Questions answered this episode: How can I affirm the single life as a valid and holy vocation, especially for those who feel overlooked in typical vocation stories? As a wife with low sexual desire due to hormones (e.g., postpartum), is it okay to engage in intimacy for my husband's sake even if it's uncomfortable - and is it wrong to show enthusiasm I don’t truly feel? When teaching my kids about sexuality, should I share my own past sexual sins - or could that send the wrong message, even though I’ve been forgiven? Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! --- Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. --- Resources mentioned this week: View our COURSE SCHEDULE --- 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ Join us on one of our pilgrimages! If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Hey, Wendy. Yeah, it's the week of the bridegroom. The week of the bridegroom. That's what the Byzantine Church calls Holy Week. Wow. Yeah, everybody's listening to this during Holy Week. At least that's when we've released this episode, but we're recording it the week before Holy Week.
But for those listening, it's the week of the bridegroom. Pretty special. Christ himself describes Holy Week as as the time when the bridegroom is taken away. I gave a parish mission recently. You came to it near where we live here in Pennsylvania, and I was diving into this spousal imagery of Holy Week. How, You know, Holy Thursday, of course, is the institution of
the Eucharist. And John Paul the second describes the Eucharist as the sacrament of the bridegroom and the bride, which of course is sacramentally presenting what Christ does the next day on the cross, which is consummating the marriage. And in the Jewish ceremony of the wedding, there is this night of consummation. And it would happen when the bridegroom would leave the wedding party and and go to celebrate the nuptials.
And this is fulfilled in the time period between the Last Supper and his return on Easter Sunday. Easter, right the facing the East, the land of the rising sun. Sunday, the sun comes forth like a bridegroom from his chamber. It says in Psalm 19. All of these glorious, mystical nuptial realities are unfolding for us here in Holy Week. Very, very, very, very exciting time. Lord, help us.
Help us to enter in. I also want to give a shout out to everybody who was on our ski trip a couple weeks ago. This is the first time I've been back in the studio with my dear wife recording an episode since we went on that ski trip. And everybody on the podcast has been hearing me talk about the ski trip for a long time. It happened, and it was so much fun. We had a great group shoutouts to Father Daniel, our chaplain, and Jason Everett and Kristalina, who came. And yeah, I think everybody just
really benefited from the exercise, the fun of skiing or snowboarding, and then gathering at the end of the day for reflections. We dove into these themes about Holy Week and Christ the Bridegroom, as it was really, really, really rich. So everybody who's there, thank you. And we will do it again next year. We're not sure exactly where we're going to do it or exactly the dates yet, but as soon as we have them, we will certainly be letting people know it was a it was a great success. That's beautiful.
Yeah. I'm so happy for you. You came back looking blessed and refreshed. It was. So nice. Yeah, Whenever I get out on skis, it's a good thing. Yeah, I'm so glad. I want to tell our listeners too that I have a little bit of a cold. I don't know if you can hear it in. Sniffle, sniffle. You can hear it in my voice, sounds a little strange. So sorry about that. All is well. Do you have any updates for us from the Toby Institute? Yes, I want to say a word about the course I'm teaching in July here in Pennsylvania.
Of course, I'm teaching TOB one in June. And then Bill Donaghy, my esteemed friend and colleague, will be teaching his course, Poets for the Kingdom on CS Lewis and Tolkien, all through the lens of John Paul's teaching. That's in August, but the course I'm teaching in July is one of my favorites to teach. We call it, we used to call it TOB 3. We just call it now TOB in the New Evangelization. We don't call it TOB 3 anymore because we've removed TOB 2 as a
prerequisite. We used to say you had to take TOB 1 and TOB 2 to come to TOB 3, but then we realized you only really need TOB one to then come to what we're now calling theology of the Body and the New Evangelization. So for anybody out there who's already taken TOB 1, please, please prayerfully consider coming to TOB in the New Evangelization. Here's what we're doing. We're putting our TOB glasses on, and we're taking a tour of
the Catechism of the Catholic Church. First of all, we look at John Paul the Second's document on the New Evangelization, which is really his pastoral plan for the new Millennium. That document is called Novo Millennial Inuente at the dawn of the new Millennium. And Oh my gosh, that is full of so many glorious insights about the state of the church, the state of the world, how we proclaim the gospel at this current age and time. We're only 25 years into this pastoral plan.
It was the pastoral plan for the church in the new Millennium, right? So we're only 25 years in. We can tend to think, oh, that was a long time ago, let's move on. No, no, no, no, no. We haven't even begun to scratch the surface of what JP 2 gave us. And if somebody were to ask me what's the greatest gift John Paul the Second gave the church, wait. What I want to ask you something. Wait, wait, I'm on a roll. I need to ask you. Something OK, go ahead. What's the greatest gift Jean Paul the Second gave the church? Well, you might think I would say what?
The theology of the body. Right. You might, yeah. But if you really pressed me. OK, I'm pressing. He's she's pressing me, everybody. I wouldn't say the theology of the body. What would you? Say I'd say the Catechism of the Catholic Church. However, I love what Mikhail Wahlstein said, that the theology of the body is the John Pauline lens for properly reading the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
So you need both, right? The the Catechism without the John Pauline Lens. You'll get some good stuff out of it for sure, but you won't get that deep juicy rich nectar that you get when you wear those TOB glasses. So instead of TOB in the New Evangelization, just call it the Nectar. The rich juicy nectar course. Yeah, Well, I I like to imagine that all our courses offer some rich, juicy nectar, and each does in its own way.
But this is the rich, juicy nectar of the greatest gift John Paul the Second has given the church, which is the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Read through the lens of theology, the body. I'm telling you, you're you will. You will, you will come away from this course seeing the Catholic faith with new eyes and with new delight and joy. We go through each pillar of the catechism. There are 4 pillars of the catechism. The first pillar is the creed. The second pillar is the life of the sacraments.
The third pillar is the moral life. And the fourth pillar is the life of prayer. And that's my favorite right there, the life of prayer. When we get to the fourth pillar of the catechism. And I've had experiences of, of students right in front of me entering into deep contemplative prayer. Like it kind of clicks and you can see their hearts opening up and you can see them experiencing this deeper union with with the Lord in prayer. It's really, really thrilling for me as a teacher to lead people there. So anyways, that's my plug for the course the second week of
July. Check out the link in the show notes. You can take TLB one online before then or in person in June. Hey, just double do it. Like come in June if you haven't taken TLB one and then come in July or take TLB one online before June and before July before July, right? And then come in July to the New Evangelization course. That's all I have to say about that for now. I. Loved that. That was really exciting. I kind of surprised you there
about the Catechism. So you would think I would say the greatest gift is the I would think I would say that too, but I didn't. I think it's the Catechism, but you got to read it correctly. Well, hey, I have something to share with you. Yes. What is that? It's a question from one of our patrons. This is the Ask Christopher W podcast hosted by Wendy W, isn't it? That's right. So let's get right to it. Here we go. This is from a patron named Preston. Hey, Preston. My question has to do with the Catholic understanding of
vocation. I hear many vocation stories and understand that we are called to pray to discern what God wants for our life. Usually vocation testimonies are shared by priests, religious, sisters, and married couples. What about those who are called to single life? I am a married man, but I want to be able to help those who aren't married or may be called to singlehood.
I feel for those who hear the two options and may feel that their story's not part of God's plan. I understand how singlehood can be a holy life, but I'm not sure how to communicate that. Bless you, Preston, bless you. Bless you, bless you, bless you. First of all, every human life is part of God's plan. Absolutely every human life, regardless of your state in life, you are part of God's plan. How do I know this? Because you exist. Because you exist, you are part
of God's plan. Now let me just give a little history here into this question of vocation and in in terms of how it impacts the modern situation. We are in a situation in the modern world unprecedented in human history, where you have large numbers of men and women remaining single into their late 20s, thirties, 40s, fifties, 60s, and, and not finding a spouse or not choosing a, a
consecrated life, a more formal vocation in, in the life of the church. And this presents a pastoral problem. And Preston is feeling it. You're feeling that in your heart, Preston, and, and good on you because it is a real pastoral problem. It's a situation that the church has not dealt with in its history until now. And there are all kinds of reasons for this. First among them is the fallout of the sexual revolution. We are so confused about the
meaning of our humanity, our sexuality, what it means to love, how we're supposed to spend our lives. The confusion over sexuality has taken out the foundation of both vocations, the married vocation and the consecrated vocation. And I say both vocations for a reason. I'll get to that in a minute Preston and and this has this has caused a large swath of the population of the church to say what about me? Where do I fit into that
traditional idea that there are are only two vocations, married life or consecrated celibacy. I'm a single person. I don't really fall into either one of those categories. Does my life not matter? Do I not count Am I not part of God's plan. These are all the questions that are, are very appropriately on Preston's heart. SO11 approach to that pastoral problem has been to kind of
invent this third vocation, the single life. And, and, and I, I, I don't think that's the right approach. And, and here's why. Here's why because the word vocation has has different meanings, right? So first you have the broadest meaning of the word vocation and this is right out of the teaching of John Paul. The second, this is from his document on the Christian family in the modern world familiar as consortio.
He says every human being has the same vocation, which is to love in the image and likeness of God in the broadest sense of the word vocation, meaning calling from God. Every human being has the same vocation to learn what it means to love when Christ says love one another as I have loved you. He established definitively this the the, the, the vocation that
every human being shares to learn how to love. So that's the word vocation in the broadest sense. I love that. Yeah, that's very important. So we all have the same vocation to love, to learn how to love as Christ loves. And for all of us, that's, that's in one way or another a, a bodily gift. I'm going to make a gift of my life, a gift of myself in a certain direction. So that's the broadest sense. We all share the same vocation. Then we get into a more specific sense of the word vocation. And when the church uses the
word vocation in this strict sense, it means a an irrevocable choice of the whole of your life. And so you take vows like I am dedicating my life to this before God. That is, those are the, the, the two vocations, married life or a consecrated life of celibacy or virginity, right? Those that's why the Church is right to speak of two vocations in the strict sense, because
they demand a vowed commitment of the whole direction of your life. It's an irrevocable gift of yourself in this direction. What do we say in that context about those who are living a single life? We can say they are meant right where they are, whatever they're doing with their lives, in their work, in their extended family, in their parish life, in their communities. They are meant to be living the fundamental and innate vocation
of every human being. That's the quote from John Paul the second, the fundamental and innate vocation of every human being is to learn how to love as God loves. Do that where you are. You are part of God's plan. You are called to live that love and no less than anybody else. Go live it out to the full. Wherever you are in your workplace, in your community and your extended family, in your neighborhood, in your parish, live that out. Learn how to be a gift to others. Learn how to love and be loved. Learn how to serve.
That is your vocation. I don't think we are doing a service. In fact, I would say we're doing a disservice. We're watering down the the meaning of that, that stricter sense of the word vocation. When we say, well, there's this third vocation called the single life. I don't think people are called to to the single life in the same sense that they're called to be a consecrated celibate or called to marriage because it
doesn't involve A vowed state. One could be living a very fruitful single life, active in the parish, active in your community, active with friends and wider family, learning how to love and be loved. You're living it out. Awesome. Praise God, you're part of God's plan. But you could also say you live that in your 20s and your 30s and your 40s, and then you meet somebody and you get married. I don't think you would say, well, I, I, I, I, I, I, I gave up my calling to the single life
to get married. No, because it's not a calling in that stricter sense of the word. You found later in your life that vocation in the stricter sense of the word, and you gave yourself to it. I can't having chosen my vocation, which is married life to you Wendy, Thanks be to God, I love my vocation. Thank you my. Love, yes, you're awesome. I love being married to you. And there are joys and there are trials, and I accept and receive them all, and hope and God's
promise to turn all our sorrow and our joy into glory. Let it be. But I can't. Once I've chosen this, I can't choose another one. That's the very nature of the strict sense of the word vocation. Once you've chosen it, you, you can't, in the normal course of events, choose another one. Now, if you died, I could, I could choose to become an ordained priest and live a celibate life, But that would be, you know, because you died. There are cases.
I'm just trying to cover all the bases here. There are cases in which someone could have been ordained to the priesthood and lived a celibate life, and then the Church in her mercy does on occasion lay a size certain priests and they can get validly become validly married. But those are kind of pastoral exceptions to the general rule that once you've chosen your vocation, you can't choose another one. One who is single can eventually choose either to enter religious life or consecrate A celibacy or
can choose to enter the state of marriage. That's why in the strict sense of the word, we don't call that a vocation. In the broad sense of the word, vocation. Absolutely. Now, if somebody were to say to me, Christopher, I have chosen to remain single as my life's calling. I, you know, maybe somebody even says I'm a doctor. And I believe God's calling on my life is to remain single so
that I can travel the world and give myself to, to medicine in, in places where there are natural disasters, for example, or I'm going to go to Africa or the Philippines or wherever they are in, in need of, of medical assistance. And I'm going to make myself free to do that in love and service to others. I'm choosing not to get married so I can give myself fully as a single person without the, you know, being held back by commitments of married life.
I'm giving myself to medicine or I'm giving myself to music, my calling in life. I'm a concert pianist, and I'm going to travel the world and share the gift of music. And I feel so convicted that this is God's calling on my life that I've made a kind of private vow. This is how I'm spending my life. This is how I'm going to learn how to love as Jesus loves. OK, OK, I'd say that person is pretty darn close to that stricter sense of the word vocation. And I would grant the use of that word.
And if that person were to say I'm so committed to this for the whole of my life, I feel God has called me to this, that even if someone came along and wanted to marry me, I would say no because God's calling on my life is this. I'd say, OK, I grant you that you, you are living vocation in the stricter sense of the word. But somebody who's living a single life because they haven't yet discerned or found a spouse or discerned, they're called the celibacy. I, I, I'm not going to use the word vocation in the stricter sense of that. I don't think it does a service. It waters down what a vocation is.
So yeah, it, it comes down to the definition of that word vocation. And in the strict sense of the word, I don't want to water it down because it has a very specific meaning. I hope what I've said is helpful. We we do have a pastoral problem on our hands. And we do have to let these people know that they are fully part of the church by virtue of their baptism. They are fully part of God's plan because they exist and they can live very, very fruitful lives. But, but just for the sake of wanting to be inclusive, we shouldn't change the definition
of of words here. I I am having a memory as you're sharing this and I'm looking at Preston's question, which I know you're not, where he says, I understand how singlehood can be a holy life, but I'm not sure how to communicate that. I was just struck that when you were talking about the fundamental innate vocation of every human being, you as the call to love, as God loves. I think you were, you were
answering that. And I just want to share something from my experience of being in that state of life of singlehood that just might be added thoughts for those who are single or those who are wanting to talk to others who are single about ways to experience that fundamental vocation. So I'm remembering that I kind of didn't think of myself as kind of, I don't know, like finishing college for me was
like part of the end of childhood somehow. Like, I know when I was in college, I was probably already out of childhood, but there was something transitional about those years that I didn't feel launched yet. Somehow I felt like it was just in a process that was unto itself. But I remember when I finished college, there was this feeling of like, OK, how am I to live now? How am I to follow the Lord now in my life? And I did, you know, have a hope
to be married someday, But I didn't want to make it my project to be married. I wanted just to follow the Lord, the next step in my life and see where that took me. Like, where does that? What how does the Lord use my following the next steps in my life that I sense he's calling me to to bring about whatever vocation he has for me and I, I was open to him also calling me to a consecrated celibacy if that was his plan, but it was just kind of a what's your next
step for me, you know, and a real trusting like I just want to I just want to take the next step you have for me. And as I would pray that way, like this desire to do something that wouldn't necessarily have occurred to me. I had I had studied nursing, so I wanted to be a nurse, but also to like live with my elderly grandparents and help them in their life. Just kind of landed in my heart as a gift from the Lord. I really want to do that.
I want to go be with them. And it meant moving and it meant, you know, change. And somehow it just, I sensed it as a, a calling as a next step in my life. And it was, there was some learning how to love. It didn't just flow easily all the time. There were expectations I had and that they had that created conflict and stress. So I, I don't want to make it sound like I was all ready to do it. You know, I needed to learn, I needed to be taught, I needed to be humbled, I needed to grow. But also in that time there was
a, a friendship with you and I definitely had a desire that that could lead to marriage, but only if it was the Lord's plan for us. I didn't want it just because I wanted to grasp it and say this is what I want. And I remember in that thinking about you and kind of having my thoughts get a little caught up in not just a little caught up, very caught up in, well, how's this going to happen and what will it be like? And just kind of a an spending a
lot of time in my brain there, you know, on thinking about you. And there was a real like just word from the Lord that came to me. And it was a word from or some lyrics from a song that you had written in which you. Yeah, you said, and you, this was from theology, the body, from your learning about the fundamental vocation of a human being. In this song you wrote, you said
love means you lay down your life. And I remember hearing it and looking at our relationship and thinking, OK, well, I can't lay down my life for him like a wife. We're not even dating like we're just if I'm laying down my life, it means as a friend, like, and only as a friend. And so I can't if I keep my brain in this like the place of wishing to be your wife and wishing you noticed me and all, you know, whatever, you know,
had that same desire. Like that wasn't like honouring of what am I called to right now. I'm, I'm his friend. And it gave me such a piece about continuing to have a friendship and to pray for your good and your vocation and God's plan for your life as the highest good for you. And it was such a source of peace for me as a single person. So I just felt like sharing those things, you know, eventually those prayers and our
friendship, you know, took us to a vowed state, but it wasn't guaranteed to do so. And that that was a very fruitful way for me to understand learning to love as God loves and to find fulfillment in that right in the present. And I was the direct, direct beneficiary of your willingness to to learn how to love in that way. I remember as our friendship was growing, just being so struck by your selfless love.
It was it. It pierced my heart deeply and beautifully. And I'm so glad, Wendy, you were not called the celibacy. Well, same for you my love. Anyway, I hope Preston, some of that is, I think it's an important question he brought up and I, I like the way you explained just the different meanings of that word vocation. I know it's come up in previous questions, but there was a certain angle that with Preston was getting at with his question
that I really appreciated that I can feel his love for these people. And I would encourage you, Preston, to to take what Wendy said there and just ask yourself what, how can you, you, you have these people on your heart in a particular way. They, their situation weighs on you. And that's already a sign of the tenderness and love you have towards them. I would just encourage you to take up Wendy's wisdom there and, and ask the Lord, how do I love these people? How do I serve these people? How can I as a friend, lay down
my life for these people? It will bear fruit whenever we pray that with an open heart, good fruit is born. Bless you, my brother. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Hello dear anonymous listener, whoever you are, bless you. As a wife, how can I give myself fully and joyfully to my husband even when I'm in a life
situation that causes me to have little or no sexual desire? For example, my husband and I recently had our first child. During the pregnancy and first few months postpartum, my sex drive was abysmally low. Due to the hormones, it was physically difficult for me to experience any kind of sexual pleasure or arousal, despite genuine effort. During this time, I would engage in the marital act with my husband because I wanted him to feel satisfied and loved, even
though it often felt like a chore and I disliked the experience. I feel bad that it felt like a chore. I wanted it to be a beautiful experience, but I found myself just wishing it would be over the entire time it was happening, despite both of us giving it our best effort. I know this is a common problem for women to have, especially when they're going through hormonal changes such as pregnancy or post menopause. What is the proper response of a wife during these times?
Should I engage in the marital act for my husband's sake, even though I find it uncomfortable? Also, is it lying to express enthusiasm during the marital act even when I'm not actually feeling enthusiastic? I've never lied to my husband about my level of enjoyment or my ability to achieve climax, but I certainly will at least try to seem enthusiastic during the experience for his sake, even if I do not feel that way. Is that wrong? Bless, bless, bless this dear
wife. Gosh, I just sense all the tenderness and sensitivity of this very delicate matter in their marriage. And and Wendy, I'm going to be deferring largely to you on this to speak into this as a woman. I'll, I'll, I'll pare down my thoughts to just a few.
I think your desire to want to bless and please your husband is, is a good desire. I do want to qualify what I'm what I'm saying here because there's a whole array of situations that married couples find themselves in. And I am not saying that if if a husband is uncaring or lacks tenderness or is causing his wife pain and doesn't seem to care and is kind of a a bit of a bully in the bedroom, that it's
a beautiful thing for a wife to just submit to that. I am not saying that, but I am not gathering from the way this question has been worded that that's what we're dealing with. It seems to me that what we're dealing with is, is a woman who loves her husband, her husband loves her and she's finding intercourse difficult, somewhat uncomfortable. Her body is not cooperating. She's postpartum and her desire to want to her husband to know that he is loved and she desires
the union even if her body is not cooperating. I think that's beautiful. I think that's that's that's a lovely tenderness that you're showing towards your husband. I hope, I hope he's also showing you a lovely tenderness and understanding in in realizing that it's uncomfortable for you. But I'm also wondering to what extent have you communicated that to him? I think it's important that then
this raises just some thoughts on your question. Am I lying to him? Am I being dishonest? Am I faking something? Am I being insincere? That seems to indicate that maybe there's been not so much verbal communication about the discomfort and the struggle that you're having. And I would invite you to that. I would invite you to to open up to your husband and express to him how much you you long for the your union, how much you
desire for it to be delightful and pleasurable for the both of you. But in your present physical state, the honest reality is it is not that for you. I think he will feel your love. I think he will feel your desire for for closeness and intimacy. I think you will feel your sincerity and I think for you it will honest communication about it will, will resolve the feeling that there's some level
of dishonesty or role-playing or acting going on that that is causing you a a bit of a pang in your conscience. And, and I don't think this is a a gravely serious matter. As you said, you're not faking climax or something. John Paul the second does strongly caution against that, saying this is not honest in the marital act for a, a wife to feign climax. He says this in love and
responsibility. But I do think that pang of your conscience is a call, a desire. It's showing a desire in your heart for more open, honest communication about what's really going on. And I would encourage that have those conversations so that he can show you an appropriate tenderness and understanding in your current physical state. I'm going to leave it at that and toss it over to you. Yes, I appreciate the situation that this wife is describing and
I I can relate to it and I know others can as well. And I, I, I feel it as like a Lord, what am I to do here? Kind of question. And I, I can't say that I've handled it perfectly or that we've handled it perfectly in our marriage. So and I, I do think we, we are encountering at this level of, of marital just, I don't know,
kind of finding your way in ministering to one another, if that makes sense. There is something so individual to the couple that it's hard to just answer, you know, here's what to do or not to do. I think one thing I've kind of been learning about recently is, is putting words to the reality that there isn't necessarily just one way that we feel about
things in our lives. There's like multiple things going on in our hearts at the same time. And so one of the things we may be feeling would be frustration. Why won't my body just respond? I want it to respond. It's so frustrating. And if that were the only thing and we felt powerless about it, then, you know, that would be it would feel like something to be resentful about that any, you
know, expectation could be there for the marital embrace. Like there's nothing here to, you know, indicate that that's a good thing for me right now, you know, but but that's not the only thing in the wife's heart. There is as she identified like this. I do love him and I I do want to like bless him and I so that that's like that's where the inner conflict is there. And that's why it can be confusing something that wasn't mentioned in this question.
But I, I feel it in my heart that we as wives need to explore is what would bless me right now. I don't want him to just leave me alone. I, I, I don't want to have no contact, but to actually get in touch with like what would feel like an expression of his love that kind of filled me in some way.
And that will be different for each person. And it may take some real exploration as a couple, but I think it doesn't even occur to us to ask ourselves that question. We kind of think of it as we're married and I know he's made in a way as a man or, or this is my husband anyway, he's not having any change in his desire just because my hormones are in the state they're in. So that's kind of the problem. We're looking at that instead of
like step, taking several steps back as a couple and saying we want to express our love for one another. If you discover ways that your husband can express physical affection toward you that is deeply meaningful. I could, I mean, I could just throw out a few thoughts like a foot rub or just lying together spooned together, like
different. I'm just kind of giving a little bit of suggestions. I'm not trying to limit what, you know, each individual heart discovers is deeply meaningful within respect for the marital embrace. I'm not suggesting something, you know, unchaste, but just really just a, a loving, comforting, affectionate encounter with one another that could really minister to the wife. Like what a joy that would bring
to the wife's heart and what a balance to their relationship so that if you also discern there will be times that you come together in the marital embrace, I think it can lessen that frustration. It can help carry you through together as a couple, trusting your desire hopefully will return. You know, we pray that it will. But I just, I just felt called to share that, like call women
out to say, like, are you even asking yourselves? Like how can my husband show his love so that he can know? And I want to call the men out here as well. I have learned this in the span of three decades almost of married life, that learning that mastery of yourself where you can be tender, naked, close without seeking the climax of
marital intercourse and its full expression and contain your own sexual desire and put it at the service of your wife without needing climax. Learning the art of tenderness, learning the art of entering into her other emotional world. JP 2 talks about this in Love and Responsibility. He says the woman is a world other from the man and the man
is a world other from the woman. And we need to learn each other's worlds. And I see in this wife's question that she is wanting to understand her husband's world and meet him there. And that's beautiful. But there's there's also a need for him to to know your world. And he's called to meet you in your emotional world and in your unique make up and in your physical limitations and to
honor and love you. We call it lovemaking after all. Are we wanting really to love the other as he or she is in this current situation? Or do we have some predetermined goal? No, what I want is this. And if my wife's physical limitations get in the way, well, she's just going to have to endorse some discomfort because I know what I want is that love. That does not sound like love to me. Now it, it, it could be that you know, the wife in wanting to
enter the world of her husband is willing to to say, yes, we can Make Love tonight because I love you and I want to bless you. Even though it I know my body is, is in a state that it's not going to be so easy to be aroused. That could be the wife attempting to enter into his world. That could be beautiful. It could also become, if it's not balanced in the other direction with the husband being willing to enter her world and sacrifice for her part, the imbalance there could become oppressive and really, really
dysfunctional and problematic. So I'm calling out the guys here. Guys, it is so rewarding. Not easy, not easy, but so rewarding to learn how to put your sexual faculties truly at the service of entering the other world of your wife. Learning to swim in her ocean, so to speak. Learning how to understand the contours of her heart which are so different than the contours
of a man's heart. And you will be enriched by learning that path. Wendy, I know I have not done this well over the years. I have flubbed, I have misread, I've misunderstood. I've imposed my own thinking because I haven't understood how to enter your world. Love, we've both been growing through the years and I think that's what the Lord desired for us. Yeah, and we, we have grown. Thank you, God, we have grown. And I can witness to the joy of learning to love you, learning
to enter into your world as you have welcomed me into your world. It's not easy. It is not easy, but it is so rewarding, gentlemen, to put your sexual faculties at the service of really loving your wife. But I'll, I'll say again to this dear wife, please, please make your heart known. Make what's really going on known so that your husband has the opportunity to know you there and be tender with you there. Yeah.
Bless, bless, bless, bless, bless, bless, bless, bless, bless. Gosh. Marriage is tender stuff. It's. True. Our next question is from a listener named Stephanie. Hello, Stephanie. Hello, thank you both so much for this podcast and the wonderful insights you both bring to your listeners. You're welcome, Stephanie. I've only recently discovered your show, and I so wish that I'd heard all of this when I was a young person. Though my parents were excellent examples of faith and self giving marriage, we never had
deep conversations about human sexuality and how to navigate the temptations we all face as humans in this regard. Well, here's a little suggestion, Stephanie. I know you know young people. Maybe you could share our podcast with some young people so that they do have an opportunity to enter in at a younger age. Bless you. My husband and I both feel our own deepest questions were often not addressed by our parents because of the uncomfortable nature of the topic and we were
left to navigate sexuality alone with only our peers and culture to influence us. I don't hold this against them as they did not have the theology of the Body Institute. But all this to say, my husband and I engaged in what you call non marital sex both before our marriage and during the early years of our marriage. She's paying attention. We've come a long way. Bless you. We practice natural family planning and it has been truly wonderful for our relationship. Now we are navigating how to
talk with our preteens and teens about rightly ordered sexuality. Like all parents, we want to prevent our children from making our same mistakes and protect them from the heartache associated with and burden of such sins. However, I'm worried about telling them the truth about myself. I've always tried to tell them the truth about their bodies and their goodness. While I'm thrilled to be able to use your theology of the body resources with them, I'm not sure how to bring up my own
personal failings, or if I should even bring it up at all. I guess I worry they might ask me a question I don't want to answer, and I'm afraid to tell them this particular truth. Though I've been unburdened of these sins through the miracle of confession, I never want to convey the message that you can do whatever you want and just confess it later and everything is fine. That doesn't do justice to the inner turmoil I faced as a young woman, nor to the ways our relationship was hurt by our past sexual immorality.
I can now see even this situation not wanting to speak of this to my children as a repercussion of these sinful actions. Bless you, Stephanie, bless you. I understand the complexity of the question. I get it and I have great compassion for you. And it is not easy. It is not easy. Wendy and I have this podcast. I'm the president of the Theology Body Institute. I've written so many books on this stuff that has not made it easy to pass this on to our
children. It's given us a map. It's given us some tools, but gosh, there it's it's not easy. It's not easy. We've tried, we've made lots of mistakes. We made some, some real attempts to pass this on to our children. But you know, there's always the eye roll factor. You know, you, you try to have meaningful conversations with your children and they kind of roll your, their eyes at you. And yeah, so we're not immune to any of that. I don't want anybody out there to have this picture that, oh, what a golden family the Wests
are 'cause they have theology of the body and they teach it and they have this podcast and they must do great with their children. And yeah, talk to our children to see how we've done. Passing this on. I you'll get, you'll get a different story from each one of them. And there's good things we've done. And I think they'd all say that. And then there's some things we really screwed up. So compassion, understanding, it ain't easy. But on the question at hand, should you share honestly about
your own life and your own mistakes? Well, you're asking me my opinion and others would have different opinions, but here's mine and I'm pretty strong in it. Yes you should. You should be honest with your children. You don't have to give them all the details and you shouldn't give them all the details, but you should be honest that you are a Sinner and that you made mistakes. And you know what that's going to give you more credibility in
the in their eyes that you know what you're talking about. You are coming from a place of having lived that and you know the pain it's caused you. And you can speak from real experience into that pain that if you present it in that light, they're not going to think, well, my parents did it. Therefore I, you're, you're going to present it in a light. I screwed up and this really wounded me.
This really hurt my life and, and it really caused me pain. And, and speaking from that place, you can be a very credible witness. All five of our children, I've never kept the fact that I had a, a very broken sexual past from any of them. And they've, that's just been a normal part of their knowledge of their dad that, that I was, I didn't have this growing up as a teenager. Nobody told me this growing up. And, and I was a hungry dude and
I took my hunger to the fast food and, and my, all my kids have known that. And that has just become a, a normal part of their knowledge. And I've never felt regret that they know that they don't know all the details. They don't need to know all the details, but they know that that is a real part of my life. And I, my sense of it is that that has given me credibility in speaking the truth because I've lived the lie and, and I think you can present it in the same way. And on the flip side, I know of
situations where parents have tried to keep that from their children and it backfired on them. Their parents caught them in a lie, and that eroded the trust of the children. You know what else this affords you, Stephanie? It affords you the opportunity to proclaim the riches of God's mercy, the riches of God's mercy in your life. Put it all in that light. This is how merciful God has been with me.
And if you, if you put it in that you're not, you're not justifying your sin, you're proclaiming the mercy of God and you're not saying to your children, therefore go out and do whatever you want and God will forgive you. Put it in the light of the damage it's caused. And you want to prevent that damage in your own children's lives. Speak from that perspective. Speak boldly of God's mercy and you're, you're telling the truth. That's going to be much better for you and earning the trust of your children than trying to hide. They know, they know when you're
hiding something. They know when you're not telling the whole story. They know when you're when you're lying to them. You can't pull it all. You can't pull the wool over their eyes. So just get it out in the light, trusting in God's mercy, trusting in His Providence, proclaiming boldly how good God has been to you. That is a bold and beautiful witness and your children need to hear it. I think some of parenting, you know, of course, we can't give you A at this age say this. There's so much as parents of
attuning to your children of of sensing things about their hearts and their minds that is unique to your relationship. So I don't want to, you know, even though it would be handy to have like sort of an age guide at. Age 9 1/2. Three months and two days Say this. Yeah, that's doesn't exist, not real. But also there's such a, a, an
awareness of what you would call a teachable moment that is part of that attunement. There are circumstances that increase the interest of our children in certain things, whether it's even, you know, a reading at Mass. You know, we just had the the woman caught in adultery reading like the opportunity there to speak about the suffering of that woman and to say something like, I know something of how
she felt. You know, that is just an introduction of that of you as a person who can help them learn more about these questions of our fallen nature that are coming up. It can be in movies or books that you're sharing together. It can be in life situations. I know for us, there have been, you know, in our immediate
family or friendships, children conceived out of wedlock. Well, like that certainly raises questions in children's minds and hearts and those that creates this opening where the conversations that are needed have a place to land and feel like they're answering the the questions of the child. So I, yeah, I just want to encourage you to have that part of openness and asking the Holy Spirit to give you courage in
those moments. I can just see us kind of sometimes maybe having been surprised by a scene in a movie and skipping over it, but feeling like there's a there's something in the air now and it is something should be said and trusting the Holy Spirit to give you some words, even if they don't write at that moment, say, Oh, thanks Mom for sharing that. I think it, those are the moments where it goes in and it's it's so helpful. They need our words.
They need to know us and how they can trust us and what they can talk to us about. Well said, Wendy. Yeah, those those teachable moments, if we look for them, there's no shortage of them. Lord, inspire us in passing on to our children the full splendor of what it means that you created us, male and female, the full splendor of your gift of love, the full splendor of the call to be a gift, and the full truth that all the grace is poured out on us for us to.
Become what we are. Amen, Amen. Bless you everybody in this week of the Bridegroom. Open, open, open up to all the graces. Lord help us to say yes. Amen. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you. But. Remind you that they are not
licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...