Enduring gossip of a former partner’s promiscuity, Losing physical affection after enforcing a strict kissing boundary, and Shifting from same-sex desires to fantasies. | ACW385
Questions answered this episode: In my previous relationship, we were trying to abstain from sex. I knew he was watching porn and working on that too. A week after breaking up, he started sleeping with someone else and since has been sleeping with many people. Word that I don't care to hear spreads quickly in a small town. I'm trying to identify the lie from the enemy in this. Right now, I just know that it hurts very deeply. I'm also trying to find the truth in all this pain. My boyfriend and I have been dating for three months. Early on, we discussed physical boundaries. I shared that kissing with the intention of increasing arousal crosses a line for me, while he felt anything short of sex was acceptable. A few times I've pulled away because the kissing becomes too arousing. This causes him to shut down and get hurt, feeling he has done something wrong. Now, his response is to show barely any physical affection. How can I navigate this in a way that honors our boundaries without hurting him or falling into lust? I'm a 27-year-old man who has struggled with same-sex attraction my entire life. In recent years, I've gained control over my desires through inner healing, dedicating time to embracing my masculine identity and building good male friendships. Listening to your podcast, I realized navigating my disoriented attractions is not about repressing my eros out of shame, but asking God for more - that He might help me see the true beauty in all things, even women. I sometimes entertain fantasies of women, seeking companionship and human connection. I enjoy these because they seem more ordered than my desires for the same sex. I'm not sure if this is what it means to expand my eros. Resources: TOB I: Head & Heart Immersion Course July 14-19, 2026 Course Schedule Good News About Sex & Marriage Love & Responsibility YouTube Series with Matt Fradd Sexual Needs Into Prayer YouTube Video Fill These Hearts THEOLOGY OF THE BODY FOR BEGINNERS - UPDATED, REVISED & EXPANDED 2018 (PAPERBACK) List of trusted counselors & psychologists John Paul II Healing Center Events Desert Stream Ministries Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? Join our Patron Community! --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 List of trusted counselors & psychologists *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Hey, everybody. Thank you for tuning in. Yeah, we're happy you're with us. Absolutely. And hey, Wendy, I'm happy you're with me. Thank you. Same here. We wanted to share a little interesting thing going on at our local parish before.
Hang on, I got to kill this fly I. Got him. Oh. That was. Yeah. I think we should just keep that on the podcast. No need to edit that one. People need to know that I can record a podcast and swat a family at the same time. That was a big honking fly. Yeah. OK. Tell people what's going on at our parish, Wendy. Yeah, well we recently were assigned a new pastor at our parish and our new pastor is
just has an amazing story in history, having been first raised Jewish, then became Christian in high school, then became a Protestant pastor. Then an Anglican priest. Then an Anglican priest, then a Catholic. Nine kids, then a Catholic, then he come becomes Catholic, then he becomes a Catholic priest. So if you don't know about this, there's this beautiful gesture that the Catholic Church makes towards certain clergy from certain denominations when they
become Catholic, that they can discern whether they're called the priesthood as a married man, which is a beautiful, gracious extension of the church's open arms and heart. And I think it's beautiful. And so we are, we are now a Roman Catholic parish. I say Roman with emphasis there because there are Byzantine Catholic priests who are married priests of the Eastern Rite. But it's, it's rare that there would be a Roman Catholic priest who's married.
This is not part of the ordinariate that Pope Benedict the 16th allowed Anglican priests who convert and want to be in union with Rome. They can be ordained Catholic priests, but they remain Proclaimers and they say the liturgy in the Anglican according to the Anglican Book of of Prayer. No, this is not that. This is a Roman Catholic priest who's married and has nine kids and he's our pastor, which is very interesting and unusual and
I think kind of exciting because of just, I just, it's, it speaks, as I said, of the graciousness of our mother, the Church, and it speaks of her deep desire to build bridges and heal wounds of division. And, and we're a small country parish and we feel very honored and blessed to have this beautiful priest who's been around the block. He, he was in jail. In fact, the first thing, the reason he was in jail, I just threw that out and then I was
about to move on. He was in jail because of pro-life work as a Protestant pastor. And the Protestant service that was offered in prison was run by someone who was pro abortion and didn't want this protest, other Protestant pastor to come to his service because they didn't want to. He didn't want to deal with the conflict of having some pro lifer coming to his Protestant service. So the Catholic priest said you can come to Catholic Mass. And that was his first exposure
to the Mass. And having been raised a Jew, he recognized that this Catholic liturgy is the fulfillment of Old Testament worship. And that was a real seed that got planted that eventually grew and let him into the church. Yeah, he does have a very beautiful story just of kind of continually saying yes to the spirits lead in difficult ways. And yet he's very joyful and love filled and it's really
quite a witness just to be with him, you know, which is which is wonderful. And and, you know, kind of his amazingly unusual story just kind of stirs the heart a little bit to say, like, wow, Lord, you really do care about us and lead us step by step in ways that we maybe don't understand all the time. So it's really beautiful. And for those out there who might be singing, well, how does this work as a Catholic priest who's married, why can't all
priests be married? And, well, this is maybe longer than I have time to explain in any great detail, but the history of the Church is very interesting in this regard. For the first thousand years of Church history, they were married priests both in the East and the West. About 1000 years in, a little less than that, the Catholic Church of the West started a discipline and that's the proper word for it, a discipline to choose her priests from among
those men who have chosen A celibate life. And that wording is very important. Celibacy is has always been a calling in the church, both in the East and the West. It's only been more strictly linked with priesthood in the West for the last 1000 years. So it is a discipline. It is not some dogmatic requirement of priesthood. The married priests of the Eastern Church, they've always had this tradition. They are just as Catholic as we are Catholic and East and West.
And the Catechism in its wording here says this. And the, the word, the wording here is very important. It says priests of the Latin Rite, That's the Catholic Church of the West, the Roman Catholic Church. Priests of the Latin Rite are normally chosen from among those men who have discerned A celibate vocation, normally chosen from among those men who have discerned A celibate vocation. So that's the language of the Catechism and look more into it if it's of interest to you.
It's, it's a very illuminating topic to understand that the vocations in the Catholic Church, if you're a man discerning your vocation, it's not should I be married or should I be a priest? First and foremost, It's should I be married or should I be celibate? And if you are a Roman Catholic, you have a further discernment as a celibate, should I live my celibacy as a priest? If you're an Eastern Catholic, you have the question, should I be married or should I be celibate as well?
But you could discern I'm called to a priest either way, called to be a priest either way. So anyway, I, I love that history. I love that theology. I love the the understanding of it all. I'm just plopping it out there for anybody else who might be interested in it as well. Much more could be said. You could write a doctoral dissertation on it, but we don't have time for that, so moving right along. You could write you could write a doctoral dissertation on it is the is a kind of a sentence that you throw out there sometimes when things have a lot more to be. Said a lot more to be said and we don't have time to say it.
Right, exactly. Well, do we have time to say what's going on with the TOB Institute? Any updates? We are are approaching our summer courses. I've been talking about them for many weeks now, but it is it is time to sign up. There are some people out there on the fence it there's still some spots for TOB One in June, I'll be teaching that June 14th to the 19th. Then there is The Way of Beauty with Bill Donaghy the second week of July. And then there is the first week of August, I'll be teaching the
TOB 2 course. So you have to have taken TOB 1 to come to TOB 2. If you cannot make TOB One in June, but you want to come to TOB 2 in August, you can take TOB One online. You can check all that out in the link in the show notes. And please know if you are in need of scholarship funds, you can apply. We never want money to get in the way. If you are able to contribute to our scholarship fund, you can also find a link for our our Patron support in the show
notes. Awesome. And I just like to mention that those who do come to in person courses here in Pennsylvania, I would love to have you just if you see me there, probably at a meal, please come and introduce yourself. Tell me that you're you listen to the podcast. I love meeting our listeners. All right, you ready for a question from a patron? I'm ready. Let's do it. OK, this is from an anonymous patron. In my previous relationship we were trying to abstain from sex.
I knew he was watching porn and working on that too. A week after breaking up he started sleeping with someone else, Mercy, and since has been sleeping with many people. Word that I don't care to hear spreads quickly in a small town. I'm trying to identify the lie from the enemy in this right now. I just know that it hurts very deeply. I'm also trying to find the
truth in all this pain. Thank you for all that you do. Oh, bless you, bless you. That is so painful. Well, the lie from the enemy goes very deep here and it attacks at the level of our identity, our identity as persons. If you're familiar, anyone out there listening, if you're familiar with our podcast,
you've heard us use these words many, many times because it takes us to the essence of personhood. And so often questions we are dealing with, we have to answer them by going to the essence of personhood. And those words are the person is the kind of being who is indispensable, irreplaceable, and unrepeatable and. Sexual intimacy, if it is truly to be an affirmation of the
dignity of the person it is meant to be, in order to correspond with our dignity as persons, we are meant to be saying in sexual intimacy, you're indispensable. I will never dispense with you. I will never throw you away. You are irreplaceable. I will never replace you with someone else. You are unrepeatable, that you are the only you there ever was. And I bless and affirm your
utter uniqueness, your unrepeatability. You reveal a beam of God's glory in this world that no one else reveals. That's what sexual intimacy is meant to express, and it hurts so painfully when sexual intimacy doesn't express that. There was a dating relationship you had. There was a desire to honor the meaning of sex, so you didn't engage in it.
However, this guy's looking at porn, so he is aiming his Eros. He's allowing his body to be stirred by images of people who are not you. And so he's saying you're dispensable, you're replaceable, you're repeatable, and that hurts and then you break up and that hurts because you were discerning. Should I be with this person? The answer to this is very clear. No, you should not be with this person. This person is not in a place to be able to live out what marital
love calls us to. He's not in a place, and he has shown that abundantly clearly by sleeping around with all these other people. And to each of these women, he's saying you're dispensable, you're replaceable, you're repeatable. And I just have an itch that I need to scratch and you're a good opportunity to scratch it. So I will use you. And while you scratch the itch, I'll take advantage of that. But as soon as I'm not so interested anymore, I'll throw you away and I'll replace you with somebody else. This is terribly, terribly,
terribly damaging to the human heart. And I just think all of your nerve endings are, are screaming that that you, you feel used, dispensed with, treated as something rather than as someone. So that's the lie. The underlying lie is that you are something rather than someone. But the pain that you are in demonstrates that you don't
believe that lie. That lie might have gotten in there and is is is gnawing at you, but the pain is evidence that you know at that level of your pain. You are in pain because you know you are indispensable, irreplaceable, and unrepeatable. Thanks be to God. Right, I'm thinking of an old 80s song for my teenage years. I'm. I'm going to harden my heart. I'm going to swallow my tears. No, don't do that.
Don't do that. That's a defense mechanism. You want to give yourself permission to feel your pain because it it re roots you in those deep truths. It would be very concerning if you didn't feel the pain, if you would harden your heart and swallow your tears, that that would be damaging to your personhood. It's understandable that we want to numb ourselves to pain
because pain is painful. How about that for Profound thought pain is painful. Profound Thoughts by Christopher W Pain is so painful we want it to end. And yet there's so much we can learn about ourselves, about God's tender mercies, about his closeness to us, God's closeness to us, about the mystery of the cross. Learning about the mystery of the cross is intimacy with Jesus
and when I say learning about it, I'm not just talking some academic exercise, I'm I mean lived experience, learning the way of the cross through lived experience. This is intimacy with Jesus. My dear sister, you are in profound intimacy with Jesus in the very same measure that you are feeling treated as something by this other man. By this man you are being loved as someone by Jesus Christ, I
said in same measure. But I I want to correct what I said, because the love that you receive from Jesus Christ is infinitely beyond any measure of our pain and suffering. There is a. Correspondence here that I'm trying to draw out that in as much as you are feeling rejected and feeling that pain of rejection, a feeling that pain of being treated as dispensable, replaceable and repeatable. In that very pain Jesus is in union with you, is one with you
affirming the truth that you are indispensable, irreplaceable and unrepeatable. And that's how that pain, that's why you don't want to swallow the tears. That's why you don't want to harden your heart. You want to keep it raw in the sense of open in your pain to your true bridegroom, Jesus Christ. The marriage of Christ in the church is consummated on a bed of suffering. It's consummated on the marriage bed of the cross. That's Saint Augustine's
expression and in that consummation there is a, a, a redemption in our sufferings. We speak as Catholics often as of we speak as Catholics of redemptive suffering. This is it. This is redemptive suffering when it is opened to Jesus and you find yourself one with the Bridegroom. There was another question though, in the in the in what she had written that I I may not have yet answered. No, I think you. You did OK. Yeah, Yeah.
I'm I keeping reminded of an experience I had, so I'll just share it. It might be helpful to this questioner or to other listeners where it had been actually a couple years maybe maybe like 3 years since I had broken up with a boyfriend that at the time I had just been in pain and kind of confused by. Yeah, the experience, like I
just didn't know why I had gone through it. And it was kind of stored inside me as this painful place in my heart. And I was participating in kind of a study group where we were doing a prayer assignment of looking at significant experiences in our lives. I was, I think 22 at the time. And so one of the significant
experiences was breaking up with this guy. And I remember feeling like, Lord, I don't really want to pray about that. I don't really want to think about it, but just hurts. And and yet it just seemed like the Lord was calling me there to to look at it more deeply. And so I kind of said yes to his invitation. Yes, OK, let's look at it together. Show me what was happening. What happened there was my prayer and I, I really literally had this image of a construction
crane like with one of those sort of, it can, it looks like sort of a claw at the end that can pick something up of me being just picked up by the Lord. But it, the image was of this crane just lifted up out of that relationship and removed and put somewhere else. And even though there was so much pain that I had to go through, like just that image, it just gave me tremendous
peace, like to see the Lord's hand was in my life, even if it didn't feel comforting at all at the time. It took, it took time and grieving and questioning and praying before I could really see and receive like his tremendous love and care for me that he would have taken me out of that relationship that what wasn't where He wanted me, you know? And yeah, went by messy means
of, you know, human relationships that cause pain. But in reflecting back on it. The gratitude I finally felt for just his action in my life. And I, I, I feel that in this questioner like it is, it is painful for all the reasons that Christopher said and probably other ones that are particular to your actual relationship with this person. You know, there are, there's some specific things that of course no one else knows but you that are adding to the pain.
But I don't know, I just want to encourage you that it can take time and can take suffering as just pressing in and allowing that suffering with a certain trust. OK, Lord, you have to know what you're doing in my life, in His life, and in these other people's lives. You have to know what you're doing 'cause this is hurting a lot right now. And that that trusting yourself to Him is is going to bear great fruit.
And that pain that I was Speaking of in union with Jesus is also powerful intercession for him. If you're willing to go there to offer your pain, as intercession for him and as forgiveness, that's the only way we can heal. He's doing this because he's in serious pain. This man does not know who he is, and he does not know how to love. And human life is miserable
unless we learn how to love. So this guy is in misery, and you know a taste of that misery because he dumped it on you and you feel it. And you can offer that misery in union with Jesus as intercession for him. And just saying, Lord Ioffer the pain he caused me as intercession for him. And I ask you to fill my heart with your mercy and compassion toward Him. Let him know your mercy and your compassion. Let him know your forgiveness, Lord, and just release him.
Release him to the Lord and go on with your life. He's, he's not, he's not marriageable material at this point. Bless you, dear sister. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. My boyfriend and I have been dating for three months and have known each other for four. Early on, we discussed physical boundaries. I shared that kissing with the intention of increasing arousal crosses crosses a line for me.
Well, he felt that anything short of sex was acceptable. I can tell he wants to uphold my boundaries, but a few times I've pulled away because the kissing becomes too arousing for me. This causes him to shut down and get hurt, not necessarily out of rejection, but because he feels that he has done something wrong. I've tried to explain that I'm pulling away to honor his dignity and that I'm not upset,
but it still hurts him. I'm very attracted to him and I'm easily aroused by him. Now his response is to show barely any physical affection because he says he becomes aroused just sitting next to me at times. How can I navigate this in a way that honors our boundaries without hurting him or falling into lust? Bless you, bless you. Oh, life is hard. Learning how to love is hard. It ain't easy.
What is required in this situation, as in all situations? Where we're learning how to love is self mastery, and what is lacking here is self mastery. The frustrate I can, I can just feel it, like I can taste it. The frustration of his experiencing arousal and I don't know what to do with this. How do I? How do I? Direct this in a way that honors this woman I'm dating and I want
to honor her boundaries, but I don't have the same boundaries. And by the way, that's a concern. That is a concern that he doesn't he's, he's willing to honor your boundaries. It sounds like for the most part, although he's pushing the limit here. That's OK, That's a good sign. But the fact that you had to convince him of these boundaries or he doesn't share them or he thinks so long as we don't have sex, what does that mean? I I. There, there's, there's need.
There's need for a much deeper conversion in his heart, much deeper, much deeper. And what I would urge you to do, beg you to do, invite you to do, encourage you to do. Please, please may. If you like to read, you can go to Good News about Sex and Marriage, my Q&A book. If you like to watch, you could watch together the series that Matt Fradd and I did on love and responsibility.
We'll put those links in the show notes just to get the conversation going as to why the Church's teaching is not just some oppressive list of rules to follow, but is truly the path to freedom. The Catechism says this. I'm paraphrasing from memory. It might not be a word for word report, but it's very close to this. Self mastery is a long and exacting work. One can never say I've accomplished it. We must take it up ever again at each stage of life, and then it
says something to this effect that either the human person learns to be. Master of his own passions and desires. Or he is dominated by them and never experiences happiness, never experiences peace. The peace that is lacking, the reason he gets so upset, the reason it causes pain. Is because he is not master of his desires, they get kicked. In he doesn't know how to direct
them in a healthy, holy way. The engine is running. The engine is revving. It seeks satisfaction and he's he's on the road to using you for his own pleasure because he's not master of his desires. For you to pull back and say, no, we're not going to go there is entirely appropriate for him then to shut down and be hurt. And you know, I don't know if there's any blame that you feel getting tossed at you. I don't want to read too much into the situation, but men in
that situation when they're not master of themselves, when they when they're following their disordered passions and they're letting their passions dominate them and then a woman puts on the brakes. The resentment that follows is usually full of blame like, well, if you just didn't have these boundaries or if whatever, you know, fill in the blank this, this is not a healthy situation. I wouldn't say that it's not it. I wouldn't say it's incapable of
becoming healthy. It's just that you're in a period of particular struggle and he needs particular growth. Good news about sex and marriage will be a great place to start. Read it together. And if he's not coming to see the beauty of the church's teaching and wanting to live it with his whole heart, he's not a man you want to pursue a relationship with. If reading is not your thing and you're you're rather watch something together, please watch
this series of videos that Matt Fred and I did on love and responsibility. If he's if he's not getting it or not wanting it or, you know, raising objections in an obstinate kind of way, all questions are fair game. Well, why did what about this and what about that? That's fine. But if he's in the end obstinately rejecting the church's teaching and vision, he's not someone you want to be with. It's not going to get easier. It's going to get worse. And it's not like once you get married, you don't have to worry
about these things. Now we're married and we can just follow our passions. No, no, no, no. Chastity in marriage is even harder in many respects than chastity before marriage. Now you're in the same bed with this person and there are times where you have to abstain because it's the fertile time and it's not appropriate to bring another child into the world. Or maybe one of you is sick and you'd you'd want to Make Love on a in a normal circumstance, but you have to abstain for any
number of reasons. Self mastery. Remember that quote from the Catechism? It's never achieved once and for all. We must take it up anew at every stage of life. You, you. If we have this idea that once we get married we don't need to be chased anymore, Or chastity until marriage, or self mastery until marriage, Or control yourself until marriage. We we don't know what love is. Love demands self mastery. Period.
It just does. If self mastery is not part of the equation, then we're just following a hormone or a passion we cannot control. If we are not in control of our passions, we will inevitably seek to control others to gratify our passions, in the analogy I often use. Here you've heard it before if you're if you're a regular listener of our podcast is a musical instrument. Think of a piano. If if in order to make beautiful
music on that piano, if you want to make beautiful music, you must learn self mastery, you must learn discipline. You must learn not just to bang on the keys and make meaningless noise. That's what lack of self mastery leads to, banging on a piano keyboard and making meaningless noise. And you are asking him, you are saying, I don't want to make meaningless noise, I want to make beautiful music. And he's struggling to gain the discipline required to make that beautiful music.
You haven't shared too much about your own situation. But I I don't want to just say it's only him who needs to learn how to make beautiful music. Because to make beautiful music it takes 2. It takes 2 who are disciplining their passions. And disciplining passion does not mean squashing passion, right? There's a huge difference between repression and redemption of our passions. We are not invited by the gospel just to squash our passions. JP 2 is so clear on this.
He says if that's our approach to chastity, that we push our desires and our emotions into the subconscious, well, they await an opportunity to explode, he says. This is not self mastery. Repression is not self mastery. Self mastery, JP 2 says, is our ability to direct our attractions, our desires, our emotions according to the true dignity of the person. To put our attractions, to put
our desires, to put our erotic stirrings at the service of the dignity of the person. Please, please, I beg of you. If if what I'm saying is like, oh that's interesting, never heard of that. How do I do that? Please, I beg of you, take up a study of John Paul's Theology of the body. That's what the whole theology of the body teaches us to do, teaches us how to love by gaining proper mastery and entering into the redemption of
our bodies, the redemption of our sexuality, the redemption of our erotic desires. Check out some of the videos I've done on YouTube about turning erotic desire into prayer. We'll put some links in the show notes for you to watch those videos. Please read Theology of the Body for Beginners if you haven't already. Good news about sex and marriage if you haven't already. Fill these hearts if you haven't already. There are so many resources out there to take people on this pilgrimage of learning how to be
master of themselves so that we can learn the freedom of love. Sexual freedom is not the freedom to indulge our compulsions, it is freedom from the compulsion to indulge so that I can become a true gift and make beautiful music. This is what the theology of the body is all about. Please take up a study of it and not just oh, we'll study it for the next 6 months. Make it your life's mission to learn, live and share this with others because it is the answer
to all of our. Crises and the Crisis of our times. All of our crises and love go back to this. I'm struck as I'm looking over the, the question again, just first of all, I, I sense I kind of kind of read between the lines a little bit and you could get it wrong. So I, I, I hope I'm not, but, you know, one of the things I'm just picking up on is there's sort of a knowledge of some of the, the concepts of, of the
positive of chastity, the chastity vision that is so in keeping with theology of the body and with just the teaching of the church in general, that of choosing the good of the other, choosing to speak the truth with our bodies, choosing to, yeah, respect that power that's there and not to kind of push each other into, you know, places of strong temptation that
just isn't loving. And so there's a lot of just the, the, the desire to really love. And one of the things she said was that she's she's pulling away to honor his dignity, she said. And she says, I'm not upset. And there's something really just like beautiful to me. I'm just feeling like the the steps that go from learning about something to putting it in
practice. Yeah, hard, hard stuff. It's, it is hard and it is understandable to get a little upset because we all enjoy positive exchanges that make us feel happy. And physical affection can be one of those positive exchanges that make us feel happy. And so it could be understandable to get upset when you feel like, oh, now this is not going to end positively
because I'm, I'm pulling away and I, I want to somehow keep it positive. But gosh, I can anticipate there's going to be some yeah, like disturbance between us as a result. And I'm so just proud of you, this woman, you know, listener who who says I'm not upset. Like there's a maturity there that is really good that. You picked up on that, Wendy. It's. Really beautiful to say. I'm willing.
I'm willing to communicate. Even though it kind of disturbs the scene a little bit. I'm willing to communicate where my boundary is and trust that you're learning and willing to learn. And we're in this journey together. And I'm not upset about that. Like that's so touching to my heart. Just to to read those words that you included there. And I was also interested in when she said, now his response is to show barely any physical affection because he says he
becomes aroused just sitting next to me. At times. I'm like pondering that part because on the one hand, that could be good. Like to just say, well, then let's have an opportunity to direct our interest in one another towards getting to know one another, to maybe expressing our the things that we like about each other with words or asking questions about each other or even doing an activity that we both enjoy.
Like there are different, like good things that could come from that. If the, if it is OK with both members of the couple just to say, hey, like we're just getting to know each other. This has only been a few months. Like it could be so tempting to be drawn to the comforting feeling of physical affection that kind of it can it can give us a little bit of an illusion of a security in the relationship that maybe we still need to work on the relationship
before and not live in that illusory place. So I don't know if his not showing affection feels like mean or cruel, but part of me says, well, like, hey, that's kind of neat. You know, what is the opportunity here to both grow? Read the books that Christopher is talking about? Like, what is what is God calling you to in this relationship? Maybe that's like the deepest question. Like sometimes when we get attracted to somebody and think
we'd like to start dating, we maybe don't have any vision beyond like, will I get this person's attention? Will he be interested in me? Will we start dating like that? That wondering part can be so occupying that once the relationship actually begins, there can be sort of no clear direction, like why are we in this relationship? So I feel like maybe in some of the grace going on here is first of all, beautiful graces in the woman asking the question that
she's felt confident to communicate our boundaries and to even say, I'm not upset. I just need you to know, like that's a beautiful grace. But there could also be further graces in just causing you to pause and say, like, Lord, I want to know what you want for us. And I don't want to fall into like a false security and safety and comfort that isn't really matching the real relationship
that exists between us. So I feel like in different ways, there's like beautiful opportunities coming to this couple. Wise words from Wendy W 4 WS 4 WS there. I just want to add this that taking that step back from expressing affection again, I want to make the distinction between repressing passion and crying out for the redemption of passion. If if pulling back from expressing affection is leading to it's bad, my desires are just evil.
I need to repress, repress, repress. It's all bad. It's all bad. It's all bad. That is dangerous. That is not the path. Pulling back from affection in a healthy way would be something like this. Lord, when I'm I'm just sitting next to her, my girlfriend of three months and. I find myself aroused. You made me this way. My body is designed to seek union. But I'm also fallen here and my passions can be disordered and can seek gratification in a
selfish way. Lord, integrate me. I. Cry out to you, I don't want to repress my passions. I ask you, Lord, please to redeem my passions, Redirect them. Help me to die in myself to what is selfish and help me to rise again in my passions so that my passions, and I'm here using language from JP 2 so that my passions are welded to the dignity of the person. So that my passions desire.
What I desire with such passion is not just gratification at somebody's expense. What I desire in and through my passions is to learn how to love, to lay down my life for this person. And right now what that requires of Maine is that I not indulge in these passions, but that I cry out to you. And I ask you, Jesus, in, in this temptation to indulge in my passions, in this temptation to treat this person whom I I want to love, but I'm tempted to treat her as an object for my selfish pleasure.
I give this twisted, lustful desire to you, Lord, and I ask you, please, by the power of your death and resurrection, to untwist in me what sin has twisted up so that I might come to experience sexual desire as you created it to be, as the desire to love freely, totally, faithfully, fruitfully, to lay down life that I might learn to love as you love Jesus. Some prayer along that regard, where Along those lines where we're not, we're not shutting our humanity down, but we are
opening it up to the Lord where we are fallen and in need of healing and we're letting Him do that work in us. This is the path to integration. This is the path to welding our attractions and desires to the dignity of the person, raising them to the level of the dignity of the person. That's the teaching of JP 2. That's the language of JP 2. It's really possible to live this. It ain't easy, just like learning how to play the piano and make beautiful music ain't easy, but it is so worth it.
So worth it. Keep going, it's worth it. I love that image. Passions welded to the dignity of the. Person, Yeah. That's a go. JP 2. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. I'm a 27 year old man who has struggled with same sex attraction my entire life. Bless your brother. In recent years, I've gained a sense of control over my desires, which came through significant inner healing.
Beautiful. I've dedicated much time to embracing my masculine identity and building good faith oriented male friendships. Awesome. When I started listening to your podcast, I realized that to navigate my disoriented attractions is not to repress my arrows, something I have always sought to do out of shame, but instead to ask God for more that that He might help me see the
true beauty in all things glory, even women. Glory. At this point in my journey, I sometimes entertain fantasies of women, Not always sexually explicit, though this does happen, but sometimes, just in desiring A deeper relationship, I seek companionship and human connection. And I enjoy entertaining these fantasies because they seem more ordered than my desires for the
same sex. I'm not sure if this is what it means to grow and expand my arrows. Bless you brother. Wow, you are on quite a journey and as you could tell from my exclamations there, there's something I think really beautiful going on in your heart. Yeah, I'm trying to parse out the questions because I'm, I'm just kind of marveling at God's grace and his response to God's grace.
Can you, can you, Wendy, parse out the questions for me like what he is? What's the specific thing that he's asking? Well, as he's looking to increase to pray for more arrows, he says he sometimes entertains fantasies of women. Not always sexually explicit, though this does happen. And he says he enjoys entertaining these fantasies because they seem more ordered than the desire for the same sex, and he's not sure if that's
what it means to grow and expand his Eros. Well, let's let's talk about expanding Eros and, and for those who may not be familiar with this idea, of course we're talking about the Greek word Eros Eros. And in English we have the word erotic. Tragically, in our culture, the word erotic has been confused with the pornographic. Eros and pornea are two Greek words very, very different words The.
Church adopts the language of Eros to speak about the passion in us, the yearning in us, the ache in us for everything that is true, good and beautiful. When Saint Paul says whatever is true, whatever is honorable, whatever is pure, whatever is holy, whatever is sacred, think on these things, that's Eros. That's Eros. That the the the yearning in us that is attracted to what is true, good, beautiful, pure,
honorable, holy, sacred, that's holy Eros. Pope Benedict the 16th says Eros is the holy passion in us that seeks union with God. That's what we're after. Ephesians chapter 5, verses 31 to 32, which John Paul the second describes as a kind of summa or compendium of everything God wants to tell us in the in the whole Bible. This is where we read that the union of man and woman in one flesh is a great mystery, a mega mysterion, and it refers to
Christ and the Church. That's holy Eros. How do we overcome bad arrows or or disordered arrows or lustful arrows? How do we overcome any evil with good? Right? We overcome bad arrows with good arrows, and plenty of it. The way you overcome darkness is not by yelling at the darkness or trying to repress the darkness. You overcome the darkness by turning on a light and getting
more and more light, letting letting that light become brighter and brighter and brighter to cast out all shadows, all all hint of darkness. The brighter the light, the less shadow, the less darkness. This is what our questioner is meaning when he says asking for more arrows, he's not saying give me more of the lustful stuff. He's saying give me holy arrows. Give me good arrows, because the only way to overcome bad arrows is with good arrows and plenty of it.
That is a a quote from Timothy Petitsus, an Eastern Orthodox priest and theologian whose whose work I have admired and I think is is quite good. Anyway, that's where I got that statement from. The question is for this man, he is finding himself as he as he's navigating these difficult water's not easy. He's asking the inviting the Lord into his heart saying Lord redirect my desires. He has taken the approach much of his life of repressing Eros
out of shame. As he said that is understandable that we do that, but it's not in the end going to heal us. We're, we're, if, if we are repressing this nuclear energy of our souls and our bodies, if we are trying to contain it in a, in a, in a damping down way, in an annihilating way and trying to erase it or annihilate it. It's impossible to erase or annihilate our passions in this sense.
What they must be is crucified. St. Paul says, I allow my sinful desires to be crucified. Why? So I don't feel any desire anymore. No, we carry the death of the Lord in our bodies. Saint Paul says why? So that the life of the Lord might also be manifested in our bodies, And the life of the Lord is the love of the Lord.
The love of the Lord is the life of the Lord. The life of the Lord is the love of the Lord. The love of the Lord is what led him to the cross. And Pope Benedict the 16th says, is there any more mad Eros than what led Christ the Bridegroom to give up his body for his bride on the cross? God's arrows is manifest for us on the cross, says Pope Benedict the 16th bank on that. Take that to the bank. God's arrows, holy arrows, mad
arrows, good passion that that led him to love us to the end, to the last to to lay down his life. That's what we're talking about. And that's what this beautiful questioner is, is after he's he's discovering that this is repression is not the approach. We talked about this in an earlier question. I'm glad we can build on it here. Repression is not the approach. Redemption is the approach. Now he's asking I'm I'm beginning to feel an erotic inclination in these.
He called them fantasies towards or about women. And he's saying it seems more ordered than other desires I've experienced in my life. And I'm going to agree with you, it's more ordered, but it's probably not fully ordered. Or I think we can say certainly not 'cause I mean, we're always on the pilgrimage, right? Nobody can say I am fully ordered in my erotic desires. Nobody can say that. We can say we're on the journey. And brother, you are certainly
on the journey and there are major graces unfolding here for you to rejoice in. And finding yourself inclined towards these fantasies, I want to say it this way, finding yourself inclined toward these fantasies is a positive step, But I would not go so far as to say, therefore, you should continue to indulge in these fantasies. I don't know how you understand fantasy, but as I understand fantasy, and as I took on fantasy in my teenage years when
the hormones were going berserk and I didn't know what to do with myself, fantasy became going into some alternate reality that I created in my imagination in order to arouse myself and indulge in disordered Eros. I don't let, let me put it this way, the redemption of fantasy. As I understand fantasy, it becomes imaginative prayer, right? That's the redemption of fantasy. Is imaginative prayer.
And brother, there is. A new Eve, her name is Mary and I'm just going to quote from John Paul the second here. He says every man must face the same fear that Joseph faced of bringing Mary into his home, taking Mary to himself. Joseph faced the fear that he had to overcome. This is the most beautiful woman God ever created. And JP 2 says this is a paraphrase, but it's it's very
close to what he says. I'm working on my memory here. He says something to the effect that perhaps you are chosen by God to speak to Mary and he speak to JP 2 is speaking to each of us as men here. Perhaps you are. And I'm going to speak this to you, my brother. I'm going to speak this to you. Perhaps you are being chosen by the Lord to speak to Mary about her true beauty as the most beautiful woman God ever created.
And if that is the case, if the Lord is inviting you to honour and cherish Mary's beauty as a woman, do not be afraid. The only thing we should fear in this circumstance, JP 2 says, is that we would appropriate her beauty for our own selfish pleasure, right? Fear that, yes, don't go there. But if you were being invited by the Lord to honor and behold Mary as the New Eve, as the fully redeemed woman, as the
most beautiful creature God has ever created, and to rejoice rightly in Mary's beauty. That my brother experiencing that kind of affirmation of Mary and a holy desire for Mary and an honoring of her beauty with a please hear me rightly here with a holy passion, with a holy desire that honors her status as
the most beautiful woman God ever created and learning how to honor her with your masculinity, with your masculine heart, with your holy Eros. Joseph had to go on that road. Ask Joseph to teach you what that means. That would be the sense in which what you've described as fantasy about women, that that delight you in some respect. That would be the redemption of that.
That would be the healing of that. It becomes imaginative, an imaginative experience in prayer where we behold with holy beholding, with holy desire, with a willingness for everything to be out in the light and exposed, where we are not appropriating Mary's beauty to ourselves, but we are honouring God within her. Right? Just maybe you could in an
imaginative prayer experience, place yourself in the presence of pregnant Mary, place yourself in the presence of pregnant Mary and say, Saint Joseph, teach me how to honour pregnant Mary. She is everything we desire. You could, you could read the Psalm. You could not just read it, but pray this Psalm. Pray this Psalm, brother, and pray it with an imaginative a prayer, and let the Holy Spirit guide your prayer. This would be the redemption of
all of what you're saying. It's right out of scripture. One thing I ask this alone. I seek to dwell in the House of the Lord all the days of my life, to contemplate the beauty of the Lord within His temple. All of that temple language is fulfilled in Mary because she is the dwelling place of the Lord. One thing I ask this alone. I seek to dwell in the House of the Lord, to contemplate the beauty of the Lord within His
temple. Enter into that brother, and you will discover. You know what you'll discover? You will discover the holy arrows for woman, for the temple, for the dwelling place of the Lord, for Mary, and you will find the holy arrows for Christ. Because one thing you ask this alone, you seek to behold the beauty of the Lord, that's Jesus within Mary. She's the temple. That's the redemption of of
masculinity and femininity, and that's the redemption of disordered attraction both to both to the masculine and to the feminine brother. Any twisted erotic inclination towards the masculine that gets untwisted and rightly directed. It's going to take you directly into a proper relationship with Jesus Christ and any arrows towards woman that is misdirected and disordered, that gets rightly directed and rightly ordered. It's going to take you into a
wholly appropriate, beautiful, sacred bond with Mary. That's how it works. Everything about our masculinity and femininity as human beings gets redeemed, and our attraction to both the masculine and the feminine gets redeemed in proper relationship with Jesus and Mary. This is how it works, brother. And if what I'm saying sounds crazy or scandalous or weird or I've never heard any of this, well, spend some time with the Saints. Spend some time with Louis du Montfort.
Spend some time with JP 2. Spend some some time with the Mystics and the fathers of the Church. Spend some time with those Mystic Saints who've written their commentaries on the Song of Songs and they understand that ultimately, this beautiful sacred erotic love poetry. Holy Eros in the Song of Songs, ultimately it's all about Jesus and Mary. That's the bride and that's the bridegroom. In the Song of Songs, it's virginal, it's mystical, but it's a holy Eros.
It's redeems everything in US. I'm going to use my line again. I could write a doctoral dissertation and I should to qualify everything in the right way so that there's I'm not misunderstanding, but you, you have to trust me. This, there is a holy path here, a sacred, sacred path here, brother, you're on it. Keep going. I'll quote here from Pope Benedict the 16th. He says when the Christian prays, what he's really looking for is nuptial union with the Lord.
That's what we're looking for. That's what we're looking. We're looking for the nuptials of Christ and the Church, and they are, they are held in their mystical tension. They are held in right relation, in their virginal integrity. All these words are very important, Holy, sacred, virginal integrity, mystical. All of these words are very important to understand. The nuptials that the Saints talk about, that they experienced by pondering the glory of the Song of Songs. It's all there brother, keep
going. This is where I lead people in TOB 2. You got to take. TOB 1 to get to TOB 2. But our main our main goal in TOB 2 is to enter this glory in the song of songs. So consider taking TOB one and either online or in person this summer and then coming to. TOB 2 in August. This is where we go. You're on the journey, brother. Yeah. And thank you so much for just being honest about your journey. And I think. So many of our listeners are just surrounded by the messages
of this world, which kind of, you know, would somehow want to say that, you know, a person just is gay, for example, like uses that terminology as if that's an identity and there's such a needed witness just in you speaking. The few things you have about your journey of, you know, having experienced shame, having experienced inner healing,
having heard the call to have it, an increase of arrows, experiencing this openness to like, Lord, are you showing me that I, I desire deep relationship with a woman and communion and all that goes with that. Like that is a beautiful, beautiful witness to all of us and we are uplifted by the incredible effort that is
involved in that journey. It is so much easier to just give up and to believe what the world says about our fallenness, that somehow it's not, that there's no grace available for us and we just have to deal. You have received so many graces already and I don't know the details, of course, of how you came to experience those graces. I do wonder if there's been any counseling involved, if you've met with a good therapist at any
point because there is a lot of things in the interior of the person that could be helped by a good therapist just to really resolve inner conflicts or heal other wounds that are still there. And I just wanted to mention that we do keep a list of recommended therapists and counselors available to our listeners because there are there are deep things in the journey that it can be helpful
to have someone to journey with in some of those deep things. Yeah, I would just hold out two more recommendations for you, good brother. 1 would be the work of Bob Shoots in the John Paul 2 Healing Center. Like go on a retreat with them healing of the whole person or they have retreats on the Healing of desire and the work of Desert Stream Ministries and Andrew Comiskey. We do a course here at the institute with their ministry team called Sexual Integration
and Redemption. Check out the Living Waters program put on by Desert Stream and Andrew Comiskey's team. We love you there, brother. Keep going and thank you everybody for tuning in this week. If you were blessed by what you heard and you think others could be blessed, would you please hit that share button and help us get this message out to more and more people? We're grateful for you and we are honored to be a gift to you, and you are a gift to us. Lord, give us the grace we
become what we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...