that she put out
there. Is it wholly in its own way? There's certainly an yeah. What do you think she means by that? Wholly in its own. Way what you talk about maybe things that need to be untwisted, you know like to see the deeper human reality is somehow holy, I think I don't think you can say that you know in an absolute one way or another, but I do think just what I'm I've heard you talk about this before and what I'm feeling right now kind of strongly. It's just that that sense of the, the conversation and like,
I can sense how there are people who are in different types of ministries, say they are youth ministers or teachers or like young adult group organizers or something where they, they kind of have to read a larger group in a certain way in terms of what they're sharing in music and movies. And I think, you know, there you have situations where you kind
of have to lean towards that which is less likely to offend for the sake of the group because, you know, there's just too much variety in in the hearts that are present in a in a group setting for us. I know, you know, we enjoy listening to things and watching things together and talking about them and, and sometimes one person's response is very
different from the others. And, and we are enriched by sharing about that and seeing things from a new perspective. So I, I think when you're looking into this question of media, you're, you're going into very personal space. Yes, you are. And, and the personal space for Christopher, He, he does, he feels things deeply in this realm of, of music and movies. And not everyone has the same
feelings and reactions. And that's OK. We're not here to, you know, enter a debate about a specific song or movie or something, because we know. People are in. Different places, yeah. If I could comment about that, is it holy in its own way? What what's holy in its own way is the subject of of human sexuality, right? This is a great mystery. The two becoming one flesh is a great mystery and it refers to
Christ and the church. That's what's wholly in its own way. What the enemy wants to do is get his hands on that holy reality and twist it, twist it, distort it. Pornography, the the vulgar, the profane is is a hellish mockery of a heavenly reality. And all of those lustful vulgar songs, and there are plenty of them, they are a twisted attempt, a twisted attempt of
the human heart to sing the song of songs and all of them can be redeemed. And when those twisted, lustful, vulgar, so I mean, they're, Oh my gosh, the, the halftime show, for example, at the foot at the Super Bowl this year, I could, could not stomach it. I could not, it was churning my stomach. I was, I was at a friend's relative's house and, and it was shown on a big, you know,
projector on the on the wall and, and it was not easy to say, Hey, can we turn this off? So I, I, I was exposed to some of it and I just became intercession for me. I'm just praying for everybody around the world who's watching this terribly profane, vulgar, pornographic halftime show that was supposed to be musical, but nonetheless that is a twisted, diabolic, twisted version of the Song of Songs.
The devil doesn't have his own clay. All he can do is take God's clay, his holy clay, his beautiful clay, and twist it. The good news, when I talk about the principle of the incarnation and redemption, I needed to bring Christ into the imagery and the lyrics that I saw and heard at that halftime show. I needed to bring Christ into that, to untwist it. And as I let him come in to those places that needed to be redeemed, the imagery and lyrics
that I heard that needed to be redeemed, I was taken into a profound place of communion with Christ and His church. I, I, I, I, I don't know how to say it other than to put it that way. And this, this really, really can happen for us between here and eternity. Everything gets redeemed. How much gets redeemed, Wendy? I think everything I. Think everything I know everything, everything, everything gets redeemed.
Every perverse, every vulgar, every profane thing you've ever seen or heard will be untwisted and redeemed. Everything that the enemy is twisted will get untwisted. Thanks be to God, and we can begin that journey now. Now, don't go running out exposing yourself to twisted stuff just because, well, I know the Lord's going to eventually untwist it. Christian, know thyself. That's the best advice I can give anybody when we're talking about media. Know thyself.
Know where you are on your journey. Don't. Don't let the twisted stuff twist you up. Don't let it lead you astray, but be discerning you. We are, we are able to say in maturity, in a place of freedom. There's the weeds, there's the wheat. I'm not going to water those weeds. I'm going to water that wheat. It's really possible. Otherwise, just go bury your head in the sand and and don't live in this world because you're going to be exposed to crap in this world one way or
another. All. Right. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Recently, I've been trying to find the right words to describe my inner journey. In a YouTube video, I heard Christopher make an important distinction. It is not the same thing, quote, to be gay, UN quote, and to experience attraction toward people of the same sex. I began to understand that the sexual dimension does not define the whole person, that there's
something more within me. However, that something more has become almost invisible to me, especially because of my exposure to pornography. Inside, I mostly feel desire, longing, and inner conflict. I've come to understand that every person carries inclinations that are not fully aligned with God's will, and yet for me, it has felt as though if I fought against this inclination, there would be nothing left of me. The need for love and the need
for pleasure became so intertwined within me that I could no longer distinguish between them. The fact that no one was physically beside me became, in my mind, proof that I'm not worthy of love. For many years I tried to fill this emptiness through various experiences and fleeting moments. But after much pain, I'm beginning to ask myself whether there might be another way to fill this void. A void that cries out for something, perhaps not necessarily pleasure, but for deep, true soul, soulful
closeness. Is there another way? Yes, yes, yes, there's another way. Do do we know if this is a man or a woman asking this question? I don't know. And I actually, even though it started with this reference to same sex attraction, it's not even clear whether that's. This particular struggle of this. Person, yeah, it kind of open in that way. OK, the oh, bless this dear person. I I wanted to share a couple
things that struck me as you read the question. Could you read? It was right towards the beginning of the question reread where he says something about I realize sexuality doesn't define the whole something. Can you? Yeah, I began to understand that the sexual dimension does not define the whole person, that there's something more within me. OK, OK. I want to, I want to comment on that because it, it depends what we mean bisexual. And I think from the context of this person's question, he or
she is using the term sexual to refer to his or her experiences of sexual desire. And absolutely that our experience of sexual desire, the way we experience desires, the things we're desiring, what we're find ourselves attracted to, and one thing, those desires do not define us. However, I would not call that your sexuality. The culture calls that your sexuality, but that is not your
sexuality. Your sexuality is male and female. He created them, right? Are you a man or are you a woman? That is your sexuality. And when we understand sexuality in those terms, it does indeed define our humanity. Sexuality, maleness, femaleness is by no means something purely biological, John Paul the Second says, but concerns the innermost
being of the human person. So I I just wanted to point this out. How are we using our terms? It's the culture that wants to say the way you experience sexual desires. That's your so-called sexuality. No, it is not Your sexuality is are you a man or are you a woman? And God made you to be a man or a woman through and through. And that does indeed define It's not just a dimension of your humanity.
It is your humanity as a man or as a woman that is your humanity. There is not some generic human nature that gets squeezed into the male or the female body. We are male or female through and through. The human nature is the nature that is sexually differentiated. We share the same dignity as human persons, but there are two incarnations of our humanity, male and female. So it does in that true sense, the word sexuality define us.
OK, just wanted to say that the way we use words is very important. And the way the Church uses language, the way the culture uses language is often very, very different, especially when it comes to sexuality. And the goal of the way the culture uses language here is to confuse, distort, rob us of our true identity, rob us of the truth that sets us free. The truth that sets us free is this. We are made in the image and likeness of God as male and female, to learn what it means
to love in the image and likeness of God. And that is most definitely the deeper cry of your heart that you are feeling when you ask is there another way? Or when you say, I know there's more than just the way I'm experiencing my erotic desires, I say, yes, there is more. There is more. What you are experiencing in that cry for more. You're experiencing what John Paul the Second calls the echo of the beginning.
John Paul the Second says the roots of our humanity lie in the Garden of Eden. The roots of our humanity lie on the other side, he says of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. When we were naked and felt no shame, why were they naked without feeling shame? Because there was a perfect integration of that which is spiritual with that which is physical. There is a perfect integration, therefore, of sexuality and
spirituality. There is a perfect integration, if we're going to use the Greek terms here, which the Church has adopted, There is a perfect integration of Eros and agape, right erotic desire. Eros in the beginning was nothing other than the desire to love and be loved as God loves. That's what Eros is in the beginning. What you are feeling when you say, is there more?
I, I, there must be more. I sense there's more. That's the echo of the beginning. And here's the good news. Here's the good news of the Gospel. This is a quote from the Catechism. Christ came into the world to restore creation to the purity of its origins. Hallelujah. Hallelujah, Hallelujah. How does he do this? By taking our sin upon himself
without sinning, right? He was like us in all things but sin, but he became sin. He who knew no sin became sin. Why? So we might become the righteousness of God in Christ, taking on our sin. That's what was crucified. That's what was crucified. Sinful humanity, our sinful passions were crucified. Why? So that our humanity could be raised up, fully restored, right? We carry in our bodies the death of the Lord.
Why? So that the life of the Lord might also be manifested in our bodies, says Saint Paul. Right. We Saint Paul also says we must allow our sinful passions to be crucified. Why? So that our passions themselves can be resurrected, So that desire itself can be transformed. The Catechism says that in the Sermon on the Mount, the Holy Spirit gives new form to our desires, those inner movements that animate our lives.
New form. And what does Jesus say in the Sermon on the Mount? Among other things, he says blessed are the pure of heart, for they will never have sexual feelings again. No, no, no, that's not what he says. Blessed are the pure of heart, for they shall see God Where? How? Everywhere. Because God is everywhere. He is in and through all things. We can see a flower and see the
revelation of God. We can experience a good beer and experience the revelation of God. We can see the human body and and and experience our desire for union and communion in the body in a pure holy way as a revelation of the mystery of God. Because we are male and female made in the image and likeness of God. And the call of the two to become one flesh is a great mystery and it refers to Christ and the church. Brother, sister, whichever you are to me, I do not know, but I love you and you're on the
journey and I say keep going. And I invite you personal invitation for you to come to Black Rock Retreat Center in Pennsylvania, June 14th to the 19th, when we will spend 5 days entering into this transformation of our humanity, this restoration of our humanity, this redirection of our humanity, this reinfusion of Eros with Agape, right?
I'm not saying after five days all will be well, but you will have a map, you will have a vision. And without a vision, we the people perish. Scripture says you will have the the the tools to take you on the journey for the rest of your life, to pick up your cross and follow in such a way that you are not frustrated, but you are sublimated in your humanity, raised up, made sublime, becoming who you really are. Yeah, this person is truly
already being set free. Like the very reality of of seeing God's light shining in your heart that you can look at your story of your journey and see the deeper desires that have been there that have been Co opted by the father of lies and directed towards things that bring harm to you and others. Like the freedom that comes from that light shining on your
heart. To say that's not even what I really wanted it, but it got all tangled up and twisted up inside me and I, I long to know who I really am apart from those lies and those false directions of genuinely good impulses within. So bless you for all the small little yeses along the way that have gotten you to where you are right now already.
And you're still at at an early stage of your journey in some sense. But you didn't just wake up there. You, you got there by an just open ears, open heart, open eyes to see something's not right. And I long for rightness, I long for goodness, 'cause you're made for it. And we're all made for that genuine goodness. And and realizing we're made for something more doesn't Isn't this the just OK, then you flip
the switch and you're there. You still have to keep journeying, but now it's a journey that involves cleansing and it involves a certain quiet while the Lord is working on things under the surface that we can't always tell what he's doing, but we've said yes to him and so we can trust that deep down inside he's at work and we're quietly waiting sometimes for the next step. And it's it's a beautiful thing
to see you on this journey for, for your just the witness of your being honest about really, you know, terrible actions that you've taken, but out of a place of pain and longing that you're regretting those and turning towards what does God? What did he make me for? What is my true longing? He's speaking to your heart. You're getting it.
And he wants to keep speaking. And I agree with you, Christopher. It would be a tremendous gift to come to TOB one. I really encourage that. And I, I could also see it being a great gift maybe to meet with a, a trusted counselor to look at some of this with the added input of someone wise in the ways of the heart and the journey. But truly, the grace at work is tremendous. I love what you said, Wendy, about those little yeses. You know, they add up quickly
and they're not so little anymore. And that's how grace operates, Lord. We ask for the grace to say yes in the little things day-to-day so that we can step by step become a wide open yes to you. Give us that grace, Lord. Yes, Lord, help us to become who and what we really are. And I think I just stole your
line, Wendy, but. Let me just say it. Just say it anyway. Just say it anyway. So you are a gift become. What you are and become one who shares this podcast with others. How about that? Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that
the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...