Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Overcoming Marian barriers, Reviving a "dead battery" heart, & Navigating the morality of “life-saving sterilization” | ACW378

Mar 30, 202642 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: I came into the Church about three years ago, and my fiancé is entering this Easter. He quickly came to know Mary, but it has been taking me some time. I buy her flowers and pray the Rosary, but I don’t seem to connect with her. In John, Jesus says, 'I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.' Yet there is the saying 'to Jesus through Mary.' How can I know her?" The girl who I thought I would marry had suddenly broken up with me. I'm happy to report that the Lord's healing has been present, and He has worked a lot of good in my heart. However, I find that my romantic desire is seemingly broken. After two or three dates, I feel like my heart just gives out. Like a battery in a TV remote - it comes back on for a little while and then it goes back out. How can I cultivate eros again? I know that I’m supposed to feel it. My husband and I will celebrate our 20th wedding anniversary. I am now navigating perimenopause and have been diagnosed with potentially dangerous ovarian cysts, adenomyosis and endometriosis. Doctors have suggested medically inducing menopause to stop ovarian function and potentially stop the progression of these conditions. My husband made the remark that inducing menopause artificially is a way of making me intentionally sterile. I am now torn by the idea that I would be committing mortal sin. Resources: 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Welcome everybody to another episode. We're happy to be with you. We are A couple weeks ago we were recording and before we hit record I was like humming a a

tune from a movie we had listened. To the soundtrack. It was in my mind and heart and I was humming it and you just asked me to sing it into the mic. Forgive me for how that sounded, but anyway, you said to our listeners, does anybody recognize that where that came from? Yes, the soundtrack to what movie? Yeah. So I want to say hi, Stephanie. Stephanie was the only person who Stephanie knew, she said. Christopher and Wendy, your love theme comes from Dances with

Wolves. I love that movie. Oh. Stephanie, we love you because you love that movie, because we love that movie. That's. Right. In fact, we just since we are in the zone of the soundtrack we like, we got to watch the movie again. It's been a long time since we've seen it. Exactly. So we did. And I had a interesting observation that I was our kids don't really like that. They don't dislike the movie. They don't like it as much as we like the movie. And that is sometimes the case with Generation. There's like a generation gap. And I realized for the first

time watching Dances with Wolves, just the pace of the movie. It's the pace that I like. It's storytelling. There's they're, they're quiet moments. There's a pace to it. You, you, there's no explosion every 30 seconds or buildings crumbling down or quick cuts. And, and I realized, Oh my gosh, I, I realized if you were raised on those quick cut movies with explosions every 30 seconds and total action all the time, if that's the way you were kind of trained to appreciate

entertainment and then you sat down to watch Dances with Wolves, you'd be like, but I need a little in my life. I need a lot of in my life. I remember the first time it hit me is when the the Superman movie came out 15 years ago or whatever the newer 1 and I I just wanted to see Christopher Reeves save a cat from a tree. The the fast-paced action was too much for me but our teenage boys at the time, they were

glued to the screen and they loved every minute of it. But there you have it. If you're an old fogey and you want to have some relaxed time, Dances with Wolves is a great movie. Although although I have to say, they should have put the lovemaking scene after the wedding. I mean it's like they just could have edited it that way and it would have been much better. It's not super graphic or anything but it is before they get married and that's just stupid. Whatever. Such as a Hollywood movie. Yeah, it is. Yeah, It's not like everything

is perfect in it, but it does. There is a lot of goodness, a lot of beautiful, just discovering the real humanity of people very different from oneself and having that transform the heart and and the beauty of creation also is a transformative experience. So if there's a lot of goodness in there. A lot to recommend in that moment. Check it out if you haven't ever seen it. So what can you tell us about

the TOB Institute right now? Well, you know, we have these listeners all around the world. We do and they may not know that I also travel all around the world. I want to invite everybody to click in the show notes to see our tour schedule will be several dates in the United States for the rest of this spring season. We kind of do our traveling in seasons. We have this winter, spring season, summer season, fall season. So check out where we'll be on tour in the US for the rest of the spring season.

We're going to Croatia in June. We are going to Romania in September. And I think there's another international stop on that trip that I'm forgetting about right now. Forgive my brain fart, everybody. But then we have a full slate of dates also in the fall. If I travel over the summer, it's usually an international trip. But we have three courses at the institute this summer.

You can also check them out in the show notes. And that's why I don't travel as much during the summer months because I'm usually teaching our intensives here right in Pennsylvania. That's when you get to travel to come see me and come see, I'll be there. The host of the Ask Christopher W podcast That's. Wendy West and I, I will mention, I love it when podcast listeners, listeners introduce themselves and say I'm a listener. It's great. And if you want to bring one of our touring events. And when I say event, it's not just me giving a presentation,

although I can do that. But when we do the touring events, it's live music with Mike Mangioni interwoven with my live presentation. We bring Briggs big screens. We show video clips, sacred and secular art clips, and we make it a whole sensory experience. It's much more like a a night at the theater. And it is a ticketed event as a kind of night at the theater. So there's not, you know, you don't have to pay our stipends or airfare, There just needs to be a commitment on your part to work our marketing program to

get the word and message out to sell the tickets. And that's how the whole thing is supported financially. Exactly. All right, Well, it's time for a question from a patron. Let's do it. This is from a patron named Grace. Grace, I want to just say thank you for believing in our mission. Thank you for your monthly support. We can't do it without you. I hope you're checking out the benefits that we offer exclusively to our patrons. If you haven't been on there for a while, go check them out. And we're going to be expanding that. I have some announcements that

are coming down the Pike just to how we're going to be expanding what we offer our patrons and expanding our our online community. It's really exciting what's coming, but I'm going to push pause there because not here yet, but I wanted to just build a little anticipation. So thank you, Grace, for believing in US. Grace says thank you, thank you for the work you'd do. My fiance and I have date nights listening to your podcast. Oh, that's fun. And your book Good News About Sex and Marriage, has been a wonderful part of preparation

and engagement. Great. I came into the church about 3 years ago and my fiance is entering this Easter. Awesome. He quickly came to know and understand Mary and loves the rosary, but it has been taking me some time. I buy her flowers, I pray the rosary and attempt approaching her in prayer, but I don't seem to connect with her the way others do. One thing specifically I'm

trying to get around is in John. Jesus says I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. Yet there is the saying to Jesus through Mary. I want to know her and trust that she is someone very important to know. But how can I know her? Grace, I love your heart.

I love your honesty. I love your desire. You're seeking, you're, you're hearing things. You're like people say this about Mary and people seem to have a closer relationship with her than I do. I'm not so sure I get this. This guy I'm engaged to, he wasn't even Catholic. He's coming in the church and he seems to have a closer relationship with Mary than I do. What's going on here? I love you. That's beautiful. Keep going. And I want to mention, I just can't help but mention, look at your name.

Your name is Grace, and that's also Mary's name. Did you know that? It's it's unfortunate the way we have translated the scriptures to put it into what we call the Hail Mary. Both words are wrong. The Angel does not say Hail Mary. He doesn't even call her Mary. He doesn't even say Hail. He says rejoice, and then he gives her like an here we are talking about Dances with Wolves, which is John Dunbar.

John Dunbar's Indian name is Dances With Wolves because he dances with wolves. So they call him Dances with Wolves and he marries a girl with an Indian name, stands with a fist because she stood with a fist and that's what she was called. So Mary is given a kind of, if you will, an Indian name. She's given a name that describes who and what she is, and if you were to translate the Greek into English, that is Mary's name, it would be something like this. The Angel says, rejoice, you who

are continually, perpetually and perfectly being filled with the divine life of grace. That's Mary's name. That's who she is. She's the one who is always open to the life giving love that is always pouring out of the Trinity. She's the one who is open to that. And it is a basic bedrock biblical principle that the way that the way comes to us is

through Mary. Jesus is the way with a capital T and a capital W, But Mary is small T, small W, the way to the way, right? If you want to know Jesus, KNOW. There's no better way to know Jesus than to know Mary, right? If we know Mary, we will know Jesus. Jesus is not an abstraction. He's not just a concept, he's a

divine person who has come in the flesh. And the way we get to know Jesus is through his flesh, through his body, and that body was given to Christ by Mary. Mary in this sense is the way small T, small W to the way capital T capital W So no Mary, no Jesus, no Mary and O no Jesus. And all right, He's still an

eternally existing divine person, but without Mary and her, yes, without Mary's womb, without the Annunciation of the Angel who came and said not, hey, Mary, what's up, hell, Mary, hey, no, he says, rejoice, you who are being continually filled with grace. He gave her a new name. Without this woman. Who has this new name, the one continually, perpetually, perfectly open to grace? We don't know who Jesus is. We have no incarnation.

We we don't have Jesus in the flesh. And the only way we can encounter Jesus, the only way we can encounter Jesus is through the incarnation. How can we come to know Mary? Well, you wrote down a question and you sent it to us. Have you ever thought about writing down your questions and sending them to Mary, so to speak, or sending them to Jesus? Say Jesus, you know and love

your mother and from the cross you said, behold your mother. I'm a beloved disciple, that beloved disciple at the foot of the cross to whom you said that behold, your mother is represents every beloved disciple. And so you say to me, behold your mother, come to know your mother. Take your, take her into your home. That was the invitation that Jesus gave to to John, the beloved disciple at the foot of the cross to take Mary into his home. Another translation is into his own.

We have to learn what it means to take Mary into our own, into our hearts, into our experiences, to to, to let her show us who she is, to let Jesus show us who she is. So Grace, my invitation to you, write down in a letter to Jesus. Jesus, I'm going to get to know your mother because she's my mother too, because you gave her to me right before you died. You gave her to me. You know, you got to know that

the things that Jesus said right before he died or some of the most important things he's ever said, this is his last chance before he dies to say something. And he says to all of us as beloved disciples, behold your mother, and we have to learn how to bring her into her home. So write down your questions to Jesus. Take him to Jesus. Read that letter to Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament and pause. Be still and listen, Grace. He's going to speak to you in

the language of your heart, your heart, the way he speaks to you. That's how he's going to speak to you. What's the language of your heart? I don't know the language of your heart, but I'm going to tell you the language of my heart. And I'm going to tell you an experience I had several years ago. That was one of my first, I was about to say holy shit moments, but I won't, but I just did. Sorry, everybody. It was a, it was a, it was a holy Nike moment for me. I was praying in our local parish here in Pennsylvania. This is probably 20 years ago

and, and I was praying for the Blessed Sacrament. And then I felt something, I don't know how to say it, don't know how to put it in words. I felt a presence and it was a holy presence, but it was distinct from the presence of Jesus with which I was more familiar. And this holy presence was, I agree. I, I, I don't even know how I know this, but I felt it. It was feminine. It was a feminine holy presence.

And I fell on my face in the church like I fell on the floor. It was too holy for me. It was too close to me. It scared me. And I fell on my face and I, I, I, the presence kind of grew and there is almost a fragrance to it, a feminine fragrance to it, like a certain flowery perfume. I don't know how to say it. I don't know how to really put in words, but that's kind of what I felt. And it scared me and I I was too much for me. And I ran out of the church and I got in my car to drive home as

quickly as I could. And I put the radio on to distract myself. And this is the song I heard. It's a song from my childhood and it's a woman's voice singing One way or another I'm going to win you. I'm going to get you, get you, get you. I was like oh crap. And I, I pushed shuffle on my radio knob And the next song, female voice singing I love you. Always forever, near and far closer together.

Everywhere I will be with you. Everything I will do for you. Say you love me, Love me forever. It was Mary. It was Mary on the radio. I it was Mary. It was Mary on the radio. I don't know how to say it. It was Mary on the radio. She was singing to me. It was an encounter. It was in the language of my heart. She was singing my language. She was speaking my language. And, and, and when that were those words said, say you'll love me, love me forever. Never stop, never whatever. Near and far closer together. I was like, OK, Mary, you got

me. One way or another, you got me. You got me, got me, got me, got me. And I'm yours. I'm yours. I give myself to you. I'm done running away from you. I give myself to you. And, and up to that point, relationship with with Mary was a lot of theology and a lot of theory, which was beautiful and good and helped me, formed me, shaped me. But it started becoming a lived experience. It's real. She's real. She knows you, she loves you. She's divinized. She's not divine.

She's not a divine person. She's a human person, but the divine person named Jesus Christ, the divine person. Jesus Christ was humanized so that we human persons could be divinized, taken up into the divine life, sharing in it, participating in it. That's Mary's name. She's the one who's always open to the divine life, the grace being poured out. And because she's been divinized, because a human person has been divinized, she shares in the power of God. She's not God, but what God is

by nature. She is by grace. She's been divinized. She's a human person who participates in the divine life. That's why we don't have to take turns talking to Mary. That's why we can all talk to her at the same time because she can more than by locate. She can be present to everybody because she's already participating in the divine reality. She's real. She knows you, Grace. She loves you. She wants you to know her. She wants to share her beauty with you. She wants to show you what it means to be a woman. She wants to show you what it means to be a wife. She wants to show you what it means to be a mother.

She wants to show you what it means to remain open, open, open to the life giving love being poured out eternally from the heart of God. I'm wondering something, Christopher, do you know, and maybe the answer is no, but the origin of that expression to Jesus through Mary. It I'm and other Saints may have said it, but definitely Louis De Montfort says something, if not exactly that very similar where

we we consecrate ourselves to Jesus through Mary and the the the importance of this is to save us from abstraction, right? Jesus is not just a concept. He's an Incarnate person. I think it was the theologian Karl Ronner who said abstractions need no mother, right? The word mother in Latin matare is related to our word matter,

right? Stuff, substance, earth. Jesus without a mother is ex carnate, right? We need the mother because we need Jesus in the flesh. We need Jesus to matter, and we need Jesus in his mater. And is there any book or or content on that consecration that you would particularly recommend? Yeah, well, my book Heaven Song talks a lot about the Louis du

Montfort consecration. John Paul himself. I just want to hold this out. John Paul himself gives a little bit of a warning or disclaimer in his endorsement of Louis De Montfort. He says his language can be easily misunderstood. And I have as many big XS in the margin of my copy of True Devotion from Louis De Montfort as I do big stars and checkmarks. I don't like this language. Yeah, he wrote 253 hundred years ago and and in the language is is difficult, but JP 2 says the

treasure underneath it is undeniable. So, so get a good interpreter of Louis De Montfort if you if you like what I'm having to say, you could read my book, Heaven Song Grace. Or by all means, take my Marian Mystery course either online or in person. I'll be teaching Theology of the Body and the Marian Mystery from November 1st to November 6th of this year, 2026. It's my favorite course to teach. Why don't you and your new husband come to that course?

I'm assuming you'll be married by then, but maybe you won't be. It would also be great marriage prep if you're not married. I talk a lot in that course about Louis De Montfort. Yeah, and I, I just, I know that any person that you talk to Grace who, who has a relationship with Mary will have his or her own journey. No two people are that's right, the same. I can remember as a teenager kind of coming to a deeper faith, but it was sort of it was

through a lot of more Protestant influence. And so I didn't know how to fit Mary in that. And I remember just little steps of my heart opening to her, kind of having a certain awe about her carrying Jesus in her womb that like just open my eyes to her wonder a little bit. And there have been many things that were just little touch points in my life through the years. And one of a big one for me was when you and I went on that

pilgrimage to France in 2023. We started in Lourdes, which is a place in France where the Blessed Mother appeared to a peasant girl named Bernadette Subaru in the late 1800s, mid 18. Hundreds. Yeah. And, and then we visited other places in France and I, oh, remember. Yes. In Paris, it was Catherine Laboure the the miraculous metal shrine.

So I know these things sound so Catholic. They are. They were, they are. It's not like the United States. It is impressive. But that trip I felt the motherly tenderness of Mary, like in a way I can't even. I couldn't have known I needed it. I couldn't believe it existed. The tenderness, the motherly concern for her children, and I am one of them. That I experienced it was and is

profound. So I just share that with you, Grace to encourage you that it's there's nothing strange about being on that journey, that it is a journey. And I personally, I've never bought flowers for Mary. So good on you. I'll just throw one more thing out there that again, in relation to your name, Grace, Grace perfects nature. As you've heard me say on this podcast, Grace perfects nature. We need a mother according to

the order of nature. Grace does not delete that, it perfects it. She is our mother in the order of grace. You can't have God for your father and Jesus for your brother if Mary is not your mother. The family reality of nature is what Grace perfects. Hallelujah. Thank you, Mary, for being our Mama. Our next question? Ready. Yep. It's from an anonymous listener. A few months ago, you answered a question that I had submitted.

Uh huh. The girl. Aren't you lucky we're answering another one of you? In a double, double appearance on the Ask Christopher W podcast anonymously, the girl who I thought I would marry had suddenly broken up with me and I was in a lot of pain. Oh. I think I remember this guy. I'm happy to report that the Lord's healing has been present. Thank you Lord so far, and He has worked a lot of good in my heart. However, I find that my arrows,

my desire, especially my romantic desire, is seemingly broken. I've gone out on a few dates with women that are good, holy, and lovely people, but every time after two or three dates, I feel like my heart just gives out, but my romantic desire just isn't there anymore. The best analogy I've come up with for this is like a battery that goes out in the TV remote. The remote dies, but if you take the battery out and put it back in, it comes back on for a

little while and then it goes back out. That's what my heart feels like. How can I cultivate Eros again? I know that I'm supposed to feel it, and yet for the last six months I just don't. Brother, I want to express just tenderness towards you, understanding towards you and invite you to understanding and tenderness and patience with yourself. I like your remote and the

battery image, the image that was coming to me as Wendy was reading your question. As I, I saw a sailboat and, and the wind had died down and the, the sail was up, but the wind wasn't blowing. So it wasn't full, it wasn't moving. And, and I, that's an image of, I think a, a, a broken heart, a wounded heart, a heart that has been through a hard time. And I just urge you patience

with yourself, tenderness toward yourself, compassion towards yourself, and trust that that holy passion you're talking about, Pope Benedict the 16th describes Eros properly. Understood. We're not talking about some lustful base passion here. We're talking about that holy desire for love, for union, for affirmation, for happiness, for joy, for the true, the good and the beautiful. That's holy Eros. Pope Benedict the 16th calls it

the Holy Passion. It's the desire in US ultimately that seeks God. Francis de Sales says that Eros is the passion that rushes towards divinization. What we are ultimately looking for is to participate in divine love, in divine life. That is not dead in you, brother. How do I know this? Because you're a human being, that that is the image of God in

us. Again, Pope Benedict says this holy passion, this holy Eros is like a signature imprinted on the body and soul by God himself. God's signature imprinted with fire, imprinted with fire. That fire, maybe it's not blazing right now, dear brother, but there's a spark in there that has not gone out. It just needs a little time to be rekindled.

And you can trust it will be rekindled, But maybe maybe the reason it hasn't been rekindled in this sense or in this way that you're hoping for is because you just need a little more time for healing. Don't rush it. Just throw it up to the Lord as a prayer. Lord, what are you saying to me here? I'd like to kind of be back to normal, but I don't feel it. I'm going out with these very good women.

They're attractive, they're holy. I, I, you know, all things considered, I, I could want to date them and maybe even marry one, but I, I'm not feeling it. Lord, what are you trying to tell me here? What's going on in my heart? Something very important is going on in your heart, brother, and you can trust that to the Lord. Yeah, you know, I I love your sailboat. Waiting for the wind image. I think it's, it's so just beautiful. And there aren't sailboats in Scripture maybe, but they're

the, the Holy Spirit, the wind blowing where it will. And that mystery of that is certainly a scriptural image. And that's what I was thinking of when you said that I can tend to get medical imagery 'cause I used to be a nurse and, and 'cause he's talking about his heart, which is both, you know, obviously and image of our deepest core and our emotions, but it's also physically part of us. And so I, yeah, I have a little bit of an image of somebody

recovering from, you know, a heart procedure and feeling like, oh, I think I'm, I'm, I'm healing. So, so let me do something. And then finding the fatigue and the, the body just saying no, not yeah. Oh, I. Like that? And and the the frustration that that can bring when you're recovering from. Something you want to be better than you are? Yes. Can I go jogging? Yes. Or for me, can I go skiing? No, not yet. Right. But the trust that the process

of healing that we cannot see, that's hidden is ongoing. And, and that is just so encouraging and, and it gives us hope, even though there are disappointments and frustrations along the way, that progress is happening. And that's a beautiful thing. And I think there are people listening who needed to hear that today, who needed to know, don't give up hope here. Don't give up hope. The Lord is at work at those quiet times where it seems like nothing's happening or it's just happening too slowly.

He knows what he's doing. And that's such a a place to trust, trust in his heart. I'm here, Neil Young right now, OK, But it's a version of the song by my favorite band from my high school years called The Alarm. And there's a line in there that goes there's man of the people saying keep hope alive. I got fuel to burn. I got roads to drive. Keep on rocking in the free

world. Keep going, brother. Keep on rocking in the free world. Be tender with yourself. Let yourself heal. There's still fuel in there to burn. There's still roads to drive. There's a man saying keep hope alive. Keep your hope alive, brother. Your, your, your heart will come alive again. It's just in a time of convalescence and and you need to be tender and patient with yourself while your heart's healing. Yeah. Our next question is from an anonymous listener.

This year, my husband and I will celebrate our 20th wedding anniversary. Congratulations. In those twenty years, we've been blessed with four healthy, gorgeous children. I am now navigating perimenopause and for the past two years have had a host of painful symptoms, cancer scares and unanswered medical questions. I've now been diagnosed with potentially dangerous ovarian cysts, adenomyosis and endometriosis. Aside from the constant pain,

doctors have concerns about the potential development of the ovarian cysts and endometriosis, which could lead to cancer. In the need for surgery, they have suggested medically inducing menopause to stop ovarian function and potentially stop the progression of these conditions. I've made peace with aging as I'm sure that if our good God designed women to live a third of their life in menopause, He didn't do it to make us feel useless. Amen. However, my husband, who's also

a Deacon, made the remark that inducing menopause artificially is going against God's will and is in fact a way of making me intentionally sterile. I was really hurt by his comment because he doesn't understand the challenges that will come with it, but I'm now also torn by the idea that I would be committing mortal sin. My understanding of TOB is that if infertility is a not wanted side effect of a necessary

treatment, it is not a sin. But I would greatly appreciate your insight because it will help me to understand how to navigate this and more importantly, be at peace. My dear sister, you are correct. Your understanding is the correct one. Your, your husband is just not properly formed. And maybe that's a blow to his pride or something, 'cause he's a Deacon and he's supposed to be well formed in this, but he's not he's, he's not properly formed here. He's not understanding something

correctly. Now, I want to commend your husband. It's clear that he has a valiant desire, even under strain and stress and difficult circumstances, to want to follow the Lord. And that's a beautiful thing. But he's misguided here. It's just plain and simple. He, he's misguided. You are absolutely right. The intention of this procedure is not to sterilize you. The, the, the intention of this procedure is to stop a progressive degeneration of your

body that can risk your life. Now the the what is what is being desired here is the end of the the cancer not to sterilize you right? It that's not the intention. Contraception is in the act of the will, right? You do not have a contraceptive will here. You have a desire to cure a a medical condition that is not fertility. That's not what's trying to be cured. What's being cured is is cancer.

Or actually other underlying. Maybe I don't know the the exact underlying circumstances that when do you know it better as a medical professional, but the the, the, the goal, the end of the procedure is not to render you sterile. The end of the procedure is to save your life from disease. Whatever the disease may be, cancer or what have you, There is the unintended side effect that this will bur on, bring on

infertility. That is not what is intended. So you are not guilty of any sin of contraception. That's the truth. That's what the Church teaches. That's what the Church believes. You can find the outline of these truths in Humanae Vitae. You can find the outline of these truths in the Catechism of the Catholic Church. You can find it in any magisterial document that is talking about the morality of this. These issues that medically necessary procedures to cure a malady that is life threatening, that may have the unintended

side effect of sterility is not the same as willfully rendering yourself sterile. Different animals, different species of moral act. So I just encourage you to have your husband listen to this. If he has further questions and he wants me to point him to specific magisterial documents, I can do that. He can write in and and I'll make sure to get that to him. And yeah, I'm happy to help. Read my book, Good News About Sex and Marriage, where I go into all the details there with proper citations from Vatican

documents. That's what I'd recommend in Chapter 5. Sorry. Chapter 6 of Good News about Sex and Marriage is where I go into these details and cite properly the magisterial documents. Your husband will find it all there. And I know it could just be a thing that kind of catches people. It's attention and I just want to press a little bit for the sake of our listeners. Yeah, let's let's get as clear as we can here. You said something in when you were speaking about the church's, you know, affirmation that it is acceptable to seek

treatments even with these unintended side effects. You said an illness that is life threatening. And I don't know if you meant to say that as if it were a qualification that the church holds out or if it's. I'm so glad you're bringing that up. It, it doesn't even have to be necessarily life threatening, but something that is worthy of treatment because we're humane and we, we, we need help. You are not this. This is a very obvious case in point.

You are suffering pain every day and the goal of treating that pain is not to render you sterile. The goal of treating that pain is to relieve you of that suffering, relieve you of that pain. The unintended consequence of relieving you of that pain is that you will go into early menopause and thus be rendered sterile. But you are You are not choosing that as the object of your choice.

You are accepting that as the unintended consequence of a medically worthy procedure. So whether death is on the line or life is on the line is, is not of critical importance. I just, I said that for the sake of emphasis that it does sound to me and unless I'm mistaken, that there is the potential for life threatening cancer here if she doesn't seek these treatments. Was I, was I wrong about that? Maybe I was. Well, I guess regardless.

Regardless. Regardless. Some of our listeners don't have that, so I just want to make sure. Thank you, Wendy. That was very important qualification. Yeah. And, and I just, I want to say as well, like these are challenging times. Illness is a challenging time. And I think we can be, you know, when we're, I'll, we're extra vulnerable and we're looking at just the confusion and the potential of doing something that, OK, this treatment will take care of one problem, but it

could bring other problems. And that's, that's a difficult thing to wrestle with, not just the infertility, but also the changes of menopause that will be difficult. So there's a, it's a challenging and it's vulnerable. And I think maybe there's a way in which your husband, as a representative of the church, he's an ordained Deacon. It could have felt like the church is uncaring because you're in a vulnerable place right now.

You know that that is particularly vulnerable when it's your husband or depending on, you know, how you know him and the things he says. Maybe you're used to it, but some people would find that a hard, painful thing to be sort of somewhat accused of considering something unacceptable to the church and meaning unacceptable for our own good. And so all of that I just want to acknowledge is is a little bit extra tender in this situation and and in your kind of being confirmed by what

Christopher shared and what's in good news about sex and marriage and other documents of the church, of course, that it's not a wrong thing to seek treatment at. I think there's also just a little hurt here in your marriage that is worth. Just exploring together as husband and wife and with mercy and and learning more about each other's hearts through this experience. Yeah, I would in light of that, what Wendy's saying, which I think is important to approach your husband with, with gratitude that he wants to do the right thing.

Good on him, good on him. But there's there's no need to be, as the saying goes, more Catholic than the Pope here to to trust the church's wisdom here and to help your husband to understand that wisdom is certainly loving for him and toward him. And it can bring real healing to where there may be a a a, a need for that. I hope that blesses you. And we hope all that we've shared with our listeners today has been a blessing somewhat of

a light in your own life. If it has been and you think it would help others if you could help us get the word out and hit that share button so we can expand our listenership, we would be grateful. Thank you for being a gift to us. You are made in the image and likeness of God. You are indispensable. You are irreplaceable. You are an unrepeatable gift of life and love. Thank you, Lord, for the grace you give us. Help us to become what we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to

you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode