Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Why blood belongs inside, Physical abnormalities & the TOB ideal, My Husband’s Desire Feels Twisted | ACW368

Jan 19, 202654 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

-This episode is sponsored by Truthly- Questions answered this episode: Recently I had mole excision surgery that led me into some unexpected reflection through a TOB lens. I was awake with only local anesthesia and watched the doctor use a scalpel to cut into my skin. Seeing the blood flow out made me lightheaded and nauseous, and I wondered why many people feel queasy at the sight of blood. In TOB terms, is this like “your seed belongs in her garden”? Might blood also feel like something that belongs inside the body? How does this connect to Christ’s Sacred Heart being pierced and his blood poured out for us - and why don’t medical professionals react this way? I’ve been listening to an introduction to theology of the body you gave, and my heart is stirred with a desire for all the beauty and goodness that is offered to us through the truth of our bodies. I can’t help but wonder as I listen how this truth of what is intended for our bodies applies to those who experience unusual circumstances such as infertility, reproductive disorders, or illnesses, and the smaller percentage who are born with physical abnormalities that affect their sexual or reproductive organs. How does the ideal of the theology of the body reconcile with these natural realities? My husband and I have been married for 38 years. I came into marriage with insecurities and abandonment wounds - my father died when I was 3, my mother never remarried, and my older siblings left home after marrying. My husband’s love language is touch and quality time, and he didn’t receive much of either from his parents. Because of our woundedness, we had immoral patterns in our marriage - dressing inappropriately and spending at least 10 years going to nudist resorts. I’m further on my journey through counseling and our Catholic faith, but I’m not sure where he is. I feel pressured when he comments on my body, stares, and wants us naked at home. What steps can I take to have a healthier response to my husband? Resources: Colorado Ski Retreat with Christopher --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Our faithful listeners know that I've been of late sharing with you guys an app called Truthly. Truthly. We've entered into a partnership with Truthly. I believe in what they're doing, they believe in what we're doing. And our audience who is familiar with asking questions about the Catholic faith, you guys should really know about this app called Truthly, TRUTHLY faithful to the Magisterium, rooted in Scripture, thinking with the

mind and heart of the Church. You can go on truthfully and ask any question about the Catholic faith and you'll get an orthodox answer using all the technology of artificial intelligence and putting it to very good use. I've been using Truthfully just to poke around and see what kind of answers they come up when when I type in certain questions and I've been impressed. I've been impressed. They're doing good stuff and I think it is definitely worth our just shouting out to our audience and say give it a try. You can get a 7 day free trial

by just going to wherever you get your apps, the Google Play Spot if you're an Android person, or go to the App Store on the iPhone and learn more about what the good folks are doing at Truthfully. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast.

Well, hey everybody. Hi listeners. Welcome to another episode of the Ask Christopher W podcast, hosted by. Wendy West. I wish everybody could see what I see right now. Tell everybody how you look, Wendy. Well, here's the situation. See many of our listeners probably know that we record Christopher's this podcast in Christopher's office, which is attached to our garage, which is can be cold and we did not remember to turn on the heater today. So I am very bundled up.

I have many layers on. I hate to be cold. So I'm offering it up for all of you. And Christopher is just amused by my layers, The hood over my head. I have gloves, multiple socks. I mean, I'm really trying here. And Speaking of cold, yes. I have a cold you can hear my voice is a little funny too. Hey, listen, it's all for you. We do this for you people. No, we, we, we take great joy in doing this podcast.

We have been doing it for how many years? 7. Seven years over 7 years, and not only do we get so many messages from our listeners about how much they've learned, but we have learned so much. We've learned so much about each other. We've learned so much about how to respond with not just our theological knowledge, but our own trying to live that out. We're just broken human beings trying to live the stuff in our

own lives. And if you want to learn something really well, teach it. And doing this podcast over all these years has really refined our own thinking, our own experiences. It's been such a blessing. So thanks for allowing us to do this for you. Sometimes a listener will remind me of something they learned on a podcast and I'll think, oh, I needed to be reminded of that. It's amazing. Yeah, I, I, I've had similar experiences and people come up to me and we'll say very

personal things to me, like tell me personal stories from my life. And I'm like, how? How do you know that? I heard it on your podcast. Oh, right. So here we are, TOB Institute podcast and all. Any updates on the TOB Institute? Yes, we have a very special offer for those who want to go on this ski retreat. Oh. Yeah.

Jay Ezell, who's on our team here at the institute, he's in our marketing department. He and I are long time ski buddies. You know this, Wendy, when, when we lived in Colorado, Jay Ezell and I would get these season passes up in the Rocky Mountains and scare little Batootsie's off together. And he came last year on the ski retreat. And we had such a great time. We hadn't skied together in probably 20 years. And it was so much fun. And he and I did this Instagram Live last week in which we extended this offer.

And I had forgotten that because of the schedule of the way we record our podcasts, we would not be able to to have our podcast listeners get a chance to have this offer. Jay Ezell and I had originally said we were going to extend this offer until January 16th, but to include our podcast listeners, that's you, that's you guys. We are extending this offer to January 23rd at midnight, East Coast time in the United States. And here's the offer, if you

sign up to come on this ski retreat, we're going to this beautiful mountain estate. It sleeps 30 people. We're going to be all in the same house together. We're going to be eating meals together. We're going to be skiing all day and in the night. We're going to be in the evenings. We're going to be reflecting on John Paul the Second's vision of the human person. Our creation is male and female. We're going to go deep. Last year, lives were transformed. It was such a beautiful experience. This is all in the spirit of JP

2 March 9th to the 13th in the Rocky Mountains. You can check out the link if you sign up by January 23rd at midnight. I don't even think you know this offer, Wendy. I don't. I'm so excited. Are you so excited to hear? Absolutely. Well, we're going to throw in a full scholarship to an online course at the institute. That's a 30 hour course that usually costs 900 bucks. Sign up for the ski retreat and you're getting a full scholarship to one of our courses, but you got to do it

before January 23rd at midnight. That's right, Make that decision just. Do it, just do it. It's so fun. You know what I love about these ski retreats, Wendy? You know, when I'm teaching a course at Black Rock Retreat Center here or when I'm giving a seminar around the world, I, I, I'm kind of in and I'm out And even at a course, which is just down the street, teaching a five day course, 6 hours a day, lecturing is exhausting. And I have to really guard my time and my sleep.

And so I, I usually come in for the sessions and I, I have to leave after the sessions just to have downtime generally. But on these ski retreats, I'm living with everybody who's there. We're sharing all our meals together, We have conversations. I I really get to know people and it's, it's an experience that's unlike anything else I do in my ministry life, so. That's awesome. Thanks for sharing that. Thanks for extending the offer

to our people. Yeah, let's get going with a question from a patron. Let's do it. Our first question is from an anonymous patron. Dear Christopher and Wendy, Recently I had mole excision surgery that led me into some unexpected reflection through a TOB lens. The procedure was done with only local anesthesia, so I was awake and able to watch as the doctor used a scalpel to cut into my skin. Seeing the blood flow out of my body made me light headed and

nauseous. This experience got me wondering, why is it that many people have this kind of queasy reaction to the sight of blood? In TOB terms, could this be somewhat like the way Christopher explains to men that your seed belongs in her garden? In a similar way, might blood be something we sense intuitively belongs inside the body rather than outside of it, perhaps even as an echo from the garden? How might this connect with the mystery of Christ's Sacred Heart

being pierced and his blood poured out for us? I also find myself curious about why medical professionals often don't react in this way. Had they built up a tolerance? Could it be a form of heroic virtue? On the other hand, is it perhaps actually more integrated to feel queasy at the sight of blood, since it signals the rupture of something that should be whole? Oh my word. That's a lot. I love this person who asked

this question. This person is a thinker, and I'm a thinker and not a once in my entire life of thinking about these mysteries, bodily mysteries, the passion of Christ, my own experience of getting queasy when blood is flowing out of my body or somebody else's body, getting lightheaded whenever I've donated blood.

I have never, ever gone there. I never thought about this. I never entertained these questions. I love this question. I mean, this is, this is. I'm just sharing what's stirring in me right now because this is all new to me. I've never even thought about it. But I think she is putting her finger on some astounding truths. And I, I want to address first this idea of medical

professionals who don't feel this, don't feel queasy, don't feel that uneasiness about blood and cutting into bodies. And I do think in order to to do that and not feel queasy, you, you have to get yourself in an objective, almost abstract place. I remember again, I'm just

pulling stuff out that's stirring in me right now. This is random, but I think it's related. My grandfather was a surgeon and the general practice is that a surgeon should not be operating on his relatives. And there there was an exception made when I had appendicitis when I was 11 years old. And my grandfather did operate on me. But knowing that was an exception, it was not General Medical practice. I remember asking what it why, what, what, why can't?

Why would it not be normal for my grandfather to operate on me? And I remember somebody explaining this, maybe my mom, that, that when it's a relative that the objectivity can be lost and, and you enter into the realm of subjectivity and this is someone you know and love and you losing objectivity is not good in a medical situation. And that always stayed with me. And I think this is necessary. I know it's necessary that

objectivity is necessary in order to perform medicine, but it does have its downsides. How often do people complain about, you know, you might have the stellar world renowned surgeon who just saved your life, but when he comes to visit you the next day in the hospital to see your incision and see how you're healing up, has 0 bedside manner. Doesn't know how to look you in the eye, doesn't know how to treat you as a person. This is a common experience in

in medicine and it's understandable because he is trained and has had to train himself to have an objectivity about it all. And, and, and what this questioner is demonstrating is a profound subjectivity, of course, a profound interior view, which takes us into mysteries that are not accessible to merely an objective medical scientific approach.

She's talking about the passion of, of Christ and how watching her own blood flow out of her veins makes her queasy. And is that maybe more a more integrated approach? And I would say, yes, it's more integrated. And yes, it, it, it is a sign that, you know, I think she's right on. I think she's, she's putting her finger on what she knows to be true. My blood is meant to stay in my veins.

And I like even this analogy she's drawing with what I say about the husband's seed belongs in the garden. So I I want to comment here also on what she said about the piercing of Christ's heart. And what are we to make of this outpouring of blood? Well, blood is life, right? Lifeblood. We even use that term, lifeblood. Blood is life, life is blood.

Christ's outpouring of blood is the outpouring of his life. The theological term would be canosis, self emptying, the pouring out canosis. Unless you eat my flesh and drink my blood, you have no life in you. It's the sign of the total outpouring. And I'm going to make a connection here with what she said about the seed in the garden because in I believe it's

forgive me, I am not a language scholar. It's either in the the Greek or the Latin, one of the, the ancient languages. I don't know Greek, Latin, Hebrew, I'm not sure that blood and seed, specifically the male seed poured out. It's the same word. It's the pouring out of one's life. And what does Saint Augustine say about the flow of blood and

water from the open side of the bridegroom? He says it is as it were. You know, that's an important qualifier. He's saying this is mysterious. This is this is an analogy, but it's fitting. He says the flow of blood and water is as it were the spiritual seed of the bridegroom. This is the term he uses is the spiritual Seminole fluid of the bridegroom. It's the life giving essence of the bridegroom poured out and and I have reflected in one of

my books. I think it was Heaven's song that could we see the flow of blood and water? Could we see the piercing of his side? Could we see the sweating of blood in the garden? Could we see the blood of the scourging? Not so much as as wounds happening from with wounds happening from without, but rather the explosion from within

of infinite love flowing through a human body like Christ's human heart. I I just hold this out for people to to enter into as a proposal. Could it be the flow of blood and water is not so much because he got pierced from the outside in, but rather his human heart exploded from within because it contained what cannot be

contained, the infinite love of the Trinity and the flow of blood and water is like the explosion from the inside out? It's worth pondering. And, and I I don't know how to tie this all up in a neat bow. I don't think you can because these are these are, these are mysteries. So I think I'm going to leave it there. But I, I just want to say again, how how stunned I am by this beautiful person's heart that it could even articulate such a

question. And I don't know if I've answered or not, but I've just thrown out some food for thought. I had the feeling as you were talking of sort of like poetry or a painting full of symbolism or song lyrics, that it doesn't necessarily have one point to make, but more like just shining light on, on mysterious felt connections that are real and important to our hearts.

I, I also felt like just adding, as you were in the initial part of your response, talking about your grandfather as a surgeon and just learning about the need for objectivity in order to do the work. And well, certainly there are some doctors or medical professionals who, you know, lack some bedside manner. Of course, not all do. And I know you weren't saying that, but I also liked her

comment or her question about heroic virtue, because certainly there is a a desire for the good of the other that is behind that taking that posture of objectivity, that the intention to do good for the patient is the motivator. And so that is. Heroic and yes. Yes. And there's a sacrifice. There, yes, there is. There's, Yeah, obviously facing

a lot of challenges in the process of learning and overcoming a very natural aversion to drawing blood, you know, as she witnessed. But also the the sacrifice of something of feeling just like every other person, of knowing you've accomplished this certain amount of objectivity that kind of distances you from the normal human, human experience.

There's a sacrifice in that as well that is for the good of the other. So I just wanted to come in on that. You know, many of our listeners know I used to be a nurse and I have a certain I just interest in and respect for healthcare. So I wanted to mention those. Yeah, it makes me think of our friend Gary, who's been AEMT for and a firefighter for however many years, 25 years or more. And he, he and I have had conversations in which he shares

what he has had to sacrifice in his psychological experience of, of the world because of what I would call his heroism in being willing to pull mangled bodies out of mangled vehicles in horrible car accidents. And the PTSD that he deals with every day from day in, day out, week in, week out, month in,

month out, year in, year out, that this is what he does. With great heroism because of his desire to rescue people, to help people, he has been willing to make such a sacrifice and and to survive that you have to you have to kind of block out, learn how to block out what what would be that normal total aversion to running into those situations to pull people out.

So God bless all these heroes, medical professionals, EMTs, firefighters, rescue workers for what they sacrifice and what they do for our good. Wow. Yeah. Thank you, Jesus. He isn't he the ultimate hero here. Yes. Thank you Jesus, for what you did for us. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. I've been listening to an introduction to theology of the body you gave, and my heart is stirred with a desire for all the beauty and goodness that is

offered to us through the truth of our bodies. I can't help but wonder as I listen how this truth of what is intended for our bodies applies to those who experience unusual circumstances such as infertility, reproductive disorders or illnesses, and the smaller percentage who were born with physical abnormalities that affect their sexual and reproductive organs. How does the ideal of the theology of the body reconcile with these natural realities?

Thank you. Thank you for asking this question. It's, it's very important, especially it sounds like this person is new to some of these themes and entering into this vision for the first time. And these are the kinds of questions that vary naturally get stirred and I'm more than happy to speak into them. We can certainly say looking at all of the abnormalities, the the sufferings of infertility, she spoke of the tragic

circumstances of somebody who's born with genital deformities. We can certainly say of all of these things, like we can say if somebody born blind or born deaf or born missing limbs. In the beginning, God created a world of harmony, of truth, goodness and beauty that was not spoiled by what we call the

fall. And you know, we're not going to get into a long conversation right now about the fall other than to say when Jesus says in the beginning it was not. So he's taking us back prior to the fall. And I want to bring up another scene in the Gospels where the circumstances of this blind man, these circumstances are being questioned. They come to Jesus. Is it his sin that made him blind? Is it his parents sin that made him blind?

And we have to be very, very careful here about our quickness to want to assign somebody's sin to somebody's else's suffering when it comes to physical issues like blindness or infertility or any other bodily abnormality. And listen to the importance of Jesus answer. No, it was not his sin. No, it was not his parents sin, but God allowed this to bring

about and reveal His glory. All right, pause right there. Pause right there and let that sink in. There is something utterly profound there that will open our minds, our hearts, our yearnings, our hopes, our dreams, our desires to something utterly, utterly astounding. And if we are to enter into the depths and the heights that

these words of Jesus invite us to, it will give us the grace to endure any trial, any suffering with great hope. It will give us the grace to endure any evil with great hope that God can bring about a greater good, a greater glory through this suffering, through this evil, through this sorrow.

As horrific as it can possibly be, a greater glory is possible through this suffering then could have been possible without this suffering. Looping it back to the question of infertility, this begins to make sense out of some odd scriptures like Greater are the children of the barren woman. What? What greater are the children of

the barren woman? How can a barren woman have children? How can an infertile woman be fertile? Well, let me loop it right back to the what I said in the the previous answer to the previous question about the spiritual seed of Christ, the new Adam on the cross, what Saint Augustine called the marriage bed of the cross. Well, who's the bride in this

situation? The Fathers of the Church had no hesitation in recognizing that of course the woman at the foot of the cross is his mother in the flesh. But in this deeper mystical dimension, she's the New Eve. She's the bride. She represents the Church, and at the foot of the cross she becomes the mother of all of the living in a supernatural fecundity, a supernatural

fertility that flows from the supernatural mystical nuptial union that was consummated on the marriage bed of the cross, consummated virginally but not asexually. Meaning that's a man on the cross and a woman at the foot of the cross. And who's beside both of them? The beloved disciple. What does Jesus say to the beloved disciple? Behold your mother.

What does he say to the woman at the foot of the cross? Behold your Son, who's the Beloved Disciple, the mystical offspring of the mystical marriage of Christ in the Church. There is a new kind of fertility that when we unite our sufferings with Christ on the cross and his bride at the foot of the cross, when we unite our sufferings with the new Adam and the new Eve sufferings, what happens? We ourselves enter in a new kind

of fertility. We ourselves enter a new kind of fecundity. And the principle we're talking about here, which is so important, is that grace perfects nature. What does that mean? Nature. The very word nature comes from the Latin Nautilus, which means to be born earth, generation, grace, the supernatural realm of grace perfects the natural realm

of generation and birth. We can enter a new kind of fertility and and if we do not, we're not going to enter the Kingdom. What does Jesus say to Nicodemus? Unless you are regenerated, unless you are born of water in the spirit, you cannot enter the Kingdom. In other words, if you're not an offspring of the New Adam and the New Eve, you're not going to enter the Kingdom. This is what baptism is. I'm going off on some some tangents here and I want to I

want to try to loop it all back. The question is, in this beautiful mystery of natural conjugal union, in this beautiful mystery of natural fertility that reveals such beautiful divine mysteries, what about those people who have birth defects or later injuries or what have you that don't enable them to participate in that natural reality? Well, they can still participate in the supernatural reality. And precisely by offering their wounded nature to the

supernatural reality that happens at the cross, whatever is wounded in them gets perfected. Whatever is wounded in their nature gets perfected in a supernatural glory that we begin to enter into even here, but will be fully revealed in the resurrection of the body. What will happen in the resurrection of the body? The blind will see, the deaf will hear, the lame will leap. Those who had ambiguous genitalia when they were born

will no longer have ambiguous genitalia. Those who were infertile in this life will now participate eternally in the eternal fecundity of God the Father and the Blessed Mother. What's it going to look like? I don't know. Haven't been to heaven, haven't experienced A resurrected body. But we have a sense of it through the mystery of our creation, as male and female as God intended it to be. This is why God allows these things. This is why God allowed that man's blindness to reveal the glory of God.

It's real. This is where we put our faith. This is why we are people of hope. We place our faith here, not in medical science. Although it can do wonders for us, it cannot solve all our problems. It never will. Only the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ, only the consummation of the marriage of Christ in the church, Only by entering that mystery can we find the Super abundant solution to all of our problems. And we place all of our faith there. And it doesn't mean we'll have the solution to all of our problems in this life, but we

have the hope that in the resurrection of the body, we will have the Super abundant, overflowing resolution to all of life's sufferings and sorrows. That's our hope. That's our faith. If that's true, let me in 'cause I desperately want it. Yeah, one of the things I felt that with this question was just that there was something stirring in her heart about just, like, feeling uplifted and inspired by seeing deeper mysteries contained in the

natural realities, as you were talking about. And then a caution like, oh, but would that be painful and sad if I, you know, couldn't participate in them? And in this way that just is suddenly seeming to me so deeply beautiful. Or how, how would this land in the heart of someone who experiences that suffering? And there is a, a natural just especially because we all know

people who are experiencing those things. It's just natural to be cautious and sensitive. Like, how does that feel from that perspective? And I just want to encourage this listener and all our listeners that we have just encountered so many people who are in those situations who are so ministered to by this teaching of theology of the body. It does not exclude them. It it gives such tremendous

meaning to suffering that maybe could have been dismissed in a culture that doesn't say value the gift of fertility all that much. You know, where they kind of for any number of reasons because it's it's true and good and beautiful and each person's experience is unique. Yet the truth and goodness and beauty of God's love poured out and his image in us that's affected by the fall, but not

lost like that is an entry point for such grace even in the lives of people who are experiencing the very things that were brought up in this question. So I just wanted to say that from our experience in ministry, like it may be a, a longer journey and there could be bumps on different bumps on the road, but it's, it's still profoundly beautiful and part of the healing in all kinds of circumstances.

I'm reminded of such a beautiful story, one of the most beautiful stories I've ever heard, from one of our students at the TOB Institute. And I have permission to tell this publicly from her and her husband, infertile in their marriage. I don't even like that word because there's a supernatural fertility in every marriage open to the Holy Spirit, the Lord and Giver of Life. And this was the way she learned that supernatural fertility in which she was participating. They, they, this was like 7-8

years into their marriage, longing for children. And month after month after month after month, her period would come and she'd weep. Her period would come and she'd weep month after month after month. And she would just learn. She learned through coming to the TOB Institute about this mystery of supernatural fertility. And she would just put herself in front of a crucifix when she got her period, and she would weep. And after month after month

after month, it finally dawned on her, blood and water. I'm bleeding and I'm weeping. Blood and water is flowing from my body. Blood and water is flowing from my body month after month. And I know I've told the story before on this podcast, but it's it's so worth repeating for those who haven't heard it, that she realized she was

participating bodily in the mystery of the passion of Christ and what happened at the cross. And just as Christ's heart was pierced by that Lance, so was the bride's heart pierced. What did Simeon say to Mary? A sword will Pierce your heart also. And month after month, she was experiencing that piercing. And that piercing became supernaturally fertile. That couple will enter into

heaven. And when they do, they will meet a super abundant number of spiritual children who are in heaven because of their willingness to participate in the supernatural fecundity of the marriage bed of the cross. More are the children of the barren woman More, more. That's the more we're talking. About such a beautiful promise. Our next question is also from an anonymous listener.

My husband and I have been married for 38 years. Getting married, I had many insecurities and abandonment wounds. My father passed away when I was three years old. My mother never remarried. My siblings were much older and left the house after getting married, hence more abandonment. My husband's love language is touch and quality time. He did not get a lot of either one of those from his parents because they were farmers and

his dad demanded a lot from his mother. They were loving and good in their own ways. Because of our woundedness, we had a lot of immoral actions in our marriage, dressing inappropriately at home and on vacation. At least 10 years of nudist resorts. More on the hedonistic side. I'm further on my journey thanks to counselling and diving deep into our Catholic faith. I'm honestly not sure where he

is on his journey. Sometimes I have trouble being naked or wearing certain clothes in front of him because I feel like I'm being stalked or pressured to be intimate. He makes so many comments about my body and he can stare uncomfortably. He gets very turned on by me which is good but sometimes it seems too much to me. He has said if we could walk around naked in our house all the time that would be great for him.

Any thoughts on what steps I can take to have a healthier response to my husband? Bless you, my dear sister, bless you. Thank you for trusting us with the real and intimate struggles of your heart and your marriage. I, I just want to honor your honesty and honor your questions, your sufferings. I just, I feel great reverence

for this dear sister of ours. I I don't know who she is, but I just feel tenderness towards her heart. So raw and so honest, so real. Here's here's where my heart is led to go. I think your instincts are correct, that your husband's desire to see your nakedness is

is caught up in paradigm that does not do justice to your dignity as a person. And I think that's where the uneasiness comes from. I love that you recognize that it's good that your husband is attracted to you. It's good that he wants to see you naked. It's good that he's aroused by your nakedness. That's all in itself. At the deepest level, it's good.

But something's gotten twisted up here. The the principle that is so important here and in all of life, people who are familiar with my teaching have heard me say it 100 times or 1000 times. The devil doesn't have his own clay. Sin is a twisting, a distortion of a fundamental goodness, right? The thing that's gotten twisted here is that original,

beautiful, holy experience of nakedness without shame, right? Nakedness without shame is the way God made us. We, we cannot enter back into that nakedness without shame, without undergoing radical, deep, long term, painful purifications. And if we try the, the, the,

the, the desire to enter into that, the desire to live naked without shame is good. It's a desire to return to Eden. And that's powerful. That's at its root. It's holy. But thinking we can just leap into a nudist resort and all of a sudden be naked without shame. The danger here is that what we will experience is not nakedness

without shame, but shameless nakedness. What's the difference between nakedness without shame and shameless nakedness? Nakedness without shame is the experience of nakedness in which there's no need to cover the body because the body is being properly honored as the revelation of the mystery of the dignity of the person and God's glorious, beautiful plan for us to love in His image and

likeness. Shameless nakedness is an experience of nakedness in which you are exposing yourself to lust. What is lust? Lust is Eros without agape. Lust is sexual desire that is not informed and inspired by divine love. Lust is an inversion of the sexual appetite where the desire

is not. This is my body given for you. But there's your body and I'm taking it for me now. There's no doubt in my mind that your husband, just like any man on the planet, is a mixture of wheat and weeds growing together. Your husband is not 100% weeds. There's good wheat in there. There's good wheat in there and it should be blessed and it should be affirmed. The good wheat in there should be blessed and affirmed.

But you are not crazy to recognize there's some weeds in there too, and they should not be blessed and affirmed. You should not pour water on the weeds. Should you just go in there and uproot the weeds? Well, what did Jesus say about that? Don't go in there and attempt to uproot the weeds too hastily, because if you do that, what else is going to come up with it? The good wheat. The good wheat can get pulled up with it and the catechism tells

us that until the end of time, I don't care if your Mother Teresa, I don't care if you're John on the cross or Saint John Paul the 2nd until the end of time in every one of us, the wheat and the weeds will grow together. The bottom line question here, that was all background. Now to get to this bottom line question is what would what can she do to how did she put it? How? What can I do to? Have a healthier response to my

Have a. Healthier response to your husband what is needed is for you with God's grace and help to discern where's the wheat in my husband's heart where are the weeds and to water the wheat water the wheat, water there's there's even the weeds even what's distorted in your

husband's heart. Remember look at the very word distorted. What does that mean? Something good is twisted even when you see the twisted reality. To be able to recognize behind this distortion is something good that got distorted. And the ability to tease out what is good even in the midst of what is twisted up. This is what love does.

This is what love involves. Or think of Jesus with the the woman at the well. Think of Jesus with the woman caught in adultery. He was able to see what was good in these, in the desires of these people's hearts, and draw it out without condemnation. Is no one here to condemn you? He says to the woman caught in adultery. I do not condemn you either. But then there's the call to to go and sin no more. There's the call to virtue.

There's the call to holiness, your affirmation of the deepest desires of your husband's heart without blessing or affirming what is distorted in your husband's heart is going to call out of your husband's heart more and more the true, the good and the beautiful. And it means loving him through all his childhood wounds that led him here. It means it means showing mercy on the ways that his distortions have led to real pain in your marriage and real sin in your

marriage. Genuine love covers a multitude of sins and not just covers them over, but restores what's distorted into goodness. But the only path there is through the cross. Through the cross, by opening your sufferings, genuine, very real sufferings in union with the the sufferings of Christ, uniting your sufferings with Christ becomes redemptive for your marriage.

What does that look like? It it means doing what you're already doing, opening your pain. You've opened it to us in such a an honest, trusting way. Do that also with Jesus in your life of prayer. Write a long letter to Jesus speaking to Jesus from your heart about what you have suffered in your marriage. It might be 25 pages long. It might be a 100 pages long.

Or just get it all out and give it to G. It might take you a year to get it all out. Get it all out to Jesus and place it in the open wound of His heart on the cross and let the flood of life giving water come to redeem those sins. Redeeming sins does not mean just pretending they didn't happen. It means entering into the roots of those sins and, and grabbing

it by the coattails and, and, and turning it inside out, restoring the distortion to its original glory. That is the promise. That is the path we're on. Our whole life is that path. If we let Jesus in, He's knocking on the door of your heart. And if you open the door, all these pains, all these memories, open all those doors. He will come in and eat with you. That is his promise. That means He will offer you his body and blood and you will, you

will receive the true bridegroom and that will become the source of redemption in your marriage. It's not a magic trick. It's not a once and done. It's a taking up your cross every day and following. But but there is real concrete fruit that comes from making that journey every day. Such powerful stuff. I just found myself thinking a little bit about the fact that she said she's on this journey

both learning more about the Catholic faith and in counseling. And I just wondered if because she knows her husband so well, they've been married for 38 years, if, if she might find ways to share a little bit about that journey with him. And she said, I don't really know where he is on his journey. So there are obviously things that they don't regularly talk about since she doesn't really

know. But, but I think that the learning your faith and prayer and counseling are kind of opening her eyes to some realities that are really important and maybe have been stuffed down or ignored. And finding ways to share a little bit about that with your husband is, I think, going to be really helpful.

It will open up conversations. I could also imagine even talking about those vacations at the hedonistic nudist resorts, like in some way to, to maybe open up a conversation about, you know, what, what was really the story of the people that we were vacationing with there? What was going on underneath and, and why did we and they choose that kind of vacation?

What, but were we sort of trying to distract ourselves from I'm I'm not trying to put words in your mouth. It's just that I feel like dialogue, not not saying here's what it is, Here's what I've learned shape up. But but really, entering into a sharing of what you're learning and a desire to know him better, I think could be part of that watering of the wheat in his heart. Good words, Wendy, good words. We know that we deal with heavy

themes on this podcast, and sometimes our responses, I'm sure, can stir more questions in your heart than you had before you even listen to the episode. And we're not pretending we're giving definitive answers here. But I want to hold out a resource. If you have an answer, a question about the Catholic faith and you're looking for sound answers, try truthfully. Truthfully is a sponsor of this

show. And we, we have, obviously if we're ever going to have some sponsor, we're, we're going to be very discerning here. And I, I have my reservations about artificial intelligence, but it can be put to good use. And I think truthfully is putting artificial intelligence to good use. It has this vast database of the writings of the Saints, the writings of the fathers, the writings of the popes over the years, all, all the teachings of

the Magisterium. And when people submit questions on Truthfully, that's where it's drawing to give answers. So try out truthfully. If you have a question about the Catholic faith, I think you'll find it valuable and keep the questions coming our way 'cause we love doing this podcast and and we're so happy you're part of it. If you've been blessed by Today, our show, would you hit that share button to help us get this podcast to a wider audience?

We'd be very grateful. You are a gift to us and it's a joy for us to be a gift to each of you. And Lord, we pray for the grace that all of us would. Become what we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W. It's brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed

councillors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode