When Jesus Doesn’t Have a Body, Balancing Family Worldviews, and Cremation | ACW297
51 minAudio
Questions answered this episode: How can we love Jesus on earth when he doesn’t have a body? How can prayer feel more like a full relationship and not just long distance communication I was homeschooled and raised in a close knit immediate family. We never spent much time with relatives or friends and my parents always sought to solely invest in each other and their children. On the other hand, my husband was raised in a large family where relatives and friendships were very important and he still likes to get together with them. He’s also always willing to get involved with our community and it is hard for me to relate to that. To me, his desire for connection outside our immediate family feels unnatural. How can we embrace these two apparently differing worldviews in our marriage? Is cremation ever acceptable in the Catholic Church? Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: John Paul II Legacy Foundation: dave@jp2legacy.org Catechism of the Catholic Church #796 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here 🌟 For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. It is one of those gorgeous August days here in Pennsylvania. I love this time of year. I forgot how much I love this time of year. It's we had a lot of rain recently. It was really humid. Prior to all that rain, we were having some rough sleeping
nights. But now these storms have passed. It's 80°. It's sunny, clear blue skies. I love the angle of the sun this time of year. I love the cool August breeze. I love eating Peaches. I love corn on the cob. I love big honking fresh tomatoes with fresh basil, salt and pepper and a little olive oil and maybe some feta cheese. And I like to cut big thick chunks of them and put them on a
piece of toast. You do, It's true. And oh man, thank you God for August. And you can feel that just the the like the earth is. I mean, the earth is always turning. It's true. But you kind of feel like it's in a certain, of course, it's always in a what am I trying to say, Wendy? They're they're hints of of the change of season that's. What I'm trying to say, and you can feel it in the air, and I like that. It's kind of special. Thank you, Lord, for these
beautiful, beautiful August days. I think too, they have a little of the wistfulness of that we have as children about summer ending and school starting that we kind of want to soak up the last bit of summer goodness. Yeah, Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Thanks. You just put a feeling of dread back in my soul. I hated that school starting. We don't, we don't know when you're listening to this.
Maybe school already started by the time you're listening to this. But it's mid August when we're recording this, so it is delightful. I'm so glad I'm not starting school. It. Did you just, like, stirred up all this stuff? Sorry. Do you remember? I don't know if anybody else used to think this, but I remember thinking that summertime was a whole year when I was a little kid. Why are you laughing at me? This is true. And you should see this look that Wendy's throwing me right
now. What is the look? Describe your look. Describe what you're feeling to our listeners. What? The whole thing, like I I was trying to join you in the joy of August and you said it made you feel sad. Sorry, you reminded me of that feeling I had when school was about to start and summer was and I I like the sucking the marrow out of the last days. That's what I was. Talking I'm I'm that that was. But right on the other side of
sucking the marrow out of the last days of August was the dread. The dread of. I didn't dread the start. Of oh, I did I. Dreaded it, so sorry. And I remember when I first learned that summer was not a whole year, it was only three months. I'm sorry. I think I was 19 when I learned that. No, only younger than that. No, I was probably six or seven when I learned summer was not a whole year. Oh well, moving right along. I do have an update from the
institute and I'm going to share it before you even ask me if I have. One, go right ahead. My update from the institute is just to to keep sharing a little bit about this new initiative. We announced it a couple podcasts ago as part of our 20th anniversary celebrations this year. The TOB Institute started in 2004. It is 2024. I did learn math in school. 24 -. 4 is 20, so we've been around
for 20 years. As part of our celebrations, we have launched a new initiative that the goal of which is to ensure the spread of John Paul the Second's legacy around the globe for decades, if not centuries to come. We believe that we are part of the generation, not that we are not. Please hear this correctly. Not that we at the TOB Institute are the sole movers or shakers
in this regard, but we believe we are part of a generation of Catholics and many, many of this generation have given their themselves to this cause, which is to ensure the legacy of Saint John Paul the Second for future generations. You know, here we are hundreds of years after Thomas Aquinas. How is it that Thomas Aquinas is still part of the the ethos and thinking and mind of the church? It's because people in Thomas's
day saw how important what he was doing was and absorbed it and passed it on to the next generation. And then that generation passed it on to the next generation, and that generation passed it on the next generation. We are at John Paul the 2nd St. John Paul the Second no doubt will be named a doctor. The Church will be known to history as Saint John Paul the Great. And at the core of his great legacy is his theology of the
body centuries from now. The same way that Thomas Aquinas and his Summa Theologica is part of the just bread and butter of Catholicism. All these hundreds of years later, hundreds of years from now, John Paul the Second's theology of the body will be just part of the way the Church sees the world. And we are the generation that has been entrusted with this, and we have to pass this on for future generations. That's going to take lots of
resources. That's going to take lots of funding. And we have started a new organization called the Saint John Paul, the Second Legacy Foundation. And that's the mission to ensure his legacy, to train future generations, to train, train up the current generation who is coming of age. Now I'm in my 50s. I only have maybe 25 or 30 more years to give my life to this, God willing and people of my age
who were kind of the first to be entrusted with getting this message out now see the need to pass it on, pass it on, pass it on. So that's what the John Paul the second Legacy Foundation exists to do. We are so new that we don't even have a website yet. We have brought on a director to to run this this new endeavor. His name is Dave Sloan and we have his e-mail listed in the show notes for this episode. So please, please e-mail him if you want to learn more and get involved.
We are looking for people who are people of means who can help fund a global endeavor to help people learn, live and pass on this theology of the body. So e-mail Dave Sloan if you want to learn more about this new endeavor. And we would love to partner with you to ensure that John Paul the Second's legacy is passed from generation to generation for centuries to come. Awesome. Yeah. And what a what a privilege to be part of the 1st generation to
to pass this torch man. Absolutely. Are you? Ready for a question. I am ready. Here we go. This is from Natalie. Hi, Natalie. Natalie says Hello Christopher and Wendy, thank you for your podcast. I've been a faithful listener for almost 2 years now and it has blessed me so much. My question is this. John Paul 2 says that the body, and only the body is capable of making visible what is invisible, the spiritual and the divine.
We can't just love somebody's soul but not their body, because the two are inseparable. So how can we love Jesus here on earth when He doesn't have a body here on earth? I know that we have the Eucharist, but it's not like I can hug the Eucharist or make the Eucharist a good meal or wash the Eucharist's feet. So how can I love Jesus in a practical way here on earth? It feels so limiting to only be able to express love to Jesus with words.
How can prayer feel more like a full relationship and not just long distance communication? Wow, Natalie, I can tell just from your gosh, articulation of this question that you really love the Lord and want to love him more. And I'm brought in my own memory directly to something my mentor said, the great, late and great Monsignor Lorenzo Albacete.
He was a a personal friend of Saint John Paul the 2nd and I had the privilege of studying under him and he became a friend of mine over many years. He died in 2014. But there's so many things he said that have just stayed with me, and this is one of them. He was asked a similar question, where do I find Jesus, flesh and blood here and now, like in this world? And if we can't, he would say,
then Jesus is just an abstraction. If there is not a flesh and blood manifestation of Jesus here and now on planet earth, then Jesus is just an idea. He's an abstraction. And we know because the Word was made flesh that Christianity is the the antithesis of theological abstraction. Christian theology is theology based on the concrete reality of the incarnation God in the
flesh. Christian theology, therefore, is always theology of the body, right? This is where Christian theology begins, with the Incarnation. So how did Monsignor Albusodi answer that question? Where do we find flesh and blood Jesus here and now? This, this was his answer. In the creep sitting next to you, that was. That was his answer. In that person that annoys you to no end.
That was his answer. Because we are the body of Christ. That's not just some wispy metaphor. No, Jesus said to Saint Paul before he was Saint Paul, he was Saul, and he was persecuting Christians. What? What did Jesus say? Why are you persecuting Christians? No, no. What did he say? Why are you persecuting me? Why are you persecuting me? What else does Jesus say?
Whatever you do or do not do to the least of these you do or do not do. To me. To, to me, he said. He identifies with us so intimately as to call us his body. There are there are distinctions to be made here and here's how the Catechism puts it. I don't have the direct reference, but I'm going to give a shout out to our producer right now. Juan, can you do a a search of
the Catechism for this reference and put the direct link in the show notes? But the Catechism says it's using this image that Scripture uses of the head and the body, right? The church is the body of Christ, and the person of Christ is the head of the body, right? So that's the image Paul uses. But the Catechism in unpacking that image from Scripture says when Jesus refers to the head,
he calls himself Christ, but when he refers to his body, he refers to himself as the bride. Did you hear that? When he refers to the head, he refers to himself. He refers to himself as the head. When he refers to the Church, he refers to himself as the bride, as the body. We are that bride.
We are that body. When you touch, when you serve the bodies of other human beings, what you do to the least of these or do not do, you do to Christ. He's here. He's in the creep sitting next to you. He he's in that annoying person. He's in that annoying spouse. He's in that child of yours who who has rejected everything you taught and is ungrateful and
has, you know, really, really hurt you and wounded you. That's where you find Jesus. You find Jesus, as Mother Teresa said, in the maggot infested homeless person in the streets of Calcutta. You find Christ in everyone you encounter if you have eyes to see. That's what faith teaches us. He is still here among us. We are his body. I invite you to take that to
prayer and realize it's not just a wispy metaphor that it it has real teeth. It's really concrete. It's really incarnational and if we let it, it will challenge us to the core. Lord, we need to be challenged to that core. Everyone we slight, everyone we ignore, everyone we glance at judgmentally, we're wounding
Christ, that that who, that's that's Lord help us, that's to live that way is is a game changer. You're reminding me and you even brought it up there in your answer, but of a book that profoundly impacted me. And it's just a collection of things that Mother Teresa said. The title of the book is Loving Jesus and it it spells out through her words and also maybe a little commentary that her
understanding of the work that she did and that her sisters did the Missionaries of Charity or that they still do is being contemplative and active at the same time. In that she talked about a contemplative life is maybe focused really on on depths of prayer and encounter with the Lord in spiritual practices and her deep calling and that so
many other women have felt called to also was to take that experience of of desiring to know and love Jesus and look at what he said. You did it to me. That's what she loved to quote you did it to me from Jesus's words. Whatever you did to the least, you did it to me. She would just remind herself and remind her sisters over and over again. You did it to me and that she loved those simple phrases that
could really Orient your heart, but she would acknowledge like, OK, yes, you're caring for someone if it's a creep or if it's somebody that you find repulsive in some way. She's not saying you should it just kind of force yourself to enjoy that. But to she called it the distressing disguise that to recognize that Jesus is presenting himself in need and in need of our love and care,
but that it is hard for us to encounter Him that way in that distressing. Yeah, the distressing disguise. Yeah, that. So to not to think that that's something that we should kind of be so strong that we don't feel that, but to acknowledge, Lord, you're here. But this is a distressing disguise. Help me to recognize you even though you were in this distressing disguise. And she would often say the distressing disguise with the poor. But for me, in my life, I encountered other distressing
disguises, which could just be people with a really bad attitude. Could be your husband. Distressing disguise. I know I have. I know Christ has appeared to you through me in a very distressing disguise. Right, it's true. So I guess. Yep, she admitted that one readily, didn't she? It's true. Why would I expect otherwise? As have I to you. So anyway, I just wanted to get spend a little time with that. That is a huge, we're talking about two super significant
Saints of the 20th century, Pope John Paul the 2nd and Mother Teresa of Calcutta. And there's such a, a uniting of their visions and their gifts in, in what we're talking about in this question and what's on Natalie's heart. And I think so important. God gave them to us to speak to us because we needed to know these things. While you were formulating your answer there, I was actually on my computer looking up this quote from the Catechism. That's why had you already mentioned the distressing
disguise weren't yet because I wasn't paying attention. I was looking this quote up from the Catechism, which is 796, and here it is. I'll read it and it's Speaking of the whole Christ as head and body, one body formed from many members. And then it goes on to say whether the head or members speak, it is Christ who speaks. He speaks in his role as the head and in his role as body. What does this mean? The two will become one flesh.
This is a great mystery and I'm applying it to Christ and the Church. So here the catechism is quoting Ephesians chapter 5 verses 31 to 32. The catechism goes on and says, and the Lord himself says in the Gospel. So they are no longer 2 but one flesh. They are in fact two different persons. If they are one in the conjugal union, then here's the key line. As head Christ calls himself the bridegroom. As body, he calls himself.
Bride. Wow. Wow. Yeah, he calls himself bride. So Saint Paul says he who loves his wife loves himself. That's how intimate your and my conjugal union is. But that's just a shadow of how intimate the union is between Christ and His Church. When we serve others in that distressing disguise, truly, truly, truly, we are serving
Christ. Lord, open our eyes to so great a mystery. Thank you. You ready for another question? Now let's do it. OK, our next question is from an anonymous listener. Dear Christopher and Wendy, I was homeschooled and raised in a very close knit immediate family. We never spent much time with relatives or friends, and my parents always sought to solely invest in each other and their children. My parents saw that it was their responsibility to teach their children in morals and faith,
and we're always hesitant of the culture pressing in on our family life. All of our friendships and contacts with members outside our immediate family were parent approved or even parent monitored. Our family time was very important and my parents made it feel like a burden if anyone disrupted our time spent together. I've been married to my husband for the past 10 years and we have our own children. We live in a different state than the one I was raised in, so it's easy for me to focus on raising my new little family without interruption. My husband was raised in a large
family in which relatives and friendships were very important. He uses the analogy of the way I was raised as a a wagon train where we circle around to ward off outsiders and protect our immediate members. He still likes to get together with his parents, aunts, uncles, and cousins as they've been an important part of his life since the beginning. Yet it is hard for me to relate to that. He never hesitates to spend time helping anyone in our community that needs his time and help. To me, his desire for connection
outside our immediate family feels unnatural and sort of like he's choosing others over me and the kids. Yet he tells me that in the eyes of God, everyone has the same worth and we need to have that Christian worldview of welcoming others into our time and space. I just wondered how we can have this Christian worldview that he's describing, yet at the same time live up to the Bible verse that my parents often quoted where a man should leave his father and mother and cling to his wife in a way solely investing in one's wife and
children. Thank you for your help. I will tell you what's coming to my mind here there. There are so many points and good points on on kind of both sides of this question and they need to be held together in a proper balance. So what's coming to my mind, as often does, is a line from a movie. So I'll just quote, in the words of the prophet, Mr. Miyagi,
balance Daniel's son, not just karate, but whole life. And I would say, my dear sister, that your parents zoomed in on certain truths, which are truths, truths, right, but failed to balance them with other truths. It is true you should leave father and mother and and cling to your wife. And that means a certain break from your family of origin and a putting priority on your your
new family. That is true. But your husband is also speaking a truth about the missionary spirit of marriage and family life that is not just closed in on itself. It's not insular. And I think when we get imbalanced with that certain truth, it's one truth, but we're not balancing it with the missionary side of things. We become insular.
And I think your husband is is offering a proper critique of, and I don't know all the details. This is only my impression from what you shared, right? So I don't have the whole picture here. So take this for what it's worth. But based on what you have shared, I would say there are, there are concerns that I would have that for all your parents good intentions and I I have no doubt about that they were good intentions. But I it seems to me it created
a certain insular experience growing up what your husband is presenting. It could be imbalanced on the other side where he's spending too much time outside the family circle. That imbalance is also a very real possibility. Hence the words of the prophet Mr. Miyagi Balance, Daniel's son. Not just karate. Whole life. And if you don't know what the heck I'm quoting, you were not alive in the 80s. Or maybe you were alive in the
80s, but your family cultural situation was so insular you didn't watch The Karate Kid. We have to have. That was not an accusation, just an observation. We we have to have, we have to balance those things priority on the I'll just speak from our experience. Wendy, you next to Jesus in my life, you are my first priority. Growing in intimacy with Jesus is my first priority and the natural fruit of growing in intimacy with Jesus in my life.
Because my vocation is marriage and family life, the natural fruit of a genuine intimacy with Jesus in my life will be a genuine intimacy with you. Wendy. You are my priority. Our children after you are, are my priority. But if I spent 100% of my time and energy merely in our home doing only something for you and our kids that didn't have a broader scope, what I would call
that missionary outreach, then we wouldn't be doing this podcast. And that becomes that without that missionary, the balancing the priority of of First things first. But there's a missionary outgrowth, as my spiritual director always says to me, and I don't get this right all the time. I haven't gotten it right, and I have to work on it constantly to get it right. My first priority is my intimacy with the Lord. The natural outgrowth of that is
a proper intimacy with you, Wendy, and with our kids. And that's where my time and energy has to go first and foremost. But the natural fruit of that is going to be a missionary outreach. And in my life that manifests itself through the work we do at the Theology of the Body Institute. All that has to be held in a proper balance. I do believe that your family of origin was imbalanced based on what you've said. I think there could be an
imbalance. I don't know. I don't have enough information. There could be an imbalance on what your husband's upbringing was. But I, I, I doesn't sound imbalanced to me. I think your, I think your husband's upbringing is closer to balance, but it may seem really extreme to you or on coming from a a really different place because of how different it was from your upbringing. But my sense of it, I could be wrong. I don't have a crystal ball.
Please don't take this as if I know everything. I certainly do not I I I could be wrong, but my sense of it. My hunch is your husband is probably offering some legitimate challenges to to ways that you need to to expand from what seems to me a a possible insular experience growing up. When do you how are you taking this? Yeah, I'm really kind of drawn into this story a little bit and I feel for this married couple. And I'm, I'm impressed, first of
all, that with that upbringing that these two people from these different backgrounds met and fell in love, fell in love and are married. That's like the Lord is kind of, you know, just at work and that of course, and doing good things on this earth through their marriage and their family. And I, I love that. I want to affirm that. And it just is a delight to know. And I, I feel like there's something revealed in this question of some of their sharing about their different
backgrounds and their different visions of their life now. And I, so I love that communication and that just exploring your past together and how it's impacting your present. I just can relate to that. And I think it's good. And I think there's a couple things that I would encourage. 1 is to remember that it's important to each person that the good that they received from their family is affirmed by the
other that that if there's only the buildup of resentment because of the discomfort it's causing me now. And and that's the main message is I wish you didn't have that experience and you didn't think that was what we should be like, because I don't like it kind of vibe that that makes people kind of, I don't know, retreat from one another. And I think if we can continually like recognize the good in one another, what one another's bringing, and yet, you
know, be willing to be challenged, as you said, I think those are important first steps. And specifically our questioner, the wife, one of the things I'm feeling is that it's OK for things that he thinks are fun and pleasant for you to maybe not necessarily feel the same way. It's important for him to know that about you and to be gentle with you, you know, to maybe put certain limits on himself on the
amount of maybe hosting or going to be with other people. If he limits that somewhat out of just concern for your heart and your needs. That's one of those ways that we meet each other and and honor each other and, and sometimes then we kind of we develop over time and we don't have to be hard and fast about this is the amount of socializing that's acceptable because different stages in our life are different. But I think that that if he can
approach you with a certain awareness that this doesn't feel as fun and happy to you as it does to him, that it, he can be sympathetic to that. And if he, if you feel that he, he understands you, it can then open your heart to actually receive a blessing in that setting. If you feel like he doesn't get you and he's forcing this situation that is so unpleasant to you, it kind of closes you off to receive the good that could be there for you.
That's my kind of stepping into, if I were in your shoes, kind of the inner dynamics that could be present there. So my, I hope I'm saying this in a way that our listeners can understand that, that a certain feeling known and loved and accepted as I am makes me open to becoming different and feeling not understood can close me off to change. So that's maybe the succinct way to say that I I also felt a
certain caution about maybe too much looking at like is this what the Bible says we have to do? Therefore we must do it at certain like over emphasis on drawing from scripture. There there could have been a lot of other factors at play in your parents choices, their own backgrounds and their the setting where you were in physically living growing up. There's a lot of factors and and you could tell your family we're doing this because the Bible
says it. But really that's not the only reason. You know, there's we're all human beings with stories and pasts and fears. And and so I think, you know, to just point, but what about this scripture? But what about this scripture? It kind of maybe misses the the bigger picture of. Human life justification for not looking at some imbalances. And then my final thought is this, if you've only been married for 10 years and you have a few children, then that means to me that you have young children.
And it could be important when you have young children to alert your husband the level of need you have for his presence that he may need to, for a time limit some of his service outside the home because he needs to get to know better how he can serve in the home. So those are those are my three points. Good stuff, Wendy. Thanks. I remember. I remember those. Oh man, I remember those years
with young kids and I was gallivanting all over the world giving talks on the theology of the body and my wife with young kids was at home. And I'll just say something about that. You know, we, it's so natural that it's more fun to serve in settings where we feel we know what to do. Yeah. And it you didn't always feel like you knew what to do at home. That is true. And so it's, it's, oh, I get it. And, and that may be true in this marriage as well. So it may be a challenge for the
wife to be patient with her husband, to learn more, how he can be helpful at home. And you did go through that. The Lord helped you in great ways, you know, to show you the, the hearts of your very small children and how you could be a blessing to them. And that blessed me so much. So I just want to say, you know, we've gone through growth in this as well. Yeah, and it it is a challenge to the man in a particular way when he's out and about doing what may come more naturally. The image that my spiritual
director used to use with me was, Christopher, you you're, you're throwing with your right hand, 'cause I'm right-handed. When you're writing books and giving talks and teaching courses, 'cause you have a gift to do that when you're at home serving in a more domestic way. You're throwing with your left and you feel awkward about it. And, and you don't like to feel awkward. You like to feel capable and adequate and accomplished. And you got it. You got to, you got to learn how to throw with your left hand.
He used to say, and so I'll put this challenge out to this woman's husband that if that dynamic is going on, if that resonates. Yeah, you got to learn how to throw with your left hand. And and I'll, I'll throw out another story from our relationship. We were we were in Littleton, Co. So this would have been the early 2000s. We were married seven years. And and I got my first cell phone and I was putting in the numbers and you know, this is
such and such a number. And I put my parents number in my cell phone and I had listed it as home. And what did you say, Wendy? That hurt that you would put home for your parents. Our home is home, right? And I remember you called me on it and I'm just, it was like in my brain, the, my home number was my parents number because that's where I grew up. That's my home. And you said, whoa, whoa, whoa, that that's not your home. We I'm your home. This is our home.
And I, I accepted the rebuke because you were right. But it was just an indication. It was a little sign that I had not yet left father and mother in some way to cling to my wife. And and we that was seven years in the married life. So we go through growth here in, in stages and and yeah, so there are challenges on either side. Mr. Miyagi said at best balance. We just, we need balance in all these things. There, there are real gifts that you receive growing up in your
family and but it needs to be balanced out with gifts that your husband also received growing up in his family. And guess what? That's what marriage is all about. That's why the two become one flesh to to to learn from each other and expand each other's horizons and find balance. And there's a, there's an exciting fruitfulness about that, you know, for us and for all couples. And it just reminds me of another line from Karate Kid. What this is right when Mr. Miyagi says it, when he's saying balance in all things.
Daniel's going out on a date and and Mr. Miyagi says Daniel's son, go find your balance. And he meant he meant the girl. Yeah, next question, also from an anonymous listener who asks is cremation ever acceptable in the Catholic Church, especially when looking through the lens of theology, the body, and the hope of resurrection and glorification of our earthly bodies? The short answer to that
question is yes, so let's move on. No, I want more. I want more I'm. Just kidding. Don't stop there. I was just kidding. Kidding, kidding, kidding. The short answer is yes. I wasn't kidding about that, but I was kidding about just moving on. There's more to say. Cremation is not the church's recommendation, but the church does not forbid it. It is not objectively wrong to speed up the process that would
happen just through the natural course of the body's decay, right? You are dust, and to dust you shall return, right? Cremation is just a speedy way of bringing about nature's processes of returning us to dust. So the church does not forbid it. But why does the church not advise it or recommend it? Because there is, especially in our I'll use this expression in our ex carnate world.
What do I mean by that? Well, it's the opposite of Incarnate, right? We, we live in a world where we, we see the body as just material stuff, just a thing. If we're looking at the body as something that's a problem. And when we desire cremation because we have grown up seeing the body as something that is just easily dispensed with and
we treat it recklessly, we don't give it due respect. Well, that's a problem. That's a problem and, and a lot of the move, there is a big, big move in the modern world to cremate rather than bury the dead. And the church is rightly cautious about that because the church is waving a flag and saying where is this coming from? There is a real danger, not an inevitable danger, which is why the Church does not forbid it.
But there is a real danger in a dualistic world. And what I mean by that dualism is this, this ruptured view of the human person that you are a spirit trapped in a body, that your body is a prison and death is where your soul, your real self, is finally liberated from the prison of your body. This is not our faith that is heretical, that that idea of the human person is a direct frontal attack on the deepest truth and
reality of who and what a human being is. We are a marriage of body and soul. The separation of body and soul at death is a cosmic tragedy. It is not liberation, it's it's a state of paralysis. When the soul is separates from the body, the soul is not liberated. The soul is in some way paralysed, in some way paralyzed. Until what? Until the resurrection of the
body. We believe this is the final climactic declaration of the Apostles Creed. We believe in the resurrection of the body and life everlasting. Amen. This is our faith. This is Christian faith. It is Incarnate faith. We believe in an Incarnate afterlife. Thomas Aquinas says The souls in heaven right now are in an inhuman state until the end of
time, when the dust to which we have all returned will be gathered up yet again, and God will breathe his life into it, and we will become eternally living beings, body and soul. So if God can gather the dust at the beginning of time and breathe his life into it, he can gather the dust at the end of time and breathe his life into it. That's the church's understanding of the resurrection of the body. It is not inherently wrong to
speed up that process and return the bodily remains to dust, however, because those bodily remains, even if it's dust, because that dust is destined for divinization, That's the Church's teaching. That dust will be divinized. God will breathe His divine life into that dust. Because that dust is destined for divinization, we must respect it. We must honor it.
That dust must have a proper burial. If you cremate the remains of a loved 1, you cannot set those remains on a mantle. You cannot just put it in an urn on on casual display. It has to be dealt with similarly to a body and and buried properly and respected properly. This is the teaching of the church out of due reverence for the mystery of resurrection. So if all those conditions are met, if one is demonstrating
proper respect for the resurrection, that that dust will be divinized and there's a proper burial of those remains, there's nothing inherently contradicting the Church's vision there. But if your aim is to spread those ashes in the ocean or in the woods or something, this does not show due respect for the fact that that dust is destined for divinization. Yeah, I know we've talked before about that corporal, corporal work of mercy to bury the dead. And it's interesting. I, I know some of our listeners
know I listened to the Bible in a year podcasts last year. And one of the things that was interesting to me was in the Old Testament, how some Jews were really endangering their lives during a, an occupation by another, you know, power. I can't remember the exact historical setting, but say, you know, the Babylonians had taken over and we're really
terrorizing people. And those who would go to retrieve the bodies of their loved ones or just of any Jew to bury them were themselves endangering themselves because this occupying power forbade them from doing it. But their commitment to showing reverence to their dead loved ones was such that they would take this risk, you know, to go and try to get their bodies and bury them. And think also, you know how much our our lost loved ones say
in war, you know, the efforts that are made to identify remains and return them and bury them. There's such a deep thing in our hearts that says this is honoring the gift of the life of this person to to bury them in the ground. And it's a beautiful God-given desire that I think our world has kind of mocked in recent years. And there's been this really forbidding sort of cost of just a normal barrier, sorry, just a
normal burial that kind of encourages people to choose cremation, not because it's really what their heart desires, but because what they're able to afford. And I, I find that concerning. I think it's important to maintain that long standing commitment to honor those that are given the gift of life by God in the way that we care for their bodies and for our own personal like just facing the
grief that we feel in that process and and having something physically to do with that body. There's something very removed from our human experience to have a a body cremated because it kind of the body is just taken away and subjected to this procedure that we try not to think about what it really is. Rather than there's something much more human about our
continuing to have our love for the person expressed by a reverence for their body after their death, and to be reminded how much we long for heaven through that experience. Wendy, what you're sharing is reminding me of one of my favorite lines from the Catechism, which I'll share here. It's Catechism 1683. Catechism says the Church who as Mother has borne the Christian sacramentally in her womb during his earthly pilgrimage. Love, that image accompanies him at his journey's end.
In order to surrender him into the Father's hands. She offers to the Father in Christ the child of his grace, and she commits to the earth in hope, the seed of the body that will rise in glory. Yeah, love it, love it, love it. There's this connection. It's so deeply embedded in Scripture, the connection between woman's womb and the
earth. Truly it's it's not the New Age movement that has claimed to the idea of the earth as mother. This is an authentic Catholic cosmology to recognize the earth as mother, just as the church bears the Christian sacramentally in her womb. So when we bury the body, whether that be the corpse, you know, flesh and bones or the remains of after cremation, which we've just as we've said,
speed up the process and returned to the dust. When we bury the remains of our loved ones, we're placing that body in the ground as a seed right from which this person will rise in glory. When the Son of justice rises at the end of time, when Christ comes forth like a bridegroom, nothing on earth will be concealed from that burning heat And all those who were buried in the ground like a seed when the
sun comes forth, when Christ comes forth like a bridegroom, like a the rising of the sun at the second coming, all those seeds will give birth. The earth will give birth to the resurrected bodies of all those in Christ. Oh, my word, yeah, yeah, yeah. Thank you, Lord, for that hope. Thank you, Lord, for your gift of your body and blood into our body and blood, which is the hope of our own resurrection.
Why do we, why do we eat and drink his body and blood? He says if you do, I, I will raise you up on the last day. I will raise you up on the last day. If you eat my flesh and drink my blood, you will have life in you. I will raise you up on the last day. Thank you, Lord, for giving your bodies, your body, and your blood up for us. Help us, help us to see, to live, to know that we too are called to live as a gift, that we are indeed a gift.
And through the grace that comes to us in the Eucharist, we have all that we need. To become what we are. Amen. Amen. Hey, hey, man. It's a, it's a fade. It's like fade on a record. Hey, man. Hey, man. Hey. Ask Christopher W It's brought to you by the Theology of the
Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...