Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Love in an Abusive Marriage, Confessing Lust as a Woman, and “Same-Sex Vocation” | ACW320

Feb 17, 202548 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: My husband and I have been married for almost 3 years. Shortly after we got married, my husband became verbally and physically abusive. There’s such a disconnected between his professed love for me and the lived reality of our marriage. As his abusive behavior has continued, I’ve found myself walling off my heart more and more. Intellectually I know that a covenantal relationship with God is different and I need to remain open but it feels like my heart has stopped believing it. Many days I feel like if marriage reflects how God loves us then I’m sick of “being loved”. How can I stay open to the beautiful promises of the eternal wedding feast when its early foretaste is ugly and painful? Recently I was in confession and I said that at times I am “lustful”. The priest asked me to be more specific and as a woman I felt very uncomfortable being more specific. After confession I was reflecting on it more and realized maybe I do need to be more specific so the priest understands what exactly I’m confessing. Typically how I feel when I engage in this sin is when I see an attractive man that’s not my husband, I may find myself aroused by him and let myself entertain the idea of him to much. Also at times I see my intentions for coming together with my husband are not fully pure and there might be some selfish, lustful desires there. Many times I stop myself and do not suggest coming together with my husband to avoid using him. Is there a more concise yet specific way of confessing these sins without giving all these details? Is there a name for these sins? I want to be accountable but understand that priests are fallen men too and I want to be prudent especially because I’m a young woman. What would your advice be for two catholics with same sex attraction who want to adhere to the teachings of the Church who believe it is their vocation to be life partners romantically but not sexually? Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: Jameis Winston Video Join Christopher on a ski trip to Utah Click here TOBI Event Calendar Hope’s Garden Desert Stream Ministries 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. ⛷️ Join Christopher on a ski trip to Utah Click here 🏔️ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here 🌟 For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Welcome to another episode everybody. Thanks for being with us. Yes, hello listeners. I wanted to share something with you that really blessed me. When do you know how much this blessed me? Our daughter Beth shared this video of Jameis Winston. He plays, I think he's a backup

quarterback for the Cleveland Browns. And this is a little clip of him. I'm going to, you're only going to obviously hear the audio here, but we're going to have the link to this in the show notes of this episode. So you can watch this guy on YouTube. You got to see his face when he says this. This is the quintessential rejoice in the Lord always. So it's really cold weather and snowing. And this is a little interview right before the game. It's just a a minute long. Here, give this a listen. Here we go.

Weather conditions tonight, we're expecting winds up to 15 mph in a wintry mix. How will that impact your ability to throw the ball? I am so happy and grateful that the Lord has blessed me to play in some snow to be in true football weather in Cleveland, OH at Huntington Bank Field today to get him the glory. It's a beautiful day. You have to see his face. You got to click on the link in the show notes because his face is beaming as he says this. And I showed this to my students at the recent Marion Mystery

course, and he kind of became the the star of the week, other than Jesus and the Blessed Mother, of course. But I, I played this video four or five times for the students because everybody loved it so much. And there's just something you something. What is it, Wendy? What? Is this sincere? Like she's just looking for something negative or anxious coming from him and there's nothing of negativity or anxiety he's. Got so happy that I get to play football in in in some true football weather. It's a beautiful day.

He, he, whatever the circumstance in his life, I bet you he's just praising God and rejoicing in the Lord. And it reminds me of Saint Paul. Rejoice in the Lord always. And I had a little bit of a rough morning this morning, so I, I needed to hear that. So yeah, it's a beautiful day. Even though I had a rough morning, it's a beautiful day. Thank you, Lord. I'm going to give you the glory, Lord. Thank you Jesus, that is so good. Well, tell us some updates from

the Theology of the Body Institute. Yes, we are getting down to the wire on this ski trip that I am doing with Jason Everett. Yeah, we are going to Snowbird, Utah from March 26th to March 30th. This is all in the spirit of JP 2 and how he would go skiing with people and then at the end of the day talk about God's plan for human life and the universe. That's what we are doing. Jason Everett has invited me on this trip. I'm going to be giving some talks on JP 2's teaching.

Jason is going to be giving a talk on the the life of JP 2. So a little bit of his life story. And of course we're going to be skiing all day and partying all night in the right sense of party. And you know, it's a Catholic party and there ain't no party like a Catholic party because a Catholic party don't stop. So check out the link below to learn more about coming skiing with us. And also check the link for our

events. We have, we have quite a full tour schedule this winter and spring of 2025. And we may be coming to an area near you. So check out those links. Awesome. Are you ready for a question from a patron? I am. Let's do it. This is from an anonymous patron. Thank you for opening your hearts up to us on this podcast and for your compassionate insights on how to live out the theology of the body. I'm hoping you can share your

wisdom one more time. But of course. My husband and I have been married for almost three years. Shortly after we got married, in fact, on the honeymoon, my husband became verbally and then physically abusive. Mercy. There's such a disconnect between his professed love for me and the lived reality of our marriage. As his abusive behavior has continued, I found myself walling off my heart more and more. Intellectually, I know that a

covenantal relationship with God is different and I need to remain open, but it feels like my heart has stopped believing it. Many days I feel like if marriage reflects how God loves us, then I am sick of quote being loved. How can I stay open to the beautiful promises of the eternal wedding feast when its earthly foretaste is ugly and painful? Oh godly, I am just hearing Mary's heart going to Jesus for

this couple. They've run out of wine. They've run out of wine, Jesus, Jesus. They've run out of wine, Jesus, they have run out of wine. Mercy, Lord, mercy, mercy, mercy. To the degree that a marriage is open and receiving and drinking

and living from that new wine, it does become, it does indeed become a taste of something heavenly. But in as much as we are living from that fallen place in our humanity where we have run out of wine, it does become a, a, a taste of of the other destiny. It becomes a taste of hell, can become a living hell. Here's the good news.

Here's the good news. It's so hard to reckon with it, but it's true. Jesus descended into hell. So whatever our hell, whatever our taste of hell, good news is we can find Jesus in it because he's descended into it. And it is evident from what you have shared that your husband's heart, in as much as he is verbally and physically abusive,

his heart is, is locked up. His heart is closed. His heart is shut down to that new wine. And as much as he lives from that place, but this does not mean your heart needs to be shut down or closed to that new wine. And I'm I'm really struck by her there seems from the question here a, a, I'm not going anywhere. This is really, really hard. But this is my husband and and

I'm going to I'm going to love him. Now I just want to say this for all who are in very difficult circumstances in a marriage. If there is physical abuse and you are you are in danger, you have every right to get yourself out of there and and safe. Please don't hear anything I'm about to say in terms of commitment to your marriage as a you must stay in an abusive relationship where you are being, where you are being harmed.

If you are being seriously harmed, protect yourself there. There there is no no reason to submit yourself to ongoing abuse of this fashion. That needs to be loud and clear at the same time, even in a separation that may be necessary due to serious abuse. If the marriage bond is valid,

then it lasts until death, and that marriage bond is sacred even in horrible circumstances. And the one who is being abused can learn the way of the cross. Here again, the way of the cross does not mean you're putting up with with the abuse. You may need to separate and be in a place of safety, absolutely. But in your heart, in your interior, even if you were to be in such an abusive situation where you never saw the person again, you could learn how to

open that suffering, that sorrow, that abuse that took place and the very fact that it was so bad that you had to leave. And I don't know if the circumstances for this particular person warrants that. I'm just trying to be inclusive of of the worst case scenario here. But even in the worst case scenario, that person that who has been abused and has taken shelter and separated for his or her own safety, that person can learn the way of the cross, opening that pain, opening that sorrow to Jesus, to Jesus, and allowing Jesus to descend into

that very particular to you, that very particular to you hell. Jesus is in it. Jesus is there. And we have talked many, many times on this podcast about Catechism 2843. And I'm, I'm sorry for those who listen to this podcast regularly. If this is sounding like I'm, I'm a broken record here, but there's nowhere else to go. This is the only place to go. Catechism 2843 says it best.

It is not in our power not to feel or to forget an offense when we are wounded by others. It's not in our power not to feel it or to forget it, But the heart that offers itself opens that pain to the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit transforms the pain into compassion. Why is your husband causing you pain? Because he's in pain. He's in pain. And as you, as you come to realize the pain you are in is a taste of the pain he is in, the

Holy Spirit can transform that experience into compassion. Oh my gosh, my husband's in so much pain. How do I know it? Because I'm in so much pain and he dumped it on me. It comes from him. He's in this pain. That's that's the open door of the heart to compassion. And then the Catechism goes on to say that the Holy Spirit transforms the memory of that pain into intercession. That pain you are experiencing at the hands of your very wounded pain husband, open to

the Holy Spirit, can become compassion and powerful intercession. Your pain united to Christ, pain offered to the Father, becomes the power of redemption for your husband. And that power is all the more powerful in and through your marriage bond because you have become one flesh. You are bound in that marital bond, the holiness of that bond. So what you go through, your

husband also goes through because you are one flesh, you open that in your heart to the Holy Spirit and it will have an impact on your husband. Now your husband is his own person and he can continue to throw up the walls and continue to say no. He has his own freedom, but your willingness to continue interceding for him in that powerful way of uniting your pain with Jesus and Jesus offering your pain and his pain to the Father for the power of it, for the sake of redemption. There is real power, real power

then flowing from the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ to reach your husband and bring about a healing That is the beginning of the journey. Much, much more could be said. I'm sure, Wendy, you're going to shine a light on this too, but I'll, I'll, I'll, I'll pause there for to hear what you have to say, Wendy. Something that really struck me about the way she worded this question, it struck me because I could relate to it so much when she said, I feel like if

marriage reflects how God loves us, then I'm sick of being loved. Yes, yes. And not that I have ever felt exactly that, but I remember a really important time in my growth as a a woman, as a married woman. And that kind of prepared the ground in my heart in some ways for things I needed to talk about with you was that experience of feeling like I couldn't connect to the Lord that that I couldn't experience

like just that love somehow that my, there was like a wall between me and the Lord. And as I experienced that for a while, it started to occur to me like maybe something's wrong here because something's wrong in our marriage. And, and that was a helpful like realization of the deep connection and the need to like look at things that I didn't

really want to look at. So I, I felt like, you know, that how many times have we noticed this, that suffering can be an entry point for grace and the need to open to grace because we can't ignore the suffering is, is in some ways like a mysterious way that the Lord can work in our, in our lives and in our stories. So for me, like being honest with the Lord about that, like, gosh, I feel like there are

things I need to look at in my marriage. And some of the things were things that had happened in the past that had kind of we'd sort of grown past and they weren't still happening, but maybe they've never been looked at. And so I'm just sharing this, maybe not as much in every way for this specific questioner, but for all our listeners, like how that can be so fruitful in our lives and our need to grow when we recognize these connections in our hearts

between relationships with important people in our lives and how it affects our relationship with the Lord. So I guess that's kind of the the thing that struck me about her question and the prayer that that would would bear the fruit that her longing for the promises of the eternal wedding feast will remain accessible to her in the midst of also very difficult circumstances that that need to be dealt with in

various ways. And, and it is so important and sensitive for us to try to talk with, with our listeners about like so many people might want to ask, like, where is the line? How do I know when I shouldn't stay? And oh, such hard questions we don't ever want to be faced with. And I, we do pray for our listeners that, that there would be the grace of the Holy Spirit that there would be people to walk with you, whether

counselors or just friends that could, could help you in that discernment because it's, it is so difficult. And, and I, I know that and I do want to share a resource with all of our listeners. There's a ministry called Hope's Garden that we have some connection with or at least some knowledge of people in that ministry. Some of them have certainly taken many courses with the theology, the Body Institute that initially were working with

women who have been in abusive relationships and needing to have that healing in their relationship with the Lord and support from others who share their faith. Who can help them to work through those kinds of questions of how do I be a healthy person? What do I do about my relationship? What do I how do I grow with the Lord. So those very questions are the needs that this ministry attends to and they do now have ministry

to men as well. Yes. So I just want to share that with our listeners. Yes, we'll have a link in the show notes to Hopes Garden. Yes, for that ongoing need for just people who've been there and can help make sense of this aspect of your story and help you to receive profound graces in the midst of, as Christopher said, in the midst of a hell. Yeah, I just want to affirm Wendy, your your looking at that aspect of her question.

I think it's so important that she understand and, and I'll emphasize it here, that what you are experiencing in your marriage, the way your husband is treating you, he is not loving you as Christ loves the church. He's doing the exact opposite. How does Christ love the church? He takes our wounds upon himself. He does not inflict additional wounds. He takes our wounds upon himself. Your your husband here is is exactly a an image of an of a a

a the he is sorry Juan edit that your husband is exactly here an image contrary to the way Christ loves his church. So please do not think you are. You are obligated to submit to your husband's abuses here. This is this is not Christian marriage. You are invited in the mystery of the cross. You are invited to offer your sufferings for him. He may not be loving you as

Christ loves, but that should not stop you from loving him as Christ loves. And that's what we are inviting you to, as difficult as that is, that is the call of married life. And, you know, just to put your comments in a maybe a little more context from my perspective, Wendy, there was a long stretch early in our marriage where I just did not know how to honor your heart. I didn't know how to do it. I was, I was ignorant, I was broken, I was wounded. The contours of the feminine

heart were were mysterious and scary, and my own heart was locked up and shut down in so many ways. And there's that line in Ephesians 5 that says he who loves his wife loves himself. Well, the opposite is also true. He who does not love his wife does not love himself. And my failures in loving you were a failures in were failures in loving myself. And, and your heart got shut

down because I didn't know how to honor it. And you're, you couldn't have your heart open to me in a, in a deep, intimate way because I didn't know how to honor it. You needed to guard your heart. And, and that had a deep impact on your relationship with the Lord. But you did learn that path of Catechism 2843, learning how to open your pain to the Holy Spirit so that it would become compassion for me and intercession for me. And that compassion and that intercession has borne abundant,

abundant fruit in my life. I I'm not saying everything is healed and, and there never is in this life, but but I can declare I want to bear witness to this reality for this woman as a husband who didn't know how to love his wife. You're, you're walking that path, Wendy. You're learning to open your pain that I was causing you to the Holy Spirit. You're having compassion for me and my pain. You're turning your pain into

intercession through the Holy Spirit. It has borne tremendous, glorious, real fruit in my life. It's real. This is not a theory to us. This is not just something we read in the Catechism. This has become a lived experience. It has become a lived experience again. We're we got a long way to go. We've come a long way. There's still a long way to go, but this is real. I just want to declare it boldly. It is. It's brutal because it takes you

to the cross and the cross is brutal. And if we are followers of Christ, we have to reckon with where he went. Where did he go? We went to Calvary. It means our lives too are at times going to be a bloody mess. Because Calvary is a bloody mess in this idea that following Jesus makes your life nice and tidy and neat and clean and wonderful all the time. That's just BS. It's not real, it's not reality, it's not the gospel, it's a crock of you can see I get a

little zealous here because it just people are sold this false notion of following Jesus. It's going to be a bloody mess and it's going to be glorious. That's Good Friday and that's Easter Sunday. That's what it is, a bloody mess. That is the path to glory. It's real. I hope that some of our maybe younger listeners who are afraid of those words and, you know, I

think there's a a place in life when you've come through some of those cycles, you know, of experiencing those lows and those graces and those glories that can give you a certain perspective that increases your trust. And sometimes when you're just starting out, that just sounds terrifying. And and you really just like, no, not me, no, not me, Lord, please, you know, and I that is,

that's a valid just, I just want to affirm that's not a valid and normal reaction. And we're not like wishing great suffering on anybody here. But it's, I think the honesty of saying like, you know, we are all broken and we don't all see the ways that we're broken. And it's part of our life journey to come up against the effects of our brokenness and open that to grace and it. Causes real pain. The brokenness causes real pain. It just does.

But in Jesus Christ opened up to Jesus Christ is all worth it for the joy set before him. Christ endured the cross, and that joy is real, and it's all worth it. Amen. Our next question is also from an anonymous listener. Recently I I was in confession and I said that at times I am, quote, lustful. The priest asked me to be more specific and as a woman I felt

very uncomfortable being more specific. After confession I was reflecting on it more and realized maybe I do need to be more specific so the priest understands what exactly I'm confessing. Typically how I feel that I engage in this sin is when I see an attractive man that's not my husband, I may find myself aroused by him and let myself entertain the idea of him too much. Also at times I see my intentions for coming together with my husband are not fully

pure and there might be some selfish lustful desires there. Many times I stop myself and do not suggest coming together with my husband to avoid using him. Is there a more concise yet specific way of confessing these sins without giving all these details? Is there a name for these sins? I want to be accountable but understand that priests are fallen men too, and I want to be prudent, especially because I'm a young woman. Oh, bless your tender, tender

heart. Gosh, gosh, I feel so honored by people making themselves so open and honest and vulnerable here. And what a, what a privilege it is to have just a window into this person's heart and what she's wrestling with, what she's struggling with and what she's seeking. And I can understand all those questions, all the, the reasons she, I, I was especially struck by her saying, I know a priest is a fallen man too. And, and I, I want to be

respectful of that. And that's beautiful. Bless you, bless you, bless you. I just want to bless your heart. I do have a, a few thoughts. I think maybe a concise way to put it where you're, you're giving the right. I do I, I understand the priest, let me put it that way. I understand why he's saying, can you be a little more specific? He, he may want to give you counsel. He may want to understand a little more to direct you in the in the right way. So I understand where he may be coming from there.

And I think a way you could say it that would not raise that same question in a priest would would be to say to talk about Christ's words in the Sermon on the Mount. If you even look lustfully at another, you've already committed adultery in your heart. Now Christ points out a man in that scripture. If a man looks lessly, but it applies just as much to a woman. So you could say I have, I have looked at others with lust in my heart. I have not upheld their dignity as persons made in the image of God.

I've entertained thoughts of of using others sexually. And you could say sometimes that same inclination to use someone sexually has entered into my own marriage. And I don't want to treat my husband that way. I want to love every man as a person made in the image and likeness of God. And a good way to talk about our sins is to talk about the virtue that we are lacking and committing them. So you could say to the priest, Father, I so long in my heart to see every man as as a person

made in the image of God, as someone to uphold in his great dignity as another image of Christ, the Bridegroom. Because every man, just as every woman is an image of the church, every man is is a living image of of Christ. The bridegroom doesn't mean either of us either women or men live up to what that means. But that's our authentic identity. So you could say, Father, I long to uphold the dignity of every man in the way I I see them. And I want to be rightly attracted to masculine strength

and goodness and I want to see Christ in every man I encounter. And sometimes I don't. Sometimes I slip into treating men in my heart and in my mind as an object for my own selfish pleasure, including my husband. I think that would be a good way to say it. That's all. That's the proper level of detail. You don't get need to go into more detail than that. It it clearly specifies the, the sin you are committing. And I think that's all the priest needs to, to hear to give you the proper counsel in the confessional. At the same time, I, I would want to invite you just as

you've been so honest with us here to, to be just as honest with Jesus in your, in your prayer life. I, I don't know if you keep a prayer journal, if you don't keep a prayer journal, maybe just write a letter to Jesus in which you say, dear Jesus, this is what I'm struggling with in my heart. This is what really goes on in my heart. And, and write it out just as you experience it and, and, and allow the cry of your heart to,

to see men rightly well up in you. Because every time we're, we're looking at someone lustfully, there's a genuine desire underneath that, that we're seeking in a disordered way to, to satisfy. And we have to learn how to get in touch with that genuine desire and open it up to Jesus and let him let him into all the distortions, but let him untwist those distortions to get us in touch with that genuine desire. You've heard me say it before on this podcast if you're a regular listener.

The devil doesn't have his own clay. All he can do is take God's very good clay and twist it up. Christ comes into the world not to throw away that twisted clay. Christ comes into the world to untwist it. Christ invites us not to redemption from our sexuality. He invites us to redemption of our sexuality, and that means we have to let them into those places in our heart. So write out a letter to Jesus without censoring anything,

without censoring or qualifying or, or or numbing, dumbing it down at all. Write it out to Jesus just as you feel it. Now, say, having said that, I would also say this, I would hope for you, I would wish for you that you would find a priest who could be a regular confessor, whom you could come to know and trust so intimately

with your heart that you could read such a letter directly to him, uncensored, unfiltered, in the confessional. That would be the ideal. We don't live in the ideal and sometimes we don't know the priest well enough to know if he can handle all those nitty gritty details. And, and I think there is when you don't know the priest, there's a proper prudence in not giving all the nitty gritty details, but specifying the sin enough that it's in the light

and you can properly receive absolution and he can properly counsel you. And what I shared earlier, I think is the proper way to classify your sin in the confessional with a priest you don't know. I, I'm speaking from my own experience here where I've been journeying with a priest now for over 20 years, who knows me thoroughly. I can trust him with anything and everything. And I can share my deepest and my darkest and get it all out uncensored, unfiltered as I experience it. And that has been a tremendous

gift and blessing to me. Again, not everybody has that that gift and blessing in his or her life. So their prudence is appropriate here. And I think her sensitivity is appropriate. But I'm just holding that out as pray, pray, Lord, if you want me to have a priest in my life who's a regular confessor with whom I can get out my deepest and my darkest without censoring or filtering anything, please send that priest into my life. Please send that priest into my life. Lord, I, I hope I've covered all my my bases there in, in

qualifying that in the right way. Do you think I did, Wendy? I, I think it was really helpful. I, I had just one other thing I wanted to share, which is that the, the sensitivity of your heart to some of the, the interior sins, you know, that aren't played out in action necessarily, but they are just encounters with your own fallenness. And, and maybe looking back and wishing you had not maybe stayed

with a thought or a desire as long as you did. I think is a sign of your, your sensitivity, your desire for the true and the good and the beautiful in your heart. I also just want to encourage you and all of our listeners to also recognize how often the grace is there, right? And you receive it. So to sometimes as Catholics with our, you know, understanding that we should

confess our sins, we might forget that we're, we should also give thanks for the graces and the redemption that goes on in our lives. Cause like we have a set aside time for confessing sins, but till we set aside a time to thank the Lord for his faithfulness and and for the growth that has happened in our minds and hearts and interior that you, you know also, you know, it's almost implied in the way this question is worded that there are also times when when

you know, you don't dwell on these desires or entertain things that are lustful. So I want to give thanks to the Lord for His goodness in your heart that has enabled you in many circumstances to do exactly what Christopher was saying, to honor the men in your life as a gift and for their dignity. And I hope all of our listeners can also recognize how beautiful that is, how amazing and life giving that is to the world when

we when we live in touch with the Lord's grace and we are able to honor people and their dignity in that way. She really does have a rich sensitivity to to these things, which itself is a work of grace. And I, I just want to add two more things for the sake of clarity. The one is, please don't hear what I was saying earlier. Please no one hear what I was saying earlier as if I'm saying you should be hiding certain things from your confessor. No, no, no, no, no. But there's, there's a level of

detail that is not always required in the confessional. The priest needs to know what sins you have committed, but but not necessarily all the insurance and outs of it, what's going on in your heart, because that might not, you might not have time to get into all that detail. There might be a line of other people up for confession or whatever. But I'm saying if you can find a priest that you can share all that level of detail of what's going on in your heart, it can be very fruitful. I just wanted to clarify that. And one other thing I wanted to

mention was she had said sometimes she feels that lust in her heart for her own husband and will will refrain from the marital act. I, I would invite you in that situation. I think your desire is clear that you want to honor your husband. That's beautiful. I would invite you, though maybe instead of saying we shouldn't come together, maybe you should say to your husband, honey, can you pray with me? I'm just struggling with certain lust in my heart.

Can you pray with me that my heart would be open to the Lord's grace and I I would, I would love you in the right way and we would come together in the right way. I just hold that out as a suggestion because sometimes our our hearts can get so fearful that we think I can't come together with my husband unless I'm perfect in my intentions. That is not the case. All that is required is that our hearts are open to God's grace in our imperfections. So I hold that out. Yeah. Our next question is from a listener named Nathan.

Hi, Nathan. What would your advice be for two Catholics with same sex attraction who want to adhere to the teachings of the Catholic faith, who believe it is their vocation to be life partners romantically but not sexually? Bless you Nathan. Thank you for this question. I, I just want to praise God for the grace that is evident in your life, that you want to embrace the, the virtue of

chastity. And I also want to call you to a, to a deeper love of this person in your life. And what do I mean by a deeper love? Men are called to love other men rightly. I, I need the bond of, of brotherly love in my life. But I'm going to challenge you, Nathan, here to to recognize

that when brotherly love takes on a romantic shape or sense or connection, something is still in need of healing. Something is still in need of being set in right order. An emotional entanglement between two people of the same sex that has a romantic flavor to it.

It is coming from a place in our hearts that is not in keeping with God's plan for same sex relationships. You are called to love this man. He is called to love you. The question is, what does that mean really and truly to love each other? You 2 are are on a journey. It's it's evident that you're on a journey and you see the beauty

of Catholic teaching. But as is the case with all of us, and I'm first on the list, there's always more. There's always a, a call deeper. There's always a need for a deeper purification. There's always a need for a a deeper enlightening of our minds and our hearts in a a, a a new level of untwisting what sin has twisted up in our lives. In your same sex attraction, there is something good you are

looking for, something good that's gotten because you're broken. Like I'm broken and everybody's broken. The good things in our lives get twisted up and it's OK that we are broken. It's OK that things are twisted up in our lives because there is a remedy. There is a there is a path of redemption where we take up our cross every day and we follow the Lord and we open our hearts to the Lord and we let Him into all areas of our lives. All of our attachments, all of

our romantic feelings, all of our erotic inclinations, all of our hopes, dreams, and desires. We let Jesus into all of it. And we give him full permission to rearrange the furniture however he so desires. As we go on that journey, we will find things in our lives that we were once attached to, once attracted to, once desirous of. We will find ourselves less so. We will find our hearts more and

more inclined towards the things that our hearts are meant to be inclined towards. It doesn't mean we don't still struggle with certain things. It doesn't mean life isn't still a a battle to follow God's will. It can and will be a battle in this life till the day we die. But the battle aspect of following God's will can be lessened greatly. We can make real progress on that journey. So I would just invite you, Nathan, to open your love for

this man, which in many ways is beautiful and genuine and true and right. And I don't question that. But you like me and everybody else on the planet. There's all kinds of other things mixed in with our life and our loves. I I love you Wendy, I love you. I love. I know it's real, I know it's genuine, I know it's right, I know it's true. I know it's beautiful in so many many many ways. I also know cuz I'm broken, that's messed up and I got twisted stuff in there and I got stuff I got to look at all the

time and I got to go deeper and deeper in loving you rightly brother, if you go on that journey with this man you love, things will be set more and more in order. And I am convinced that what is romantic, what has an erotic undertone or overtone, that erotic dimension or slash romantic dimension of your attraction will become more and more a genuine brotherly attraction that desires that

other brother's good. And, and you will come to know that the romantic dimension of a relationship with your own sex is, is not in keeping with God's good, beautiful, wonderful plan for you, but an authentic brotherly love, which is what you really desire that is in keeping with God's plan for you. Much more could be said should be said, but we, we don't have time in this forum. I would, I would invite you to

learn more about the ministry of Desert Stream and their Living Waters program. We'll have a link in the show notes to learn more about that. I would invite you to maybe join our patron community and watch the retreat that I did with Andrew Comiskey and his team where we we get into some of these issues. I think you will find that helpful as just a further step and maybe my book Good News

about Sex and Marriage that has a chapter on these topics might might also be of assistance to you. Yeah, I just, I sense you're there's in your answer, Christopher, there's a, a loving call higher and it, it's you're giving it with an acknowledgement that that already to people who are considering this as a, as an option are already, you know, experiencing some call higher,

but they don't yet see how, how what else is possible and desirable. And it's it's sort of like a desire to say, well, I know I'm, I'm weak and needy. So can I like follow this rule and then just kind of live in what comforts my weak neediness somehow. And it's so human and understandable and relatable.

And so, you know, it's also important just to like continue to affirm that there has already been grace at work, what you said. And and that is so true for for those of our listeners who know people in this kind of struggle, maybe it's not your personal struggle. Like, I do want to ask you to continue to pray for them to receive that higher call of a true, true love and desire for

the good of the other and, and desire for the good of their own story to be truly in keeping with God's intention for them and what is possible through grace and, and all of that prayer in, you know, infused with mercy. Like we don't choose to be fallen. We don't pick it out and say, Oh yeah, I'd like that. We, we are born in fallen worlds.

We experience things in our lives that are painful, that we cope with in ways that, you know, become so familiar to us that we don't even know what we're doing sometimes. And we need help in that journey and we need God's mercy. And so I just want to encourage all of our listeners as they hear and reflect on this, to be inspired to pray and to, you know, be open to God's mercy and also to that goodness of being.

All of us called higher in our journey toward the Lord. And I mean, I'm speaking to myself as well. You know, I need that. I need to be called higher. And so I thank you for what you said and, and I do pray for this and every couple that's struggling in this very way. All of our loves need to be purified. That's the bottom line. My love for you, Wendy, needs to be purified. Your love for me needs to be purified. This man's love for this other man needs to be purified. And we just have to commit

ourselves to that journey. As I said earlier, it's OK that we're twisted up because there's a remedy, but it's it's not OK to call what's twisted up healthy or good. The Lord wants to come in to all of our attachments and purify them. And guess what? We get them back better than they ever could have been if we were just clinging to what we thought we we wanted. Lord, help us to trust You with our road and journey of purification. Help us to live as the men and

women You created us to be as gifts, and help us to embrace the grace that enables us to. Become what we are. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed

counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Christopher West Host Feed-stated
  • Wendy West Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode