Questions answered this episode: I’m a prosecutor working with men who’ve abused women. I speak to them about porn, objectification, and Love and Responsibility. What else should I say to reach hearts already hardened by violence? My boyfriend isn’t a virgin, but I am. He’s repented, but I still feel sad and conflicted. Am I allowed to grieve what we’ll never share? If marriage helps us grow in holiness, why does Scripture say the unmarried are more focused on God? Did Jesus contradict marriage by calling Peter away from his wife? Resources: Event in Rome Link COURSE SCHEDULE Join us on one of our pilgrimages! TOBI Event Calendar --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! --- Submit you question here! --- 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ Join us on one of our pilgrimages! If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org List of trusted counselors & psychologists
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Hey Wendy, you know how sometimes I've started our episodes by singing It's a Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood? That's right, you have. Well, I have good reason to sing it today, but I'm not going to because you're going to. Yeah, you are. Go ahead.
Just give it a give it a shot. It's a beautiful day in the neighborhood, a beautiful day for a neighbor. Would you be mine? Why are we singing that? We watched the movie of that name. A beautiful day in the neighborhood, right? Yeah, it's so good. And I would bet that when we saw it in the theater in 2019, we talked about it on an episode. If we want to go back to what would that be like episode 50 or
something, I bet you somewhere back there we talked about it because it's so good. It's so insightful, it's so human, it's so honest. It's so compelling. It's just the human story of pain and hurt and forgiveness and told so well. It's just good art if you're. Looking for the acting the. Acting is.
Powerful. I'm, I, I share this at the dinner table with our kids that I'm like 5050 on Tom Hanks being Mr. Rogers. Like 50% of the time I'm like, yeah, yeah, he's yeah. And then 50% of the time I'm thinking that sounds too much like Forrest Gump. But anyway, that's beside the point that it's it's good art. It's good art and, and it, and it is so beautifully tells the story of, of how Mr. Rogers in his own quirky, soft spoken Mr.
Rogers way, loved people and then loving people changed people's lives. You and I were kids in the 70s Mr. Rogers was a big part of your childhood and mine. And, and I, I, I wonder, like, if, if you could snap your fingers and the impact of Mr. Rogers on our own childhoods was erased, how would how would we be different? Right. We would be because it had some impact. It had.
And I remember as a boy watching Mr. Rogers and my mom would watch it with me and she would be in tears and I'd be like, what, what am I missing out on? I don't know what what's going on in my mind, but it's just because it was a presence of of genuine love for people. And I know that touched my mom's heart deeply and I know it had an impact on mine. So anybody out there looking for good art, a good movie to watch with your family and to talk about a good movie for a married
couple to watch together and talk about it? Yeah. It's it's really a look at the interior journey of dealing with our pain and learning to forgive. Yeah. Anything else you want to share about that, Wendy? Yeah, I'm so glad we watched that together today. It was really, really a gift. Even though Mr. Rogers was a little kids show. This isn't a little kids movie. That's right. It is rated PG, but it's the
things it's dealing with are much more about the adults in the story, not about the children. So just so you know. That yeah, yeah, yeah. When I say family movie like Teens and Up, yeah. Yeah. Good point. Do you have any updates on the TOB? Institute for Us updates to share. Last week I talked about this surprise trip to Rome that I'm going on and we're going to be doing a made for more. We're doing this made for more at some facility that John Paul the Second himself established and had built during his time as
Pope to reach young people. This event made for more is not just for young people. It's not even primarily for young people, but we're we're doing it at this place that John Paul the second established, which is is special to me and we only have a little bit of time to promote it. If you know of anybody who's going to be in Rome for Jubilee events on July 27th, check out the link below and sign up for you have to get a ticket to come to this event so you can check
that out. Another update is where we're at, the very last call for anybody who wants to register for Bill Donaghy's course called Poets for the Kingdom. It's a look at the storytelling of CS Lewis and JRR Tolkien in light of theology, the body. Bill Donaghy is a master at this. He's, he's superb. It will change the way you understand stories and your own
life. And if you're ACS Lewis fan or Tolkien fan already, you'll be more of one. If you're not a fan yet, you'll become one. So check that out. And there was one other thing that I What was that? Oh, another pilgrimage. Oh. Another pilgrimage. That's right, we have a pilgrimage. I am not leading it, but my esteemed colleague and dear friend Jason Clark, Executive Director of the TOB Institute, is leading a pilgrimage to Mexico City in February 2026 to
go see the Tilma. And the chaplain who's also kind of a Co leader of the pilgrimage. He is one of, I would call him one of the top experts on the tilma in the world. And I don't think that's an exaggeration. His name is Father Tim and he has had unprecedented access to the actual Tilma to photograph it with the most high tech modern photography equipment and
he's the only person in the world who's had this access to the tilma. His doctoral dissertation was on John Paul the 2nd and Our Lady of Guadalupe and how the 2GO together in the New Evangelization. So it's going to be an awesome, awesome pilgrimage. I'm sorry I'm not able to go on it myself, but you are in good hands with Jason Clark and Father Tim. So check out the link in the show notes below to register for that pilgrimage. It's in early February 2026. That does sound wonderful. It's going to be awesome.
That's great. Are you ready for a question? I am. I am. This is from a patron named Vitor. Hello Vitor. Dear Christopher and Wendy, I'm 47 years old and live in southern Brazil. I've been meaning to write to you for a long time to thank you from the bottom of my heart for the evangelization work of the Theology of the Body Institute, especially for this podcast, which I started listening to in mid 2023. Hey, Vitor, I'm coming to Brazil in just a few weeks, August 20
something. We'll have the dates and information on that also in the show notes. So check it out. We'd love to meet you. He says I've listened to every episode of the podcast for almost a year and a half, usually during my morning running workouts. I often find myself laughing out loud at Christopher's good humor, praying with Wendy's prayers, and also crying at the stories of suffering from many listeners. And imagine people seeing a man running and having these reactions. They must think I'm crazy. That's great.
The teachings you share with us through this podcast are filled with the anointing of the Holy Spirit and help me greatly on the path to holiness that God wants for my family. I'm married and have two daughters who are 13 and 11. The teachings of Saint John Paul the Second inspired me to start a project at work. I'm a public prosecutor. Specifically, I prosecute people who commit homicides in jury trials. In the last 4 1/2 years in my city, which has a population of just over 500,000, there have
been 30 attempted murders of women in situations of domestic violence and 14 actual homicides of women. Mercy. Mercy, Mercy Jesus. So I started giving talks to men who have restraining orders against their partners because I know that the cause of all this is essentially the sexual revolution. My intention is to explore the philosophical teachings of the book Love and Responsibility and emphasize the harms of pornography for couples, as this type of content encourages the
treatment of women as mere objects. The question I ask is this When faced with domestic violence situations, what else can I emphasize in my lectures for men who already have a history of abusing their partners? Vitor, I think you're right on it. Like, precisely on the cure for this horror. The only cure for sin is to see the human person as he or she
really is, and learn to love the human person as he or she really is. And we could say that all sin involves A blindness or a disregard for the true dignity of the person. So the solution to all of that is to empower people to see the true dignity and value of the person. You're exactly right that this
utilitarian attitude that is fostered and promoted by our culture is at the root of of violence. The sexual revolution, which I don't even like that phrase sexual revolution, the the word sexual is a fine word. It's a holy word. The revolution was a pornographic revolution. And the pornographic revolution is precisely the the rupturing of the body from the soul.
It's this rupture of of the body from the true dignity of what a human being really is. And the very definition of death is the separation of body and soul. So if you're living in a way where in your treatment of other people, you are already separating them, body and soul, in the way you treat them and think of them, which is exactly what pornography does. Pornography is death dealing
because what pornography does is ruptures the body and the soul, and that's what death is. If that's your attitude towards another person, it's not much more than a a, a a hop, skip and a jump from having that attitude to to living it out to carrying it out. If you have a death dealing attitude, it doesn't take a lot to to to go into behavior that dishes out death. So you are not wrong.
You are not wrong to recognize that the healing of all of it is precisely contained in what John Paul the Second teaches in love and responsibility. What are we responsible for in love? We are responsible, John Paul the Second tells us, for upholding the greatness, the dignity of the human person. If the world knew the teachings of love and responsibility, not just knew them intellectually, but knew them in the sense of interiorizing them, there would
be no murder, there'd be no domestic violence. It would come to a halt because the heart would be converted to love and responsibility for the dignity of the person. So stay right there, brother. And the thing you really have gone for you in taking that approach is love and responsibility, as you know, is a philosophical work. It's then that means it's not a work that appeals first to scripture or to, to to faith, but it appeals to genuine human
experiences. And so we can, we can begin this conversation and enter this depth of conversation without any appeal to faith. So it's, it's possible to have these conversations in a, in a secular realm in, in such a way that can prepare people for faith. But faith is not explicitly required to engage in these conversations. So keep going, my brother, you're right on it. And please, please come check the link of my events that I'm doing in Brazil next month,
August 20th, 21st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th. I'm not exactly sure the dates because I'm not looking at my calendar, but they will be there in the link below. And, and if you're able to come, please come say hello to me and just remind me that we addressed your question on the podcast because I'd love to meet you. Something I love about what Vitor shared in his question here is that he he has a job working as a prosecutor. So clearly, you know, needing to
gather and present evidence that would cause people criminals to be punished, but that's his job. But the the fact that his heart being blessed by this vision of human dignity and God's plan for us is causing him to want to prevent more of those things by by like his ability to reach out to these men who have already,
you know, been in some way violent. There's a restraining order, but but like to prevent this from, you know, getting worse. But what, what is the change of heart? And I, I think I love all that he said and you said, and I just kept feeling like these men also need to know their own dignity. Like when you're engaged in such a struggle, when the there's a legal action taken against you, when you've been, you know, caught, you've been accused,
you've been called out for your, you know, violence, your anger, your, the things that are wrong inside you. It can be, I would imagine, hard to know that deep inside you is also you deserve to be treated with dignity and and maybe the not knowing that goes back pretty far in a person's life. And so to also just as you're highlighting the dignity of the
woman, to highlight the dignity of the man and the the ability when you know your own dignity to bring about great good in the world, like I think that's so empowering. So that's just what. I want well said, well said Wendy. I'm I'm reminded just in conclusion on this question of a book I read, gosh, 30 years ago. That said, and it's always stayed with me. Perversion of the life instinct. And that's what human sexuality
is in God's design, right. It's a life giving reality. Perversion of the life instinct begets a death instinct. Think of, you know, just perusing through the movies on Netflix. Think of all the images of provocatively posed men and women with puddles of blood behind them. Or they're holding knives or machine guns or violence, blood and lust all go together.
And the the first rotten fruit of that is abortion. We are willing to kill to indulge our lusts. That's that's what you get when you pervert the life instinct. But here's the good news. The death instinct that comes from lust can be redeemed. And that's why Christ came into the world, his first miracles at a wedding to restore what's been broken in the male female relationship. So let's drink up of that new wine ourselves and share it with others, just as Vtor is doing. Yeah.
Thank you brother, for what you're doing. You're inspiring. Hey everybody, this is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on tour this year. We're going to places like Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Michigan, and also other countries like United Kingdom, Germany, Ecuador, and Brazil. We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our events schedule in the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Peace. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Thanks for all you do. I wanted to hear your advice on the appropriateness of me
feeling sorrow because of the fact that my boyfriend, potentially future husband, isn't a virgin. He lost his virginity years ago, has worked through it with the Lord in confession, and feels deep regret. I'm more not being able to experience it together for the first time in marriage. I feel like I'm almost not allowed to because it's behind him and I shouldn't bring it back up. I don't want to hurt him or make
him feel more ashamed. How do I work through? This bless you, dear listener, bless your heart. I, I, I feel that sorrow in your heart. And it's not inappropriate. It's entirely appropriate that you would feel sorrow. That sorrow is real. Sin is real, and sin brings about sorrow. That is, that is the right response. Sorrow to for sin, sorrow over sin, something that was never
meant to happen has happened. And there is pain in that. And I would invite you, my dear sister, in those tender places in your heart where you feel that pain and that sorrow, to give that to your true bridegroom, Jesus. And let him pour oil on those wounds in your heart. Let him, let him pour the oil of of the Spirit of his Holy Spirit, which is the love of the Trinity, right into those
sorrowful places. Journal it out. Maybe write a letter to Jesus in which you express, without censoring one iota of what you actually feel. Get it all out just as you feel it. Give it all to Jesus in a letter, and then maybe as a sign of handing that over to Jesus, putting it in the fire of his love. Maybe you burn it just as as a
sign that I am letting the flames of Christ's Sacred Heart consume my sorrow. Not that you'll never ever feel it again, but it those symbols can be very, very meaningful to us. And I'd also say this, it reminds me of what I said on last week's episode, which is so pertinent here, so important here in a in a question last week, we were dealing from the opposite perspective. A man who had lost his virginity wrote to us and was talking
about he feels like something irrevocable has been lost. And what if I get married in the future? And what I said to him in last week's episode is so important also for your heart. It is an injustice. It is an injustice, a terrible injustice, to compare what happens in the marital embrace to what is a lustful, non marital and even anti marital sexual act.
It is not the same thing. It is a different species of act because one comes from a lustful utilitarian heart and has no promise being renewed. It's vacated of its true meaning. Whereas what's going to happen if you're called to to this to marriage with this person, What's going to happen is going to be the marital act where so long as your hearts are desiring this, there's no guarantee that
just because you're married that the sexual acts you're engaging in are marital acts. There are loads and loads of married people who are having non marital sex or even anti marital sex. For example, if you're contracepting, if you are rendering the sexual act sterile, that is an anti marital act. That is no longer the marital act, even though the people doing it are married right to. For it to be an authentically marital act, it has to express what marriage is.
And you will stand at the altar. If you were called to marry this man, you too will stand at the altar, and the priest or the Deacon, whatever the case may be, we'll ask you these questions. Have you come here freely to give yourselves wholeheartedly in marriage? And you will say, yes, we have. Do you promise to be faithful all the days of your life? Yes, we do. Do you promise to receive children lovingly from God? Yes, we do. Well, the marital act is the renewal of those promises expressed with the language of
your bodies. As John Paul the Second says, your boyfriend and possible future husband has never expressed that with anybody else. That doesn't mean what he has done is not an injustice. It's precisely an injustice because he engaged in a sexual act that was not marital. That's what makes it an injustice. And if he were to engage in the same kind of act with you, a non marital act, even if you were married, that too would be an injustice.
But know that if the two of you come together and truly are renewing in the language of your bodies those marital promises, well, you are doing something together with him that he's never done with anybody else. Let that sink in and I think it will bring great peace, great peace to your mind and your heart. Not that it will take away the sorrow. The sorrow is that he mocked the marital act. That's the sorrow.
And, and as you pray into that, I think the sorrow will, will transform from a, a sorrow that you might have for yourself into more of a sorrow that you feel for him, that he wounded himself. And that sorrow can become a beautiful prayer of intercession for his healing. Now I know, Wendy, you can speak into this because you you lived through this in our engagement and marriage.
And maybe maybe you want to speak into your own experience there. Yeah, thank you. I, I love all that you said there. I think for me and for us like it we are, we are us. We're, it's our story. And it may not be other people's stories, but there was something helpful to me in that you were willing to answer some questions that I had about that past
relationship as they came up. Wasn't like a, oh, let's talk about every detail all at one go or something. It was more like, let's acknowledge a little bit and like, let me process that 'cause I'm kind of a slow processor. And then maybe sometime much later a question would occur to me. And what you gave to me was a certain feeling that it was safe to ask the question. Not that it wouldn't be painful at all, but that you understood
that I had questions and that where I was coming from was not to be like, as she said, she's afraid of making him more ashamed. Like that wasn't where it was coming from. It was, it was a wanting to understand you and your story and maybe in my innocence and naivete, like understand something more about the world and human beings and their experiences through what you could share with me. So there were different reasons
that I would have questions, but I appreciated that in our relationship, it was a safe thing for me to ask questions. So I just share that and I know that that's not everybody's experience, but it, it was, it was helpful and it would sometimes make me sad and distressed. I mean, that's true human, but it, but it was also, it was like there was something very helpful about it as well to me. So thank you for that. You're welcome, Wendy, and thank
you for the great tenderness and mercy that you have always shown me in my sinfulness. And particularly I remember, I remember when we were first talking about my sexual past when we were dating, because you knew about it, because the, the night Wendy met me, I was giving my conversion story to Christ at a a Christian Fellowship meeting at the University of Maryland, October something of 1991. That's right.
And you were there and I told the whole story of this relationship and how I had been sexually active and because that played such a, a large role in my conversion. And so I knew you knew about my past and, and I knew this day early in our relationship, it was time that we, we talked about it and, and you were so tender with me and showed me such great love. And, and I remember you saying I'm not happy that that happened, but mostly I'm not happy about it because I know of the pain that it caused you.
And there was a beautiful, there's a beautiful selflessness in your sorrow. Not that it didn't also 'cause you pain, as you already mentioned, that's only human, but but there was a beautiful. I mean, that's why Christ weeps over our sin because he's he's weeping for us, because sin hurts US. Sin ruptures us. Sin sin cuts us off from him. His his sorrow about our sin,
his pain for our sin is is is pain for us. And he takes that pain into his own heart. That's something we can all pray for the grace to be sorry for sin the way Jesus is, which is not vindictive. It's not scolding or shaming. It's it's a sorrow for the pain that it causes the Sinner. And, and that's what I
experienced from you, that kind of love. And it helped me heal. And I'm, I'm so grateful to you for that, Wendy. Yeah. And I, I sense some of that as well in our questioner just in her concern about not wanting to, to bring it up and cause him more pain. There's something similar there, yeah. Lord, you know where all these tender places are in our hearts and in our stories and how memories lodge even in our bodies.
And I'm I'm just sensing those words of Scripture as Ioffer this to the Lord. Power went out from his body. And what is that story? It's the story of the woman with the hemorrhage. It's, it's, it's a beautifully spousal reality. I don't think a lot of people think of this, but there's always a spousal theme of one kind or another in, in Christ's interactions with people. And and here it's it's leaping out of the story, if you have
eyes to see it, that Christ is the bridegroom. This woman who's been bleeding from her womb. The most intimate place of her femininity touches him and power goes out from his body as the bridegroom and it enters her womb, enters her womb and heals her in that bleeding womb is a physical sign of of deep, deep wounds in her feminine soul.
It says in Scripture that she suffered greatly at the hands of many doctors. Well, man, you there's not explicit information as to what that was, but you can imagine what that might or could have been. She was a wounded woman at the hands of other men. And, and here she touches the bridegroom, Jesus Christ, and power goes out from her body into her body in her most intimate place and heals her. And Lord, we ask for that power
to flow from your body through the sacraments of the Church to our bodies so that our bodies where we, where those memories lodge, where the shame lodges, where the pain lodges, where the sorrow lodges, that all of that pain and shame and sorrow would be transformed into hope and and and forgiveness and new life. We ask for the grace to open to that power, Lord, and to let it heal us. Amen.
Amen. Our next question is from a listener named Tassiana. Hi, Tassiana. The Church describes the vocation of marriage as a union that helps each spouse become holier and get to heaven. I think this is beautiful, but I sometimes get confused when it comes to what the Bible says about marriage, too. I've heard it said once that God will never ask you to do something that goes against your primary vocation.
However, Jesus also called Peter to leave his wife to follow him. Also, if marriage is supposed to help sanctify a person and help them get to heaven, why did Saint Paul write in First Corinthians that the unmarried woman cares about the things of the Lord? That she may be holy both in body and in spirit, but she who is married cares about the things of the world, how she may please her husband. Here it seems that pleasing one's spouse is almost contradictory to pleasing God, or at the very least takes away
from pleasing God. Tatiana, you are a a thinker and a ponderer. Is that a word? Ponderer. I think it is. All right, it is now and I I appreciate your ponderings because yes, scripture, Scripture can be confusing. Paul's letters can be confusing. In fact, did you know it is a scriptural truth that Paul's letters can be confusing? Because elsewhere in the Bible, in one of Peter's letters, he's
talking about Paul's letters. And he says it's well known that Paul's letters are often confusing and hard to understand. So it's a biblical truth that Paul can be confusing and hard to understand. As you are experiencing, you're experiencing A biblical truth. So let's see if we can enter into this the the the question of Peter leaving his wife. And the Lord would never ask you to do something contrary to your primary vocation that that's a little fuzzy. Like we don't know exactly how Peter lived out his marriage. We do know he was married.
We don't know what that all looked like. Certain writings have imagined what that would look like. And I don't think we're justified to go there to think, Oh, we know exactly what happened, that Peter left his wife to follow the Lord. Peter was called to love this woman. I mean, she was his wife and Peter was a St. So he did not neglect his call to love his wife. I don't know how all that looked. I wasn't there.
I don't know the history of it, but I think we would be mistaken to imagine there was somehow an abandonment of of his wife. I don't I don't think that jives with with the way we're called to love anyway that that's my two cents on that much more could be said and should be said, but we don't have time to go down all those paths. But I do want to say something about Paul and those who are unmarried are anxious to please the Lord, while those who are married are anxious to please
their spouses. Does that mean pleasing your spouse does not please the Lord? Paul here and and this is interesting because John Paul the second in his theology of the body comments on this. That's right. And the staff at the TOB Institute over the last year or so has been going through the Wednesday audiences and we were just reading this audience just last week as a staff. So it's fresh in my mind. John Paul the Second says that Paul here is is his letter is unique in as much as he says
things that are uniquely his own and have his own tone and the mark of his own kind of personality. And he makes distinctions which are important here. He'll say this is a command from the Lord, but this is my own counsel, right? So so that whole distinction is important to carry with us through the letter. And John Paul the Second says moral theologians who may
sometimes this is a paraphrase, not a direct quote from JP 2, but this is the idea he's getting at. He says moral theologians are are quick to turn to Paul's letter for answers to moral questions, understandably. But then JP 2 says, But we must remember that our teaching of moral theology must be rooted primarily and first and foremost in the teaching of Christ himself, and not simply in a
counsel that Paul has given or an opinion that Paul has given, but rooted specifically in the teaching of Christ. So that we need to hold that. Now I know you might be thinking well, but it's still Scripture. So isn't this the word of God? Well, Catholic Church has a, a, a very nuanced understanding of Scripture here that it allows for Paul in the word of God, that his letters are the word of God.
But he's, he himself is saying, and so we need to take him at his word. That's what we do when we read the word of God. We should take it, take Paul at his word. This is a command from the Lord. This is not, this is my counsel. So those are all very important things to keep in mind when we read Paul's letters. John Paul himself says this is his audience #84 Section 1 of audience 84 in the theology body. He says that every Christian who lives his faith fervently is
anxious to please the Lord and in marriage. Because when we read Scripture as a whole and we understand that marriage is a sacrament, in Ephesians 5, Saint Paul says that the union of husband and wife in one flesh is a great the Greek is mysterion and the Latin is sacramentum, right? When we understand marriage as a sacrament of the way Christ loves the Church, then we can recognize that based on the very reality of sacraments that. Wendy, If I'm seeking to please
you rightly, which is to love you rightly in loving you rightly, I'm loving the Lord rightly in loving you rightly in in being anxious to please you in the right way. I'm also anxious to please the Lord because it pleases the Lord when I love you as he loves the Church, that pleases the Lord and that bears great fruit for the Kingdom. But JP Two goes on to say that this idea of being anxious to
please the Lord versus anxious to please your wife or your husband in in the celibate person that anxious to please the Lord, they can give themselves to the affairs of the Lord, meaning spreading the Kingdom, building the Kingdom in a more direct way than I can as a married man. I'll, I'll give you an example that I often give to my students when I'm teaching from this part of the theology of the body in my this comes up in the Theology of the Body Level 2 course.
Wendy, you will remember well all those years ago when I started teaching these courses, these week long intensives, these were not very happy weeks for you. Do you want to? Do you want to share why that was? Well, I guess I kind of still needed you and you were a little too busy. Yeah, I would, I would. This is a retreat center right down the street from our house. And I remember when we moved into this house and we started the institute and we're teaching these courses. We are both excited that, wow, I
don't have to travel to teach these courses. I can go right down the street and then come home and be with you. And but I would go over there like 8:00 AM breakfast and I wouldn't get home till like 10:00 or 11:00 at night. And I'd stay there for all the meals. And I was talking everybody at the breaks and I was even, oh, I was just pouring myself out more and more and more for the students. And you felt, understandably. Abandoned. Abandoned and neglected. And here if I were a celibate
priest, I could give myself more wholeheartedly to those students. But I'm not. I have to also that's that's a certain way that I build the Kingdom in teaching these courses. But my primary vocation is to serve you. Have I gotten this right? No, I have not Have I wounded my wife and my kids because I haven't gotten this right? Yes, I have and and this is part of what what Paul is getting at.
There's a there's a single heartedness for the affairs of the Lord in the celibate that that at the celibate life affords that I I have to watch the my that I'm being faithful to you my my primary vocation. And Wendy, I'm sorry for the ways that I have not done that well and I'm sorry to my kids too. It it it really it does cause real pain. And I think this is a struggle for for men in all kinds of fields where their work, you
know, and it's a tricky thing because our work is also serving you, right? The work that I do is to provide for our family also. And, and so I am serving you and our kids when I work. But man, there's a hard balance to get AT. And I think at least JP 2 says this is in part what Saint Paul is getting at here. Yeah, I feel it. But as you're saying that I'm, I'm looking at, as our listeners know I do, you know, while
you're speaking, I'm listening to you and rereading the question and kind of reflecting and formulating if I have something to add. So that's familiar to our regular listeners that I do that. But I, I was looking at over this and sensing what I had sensed originally when I read Siana's question, was this anxiety in her like it's an anxious question. Wait, what is this vocation of marriage? Is it, is it holy? Is it pleasing to the Lord?
Is can we really conclude that or, or is scripture telling us something else that it's kind of less than is it, is it inferior in some way? So I kind of felt that being like an anxious tone underlying the question. And it's an understandable anxiety, of course, because we do love the Lord and we do want to please him. But as you were talking there about what JP Two said, and it
kind of was crystallizing more for me how Saint Paul, you know, in presenting this image of a woman be living a celibate vocation, he's like affirming the gift that that is to the body of Christ. And how this which might seem less than because she doesn't have a husband and children, which might seem the normal thing to have.
He's like building those women up in the value of their gift and kind of helping to establish the Christian society that includes that gift of self as a bride of Christ, serving him through your prayers, through your sacrifices, through some maybe works in the community that are particular to your life as a celibate woman. Like that's beautiful and and
unmarried women need to hear that you know that you have a very important role and the Lord sees you and knows you. And so like that's wonderful to say that a married woman is anxious about the things of the world and pleasing her husband isn't saying that she's not pleasing the Lord. Like we need people to be anxious about the things of the world, people of faith, because the works that we're doing, hello, when I bring a meal to a woman who just had a baby,
that's an anxious about the things of the world in A and we need that, that is important. That is necessary for human life. That that people of faith would be anxious about the things of the world that they would seek to please their spouse, their family. Like that's essential. That's not like secondary in any way. So I, I sense like from Paul's perspective, just he's, there's no question to him the value of
marriage. Maybe he's just trying to help people understand this value of living, as he says in other place in his letters, as I do, he says because he's an unmarried person and he's he's seen fruits of that in his life and he's letting others know about that. I mean, I'm saying like, I know everything. I know I don't know everything. I'm just saying it's striking me that way and I like it. I like you. Thanks. I like the way things strike you. Thanks. Yeah, I'll just add one more thing after your musings there,
Wendy, which I did like JP 2 says in love and responsibility, it's very clear that when we are loving our spouses rightly, we are loving God rightly. That's the very nature of sacrament to, to love your and that's the key to love your spouse rightly. Husbands love your wives as Christ loved the church. That that's, that's the call when when we treat marriage as something removed from the realm
of the holy, then we can set up in ourselves a certain division between marriage and the holy life. When we understand that sexuality itself was created by God to be the power to love as he loves. And if we take that seriously, and if we're allowing the grace of the sacrament of marriage to rearrange the the furniture in our hearts, so to speak, to set love in order, that is the call
to holiness in marriage. And it is very pleasing to the Lord when we treat marriage as some legitimate outlet to indulge our selfish, lustful instincts. That is not pleasing to the Lord. And and if we think that's the only option, we're going to set up this false dichotomy between celibacy and marriage if we have a suspicion in our hearts. And JP 2 speaks of this. He speaks of the interpretation of suspicion that believes lust is all you get in married life and and your options are are
either repress all your sexuality and live a spiritual celibacy where you negate all that unholy sex stuff, or you have that second class vocation for people who can't handle celibacy where they get to legitimately indulge their lust every once in a while so they can have kids. This is not the Christian view of things. No, no, no, no, no, no. And if we're reading that into Paul, it's because of the jaded ideas we're already bringing to
Scripture. Paul himself says, I'm not saying this to restrict any of you against marriage, because some have the gift of celibacy and some have the gift of marriage, and the word he uses is charism. Some have the charism of celibacy, some have the charism of marriage. And charism, in Christian language, means a gift of the Holy Spirit, a charismatic gift. JP 2 says the marital act is meant to be open to the life and love of the Holy Spirit. It's meant to be a participation
in the very life and love of God. Husbands, love your wives as Christ, as love the church. If we're treating marriage that way, it is very pleasing to the Lord. And guess what? If we're treating celibacy as a the repression of all things sexual because that's all bad and and and of the devil anyway, that is a celibacy that is not pleasing to the Lord. And I'll just close with this. He says in theology, the body. So clearly the perfection that we're all called to is measured
by love, not by the state or vocation that you're in, right? The perfection be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect. What's what's perfection here? Loving learning to love, learning to love and if we think somehow that that marriage is easier than celibacy, JP 2 says in love and responsibility. No, if you're taking the call to holiness seriously, marriage is going to be even more difficult journey to holiness.
It's not easier because you get to indulge your lust. You don't get to indulge your lust. You have to learn how to open all of that lustful stuff inside our in your heart to to purification painful purifications. Put it this way, if we could say in a sense, when it comes to sex, we're all Alcoholics. It's easier for an alcoholic to give up booze altogether, IE celibacy, than it is for an alcoholic To learn how to drink wine rightly and then call to holiness in married life is to
learn how to drink wine rightly. That's a real call to holiness. It's a real call to live the gift of loving as Christ loves. It's a real call to. Become what we are. Ask. Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that
the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...