Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Death & God's Permissive Will, Church’s Teaching on Masturbation, and Is NFP Truly Open to Life? | ACW329

Apr 21, 202551 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: At a recent funeral, people spoke about God's perfect timing in death, but I wondered, isn't death, the separation of body and soul, a result of the fall? Doesn't God's will have both a perfect and permissive side, given our fallen world and freedom to choose? Wouldn’t God prefer us to live forever, body and soul, rather than just our souls going to heaven? Can you help me understand all of this in the context of Theology of the Body? I was discussing sexuality with my atheist friend when she asked why the Church says masturbation is wrong. She then compared her body to a Ferrari, claiming she worked hard to take care of it and should be able to enjoy it alone. I was left speechless. What does the Church and Theology of the Body say about this? I’ve been practicing NFP with my husband since our marriage, but I’m struggling with my conscience. He wants to wait a year before trying to conceive, while I feel ready to start our family. I worry that NFP is being treated like contraception. I’m also feeling lonely and disconnected, especially since it’s easy to abstain for weeks. How do I talk to my husband about this, and am I wrong to think NFP isn't right for us right now? Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? ⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠ --- Submit your question at ⁠⁠AskChristopherWest.com⁠⁠. --- Resources mentioned this week: View our ⁠⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠⁠ --- 🎥 Check out our ⁠⁠YouTube Channel⁠⁠ 📚 View our ⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠ to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 ⁠GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE⁠ by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ ⁠Join us on one of our pilgrimages!⁠ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Hey everybody. Happy Easter. Monday and he said that at. The same time we did. That was kind of funny. I have a little question for you, for our listeners and. I don't know what it is that's. Right, I'm going to surprise. And then I'm going to ask you one. Oh no, I'm not an on the spot

person. It's. Going to be good. Darn it, see you like the surprise. But if you get to do it, I get to do it. No, it's not the same. All right, Well, here's my question anyway. What I wanted to ask you is in the Gospels and maybe Acts. No, I think it's just in the Gospels there are these different stories of encounters Jesus has after his resurrection. In in Acts 2 with Saint Paul. Good point. But that's after his ascension

too, isn't it? Yeah. So that's different. OK. OK. So anyways, what I want to know is, do you have a favorite encounter, Favorite resurrection encounter? If so, would you share it with me? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I I tend to like especially when John and Peter run to the tomb and see that it's empty. And it says John looked in and believed.

Now he he didn't encounter the risen Christ in that moment, but he encountered something that made him realize his body wasn't just stolen. Wow. He he saw, we don't know what he saw, but he whatever he saw, he believed. So what is that? That mystery intrigues me and I love there's a particular painting I wish I knew the artist.

I don't know the artist. We have it hanging on our refrigerator of Peter and John running to the tomb, and you just know it's just these two faces. But the first time I saw that painting, I didn't even have the context. It wasn't in a religious context. I saw that painting and I knew it was Peter and John looking at the tomb. There's something about just the fact that the artist could portray their faces in such a way that I knew that's John and

that's Peter and and that's what they're seeing, that moment, whatever they're seeing, John says. I believed that's that speaks to me. Yeah, that is so beautiful and it's so fruitful to pause and just ask ourselves those questions. What did he? See. How did he have that knowing? How did he have that faith? Wow, Lord, are there moments like that in my? Life. Yeah, yeah.

That's beautiful. Thanks for asking. I have a question for you now, Wendy. OK, ready. No. OK, she's not ready, but I'm going to ask anyway. So, without giving it much thought, what is the first Easter song that comes to your mind? Jesus Christ is risen today. That wasn't too bad. Do you remember the old? It was one of those charismatic

songs in the 70s and 80s. He's alive, he's alive, he's alive and I'm forgiven. Something, something, something. I don't know the rest of the words. Do you know the one I'm talking about? You don't know that one. He's alive. But you're making me think of another one. Wait, let me. It's OK. Oh, he's alive, and I'm forgiven. Heaven gates. Heaven's gates are open wide. He's alive. You don't know that one. I don't, I don't know that song. Oh, well, I couldn't think of

He's alone. That sounds great. Well, I you know what one we've often remembered is that hear the bells ringing this. Singing that you can be born again. Yeah, that's a good one. Yeah. The Angel up on the tombstone said he is risen just as he said. Yes. Quickly now. Go tell his disciples that. Jesus Christ is no longer dead.

Joy to Yeah. OK, we better stop that now or this is just going to be a singing Easter song. That's right. Sorry everybody, we got a little carried away there. A little different, OK. Moving right along. Moving along now, Happy Easter again and I'm so interested to hear any updates from the Theology of the Body Institute. Yes, I have some exciting news. At the Theology Body Institute we are having our very first online TOB One course in Spanish.

Oh, fun. Yes, and it is happening April 21st to May 2nd. If you are a Spanish speaker, or if you know Spanish speakers who would like to be immersed in John Paul the Second's glorious teaching, now is your opportunity. My dear friend, colleague and former student Evan Lemoyne, who teaches Theology of the Body in Spanish, has translated RTOB One online course into Spanish.

So you get the video with me, but you get Evan Lemoyne's voice in Spanish. Wow, that was a big project. That was a big project. Thank you, Evan. Yes. Thank you, Evan. This is our very first time we're doing it, so it's brand new. Check it out in the show notes. And we also have May 5th to May 16th, we have our Catholic Sexual ethics course taught by Father Joe Koopman. He is the moral theologian in the Diocese of Cleveland, OH.

He has taught this live for us a few times. We filmed it. We now have the online version. He is superb. He is going to give you an excellent history on the questions of sexual morality. He's going to give you a particular tour of the 20th century theological developments in understanding Catholic sexual ethics. John Paul the Second's personalism and how important that is. Let me just give you a window into how important it is to understand John Paul the Second's personalism when it comes to sexual ethics. This is a funny, tragic, crazy

story, but it's it really happened in 1968 when Paul the 6th issued his famous encyclical Human Evitae, famous or infamous depending on whom you speak with. There is a group in the Catholic Church that was trying to promote human Evitae and they printed a bunch of posters that had Paul the 6th on the poster wagging his finger and the

poster simply said the pill is a no no. Is this all we have to offer? That is utterly. No wonder people, if that's all the church has to say. The pill is a no no is this Oh my Lord, God have mercy on us all, Father Joe Koopman. I learned that from Father Joe Koopman when I took his course and he gives so many other interesting tidbits about the history here and the desperate

need for a renewal in Catholic moral theology. Not a renewal that changes the teaching, that would not be a renewal at all. But a renewal in theology that gets us away from the pill is a no no to demonstrating the beauty, the splendor, the glory, the awesomeness of being created, male and female, in the image and likeness of God. And when you have a sense of how beautiful and glorious and awesome it is, as JP 2 says, you don't want to violate the beauty and splendor of it. It would be like trampling on a

glorious flower or something. Why would you want to do that? But when you don't know how valuable it is, you don't know how to take care of it. This course on Catholic sexual ethics will help you know how valuable it is and how to take care of it. So you're going to want to check that out. Yes, that's great. Well, I have something for you right now. I have a question from one of our patrons. Let's do it. This is from an anonymous patron. Thank you, dear anonymous Patron, for believing in our mission and your monthly support enables us to do what we're doing. And I'm going to shout out one more time, I've said this in a

few episodes recently. We have some exciting new developments coming for our patron community. Not yet time to announce them, but they are on the horizon. Thank you patrons. I was recently at a funeral for a young person where many well meaning people were saying when God calls you home you go. His timing is perfect. I know that they meant it in a put your trust in God sort of mentality. Yet I couldn't help but think

about it in terms of theology. The body wasn't the rupture between body and soul that death causes, a result of the fall. Isn't there such a thing as God's perfect will and God's permissive will? Due to the fact that we live in a fallen world with the freedom to make choices? Wouldn't God rather us live forever, body and soul, and not just call our soul to heaven as is often said at funerals? Can you put all these thoughts together for me within the lens

of theology of the body? Bless you. I am so moved that you are wrestling with this because so few give it a second thought. And you are absolutely right to give this a second thought. And 1/3 and 1/4 and 1/5 and it I. I have the very same sensitivity at funerals when people say well meaning things but just not properly informed. And it's an attempt to offer

some consolation in the midst of of real grief. I get that. But people can say such unthinking things. I I'm reminded Wendy of of our dear friend whose husband died of brain cancer years ago and she was suffering. Obviously her husband just died. She's suffering. But what she was particularly suffering with was the thought of her husband's body rotting in the ground. And well, meaning but very misguided Catholic friends said things like, oh, you don't have

to worry about that. You don't have to be sad about that. He's now in heaven. That's just his body. And she responded properly with an authentic Catholic sensibility and said, but that's the body that loved me. That's the body I loved. That's the body I embraced and kissed. That's the body through which I conceived all of our children. And it's rotting in the ground and it's tearing me apart. Yes, exactly. That's what death does.

It tears us apart. It ruptures us. And no matter whatever dance we want to do, to pretend this is just normal and natural, It is not. The separation of body and soul was never, ever, ever meant to happen. And this, dear listeners, wise distinction here between God's will and his permissive will, what He actually wills and what He allows. He allows our freedom to make wrong choices, to bring about a

greater good. That's how awesome and almighty He is. And why does it? Why else does He allow us to make wrong decisions? Because He loves us. And the ultimate goal here is to participate with Him in an eternal marriage. And if the marriage was forced, if we didn't have the freedom to say no to this eternal marriage, guess what? It wouldn't be. It wouldn't be a real marriage. It wouldn't be real love. We would just be automatons.

We would just be robots. God took the risk of giving us freedom, knowing in advance that we would use our freedom wrongly, knowing also that we would have the capacity to use it rightly. And he already had a plan to redeem our wrong use of our freedom. All of that is foreseen. And in that foreknowledge, God's permissive will allowed our freedom to choose wrongly. And the fruit of that was death. And the very reality of death is

the separation of body and soul. If human redemption is real, then it is the redemption of our real humanity. And our real humanity is the union of our body and our soul. Thomas Aquinas says that the souls in heaven right now are in an in human state, waiting for the resurrection of their bodies. We can never, we must never

forget this teaching of our faith. It's not a footnote. It's not some scratch at the bottom or some little in a dispensable idea. This is our faith. If the resurrection of the body is not real, Saint Paul says our faith is in vain. When we proclaim that we have Christian faith in an afterlife, that afterlife is the resurrection of the body.

There's this in between state again, the souls are in an inhuman state. It's an in between state waiting for the resurrection of our body. So can you, can you read again Wendy? I, I launched on all these ideas and I she, but she said some very specific things about that. I want to address 1 by 1 about these sentiments that were were well meaning but misguided. Yeah, people were saying when God calls you home, you go. His timing is. Perfect. When God calls you home, you go. His timing is perfect.

OK, you you are right to have a Is that the best way to put it? Now, God in his permissive will obviously allows people to die. It happens every day. But you are right to say this was not part of God's original plan. Death was never part of God's original plan, and so it would be a more sensitive thing to say something like God, in his loving plan for the universe, has allowed death to enter, and

this young person has now experienced death in this fallen world. But Christ was sent into the world to absorb the pain of death, to absorb the sting of death, so that we can say where O death is your victory, where O death is your sting. That pain is real, that rupture is real. The grief is real. Jesus, Jesus wept when Lazarus died and we should weep. We should weep. Death is a horrific thing.

It is not normal. It is not natural. And I don't think, I don't think we, I don't think we're doing justice to people's grief when when we when we say things like God's timing is perfect and whenever he calls, we should go, no, I don't think that does justice to people's grief. I think we need rather to say there is a real sting here. There is a real pain here. There is a real tragedy here. That's true. And this is also true.

Death has been swallowed up in victory. Where O death is your sting? Where O death is your victory. But we await the victory. The victory has not even fully happened for this young person. It won't happen fully until the resurrection of the body. We have to hold that together. Was there something else she had said? Wouldn't God rather us live forever, body and soul, and not just call our soul to heaven as is often said at funerals? Yes, yes, to think that oh, this person's soul has been called to

heaven and all is well is also not doing justice to a proper understanding of God's eternal plan, that we would live with him forever in the union of body and soul. And that death, the entrance of death into the world, is an abject tragedy. That tragedy again, has been swallowed up in the victory of Christ's death and resurrection. But it remains A tragedy. Tragedy and victory, agony and ecstasy. Let give people the space to go

through their agony, because the Lord teaches us courage in the prayer of agony. This is a summary of Saint Teresa of Avila's teaching. The Lord teaches us courage in the prayer of agony. Because we need even more courage, she says, to endure the prayer of ecstasy. And that prayer of ecstasy in its ultimate expression is the ecstasy of being in union with God, body and soul, forever.

I bless and I affirm all your sensitivities. Here you are. You are putting your finger right on it. And Lord, please, I pray that we would have a renewal of understanding of the true meaning of being male and female, being embodied. That the body is not an afterthought, it's not a footnote, it's not an extra. The resurrection of the body is absolutely essential to what the Catholic faith is.

When did you have any thoughts to add here? I loved when you mentioned that Jesus wept when Lazarus died because I have thought about that so many times. We think about Jesus, who hopefully likely knew his Father was going to answer his prayer and raise Lazarus from the dead. And still the fact that he had died caused Jesus to weep.

And I think like if Jesus would weep because of his dear friend's suffering. And none of us can really know what it is like to make that Passover of death. I do think that sometimes people experience a certain surrender about it and a certain accompaniment of the Lord in their journey that is is consoling.

But I. I don't know, I, I think there's a reason we all fear it so much. I think it is intensely difficult and no one else can do it for you. And that's, that's a lot to go through. And I I sense like Jesus is knowing that for his friend in that story, like that is a a terrible suffering. And yes, it, as you said, my love, it does happen every day.

And yet it is so difficult. And we have a friend who sometimes says, I hate death. And I think, you know, yeah, it's OK for us to hate. Death we should. We don't have to celebrate it. Or, you know, I, I think maybe one of the concerns I have is like we've learned, you know, about stages of grief and, and there's something of like jumping to the resolution stage without journeying through all

the other stages when, when you kind of call out, well, his timing is perfect. Just like, you know what, that that rubs us wrong on different levels, one of which is the level this questioner put out. And you did that like the whole thing is not really God's original plan for us. So that rubs us wrong. And I think it rubs us wrong too, because like there's a a something in us that says

that's, that's not going to help me right now. Yeah. Let me grieve. Yeah. So I, I sense all those things in this and I do sense like, as a person who has been so infused with the gospel through studying theology of the body, you and I are both in that place. There is such a hope for the resurrection of the body, for like the communion that we're

all longing for being closer when we make that Passover into death. But it's still to come because we our resurrection is still to come. But it's that hope is a tremendous gift. And the older we get, the more people we know who are waiting on that side and there is a hope of that kind of reunion with them. Those are those are things that

are genuine in our hearts. It doesn't mean that we aren't also able to say I hate death. And the Lord agrees. I'm, I'm hearing in my head that old Carly Simon song, I haven't got time for the pain. This, this is our culture that that song was used as an ad campaign for some Tylenol or something or other when we were kids. And we're just, we have that ingrained like we don't know how to suffer. And the culture is trying to get

us not to think about suffering. And, and I would suggest if you the next time you're at a funeral, instead of trying to comfort somebody with, oh, this is God's perfect timing or his soul has flown away to heaven. Instead of that, could I invite all of us to offer the consolation. And that word is, is significant console.

It means to be with someone in their aloneness, in their solitude, Consola consolation, to be with someone in their aloneness. They feel alone in their grief, in their sorrow, in their suffering, instead of trying to wish away that suffering or say in essence, well, if you really had faith, you wouldn't be suffering. Rather, how about we go the opposite direction of I haven't got time for the pain and we make time for the pain and we

say, I'm going to be with this person in his suffering over the loss of this loved one. I'm just going to be there. I'm going to be in it. I'm going to sit in the pain with this person and feel the pain and weep with Jesus. That is true consolation to be with that person in his or her sorrow and, and in grieving that. Then the hope comes. A real hope comes in the

resurrection of the body. That death really is swallowed up in victory. I'll leave it at that. Much more could be said, but we'll leave it there. Blessed, blessed, blessed bless. Our next question is from a listener named Maria. Hi, Maria. Hi Christopher and Wendy, thank you so much for your podcast. I've been listening to you every week and it has been a huge blessing in my life. I was talking with one of my friends, she's an atheist, about the church's teaching on

sexuality. At one point in the conversation, she asked me what does the church think about masturbation and then why is it wrong? After talking about the joy of sharing the gift, she said well as I understand it, my body is like a Ferrari. I won't let everyone drive it, but who else can enjoy the Ferrari better than me? I worked so hard to get it and take care of it, why can't I just enjoy my Ferrari by myself?

And she left me speechless and asking myself the same. What does the church and theology of the body say about this? Interesting analogy, and it betrays the fundamental problem. Because a car is a thing, you Rev its engine, it's a, it's a mechanism. And this is how we've been trained to think of our bodies in the modern world, very mechanistically.

And therein lies the problem. When we think of the body as something, then we think we can use the body, manipulate the body, treat the body as something. But we run into a fundamental problem. The body is not something. The body is someone, right? What is the difference between something and someone?

If you saw a car on the side of the road that was smashed up but no one was in it, OK, that's one thing you would say, oh, that's sad, somebody's car got smashed. But if you saw that that car was smashed and there was a person in there bleeding, you would have a very different reaction. You would pull over the side of the road, you'd call 911. Why? Because there's something there's there's a fundamental

difference between a car and a person. When a person is treated as a thing, it violates that person's dignity as a person because that person is not merely a thing. And the the words that I have learned from John Paul the second that get us into the very essence of the difference between something and someone are the words indispensable, irreplaceable and unrepeatable, right.

A Ferrari is, I mean, it's, you pay a lot of money for it, but nonetheless, it's dispensable. Eventually it's going to rust and you will dispense with it. A Ferrari is dispensable, It's replaceable. When your Ferrari rust or say it's totaled in an accident, you replace it with another Ferrari. And in fact, you can replace it with another Ferrari exactly like it. Because Ferraris are not only dispensable and replaceable, they are repeatable.

There are thousands of the very same model of Ferrari at Ferrari dealerships all around the world. Because things are dispensable, replaceable and repeatable. But the human person is the kind of being that is indispensable. Can you think of a time in your life when somebody used you and then threw you away? How did that make you feel?

Not very good, because you're indispensable. That's why that feels like a violation, because it is a violation. Have you, can you think of a time in your life where somebody used you, threw you away, and then replaced you with somebody else that was a wound to your heart? Why? Why did that hurt you so much? Because you're not only indispensable, you're irreplaceable. It wounds you when somebody throws you away and replaces you with somebody else, because you are irreplaceable.

And it wounds you when you get compared to other people, measured by other people, because there's no other you. You're unrepeatable. You are incomparable. You are the only you there ever was. That is true of every single human being. And if that is true, then the only proper response to a human being is it is certainly not to use that other. That is a violation of the other human being.

What is the opposite of using loving? Loving the person. And the person is the kind of being that can only be upheld in his or her dignity when he or she is loved. And love demands relationship. Relationship, the very meaning of the body. First of all, you have to know what something is for to know

when you're using it inappropriately, right? What is human sexuality for? What are genitals for and why are they called genitals? Right, We're talking about a a woman here who is trying to justify masturbation, and I'm sorry to be frank about this, but there's no way to have an honest conversation about this question unless we talk about what is a vagina for? What is the clitoris for?

What? What are they designed to do? There is a purpose to things, and we never flourish when we act contrary to the purpose of things. There's a reason we call a man's penis in a woman's vagina. They're genitals, right? Because these are organs designed to generate, and they are designed to be in communion. A man's penis can't generate on its own. A woman's vagina can't generate on its own.

Hey, how about this? It's through the union of genitals, genital union, that generation takes place. We, we used to call this the facts of life, right? But in a mechanistic view of the human body, when the human body is treated as something and when we erase fertility from the equation, then what's what we reduce our genitals to are are we just reduce them to pleasure? And if the goal of their genitals is merely pleasure, well, then why can't I pleasure

myself? That's sound logic. If the goal of genitals is pleasure, then why can't I? Then you can pleasure yourself. But that's not the goal of genitals. The goal of genitals is holy life giving communion. Holy life giving communion. That's the purpose of genitals. How do we live our lives in such a way that we honor that purpose?

The whole reality of human sexuality is a call out of myself to become a sacrificial life giving gift for others in Holy Communion. To train my genitals in in masturbatory practices of just self pleasure is the exact opposite direction of training myself in the direction of self giving love. This is why masturbation is

contrary to the dignity of the person, because you end up treating your body like a Ferrari let you Rev for your own selfish pleasure, which is utterly contrary to the call to go out of myself and live in life giving communion. Am I saying this to scold anybody, shame anybody, condemn anybody? No, I have my own long laundry list of sins I got to look at in my life. I'm saying this to turn the lights on so we can see a path

forward to real flourishing. At the very foundation of human flourishing is the sexual call to learn how to love. That's the very foundation of human existence. When we get this wrong, we get all of humanity going in the wrong direction. That's the culture we live in today. The invitation is to live the truth of the call to life giving Holy Communion, which is the exact opposite of a masturbatory mindset.

Yeah. The the connection of the kind of philosophy that you know is is there in that justifying of this behavior to all of its ramifications. That philosophy has so many ramifications that our world just kind of thinks are normal. But but it does like that that point you made about like, is it just for pleasure? Is that its purpose? Then you know what that

philosophy leads to? It leads to abandoned children. Yes, yes, and it leads to treating others as objects for our pleasure. It leads to treating others as dispensable, replaceable, and repeatable. It leads to a utilitarian culture versus a culture of life giving love. Yeah. And to see how deep in our hearts we know that we want to have parents who love one another forever and are

committed to one another and to us, that's like a great window, you know, to know the suffering in the world and maybe in our own stories from the lack of that. If we can recognize how that is absolutely related to the same approach that justifies masturbating, we we get it. We get it because in our hearts we know like parents are meant to love their children. And this, as you were talking

about, our genitals are for generating life. They're for becoming parents. So how can we have that right orientation toward a genuine noble willingness to really serve like the needs of children? I that's just what keeps coming to me is you, you just, it's, it's all from this rejection of the call to love.

And maybe we reject that call because we aren't up to the task. And so that's like where it points out our need for a savior. Preach it, Wendy. Preach it, Wendy. You know we need a savior. Yeah, we need a savior. And we need to trust him. Lord, teach us, teach us that call to generous generating love. We are made in the image of a God who is generous generating

love. And guess what? This is why God gave us genitals, so we could image His generous generating love. Lord, Lord save us. Save us from that masturbatory mindset and and redirect our desire towards generous generating love, please Lord. Yes, our next question is from an anonymous listener who says

I'm struggling with my conscience and the practice of natural family planning. I'm a 27 year old woman and my husband and I just got married in the church 5 1/2 months ago. Congratulations. We've been practicing NFP since then. My husband wants to wait to start trying to conceive until we've been married for a year. He wants us to get finances figured out, get to know each other more, go on a trip together, etcetera. His father was the one to say wait a year because once you

have kids you won't get to do anything fun for years. There's, there's some truth to that, but that's, that's, that's that's, that's not true. OK, I resent this attitude as I can't wait to start our family and don't care about whether we go on some big trip or not. We own a home and both have good paying jobs, so in that way I know we are more blessed than many newly married couples. Thus, I've been at odds with NFP

since the beginning. I had a sexual past including contraception before my husband and before I came back to the church, whereas my husband was a virgin on our wedding day. So I know I've come to our marriage with baggage, and thus I worry that NFP can be treated as contraception. I don't feel like we're saying yes to God and trusting in Him when we come together very strictly within the infertile times. I want to be open to life and to

God and His timing for us. I feel very lonely in this. I want to be a Good Wife and follow my husband's lead, but continually I feel this tugging on my heart to surrender to God. I'm also becoming withdrawn because it has become easy for us to abstain for two to three weeks at a time. Like my heart isn't in our union because the desire for children isn't there for both of us. My husband does want children,

but I know he's afraid. How do I talk to my husband about this? Am I wrong to think NFP isn't right for our current situation? Thank you. I want to clarify some of the the language here. She said she was at odds with NFP and can NFP be used as contraception? And I want to remain open to life. Yeah, I, I want to address each of those and then I'll get to her underlying some of her

underlying questions. I would say you're not at odds with NFP, but you, you are at odds with your use of NFP given your circumstances. I just think we we need to be really careful about the way we use our language here. NFP is not the problem. It's your use of NFP that may or may not be the problem. Similarly, it's not that we can use NFP as contraception, because contraception is the choice to engage in an act of intercourse and then render it

sterile. Couples who use natural family planning never engage in intercourse and render it sterile. Never. And that is precisely the difference. So again, just a precision in language here. It's not that NFP can be used as contraception, but rather one might not have just reason to be abstaining from intercourse during the fertile time and then could be using natural family planning with a wrong motivation. That does not make a contraception.

It remains natural family planning, but it might be being used without just reason. And I think that gets us to the underlying question, do you have a just reason to be avoiding a pregnancy? Although I don't know all the circumstances. And to give a more thorough answer and a more a more educated answer, I would need to be more educated about your actual situation.

But from what you've shared with me, that's all I'm working on because that's all I got. And you filled in the some of the blanks that your finances are there. You both have good jobs. The motivation here is basically you should have a year to yourself and go on a nice vacation. I do not think that is a just reason to be avoiding children. You're asking me what I think and that's what I think. I don't think it is.

So I think you have a proper pang in conscience that you are using natural family planning to avoid a pregnancy when you don't have a just reason to do so. So the question then another question you asked is how do I talk to my husband about this? My guess is there's something going on in your husband with his dad. You had said that his dad was

the one your your husband's father was the one who made kind of a strong recommendation that you have time to yourself the first year because after the kids come, you're never going to have any fun together. Those are some pretty strong words and can be kind of scary. And when you have respect for your dad and trust in your dad's advice, you know, you can take that to heart and absorb that. And it becomes kind of lodged in the heart as as this is fact. My dad said it. I trust my dad. Oh my gosh, kids are going to be

such a burden. We're never going to fun together. We better at least give ourselves a year of breathing room before kids come along. I think something pretty strong went into your husband's heart in that comment from your father. And there might need to be a a kind of spiritual disentanglement from certain lies that got into your husband's heart there from that strong and and rather exaggerated statement from your father-in-law. That's my read on it. How do you talk to your husband

about this? Why don't I don't know your husband and I don't know you and I don't know what your communication styles are. So, so take all that into account, but just be honest with him. Be honest with him about, hey, he's your husband. He should be able to have a conversation about hey, honey, you know, I here's what's going on in our in my heart. I'm having this pang of conscience because I don't think we really have a just reason to be avoiding a child. And my conscience is is telling me as such.

And I would be remiss and I would be unloving towards you and unloving towards myself and unloving towards the Lord if I didn't put in the light with you what I'm feeling. Can, can we talk this through? Do you think we have a just reason to be avoiding a child? What do you think it is? And and then just let the conversation unfold, talk it through and you may find yourself confronted with with a lie that's kind of been implanted in his heart from his

father. Again, I'm, I'm, I'm making this assessment based on very limited information here, but that's all I have to work on. And I have a hunch. I have a hunch that there might be a need for a disentangling of your husband's heart from this comment from his dad. Wendy, what are your thoughts here? I think any conversation will go better if it if it comes with a certain curiosity and openness, just as you want your husband to

be interested in in knowing how you're feeling about all those things, he wants you to be interested in knowing him. And, and both of you, you know, you're new to your marriage and lots of things have been new in your lives and there's a lot that's going on that you're finding ways to work together. So all of that is your kind of the setting of this need to talk. And I just want to encourage you

to come to the to conversations with an openness to get to know your husband better, to maybe look together at what each of your experience has been of your marriage up to this point. Those conversations are sometimes surprising and sometimes a little painful, but like they're all so fruitful. And I think it can help the outcome of the conversation if your husband feels that you want to know him better and love him

better and are are open to hearing something you hadn't heard before. You know, it's understandable to kind of piece together the story from what you know. But we're in this for the long haul to know each other more and more all the time. So to recognize that even this conflict and difference is an opportunity to grow in your communication and your ability to listen and your ability to share your heart to, you know, just be true to yourself and and

allow him to be challenged by you, but also you to be challenged by him. That's where like the grace of your sacrament just flows in. And I do think it's, it's more likely to bring a greater unity in your discernment about NFP than it would to kind of come to the conversation thinking, I'm pretty sure we shouldn't be using NFP. And I need to tell you why. That kind of can throw off the

the flow of grace, I guess. So Wendy, that your, your advice here is important. And as you're sharing what you're sharing, I'm imagining a, a scenario in which maybe in being open to what her husband shares and where he's really coming from, maybe, maybe they would discover that they have a just reason to be avoiding a child. Maybe there's a psychological wound in your your husband, some

deep fear that's preventing his readiness and and addressing that fear could be, you know, giving a little space to address that fear could be a legitimate reason to be postponing a pregnancy. Yeah, I think your call to openness there is is important. Thank you, Wendy, for sharing that. It, it allows a husband and a wife to recognize the gift that each is to each other. And that I, if I just jump in with my own preconceived ideas

as if I'm right and his, he's got the problem. That's going to be a very different conversation than one in which you go with an openness to hear the other's heart. And that would prepare the way also for him to hear her heart and live that reality of of being a gift, which is what it's all about from the start. Yeah. Lord, thank you. Thank you for this call to be a gift. If you've been blessed by what you've heard in today's episode, would you please hit that share

button to help us expand our audience and keep the questions coming? Patrons, don't forget that you have a special place to submit your questions. If you're a patron of our work, you can go to the Patreon website and submit your question. There you get a higher chance that we will answer your question. We're very grateful to all of you who send in questions. Know that you are a gift to us. We hope to be a gift to you. And we praise God that there is grace in all of this for. Us to become what we are.

A gift that's pretty special. You're a gift to me, Wendy. You. Like to meet? Thanks. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode