Questions answered this episode: How do unbaptized people fit into the body of Christ? My husband and I are new Catholics. We both have a past in regards to sexual sin. While dating we frequently had to stop ourselves in times of passion and it seemed like he was always aroused when we were together. Then we got married and all of that went away. He never wanted to have sex in the earlier part of our marriage while I did. Two and a half years later, we have significantly decreased the frequency of our union. How can we seek healing and move forward and grow closer together in this? I’m constantly worried about looking lustfully. I want to be able to appreciate sexual beauty as you describe in one of your YouTube videos but I’m afraid that opening myself to that can lead to lust. Could you explain these topics deeper? 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: Please reach out to Dave Sloan for info on the John Paul II Legacy Foundation: dave@jp2legacy.org Click here if you’d like to make a gift to the St. John Paul II Legacy Foundation List of trusted professionals. “How To Discern Lust and Attraction” video “Is It Possible To Look At Bodies Without Lusting?” video “TRUE PURITY: Going Beyond Just Avoiding Lust” video Love & Responsibility YouTube Series 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here 🌟 For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. I was about to say good morning to all of our podcast listeners. Good morning. Because it's morning. It's morning when we're recording, but. It's probably not more. I don't know, maybe it's morning if it's morning for you. Good morning. Thanks for listening. We're back for another episode and we're happy to be with you. Hi, podcast listeners. I had a fun trip to Mexico
recently. It was jam packed, I had a lot of events in a very short time frame, and I was exhausted when I got back. But. That's kind of normal, isn't? It. But what I'm what I'm wanting to share with all of our podcast listeners is a very memorable encounter with a beautiful, beautiful nun. She didn't speak a word of English. We needed a translator to communicate with words, but she communicated with such joy about
how the theology of the body has changed her life as a religious woman, as a woman who has given her whole life, body, mind, spirit, heart to the one bridegroom, Jesus Christ. And one of my favorite things, you know this about me, Wendy. One of my favorite things in my work is to bless nuns. I love blessing nuns because they're so underappreciated. And when they catch that TOB fire, when, when their lamps get
lit on fire, to use that biblical image, you know the difference between the wise virgins and the unwise virgins. The wise virgins have oil for their lamps. That means their heart is on fire. It means their yearning, their bridal desires, their Eros, properly understood, is is ignited and aimed at its true end, the marriage of the Lamb, union with Christ. And this nun, she must have been. I don't know, pushing 70 anyway. And, and you could just tell she
had caught this bridal fire and she kept kissing my hands and kissing my head and squeezing me and hugging me and, you know, trying to communicate just with her body language because she knew I didn't speak Spanish. And, and I just hold her in my heart. I'll never forget her. She was so beautiful. I love her, love her. Can't wait to be in heaven forever and ever and ever with this nun. Beautiful. Yeah, thank you Lord, for I wish I remembered her name or I don't even know if I ever learned her name. But bless you, dear sister, whoever you are, I love you.
I love you, I love you. I I am so excited that you have caught this fire. And man, I can't wait to see you ablaze forever. That's awesome. Do you have any updates for us from the TOP institute? Now is the last opportunity if you are on the fence about coming to the theology of the body in the Marion Mystery Course from January 5th to the 10th, 2025, registration will be closing probably this week. So if you're sitting there and
you're thinking, ah, guys, yeah, yeah, just do it. Just come. We do have a few spots left, but only a few. So they're going to go very quickly. So if you're on the fence and you want to come, now's the time. And I do want to give a shout out. We have gotten a generous response to our initial campaign for the Saint John Paul, the Second Legacy Foundation. Thank you Lord. There was a generous anonymous donor recently who gave us $50,000.
Thank you, Lord. Thank you, Lord. Thank you, Lord. Thank you. Our first campaign is to raise $450,000 in order to supply 9. What it No, I always get the math wrong. My brain is not. I'm not a mathematician. What did I say, 1000? Scholarships for online courses. 1000 scholarships for online courses The the regular price for an online course is $900. The TOB institute is putting up half of that, which is where we get the number 450.
Am I doing my math? Right. It's great. OK, Yes, we we need to raise $450,000 to meet this initial goal. And I just want to say thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you to that anonymous donor who so generously gave us $50,000 towards that campaign and is going to be put to very good use going straight to the scholarship fund to enable people to attend our courses who couldn't otherwise pay for them. If you are able to help us in this campaign, we would be so grateful. All donations are tax deductible
to the Saint John Paul the Second Legacy Foundation. And we'll have a link in the show notes are. You ready now for a question from one of our patrons? I. Am ready, Let's do it. This is a question from a patron named Sarah. Hello Sarah, Thank you so much for supporting our work. So grateful to you. Hi Christopher and Wendy, thank you so much for your beautiful ministry and the sacrifices you've made to share theology of the body with us. It is so appreciated. My question is how exactly do
unbaptized people fit into the body of Christ? I was taught that Christian baptism following the Trinitarian rite is what brought someone into Christ's body, and I've heard you share about serving and loving Christ bodily and his members here on earth. But this leads me to an awkward place of wondering, what about those who are not baptized Christians? My intuition and heart tell me that we are absolutely loving Christ through loving everyone.
And I think about quotes from Mother Teresa talking about serving Christ in the distressing disguise of the poor, whom I presume were largely unbaptized in that part of the world. But how does this work if I'm loving Christ in someone who's not technically a member of his body? Or are they members of his body in some other mechanism of being his creations and made in his image and likeness? I'd love any insights you have into baptism and what it does on a deeper level.
Sarah, I love your question. This girl's a thinker. Oh yeah. She's going for it. And I, I love that you even come up with that question, Sarah. It just means it's evidence that you are pondering the mysteries. So thank you. Thank you for your open heart pondering these mysteries. I am LED immediately. I mean, she thinks she's already answered her own question. She's got some instincts and she wants to know. Yeah, I just want to affirm, Sarah, your instincts are correct, that we're all made in the image and likeness of God,
and we are all made in the image of, in likeness of God through the Son who is the perfect image of God. So this reminds me of a quote from the Second Vatican Council. This is Gaudium Atspez. I think it's I think it's in that famous paragraph 22, if I'm not mistaken, where the council says that when the word was made flesh, he united himself with
every human being in a certain sense. Now that qualifier in a certain sense is is important and it is a sense that is distinct from what happens in baptism. And we could use different language here, different vocabulary, different terminology to get at the same truth. I'm going to venture this as a, a possible way of speaking about it, that there is a, a natural
unity with Christ by the very reality of being made in the image and likeness of God. So we are images of God in and through the perfect image of God the Son, Jesus Christ. So that's a, we could say a natural unity with Christ that is to be distinguished from a supernatural unity with Christ that only happens in baptism. Something very real, something
very significant, something that leaves an indelible mark on the person happens in baptism. So there is an ontological to use a fancy word meaning in our very being difference between a baptized person and a non baptized person, right. Everyone is a son of the father or a daughter of the father naturally through the fact that there's one God and he created
us all. But that is a natural reality. There is a supernatural reality of regeneration that takes place in baptism, and that is a change so fundamental, so deep that it is ontological, meaning it is a change in our very being. We are all generated naturally by our parents and by God, who is part of the action in in the union of of our parents.
When we were conceived, God was an intimate part of the action. And in that natural sense, God is the Father of us all. And we are all united in that sense, in a natural sense with Christ. But an altogether new reality, grace, perfecting nature. And, and I love, I love this idea. This is Jesus speaking to Nicodemus. You cannot enter the Kingdom unless you are regenerated, born anew. And Nicodemus gets a little confused.
Can a mother, can a man enter his mother's womb a second time? And Jesus doesn't say no. He rather raises the conversation to the supernatural level. He says, Nicodemus, if you don't understand the natural reality, the earthly reality, you're never going to understand the heavenly reality. So let's just assume, as you are assuming, and I think you're correct, Sarah, that many, many, many of the people that Mother Teresa was caring for were not baptized. Nonetheless, she saw Christ in
them through this natural connection that we're all sons of the Father, daughters of the Father by virtue of our natural birth and our being made in the image and likeness of God. So you are, you are correct, but there is that distinction. We are called to be born anew and that regeneration is not superfluous. It is very significant and very important, which is why Christ in the Great Commission said go out to the ends of the earth and baptize everyone in the name of
the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Yeah, I want to ask you just reading over Sarah's question and I just, I don't know the answer to this. So here this is a Wendy W question. All right. Did you submit it to the? I didn't. I didn't you're. Sneaking it in, it's true. Oh my word, here it is. I think you're button in line. OK, I've kind of worked hard on this podcast. Just let me ask a question. I, you know, I was just being a goofball. Yes, I, I do.
I thought our listeners would appreciate me pleading with you a little bit. OK, so I, I know that and if you already answered this and I got distracted, I'm so sorry. But so yes, everyone is made in the image of God through Jesus, and we are in countering Christ in every human being. And yet there's something that Sarah mentioned about baptism
causes someone to become part of the body of Christ. And I wonder if in the image of God and part of the body of Christ are two different things. Yeah, I don't know. I get no, I I didn't address that Wendy, so you didn't get distracted. I didn't address it and and it's a it would take a doctoral dissertation really to parse these things out. But I think we can say and
rightly say we are, we are members of the body of Christ only in the, in the fullest sense, in, in the truest sense of the word of what Paul means through baptism. We, we are, let's put it this way, we are related in potential to the body of Christ in as much as we are human beings because we are made to be, we are made by God to be part of that body.
So there is a there is a relationship to the body even for unbaptized persons in potential incapacity like the heart, whether the heart knows it or not, the heart is yearning to be incorporated. Think of that word incorporated, brought into the corporeal reality of Christ. There is a yearning for that in every human heart, and that yearning that fundamental reality of being human, that we
yearn for something that we cannot put a word to. What we yearn for is to be one in the flesh with Christ. We yearn to participate in the divine life. We yearn for union for for the affirmation of our very existence at its deepest being. And that is the grace of baptism, to be incorporated into the body of Christ.
And in being incorporated, because Christ's body has been taken up through the Ascension into the everlasting bliss of the Trinity, Baptism into the Body of Christ is the promise that our bodies too will be raised from the dead and assumed into the everlasting bliss of the Trinitarian exchange. That is what the heart yearns for, whether it knows it or not. So every heart, every human being, I would say, is, is at
least in potential oriented towards that incorporation. But but there is a definitive reality of incorp, of being incorporated, which is baptism got. It that's beautiful. I I, I love the teachings of Mother Teresa. They really impacted my life at an important time as I was entering adulthood. That idea of loving Christ and in the distressing disguise and,
and it is amazing to think that you can love Christ in every human being. And I think what you're sharing about that potential, that capacity, that yearning kind of increases the sense of compassion for suffering humanity, knowing that perhaps some of that suffering would be given meaning or be relieved by being truly joined in the body of Christ. And what you know, that
compassion goes beyond the physical or the emotional to the the ontological. How do you like me throwing that word in? My wife just said ontological. Yes, love it. You know, what I love about Mother Teresa is just her, the simplicity of her faith. You know, there is a place in, in the church for the, the, the nuances and scholarship of, of real technical, theological
language. There's a place for that. It's very valuable. But man, there is a place for the simplicity of a Mother Teresa who who is living that theology in recognizing this person lying in the gutter is is Christ in his distressing disguise. We need both. We need all of that in the church. Amen. Amen. Thank you Sarah for your question. We hope our reflections were
were helpful to you. You're, you're on the right track, Sarah. Love your heart. Keep going. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. My husband and I are new Catholics, ex Protestants and have been so incredibly blessed by our new found faith. Praise God. We both have a past in regard to sexual sin. He has a previous marriage as well as porn and masturbation. I also have a past with masturbation.
While dating, we frequently had to stop ourselves in times of passion, and it seemed like he was always aroused when we were together. Then we got married and all of that went away. We struggled through some Ed in the earliest part of our marriage. He never wanted to have sex. Mercy, I always did. Mercy. Now 2 1/2 years later, we have significantly decreased our frequency. We're now at about once a month. Let's just say NFP is quite easy
for him. I'm confident that there's no porn use or masturbation happening with either of us. How can we move forward and grow closer together in this? He has never initiated sex and I'm turned down about 70% of the time. It is highly frustrating. We both want to be better, but there are obvious issues. How do we address this and seek healing? Bless you, dear sister, bless you, bless you, bless you not.
Not only I'm sure, is it frustrating, but it's painful. It's. Painful to put yourself out there so vulnerably and and be rejected, turned down. Ouch. It it, it wounds the heart. It hurts the heart. And then the question becomes, am I? Am I not lovable? Am I not attractive? Do I not excite him? Does he not desire me? All of those, all of those very, very real, very, very vulnerable, very, very painful
questions of the heart. I feel so honored that that people entrust such vulnerable, tender realities of their heart to us. And I just want to show that place in your heart, my dear sister, great reverence, that that pain, that sorrow, that longing, that suffering is, is a sacred reality. You are deeply united with Christ in it. He is deeply united with you. And that would be just my first word of encouragement is to
recognize a mysterious, a very real, but also mysterious intimate union with Christ the Bridegroom. That you are experiencing on the marriage bed of the cross. St. Augustine might have been the first one to use that expression, but it it came into the language of the Church early on, that the cross is the
marriage bed where Christ consummates the union with His bride. And in this suffering, my dear sister, you are being invited by Christ the bridegroom to this other marriage bed, to this marriage bed that is not a bed of pleasure, but a bed of pain, a bed of sorrow, a bed of piercing. But it is a fertile bed.
It is a fruitful bed. And that suffering that you are experiencing because of the dysfunction from a sexual past, that suffering united with Christ, open to Christ, presented to Christ, offered to Christ, will bear fruit in your marriage. This is Christ's promise. Those are my first words of encouragement in the absence of
union in your sacrament, you are experiencing in the very pain of that, a profound union with the true bridegroom on the marriage bed of the cross. And, and I would invite you to say Jesus, my bridegroom, my true bridegroom. What does this mean? What do those theological ideas really have to say to me in my day-to-day sorrow in my marriage? And your bridegroom who knows you and loves you, can speak to your heart and wants to speak to
your heart, and he'll speak to your heart in the language of your heart as you present your heart to your true bridegroom. Maybe you, maybe you hear a favorite song from your childhood. Maybe you see a scene from one of your favorite movies. Maybe you have a certain memories that come to mind, happy memories or painful memories. Maybe some of those memories from your sexual past might come to your mind and heart. If it's the Lord leading you there, don't be afraid to open those painful memories to your bridegroom, to Christ your
Bridegroom, and let Him speak to you of what it was you were truly looking for in those sexual sins. Because behind every sinful acting out, there's a genuine desire that we are seeking to gratify in a disordered way. And he wants to get us in touch with those true desires and and show us the holy path of of seeking true, true satisfaction for the genuine desires of our heart.
So that's those are my first words of encouragement. Secondly, you are right, I believe to recognize that the lack of sexual desire on your husband's part has something to do with his sexual past. That is just good spiritual math when you can see how that adds up. And I believe you are correct to recognize that's how it's adding up. And we can't know for certain what it all means or there could certainly be a biological
reality to it that is not rooted in something necessarily difficult from a sexual past. But I'm going to give it a 99% certainty that his lack of desire or fear of the marriage bed or whatever might be preventing a more regular union and desire on his part has something to do with the sexual past. So I would ask you are are you open it together as husband and wife in in talking about that?
It can be difficult, it can be painful, but could you imagine asking your husband, are you willing to seek help? Are you willing to seek counsel? Are you willing to seek spiritual direction from a a wise spiritual guide who could take you on a journey into some of those painful memories? Are are you willing to share with me what's going on in your heart as to why you don't desire our union? Why was it that in our dating and courtship, it seems you're
always aroused and, and why is it now so difficult conversation in that regard, in a prayerful environment, in an environment where he knows he can trust you and open his heart to you. Not, not an environment where you're like digging in there to, to present your own anger or, or, or frustration on him, but a place of warmth and openness and a, a soft place for his heart to land as he opens it up to you. Sometimes a husband and a wife,
you know, can be very, very difficult to, to talk about a sexual past because of how painful that is. Other times there's a an openness to a mercy that allows the husband and wife to go to those places with great tenderness and compassion. Every marriage is different and every sensitivity of a marriage is, is different. And I don't want to say every married couple has to be talking through this stuff. It might not be appropriate in a given situation, but it is possible.
Wendy, you and I can attest to this. It is possible in an environment of spiritual maturity and tenderness and mercy, and with a certain veil, to put some of those things on the table and and work through them as a couple. Above all, I would invite you as his wife to offer all of the suffering that this is causing you as intercession for your husband's healing.
This is how the cross and the Paschal mystery of death and resurrection becomes a lived experience in our lives. The pain that others are causing us is a sign of how much pain they are in themselves. And when we open that pain to the Holy Spirit. Here I'm quoting the Catechism. Everybody knows who's a listener of this podcast that I love to go to this passage. Catechism 2843 When we open our own pain to the Holy Spirit, pain that others have caused us,
the Holy Spirit transforms that pain into compassion, and the sting of the memory is transformed into intercession. The pain he's causing you is pain that he is in and you have been invited to to feel that pain and offer that pain as intercession for your husband. And this is what we call as Catholics, redemptive suffering, suffering that bears great,
great, great fruit. I'll just close by saying, and then Wendy, I'm going to pass it to you. Please look at the list of counselors that we recommend here at the Theology of the Body Institute. These are counselors that that we know of who are faithful to Catholic teaching and will not mislead you. I do think some counselling of some kind is going to be needed here to to heal. A couple of things just really
stood out to me in this question. And and I've been, I don't know, sometimes certain questions, just I carry them in my heart. And I've been praying for this couple since reading this question and just feeling the different difficulties that are contained in this brief account of their story. A phrase that struck me was toward the end when she said we both want to be better and that
mutual desire for this source of pain and missing one another. And somehow just it's like a little place that you can touch and notice that there's brokenness here somehow. And that does want to be better to me sounds like want healing and greater communion in our marriage. That's how I translate that as I hear that phrase and I I just
affirm that desire and that it is in both of you is is really beautiful. I also was struck by something she said that we struggled through some Ed in the earliest part of our marriage and which I take to mean erectile dysfunction, which meaning a feeling of like the body's not cooperating with this desire to unite and on the husband's part.
And I, I just wanted to pray for you in that that almost like is, is that a major part of the, the wound going on now in the marriage that is that a source of such a, a painful memory or shame or something that really the Lord could just allow the compassion of the wife in praying for her husband.
And for if there's just a door that's closed in his heart because of that early experience in their marriage, that that's just a prayer image for, for me that I share with you too. As you're interceding for your husband, the Lord may give you images of things, spiritual realities in his life and in his story that that can direct your heart in praying for him. And I'm not saying that's like a magic trick that suddenly it all
gets healed, but it, it kind of prepares both hearts for the healing that the Lord has in store for you. And I, I completely agree with you, Christopher, in, in your encouragement about intercession and about counseling. I do think there's reason for great hope and growth. And I, I do think also that like just saying thank you to the Lord for the graces he's already pouring out in your marriage is
really important because if you would let this struggle define your sense of your marriage, it could kind of put you in a state of just kind of agreeing with the evil ones plan for you. Like this is a messed up marriage. This is a marriage of, you know, some kind of failure on our parts or something. Instead of seeing like the Lord loves these two wounded people so much and he loves their love
for one another and allowing their woundedness to affect their lives is, is a step in the process of it, of their woundedness getting the healing it needs. So I, I just encourage you to see that your story from the Lord's perspective in that. Wendy, your words are anointed. I am feeling your words just kind of wash over me like a bath and it, it, it taps your compassion for this husband who
has I don't like these technical terms, you know, erectile dysfunction Ed that's the vocabulary. So I'll go with it. But I the reason I don't like that vocabulary because it doesn't, it doesn't reach the tender human reality underneath it. And that's what you did with your prayer, Wendy. And I felt something in my own heart as your husband just get get blessed by your tenderness there.
I'll just speak to that for a moment that you know, where, where else can you hear honest conversations about these things but on a podcast? Where are this is our subject matter, the theology of our bodies and and the genitals are such a tender, tender revelation of in most realities of our hearts. And when a man's genitals are not functioning in the marital embrace, that can cause a deep
wound, a deep sense of inadequacy, a deep sense of fear, a deep sense of I'm not a man or am I less of a man. All these questions that attack our sense of ourselves and they go so deep. And Wendy, I think you are probably putting your finger on something very important here in their relationship. And I would invite this, this wife to, to ask the Lord for a window into your husband's heart
there. And I, oh man, I can almost feel it how that could shut a man down, that that wound could shut him down, could make him afraid of the marital act because it's so painful, because these realities are so intimately tied to our identity. And for him to know from you as his wife that you love him right there in that very fearful place, in that place of feeling inadequate, in that place of
feeling, I can't be the man I'm called to be. I failed for him to know your tender love. And I, I don't want to get too into intimate details here, but but I, I'm not afraid at the same time to invite this wife. If you could imagine this as a holy reality, because it is a holy reality just to, to lay your hands on your husband's tender places and, and say, I love you and I bless you here.
And I, I, I, you are no less of a man to me because you had this erectile dysfunction. You are no less of a man to me. I love you here, I love you here, I love you here. I want to be with you here. I want to cast those lies out of your heart that you are not a man, that you are less of a man. I want you to know that I love you in your tender places of body and soul. Every man needs to know that
every and I just. As I As I pray that I. I'm just seeing like walls coming down. I'm seeing this, this fortress like collapsing. And, and that's what I'm a frightened man does. He builds a fortress around his heart when he when he feels inadequate, when he feels afraid, when he feels not up to the task. He just builds walls around his heart. How do I know this? Because I've done it, done it 100 * 1000 times in all my fears and insecurities and, and Wendy, knowing your love in my
vulnerable broken places that has enabled walls to come down. It's real. I'm so grateful to you, Wendy, for your insight into that, that reality and for speaking into it. Lord, we lift up this couple. We lift up every couple around the world. We lift up our marriage and we ask you, please, Lord, please shine your light into our broken places. Please help us to be as tender with each other, Lord, as you
are tender with us. We're all are. Those wounds and insecurities lie, Lord. Come, come kiss us there. Come let us know that we are loved there. Yes. Lord, and that we can grow and we can heal. Amen. Amen. Our next question is from a listener named Christopher. Well, hello, Christopher. I like that name. Hello Christopher and Wendy, I was watching your video about looking at bodies without lusting and appreciating their
sexual beauty in a holy way. I am almost constantly very worried about looking with lust and mistreating and disrespecting people whom I love, for example my girlfriend. I want to be able to appreciate sexual beauty as you describe in your video, but I'm afraid that opening myself up to that can lead to lust. This is especially worrisome for me, as I feel that this line of thinking justifies unmarried
couples being naked around one another to appreciate the other's sexual beauty in a holy way. I feel that this is inherently immoral, not just unwise. Therefore, I have trouble accepting this thought process as I feel that it will likely lead to sin when applied to real life situations. If not for everyone, at least for me. I would really appreciate an explanation as I want to grow in holiness. Thank you. Bless you, Christopher, Brother
I I can so relate to all the questions, all the wrestlings, all the stirrings. Believe you me and I imagine you're referring to a video on our YouTube channel. We've we've had various videos on our YouTube channel where I address this topic and I'll ask our producer to to put a link to some of those videos in the show notes for this episode so people can watch those videos. Can you read the first line about where he said, looking at the?
I was watching a video about looking at bodies without lusting. OK, I want to just pause right there. Looking at bodies is is to me a problematic statement. Or it could be problematic because we have such a tendency to rupture the body from the person, to rupture the body from the person. That's the very definition of looking with lust, where we rupture the body from the dignity of the person.
So this video that he's referring to is not about so much looking at bodies in some abstract way without lusting. It's rather about the call to see the person integrally, body and soul. To see the person integrally, body and soul. Here's the danger if we don't go on that journey, Christopher. If we don't go on the journey,
which is difficult and it is fraught with danger, and you are not wrong to say, gosh, if I open this up, it could lead to lust. Yup, it could, but it doesn't have to. Remember these words of Saint Paul, Christopher, It is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Only he says do not use your freedom to indulge your sinful passions.
Now notice he doesn't say lock up your freedom. The way to avoid using your freedom to indulge your sinful passions is by eradicating your freedom by chaining it up. No, no, no, it is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Free to live, free to love, free to see the world rightly. Christ's words in the Sermon on the Mount about looking with lust this is a direct quote from Saint John Paul the Second. Christ's words in the Sermon on the Mount about looking with
lust are an invitation to a pure way of seeing others, a pure way of seeing others capable of respecting the true meaning of the body, what John Paul the Second calls the spousal meaning of the body. Christopher, you are right to recognize that we can, we can use the beauty of the human body
in a lustful way, but there's another way to see, there's another way to think, there's another way to experience it. And the danger here, Christopher, of, of a mentality that that says, well, you know, there's really no other way to see the body than lust. I'm always going to be lusting. That's just the way it is. The danger of that mentality is that you see, you come to see by necessity within that paradigm,
by necessity, you come to see marriage as the legalization of looking that way at your spouse, right? Well, it's OK in this situation because she's my wife. Well, what's OK? Is it OK to look at your wife's body as an object for your pleasure? Is it suddenly OK on the wedding night to be naked in front of one another because now your lust for each other is
legalized? This can't be the case. This can't be the case that marriage provides a legal opportunity for us to indulge our lusts. This cannot be the way. This is not the freedom for which Christ has set us free. Which means there must be another way to see the human body, and there is. And Christopher, you're right. When that invitation is held out
to us, we are right to recognize, Oh my gosh, that could be dangerous. If I get out of the boat here, I might sink. Yep, that's true. But the Christian life does not lie in using this imagery of walking on the water with Jesus, right? This the The Christian life is not in the safety of the boat here. The Christian life is in following the call of Christ. Peter, get out of the boat.
Peter got out of the boat, and so long as his eyes were on Christ, he could walk on water. The moment he took his eyes off Christ, he sank and then Jesus scolded him saying, you idiot, what are you doing out here in the 1st place? Get your butt back in the boat. No, he said, Peter, why did you doubt? Why did you lose faith? Christopher? If you are relying only on your own resources to get out of that boat, you will sink and that's
what your heart is. Feeling like this is dangerous. It sounds like it's justifying sin. It sounds like I'm being called to walk on water and I can't do that. You're absolutely right. You cannot of your own strength walk on water. But with your eyes fixed on Christ, you can walk on water. What seems impossible and is impossible for us in our own strength becomes possible only only by the power of Christ at
work in US. Better to get out of the boat and sink than never. To get out of the boat. It's like the guy who buries the treasure, buries the talent, right? He puts it in the ground because he's afraid that he could lose it or he's going to screw it up or, or the, the, the, the Lord's going to be unpleased with with what I did with it, so I'll just bury it. No, the Lord is going to be unpleased if you just bury it. The Lord is going to be unpleased if we just stay in the boat because we were afraid we're going to screw it up. Be not afraid to get out of the boat, but keep your eyes fixed
on Christ. This is not a a justification for looking with lust, it is an invitation to another way of seeing, living and experiencing the body. And it is the freedom for which Christ has set us free. There's something I want to ask you, and I think it's am I? Another question on this one, yes. Two in a row. Am I trying to understand something about Christopher's way that he heard what you said in that video? It seems like he you.
I didn't watch the video or if I did I don't remember it. But you may have spoken about sexual values because I know that is a term that JP 2 uses, JP 2 uses. I feel like he heard that as needing to see naked bodies in in order to kind of prove his purity. And I don't know if if nakedness is really what you were speaking
about. I think when people hear the word sexual, they may hear it differently than you're saying it. Like I know you to be pointing out the fact that she is a woman, the fact that her body has a feminine shape, that her face has a feminine beauty, or the fact that he is a man, that his body has a a masculine form that is noticeable is meaningful.
Communicate something that's seeing sexual values, not because of nakedness, but because of of recognizing the revelation of a male person or a female person has a physical expression that that falls in the category of sexual, maybe in a different way than how Christopher was hearing. It Wendy, you. You're coming again from a, a beautiful angle and seeing something that I I didn't see. And This is why we should always do this podcast together.
And I never, ever, ever want to record an episode without you, which I had to do a few weeks ago because you were sick and I hated it. Thank you for shining that light. So important. Yeah. Yeah. I, I never even thought it because I'm so immersed in JP 2's vocabulary and the way he uses words and. And yeah, I, I guess it could come across when, when I talk quoting John Paul the 2nd about honoring another person's sexual values, you're exactly right, Wendy. It means honoring that other person as a man or as a woman.
And it doesn't. Maybe if Christopher took that to mean getting naked and honoring the other person's sexual values in a in a naked way. Yeah. So I I could see why that could be a a stumbling block for somebody to honor another person's sexual values, just as Wendy said, is to see this woman who looks like a woman and should look like a woman and shouldn't dress in such a way that she doesn't look like a woman. In fact, John Paul the second says that modesty in dress is not incompatible even with
emphasizing our sexual values. Meaning when a woman dresses, she should look like a woman. She shouldn't be trying to to hide the fact that she is a woman. That would be a topic for another conversation about what are the the appropriate ways of dressing, etcetera, that might emphasize sexual values. Well, let me just throw this out just because I brought it up. John Paul the second says that which is immodest in dress is that which seeks specifically to
arouse lust in the other, that which displaces the value and dignity of the person merely with a vision of the person as a sexual object. That would be what would be immodest in dress. So I'll just leave that. Right. Right there and and and and add this. But it's so important. There is a chaste way to see the human body.
Now, you and I, Wendy, we reserved nakedness for our our wedding night, Yes, but let's suppose that I mistakenly entered your your, your house and you were standing there naked or something before we got married. Right, an accidental revelation. An accidental revelation, right? An accidental revelation of your nakedness. Suppose that had happened before we got married. I should have been able to see you with honor and dignity and
not have treated you as some object for my pleasure. There's good reason to save nakedness for marriage. There's good reason for that. But it is not impossible to see the others nakedness rightly. It's difficult, but it is not impossible. These are very nuanced discussions. John Paul the second gets into it with great insight. Revelation beauty understanding
in his book love and responsibility. And I would urge you Christopher, please Christopher, my my good brother, please, please take up a study of John Paul the second's love and responsibility. You could take our online course if you find his language difficult. Many, many people do. We also have Matt Fradd and I did a a like a six or seven hour mini course on love and responsibility, which you can watch for free on three episodes are on my our channel at the TOB
Institute and three episodes are on Pints with Aquinas. We'll put the link in the in the show notes below. Please expose yourself to love and responsibility, where he goes into a much more detailed analysis of these very delicate and easily misunderstood questions. Do you think do you think we covered our bases there? Wendy I I. I I think it would be good if after that clarifying question I asked for people to just rewind and listen to your answer again, just in case anybody was
thinking. Getting out of the boat means OK, we have to get naked with each other. I I don't think that's what you were saying. Well, you know that's not what I'm. Saying, and I think it's important to to re listen and realize what is meant by getting out of the boat is allowing yourself to be challenged to see the person and appreciate the physical beauty, the expressions of femininity or masculinity integrated with the person. And to let your heart be
challenged by that experience where it's difficult to see that. And if anyone uses any of what's been said as licensed to indulge their disordered desires, they are not hearing anything I have said for freedom. Christ has set us free. Only do not use your freedom as the opportunity to indulge your sinful passions. That is what I'm proclaiming. That is the freedom to which I'm calling all of us. Because that's the freedom that
Christ calls all of us to. That's the freedom the whole world yearns for. But because we don't know that freedom, we go in the direction of thinking Sexual freedom means I get to indulge my compulsions whenever I want. Dear God, have mercy on us. We are so desperately in need of discovering what it means that we are a gift. Please, would you? Would you share this episode with somebody who needs to know that he or she is a gift and are
meant to be seen as a gift and meant to be loved as a gift? There is grace poured out for us in the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ for us to live the love we are made for, to be the gift we are meant to be. There is grace flowing from the Pierce side of Christ to enable us to. Become what we are. Amen.
Ask. Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...