Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Navigating Family Conflict Over NFP, Letting Go of a Love That Still Lingers, Finding Intimacy in a Celibate Marriage | ACW325

Mar 24, 202554 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: Dear Christopher and Wendy, thank you for all you do. For context, my husband and I are expecting a baby again for the third time in less than three years, despite our best efforts to practice NFP. I am exhausted and facing potentially serious health concerns. My parents have never understood our stance against contraception, despite being Catholic themselves, and have always tried to persuade us to use it. Things came to a nasty head recently when we announced our latest pregnancy, and we had a major fight. My father says Catholics are not bound by the teachings of Humanae Vitae and are thus free to practice contraception because it is not, quote, ex cathedra doctrine. How do I respond to this? My dad said some very hurtful things about my husband and me. I don't know what to do. I held my ground during the argument, but now I'm starting to doubt myself. Please help. I'm a 20-year-old college student who truly started choosing Christ in my first year of college. In high school, I was in sinful relationships, but when attending a Catholic college, I wanted to stop that. Everything changed when I met a girl who inspired me to pursue sainthood, and I knew I needed to grow in virtue to date her. After seven months of waiting and growing, we began a Christ-centered relationship. But it ended after a month and a half when she chose to discern religious life. Two years later, I still struggle to move on. I've mistakenly entered other relationships hoping to forget her but constantly find myself thinking of her and comparing potential partners and even friends to her. Deep down, I don't want to let her go and feel drawn to reach out, remembering the Christ-filled joy our relationship brought to both of us. My question is, should I let go or should I pursue this relationship? I've been married for 21 years. On our honeymoon, my husband suffered an injury that made sexual intercourse extremely difficult and eventually impossible for him. We have seen doctors for treatments that were unsuccessful and very embarrassing for my husband. In time, we realized it was not going to get better, and it hasn't. By God's grace, we were able to have one child, but marital relations between us have not been possible for over 17 years. My heart aches and longs for this affection from my husband, but I long ago accepted the fact that our marriage is celibate and always will be. In the early days, we fought about this all the time, mostly because he avoided physical contact with me so as not to arouse himself, and I felt very rejected. He's never really liked to talk about this as he finds it very difficult to share his emotions. I used to pressure him to talk, but I've learned that that just isn't his way. I've also learned to see the many other ways that my husband loves me through his acts of service and dedication to our family. He is a wonderful husband, and we love each other deeply. Our strongest connection is our Catholic faith. I experienced a very deep conversion back to my Catholic faith a few years after our marriage, and this has helped me to mature and grow a deep intimacy with God. Even though I have that intimacy with God, I still at times feel so very alone with this cross and have spent most of my marriage feeling as though my husband doesn't desire me, as if he doesn't miss the intimacy because he won't share his pain with me. I have recently begun reading a book, The Cantata of Love, a commentary on the Song of Songs. The imagery in the poem is so beautiful, and it has reawakened in me again the feelings of how much I miss my husband. This part of me I mostly shut down because it's too painful to keep revisiting those unmet desires. It feels a bit like, why torture yourself by reading this? At the same time, I realized that the poem is also an allegory of the love between the bridegroom and the bride, Jesus and my soul. I wonder if you have any experience with people in similar situations and what has helped them. Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. πŸ”₯ Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body πŸ“• Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) ⚑️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: Marriage Missionaries [Mike Mangione, director of events contact to inquire about β€œThe Well”](events@tobinstitute.org) TOBI Event Calendar πŸŽ₯ Check out our YouTube Channel πŸ“š View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! πŸ“˜ GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. ⛷️ Join Christopher on a ski trip to Utah Click here πŸ”οΈ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here 🌟 For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Hey, everybody. Welcome to another episode. Yeah, thanks for tuning in. We are in the middle of Lent 2025 and you know, at the very beginning of this Lent, I just felt a real inspired moment of prayer with our kids, just our

morning prayer together. But just really a, a sense of like, I want to invite the Lord into deeper places in my heart and want to just just feel that just even the fearful way it can be to open it up. But like it really was a just a guiding sense for our Lent. And then you shared a beautiful quote about Lent with me that I thought, Oh, our listeners would appreciate that because maybe because I appreciated it. So I figured. Others would too.

Good One shout out to my friend and dear brother Matt Dalton, who sent this to me. Matt Dalton and his wife Mindy run marriage missionaries. We've talked about how they do coaching for married couples and we'll have their the link to their ministry in our show notes. That was not a paid advertisement. I was just a shout out to the good work that they do. But anyway, Matt sent me this quote and I just love it.

I had never read this from JP 2 or if I had, I forgot it. That's part of my 55 year old brain. But listen, this good juicy nectar, the Sorry, that's my image of a good quote. It's like nectar out of a What do you get nectar out of? Peaches. Peaches. All right, Millions of Peaches. Peach. Sorry, here we go. Here's the quote. The purpose of Lent is not to force on us a few formal obligations.

Thanks be to God. That was my editorial comment. But to soften our heart so that it may open itself to the realities of the Spirit. To experience the hidden thirst for communion with God. Saint John Paul the second. Love it, love it, love it, love it. I often approach Lent like, OK, here comes the season where I got to do those things. The formal obligations.

Nope, Nope, Nope. The purpose of Lent is to soften my heart so that I can get in touch with my thirst for God. Which is to say, if you're familiar with the work we do here at the TOB Institute, I learned this from JP 2. The thirst that yearning for communion with God. The Church borrows her language from the Greeks here and calls it Eros Eros. The purpose of Lent is to get us

in touch with our Eros. Pope Benedict the 16th says Eros is the holy passion. It is the desire within us that seeks union with God. There it is, there it is so Lord, this Lent in in our sacrifices. Why, why do we fast? Why do we give things up? It's to to feel the hunger, right? I'm hungry right now and, and you know, my immediate reaction

is I want to go fill my belly. But it's actually, it's actually good for me to feel that hunger in my belly for a time and not just immediately satisfy it or take it away by eating something. Because as I feel that physical hunger and I let myself feel it, it is meant to, and it can and it does if I let it get me in touch with my deeper hunger, my deeper yearning, the deeper cry of my heart.

Man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God. We are the kind of creatures that we're not. We're not just hungry for, for, for food on the table. We're we're hungry for something infinite. And mystery of mysteries, the Infinite One has made himself food. The infinite we don't, we do not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God. Well, mystery of mysteries, the word that comes from the mouth

of God becomes bread. We can eat, or we should say that bread becomes him. Astounding, astounding. So let us learn. Learn, Lord, how to get in touch with our deeper hungers and our deeper thirst. This lint, teach us how to get us in. Teach us how to get in touch with our Eros, our yearning for communion with you, Lord. Amen. Do you have any updates for our listeners from the Doobie

Institute? Yeah, I thought this week I would share a new event, a new live event that we have developed here at the Theology Body Institute. We're calling it the well, as in come, all of you who are thirsty, come to the well. It's a response to the Bishop's call for Eucharistic revival. And we are through this event. We're going through the story of the woman at the well talking

about there we go again, that thirst, that deeper thirst for communion with God. Well, where do we experience the satisfaction of that deeper thirst for communion with God? Again, we were just talking about it, the Eucharist. The Eucharist, the well is a 2 1/2 hour event that would be held typically during a week night at a parish. And we've designed it so that it doesn't cost a parish anything financially to bring it to the parish.

What it will cost you is a commitment over four to six months to go through a promotional process. We've been doing this a long time. We fine-tuned how to promote these events and how to sell tickets to to get attendees in the seats. And that's how the event is funded through ticket sales. And those ticket sales go to support the global mission of getting this message out around the world. So it's a win win situation that brings Eucharistic revival to

your own parish and experience of it. And it also helps to fund the global efforts of getting theology, the body out to other people around the world. So we'll have a link below to learn more. There are other live events that we offer at the institute. We'll have a link to those as well. But I just wanted to give a shout out to this new event. If you're looking for an opportunity for Eucharistic Revival at your parish, please contact us because we have an event that I think will really, really be a blessing for your

community. Awesome, I want to go to the well. Yeah, I've. Never been. It's kind of exciting. Thanks. Thanks. You ready for a question from a patron? This is from Amy. Hi, Amy, thank you so much for being a patron. Dear Christopher and Wendy, thank you for all you do. For context, my husband and I are expecting a baby again for the third time in less than three years. Bless you, bless you, bless you. Despite our best efforts to practice NFP, I am exhausted and

facing potentially serious health concerns. My parents have never understood our stance against against contraception, despite being Catholic themselves, and I've always tried to persuade us to use it. Things came to a nasty head recently when we announced our latest pregnancy and we had a major fight. My father says Catholics are not bound by the teachings of Humane Vitae and are thus free to practice contraception because it is not quote ex cathedra doctrine.

How do I respond to this? My dad said some very hurtful things about my husband and me. Oh. I'm so sorry. I don't know what to do. I held my ground during the argument but now I'm starting to doubt myself. Please help. Amy, Amy, bless you, my dear sister. My heart is aching for you. First of all, your father is wrong. Your father is flat out wrong. Humane Vitae teaches the truth and every human being is bound

to follow the truth. And contraception is always and in every situation. Rendering the marital act sterile is always and in every situation, a violation of God's plan for marital love. Always it does harm. Always, always it does harm. And your father is blind as a bat, and that needs to be said clearly. Doesn't mean I don't love your dad.

He's broken. Like I'm broken and we're all broken. We all got our issues. But your your father is blind. And when all is revealed, when all is made known, when everything that in this world is hidden comes into the light, your father will fall on his knees and weep at your feet for the ways his blindness has harmed you. It makes me righteously angry

that your own father, who brought you into this world through his love for your mother, would scold you and shame you and and fight you in your desire to live married love as God has created it to be what you are going through. My dear sister Amy, I know it's difficult. 3 pregnancies. 3 pregnancies in three years. Very difficult.

I don't doubt for a moment that you're at your wit's end and and there's all kinds of anxiety connected with what you're experiencing. But what you are experiencing is without a doubt salvific for the world. And it is salvific for your Father, who is desperately in need of salvation here. Between here and the Beatific vision, all of us will come to grips with the Church's teaching

on contraception. And we will see in the plain light of day that the Catholic Church was inspired by God and has been for 2000 years in declaring this. And we will see the havoc wrought on the whole world by the modern embrace of contraception. And we will see the courage, the valiant courage of Pope Paul the 6th as Vicar of Christ, to stand up and declare in the face of global opposition, rendering the marital act sterile.

Can never, can never lead to happiness, Can never lead to the joy, can never lead to the love we're we're desiring and looking for. It is a cheap out from the cross to to to embrace contraception. To accept contraception is to accept the father of lies saying come down from your cross. Come down from your cross. No married love is a call to embrace the cross and you and your husband are also valiantly

staying on that cross. God bless you. That's why I say what you are doing is salvific for the world. Dear Amy, I needed to say that boldly and I needed to say it with zeal because it's the truth. It's the truth, and the truth is what sets us free. All of that said, I just want to speak words of compassion and understanding for all that you are experiencing.

And three pregnancies in three years. Wow, wow. We, we had 2 pregnancies close together early in our marriage and then another 2 pregnancies close together later in our marriage. And so we, we know something of, of what you're going through there. And, and it can be exacerbating to say the least. The Lord is with you there. There is grace there. This grace of the sacrament of

marriage is real. To think the solution is you should have sterilized your union and this life should not exist. What, what, what, what this child conceived of your love for your husband. Yes, there's hardship involved. Let's not undermine that or pretend it's not real. It's real. But that is a life destined to live forever in the communion of Saints. That is a life that God has desired to exist from all eternity, and your yes has

changed eternity. When we put things in their proper perspective, we're able to more readily, I think, accept the sacrifice that comes with the joy of bringing a new life into the world. Much could be said here about natural family planning, and you know, we need far more details to know why. As you said, despite your best

efforts in practicing natural family planning, you've been conceiving. I think you do have a just reason to avoid another pregnancy after this. And I would encourage you. I don't know what your training in natural family planning has been. Some people say we're making our best effort in practicing natural family planning, but they haven't been properly trained. They're just kind of doing some guesswork. I don't know what your situation is. I don't want to try to read into it, but but if by chance that is your situation where you've maybe just read a book about it and then your husband and you

started trying to to live it, please, please, if that's your situation, please get proper training from properly trained people in how to use natural family planning. And there are times throughout our marriage. We, we, of course, we're past childbearing years now, but for for long, long years in our married life, 25 plus years in our married life, we practice natural family planning. And there were times where we'd be in a certain cycle where we were confused about the signs of fertility and we would have to

contact the couple to couple league. That was the organization that we were in touch with and that we, we had people there that we knew who could help us when we had specific questions. All of all of that is to say, there are people out there, Amy, who can help you practice natural family planning effectively. My prayer for you is that you stand firm in this truth. There are lies, Lies after your heart, lies after the the the

life of your child, lies after the sacrament of your marriage. And sadly, they are coming right through your father. In the name of Jesus, we rebuke those lies, and we ask first and foremost grace for Amy and her husband to stand firmly in the truth. Send Amy and her husband people. They need to help them walk this pilgrimage in practicing natural family planning. And Lord, please, please, please

bring salvation to Amy's father. Please deliver him from the lies he has believed. Your life, Amy, is a confrontation with the lies your father has believed. So of course he comes back and attacks you because you're the witness of your life is confronting him with the lies that he has believed. And he doesn't want to believe that they're lies. Well, they are lies. He's believed lies and those lies have damaged him and blinded him. Offer the suffering he has

caused you, Amy, which is deep. Offer the suffering He has caused you as intercession that your father would be set free from these lies. Yes, I, Amy, it's a, it's a, a very painful situation that you're in. And I, I know all that Christopher has said. I, I believe with my whole heart and I, I know it's, it's a very painful thing to be wronged by your own parents.

It's such a vulnerable time. And I, I do pray for your heart, Amy, and for your husband's heart in that you are vulnerable. You talked about exhaustion and health concerns and just the fact that you have already 2 very small children who on the one hand like are amazing miracles and you are blessed to be the receiver of their sweetness and their smiles and their discoveries and all that

is wonderful about small children. But at the same time, they involve maybe moments when you you don't have anything left to give, but they still have needs. And those are painful moments. I want to encourage you and your husband to really turn to the Lord together and turn to one another because even as this attack has come from your parents, the Lord has you in this sacrament and this family

that you're you formed and are forming with. Your husband is your family. And that is an incredible gift. And if the evil one would succeed in sewing just a lot of dissension between you and your husband and making it that much harder to live this season of your marriage, that would be just so tragic. And when we're at our lowest, we are very vulnerable to those kinds of attacks.

But we're also so open to grace. And sometimes it doesn't appear right away. And we, we go through this time of, of darkness, but even if there is some darkness in this time, like Please remember that the light is coming and that the truth will always set us free, even if it's a process of being set free. That the love that binds you and your husband together doesn't just come from the two of you.

It comes from the Holy Spirit because He is the love in the Trinity and He's the love in your marriage. So I just encourage you to allow this experience even in the ways that has kind of, I don't know, knocked you down in a sense that even from from that place of being knocked down, that that you would experience the Lord and his own collapse on the road to Calvary. You know, he's he knows what

it's like to be anxious that he can't bear a burden because he couldn't bear the weight of the cross at times. He knows that feeling. He knows that lowness, but he also knows the the joy set before him that that kept him going and the love of the Trinity in his heart was the found of his. Yes, and I believe it is to be for your marriage as well. So know that you're in our heart and prayers and that there's good to come, there's beauty to

come, and we're praying for your dad as well. Amy, I want to speak as if I were the loving Father that you deserve in this situation. And I want you to imagine my smiling face when you just told me you're pregnant with #3 And I want you to see there's a tear in my eye as your father of joy, but also a realization of the suffering and the sacrifice that you've embraced. But that tear is also a great

love for you in your courage as a mother. And I want you to imagine that your heavenly, that is your, the voice of your heavenly Father. You don't have to imagine it. Your Father, your Father in heaven is so proud of you. And if I could enter in and just give voice to it, the earthly father that you are worthy of, that you should have had, who would have stood up for you, would have said, Amy, I'm here for you. Your mother and I are here for

you. There are going to be sacrifices involved here. But we are with you in this. We stand with you in your courage, in your embrace of the truth. We are with you and we will walk with you on this journey and we will be with you. We will help you. I'm sorry you didn't hear that. I hope hearing it from me, not that I can live it out other than through my prayer and and love for you from a distance, but I just thought you you needed to hear the the words of a Father speaking truth to you, speaking what you should have

heard and what you are worthy of hearing. Bless you Amy, bless you. Bless you, bless you, bless you. This is going to become a beautiful part of your testimony of God's faithfulness. Amy, it is. Our next question is from Gabriel. Hi, Gabriel. Hello Christopher and Wendy, I recently discovered your podcast and have found it to be deeply spiritually formative. I'm. So glad. A bit of context before my question. I'm a 20 year old college student who truly started choosing Christ in my first year

of college. In high school I was in sinful relationships, but when attending a Catholic college I wanted to stop that. Everything changed when I met a girl who inspired me to pursue sainthood and I knew I needed to grow in virtue to date her. After seven months of waiting and growing, we began a Christ centered relationship but it ended after a month and 1/2 when she chose to discern religious life. Two years later, I still

struggle to move on. I've mistakenly entered other relationships hoping to forget her but constantly find myself thinking of her and comparing potential partners and even friends to her. Deep down I don't want to let her go and feel drawn to reach out remembering the Christ filled joy our relationship brought to both of us. My question is should I let go or should I pursue this relationship? God bless you Gabriel.

So human what you're going through. My initial sense is just to honor in your heart the deep impact she had on your life and to praise God for it. She had a deep impact in your heart, in your life and that is a good thing. Brother, you are not meant to forget her. Don't try to forget her. You will remember her, and you should remember her for the rest

of your life. And you can continue to love her because to love another person is to desire that other person's good. So that also loving her rightly is going to be a call to purification in your heart. Where you might be clinging to something in an inappropriate way, where you might be desiring something with her in an

inappropriate way, genuine love is going to be ready and willing to sacrifice itself for her good. Is she called to religious life? I don't know. I don't know. But she believes she needed to go discern that, and genuine love would honor that, would honor that. So wherever you find it difficult to honor her decision to pursue religious life,

wherever you might want to intervene in that and assert your own desire above that, I would just invite you to say in your own way, in your own way of praying, Lord, I, I, I see this desire in my heart to insert and assert my own desires above her desires and possibly even above what is good for her and what you desire for her. Teach me, Lord, the gift of true

love, which involves and this is a quote from JP 2A Disinterested tenderness. Disinterested means here that you are not interested in a selfish way. Disinterested. It doesn't mean you're not interested in the right way, but to be interested in the right way is to be interested in her good, whatever that costs you. And to set your heart on on that. Good Lord, I'm going to, I'm going to choose her good, even

if it costs me, even if it brings pain and suffering to me. I want to choose her good. And that will come all the more readily, I believe, Gabriel, from your heart, the more you, instead of trying to forget her or compare other people to her, but to to bring all that stirring in your heart, that desire to forget her. You know, I want to date this other person because I just want to try to forget her. Well, something's off there. You don't want to forget people that blessed you. This woman blessed you.

Open that up, Say and and give praise to God for the blessing that she was in your life. And I think coming from a place of gratitude for what she meant in your life and still means in your life, that gratitude will free you up to desire her good. Thanksgiving is really the healing of many ills in our hearts. Or to put it another way, a lack of Thanksgiving is the source of many ills in our lives.

Thanksgiving can be healing. Let your let the disposition of your heart be one of Thanksgiving for for the blessing she was in your life. And also from that launching pad of Thanksgiving, I think you will find as you, if it is God's will for you to pursue other relationships, that you won't be comparing. You won't be comparing others to her because thanking God for her is also releasing her into God's hands. Thanking God for her is

recognizing she's unrepeatable. She's unrepeatable. And guess what? So is this other person you might be entering into a relationship with. This person is unrepeatable, and that means to compare one person to another is an injustice to the unrepeatability of the person. This person you're now dating, if you enter into a new relationship is her own person. It's a terrible injustice to compare her to somebody else, and it's also a terrible injustice to this woman who's

discerning religious life to hold her up as the standard by which other people are are measured. It's an injustice all around. And again, Thanksgiving can become the place of healing from those disordered ways of of relating. I hope that's of help to you, Gabriel. I think he he put the question this way. Should I let go or should I pursue this relationship? And I think what you're offering

is like there's a third option here. And it, it leans toward the letting go, but with a heart that is not rejecting of the past experience. It is it is a a a letting go that involves just the the the place of sincere appreciation, but also knowledge that the Lord has a plan for your life and for her life.

And if it is only that your intersection of your lives was that brief time to be and at peace with that and to be grateful for that and to, you know, allow the seeds that that planted in your life to grow at their own pace, you know, and not to hurry that like I have, you have experienced a profound change in your life, Gabriel, like from your your story and the direction you were headed before you came to college and,

and the the new direction that your life has taken. It's awesome. It's the power of God in your life and it's so exciting. And it would be tragic if one of the great gifts of God in your life caused you not to continue on the, the forward path that the Lord has set you on. Because you're kind of stuck in a little mental swirl or, I don't know, like cycle of just reflecting on that aspect of

your journey without it just kind of sending you to the next phase in your growth in love with the Lord and in love with doing his will and finding joy in that. So I, I just, I want to rejoice in all that the Lord has already done in your life and encourage you to, as Christopher was saying, it's that it's that third option of reflecting with gratitude and allowing it to, to be a, a force for your growth

that you continue to need. And that's OK. Like it's OK to need growth. We all do. I still do, you know that's OK. I'm going to go out on a limb here and, and just comment on one other thing he said. He described before he came to faith that he was involved in many sinful relationships. And you helped me to understand this, Wendy, years ago when when you and I were starting to date and fell in love and got engaged and I had been in a a

relationship in my my teenage years that I had just kind of written off at this point in my life in my early 20s, after I came to a deeper faith, I kind of wrote it off as that was sinful. Well, yeah, there were sinful aspects of it, but there were really good aspects of it too. And, and I wonder if in in Gabriel's life, there's a that was painful. So I'm just going to put that in that category over there and, and try to try to forget it and

move on. And I, I kind of see that with this woman who's discerning religious life. Should I just forget it? And I think he, he may have done this also with these other relationships by labeling them sinful relationships. Now, don't get me wrong, I know there was sin involved in those relationships, but I don't think you should label the whole relationship sinful relationship. It's more complex than that. We, we are wheat and weeds that grow together. And eventually, Gabriel, I don't know if this is the season to do it, but eventually in your life, the Lord might bring memories of

those other relationships back to you and say, OK, let's discern together where the weeds were. Let's be clear about where the weeds were. But don't think there weren't also some real stocks of wheat growing there. And maybe the Lord wants to show you the wheat there too, so you don't write off the whole thing. And you can also be grateful for those past relationships, for the wheat that was part of it and how the Lord reached you even there, even there. Just holding that out.

I know I'm going out on a limb a little bit, but thought it was worth mentioning. Bless you brother. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Hello, Christopher and Wendy. I've been married for 21 years. On our honeymoon, my husband suffered an injury that made sexual intercourse extremely difficult and eventually impossible for him. We have seen doctors for treatments that were unsuccessful and very

embarrassing for my husband. In time we realized it was not going to get better and it hasn't. By God's grace, we were able to have one child, but marital relations between us have not been possible for over 17 years. God bless you, God bless you, God bless you. My heart aches and longs for this affection from my husband, but I long ago accepted the fact that our marriage is celibate and always will be. In the early days, we fought

about this all the time, mostly because he avoided physical contact with me so as not to arouse himself and I felt very rejected. He's never really liked to talk about this as he finds it very difficult to share his emotions. I used to pressure him to talk, but I've learned that that just isn't his way. I've also learned to see the many other ways that my husband loves me through his acts of service and dedication to our family. He is a wonderful husband and we love each other deeply.

Our strongest connection is our Catholic faith. I experienced a very deep conversion back to my Catholic faith a few years after our marriage, and this has helped me to mature and grow a deep intimacy with God. Even though I have that intimacy with God, I still at times feel so very alone with this cross, and I've spent most of my marriage feeling as though my husband doesn't desire me, as if he doesn't miss the intimacy because he won't share his pain with me. I've recently begun reading a

book, The Cantata of Love, a commentary on the Song of Songs. The imagery in the poem is so beautiful and it has reawakened in me again the feelings of how much I miss my husband. This part of me I mostly shut down because it's too painful to keep revisiting those unmet desires. Feels a bit like why torture yourself by reading this? At the same time, I realized that the poem is also an allegory of the love between the bridegroom and the bride, Jesus and my soul. I wonder if you have any

experience with people in similar situations and what has helped them? Wow. My dear sister, my dear sister, what a cross you have carried. I, I, I'm tasting the weight of it and I feel honored that you have entrusted such a tender, tender, painful place in your heart to, to, to us. And I know I, I can't possibly

do justice in this format on a podcast, but I hope I can can speak a few words to your heart that may, may point you in a, in a direction that will serve you. Lord, please guide our reflections. So tender golly, I want to talk about that book you're reading, Cantata of Love. I'm very familiar with it. I've read it more than once.

I have major underlines and highlights and stars in the margin. And I use it in my course Theology, the Body Level 2, where we we enter into the Song of songs. It's a beautiful book. I'd recommend it to anybody who's interested in in getting a modern commentary on the Song of Songs that draws from all the greats throughout history, the Saints have written more commentaries on the Song of Songs than any other book in the Bible. Why? Why? Because they understood just

what this questioner understood. As she said, it's it's not only the love poetry of a man and a woman, a husband and a wife. It is that. But this love poetry is a beautiful, beautiful allegory or analogy or even a kind of Sacramento entering into the mystery of Christ the bridegroom, and his love for His bride, the church.

It can be very, very painful, as she has described well, to feel this longing for union with the bridegroom and realize this is not possible in our marriage because of her husband's injury. And it stirs all the pain of their history, the arguments they had, his shutting down, her shutting down, not being able to talk about it. Frustrations, anxieties, grief

and loss. All of that gets stirred, certainly for you as as the bride reading this beautiful love poetry of a husband and wife. But I think you're you're on the right path. I sensed hope in your words when you said, but I also know this is an image of Christ's love for the church. So isn't there something here for me, even though I can't experience this with my earthly husband? Isn't there also something here for me as as a bride, as a

woman? But how do I enter in? Should I enter in? Can I enter in? And then the fear comes back and she said I mostly just shut it down because I can just feel all of it. I understand why you shut it down. My encouragement, my dear sister, with great reverence for all that you have endured, my encouragement would be be not afraid to open that up to your heavenly Bridegroom, Jesus

Christ. One of my favorite lines in the New Testament is when you pray, go in your inner room and close the door. My dear sister, this is my invitation to you. And if it's, if you hear the Lord in it, go with it. My sense is the Lord is inviting you into your inner room with the door closed. And the inner room is also another way of describing the bridal chamber, right? That sense of the bridal

chamber, that place of safety, that place where I am alone with the Lord. This is a quote from Pope Benedict the 16th. He says when the Christian prays, and we could add here whether the Christian knows this or not, but when the Christian prays, the Christian is seeking nuptial union with the Lord. Pope Benedict the 16th said that. John Paul the Second said this.

We have a duty to show the modern world the depth to which the relationship with Christ can lead. It can lead into the depth of prayer in a dialogue of love, a dialogue of love. I I'll return to that in a minute. It can lead in this dialogue of love through prayer as we embrace, yes, painful purifications, but this dialogue of love and prayer leads us to the ineffable joy of what the Mystics called nuptial union

with the Lord. Nuptial union. I believe in this inner chamber, this bridal chamber. Go in your inner room and close the door when you pray. I believe you are called to this dialogue of love where you open these buried pains in your heart to the Lord, where you open your longing for the affection of a husband to the Lord.

Where you open the frustration towards your husband that he, he, he's not so good at communicating the things of his heart and he hasn't been able to talk about these things. And that has caused you pain, that you open that in this dialogue of love to the Lord. Because guess what? Your heavenly Bridegroom knows how to share his heart, knows how to speak his own emotions, knows how to give voice to them, knows how to communicate them to your heart.

And guess what else? He knows your husband's heart. He knows where the blocks are. He knows where the pains are. And he may well want to show you them to give you a deeper compassion for your husband and to encourage you as your husband's main intercessor, to offer all that you have suffered in your marriage to Jesus, the Bridegroom, who will offer it with you to the Father. For the work of a mighty

redemption in your husband's life that brings, God willing, a softening of his heart, a piercing of his heart where the contents are able to come out. And the two of you couldn't, could embrace in in tears just for what you have been through together. And, and you could, God willing again, it's not going to come easily, but I can speak from my own marriage. When do you have become this beautiful intercessor for me? And it has enabled my own heart

to open up. It has enabled me to get more in touch with my own heart, the good, the bad, the ugly, the beautiful. And it's, it's, it's become the ground for a deeper intimacy in our own marriage. As you've entered into those painful places of prayer for me, for which I am forever grateful. That is to say, just sharing that little bit of our story is to say it's real. It's real when we enter that path of intercession where we offer the pain that another has caused us as prayer, as

intercession. It bears fruit. It bears fruit. It's not a quick fix, man. It took years, Wendy, for you, for your prayers to bear their fruit in my life. And there's still places where fruit is yet to be borne from your prayers. For me, that's just the way it works. We're we're committed to the long haul as a husband and wife. We need the span of a lifetime for married love to bear its fruit. That's why marriage is a lifetime. We need a lifetime for married love to bear its fruit. But you are not wrong, my dear

sister, to imagine that there is a path with the Lord where that yearning your of your heart as a bride for union with the bridegroom can be fulfilled. And if that sounds weird to any listener out there, it's only because you're unfamiliar with the mystical tradition of the Church that that you're unfamiliar with the whole tradition of the Church's reflection on the Song of Songs. Why do the Saints love the Song

of Songs so much? Why have they written more commentaries on the Song of Songs than any other book in the Bible? Because they see that beautiful erotic imagery, that sacred holy love song, the love of husband and wife, as the proper and most fitting language to give voice to their own experience of union with the Lord in prayer. Nuptial union. When the Christian prays, the Christian is seeking nuptial union with the Lord.

If that is a jarring image. If that is a fearful image, it's just an indication it shouldn't surprise us. We're in need of purification. We're in need of healing in our own hearts. These are such sensitive, tender places in our hearts. Blessed are the pure of heart, for they shall see God. The union of husband and wife in the marital act is a great mystery, Saint Paul tells us, and it refers to Christ and the Church.

John Paul the 2nd St. John Paul the Second says that that passage where Saint Paul links the intimate embrace of husband and wife in the marriage bed with the way Christ loves His Church and the way the Church loves Christ. John Paul the Second says that linking of those two unions brings us to the very compendium, the Summa and the Compendium of all of Scripture. The summary, the summing up of

the whole Script, Scriptural message. He says it is this that God wishes to tell us above all in His Word. What is it that God wants to tell us above all in His Word? He wants to be in relationship with us That is so intimate that the Scripture compares it with the marital embrace. The whole Bible in five words is God wants to marry us. God wants to be 1 flesh with us and it happened sacramentally in the Eucharist.

Trying to sum up my thoughts here. I know I've shared a lot and, and Wendy, I want to I want to give you time to share what you want to share because I know it's going to be beautiful. But there is a path, my dear sister, in in your painful cross that you are carrying. There is a path to true nuptial union, nuptial union with Christ, the bridegroom. And it comes through what Saint Augustine described as the marriage bed of the cross, the

celibacy that you have needed to embrace unwittingly in your marriage because of this injury has taken you directly to the marriage bed of the cross. And there are new fruits to be received from being with Jesus on that marriage bed. I'd, I'd also invite you in the, in the intimacy of your prayer when you close the door and you're alone with the Lord. I'm sure there's pain and, and the deep, deep question of why,

Lord, did you allow this injury on our honeymoon when we're meant to be at the very beginning of marital joy in our lives? You allowed this. Why, Lord, why, why, why, why? Why? Don't be afraid of that question. You're entering right into the prayer of Christ on the cross. Why, Why, Oh God, why, why? If, if anybody ever says you should never say why to the Lord, your response should be why. The Lord himself said why to the

Lord do not be afraid to enter into that why you will find a profound intimacy with Jesus there. I could say more, but I I'm just going to pause there and and pass it to you, Wendy. I just, I hear in this questioner just a maturity that is beautiful and not to be taken for granted. You know, she is even in all

that she shared about struggles, she's also sharing about a journey of faith. That is such a sign of hope for every listener, especially those who are in very early stages of their marriage, who who don't have that perspective that she has. That is so just. I just hear wisdom. Yeah, I do too. And I, I am blessed by your story. I really am. I, I don't, of course, I would

not wish such sufferings on any marriage, but I'm blessed by seeing God's faithfulness. And it's kind of even the feeling that it's imperfect. You know, there is of course you long for many things to have been handled differently by your husband than than what he was able to express both in physical affection and in conversation. Of course that's painful.

It is and it continues to be. I know that. But I, I just want to thank you for your testimony of God's grace in a real painful human story. And I feel so like it's our place to say, read that book. Read it like I don't know how it came into your life. I don't know if it was recommended. I don't know how you opened it. It took courage to open it, considering your story. But I I think it is just the

next step of a beautiful life, a really beautiful life. And keep going. That's what I feel. I feel that too. And I was so struck by her readiness to affirm her husband in the midst of all those sufferings to be able to say, but he's, I still see he's such a good man and such a good husband to me. Wow. Wow. That's a sign of the presence of the Holy Spirit. The Lord does not promise that we are not going to suffer.

In fact, He promises that we are. He promises that we are going to suffer. He says I must go to Jerusalem, suffer greatly, be rejected, be killed and then raised. And then he says a few lines later, follow me. Hello, hello, hello. Married life is the vowed commitment to follow the Lord through his sufferings. And we can never know in advance

the crosses the Lord will allow, but we can trust that in the crosses the Lord allows, He will be with us there and it will be salvific. I don't remember what saying it was, but I read this recently a St. who said we will praise God eternally for all of our crosses, big and small, and we will even wish there had been more. We will even wish we had embraced them with more trust

because of the fruits that we now see the Lord bore in our lives that have eternal ramifications. That's what faith teaches us. That's where I'm planting my flag and and Wendy, I, I thank you for planting your flag with me in that same soil. And thank you to this questioner for sharing the real cross of your life. This is where we learn what self giving love is. It's on the cross that the fulfillment of Christ's words are are expressed. This is my body given for you.

We are gift. We are gift and and that gift comes through suffering and every day of our lives we must cry out. Lord, give us the grace. To become what we are to. Become that gift in the world. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is

helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Christopher West Host Feed-stated
  • Wendy West Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    πŸ”οΈ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    πŸ”οΈ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    πŸ”οΈ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode