Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

My ‘early’ miscarriage feels unreal, Desire makes me spiral into fantasy, and Why didn’t they recognize risen Jesus? | ACW367

Jan 12, 202654 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

-This episode is sponsored by Truthly- Questions answered this episode: I’m experiencing my third very early miscarriage, and I’m having a lot of difficult feelings because the loss is so early. I never saw a doctor to confirm pregnancy - just a few days of faint positive tests that never got darker and eventually turned negative - and I’m dreading the coming bloodshed. I’m struggling with feeling like I shouldn’t grieve; I know life begins at conception, but I’m confused, and it feels unfair to people with “real” miscarriages. My husband doesn’t really understand, and I feel alone with two toddlers. Any insight appreciated. I understand God gave us sexuality as a gift, making us sexual beings. If he knew we’d be tempted to misuse it, why didn’t he make it so we’d be attracted to beauty but not feel sexual desire until after vows in the sacrament of marriage? Since that’s not how he designed it - and many look forward to that day - how do we look forward without unchaste thoughts or fantasies? My love language is touch, and I ache to be held, but my yearning slips into fantasies and then self-abuse. Any encouragement or advice would be welcome. Why did the apostles not recognize Jesus after the resurrection? Resources: Sexual Integration Course Colorado Ski Retreat with Christopher Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This episode of the Ask Christopher W podcast hosted by Wendy W is sponsored by Truthly. Have you guys heard of this new AI app called Truthly? Yes. I want to put a plug in for this AI app, not only because they're sponsoring this episode. I wouldn't have them sponsor this episode if I didn't believe in what they were doing. You know, we've had other people approach us to do sponsorships and I'm like, I don't want to promote that to our audience 'cause I don't really believe in it myself.

But the AI era is upon us and there are concerns about it. In fact, we are in the midst here at the Institute of developing a program, including a little book I'm working on to address the whole AI question. And there are concerns. There are concerns about it, but there are also great benefits in this technology. And we can and should take advantage of them to promote the Catholic faith. And that's what truthly, truthly, which is TRUTHLY,

that's what these guys are doing. And you can go on to truthly and ask any question about the Catholic faith. And since we are AQ and a podcast, I thought our listeners are obviously people who have questions about the Catholic faith and they want to grow and learn, and I thought this could be of great value to them. It's devoted to authentic Catholic teaching. Everything you're going to be receiving when you ask truthfully a question is rooted in scripture, in tradition, in

the Saints, in the great theologians. Everything is faithful to the Church. I've asked truthfully some questions of my own. This was interesting. I asked truthfully what is Truthly and this is what I got. Truthly is artificial intelligence through a Catholic lens. Truthly is built to stay faithful to the Magisterium while helping you navigate the world. My purpose is to provide clear, accurate answers grounded the Scripture tradition in the Magisterium while fostering A deeper understanding and appreciation of the Catholic

faith. I also asked truthfully, who is Christopher West? Oh, really? Yeah, look what they said here. Christopher W is a renowned Catholic author and speaker, widely recognized for his work on the theology of the Body, a series of teachings by Pope John Paul the Second on human sexuality, love, and the divine purpose of the human body. Yeah. So if any of our listeners are interested, you can get truthfully at the Apple App Store or Google Play. And yeah, give it a shot. I think it's worth it. 7 day free trial. From the theology of the Body

Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Everybody, thanks for joining us for another episode. Most of you are joining us on a Monday, Monday, Monday. Sorry, because my musical brain again, not everybody's joining us on a Monday.

Maybe you're joining us on a Wednesday or a Tuesday or. One of those other days that one of those other. Days of the week that could be. It's either Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday or Sunday that people are joining us. That's my best guess. I gotcha. We are watching Wendy and I. You know, every once in a while we like to tell you something we're watching and just pass it along. We are watching a History Channel show that my cousin Holly recommended to us called The Food That Built America.

And it's really over the top melodramatic. Everything has to be tense and and hyper dramatic and all kinds of made-up, you know, conflicts and whatever else. And dramatic music too, to go along with it. But it's fun to learn things that we take entirely for granted about the way we eat food and the brands we, we, we shop for. And like, there's a whole episode on Kraft macaroni and cheese and Kraft cheese in

general. There's a whole episode on, well, what's the 1:00? We, we recently watched this cola wars one. And this took us back to our own childhood in the 80s. If you were alive in the 70s and 80s, you remember the Pepsi Challenge. Like this was on TV everywhere, like kids at school were taking the Pepsi Challenge. Did you ever do the Pepsi Challenge? Probably, yeah. I would, I got I, you know how marketing works. Somehow Coca, Coca Hola, Coca-Cola got stuck.

Coca-Cola got stuck in my brain early as a kid and I was, you know, the branding, the whatever the marketing grabbed hold of my psyche and I became, became loyal to Coca-Cola. And I I didn't like this whole Pepsi Challenge thing because I wanted Coke to win and then Coke. That was your. Team. That was my team and then 1985, Coke admits defeat. The drama. The drama like this was big news, people. If you weren't alive in the 80s,

you'd can't understand this was big news. People don't even know what you're talking about. Tell them what you. Mean yeah. So OK Coke in 1985 came out with New Coke. They changed the taste. Changed the taste. They changed the formula. Yeah. And if you were like loyal to the way Coke tasted like I was, this was awful. And they said initially, the old Coke is never coming back. Yeah, it wasn't just like, here's another option, you can have the New Coke.

It was like here, this is forever, that it was the death. Yeah, it was the death of of old Coke. And and of course the the whatever was left on the shelves of the old Coke disappeared right away. And I was like, devastated. What? I'm never going to be able to have my favorite soft drink ever again in my life? This New Coke is crap. Well, it just tasted like Pepsi. Tasted like Pepsi. Exactly. It tasted like crap. That's what I just said. Sorry Pepsi fans out there, but

this is this is This is why they were truly cola wars. Like I don't think shots were fired or anybody died, but Michael Jackson did burn his hair. I'm just saying. That's right, he was filming a Pepsi. He was. Filming a Pepsi commercial, they gave him 5,000,000 bucks in 1984 or 5 or whatever to be the spokesman for Pepsi and they the pyrotechnics malfunctioned. Malfunctioned. Is that a word? No, what am I trying to say? Malfunctioned. Malfunctioned. Thank you. My brain just malfunctioned

Anyway, Michael Jackson got paid $5,000,000 to be the spokesperson for Pepsi and sales of Pepsi went out off the charts, charts out of the roof. What I can my brain is malfurturing. And yeah, then Coke admits defeat. We need to change our formula to compete with Pepsi. And Pepsi, of course, capitalizes on this like we've we've they declared victory that they won the cola wars and there was such an outcry.

Oh yeah. Around the world for the old Coke that six weeks later, the Coca-Cola Company admitted they did the wrong thing and they brought what they called now Coca-Cola Classic. Yeah, if you ever wondered why does it say classic on there but. It doesn't anymore. I don't. Oh no. No, I mean, it did for a time. Like probably a decade or two decades or something. I don't know, but I don't think it's you don't buy a Coke and now that says Coca-Cola Classic. OK, sorry.

I don't even think you can get that. The new coke is like long gone. The new coke is the old coke. Oh, you can't buy new? Coke. No, they took it away. That's to gone. Anyway, why are we sharing this with you? I have no idea. We we took an interest in it last night when we watched this episode 'cause it just was so reminiscent of our teenage years. Yeah. So funny but I just remembered the the shock like some someone had died when they said no. That's what it felt like. No more coke.

Somebody died. Funny. Well, anyway, moving on. All you people who are as old as we are, or older you will, you will understand why we're kind of going off on this because it was a big deal. Yes, imagine. And if you were born later than that, you have no idea what we're talking about. Take our word for it. It was. Strange. It was a strange big deal moving right along. Moving right along indeed. Give us some updates from the. Yes, here's an update. We are getting down to the wire for our sexual integration and redemption course, which is an in person course and course is

kind of a misnomer. This is really a healing retreat. It's there are presentations and and you know, talks that you hear, but the, the majority of the time is spent in a small group with a trained leader to take the content from the head to the heart and explore regions of your inner life that are in need of healing. If you have encountered the theology of the body and you've

caught that vision and you're like, OK, but how do I live it? I'm running into such pain in my life, painful memories, traumas, difficulties, struggles, broken relationships, sexual addiction, disordered attractions. How do I live the stuff? We offer this healing retreat at the Theology of the Body Institute because we know our students need it. It is something you have to apply for. If you are interested, if there's somebody out there hearing me say this and you're like, I really need to go to

that, please click the link in the show notes and and fill out your application for this retreat. And God willing, there'll be a spot for you and maybe you're meant to be there. I also want to say that we have some spots left for our ski retreat, which is not the same kind of retreat. We're going to ski all day and reflect all night. Not all night. We're also going to sleep, but in the evening we're going to reflect together on John Paul the Second's vision on the human

person. There are only 30 spots for this. We're renting a big mountain estate in the mountains of Colorado, Rocky Mountains. We're going to ski at a Basin and ski at Copper. This is March 9th to the 13th. Spots are limited. Only 30 spots are available, so check out the link for that. Are you ready for a question now from a patron? This is from a patron named Helen. Hi, Helen. I am experiencing my third very

early miscarriage right now. I'm having a lot of difficult feelings about this because of the early loss. I never even saw a doctor to confirm that I was pregnant. All I have are a few days of faint positive lines on tests that never grew darker and eventually turned negative. I'm dreading the coming bloodshed. I'm struggling with feeling like I shouldn't be grieving.

I know life begins at conception but I'm confused about how to deal with this. It feels unfair to people who have real miscarriages. My husband doesn't understand what I'm going through. I feel like he expects me to be used to it by now. Oh oh he hasn't said that and he is very busy with work and school but I just feel alone. We have two young toddlers that are taking all of my attention.

I want to give this little soul my time as well but I don't know what that would look like. Any insight you have would be greatly appreciated. Bless you, dear Helen. Bless you. First. I I just want to say this is a real miscarriage. There's no less real than any other miscarriage. This is a real life. You conceived this life through the union with your husband. God ordained this life from all eternity to come into existence. And for whatever reason, it's a

mystery. We cannot comprehend it. We cannot fathom it. The Lord has allowed this precious life to die, to die in your womb, and that is a real sorrow. It's a real sorrow. I I want to share a little of my own experience as a husband in, in feeling outside the loop, Wendy with with with your

intimate experience of pregnancy. It's simply something as a man that I can't experience at that level. It is happening in you, right? The the male of the species is the kind of being that generates new life outside of himself. The female of every species is the kind of being that generates new life within herself. This is the key distinction between male and female.

So on the one hand, Helen, I, I, I want to invite you to have a certain compassion for your husband that he doesn't experience this at the same level that you do. Compassion and, and understanding and, and a wide margin there, if you will, just to allow him to, to be a man. He, he, he doesn't know what you're going through. On the other hand, I want to invite the husband to try the

best that he can to also have compassion on his wife and understanding for what she's going through at such a deep, profound and intimate level. And, and Helen, they could help your husband. I would imagine your husband's a good hearted man. You say he's busy with work. Men are easily distracted. They, they tend to place a lot of their sense of purpose and meaning in family life, in providing for the family, in getting their work done and

doing their work and devoting themselves in that way. I know what that whole world is like. And, and even in a particular way, when, when a woman is dealing with her particular issues around a pregnancy and the man is having a hard time entering in, he might even be tempted all the more to retreat into his world of work and get her done and responsibility. But could you, Helen, could you imagine having a conversation with your husband in which

distractions are set aside? You've you've blocked away a good amount of time. There's no danger of distraction. Maybe you're on a walk together. Maybe you're, you're, I don't know. Maybe you go away for an overnight together, no distractions, no work. And you open your heart to him about how deep this goes, that your womb is, is an image of your heart and and the death of this child, regardless of how

long the child lived, this is a real child. And you knew you had a child in your womb. And you, if you feel the loss, could you imagine sharing that with your husband in a new way, to invite his compassion, to invite his understanding, to invite a deepening of your bond together? I think if you begin by showing compassion for how difficult that can be for a man who's outside the experience, begin with compassion.

It will invite compassion. Begin with a willingness to enter into his world and show understanding in his world. We'll invite him to enter your world and show understanding in your world. I know when Wendy and I have have taken that risk and opened our worlds to the other, not that we do it perfectly, but it but it does invite we can speak to this from our own experience. It invites compassion and understanding and really can deepened can really can deepen

your marriage bond. Yeah, I feel those same things that it is understandable from a lot of different angles that it's been difficult to know how to give attention to this suffering. And one is, as you said, about just the the understandable focus on work to be done that the husband feels and and the work that the wife has to do

well, that they both have to do with these young children that are, you know, that asking a lot of them. And that is very demanding to be parents of two very small children. So it's those are understandable things. And I think, too, the very fact that Helen is feeling conflicted inside, it makes it harder, I think, for her to communicate to her husband what she's feeling because she's kind of feeling multiple things that are in

conflict and causing her some confusion. And so when we don't have a clear feeling, it's that much harder to let someone else in. And as you pointed out, the need for a less distracted and longer time to talk together is part of that because you don't want to not express all the different things that are that are going on at the same time. And, and to be patient with your husband, as Christopher said,

how foreign some of these experiences might be to him. But also in that conversation to listen to him and to just talk about maybe how he feels about what's been happening with these different 3 pregnancies that you were aware of that in each one there was a very early miscarriage. You know, is he concerned about these or, or what is it stirring

in him? And that might not be an easy conversation for him either because he might have multiple feelings. So you have the the beauty of that intimacy of marriage can be that your life is shared and and you see one another and know one another in such a deep way that that even having these harder conversations, even if they take longer or have to be spread over multiple times of talking with one another. You are on this journey of life

together. And as much as we would wish that the other would just automatically understand us, we do have to put things into words and we do have to be present to one another and listening with our whole hearts in order to have. A deeper understanding of the mystery of the other. So I, I feel all of those things that are really important for you, Helen, and that you would not feel alone. Like that's a theme in what you were saying. I feel alone.

So to not feel that way because you know your husband is with you, because you know also that the Lord is with you are really important things. But there may be other sort of outward signs that you 2 as a as spouses or you just as a mom want to put into place in your life in order to more fully honor this experience. Something that there are things that different people have done. For example, perhaps they give

the child a name and pray for the child according to that name that you've given. They might pray about or just give me a sense, was this a girl or a boy or Lord, do you have a name for this child that that I can hear in my heart and embrace as the name of this child? That could be very helpful to in order to both pray for the child and ask for the children who've

entered into their life with the Lord in heaven to be praying for your family. There are people who might, you know, make other gestures, whether they're just outward signs of this love that you have for these children. Like there's so many things like a a candle that is lit for the child or a time set aside in church just to pray and give

this life to the Lord, to thank the Lord for the brief time that this child was with you and give the child back to say, yes, Lord, I know you will love this child and we will be together again in eternity. Those kinds of heartfelt moments are can be so beautiful and part of the journey of family life. I think about what Pope John Paul the second said in familiar

as consortio about the particular presence of the Holy Spirit at these significant moments in family life. And there are many significant moments, but certainly the discovery of a pregnancy, the loss of a pregnancy are absolutely significant. And that closeness of the Holy Spirit can be experienced by the family and especially by the spouses when they recollect themselves together.

You know, and and kind of quiet other voices to be really present to the Holy Spirit and allow spontaneous prayers to come forth from their hearts together. That just recognizes how close the Lord is to us in those circumstances. I also just want to encourage you to consider looking into whether you need some hormonal support in your cycles to prevent the loss of a pregnancy.

I, I don't know whether that's the case, but there are, you know, doctors, midwives who can look at a person who's had repeat early loss of a pregnancy and look at whether there can be additional progesterone given during that part of the cycle during which the the baby would be implanting. Could that be helpful to prevent a further loss? That could be something to look into as well.

And Helen, I want to affirm that the fact that you feel this loss so deeply is a sign, a very good sign that your, your heart is aligned with the significance of, of new life, of the marital embrace of the conception of a child. The, the, the loss of a child through miscarriage is never something you should get used to. And the fact that you are not used to it is a very good sign

that your heart is in touch with reality, with the truth of things. And I know you said it's not that your husband ever said it directly, that he wishes you would just get over it or get used to it. But if you, if you have reason to believe that that is the attitude of your husband, it's, it's a sign that some aspect of his heart has has shut down. It's maybe it finds the prospect of suffering this yet again, just too, too agonizing. And you could offer some of your own agony, some of your own

suffering is intercession for your husband there that his heart might be softened. The fact that we often harden our hearts when we're suffering is understandable, but it's it's hardening our hearts. This is what Jesus laments when he says, we we played the flute for you and you didn't dance. We sang the dirge and you didn't mourn, right? This is a dirge and mourning is the proper response. So you, you, your, your heart is in tune and in touch there,

Helen and I, I bless you there. Our next question is from a listener named Vincent. Hi, Vincent. This is something that's been weighing on my heart for some time now, and I've decided it's time to ask. I understand that God gave us sexuality as a gift and as a result formed us as sexual beings. If He knew we'd be tempted to misuse this precious gift, why didn't He make it so that we'd be attracted to beauty but not

experience sexual desire until after a man and woman have made their vows to each other in His presence during the sacrament of marriage? Considering that was not how He designed it to work? And many look forward to the day they can experience that moment with their beloved or not yet found beloved. How are we to do so? That is, look forward to it without slipping into unchaste thoughts or fantasies. My love language is touch and my

heart aches to be held by someone through whom God can manifest His physical affection for me and through me for the other in a manner that only a spouse can. I feel so guilty when my yearning slips into unchaste thoughts and fantasies which then leads to self abuse. I feel as if the only way to prevent myself from slipping into unchaste thoughts would be to be put into some medically induced coma or other related state of mind.

Not that I would ever consider that of course. Any words of encouragement or advice would be very much welcome. So, Wendy, can you reread just the first bit where he's asking the question? Because I want to he he said in a particular way. And I want to address it in a particular way. OK. OK, sorry, let me read. Why didn't he make it so that we'd be attracted to beauty but not experience sexual desire until after a man and woman have made their vows to each other in His presence in the sacrament of

marriage? 1st, I want to say, Vincent, we don't know exactly how God created our sexual desires because the way we experience them is not the way God created them. How do we know that? Because in the beginning they were naked and felt no shame. The entrance of shame has radically altered the way we experience our sexual desires from the way God intended them. So I just express a little bit of caution in in assuming we

know how God created our sexual desires. We don't know. What we do know is man and woman in the beginning, before sin entered the picture, were not struggling with a battle with lust, right. Lust is the distortion of our sexual desires, the inversion of our sexual desires, the the turning of our sexual desires into something selfish and and very difficult to control.

In the beginning there was a perfect equilibrium in the way erotic desire was experienced. We can certainly say that we have lost that equilibrium this side of original sin. We can certainly say that. But I, I, I also want to say something that John Paul the second talks about in Love and Responsibility, that sexual attraction, sexual arousal, sexual desire is part of the raw material of love.

And yes, when it's not integrated with the dignity of the person, we'll say more about that in a moment because that's the real challenge. That's really at the crux of what you're, you're getting at here. Sexual attraction, sexual desire, sexual arousal must be integrated with the dignity of the person, your person, and the dignity of every other person. We'll say more about that in a moment, but the point I want to under score here is if we only experience sexual desire and sexual attraction and sexual

arousal like some magic trick, you get married and kaboom, there it is. That that. How would you? How would you? How would you fall in love? I know you said we could be attracted to beauty, but but, but what does that even mean? I mean, it's the attraction to beauty that arouses erotic desire because Eros, the Greek word Eros that the church borrows in her language and teaching.

Eros is the desire, the upward impulse. This is JP two. I'm quoting JP 2. Eros is the upward impulse of the human spirit towards what is true, good and beautiful, right? So that what is erotic also becomes true, good and beautiful. Brother, this is the pilgrimage you are invited on. You are what you are experiencing now in your sexual arousal, attraction and desire is, it sounds like for the most

part leading you not towards the truth of love. But as JP 2 says, when that raw material of love, sexual attraction, emotion, desire, when that raw material of love is not integrated with the true dignity of the person, it leads not to love but to its direct opposite. You are in a habit and a pattern in your life where erotic desire gets aroused. It goes the wrong direction. You end with masturbation and self indulgence.

And then you resent the fact that it's so difficult not to go that direction. You struggle with the attraction, you struggle with the desire. And you you fantasize of an abstract existence where where I just don't have to experience this until the wedding night. And then I can flick the switch and then I can, I can feel it and, and not sin. Well, Oh my gosh, there's so many problems with that vision of the world that I don't have time to get into all of them. But but but brother, what I want to recognize in you is you do desire the true, the good and

the beautiful, but the real struggle I think you're you're dealing with here. The real sin here is not sexual sin. The real sin here I'm imagining if the shoe does not fit, don't wear it. But I, I, I, I, I think I'm from what you're saying, I think I'm on to it. The real sin here is sloth, and sloth is the sadness we feel that choosing the good is

difficult. Sloth is the resentment we feel. I'll use an analogy that learning to play the piano is going to take a lot of sacrifice, struggle, and discipline that's I don't know how to screw it. I'm not going to play the piano. Can't. Can't I just get some magical gift that God zaps me and I can play the piano on my wedding night, so to speak? No, we have, we have to enter the struggle not on our own, always, always with God's grace. And God's grace is sufficient

for us. But we must open to that grace. We must let that grace in, and we must go on what Pope Benedict the 16th calls the Pilgrimage of the redemption of desire, the Pilgrimage of the redemption of Eros. And this pilgrimage, he says, is not about suffocating the longings that dwell in our hearts. It's about freeing those longings so they can reach their

true heights. And what are the true heights? Eros was created by God to be the very power to love divinely. In the beginning, Eros expressed agape, divine love. What happened with original sin is that Eros ran out of agape. Or to put a a biblical image to it, Eros ran out of wine. And what does that mean? Wine is a symbol of divine love,

sacrificial love, the joy of loving divinely. Wine is a symbol of divine love poured out. In the beginning, man and woman were naked without shame because they were drunk on God's wine. And so erotic desire expressed the desire to love divinely, sacrificially, through the gift of self. This is my body given for you. That is an agape expressed through Eros and an Eros that expresses agape. We've all ran out of wine here,

but here's the good news, Brother Vincent, There is good news here. Where did Jesus perform his first miracle and what did he do? He came to a wedding where they ran out of wine and he restored the wine in super abundance. Your goal in in life, Vincent, My goal in life, everyone's goal in life, is to get drunk on God's wine. Redemption begins with Eros, says Cardinal Cantela Mesa. Because it is the dominant

force. It is what is most in need of redemption here. Those rocket engines in our hearts have become inverted, and the solution is not to snuff out the rocket, but to redirect the rocket engines towards the stars so that erotic desire can again become the raw material of love. Chastity. I'm going to quote JP 2 or this is as close to a quote I can do from my memory, but it's this is his teaching. Chastity is not about repressing

erotic desire and emotion into the subconscious where it awaits an opportunity to explode. Rather, chastity is a matter of long term integration where we raise our erotic desires, attractions and emotions. We learn how to do it through God's grace to the level of the dignity of the person. My brother Vincent, the theology of the Body Institute exists to accompany people on that pilgrimage.

Have you ever been to a course? Are you, are you reading our books? Are you taking advantage? I mean, you're taking advantage of this podcast, thanks be to God. But have you taken the next step? Could I suggest you become a patron and start taking the retreats that are available to our patrons? Could I suggest that you take an online course or come in person to one of our courses? Can you come to the Sexual Integration and Redemption course in at the end of February? Because this is where that course is going to take you.

It's going to take you into those places in your heart that need to be exposed to the Lord and healed so that your Eros can reach its true height and can truly become the raw material that leads not to self abuse, but to honoring and upholding your dignity and the dignity of every other person. We don't want erotic desires to be something that we never experienced until the wedding night because we want to learn

how to love before we get married. And before we get married, we must learn how to channel our erotic desires towards upholding the dignity of the person in every situation. If we do not go on that pilgrimage before we get married, learning how to channel all of our sexual desires in the right direction, then what's the wedding night going to be? We just hold it all in until the wedding night. What's the wedding night going to be? It's going to be some legalization of your disordered desires.

There's no magic trick that happens on the wedding night that suddenly makes your erotic choices true, good and beautiful. We have to be trained in advance in how to make true, good and beautiful choices all along the way so that on our wedding night we can then apply all that we've learned to the concrete act of self giving in the marital embrace. I could say so much more. I don't have time to say much more, but come to a course, brother. Take advantage of what we're doing. Sign up for our certification

program. Go the distance in your pilgrimage. There are resources available to help you. God's grace is available to help you. Help us to help you to go on this pilgrimage and experience victory. Yeah. And I know I, I don't want to say a lot more because that's so helpful. And, and it's from, I think some of the experience, well, is also experienced by women, I think. And there's a particular sensitivity in this area for men that I just hear your heart,

having been on this lifelong journey as a man is so important for Vincent to hear. Women are also on this journey. We are also tempted to use others to just follow these like fallen desires into fantasies and selfish imaginings and behaviors. So I don't want to make it just about a man, but I yeah, I just felt like you speaking as a man

to a man was also very appropriate here. So anyway, just when you spoke about that sexual healing and redemption course, just something just kind of lit up in my heart a little bit. Not that I know for sure that Vincent should be there, but I, I'm sure it would be helpful. But I think the thing that was lighting up in my heart was that sense of there's, there's been sort of a, a lack of the growth of understanding his own unique heart in, in what's coming

through in his question. Anyway, he's it's sort of, kind of kept on this. Well, God made me this way and it just seems impossible. Even if I believe it's meant for the good purpose, it just feels impossible. Unless I'm in a coma, it's impossible kind of giving up feeling and and that unless I'm in a coma is kind of a little phrase that just kind of shines a light on this, this not knowing much about the deeper movements of the heart.

It kind of feels like this is just impossible because because it's kind of not not looking at your own story and your own just need to relate your whole life and your whole story to Jesus to connect with him on every stage of your journey and experience his genuine love and understanding of all that you

have experienced throughout your whole entire. Life. Preach it, Wendy. How healing in the memories that we don't like to think about, to experience. Jesus is a love for us there. His understanding what was going on in us, in others, in all those significant memories of our lives like that journey is so helpful. It's so maturing. It's so bringing of wisdom and integration and an ability to be

a gift to others right now in this stage of life, which is part of what our sexual desire is telling us to be, to be a gift to others right now. Even when you don't have that beloved that you're Speaking of, like how, but how, but how? And that that journey of knowing the Lord knows and loves you in every stage of your life and can heal wounds in our hearts that have affected the way we are personally experiencing some of

these desires, though, that is such an important aspect of this growth in integration that you were talking about, Christopher. Amen. And I'm going to hold out a challenge to you, Vincent. Here's an invitation. Get yourself in a quiet place, maybe in a Chapel in front of the Blessed Sacrament, and write a letter to Jesus, sharing with Jesus directly to Jesus, placing right in his heart your first

memory of being exposed to pornography, your first memory of having a sexual experience of masturbation, your earliest memories of these things. Write these experiences out. Give them to Jesus in a letter. Jesus, this is what was happening in me, This is what happened to me. This is what I experienced. Jesus, I invite you here. I want you in this memory. Show me where you were. Show me what I was really looking for. Show me where my desires got off track. Set my desires a right at their very root and He will come into

that memory. Wait for Him. Open your ears, open your heart, open your mind. Maybe other memories will come into your heart. Maybe a song will come into your heart. Maybe a scene from a movie or ATV show will come into your heart. Maybe an image from nature will come into your heart. Maybe you'll see in your mind's eye a woman's body purely for the first time. Saint Paul says whatever is true, whatever is right, whatever is good, whatever is pure, think on these things.

There is a right and a good and a holy and a pure way to think on God's plan for human sexuality. St. Paul was thinking in a holy and pure way of God's plan for sexuality when he said for this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two will become one flesh. This is a great mystery, and it refers to Christ in the Church. We're all caught in a very intense battle here. Vincent, you're in that battle. Do not despair.

That's what the enemy wants. He wants you to despair. Open, as Wendy is saying. It is so freeing, it is so liberating to bring Jesus into our story, especially those most painful and shameful parts of our story, that we think we just have to hide from Jesus because how could he possibly love us here? This is what he came to do. He came to save us from our sin. He came to save us not from our bodies and sexuality. He came to save our bodies and sexuality. He holds out to us not

redemption from the body and sexuality. He holds out to us redemption of the body and sexuality, but that means all of those diseased memories, all of those diseased images in our minds and our hearts have to be exposed to the painful, piercing, purifying light of Christ. That is the work you must undertake, my brother. That is the pilgrimage you are invited on, and you are not alone. The enemy wants you to think you're alone so that you despair and give up the fight.

No, you are in this fight with Christ, and Christ is fighting this fight with you and for you. You just have to consent and follow where He's leading. And maybe He's leading you to the sexual integration and redemption course. And if He is, say yes and come and you will experience wonders. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. And before I read it, I just want to say it's actually just one short sentence. So just to so you'll know OK,

it's. Just that, here we go. The question is why did the apostles not recognize Jesus after the resurrection? I love this question. Why did the apostles not recognize Jesus after the resurrection? It shows us that something is dramatically different about the resurrected life from the life that we are familiar with. The fact that those who ate with

him and lived with him for three years did not recognize him initially is, is a sign that there's something simply other about a resurrected body. And let me let me draw a distinction here. When Lazarus was raised from the dead, everybody recognized, oh, that's Lazarus. He's raised from the dead because Lazarus resurrection was resurrection unto normal human life.

Lazarus would die again. But when Christ was raised from the dead, He was raised. His body, His humanity, was raised to a dimension of existence beyond death, and we simply don't know what that looks like. We need to be called into it. Notice that Mary Magdalene

thought this was the gardener, but she got called into the vision when Jesus spoke her name. Mary, when she heard her name called by the risen Lord, her eyes were opened. The disciples on the road to Emmaus, they walked with him for however many miles and didn't know they were with the man they knew until what? Until their eyes were opened at the breaking of the bread, the Eucharist, right? And this is a call to a vision of faith. Mortal eyes can't see this.

We don't recognize it, we don't know what it is. But the eyes of faith can see it can recognize who and what this is. So let's pray for those eyes to see. Wow, that is a beautiful step by step that you just took us on Christopher from the the calling of Mary's name when she was with Jesus and didn't recognize him.

To recognition that we need faith that that the there are eyes beyond our mortal eyes that can see realities that we can't just see in our normal seeing kind of way. The eyes and the sockets in our heads. We we need eyes of faith. Even when there isn't, Christ is right in front of us. It's an interesting question then, just for us to ask ourselves, maybe in prayer, just to say, Lord, how am I not recognizing you in my life right

now? How? How is the resurrected Lord present but I can't see him? Wendy, that is a a perfect application of of everything we're discussing here to do that in our lives. And I'm I'm struck by you saying that I need to do that every day. I'm blind to the resurrected Christ right in front of me. Yeah. I mean, that's just what happened in my heart as you were describing that process, because it was just kind of calling out to me that that we are limited. We see the world, we see

everything around us and the people around us in limited ways. And the eyes of faith, just as those who had spent so much time with Jesus couldn't see him at at times because they needed faith, they needed different eyes. They needed his help to recognize him. Lord, help us to recognize you. Help us to recognize you and your presence, Your activity in

our own hearts and your presence in others around us that we are called to reverence and we're called to love and we're called to serve. As you spoke of when you were with your apostles, you spoke of that like visiting those who are sick or in prison and all of those examples given and they said, well, when did we ever see that? When did we see you like that? Like Lord, give us the eyes to see your resurrection, your story, to see beyond just to the

natural things that we see, to see the truth and the the spiritual realities that are more real than what we normally see. So I'm going to quickly link our answer to this question back to our answer to Vincent's question. OK? Remember, Vincent, we were talking about how after sin, their eyes were open and they knew they were naked because of lust, right? Lust changed the way they saw.

And the truth of the matter is, it's not that their eyes were opened, but their eyes were closed. And Pope Benedict the 16th, reflecting on that story of the road to Emmaus, says when their eyes were opened at the breaking of the bread, they experienced in reverse fashion what Adam and Eve experienced at the fall. It was the redemption of their vision, right, brother Vincent, That's what you're after. You're after that redeemed vision. And it is a gift that we must ask for.

And is it a gift we must, with God's grace, fight for. So keep fighting the good fight, Vincent. And if you have submitted a question to us here at our podcast that we have not had the opportunity to get to, here is a suggestion. Take your question to truthfully, it's a Catholic AI platform out there, sponsors this broadcast, and they're doing great work loading up their AI platform with all the documents of the Magisterium,

with the writings of the Saints, with the teaching of the Fathers, so that when you type in your question to Truthfully, you get a solid Catholic answer. Check it out. I think it's worth really exploring. They're doing great work and we're happy to have them as a sponsor of our show because we're AQ and a show and they're AQ and a platform. So thanks everybody for submitting your questions. Thanks for tuning in to our show. If you were blessed by what we shared today, would you please hit that share button so that

this podcast could be a gift to someone else? You are a gift to us and we pray that we continue to be a gift to you and we ask for the grace to live the gift that we are and to. To become what we are. Yeah, Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute, with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed

counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode