Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Getting married with same-sex attraction, His sexual past hurts me, and Am I a failure without a big Catholic family?| ACW363

Dec 15, 202553 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

-This episode is sponsored by Truthly- Questions answered this episode: There are many stories of Catholic men who experience same-sex attraction and go on to marry and have families, even though their predominant attraction remains toward men. Many encourage others not to dismiss marriage before exploring whether God could be calling them to it. I’m honestly confused. Would it be right for me to pursue a relationship with a woman without being attracted to her, without longing to share in the marital embrace? Some say attraction to their wives arose later in dating, but it doesn’t seem right to start a romantic relationship without attraction. I’ve been struggling for many months with the sexual past of my boyfriend. It’s been really difficult not to take it personally - feeling deeply hurt and offended that he didn’t wait for me, even though we didn’t know one another when those things occurred. He is now committed to living chastely after realizing that fornication was unfulfilling and a lie, thanks be to God. How can I place the proper weight on his past without taking it personally in a way that sabotages the beautiful relationship we’ve built? I converted to the Catholic faith 7 years ago from an atheistic background. From my parents I have a strong inclination to be a perfectionist, even during the marital embrace. I’m anxious not to fail, and I often think I will be a failure if we don’t get 3 children. We have 2 on earth and 1 in heaven. I feel unworthy compared with traditional huge Catholic families. How can I get rid of this anxiety and be free? Resources: Colorado Ski Retreat with Christopher Sexual Integration & Redemption Course Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Happy advent everybody. Yes. Hi listeners. Christmas is soon upon us. Joyous season. It's the celebration of the theology of the body. I often say to my audiences, and you've been to a lot of my talks, haven't you, Wendy? So you may have heard me say

this on an occasion or two. If you believe in Christmas, you believe. In the theology of the. Body in the theology of the body because this is a quote from JP 2. Through the fact that the Word of God became flesh, the body entered theology. Do you know the next line through the main door? There it is. If it seems strange to speak of your body as a theology, as a revelation of the mystery of God, it shouldn't. If you believe in Christmas.

Do people know this? Do people know that this is what we're celebrating? I don't. I don't get the impression that people really comprehend this, and I'm not claiming I comprehend it because these are mysteries beyond the comprehension. But it's so important that we allow the incarnation, the scandal of the incarnation, the scandal of a God. I'm just going to say it. It's going to scandalize, but

this is the incarnation, the scandal of a God who farted, right? That that's we don't, we don't, we don't, we don't I this, this is the reality. Let's face it, a a God who just loves us in a spiritual way is much more becoming than a God who farted to our typical human sensibilities. He was fully functional in all of his bodily functions. We believe in a God who shat

himself this and his mother had to change the diapers. Yes, this is the living God. We have to deal with it. We have to wrestle with it. And to the extent that we are uncomfortable with our own bodies, we are uncomfortable with the incarnation. And to the extent that we are offended by our own bodies, we are also offended by the incarnation. And I think of that line where Jesus says, blessed are those who take no offense at me.

Yes, the incarnation is a hard teaching. Who can accept it? But Lord, you have the words of eternal life. You are the Word made flesh instead of here. Here's the direction I think we can go and and should go and must go instead of projecting our own offense on our bodies onto the incarnation. Well, let's look at it from the other direction. If God took on flesh, then the flesh is something to be reverenced and honored and even venerated.

And let's let that sink into the way we approach our bodies and treat our bodies. That's that's kind of what we're all about here at the Theology of the Body Institute. Isn't that the truth? And you just mentioned Truth, which just reminded me that this episode of the Ask Christopher W podcast, hosted by Wendy W is sponsored by by. Truthly. Truthly have you guys heard of this new AI app called Truthly? Yes, I want to put a plug in for

this AI app because not only because they're sponsoring this episode, I wouldn't have them sponsor this episode if I didn't believe in what they were doing. You know, we've had other people approach us to do sponsorships and I'm like, I don't want to promote that to our audience 'cause I don't really believe in it myself. But you know, the AI era is upon us and there are concerns about it. In fact, we are in the midst here at the Institute of developing a program, including a little book I'm working on to

address the whole AI question. And there are concerns, There are concerns about it, but they're also great benefits in this technology. And we can and should take advantage of them to promote the Catholic faith. And that's what truthly, truthly, which is TRUTHLY, that's what these guys are doing. And you can go on to truthly and ask any question about the Catholic faith. And since we are AQ and a podcast, I thought our listeners are obviously people who have

questions about the Catholic faith and they want to grow and learn. And I thought this could be of great value to them. It's devoted to authentic Catholic teaching. Everything you're going to be receiving when you ask truthfully a question is rooted in Scripture, in tradition, in the Saints, in the great theologians. Everything is faithful to the Church. I've asked Truthly some questions of my own. This was interesting. I asked truthly what is truthly and this is what I got.

Truthly is artificial intelligence through a Catholic lens. Truthly is built to stay faithful to the Magisterium while help while helping you navigate the world. My purpose is to provide clear, accurate answers grounded the Scripture tradition in the Magisterium while fostering A deeper understanding and appreciation of the Catholic faith. I also asked Truthfully, who is Christopher West? Oh, really? Yeah, look what they said here. Am I to read this? Go ahead, OK? Christopher W is a renowned Catholic author and speaker, widely recognized for his work on the theology of the Body, a

series of teachings by Pope John Paul the Second on human sexuality, love, and the divine purpose of the human life. Get to the part where it says Christopher W talks about how Jesus farted. It does. Not. I'm kidding. It is kind of long actually. They did have a rather long answer about, yeah, who I am, yeah. So if any of our listeners are interested, you can get truthfully at the Apple App Store or Google Play. And yeah, give it a shot. I think it's worth it. 7 day free trial. Awesome, now we need an update

from the Theology The Body Institute. We do, and I have something very exciting to share. Go for it, Wendy. You know what? I love to do you. Love to ski, man. I love to ski, and guess who else loved to ski? Pope John Paul the Second. Pope John Paul the 2nd. And guess what Pope John Paul the second would do? He would take people on ski retreats where they would ski during the day and then gather in the evening and talk about the theology of the body and that's what we're going to do.

The Theology of the Body Institute has partnered with JP 2 Trails, which is run by Jason Everett, and Jason Everett has partnered with Core Expeditions from Wyoming Catholic College. I love this body of Christ coming together. Tooby Institute core expeditions, JP 2 trails. We have joined forces for a Colorado ski retreat in Breckenridge, Co. We have reserved a huge private

residence that can sleep up to I think we can accommodate 30 people. So it's a really nice lodge like private Airbnb type place. We did this last year in Where did we go last year? I think Utah. Utah. Yeah, we went to Utah last year. It was glorious. Lives were changed. We would ski during the day, come together at night, have share meals, have conversation. And then I'd teach. I'd unfold the vision of JP 2's teaching, and lives were deeply,

deeply impacted. Check out the link in the show notes to learn more. Spots are going to go fast. If you want to go on a ski retreat with yours truly, I can't wait to ski with you, be with you, share meals with you. From March 9th to the 13th, we're going to be skiing at Arapahoe Basin and at Copper Mountain. These are my old stomping grounds. When we lived in Colorado, this is where I would ski. For sure. So yeah, check out the link. Would love to have you join us. That sounds great.

All right, now I'm ready to give you a question. Are you ready to hear? I'm ready. I'm ready. This is from a patron, an anonymous patron. I'm so grateful for the work you 2 do. I've listened to hundreds of your episodes and your reflections have shaped my heart and my mind deeply. Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful. I'm a man in my 20s and for as long as I can remember I've experienced same sex attraction. Over the course of the last year, I've experienced a great deal of growth in my sexuality and in my understanding of my masculinity.

Beautiful. Though I've never engaged in a romantic relationship with a man, I was and am still in need of much healing. I have been free of pornography and masturbation for about 8 months after engaging in these behaviors frequently since age 12. I have a deep sense that the Lord does not prohibit same sex relationships because He wants to deprive us of something, but because He wants to give us everything to protect us, His children, from evil and bring about our flourishing.

Wow, well that is a work of grace just right there. I just have to shout it out that in a culture, the culture we live in today and the pressure, pressure, pressure to just embrace this as this is the way God made me. I'm going to go down this path. This is my path to happiness. For him to to resist that swim against that stream and proclaim what he just proclaimed, that is an amazing work of grace. My question pertains to discerning a vocation while

experiencing same sex attraction. There are many stories of Catholic men who experience same sex attraction and go on to marry and have families even though their same sex attraction is still present and remains their predominant attraction. Many of these men encourage other men with similar experiences not to dismiss the vocation of marriage before exploring whether God could be calling them to it. I'm honestly confused by these stories. Would it be right for me to pursue a relationship with a woman without being attracted to

her? Without feeling a longing in my heart to share in the in the marital embrace? Some of the Catholic men I referred to earlier have suggested that sexual attraction to their wives arose well into their dating relationship. To me, it doesn't seem quite right to initiate a romantic relationship with a woman without being attracted to her, which leaves me wondering what the right disposition toward marriage is for me. God bless you, brother. I, I can understand this

question and why it poses A dilemma to you. And I don't want to pretend that I can give you some definitive answer that will relieve the dilemma because I do think a certain tension and a certain dilemma remains even in those who have chosen this path to marry and to raise a family. And, and, and let's just clarify.

I'm so glad he's using the word Mary in the only true sense of the word, right? It, it kills me that I even have to clarify in our world that we're talking about a man marrying a woman. This is the the rotten fruit that we we need to clarify what the word marriage means. This is the rotten fruit of having redefined the term as if it were possible for two men or two women to marry each other. For all of human history until the the 2000's, the term

marriage has always meant a man and a woman in every culture on planet earth. And it still means that. But we all know what's going on in the culture. So these things need to be clarified. So the dilemma that remains is that yes, I know men, some with whom I'm I'm close and are dear friends of mine, who their predominant struggle in their sexuality has been same sex attraction. They've married women and they have learned what it means to love a woman.

That does not mean they don't still have temptations within them that pull them in a direction contrary to the truth of marriage. But guess what? Everyone, Everyone who gets married has desires within them from their fallen humanity that pull them in a direction that is contrary to the truth of marriage.

It's called concupiscence. I must battle every day in my life. I mean, sometimes the battle is more intense than others, but I can recognize the pool in my heart, in my fall in humanity, on a, on A at least a weekly, if not daily basis. A temptation, a pool, a tug to direct my heart in a way that would be unfaithful to you, my wife and I have to every day choose with an act of my will,

which itself is a gift of grace, to be able to make this choice. But with the act of grace that empowers my will to choose it, I must open my heart to grace, to redirect my heart, to turn it back to the truth of what it means, to direct my life towards fidelity. To you, Wendy, this is just part and parcel of the fallen condition, and in some sense the battle of a man whose attractions in his fallen

humanity pull him towards his own sex. In some sense it's a very similar battle that he must learn to use his will every day to resist his fallen humanity, to open his fallen humanity to the real workings of grace, to redirect his desires towards what it means to love his wife. I I think one thing that we can learn through this situation

where a man who might have strong tendencies towards same sex attraction, who chooses to marry a woman. What we learn here is that the premium placed on our culture on sexual attraction is misguided. It's placing the emphasis in the wrong place. It's it's giving us a skewed understanding of where love is most deeply rooted.

Love is not most deeply rooted in the inclinations of our sexual attractions. Love is most deeply rooted in the will, in the will to choose another every day of your life to make the choice. I choose you. I'm choosing to love you. I'm choosing against my fallen inclination, which would take me in a very different direction

than loving you. That's where my fallen humanity would take me in a very different direction than loving you. And I must choose every day, through an act of my will, to open my fallen humanity to God's grace, to direct me, to Orient me to, to channel all of my energies in the direction of loving my chosen spouse. And that choice can be made regardless of what our fallen

humanity is pulling us toward. And I think that's one of the key takeaways. I think that's one of the most important things we can learn from those men and women who who struggle with same sex attraction, but have chosen freely chosen to marry in the true sense of the word and surrender their fallen humanity every day. Which I'll say it again, everyone has to do to surrender

their fallen humanity every day to the work of grace to enable us to learn what it means to love. Now, I wanted to say that first I, I want to, to discredit the amount of credit that the culture puts in sexual attraction, right? The culture is pushing us to think that sexual attraction is love, right? And if it is love, if sexual attraction is love, well, then

what you're saying is a man who has same sex attraction could never love a woman. I, I want to discredit that that is not true. There's a truth in there that has gotten exaggerated. And the truth that is in there is this sexual desire, sexual attraction is one of the elements that John Paul the second would call the raw material of love, the raw material of love, right? It can be built into love as raw material can be built into a

building, right? It can be built into love. But if that raw material, these are JP 2's words, if, if we allow that raw material to be swept away by the wrong gravitational pull, the raw material of sexual attraction can turn not into love, but in into its direct opposite. And that's where JP 2 himself is saying, don't place the identity of love in your sexual attractions.

Sexual attractions must be deeply informed and transformed by divine grace if they are to serve the purpose of love. And I know friends of mine, men I am close to, men who have shared their stories with me, whose predominant battle in their fallen humanity has been same sex attraction. And yet they have chosen. They have opened their hearts to

God's grace to inform their choice. And they have chosen by an act of will. I am choosing this woman because I want to learn how to love this woman. And they must make that choice every day. They will have additional struggles. They will have additional battles that I don't face. But that does not mean I don't face my own kind of battles. And everyone, everyone, male and female, we are fallen. And if we are to learn what married love is, we must surrender our fallen humanity

every day to the working of grace. And what I want to under score is it's the same path in that sense for those who struggle is same sex attraction. So we all have fallen inclinations that need to be surrendered to grace, and in this sense the struggle is the same. Not exactly the same, but much more similar than dissimilar. One of the things I think I can assume, but I just want to clarify for our listeners, is

that you're talking about people who are honest with their wives. Yes. Oh, this yes, yes, this is just assumed. You're you're you're the other person in the relationship would have to know fully the the situation and also choose freely with full knowledge. I understand this is my future husband's or my future wife's struggle. And I am choosing freely to

learn to love this person. Yeah, if, if, if it were hidden, this would be grounds for an annulment. If that kind of information were withheld, that would invalidate the marriage. So right now I just want to say something just out of love for those women who are married to men with this struggle or men who are married to women with this struggle. Because although all of us struggle, there is a way in which it could be particularly

pointedly painful to know that that is my spouse's struggle at times. Even if you knew it going in, even if you like in one part of you said, I get it. I get it's a fallen world and I I get this person's story and know how this all came to be, or I have some sense of it and I love this person. Yet there would certainly be lonely moments where the particular pain of of knowing

that struggle would would sting. And I, and I just want to just say a quick, just a moment of prayer for those people that maybe hear this answer and think, you know, it's all true, but it's hard. You know, it's, it's got its own hard thing. And so, Lord, I just lift up couples that have this as their story, married couples who are in this reality. And I thank you so much for the grace of their sacraments, Lord, that you are their bond, that

you are the faithful one who loves them both for their redemption, for their healing, for their full healing, Lord. And they're on that journey together. And I ask you to strengthen them in their marriages. And I ask a particular blessing on those who are married to someone with the same sex attraction. Just Lord, let them know today that you see them, you know

them, you cherish them, they are beautiful, wonderfully made by you, and that all of this confusion and pain in this world that they are bearing with is is redemptive for them and for their spouses. We know that's true of every marriage, but today I just feel the need for that word to be, I don't know. I've just spoken to these people. Lord, thank you. Thank you, Lord, thank you, Lord, that you love us in our fallenness. You love us right there, and you

call us to love one another as you love us. Which means we're all on the journey of learning how to love ourselves as fallen human beings and learning how to love other fallen human beings in their fallenness 'cause that's how you love us. Lord. Show us the path, Lord, show us the way. Show us the calling of love. And show us the grace that you have poured out is sufficient for us. It is sufficient for us to learn how to love.

Thank you Jesus. I also want to say something specifically to this questioner about his sense of kind of not wanting to mislead women. And I just want to offer you an idea because I can sense that you're getting some ideas from some men who have spoken somewhat publicly. I don't know where exactly. You didn't say how you learned of these people. Maybe whether you know them personally or encountering them somewhere through the Internet, I'm not sure. But there's something where

you're saying, OK, they're describing this, but somehow I can't, I can't fully see my path there. I don't know how to go there because I, I care too much about the woman that I, you know, if I'm not attracted to her, like if I don't desire the marital embrace, like, what does that do to her heart? You know, and I think that's a beautiful sensitivity that you. Have sensitivity, Yeah. And I just want to hold out to the possibility that you say to

the Lord if this is your will or give me some taste of that desire. Doesn't have to be the full experience of the desire in the same way that maybe another man might experience it, but but just give me a sign of it, give me some hint of it so that I can know a real pull in my heart that's beyond friendship. I I want to feel that I'm

remembering a story of a man who had struggled the same sex attraction. And as he was going on his healing journey, there was a moment when he he noticed the the pink cheek of a woman and, and the pinkness kind of shocked him in the way that he was feeling something like tingling in his heart over seeing her pink cheek. And it was just a little hint and a sign to him of like, I

could be drawn to this feminine beauty. And, and I don't know what the Lord has in store for our questioner, but I just felt like honouring that sense that he has that like he, he feels a, a, just a, a sense of protectiveness for a woman that that this is important. So I I just want. To I don't know the, the, the fact that is this your point, Wendy, the fact that he already has the sense of of protectiveness for the woman, not wanting to misguide her is already the awakening of a

genuine love for that for that woman. I guess my point is, I mean that could be, I think he means it a little bit more abstractly. I don't think there's a particular woman yet that he's speaking about, but but it. Shows it shows that he's wanting to love rightly. Love rightly, yes. And that's a beautiful thing. Grace is at work in your life, brother, and it just occurs to me to invite you to consider coming to our Sexual Integration and Redemption course at the end of February 2026.

This is led by the ministry team from Desert Stream and the program that they offer around the world is called Living Waters and it it really gets into root causes, root issues, root struggles for all the ways that we are sexually wounded and relationally broken. And I do believe you could find grapefruit if you were able to come. So check out the link in the show notes. And if money is an issue, we will do what we can, apply for a

scholarship. We will do what we can to raise those funds to enable you to attend. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Hi Christopher and Wendy, thank you for showing up here each week to shine a bit of light in an area sexual morality where there is often so much confusion. I have been struggling for many months with the sexual past of my boyfriend. It's been really difficult for me not to take these things of his past personally, feeling

deeply hurt and offended that he didn't wait for me even though we didn't know one another when those things had occurred. He is now committed to living chastely after realizing that fornication was unfulfilling and a lie, thanks be to God. My question is, how can I place the proper weight on his sexual past without taking things personally in such a way that it will sabotage the beautiful relationship that we've built? My dear sister, bless you, bless you, bless you.

I just want to reverence that very legitimate pain in your heart. And I do not think that pain in your heart is an obstacle in and of itself to a rich, beautiful relationship. I do not think that pain in and of itself will sabotage your relationship. The question is, what do you do with that pain?

And it's not so much I shouldn't feel this pain. You are right to feel that pain because your heart is designed for fidelity. Your heart, your person, your, your being as a woman, body and soul is designed by God to receive a man who has not given himself to another.

You are meant to be the one and the only to receive that gift and to be that gift to him. I want to return to that truth in a moment, but what I want to say is that pain you feel is a sign that your heart is properly aligned with God's will and your own dignity and his dignity. And so when that dignity has

been violated, it causes pain. That pain could sabotage and would sabotage your relationship if that pain became bitterness, resentment, A a, a, a kind of self-righteous accusation aimed at your. Did she say she's dating? Is she engaged? Is she boyfriend? Boyfriend. Now I don't know what God's plan

is for your future, but I'm going to speak as if this man is meant to be your husband. Do I know that that is the case? I do not know that that is the case. But I'm surmising from the depth that this, the depth of the pain this has caused you, that the two of you are in a serious enough relationship that you are discerning your future and entertaining and asking the Lord discerning are we called to marriage. So I want to speak in, in terms of the possibility that this man might be your husband.

I remember in our time of engagement over 30 years ago, when when you and I were engaged and it was a topic of conversation that I had not saved myself sexually. I had been in a sexually active relationship. But you, you had saved yourself. And I remember the day of a a great light that shone on my heart.

And it was the realization that it is a terrible injustice. We were maybe, I don't know, two or three months away from our our wedding. And I realized it was a terrible injustice to the dignity of the marital act for me to say I had already done that with someone else. I had never engaged in the marital act. I had engaged in a cheapening, A counterfeit version of the

marital act, which was not the marital act. It was not a true marital act. And that is the injustice that I had defamed and degraded the true, beautiful, glorious meaning of sexual intercourse. The The true glorious meaning of sexual intercourse is the bodily expression and renewal of wedding vows. Our bodies have a language and they proclaim the truth of God's love. And God's love is a spousal love.

I will never leave you, I will never forsake you. I am with you forever. I am faithful to you. I have come so that you might have life and have it to the full. Love is free. Divine love is free. It is total, is faithful, it is fruitful. And that is exactly what a man and a woman commit to at the altar. And when they come together in their marriage bed, they are meant to be expressing with the language of their bodies that divine kind of love. I am yours freely, totally, faithfully. And if it is God's will, let

there be life. I had never expressed that with any other human being ever. What I expressed with another human being was a fallen desire for sexual pleasure and and mutual use. That's that's the hard cold reality of it. There were elements of love present. I love this person I was with to a certain extent, as best I knew how when I was 17/18/19 years

old. But I didn't know what love was. And that's why she broke up with me 'cause I didn't know how to love her. I didn't know how to love her. I didn't know how to love her. And so I realized a few months before our wedding, what's going to happen on our wedding night I have never experienced in my whole life. And that is the appropriate recognition. Because if I were to say I have experienced this, I would be bringing the same cheap expression of sexuality into our

marriage. And I don't want to do that. My point in all of this is to say conversion is real. Conversion is real, and fornication is not the marital act. And in a very real, very true sense, if you are to marry this man, if he's meant to be your husband, and if he understands in his heart, if Grace has sufficiently worked in his heart that he understands the true meaning of the marital embrace, then you can without kidding

yourself in any way. But speaking truthfully and sincerely and standing on a solid rock, you can say what is going to happen on our wedding night will be the first for both of us. Because neither of us have ever experienced the marital embrace, the free, total, faithful, fruitful self giving of marital love. So I want to hold that out to you. I want you to hold that in your heart. I want you to open that in your heart to the Lord and let the

Lord shine that light on your heart and that you can stand on that truth. That's one thing I want to share. Another thing I want to share is I've already said if that pain, and you're right to feel the pain and the pain, the pain isn't, it should not be put in these terms. He's already done this with someone else. We've already clarified he's never done this. If this is the marital act, he's

never done that with anyone. But the pain that you feel in the heart is, is that this man has cheapened, has engaged in sexual acts that cheapened the true meaning of sexuality. And the pain that you feel is also in part the pain that he's in. He caused himself pain. I'll never forget, Wendy, when I when you and I had the the the

real honest conversation that we need to had. We are had needed to have. We were early in our relationship and but it was getting serious. And you had known already about my sexual past because we met when I was giving a witness talk about how I gave my life to Christ and, and that was part of my story. So you knew that from the day we met that I had the sexual past. And I knew I needed to just put it out in the open with you and, and talk about it. And we did talk about it. And I, I could tell you were very sad as I shared what I

shared with you and you shared with me that a large portion of your sadness was the pain that I had caused myself, the pain that I was in for my own bad choices. And that was the sign that your love was, was very deep for me. It was very sincere. And you were not only wallowing and you hurt me, you hurt me. You were, you're not wallowing, you were, you were feeling in

your heart genuinely the pain that I was in. And you were willing to carry that in your heart and offer it as a prayer. And this is what I want to suggest to you, your pain, dear sister who's asked this question, your pain can become a profound prayer for your boyfriend for his healing. You can open that pain to the presence of the Holy Spirit, and the Holy Spirit can transform your pain into compassion for this man you love who has caused

himself so much pain. And he caused these other people, person or persons, a lot of pain. And your pain can become a prayer also for them, also for them. And this is how the pain becomes something beautifully, beautifully redemptive. The pain itself gets transformed into love. And when pain is transformed into love, guess what?

It's no longer an obstacle to love. It's love itself. It becomes love. This is the mystery of the cross, the pain that we caused Christ by nailing Him to a tree. That pain was transformed into love. Yeah, I I think that's a very beautiful answer. Very honoring of her experience and his experience, because that's the two that are, you know, in this situation of having this as part of now their

story, not just his story, but their story. And just something I just want to add there is that, you know, this relationship of, of dating and of discerning marriage and. Marrying and being lifelong partners, if that's what happens, is a journey and we have stages to any journey. And there may very well be stages in this journey where

pain or issues from his past or your past become very present, very maybe triggered by circumstances or it's just God's timing that he's bringing them up in your hearts and and you need to look at them more deeply. Like, first of all, like how awesome that that's part of the human journey, that we aren't just always the same, that we're growing, that we're getting to know more, how much the Lord loves us and, and how nothing in our stories beyond his redeeming

reach. But the process of opening things up and looking at them in order for them to be healed is deeply human, deeply vulnerable reality. And like, if we feel called to marriage, we're signing up for that. And so I just, you know, ask you as you pray through your pain. And as Christopher said, let it be transformed, which is real. It also prepares a place in you

for in the future if if there are things that come up for him where he's experiencing memories or questions or looking at what was even going on in my life and my story that caused me to kind of medicate myself that way. Because sometimes relationships and and sinful sexual activities are like a medication for our pain. So maybe he's just feeling like a desire to look at that. What was his story? What was going on? When you have already

established, like when there's pain, invite the Lord in. Let him shine his light like you're, you're preparing yourself to be ready to love him in that next stage and to experience your next stage. Because it's not something that we can just, I don't know, flush it all out right now and be done with it or something. That's not how humans work. So I just want to encourage you. That's been Christopher's and my experience. Like, yes, there were profound graces that came during our engagement that are precious to

both of us. And we have held on to those graces, but we've also experienced furthering of, of conversations about some of the memories, questions that I had early on, you know, about like what the nature of that relationship was or those experiences were that I was very grateful when Christopher was willing to answer those questions. But also just times that that pains and, and deeper meanings of these experiences we're

present for Christopher. And and my just feeling that I was called and prepared by the Lord to love Him through those things was a great gift. It was a great gift and remains a great gift to me. Wendy, you, you, you have loved me so well through those things and your love has been so healing. And that's, that's the gift of authentic love. It, it binds our wounds, it's oil on our wounds and that's incredibly healing.

Thank you, Lord. Our next question is from a listener named Paul. Hi, Paul. I converted to the Catholic faith seven years ago from an atheistic background. Wow. From my parents, I have a strong inclination to be a perfectionist. Even during the marital embrace, I'm anxious not to fail. I often think that I will be a failure if we don't get three children. We have two on earth and one in heaven.

I'm feeling unworthy in comparison with the traditional huge Catholic families. How can I get rid of this anxiety and be free? Paul, God bless you, brother. From one recovering perfectionist to another, Bless you. Do you know, Paul, about the book I wrote about my own struggles with perfectionism? It's called What's it called Love? Is. Oh yeah, Love is patient, but I'm not. And then the subtitle is

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist. There are a lot of stories in there, Paul, that I think you'll be able to relate to. This is what comes to me to share with you in light of your specific question. Even before you said it and Wendy read it to me that you're comparing yourself to other families. I just kept hearing that word. It was like a neon lights comparison, comparison, comparison that that you are comparing yourself to some imaginary standard of of what a

Catholic man is supposed to be of what the marital embrace is supposed to be of, of what a Catholic family is supposed to look like. Those supposed to's. I would really encourage you, strongly encourage you take all of those comparisons, all of those supposed to look like X, fill in the blank and submit them to the heart of Christ.

Journal it out every day in your prayer time. Just say Jesus, I have this notion that a Catholic family is supposed to look like this and write it out and just say, Lord, where did this come from? Where is your voice in this? What are you asking of me? There are so many different ways of living a a Catholic family life. Every married couple is a culture unto its own. The the details and intimate secrets of the marriage bed are

are exactly that secrets for for that married couple. And every married couples marriage bed is going to be different because you have two totally unique, unrepeatable human beings coming together in the marital embrace. And every human being reveals a beam of God's glory that no other human being reveals. And every married couple brings that their two beams of God's glory together. That reveals a a combo beam of God's glory in the world that no other marriage reveals. And guess what that means, Paul?

It means comparing yourself, comparing your marriage, comparing your family to other marriages, to other families is a terrible injustice to your marriage and to your family and to your person, 'cause you're the only you there ever was and ever will be and ever could possibly be. And you're invited into a unique and totally exclusive relationship with Jesus Christ. Now, that does not mean we tailor Jesus Christ to our personal preferences and

desires. I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying the same Jesus who is the same yesterday, today, and forever, wants to have a unique relationship with you. And He's given us his church to show us the true meaning of marriage. He's given us His church to show us what true marital love looks like. But within those bounds of what authentic love is, there are countless expressions of that love. You could have a couple who are called by God to have 12 children. You could have a couple who are called by God to have two children.

You could have a couple called by God, or God is allowed that they don't have any children. They would long for children, but don't have them in any number of situations, countless human varieties of situations. It is it is possible to learn truly what it means to love as Jesus loves. How are you, Paul? How are you called to be you? How are you called to love your wife? Those are questions that only Jesus can answer for you, Paul.

I just invite you ask for the grace to catch yourself comparing yourself to others and surrender it continually to Jesus. That is the path to freedom. Yeah, Paul, I, I think there's so much beautiful ground for you to just kind of till and fertilize and allow goodness to grow rather than this kind of barrenness of the

perfectionistic walk. There's so much more variety and interest in in being a real human being. I'm not saying you're not real, but allowing yourself to be imperfect and experiencing God's love for you in that reality. So I, I'm kind of excited for you that you're even recognizing this and asking for help to invite the Lord into this aspect of your story, which isn't the only thing about you, but it's a

significant thing and it impacts you and it impacts others, impacts your wife and your children that you, you know, have this aspect of comparison and a striving for perfection that's unfair and not, not just to you or to others. So I just want to be also kind to that aspect of you knowing that in some way it has a good intention. You know, it's, it's trying to help you. It's trying to find the measures or the sort of instructions in

the world around to, to know what to aim for. And, and that's a good desire. So I, I don't want to just reject that aspect of you, but I want to speak words to that that are really the words of the Lord. You know, think of that story of, of the prodigal son's return and the tremendous joy in the father, not because this son has been perfect, not because he's done everything right, but but

because he sought the Lord's sought the father's mercy, sought to come where he could be fed in his poverty. And and that's that image of that ground. I see you getting ready to till and it's like it's hard right now. It needs to be turned over and opened up so that the seeds and the rain can really allow you to flourish and allow your wife to flourish and your children to flourish without that that burden of perfectionism.

That's our prayer for you. I have a favor to ask Paul. Perfectionists believe that they're not going to be loved until they get their act together. Please pray for me that I would know that I'm loved in all of my imperfect humanity and I will pray for you. This is a life changing truth. Saints are not perfect people. They are people who know they are perfectly loved in all their imperfections. They are people who know the gift of God's love and that they are called to be a gift.

And they're people who know the grace that enables them to. Become what? They are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode