Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

What’s the deal with indulgences and scapulars, How do I live celibacy after divorce, Are beauty exercises vain? | ACW332

May 12, 202557 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: Can indulgences and scapulars make sense through the lens of Theology of the Body? How can I embrace lifelong celibacy after my wife left me? Are appearance-focused exercises inherently vain or can they be good? Resources COURSE SCHEDULE Eating the Sunrise Fill These Hearts Sexual Needs Into Prayer YouTube Video Chastity: Reconciliation of the Senses God Is Beauty Book --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? ⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠ --- Submit your question here! --- 🎥 Check out our ⁠⁠YouTube Channel⁠⁠ 📚 View our ⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠ to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 ⁠GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE⁠ by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ ⁠Join us on one of our pilgrimages!⁠ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠ List of trusted counselors & psychologists

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello. Hello everybody. This is Juan, producer of the podcast. I just wanted to give you a heads up. We are changing our podcast host so you will stop seeing new episode updates in the Ask Christopher w.com website. The podcast will still be available on major streaming platforms, but no longer on the website. So if you want to submit a question, just go to the show notes and you will find a link there to do so. God bless. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast.

Well, hey everybody. Hi, podcast listeners. Welcome to another episode with Wendy West and her husband. My husband is Christopher West, to whom you've directed some questions, and I'm here to read them. Well, they I think we can safely say they've directed them to both of us. The name of the show? The name of the show? But hold on, is ask Christopher West. Who, who is the star of the show? Listen, I mean, Jesus, let us pray and hope Jesus is the star of the show.

But Wendy, I travel the world, as you know, and I get to hear people's feedback and it's pretty unanimous. You know what? Here's the way it goes. Well, let me just fill. In no, no, I'm going to say something here, OK? But it's unanimous that you're that you're the star of the. Show this is how it goes. People like you, my husband, yes, stands in front of people and says, is Wendy the star of the show? And he's smiling and nodding and people say yes. Is that the way you find out? Like legitimate information I don't think. So, well, OK, maybe you have a

point, but no one has ever disagreed with me. That's so amazing. No, it is May the 7th upon this recording. As we are recording this, The conclave has just begun. You are probably listening to this episode on Monday, May 12th. Or. After or after Monday, May 12th is the day I proposed to you 30 years ago, Wendy.

It's the anniversary. Anniversary of the day I proposed to you. So there very well may be a new Pope. But since we recorded this the day the conclave began, we don't yet know it. So it's weird to think that our listeners might already know who the Pope does. That that's a little time warp isn't. It. Yet we're praying and we're, yeah, entering into that time as, as it's a very special time for the universal Church.

Yes, it is, Lord, we need, we need a Holy Father. We need a strong Holy Father to guide us through these difficult, painful, confusing times. Please, Lord, please, please, we entrust it all to you. We send blessings to those Cardinals in Rome and and we ask that they would follow your spirit and nothing else. In Jesus name we pray. Yes, yes. Amen. Amen, Amen.

Do. You have any updates for us from the TOB Institute? I do. We have a special deal for our July course here in Pennsylvania. I've mentioned this on previous episodes but it bears repeating. We have sold out for TOB one in June. That course always sells out and people are always disappointed. I really wanted to come in person this summer. I took the time, I saved up my money to make it all work, and now it's sold out and I'm on a

waiting list. Well, here's the solution. You can take TOB One online in June because we're offering it, offering it in June. And that's the prerequisite for the course I am teaching in July, which is Theology of the Body and the New Evangelization where we put our TOB glasses on and we go through the four pillars of the catechism and the faith just comes alive. And I love teaching this course. So if you want to come in person and you're on the wait list for TOB One, we have a special deal. It's like half price or

something for the online course and that's your prerequisite. Then you can come in July and you're you're getting 2 courses for almost the price of 1. How about that? Yeah, I know. I think that's great and I hope a lot of people will do that. That will be exciting. You will not regret it. That's right. I promise you. And when you come, it's Pennsylvania. Make sure to say hi to the star of this podcast who joins us for meals and such over.

It Yes, I I will be there. All right. You ready for a question from a patron? Let's do it. OK? This is from a patron named Kelsey. Hello Kelsey, thank you so much for supporting the work we do. We're so grateful to you. Christopher and Wendy, thank you for your weekly podcast. I love to listen while I'm outside running. I have a question regarding some Catholic teachings. I've been Catholic all my life, but I've never fully understood indulgences and scapulars.

Mm hmm. Now that I've been immersed in theology of the body for three years, I'm trying to put these Catholic teachings together in my mind and make sense of them through the lens of TOB. In these last three years, my prayer life has become an opening up of my life to God. It used to be more or less merely going through the motions and memorizing prayers, but after listening to this podcast and reading TOB books, I feel like I actually have a relationship. Oh, that's.

With my Lord and my God that I never had before. Whenever the priest at my parish brings up an opportunity for an indulgence, I cringe on the inside. It feels like if I were to participate in the steps to gain an indulgence, I would be in the relationship with Christ to gain something, not in the relationship for love itself. I feel like a similar situation would be giving my husband a

massage tonight so he buys me flowers the next day. I love it. That's funny. The same with the scapular. People wear them, to quote, go straight to heaven, so they say. I know people who wear them probably live a virtuous life and are asking for the intercession of Mary in their life. Yet it seems to me to be a multiplication of rules, which I learned about in a past podcast from you on a different topic. Can you explain these sacramentals and teachings in

light of TOP? Kelsey, I love this question and I love your sensitivity and that sensitivity to a certain legalism or just kind of check in the box and if you do X, you'll get Y. That sensitivity, I'm convinced, comes from this beautiful newfound relationship that you have with Christ, your bridegroom. I bless that relationship. I bless that sensitivity.

This is a beautiful work of grace unfolding. And you, you have in your heart through this encounter, through this living relationship, through this realization that Christ is a person and you can enter into union with him. You have the proper sensitivity that will enable you to take advantage of the graces that come to us through indulgences and that come to us through sacramentals like wearing the

scapular. You can, as you maintain that relationship and live that love, you can benefit from these things without falling into legalism, without falling into just a checking the box mentality. This is always the danger of religion without relationship. We fall into just following a set of rules. We fall into certain legalisms. We fall into a check the box

mentality. This is not authentic faith. This is not authentic relationship with Christ. But it is so easy to fall into you. You might call it kind of like a vending machine approach. I put in my coins and I get this out of it, right. So let's look at indulgences through the lens of the theology of the body. The lens of theology of the body helps us to see Christ is the bridegroom.

The church is the bride. Christ has given himself up for the bride. He says Everything that the Father has given to me, I've given to you. The glory the Father has given to me, I've given to you. The love the Father has poured out on me, I have poured out on you. That is that relationship of love between Christ and his Bride. The Church. The Church now is the treasury of the graces of Christ and the Church has been given authority

by Christ her bridegroom to to indulge her children in those graces, to lavish those graces on her children. And indulgence is precisely that. It's mother church saying to us, I want to lavish on you, my children, the graces that Christ has poured out on the church. The the very word indulgence conjures up this idea of of

something extra special like you get to indulge in a gift of grace. The church in her also love and care for her children, wants her children to be properly disposed to those to those graces, right? We all know when we go to receive communion, which is the grace of all grace, right? When we go to receive communion without the proper disposition of our hearts that grace falls on on well, let's use the image

Christ uses that seed of grace falls on rocky soil. We need to be good soil for the grace to go in and take deep root in the proper balance of all things, in the proper understanding of all things, in the proper relationship of all things. When the church says we invite you in order to receive this dulgence to do XY and Z, the church is saying this is like the minimum to get your heart in the proper disposition to receive the full grace of the

indulgence. It's saying prepare the soil for the seed to go in, right. There's a way that we could live that and you're very sensitive to it and you're right to be sensitive to it. There's a way that we could live that in a very legalistic, Pharisaical vending machine approach, but that doesn't mean we have to live it that way. We can take the loving concern of our mother to heart and say, I genuinely want to prepare my heart to be good soil, to

receive the indulgence of Christ's love through his bride, the church. Christ wants to lavish this love on us. He has given that full lavishment. Is that a word? Lavishment. It is. Now it is. Now he's given this full lavishment of grace to his bride, and has given the bride the Church, the authority to dispense those graces to her children. So yes, it can be legalistic. Doesn't have to be and you are right in the right spot to be

preparing your heart in a proper way to receive that deeper grace through the gift of the church. I hope that's helpful. When it comes to or Wendy, before I go to the scapular, do you want to say anything about? I, I just, I just think, you know, one could she, she specifically asked about theology of the body. And I felt like at the beginning you were, you were talking about the, the bridegroom and the bride at Christ and the church and the total gift of himself. So I just wanted to come back to that image just because it, it's

so, you know, it answers that like, how do I see this from the perspective of theology of the body? And I, I think we could almost think of some of the sort of the list of things to do. And for those of you who don't know anything about indulgences, maybe you're not Catholic or you just haven't encountered them for granted. Some of the things on that To Do List to receive an indulgence might be to go to confession, to pray for the intentions of the

Holy Father, receive communion, to receive communion, maybe to visit a special pilgrimage site. So some of those types of things would be sort of connected to an adult indulgence. I just wanted to share that. And I, I almost see it in, in a way, it's sort of like showing up, you know, in, in our comparison of the bride and the of Christ as the bridegroom and, and the church as the bride. And in a relationship, we could

want to do something wonderful for our spouse, but if the spouse doesn't even show up, there's, there's nothing gets received. So I think that that's sort of a making oneself present to the spouse and in those steps that, and not that that's in any way different than what you're saying. I was just trying to carry through that analogy. Yes, I'm so glad you did. And and you're bringing out another point too that was kind of assumed, but not explicitly stated that in this whole

analogy of bridegroom bride, there's always offspring. We are both the offspring of Christ's union with the church and we are members of the Church. So we are also the bride. There are different ways of looking at that analogy and and I was Speaking of it more from receiving mother churches indulgences as as children and you are Speaking of it from the perspective of the bride receiving that gift from Christ. Both are correct and we can go

right just to put a TOB bow on this, we can go right to Ephesians 5. For this reason a man will leave his father, mother be joined to his wife. The 2 will become one flesh. This is a great mystery and it refers to Christ and the Church. The bridegroom is always pouring out the spiritual seed. To draw out the analogy that this is the analogy that the Saints speak of.

This is Saint Augustine, the the flow of blood and water from the open side of Christ, the bridegroom on his marriage bed. The cross is his spiritual seed, so to speak, and that spiritual seed poured out, as you were saying, Wendy, we need to open our hearts and receive that seed for that life to be given. And the church is saying again, here's the bare minimum for disposing yourself to receive the seed of the bridegroom and

thus conceive in a new and deeper way these particular graces. So thank you for that. Regarding the scapular, it would be very similar, right? I wear a scapular. It's, it's not for me, any kind of tit for tat. I'm doing this to get XY or Z. For me, it's my daily reminder of my devotion to Mary. And I like to just have a reminder every day when I put my

scapular on. I say totus tuus Maria. That's quoting from John Paul the Second's papal motto. I'm totally yours Mary. I give myself totally to Mary. Why? Because I'm a follower of Christ and Christ gave himself totally to Mary. Christ placed his very being in Mary's womb and in that totus to us, Maria. We are placing our our being with Christ in the womb of Mary to be formed and shaped into other Christ's. If we want to be formed and

shaped another Christ, we should go where Christ was formed and shaped, the womb of Mary. So that's how I practice wearing the scapular, entering into that relationship with Christ, that relationship with Mary. Yes. Could it be done in a legalistic way? Every good religious practice can become a religious practice. Practice badly. And there are a lot, a lot of people who practice their religious practices badly. And sadly, they can leave quite an impression.

Well, if you wear that, did you know that there's such and such a promise from such and such an apparition in such and such a year said that if you wear your scapular this way or that way or upside down or on Fridays tucking under your ear, you're going to go straight to heaven? I'm, I'm being ridiculous in the way I'm reporting these things to make a point, right? But people get caught up in all kinds of tit for tat and legalisms. And I think it comes from a fear. I think it think it comes from a fear that we're not loved. I think it comes from a

performance mentality that says in order to to get to heaven, I have to win God's love. No, we have to open to it. We have to open to it. We have to receive it. We have to let it go in ever more deeply. If wearing the scapular is reinforcing the idea in your mind and heart because of the way you've been programmed based on your particular upbringing or what have you, or the influence of others. If wearing the scapular every day is something you do because you think if you don't, you're

not lovable or you're not going to go to heaven, here's my suggestion. Don't wear your scapular. Take a fast from wearing your scapular so that you can realize you are loved whether you wear a scapular or not right that that that you can come to a deeper place of open. And I'm saying you here. I'm not saying directly to Kelsey. I'm I'm like speaking to everybody who's listening and especially those who might fall into the certain legalisms which are so easy to fall into.

But I'm launching from Kelsey's question to to address this for everybody. If if you are falling into those legalisms act in a counter way. Don't reinforce the false idea that I'm only lovable or I'm only going to heaven if I do XY and Z or wear a scapular right. We must open open, open to the gift. This is what Christ says in the song of songs, right? He's the bridegroom ultimately in the song of songs. He says open to me, my love, my dove, my beautiful one open to me in the Book of Revelation.

He stands at the door and knocks, and those who open, he will enter and he will dine with us, right? This is not legalism, this is love. And if wearing the scapular becomes for you a reminder of love, a reminder of opening, then we are in the right place for it. Louis De Montfort himself, whom John Paul the Second based all of his Marian devotion on his teaching. Louis De Montfort himself said these practices, such as wearing the scapular or or other

devotional. Things we might do, or jewelry we might wear, miraculous metal, etcetera. These are optional. They are meant to get our heart disposed. If they serve that purpose, great. If they dispose your heart to legalism, pharisaicalism, rigorism, and fear that you're not loved or lovable, then act in a contrary way to learn that you are. That's my advice. Yeah, I think Kelsey's just kind of sensing an area of almost

like a little immaturity that is there. You you said also fear and and, you know, not sure if we're loved. And I, I'm sure if Kelsey's pastor said a few of those things when announcing, you know, an opportunity for an indulgence, the cringe wouldn't be there because they would be the context of what is going on would be there. And there's nothing to cringe about in any of that. So, so I guess it just kind of

illustrates an opportunity for prayer for, you know, these very wounds that you're talking about. Hello everybody, This is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on tour this year. We're going to places like New Mexico, Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Illinois, and also other countries like Ecuador and Brazil. We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our event schedule in the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Our next question is from an anonymous listener, Hey Drive.

West, Hey, anonymous listener. My wife of 15 years left me. Oh, I'm so sorry. I pray for reconciliation, but it would be a miracle. I believe in miracles. As a Christian, I know that remarriage is not an option, so the decision has been made for me. For the rest of my life I must remain celibate. I've searched online but have struggled to find any seemingly

good books on the topic that are not directed to priests or others in religious life. I was wondering if you knew of any books or resources that might help frame this new reality in a healthy way and give me courage and strength for the lonely road ahead. Bless you dear brother. Bless you dear brother. Thank you for putting this out in the light and seeking counsel. Bless you. Bless you. I would like first just to suggest and I, I don't know the

situation. There are no details given, so I I don't know, but it might be possible. It might be possible that your marriage was not valid from the start. I don't know that it may well be. And you may have a certainty in your conscience that it was valid. And if that is the case, then you are correct. Your fidelity to your marriage vows demands that you are

celibate for the rest of your life, unless your wife were to return to you. How does one live celibacy? I think the real question here is how does one live chastely? Because what is required in both married life and in a life of celibacy to live both fruitfully, to live both beautifully? What is required is the virtue

of chastity, and chastity is not a repression of sexual passion and desire. Chastity is a direction of sexual passion and desire towards all that is true, good, and beautiful. And ultimately, chastity means learning how to direct erotic passion and desire towards that alone that will satisfy it. The Bible begins with the

marriage of man and woman, but it ends with the marriage of Christ and the Church. And God gave us Eros that that passion, that yearning, that cry of the heart, of the body, of the soul, of the mind, for union, for union, that cry of the of the human being, For union cannot be ultimately satisfied by simply union with another human person. That cry of the heart can only be satisfied by union with God,

the living God, in the marriage of the Lamb and even in the course of of married life. Wendy and I are celebrating 30th, our 30th anniversary later this year. In the course of 30 years of married life, we must be learning not simply to look at each other as an outlet for erotic passion and desire, but we must learn how to aim and direct erotic passion and desire towards the ultimate reality,

which is Christ's union with the Church. That's what makes marriage a sacrament, A sacrament, a true participation in the love of Christ for the Church. And that demands chastity. That is chastity. Chastity is is the direction of Eros by the grace of Christ, towards that which alone can satisfy Eros, and that which alone can satisfy Eros is the marriage of the Lamb.

We can taste something of that in the sacrament of marriage, but if we are expecting another person to do what only God can do for us, we're turning the icon of married love into an idol. And simply because you're married does not mean indulging in that idolatry in sexual activity. Is is fine because you're married? No, you. You would be misusing God's sexual gift. You would be treating your spouse as as an an object.

You would be in need of a great deal of purification. All of that is my attempt to explain why what is really needed, regardless of what 1's state in life is Married state. Celibate state. Everyone needs to learn the virtue of chastity. You asked if I knew of any books or resources that could frame this for you in a in a healthy way to prepare you for what you described as the lonely road

ahead. Dear brother, I, I, I hear that cry of your heart. I, I sense that, that ache. You know, we, we get accustomed to the marital embrace. We grow accustomed to the closeness of the marriage bed. And that's a beautiful thing to grow accustomed to, which makes the loss of it a profound loss. To use that word again, Wendy, if you were to die, would I feel that loss?

Absolutely. But I would, I would also hope and I have some experience even in the course of married life where we've had extended times of, of abstinence. I have some foundation for believing that there is a an inner disposition that grows as we grow in chastity that would that would make the loss of the marriage bed. Yes, a loss, but not a travesty, not a devastation.

It would be certainly a a sadness because something beautiful and precious and good is no longer reality of of my life. If you were to die, or if we were to have health concerns or whatever, we could no longer engage in the marital act, whatever the case might be. There would be a sadness, a loss, but not a devastation because of that training of the heart. Not that I've done it perfectly. I got all kinds of struggles. Please don't hear me think, thinking that I got it all together. I don't. But there's been a training of my heart towards that ultimate

reality. That's where I have trained my heart to go. That's where I have placed my hope. And when our hope is placed in that which truly fulfills our hope, we grow in chastity. Even Saint John says that in one of his letters. It is that hope of that ultimate fulfillment in the marriage of the Lamb, that that hope is what makes us pure because it's directing our passions towards what we really desire. And no one is as free as the person who desires what he

really desires. So my dear brother, this sad loss, this tragic, it is tragic that your wife left you. That tragic loss is an opportunity to grow in a virtue that we're all called to grow in regardless of our state in life. And that is the virtue of chastity lived in hope, redirecting our hunger, our yearning towards that which really satisfies hope is I'll just quote the Catechism here. This is more paraphrase. I don't probably don't remember

it word for word, but this is the what the Catechism says about hope. Hope is the virtue that places all desire for happiness in heaven. Hope is the virtue that enables us to to trust that the deepest yearning and desires of our hearts will be fulfilled. And in my temptations against chastity, this is a scripture I turn to again and again and again. I treasure your promises in my heart, O Lord, lest I sin

against you. There is a banquet that will satisfy my hunger. There is a union that will satisfy the cry of Eros in my heart. It doesn't come in this life, but this life is a blip on the radar screen of eternity. And that eternal union, that eternal ecstasy, that eternal bliss, that eternal satisfaction is real. That is God's promise to each and everyone of us. Let us treasure His promise in

our hearts. Because if we don't, we're going to take our hunger elsewhere and sin against him. That's what sin is, misdirected desire. I still haven't answered the question. Do I know of any resources that can help you on this journey ahead, my brother? Yes. Every book I've ever written, I. Was thinking that especially Fill These Hearts was really coming to me. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I would start there. If you haven't read any of my works, my brother, any of my books I've written, I don't know 17 or 18 of them over the years,

begin with Fill These Hearts. It's all about the cry of Eros and what it means to learn how to direct that cry of Eros in the right direction. And then I would suggest perhaps my latest book, which is called Eating the Sunrise, Meditations on the liturgy and our hunger for beauty. The liturgy is where we consummate the marriage. Eating the sunrise is a metaphor for what happens in the Eucharist because Scripture says the sun comes forth like a

bridegroom from his chamber, and nothing on earth is concealed from his burning heat, from that burning love. The Eucharist is is the marriage of Christ in the Church. This is where we can go with all of our hunger, with all of our thirst, with all of our arrows. And if that sounds strange, it's 'cause we're wearing the wrong glasses. This is why the enemy goes after the erotic realm, to pervert, twist and distort it so we can no longer see it.

As a sign of the Holy Communion of Christ in the church. And that book, Eating the Sunrise will help you on the journey of untwisting all of that. To see the world, to see erotic desire, to see heaven, to see earth, to see our journey there. Not just as a long and lonely Rd. but as truly a a hope being fulfilled. A hope being fulfilled. Yeah, I, I sense that this

listener and many of our listeners, I know I once met a, a listener who was a divorced woman who said, you know, I wish you spoke more on your podcast to people who are in my situation. So I, I can picture her and I, I hope she's listening right now as well, that there is such, such a grief over the story of your life taking such a turn as

this. You know, as the, in the case of this questioner, you know, the, the abandonment of the marriage by his wife. I know people are in various, various different circumstances, all of which include, as he said, a lonely Rd. You know, there is that. And, and I think for our listener who asked this question, depending on how recently this all happened, there's a lot going on. There's a whole just shock and

sorrow and I would think probably sometimes racing thoughts, you know, that go along with that. And so I just even as we have many thoughts to share with you, just want to entrust you to a very peaceful and safe place. If you can just imagine yourself embraced by the Lord at this time and and kind of rest there and and allow the next steps in

your life to flow from that resting on the Lord's heart. I just want to encourage you that that you are kind of with the Lord charting a new path in your life and it will include absolutely the gift of yourself and to find the ways the Lord is calling you to make a gift of yourself is is another way to say some of what Christopher was saying. And I think as you see the the hints of those desires to be a

gift in various ways. I think that will be a beautiful consolation and source of redirection for you. I was even thinking, as I recommended, fill these hearts as a book to read, like write in that book, write every section that you read, write down some way that it can apply to you right now or that you could imagine it could apply to you in the future. So that you're almost entering into that conversation with what's there in order to really

make it personal to your story. Because I think you've you've lost a person in your story. And so the story needs to be take this new direction and it's it's with the Lord, with Jesus as a real person close to your heart to speak to you through a lot of different sources. But I think this would be a very good one what Christopher's recommending. Just two more thoughts. I'm gonna ask our producer Juan

to put a link in the show notes to a video from our YouTube channel that it's one of our most popular videos about turning erotic desire into prayer, into a longing for God. That's what prayer is. Pope Benedict the 16th says prayer is nothing other than becoming a longing for God. And then there was one more book I thought I'd recommend. I just read this within the last year and I found it very, very

good. It's by Bishop Eric Varden VARDEN, and the title is Chastity, Reconciliation of the Senses. Very, very insightful. Again, what is needed here in all of our lives is the virtue of chastity, and I think he does a great job unpacking what that means. We'll have a link to that also in the show notes. That's great. Our next question is from a listener named William. Hi, William. Hi Christopher and Wendy, thank

you for this incredible life changing work that you do. It inspires me to live more fully, to aim, to appreciate the goodness of God's creation more and more, to try to listen to and learn the ways He speaks to my heart, to strive for a Sacramento worldview. That's awesome. That's why we do what we do, William. For you, brother. I came late to the game and binge listen to episodes. When I do I listen on two times speed. Oh. How do we sound? And sometimes when I hear your

normal voices, it shocks me. I kind of like how they sound speed up. And Christopher sounds even more excited about the things he gets excited about. What I'm going to do, I'm going to talk very slowly so that when William is playing in double, that's getting a little too long, a little too annoying. Let me continue.

OK, my question has to do with exercises that are done with the main goal of altering one's appearance to more closely match what the culture holds as attractive. Some of these exercises have additional benefits like increased strength, endurance, and improved health in general, so I can see how they can be justified, but some seem to be done solely for looks, like jaw and face exercises I've heard of. We all want to have healthy

cheek muscles. I wonder if doing these exercises is all together vain and a sort of buying into the lies of the world that says you need to look a certain way and not not being grateful for the way we were created and look naturally. Or if there can be some good in wanting to appear more attractive in these ways. Especially if it was like a return to the way we were supposed to look. Some people say our faces have become lazy from soft foods. Orbit was for a spouse or

something. But I do see how it could be like a comparison to others and a wishing we had something we don't. So I'd like your input. William, I think you got your finger on, on pretty much the whole spectrum of issues that are involved in trying to answer this question. And I, I think I, I am not going to give an absolute statement that exercising your cheek muscles is, I made a little bit of a joke about it.

Like I, I don't even think I've ever even heard of that. But I am not going to make an absolute statement that exercising your cheek muscles is, is always and in every case motivated by vanity. But I think it's pretty safe to say it probably is in most cases. And it's buying into a a vision of the human person that is based on lies, lies that come from hell.

Now, lies that come from hell usually have some element of truth in there. That's how we get hooked, right? There's a desire for, there's a desire to be beautiful. There's a desire to be attractive. There's a desire to be desired, and those desires to be loved, beautiful, attractive, in and of themselves can become something into the those desires can be integrated with a healthy and

holy humanity. But to have those desires become integrated with a healthy and a holy humanity, they have to be purified. And to be purified, they have to be crucified. And as we allow those desires in our hearts to be purified and crucified, we're going to find that wow, we have been formed and shaped by a culture that is just riddled with perversion and lies.

Lies that have one intent to rob us of our true identity and to rob us of what true Love Actually is. This desire for beauty, physical perfection. We need to look at it honestly and get to the truth of it. And I'm going to turn surprise, surprise, going to turn to Saint John Paul the second for this. He talks about an experience in a in a retreat that he gave in 1962, a retreat that we actually

have translated into English with the Vatican's permission and published for the first time in English. The retreat is called God is Beauty. He says in that retreat that when he was a young priest, he was studying in Rome and he went to the Diocletian Baths in Rome and there were housed all of these ancient Greek sculptures of the naked human body. And rather than just running away and considering it an occasion of sin, he said, I, I

took great pains and I made an immense effort to try to understand why the human heart is always pursuing idealized images of beauty in the human body. Right? The, the Greeks didn't have Photoshop as we do today, but they did have very skilled sculptors. And every culture known to man in its own way is in pursuit of this idealized beauty in the

human body. Why? He says it two or three times. I took great pains. It was a laborious day. It took such a great effort. Why? Why does it take such a great effort? Because we have to face all of those impurities in our hearts to get to the truth. We have to expose the junk in our hearts. We have to let our arteries be cleansed, and that takes great labor. That takes great pain and effort

at cooperation with a very painful grace. That's what purification is, a cooperation, a free and willing cooperation with a very painful grace. And he says in cooperating with that grace and going through those laborers, he said I came to understand the gospel anew and I came to understand the gospel better. Pause right there. Pause right there. How instructive that is for us from a great St. to say in in

wanting to get to the bottom of this pursuit of perfect beauty in the human body. It took great pain, but as I embrace that pain, I came out the other side. I came to understand. He doesn't say sin anew. He says. I came to understand the gospel anew. I came to understand the gospel better, he says. I came to understand that this quest for absolute perfect beauty in the human body is actually a desire for the incarnation, because what does

the gospel hold out to us? The God who is perfect beauty has been manifested in the flesh. God sent his Son a male child born of a woman. It is always male and female together, revealing this great mystery of a perfect beauty that comes from heaven and is granted to us on earth. When we focus in on merely

physical perfection, we have a disintegrated understanding of beauty, true beauty, true beauty. John Paul the Second says, is to participate in divine beauty. And there's a name for a human being who truly participates in divine beauty. There's a name for a human being who I hear I'm quoting Pope Benedict the 16th, who has opened his or her heart so deeply to God's truth and beauty

that that person becomes God's truth and beauty. And the name for that kind of human being is a St. Now take Mother Teresa. If you have eyes to see, little old, hunched over, Raisin faced Mother Teresa is profoundly beautiful. If you can't see it, you're

blind. Lord, open our eyes. We look, but we do not see. Now Mother Teresa's hunched over, wrinkled body is was headed for the grave. And now it's in the grave. But it's destined for glory. It's destined for glory. The body will follow the body if we allow the natural processes of death. Returning to hummus, humiliation, returning to dust. We must, we must embrace the humiliation of the body to

experience the glorification of the body. The desire to have a glorious body is not itself the problem. The desire is. When we're pursuing all these diet fads and exercises to try to glorify our own bodies, that's the problem. We don't need to glorify our own bodies if we trust and believe that God wants to grant us a glorified body, right? If I glorify myself, what does Jesus say, Wendy? If I glorify myself, my glory

means nothing. Nothing. But I don't need to glorify myself if I open to the gift that God wants to give me, which is precisely A glorified body. How do we get that glorified body? Not by trying to maintain youth when you're 50 and 60 and 70. Not by trying to, you know, look like you're 25 when you're 85, but by accepting the humiliation that we die and return to dust in this fallen world. That humiliation turns into

glorification. Don't try to glorify yourself. Seek the glory the Lord wants to give you. And I think you'll find the proper, balanced perspective on beauty. Beauty of body and soul. Integral beauty. Beauty of the human person, male and female, as God has created him and her to be. We have to suffer and endure that in the fallen world. We lose that, that beauty. We have lost that beauty. But the gift of redemption, the gift of the gospel, is that

perfect beauty has been manifested in the human body, and that promise is ours as well. That's the good news of the gospel. I love how Williams said in his opening paragraph, before he got into the speed of our voices, he he said he's striving to learn the ways that God speaks to his heart. Yes, that's beautiful. And I think some of what he shared in the, the kind of pondering that looking at

different sides of this issue and, and just like noticing things that are off is, is part of that learning to, to listen to and to hear the Lord speaking in his heart. And I think as you, you know, if you start to notice those things and ask questions about them, you start to recognize like the stuff that's, that's under the surface, like, and the, the assumptions in the culture of sort of this, this pressure to

appear a certain way and this anxiety. And the, I've just noticed it. It feels to me like it has taken on a heightened level in recent years. And I kind of in my mind, I, I'm not watching these type of content producers on YouTube or Tiktok or Instagram, but I feel like there is, there's a whole just feedback loop of just kind of getting constant advice about how to change your appearance

and how to prevent aging and how to get this certain look that is the current desired look. And, and it just kind of, it's kind of a constant exhausting message that is kind of hard to shut out once it's gotten into your, into your life somehow. Like to, to reset and just kind of ask like, why am I allowing this anxiety to build in me and this feeling of urgency to, to

take some action? What am I trying to accomplish or what am I trying to prevent? What is what is really the motivation here, you know, and, and the recognition that like, what I really want is to be loved for who I am inside. And if I look different physically from other people, that can help to reveal my interior uniqueness. The more I look exactly like some outward standard that the

culture's promoting, the more likely that that deep inner place is lonely because it doesn't feel loved. You feel appreciated for things that you know are repeatable 'cause you're like other people. And we want to feel loved for what's unrepeatable, what's unique about us. And I think our bodies do reflect our stories. And we've talked about that before in our on our podcast

that like the actual physical expression of us, our bodily shape and you know, our skin and our hair and our all kinds of things about us will change over time according to the life that we lead. And we don't have to be afraid of that. Like, we don't have to be afraid that our bodies are telling the story of our lives, whether it

shows things that we regret or things that we are grateful for, that we gave ourselves to for purpose, for a good purpose. Like that's all fine. Like, let our bodies reveal us. Yeah, that's good. 'Cause we're lovable. We are. And I think, yeah, we've just kind of gotten caught up in such a an anxious, anxious place that doesn't have that peaceful foundation of God made me to be

unique and I am lovable. And he wants me to focus on that love and what it inspires me to do in this world. Like the the evil 1 loves distracting us from that because he knows what a light we have to shine in this world. So let's not focus on like responding to the love of the Lord. Let's focus on, you know, that's what the evil 1 is whispering deep down, you know, So I, I really think there's, there's profound growth that can come

from the very type of thing that William is noticing. And just as Christopher said earlier, this is not permission to judge everybody who's exercising. You know, we don't know everybody's stories, but it is good to let it sink into our own hearts and let the Lord ask us deep questions about what we're living for. Yeah, exercise is good, right? We need to take care of our bodies as well. The question becomes, what is my motivation if my motivation is vanity?

If my motivation is I think I'm not lovable unless I look a certain way, that that is not a worthy motivation. Lord, Lord, we expose these lies in our hearts. We expose these these very vulnerable places to you where we so desperately want to be loved and we've believed a lie that we're not lovable as we are. And so we think we have to shape ourselves into something that we're not. And yet, even if we establish

that new shape, we're still haunted by the lie that I'm only loved because of XY and Z. That's a conditional love. Lord, show us your unconditional love. Open our hearts to it so that we can take it in, so that it can inform how we accept and receive ourselves and accept and receive others. Dear God, this is what it means to love as you love. Listen, and this is your

commandment. Love one another as I have loved you. Teach us what that love is. Lord. Yes, Lord, we ask this in your name. Amen. Amen. If you heard anything today that blessed you and you know somebody who might be blessed by it, please share this episode. That's how we expand our listenership. We would be very grateful to you. We are lifting up the church in this very interesting time. Again, it's kind of weird that

people listening to this probably know who the Pope is. I wish they could tell us. God bless you. Everybody know it in your bones. You are a gift. Become what you are. Ask Christopher W. It's brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted

counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode