Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Making Peace with Girlfriend’s Past, True Respect in the Bedroom, & Favorite Musicians in Heaven | ACW307

Nov 18, 202452 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: I’m a 21 year old college student. I’m struggling to make peace with my girlfriend’s sexual past. I’ve experienced healing but remain very wounded. My girlfriend repents of her past but has also lied to me about some of the details she has shared. Some of those details I find deeply troubling. On the one hand, I understand we should show mercy, embrace the wounds of those we love and remind them that they are not defined by their mistakes. On the other hand, I can’t help but feel disgusted. I’m invaded with thoughts of her past actions and I feel no desire for her any more. I want to love her well but I can’t seem to overcome this. Do you have any advice? I’m 48 and in the world of dating after divorce and annulment. While I know that life & pregnancy is the purpose of the marital embrace, at my age it is unlikely to happen. How do I convey that to someone who is likely thinking that at our age the act is purely for pleasure. Is it enough for a spouse to just “respect me in the bedroom”? How do you pray for your favorite musicians? How can heaven be heaven if there’s a possibility of my favorite musicians not being there? Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: COURSE SCHEDULE Click here if you’d like to make a gift to the St. John Paul II Legacy Foundation Love & Responsibility YouTube Series 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here 🌟 For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Hey, Wendy. Yes, Christopher. The heater's on. Thank you the. Heater's on in my office where we record our podcast, which means it's. Gotten a little chilly? Gotten a little chilly and I

also closed down the outdoor shower. Yep. Yeah, we have an outdoor shower on our property, which comes from my love of going to the beach as a kid and having most beach houses that your rent, you know, for summer vacation. They have an outdoor shower so we had one built on our property because I like outdoor showers and I have seashells out there too just to remind me of the beach. But it closed down which means it's getting cold. I know.

You kind of shivered in your voice. I did. Because I was remembering my last outdoor shower, it was really cold. Even though there's warm water in our outdoor shower, it was cold. You knew it was time it. Was time. We had a great course last week here at Black Rock Retreat Center. If you've never been to Black Rock Retreat Center, I hope someday you're able to come. It is a life changing experience for everybody. We did the Love and Responsibility Immersion course, which is based on John Paul the

Second's book of that title, written in the late 1950s, published in 1960, the very same year The Pill debuted. That man saw. He saw what was coming, and he was speaking to it so profoundly, so directly, so insightfully. It's a philosophy book. It's not a theology book. And I call it the philosophy of the body. And one of the greatest definitions of philosophy I ever heard was this, the art of

making meaningful distinctions, that is philosophy. I think I heard that from Bishop Baron, and he probably got that from Thomas Aquinas or somebody like that. But anyways, the point being that is exactly what this book is. It is so artful in making really meaningful distinctions. And our world has lost this art. We can't even distinguish men and women anymore, let alone the inner movements of our hearts and, and, and what makes

something a utilitarian approach to sexuality versus a gift of self approach to sexuality and those fine nuances and just kind of getting under the hood and looking at what makes us tick as human beings, what makes us tick as men and women. And with such wisdom and pastoral experience from countless hundreds of couples that he helped as a priest and as a Bishop, really dealing with the nitty gritty realities of their tensions and difficulties and specifically the tensions

and difficulties under the sheets. And here is this young Polish Bishop. He is not afraid to get get into the nitty gritties of real struggles in the marriage bed and talk about stuff. And it it shocked a lot of people at the time. In fact, the French edition of the book, there was a certain chapter that they didn't want to publish in the mid 60s. And he fought to have it put in because he said basically, look, this is what people are really dealing with and if the church can't speak to it, we're failing in our pastoral duties.

Anyway, the point is, I didn't want to go get long winded on all this, but just say we had a marvelous group last week. Jeanette Clark Co taught with me the course and she brought the feminine side of things and that particular feminine insight. And we watched some great movie clips. We always show art and movie clips to make various points from the works of John Paul 2 and some of the movies and the videos we watched were really profound, really moving and people were just courageous in really going for it and looking

at the realities of life and letting God's grace in. It was. Can you tell I enjoyed it? I can can. You tell it was life giving. It was. It wasn't easy, but it was life giving. Yeah, yeah. That was really. So thank you, everybody who attended last week. Thank you for your courage. All the podcast listeners who said hello, we're very glad that we got to meet you. Yes, yeah. Do you have any updates from the TOB Institute for us? I do, I want to encourage since I'm talking about our courses and how life changing they are, I want to encourage people to

come to our next live course. You can check out our online courses as well at the link below in the show notes. But the next Live 1 is my favorite one to teach of all of them. And it's hard to choose because they're also fun to teach. But it's the Marian Mystery course where we dive deeply into who that woman was, what happened in her womb, and what it says about being human, what it says about God, what it says about his plan for the universe. It's thrilling when I see my students eyes get open to who

this wild woman really was and is. And yes, she is wild in the vertical sense of the word. She's the woman who launched with her rocket engines towards the stars and they never went sideways. So we can learn so much from this woman. Christianity begins when this woman opens her sexuality to God and she can teach us how to do the same thing. So check that out. Yeah, that's beautiful. Are you ready for a question from one of our patrons? I am, oh, did I say it's January 5th to the 10th.

And if you're in need of a scholarship, please, please, please, you can hit the pay pay later option when you register and apply for a scholarship. We will do everything within our power to provide scholarship funds for those who want to come. And on that note, just a shout out to everybody who's contributed to our fundraising campaign for our new foundation to raise scholarship funds, the JP 2 Legacy Foundation. We've had some very generous donors come forth. We have not yet hit our goal, which is $450,000, but we are, we are creeping closer and

closer with everybody who contributes. So if if there's anybody out there who wants to contribute to our scholarship funds at the JP 2 Legacy Foundation, that link is below in the show notes as well. Excellent. And now I have a. Question. Now we're ready. This is from an anonymous patron. Hi Christopher and Wendy, I'm a 21 year old college student who has recently started listening to your podcast because I'm struggling to be at peace with my girlfriend's sexual past.

Over the last two months, listening to you has been a source of abundant grace in my life. I want to thank you for illuminating my heart with the truths revealed to us by our God-given bodies. Nevertheless, I remain very wounded. My girlfriend of three months, who's also a devout Catholic and has repented of her past, just confessed to me that she has lied to me about some of the details from her past and that she actually had sexual experiences that I find deeply

troubling. On the one hand, I understand that we ought to show mercy, embrace the wounds of the Beloved, and seek healing through the Cross. I understand that I must become a reminder for her that she is worthy of love, that she's not defined by her mistakes. But at the same time, I can't help but feel utterly disgusted, and not from a point of moral superiority, since the ground is level at the foot of the cross, but from a bodily or physical

standpoint. I continue to be invaded with thoughts and images of her past actions and it's driving me insane. I feel no desire to kiss her anymore and that breaks my heart. I want to love her well and she is such a good girlfriend but I can't seem to overcome this. I don't know what God wants from me. Do you have any advice on how to approach this problem? Bless you, my brother, bless

you. Yeah. I, I, I just feel it's an injustice to rush in there with some. Here's the answer to your problem because it's so gut wrenching what he's going through and, and understandably so. Brother, I, I want to begin, of course, just with reverence for your heart and your sufferings. Reverence for your girlfriend and her heart and her sufferings. Reverence for your relationship and the sufferings in your

relationship that first, then to acknowledge that the pain you're in, you know, you might be bringing, and I mean might, of course, we all bring our own fallen humanity to the table in everything. So some of this pain is exacerbated, let me put it that way, exacerbated by your own fallen approach to it. But the, the, the, the large majority of the pain you're in is the pain that real sin

causes. This is what really happens. Sin wreaks havoc on human relationships. That's what it does. That's what sin is. It is a Wrecking Ball to our hearts. It is a Wrecking Ball to the normal realities of what relationships are meant to be. That's why it's so painful and even he used the word disgusting. Sin should cause a certain level of disgust.

Now. It shouldn't be a disgust for the person who committed the sin in here. Back to that definition of philosophy, the art of making meaningful distinctions, right? This is a very meaningful distinction. There should be a disgust aimed at sin itself, but there should not be a disgust aimed at the Sinner. And I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm picking

up something I want to be really delicate about addressing and tender towards our brother here who's in so much pain and I want to show real tenderness there and understanding. But there's some something that has happened in her sexual past that makes him disgusted at the thought of kissing her. So there's some disgust you have with her lips, with her mouth. I, I don't want to venture to guess exactly why you didn't

share that information. And I'm sure that was prudent and appropriate not to, but I can guess. And, and there is a a fine line here between the understanding, but there's a fine line between understanding why that might cause a certain disgust, but also her body expresses her person. And for you to be disgusted by

by her lips or by the thought of kissing her lips, that certainly registers in her heart somewhere as rejection of her because the body is the person. And so I think there's a blurring of that meaningful distinction between disgust for the sin. I think it's got a little blurred and it's become at some level, not outright, not

blatant, but at some level has, has, has has become a disgust for the Sinner because the body expresses the person. And I would, I would invite you, brother, to, to open that disgust to the Lord. I think there's a righteous disgust there. And then I think there's something that that needs healing in your own heart. Yeah, there's, there's, there's more. I, I, I want to say on that before I say a few other things.

But brother, my, my recommendation to you would be when you pray, go in your inner room, close the door as Jesus says. Don't take this in a kind of casual way, like set time aside because it's going to take some interior processing and you're going to need time and space for that. So find a quiet place, close the door, turn off your phone, tell anybody who might need you you're not available for an hour or so.

Just just guard the time so that you can have the space you need to look at what's going on in your heart. And I would write a letter to Jesus without censoring anything you feel because he already knows everything in your heart, right? You can't, you can't hide it from him anyway. So just get it out and place what is in your heart in Jesus heart. Say Jesus, I I am disgusted by what I've learned about what my girlfriend did with this other person.

I am just, it disgusts me and it, it's the disgust has gotten to the level where I don't even want to kiss her. I don't want to be close to her in that way because it just, it just makes my stomach turn and just open up. Everything going on really and truly in your heart and how you really feel about without censoring any of it and just place that envelope, so to speak, in the heart of Christ. Just maybe even visualize placing that envelope in the open side of Christ. That's where redemption happens.

That's the fount of redemption. That gushing fountain of blood and water from the heart of Christ is where redemption happens. Redemption is needed for you, brother. Redemption is needed for her and the pain that she has caused you. All of our listeners who who listen to to our podcast regularly know this theme that comes up again and again in our answers that the pain others cause us is very valuable as an

offering in our intercession for the people who've caused us the pain. The pain she has caused you, brother, by her indiscretions, the pain she has caused you by her sinful choices, That pain you feel can be offered to Christ. As I'm just kind of trying to find an image here as the currency of redemption, as the currency of healing, as, as when I say currency, I mean we are as

Saint Paul says, we make up in our own bodies what is lacking in the sufferings of Christ for the sake of his body, the church. Obviously there's nothing lacking in Christ's sufferings, but what is lacking is our participation in them. Brother, you are invited through the pain you are in. You are being invited to participate in the sufferings of Christ for the healing of your girlfriend. And I don't know if she's, you know, where this relationship is supposed to go.

If it's meant to go to marriage, I don't know. I know I can say with certainty for a married couple, this is what we're called to. I don't know exactly to what degree you are being called to enter into this intercessory role for your girlfriend. However, if you want to have a future with her, if you, if you desire truly her healing, this is this is a critical component in the pathway to her healing that she would encounter people who love her enough to help her

carry the weight of her own sins and give them to Jesus. And you already know the weight of of her sins, brother, because you feel the pain of them. And that is valuable currency in the economy of redemption, if you will. It's not a great image. It's not like a tit for tat. It's not that we're paying for the redemption of somebody else, but we are invited to bear the burdens of those around us and bear the burdens, especially of loved ones and help them carry

their cross. You are being invited to be Simon here, I believe, for your girlfriend and, and part of it will be opening and offering the suffering she has caused you for her healing. Not only will that be effective in bringing about a healing for her, it will be effective, my brother, in in furthering your own healing. And I'm thinking here of Mother Teresa and Saint Francis of Assisi. Why?

Because both of them in the people they were called to serve, had to overcome what is a normal and natural disgust with certain human realities. I was just reading recently, I think it was in the Magnificat, there was a reflection from Mother Teresa where she compared her own disgust at needing to love a woman who had been eaten by rats in the streets of Calcutta. I mean, there is a natural revulsion we have there. This this person is maggot

infested and and chewed up by rats and she's called to hold her and carry her and embrace her. Everyone in their normal humanity would would find that repulsive at some level and there would be a level of disgust. And she compared her experience of disgust there that she had to overcome to show the love of Christ to a a well known experience the Saint Francis of Assisi had of ministering to a leper and, and having to beg God to overcome his natural disgust with the leprosy so that he

could embrace and hold and minister to this leper. Well, sin is a kind of leprosy, right? And, and there is a natural understandable revulsion and disgust. But to love as Jesus loves, which is not from a distance, we have to we have to pray to overcome that disgust and we have to pray to be to be ready and willing to hold and kiss the leper. And sin is a leprosy And, and if we could go with either image,

the leprosy or yes, sin has kind of eaten her up like rats. And that's, that's not pleasant to look at. That's not pleasant to kiss. But love in our hearts, our own wounds opened up. And knowing that Jesus kisses us in what could rightly be considered our disgusting places, He kisses us there. To know the kiss of Jesus in our

disgusting places is how we can then show that same kiss, show that same love, show that same tenderness to others in their unattractive and even disgusting places. This is how it works my brother. It ain't easy, but it is so rewarding. So rewarding. I have a certain almost like motherly tenderness toward this questioner, probably because he is the age of our children.

And I, I feel just a, a compassion for the, the intense pain that is going on and, and it's so private. You know you can if you have intense pain from a physical injury. Everyone can see that and show compassion. It can. Sign your cast. It can sign your cast and and when you have intense pain of an an emotional and spiritual

nature that that you have to just out of, you know, deference for the other person. You can't be telling people about this pain. It, it's like I just, I, I feel a tenderness toward that, that pain in his heart. And I, I have to admit, I also find myself wondering about the pains in his girlfriend's heart. And and even the past experience that she, you know, was reluctant to share that she knew

was disturbing and and not what he wanted to hear, not what he wanted to know. I just, I feel a certain sense of of both of them at a moment where they're in particular need of grace because the evil 1 is after moments like this, just loves to latch on to these scary, troubling, you know, disturbing images and experiences and use them to keep

us down. He's I just see his claws and I know it's just such a a place. These these deeply painful and private and shameful places are so in need of the grace of Christ that the Lord who came and entered into our human experience, who showed such solidarity and love for a woman who had committed adultery and, and but he knew there's a

greater depth to her heart than what she had done. And he said, neither do I condemn you that that gospel story is just in my heart right now that that's the moment of grace entering in and, and the, the anger and the, the stones lifted up is the is what we still have now in this invisible way with the the demons that are after our hearts. I mean, I may, I hope that isn't scaring anybody by my saying

that I, it's, it's that feeling of a pivotal moment that I'm trying to get at where we, we encounter our suffering and our weakness and our need for God's grace and something that for humans is impossible, but for the Lord is not impossible. So I just want to encourage this questioner with a a deep love for how painful this is to see the Lord's hand in his life and

in his story. The Lord wanting to give him a deeper wisdom about how how to understand the fallen nature in himself and in others and to allow the Lord to speak truth into his part where these alarming things. I just he mentioned it was making driving him insane and that that feeling of an A deeply alarming, overwhelming experience is kind of what I'm sensing there.

That that's part of the gift of the ministry that the Lord has called us to. I think is, is when we're able to put a name on something that has caused such alarms that people have kind of closed themselves off from it and not been able to make sense of it or allow grace in. And I think it's beautiful that you are listening to our podcast and that you shared your question because it it's a reaching out for grace and that grace is coming and it's coming

to to speak to you both about just our fallenness as men and women in general. And also your girlfriend's particular fallenness and the fallenness of her last boyfriend or this person that she was with that that will be a source of wisdom and insight that will the Lord will continue to use in your life if you if you are open to that. So that's my encouragement. This is an opportunity for deep

growing graces that we don't want to have those opportunities and some level of our being. And yet the Lord knows we're going to have them in our lives and he's there for us. He knows our hearts. I can relate to some of this, you know, I, I had some deep, kind of hard to process things that you shared with me about your past. And I, I can relate to some of those, those troubling images and struggling to be, you know, at peace with the Lord, knowing

the hearts of all involved, even if I can't fully understand it, and to, to trust in his mercy in the face of those things. I I can say from experience it is it is a struggle. And it's an opportunity to enter into the depths of what Christ did on the cross, because all that occurred between your girlfriend and who whoever else it was, has already been absorbed into the Paschal mystery, into the mystery of

Christ's death and resurrection. Brother, that is your only true consolation here is to unite your sufferings here with the sufferings of Christ and find that mystery of redemptive suffering. Your sufferings and her sufferings can and are in Jesus Christ, redemptive sufferings. They don't have to drive you insane. They will without any hope in the resurrection because they are it does create insanity, But with the hope in the

resurrection, knowing that what whatever she has done has already been absorbed, has already been redeemed in Jesus Christ to to walk that path with Christ for her is the path to this not driving you insane, but becoming a deeper unity with Christ, a deeper experience of who Christ is and what he has done for us. And I'll just throw this out because you're a patron that in our patron website on our patron website, you have access to a retreat that I would recommend

that you and she take together. It's a retreat that I Co LED with Doctor Bob shoots on healing that we all need here in our brokenness. I think you will find that very, very fruitful. And just in closing, I'm going to say hats off to you my brother. Because the fact that she came to you and shared this most vulnerable, most shameful, most painful thing in her life is a sign that she trusts you, that you have created a relationship with her. An atmosphere in which she said,

I, I'm going to trust this to him. Wow, brother, that is a sign of grace. Thank you, God, we lift up this couple. We ask you please to continue to pour your grace out on them. Cast whatever spiritual interference might be getting in the way of of this man loving this woman in her brokenness, just as you love her Lord. And please, please console our brother in his pains and help him to know that those pains are redemptive. Amen.

Our next question is from a listener named Mary. Hello, Mary. I'm just scratching the surface of theology of the body thanks to your ministry. What a beautiful and glorious gift this has been for me. So glad, that's awesome. I'm 48 and in the world of dating after divorce and annulment. Well, I know that life and pregnancy is the purpose of the marital embrace. At my age, it is unlikely to happen. How do I convey that to someone

who's likely thinking that at our age, the ACT is purely for pleasure? Is it enough for a spouse to just quote respect me in the bedroom? Bless you Mary. Gosh this is a multi layered question. I'm trying to find my entry point. Is it enough for a spouse just to respect me in the bedroom? If he's truly respecting you, yes. If he's truly respecting you.

What does the word respect mean? Pick it apart respect to look again to see into more deeply and I I want to comment on what Mary said here about because it's she's most likely past childbearing years. She said How did she put it? It seems like all that's left is pleasure. Or how did she say that? At our age, the ACT is purely for pleasure. At our age, the ACT is purely for pleasure. I, I want to invite you and I, I

know, Mary, you said you're new to this world of John Paul the Second's teaching, but I, I want to invite you to a new vision, a new way of understanding. Obviously, God created sexual pleasure. There's nothing wrong with sexual pleasure when we enjoy it and embrace it and experience it as he intends. But it's, it's never the goal of sexual relations. If it if pleasure becomes the

goal, if pleasure becomes all that's left, well then the other person is being used as a means of pleasure for someone else. And that, to go back to our previous word is not respectful, right? John Paul the second says it's not that you have these two elements, procreation and pleasure. And then when procreation is no longer possible, all all that's left is the pleasure. No, no, no. The goal of the two becoming one

flesh is loving as Jesus loves husbands, love your wives as Christ loved the church. For this reason, a man will leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two will become one flesh. This is a great mystery, and it refers to Christ and the Church. The goal of the two becoming one flesh is not procreation. The goal of the two becoming one flesh is not pleasure. The goal of the two becoming 1

flesh is loving as Christ loves, and Christ's love is both life giving and it's meant to bring us the fullness of joy. But those are fruits of an act, the goal of which should not be either pleasure or procreation. The goal of which should be what John Paul the second calls the sincere gift of self, right, just like Christ to say to the other, this is my body given up

for you. This is our goal. John Paul the second says in love and responsibility. If if your goal is if your sole goal is procreation, then the danger is you're going to be using your spouse as a means to an end, even though it's a good end, which is procreation. Procreation should be the fruit of loving. As Jesus loves, so should pleasure. Pleasure should be the fruit of loving as Jesus loves, not the goal. He says our attention and

intention should be on our spouse, affirming the goodness and dignity of our spouse, blessing the spouse, saying to the spouse, you are good. I I want to kiss you all over, to affirm you all over. I want to, I want to pour myself out for you so that you will know your goodness from the male perspective. You know, I, I want to put it this way, I want to give your insides 500 million kisses

because guess what? That's about the number of sperm, right? 500 million kisses on the inside. I want to pour myself out for you. I want to pour my very lifeblood out for you. I want you to know how good you are. I want to affirm your dignity. I want to honor you. I want to say you are good and this is my body giving up for you. And and similarly with the wife, she should want to be saying, I want to affirm you and bless you and receive your gift and pour myself out for you to kiss you and honor you and tell you of your goodness. If that's what you mean by is it

enough for my husband just to respect me in the bedroom, then we're on the same page. But you know, respect, depending on what we mean by the word could could just end up being justification for somebody using you. And that that's not respect. That's the opposite of respect because respect means to look again, to see more deeply. When we're using somebody either as a means to procreation or we're using somebody as a means to pleasure, we are not showing

the respect for the honor and dignity of the person, right? Procreation and a new life, a new child is a beautiful fruit of loving. As Jesus loves, So is the fullness of bodily and spiritual joy that comes with the marital embrace. It's a beautiful fruit of loving as Jesus loves. But neither of them should be treated as the end, the goal. Because if you're do, if that's the only reason you're having sex, either to have a baby or to have pleasure, either way you end up treating your spouse who

is worthy of respect. You end up treating your spouse as a means to an end. And that's the opposite of loving as God loves. Yeah, I love this question. I think I just sense in Mary, she's just kind of, it seems like as she said, she's she's scratching the surface and entering into something new. And I I love the hopefulness in her question when she talked about what a beautiful gift

she's received through theology of the body. And there's a hopefulness in saying, at age 48, I'm, I'm divorced and nulled. I have this whole history. It's, it's been difficult. And yet I, I, I'm open to what God might have for me. And I, I wanted to be different. And I, I sense that in her question and, and I'm wondering, well, well, how will it be different?

And, and am I, how do I find that person with whom that will be something different and, and how different does it need to be? And, and all these, you know, initial questions that are just revealing of a of a heart that's, that's received a lot of grace and yet in need of lots more. Like, aren't we all that way, you know, but I, I just think in asking the question, it just opened up like a real deep reflection in you, Christopher,

about the meaning of our union. And I think, you know, if we, if we understand the the bond that the Lord forms in marriage and that we renew and strengthen through our marital union, that bond is so deep and personal and so intimate. And it is it is meant to reach all levels of our being and not

stop at some surface level. So I think you captured that so much in your question. I just wanted to affirm that for Mary that that would these questions that are stirring in her about what does it look like to be married at this age and and, and to have a different experience than my past one? What would that be like? I think those are are wonderful questions. And I'm hopeful that just listening to this podcast and anything that Christopher and I

have said will, yeah, open your heart to something far more human than than even maybe you previously thought human and godly. I love that sentiment, Wendy, and I'll hold out one more thing to you, Mary. I think a good next step for you would be to enter into the main themes of John Paul the Second's work that we were talking about earlier, Love and responsibility.

Maybe you can't attend a full week course or maybe you can't take the online course. I hope you could at least take the online course. But if you can't do either of those, Matt Frat and I filmed a six part series on Love and Responsibility, which, just for the sake of comparison, that's six hours of content on John Paul's teaching versus the 30 hours of content that you would get in our Love and Responsibility course either online or in person. But if you if you can't dedicate all the time and energy to the

30 hour version, there's a six hour version, a six episode series that Matt Fradd and I did that will will touch on all the main themes of love and responsibility. And I think you'll find that very, very fruitful. You can find it on YouTube and we'll put the link in the show notes to this episode. That's great. Our next question is from a listener named Renee. Hi, Renee. Christopher and Wendy, thank you for this podcast and your witness of authentically living your vocation. I look forward to the day we'll

see each other in the Communion of Saints. Whoop. Whoop, whoop. Yes, Renee, it'll be a special day. And you'll learn what you mean to me. Aw, aw, thank you, Renee. Can't wait for that time. The Communion of Saints is so exciting to look forward to. I can't wait to know you, Renee. Yes. And be known by you. Here's my question. How? Who do you pray for your favorite musicians? Huh. I I cried at Mass today because a beloved band might never know

what their music does for my heart. If they miss out on the communion of Saints, I pray for the softening of their hearts and their deep encounter with Jesus, like Saul or the woman at the well. Is there anything else I can do? There's a way of being seen spiritually through music that differs from other types of connection and somehow it doesn't feel one sided. I find myself wondering how can heaven be heaven if they're not

there? Gosh, Renee, wow, can I ever relate to what you're talking about at a very deep level? I bless your love for these musicians. I bless your heart in its openness to the gift of music. It's a sacred space in the human heart. Very, very tender and sacred space. And I'll share a quote from Pope Benedict the 16th. I love, love, love this quote. He says music uncovers the

buried way to the longings of the heart, to the core of our being where God dwells. And they says wherever this happens, meaning it doesn't have to be a particularly sacred piece of music, right? It could, you could be driving down the road and somebody comes on the radio and it taps something. It could be a melody from a pop song. It could be a guitar solo from a pop song. He says wherever this happens,

music becomes the way to encounter Jesus. It becomes the path of salvation. Astounding. And I believe you're right, Renee, to say it's, it's the way we experience. It is not just one way. It's not just that this band or this musician is, is blessing me, but that somehow in the spiritual realm, my very openness to this person's gift becomes a blessing for that person.

I'll tell you a story I just recently heard. I was watching as I'm want to do. I was watching an interview with Bruce Springsteen, who's one of my musical heroes. His music has blessed me beyond what I can say with words. That man taught me how to yearn. He taught me how to pray by feeling the depths of my yearning. Anyway, I was watching this interview with Springsteen and he talked about the the ecstatic experience he had the first time he heard one of his songs on the

radio in the 1970s. And he was just walking down the street in some town and some car pulled up to the stop sign right next to him. The windows was were rolled down and one of his songs on the radio and this guy was jamming out the kind of singing along, dancing along to one of his songs on the radio. And he has never forgotten that experience. That was over 50 years ago. And what's going on here? Why is that such a blessing to Bruce Springsteen? Because that song is an

expression of his inner being. That song is an expression of his heart. And that song is being received by this guy in the car. His gift has been poured out and his gift has been received. John Paul the second uses the expression in the theology of the body, the affirmation of the gift, and how the affirmation of the gift itself becomes an

affirmation and blessing to the person who made the gift. That's the two way St. so that when you receive the music of an artist, when you let it into your heart in the spiritual realms, you are sending out blessing and affirmation to that artist. And I, I have to believe, I do believe that in the spiritual realms, that blessing, that affirmation. We don't know how all this works. You can't diagram it on a blackboard, but it it reaches that person's heart.

I believe that is true. And I believe that's the nature of that, that two way dimension. And you asked specifically, how do I pray for the musicians who have blessed me? Well, that's an integral part of it, just to remain open to their gift. And of course, you have to be discerning in what you're opening yourself to artistically. And you can say, OK, there's the wheat, there's the weeds. I can be blessed by the wheat and I can put the weeds aside. We have to have that mature

level of discernment or we can open ourselves up to some nasty stuff and we don't want to be going there. But to even take the care to do that and not just, well, I'm not listening to that musician because I don't like his politics or I don't like his morality or what to take the time and say I, I don't agree with his politics. I don't agree with his morality, But I recognize there's still goodness in this person and I'm going to take the effort because

this person is worth it, because he's a maid in the image and likeness of God. I'm going to take the effort to to make those distinctions. There's the wheat and I'm going to be blessed by that and I'm going to throw blessing back to him or her, whoever the situation, whatever the situation might be. There's the weeds and I'm not going to let them in and I'm not going to bless or affirm them that that itself is loving that artist. That itself is a is an offering for that artist. That itself is prayer for that artist.

Receiving the artist's gift is a way and, and discerning, you know, going, taking the effort. John Paul the second talks about this. He, he says he talks about the memory of touring the Diocletian Baths in Rome and and being struck by the the masterpieces of Greek sculpture. And he says it was a very laborious day. It took great effort, he said, to ponder that Greek art and to try to understand what they had been looking for in their

depictions of the human body and the way they carved the human body. He said it took great labor. It's a labor of love. It's a labor of love. And he said, I came to understand the gospel anew and I came to understand the gospel better because in their quest for perfect beauty in the human body, I came to realize they were looking for the incarnation because what is the incarnation? It is perfect beauty manifested in the human body, beauty with a capital B. He, he went through that labor

of he could have just said, oh, those are that's naked. Those are naked statues. And that could be an occasion of sin. I'm going to run the other way. No, he took the effort to discern. He he took the effort to say, what were they looking for? What were they intending? Why were they so taken by the human body? Why did they so meticulously carve the human body? Well, we can do that with any work of art. We can say. Why did Bruce Springsteen write that song? I was so touched recently. I shared this with you, Wendy, a

few weeks ago when I discovered the Springsteen song I had never heard called In the Belly of the Whale. And it's a, it's a kind of Jonah tale, but it's it's really a pondering of death, how the wail of death swallows us all. And I had to take great pains to understand, what is Springsteen getting at in this song? Where does the song come from? What is he wrestling with? And why is he wrestling with it? And my openness to that song and my wrestling with those lyrics,

I know was a prayer for Bruce Springsteen because I was taking the effort to receive his gift. And it was, it did take some real labor on my part, but I know I got down to the core of what he was singing about in that song. And I know there is in some spiritual realm, there's a communion of my heart with his and his heart with mine because I took the effort to receive his gift. I know that's a form of prayer. And sometimes that form of prayer will will itself very naturally become a, a, a, a Hail

Mary for that artist and our father for that artist. Just a cry of my heart to be with that person in heaven. I think you're right. It's hard. It's hard to imagine the communion of Saints without the people we love. And I think we can trust in our prayers that they will have an effect. I believe I'm going to be in the communion of Saints with Bruce Springsteen. I believe it. I believe I'm going to be in the communion of Saints with Bono. I, I believe it and I believe my prayers are going to play a role in getting them there. That's how it works.

It just, that's just, that's the spiritual math. I like how you said that it just gave me a sense of a certain trust in the Lord and a surrender. Like I, I don't know the, the details of how this will work out and I don't have the opportunity. You know, I'm not in a relationship with these musicians such that I can maybe share more about the Lord in a way that would resonate with them and, and help them.

I, I don't have that option. So I have to entrust it to the Holy Spirit. I have to, you know, have that deep gratitude, that recognition that all goodness ultimately comes from the Lord. So I, I thank him for this art, this music, and I, I entrust these artists to him in that process of, of giving thanks and of just marveling at God's goodness that I've experienced through their work.

There's a, there's a sense of I don't have the power. I'm not the savior you are. You know their story. I simply just lift them up with gratitude and hope and yearning and, and I can only just offer all of that to you, Lord, that's how I'm hearing you. I'm hearing the same. And it's, it's, it's all we can do in the end is trust that the Lord desires their salvation more than we do. And we know we desire it. So we're entering into the real

heart of the Lord by desiring it with the Lord. And we can trust that in in feeling that desire for their salvation, in wanting to be with them in the communion of Saints, that that somehow has an effect. And what a joy it will be. Oh my gosh, to rock out eternally with some of my musical heroes. I want it to be. Lord, help, help that to happen. Lord, I lift up to you. We're Lord right now. Paul McCartney, I lift up to you. Right now. Bruce Springsteen, I lift up to you. Right now, Bono and The Edge and Larry and Adam from U2I lift up

to you. Mike Peters from the Alarm, I lift up to you, Richard Butler from The Psychedelic Furs. I want to be in heaven with Richard Butler from The Psychedelic Furs. I do. I do, I do. Lord, let it be as you would have it. Lord, help us to know, Lord, the gift of music. Help us to know the gift of musicians. Help us to know our own gift. Help us to know that we really are indispensable, irreplaceable and unrepeatable gifts of life and love.

And give us the grace. To become what we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Christopher West Host Feed-stated
  • Wendy West Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode