Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

What Is a Soul, Premature Ejactulation & Moral Qualm, Should I Risk Rejection for Love? | ACW372

Feb 16, 202653 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

-This episode is sponsored by Truthly- Questions answered this episode: How do you put into words what a soul is, especially when explaining it to a child in light of theology of the body - that our bodies and souls are both important and are meant to be together in heaven one day? I struggle with premature ejaculation and, despite years of sincere effort in marriage, haven’t found a real solution. I want to be a true gift to my wife, but this makes it hard for her to reach climax and leaves me ashamed, even though she’s loving and supportive. Most advice is secular and recommends “edging,” which feels morally wrong. I’m stuck between wanting help and staying faithful to Church teaching. Are there faithful resources or approaches you’d recommend? I’m a sophomore who recently ended my first relationship with a Catholic convert I met at the Newman Center. After two painful months, he broke up with me, taking the blame and telling me to pray. Since then, daily Mass and prayer have changed my heart. I realize I made him an idol and have surrendered this to God. I feel called to apologize and try again, but he asked for time. Should I move on or risk rejection and seek his forgiveness? Resources: Colorado Ski Retreat with Christopher Word Made Fresh Podcast on YouTube Word Made Fresh Podcast on Spotify Video: What It Means to Love God With "All Your Soul" --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Our faithful listeners know that I've been of late sharing with you guys an app called Truthly. Truthly. We've entered into a partnership with Truthly. I believe in what they're doing. They believe in what we're doing. And our audience who is familiar with asking questions about the Catholic faith, you guys should really know about this app called Truthly. TRUTHLY faithful to the Magisterium, rooted in

scripture, thinking with the mind and heart of the Church. You can go on truthfully and ask any question about the Catholic faith and you'll get an Orthodox answer using all the technology of artificial intelligence and putting it to very good use. I've been using Truthfully just to poke around and see what kind of answers they come up when when I type in certain questions and I've been impressed. I've been impressed. They're doing good stuff and I think it is definitely worth our just shouting out to our audience and say give it a try.

You can get a 7 day free trial by just going to wherever you get your apps, the Google Play Spot if you're an Android person, or go to the App Store on the iPhone and learn more about what the good folks are doing at Truthfully. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Hey, Wendy.

Yeah. Do you remember that cartoon when we were kids? Chilly Willy the Penguin. Yeah, I'm chilly Willy the Penguin. I wonder why I'm chilly all the I'm not wondering why I'm chilly all the time because we are dealing with record, almost record-breaking cold streak here in Pennsylvania. I just looked it up, said we haven't had this long of a cold streak since 1979 when I was 10 years old.

How about that? 01979 I remember there was a Blizzard, there was heavy snow. Yeah, yeah. OK. Well, we haven't gotten as heavy snow, but we are freezing. Yeah, it's cold and it. Is cold and our listeners probably know those who listen a lot that we record our podcast in your office and it's not always so warm not. Always. So we do have a heater going, 2 heaters actually, and Wendy is has a little electric heating pad under her feet, a winter

coat and blanket wrapped up. I'm Naked right now as a penance. Good thing this is just an audio. Podcast. Exactly. Exactly. Sorry to put that thought in people's heads. I am not naked. I have a Speedo on. I am. Why do these things come to my head and then I say them because you're silly. OK, Moving right along. We have been enjoying thoroughly

watching the Olympics. I don't know how many people out there are, like into the Olympics. Wendy and I. Oh, my gosh. My water is frozen in my office, my water bottle. OK. Wendy and I are. Are we really love watching the Olympics? We were watching some figure skating the other night and we were, we both were tearing up like tears streaming down our cheeks. Just the beauty. I was thinking, you can share what you were thinking, Wendy, but I was thinking of the sacrifices that these people

made so that we could behold such beauty and excellence. And I absolutely love seeing the male and the female form expressing themselves so gracefully and beautifully on the ice. It's it just awakens all of my love for God creating us, male and female. So beautiful. Yeah, me too. One time years ago a a a priest actually gave me as a penance to

to watch some couples figure skating and imagine that was Jesus skating with me. Like as a way of just encouraging me to. Oh, I like that. Experience his beautiful love for me. So yeah, that that definitely got stirred in my heart as we were watching. Thank you, Lord, for that priest. Yeah, yeah, really beautiful. Well, we hope others are enjoying the Olympics as well. And I'm wondering, do you have any updates for us from the TV

and. I do. Speaking of winter sports, guess what I have to talk about? I don't know, could it be ski? Ski Retreat Ski Retreat March 9th to the 13th. We still have beds left in this amazing mountain estate that Jason Everett's organization called the JP 2 Trails and he does these outdoor adventures including ski retreats with Christopher West.

We have rented this amazing mountain ski estate thing. It sleeps 30 people. There are some beds left. So come, come, come. And if you're thinking, well, I don't not going to know anybody on well, you know me, that's true. Or just bring a friend or bring your spouse and you're thinking, I've never skied before. Well, guess what, you can take some ski lessons. We're going to be at mountains that have ski lessons so you can

do all that too. So come learn how to ski. If you haven't skied, if you're a skier like I am, you can join me on the black diamonds in the mogul runs. We're going to have all our meals together. We're going to be stay in this house together. It's going to be a beautiful, beautiful experience. We're ski during the day and we're going to be reflecting on love and responsibility in the evening. I just decided that like, that's what I'm going to do. Love it. That's good. Yeah, because Love and responsibility is one of my favorite, favorite works of Ji Mean. Of course, I've given my whole life to theology of the body,

but love and responsibility is the philosophical, philosophical foundation. I was about to say the philosophical, that's not a word. The Philosophical Foundation for John Paul 2 theology of the body, which I love almost as much as I love theology body. You know this is just a little reflection from someone who sits and records podcasts. With you. I would say over maybe the last two years in a particular way, like I don't know if you were like re re studying love and responsibility. I just feel like it has really

been, I don't know, an important part of just how how the Lord is has made things clear to you and enabled you to share it with others. And I just think that's really beautiful. Yeah, well, it was three years ago. Was it 3 years ago that that I took over teaching the Love and Responsibility course? OK, so that's Jeanette Clark. And I, I just dove in again as I was designing the study guide for that course and, and I was pulling Nuggets out of it that yeah, I had, I had studied it,

read it many, many times. Not many, many. I probably read it 3 or 4 times in the 90s. And I would revisit it again and again throughout the years. But I had, I, it was in 2023 that I really devoted myself anew to it. So yeah, you have been noticing that correctly. All right, well, that's a beautiful thing to look forward to, those who are going to go skiing. Was there anything else you wanted to update us? On there was I wanted to point people to the new podcast that we're offering at the TOB

Institute called The Word Made Fresh. Mike Mangione and Bill Donaghy and I3 guys, 2 theologians and two artists. Gee, how does that work? Right, there's an overlap. Oh. One of the theologians is also an artist, and I guess I'm an artist in my own way and Mike is a theologian in his own way. So guess what? We have 3 theologians and three artists reflecting on life, culture, music, movies, art,

day-to-day experiences of being husbands and fathers. And we're just trying to help our listeners and our viewers. Because it's a video podcast. You can watch it on YouTube or you can listen wherever you listen to podcasts. And we are just helping people see the world sacramentally. We're making the word fresh, hence the title. Check it out. We have a link in the show notes. Awesome. Are you ready now for a question from Patron? Let's do it. This is a question from a patron

named Kelsey. Kelsey, thank you so much for believing in our mission and supporting us. We're so grateful to you. How do you put into words what a soul is? Oh boy. Especially in explaining it to a child in light of theology of the body, that our bodies and souls are both important and are meant to be together in heaven one day. Can you read that that second-half again? Because I my brain was already drifting away to how am I going to answer this question and it's.

A short enough question. Let me just read it and you don't interrupt. OK, here we go. Here we go. This is from Kelsey. How do you put into words what a soul is, especially in explaining it to a child in light of theology of the body? That our bodies and souls are both important and are meant to be together in heaven one day. Yeah, I've actually been spending a decent chunk of time researching this question and writing about it. I mean, I've been doing that for 30 years. It's not a new idea to me, but

I'm writing a new book on AI. It's not so much on AI as it is what is a person? How do we maintain our humanity in the midst of an AI world? And I'm looking first at the philosophical truth of what it means to be a person, and then theological reality of what it means to be a person. And doing research on the philosophy section of the book, I've dug back into Plato and Aristotle and the history of

this word soul. And interestingly enough, a lot of people don't know this. We think of the soul as as a religious idea, but it's a philosophical idea. The church borrowed the language from the Greeks to speak about body and soul. And people might say, well, what do? What do you mean the soul is used in the body or, excuse me, the soul is used in the Bible throughout and OK, true in your English Bible, it's going to say soul hundreds of times, both in the Old Testament and the New,

the New Testament written in Greek. That's a proper, you know, translation. But in the Old Testament written in Hebrew, the word that gets translated, soul is, is not, it's, it's, it's a, it's an unfortunate translation. The Hebrew mind did not think in terms of body and soul. It just thought in terms of the whole reality of the person. And I was about to say body and soul. But again, I'm inserting language here that comes from the Greeks.

The the, the, the understanding of the, the Hebrew understanding of the human person was 1 entity that was physical, yes, and spiritual. So how do we explain all this to to children? I think we get, we invite children to reflect on the fact that they experienced the world from within. First we encounter the world

with our senses, right? Smelling, hearing, seeing, touching. But then we all know that what we experienced through our senses goes inside of us to another. How do we even put it in words I was about to say to another place or another dimension, another realm of experience where we think about things, we ponder them in our hearts, we feel things we desire things

that are beyond the merely physical realm. Right. Depending on the age of your children, you could ask them to reflect on how the their encounter with the physical world leads them to reflections about meaning, about beauty, about love. Even a young child understands he wants to be loved. He wants to be affirmed, he wants to be blessed.

And when mom and dad smile at that child and run up to embrace that child and squeeze that child, that they're not just feeling things physically, but it goes to a deeper place. And we use language like the heart, it goes to the heart. And isn't that interesting? We use the word heart, which is a physical organ in our chest, but we use that to point to a deeper spiritual reality, the spiritual soul.

So I would just invite as a parent, I would invite your, your children to reflect with you on those deeper experiences, how the physical experience of being hugged leads to this warm feeling on the inside, right. There's another just use of words to try to get us to a, a deeper place. Something we experience on the outside leads us to an experience on the inside that's warm, that's happy, that feels

good. Well, that's not just blood throwing flowing through your veins, that that's an experience of the spiritual dimension of our humanity, of our spiritual soul. But we are a unity. We feel at 1st through the senses, the physical senses. The physical senses lead us to these spiritual experiences, these spiritual senses, and they're again confirmed in our experience is the unity of the body and the soul. There's a long, long history of reflection both in philosophy,

beginning with Plato and Aristotle moving into theology, eventually formulated in such a way by Thomas Aquinas that for the last 800 years the, the, the lodestar here, the, the guiding star, the, the, the, the cream of the, not cream of the crop. That's not what I want to say. But the, the, the pinnacle, the pinnacle of theological expression here is Saint Thomas Aquinas in the way he took the philosophy of philosophy of Aristotle. And Aristotle was displeased,

unsatisfied with Plato's approach to the relationship of body and soul. Plato. He never said the body was evil, as later Christian heretics would do. Plato did not consider the body evil, but he certainly considered it lesser and and he thought the soul was this higher reality. And when we die, the the soul is liberated from the prison of the body. This is not Christianity, although some many people think it is Christianity.

No, no, no, no, no. That is Platonism. Aristotle was not pleased with that. He said no, no, the, the, the body's not the prison of the soul. The soul informs the body. The soul gives the body form. The soul is what makes a human body a human person. And, and there is a much more integral understanding in Aristotle of body and soul. But but Aristotle, uniting body and soul so beautifully and profoundly, had a difficult time understanding what happened at

death. Don't we serve? Doesn't there some aspect of our humanity that survives death? Thomas Aquinas took the idea of the soul living beyond the body that we get from Plato, but also understanding the integral unity of body and soul that he got from Aristotle. Thomas Aquinas said something to inform his understanding here that neither Plato nor Aristotle had, and that is the incarnation and the death and resurrection of Jesus, which led Thomas

Aquinas to articulate the idea that the soul is separated from the body at death. But this is not human, this is not normal, this is not natural. The the souls that are in heaven now are in an inhuman state until the resurrection of the body. The resurrection of the body is not a dispensable extra, as Peter Craif says, when the 2 are

separated, we have a freak, we have a monster. This is why we are afraid both of ghosts and corpses, although they are the harmless realities of of separation. The death is not harmless, but the body and the soul are harmless, right? Even when they're separated. But we're freaked out by this. This is the stuff of our of our horror movies, ghosts and corpses. Why horror movies? Because we are horrified at the

prospect of death. We are horrified at the separation of body and soul as we should be and Peter Craif says This is why Jesus wept at Lazarus grave, not only 'cause he was sad that a friend died, but he. But because of the cosmic obscenity of the separation of body and soul never meant to happen, souls in heaven now are longing for the reunion of their body and soul. How do you teach this to children? Well, you, you, you, you just help them understand their own experience of the integral reality of their body and their

soul. That when when somebody kicks them in the shin on the playground being mean, it doesn't just hurt their shin, it hurts them on the inside. It hurts their feelings, it hurts their heart, it hurts their emotions. Why? If we were just a soul trapped in a body, then it would just hurt your shin. It wouldn't hurt your heart, wouldn't hurt you on the inside. Why does it hurt on the inside? Because we're a unity of body and soul. Help them to understand that experience. Help them to to enter into that experience and and affirm that

experience in them. And when the time comes to teach about the afterlife and the separation of body and soul at death and the ultimate reunion of body and soul in the resurrection, they will have a context for welcoming that as very good news because they will understand their humanity as an integral unity of body and soul. It's just some food for thought. I'm thrown out there. One of the thing was occurring to me, that story in Genesis of God forming the the man from the

dust to the ground or clay of the earth and then breathing the breath of life into that. Just it kind of feels like it's a story that we want to share with our children anyway and if we are wanting to. You know, explain the soul in the in the Hebrew. You didn't say what is a better translation of the word that gets translated soul. I I feel like as you were saying it's it's the whole unified

person. I've heard it described as just the life. Yes, life. Life would be Life would be a better JP 2 says in the theology of the body, the Bible doesn't make so much this distinction of body and soul, but rather body and life. And it's not so much a distinction as it is just as Scripture says, the in breathing of life into the body. So yes, that that would be a better a better translation

life. Yeah, so I, it, it could just be a, a gift to children to in to pause when sharing that Bible story and, and just think about that our entire being is gift from God because it's his forming. God is taking the earth and creating the body and it the life is coming from his breath. So I, I don't know if if I'm

articulating it in the theological or philosophical way, but just in thinking about, about the journey of children, I think those images can be really powerful in both reflecting that there's something different between a living body and a corpse, as you said, and but that all of that is good and intended to be together by God's beautiful plan for us.

Well said Wendy and I I should have mentioned the Hebrew word here that gets translated Seoul is nephesh and I will have a link in the show notes to a video that I show my students when they come to the TOB one course that talks about nephesh and and why it is not why Seoul is not the best translation of that that Hebrew word. It's a great video. It's 4 or 5 minutes long. It'll, it'll take you on quite a

journey. And whenever I show this to my students, they're like, Oh my gosh, that is so helpful because we have inherited this platonic understanding of body and soul, that the soul is trapped in our bodies like a prison. And when we see the real meaning of nephesh, this biblical word, I think, yeah, check out this video. It it'll really, really help you understand what a human being is. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Thank you for the massive impact

your ministry has had on my life. Oh, bless you, bless. You the theology of the body has truly changed me. My question is about the struggle in my marriage. I deal with premature ejaculation and despite being married for several years and making sincere efforts, I haven't found a real solution. I desire to be a true gift to my wife, but this ongoing issue often makes it very difficult for her to reach climax during the marital embrace. This has been a source of shame

and discouragement for me as a man, even though my wife is loving, supportive, and accepts me as I am. Most of the resources I find are secular. The most common and supposedly effective recommendation seems to be something called quote edging, meaning learning to regulate arousal through intentional self stimulation without climax in order to retrain the body. This puts me in a moral bind. I know masturbation is wrong,

but I feel stuck when the proposed solution conflicts with church teaching. I've wondered whether anything like this could be done together with my wife without climax, but I suspect this also crosses moral lines. Are there any resources or approaches you would recommend when common advice doesn't align with our beliefs? Bless you, good brother, bless you good brother. Thank you for entrusting your heart, your suffering, all

exhibited in this very honest, very real question. Bless you, bless you, bless you. I just want to affirm you, brother, I thank you for reaching out and I do think I can shine a light that you will find helpful. Bless you also for your fidelity to the church's teaching you. You want to be a true man. You want to be a true husband. You want to be a true gift to your wife.

And I just want to commend you. You're you're a beautiful man. Yes, you are right to say that self stimulation to retrain your body. It sounds to me like I had never heard this concept of what you called edging. Never heard that before, but I'm understanding it that you are the. The secular approach is retrain your body by learning how to stimulate your body without achieving climax so that you can maintain intercourse without

ejaculation in a premature way so as to help your wife achieve climax as well. If some of you are thinking why are we talking about all this stuff on a Catholic podcast, well guess what? John Paul the second talks about this very issue in his book Love and Responsibility, where he says the husband because the husband has a a quicker curve of arousal and he even says a more violent one, violence, not here in some ugly sense of the word, but violent in in terms of it.

It comes on quick and fast and wow, there it is a more a more violent and readily aroused Physiology. It's an act of virtue on the part of the man to learn how to maintain his own body, preventing it from achieving climax too quickly so as to help bring his wife to climax with him. John Paul the second says in

love and responsibility Such tenderness in the marital act should be considered an act of virtue, an act of true Christian virtue. How Christian virtue will think about think about Christ saying love one another as I have loved you. I tell you this so that my joy might be in you and your joy might be complete. Yes, he loves as the bridegroom. These bodily realities of the

marital embrace are are signs of a deep spiritual reality. Saint Paul says the union of man and woman in one flesh is a great mystery and it refers to Christ in the Church. Every detail of it, every physical detail of the marital act as God intends it points to a spiritual counter reality, a counterpoint in the spiritual realm. Every physical reality has a spiritual counterpoint. And and Jesus saying he wants his bride to experience joy to

the full. We can see that this is lived out in the marital embrace. Husbands, love your wives as Christ loved the Church. Yes, a husband should desire for his wife to come to the fullness of joy in the marital act. So this is a husband, everybody who wrote to us who really wants to be a good husband, who really wants to learn how to love his wife as Christ loved the church, and he's running into this physical reality. Well, my brother, I, I understand your caution in thinking well, you did pose it

initially as a question, could, could my wife help me in this regard? Could we learn together to that I could experience sexual arousal without the goal of, of achieving climax? And brother, the answer to that question is yes, this is possible. And I don't mean possible only in in a in a physical sense, it's possible in a moral sense. The intimate touching, the intimate caressing of a husband and a wife, the intimate,

intimate touching of a husband and a wife that obviously brings about sexual arousal. We are showing that we are masters of ourselves in saying this does not need to lead to sexual climax, right. There are there are many times in married life when abstaining from the sexual act, which is also to say abstaining from sexual climax, because the

sexual act, a fully completed marital embrace, that which consummates the marriage, namely, to put it delicately, the seed planted in the garden. A man's seed belongs nowhere else. A man should never being, never should be pursuing the the expelling of his seed anywhere but in the garden, right? But there are times in married life when love demands abstinence.

Maybe you have a serious reason to avoid a child. Love demands abstinence. There could be any another, any other number of reasons for love demanding abstinence. But let's just go with that. You you have a serious reason to avoid a child. It's the fertile time of the month. Love demands abstinence. Does this mean a husband and wife should never touch one another, kiss one another, caress one another, hold one another, be naked together? Oh my goodness, if, if, if, if

we think nakedness automatically means we have to have intercourse, or kissing automatically means we have to have intercourse or touching or caressing or holding each other automatically means we need to have intercourse? It does not. Freedom calls us to learn how to be intimate with one another without leading to climax, without pursuing climax, but in a way that involves some level of arousal. That's part of the marital experience, of the freedom for which Christ has has set us

free. There are some moral theologians out there who would say no. Well, if you have arousal, that has to end in intercourse. Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Where does that come from? Who said that? What, what principle is that? This is not the freedom for which Christ has set us free. I think that comes from a kind of animalistic understanding of, of, of sexuality. We are human beings. We are human persons.

We have freedom. We can gain self mastery. And my brother, I would, I would encourage you and your wife to find ways of expressing tender affection and learning in that tender affection how to master your sexual climax, how to master it. That's not going to be an easy journey. That's not going to be the 123 steps that lead you to perfect self mastery.

The catechism says sexual self mastery is a lifelong journey and it requires renewed effort at every stage of life. But yes, you could learn this with your wife. If I'm understanding correctly that the process here is 1 of intimate caressing, intimate touching that does not lead to climax and you are learning how to maintain your climax so that it doesn't happen. Or let me also say this, if you

find that it you have reached the point of no return, to put it delicately, that you would be in a situation where you could enter your wife so as not to spill your seed. If you are taking those precautionary measures so that your seed is not spilt unintentionally, you're in a you're in a safe place, you're in a sacred zone. It's OK to to learn each other's bodies in these ways, and it can

be in fact very helpful to learn each other's bodies in these ways to grow in self mastery. There's something so obviously just personal to the couple and the relationship that's being touched on here. And I know that certainly there are a whole range of different marriages that are maybe hearing these and having their own questions about how that would

look. And I, I am so drawn to a certain line in this question where this anonymous listener says, my wife is loving, supportive and accepts me as I am. And I feel like even without mentioning it, I feel like that context kind of was a guiding underlying principle in your. In the way I responding. The way you did, that's right. And you know, that is a a

beautiful sign of grace in your lives. And I just want to encourage this listener, even not as a counterpoint to your advice, you're responding to his very practical question to this listener that there are some some things about the heart level of this of your marriage that I think you need to pause and and stay with a little bit. And one of them is that your wife genuinely accepts you as

you are. And so. I just want to. Challenge you in the midst of all of this, too, to try to receive that love on a deeper level of your being that you've mentioned, that you feel shame and discouragement. Our our marital. Union is meant to be an exchange of love and an opportunity for grace. And if she is giving you that

love of her acceptance of you are. You able to receive that? Are you? Able to say Lord. In our imperfection. Your grace is abundant. Here, help me to receive the incredible grace that you're pouring out and and lift this shame. There's no need for shame here. There's no Yeah, you are loved here.

So the incredible, incredible gift that you have right now in your marriage, I believe that really also spending time working on receiving and recognizing that will bring about a certain peace that will carry over into all expressions of a marital affection. And I, I just pray that you can be freed from that sense of shame so that you can really

receive the gift of love that you can with genuine openness, talk with your wife about how she is feeling about all of this. And I, I know that we have different feelings all at the same time in our hearts. That's part of the complexity of being a human being, but to receive the genuineness of her heart that that wants to come to love you, that wants you both to be open to God's love for.

You and His grace. Poured out in your marital embrace to to really learn more about that will be a tremendous gift, I believe, and this is. Why we do this podcast together so that people can hear wisdom like that flowing from my, my wife's heart. I jumped in right into kind of the technical answer and Wendy jumped right into the level of the heart. It's so important to hold the two together. And I was presupposing you were right, Wendy. I was presupposing a certain

level of maturity in their love. That was evident from the way he he worded that. And I, I just want to also affirm what you said about, you know, every marriage has its own culture, its own inner workings. And the, the advice I'm giving to this couple, it does presuppose that there's open and honest communication. Because the the the physical aspect of what I am saying could be more, could be morally

acceptable, presupposes a a mature sharing of hearts, a mature form of communication, Because that's what it. Requires that that that. Level of intimacy, that level of of learning one another's bodies. It can't be done in silence, it can't be done in fear. It can't be done just with some technical approach to the to the workings of the body. It has to be an integral experience, a union of body and soul that the the physical

aspect and it becomes the expression of the spiritual closeness. Both are required, or you're going to have something ruptured. You're going to have something disintegrating rather than integrating. So, Wendy, thank you so much for what you shared. They're so, so important. Yeah. Our next question is from an Anonymous. Listener, I am a. Sophomore in college. And was in my first ever romantic relationship this past fall.

He was a recent Catholic convert I met through our Newman Center and our attraction and connection was quick and powerful. However, for the two months we were together, he would do things I found hurtful and I would often breakdown crying to him about these things, even if they were little. He broke. Up with me saying. That he hated hurting me and didn't want to anymore. He took all the blame on himself

and told me to pray. Now after almost two months of no contact and of me attending mass daily, praying a holy hour and rosary each day, God has completely changed my heart. I realize now that I had made him an idol in my life and the things that were quote hurting me were really just him refusing to make me an idol in his life the way I. Made him an idol in mine. After letting go and offering

our relationship to God, surrendering my entire will and life to God, I feel this desire that I do think is from God to apologize to Him, to explain that it was all my fault He. Asked for time. And I want to honor that, but he doesn't know that. I was barely even praying when we were together, I think. Things would be different. Now and I want to try again for the first time I feel like I

truly love him. But above all I want to do this on God's timeline. Do you have any thoughts on this? Should I go take the lessons I learned and apply it to a new relationship even though I love this man in a new way? Or should I be courageous and risk rejection and and ask for his forgiveness? Thank you for any insight you have. Bless you, dear sister. Gosh, this is a powerful working of grace in your life. I I want.

To affirm. My dear sister, flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but your Father in heaven who loves you. We don't come up with this stuff. You don't accuse yourself of that kind of idolatry and you don't figure out just because you thought really hard, oh, this is what was going on. This is a light in your life that came from the earnestness and sincerity of your prayer. And I, I just want to affirm

that good on you, dear sister, for seeking the Lord's face. This is exactly what we do when we're facing heartache and exactly what we do when we're wrestling with questions of the soul. We we turn to the Lord in prayer and he can and he does speak to our hearts and you have heard him and he is speaking. I really believe that this the the key for me in realizing, oh, she's getting a light here was and maybe you could read this again, Wendy, where she says I I

realized I had made an idol of him and I the pain that I felt was that I wanted him to make an idol of me too. How did she put that? Yeah, I had. I had made an idol in I'm sorry. I had made him an. Idol in my life and the things that were hurting me were really just him refusing to make me an idol in his life. OK, that reminds me of an. Experience you and I had Wendy, or maybe I just had it. You had it from your

perspective. I had it from my perspective. This was my perspective. We were. It was the day after our first date, OK. And. You had had this desire for me to date you for like 3 years. Oh, I know what you're going to share, right? And. And my. My. Perspective was oh, she's she's wanted to date me for three years. I finally asked her out on a date from my background and the way I had kind of been in a

relationship that was enmeshed where where we didn't know how to give each other proper space and boundaries and stuff. I'm just projecting onto you. Oh, she's had this thing for me for three years. She's going to want to spend all her time with me. She's coming down from New Jersey and she's going to want to spend every hour of every day with me. And, and you had you had plans the next day with some other friends. And I was a little what? Wait, wait, no, I want, I'm going to take you out on another date.

I'm going to pack a picnic. I'm going to come meet you. And you're like, well, OK, but but OK. But after I have time with my other friends and and this was this was a wake up call for me. Like oh. I this is a different way to relate to. Somebody. This is not this invitation for two people to be enmeshed in each other's worlds in a, in a, in a funky way, the way I had experienced relationships in the past. And another way to say the very

same thing is this. I was used to being made an idol of in relationships, and I was used to idolizing the women in relationships I had been in. And that's what you do when you have an idol. You worship it and you want to you, won't you? It becomes enmeshed in an unhealthy way. And I realized Wendy is you've. Had these feelings for. Me for three years, but it wasn't on that level of you had made an idol of me, but I was

already expecting that you would and and I could have been hurt. I I was I. Used the word miffed. I was miffed because it was different, but I also not that I lived this perfectly because I've been through many purification since that were still required as you know well. But it was a good eye opener for me and a good lesson for me in realizing you. You weren't making an.

Idol of me in that way and and had I gone down a different path, not just being miffed but being hurt, I wasn't hurt by it. I, I could have been if I had demanded that you make an idol of me. And there were ways in which in our married life it did play out that I wanted you to make an idol of me. And I had made an idol of you. And we, we had to work that out over many years. And now we're perfect. That was a little. Joke. That was a joke.

We're not perfect. No, we are. We are. We are still working out all our crapola because because we got so much crapola, as everybody does, that it takes a lifetime to work it out. And if you're out there thinking I don't have any crapola to work out, well, there's your crapola to work out right there. You think you don't have any? Start with that. What is my point? In all of this. My point in all of this is when you said that I realized that my pain, what I was considering hurts, was really.

The fact that. I had made an idol of him and he wasn't making an idol of me. And you took that to prayer, and you receive this light, and now you're in. A new place in your. Heart, I think a beautiful new place and you're asking us should I should I take the risk of sharing this with this man I haven't had contact with him since we broke up and he said he needed space well here's my advice because you're asking my advice so I'm going to give you my advice I don't have anybody else's advice to give you I

would say take the. Risk. And reach out to him because something has shifted in your heart. And I think this guy is going to be blessed by hearing this. And I would preface it by saying, you know, maybe you could text him or e-mail him or whatever and just say, hey, you had. Asked for space and I. Don't want to violate that, but I want you to know that I've seen some things that were going

on in our relationship that I hadn't seen when I was in this relationship with you. And I owe you an apology. And if you would be willing, I would like to offer you that apology. See what he says to that. And then I would hope and pray that he would be ready to receive that from you. And I think it would really bless him 'cause he might not have the language to articulate what was going on, but we have intuitions, you know, he felt it. He felt it going on whether he had the language for it or not. And your acknowledgement of

that, I think will just be a blessing for him. So I would say yes, take the chance, risk that and reach out to him. And, and not to get re enmeshed. That's probably why he wanted space 'cause he felt, you know, men feel it. We, we call it getting hooked. You know, when a, when a, when a girl is after us, she like sinks her hooks into us or sinks her claws into us and we want to shake that off. You're like, get that off of me. I think that's probably why he wanted space. But if and if he feels you're coming back for another hook in

there or another sink your claw into him, he's going to resist. But if you say, you know, I really need to apologize to you for some things, I think he's going to be very open to hearing that and it will be very helpful for him to hear that. So I say go for it. I I. Actually agree, I do think the the question of whether she should reach out to him, I think it's a yes. I think this light that she's received is an important one, especially for the asking for forgiveness, the seeing her own

way of having hurt him that doesn't. Necessarily. Mean that he will receive it perfectly. Sometimes we can just be in our little world of like, oh, I see this now and you know, sometimes other people don't react to. Things the way I've. Received all your apologies perfectly. Wendy OK. And I've always given. Apologies. Perfectly. So I'm just saying I'm pointing that. Out because as much as it blessed your heart to hear what

she was realizing, we can't project what place he's in he. Will feel the same, so we don't. Know but so to offer an apology is is appropriate and to let him process it in whatever way he needs to is also appropriate to respect his freedom. And when she says I love this man in a new way, I'm sure there's the romantic attraction is contained in that. I hope there's also a sense of that.

What John Paul the second calls disinterested. Sorry, disinterested Tenderness meaning a. Love that. Desires his good regardless of what comes back in return. So I think all of that is is very good and right to take that action. And I think the things that you shared, you know, that you were reflecting on different experiences may be another light for her that just to say like with.

All the gratitude. For this light right now, there should also be a sense that of awareness that her own life is going to be a journey and that this type of thing may come up again. And that's OK. Yeah. So those are my thoughts. Yeah. Remember we. Had we had experienced some beautiful healings in our engagement and we thought, oh good, done with that, moving right along. Oh Lord, he love us. We have these patterns that go so deep in US and rejoice in

those healings. But don't think you've reached the top of the mountain there. Those are little lights that OK, these are probably things I'm going to have to revisit again and again because we have these inclinations that don't just go away, but the Lord's with us every step of the way. Mercy is with us every step of the way, and we do grow and we do progress. Thanks everybody for tuning. In today, I hope you were blessed by what we had to share and if you have burning questions, you're like, well

what about this and what about that? I know the AI world is not a perfect world and I'm not suggesting you're going to get perfect answers here, but Truthfully is a platform that is applying magisterial documents, the writings of the Saints to Catholic questions in this new world we live in with, with artificial intelligence. And I think it's worth trying out So, so check it out. We have a link in the show notes and they're a sponsor for our program so we want to give a shout out to them They're doing good work and yeah, let us know if you are finding Truthly

helpful 'cause we want to know that. Also, if you've been blessed by what you heard today, could you push that share button so we can expand our family of listeners? We'd be very grateful to you. You're a gift to us. It's a blessing for us to be a gift to you. Lord, please give us the grace to become what we are and. What are we? A gift. A gift. Thanks Lord, ask Christopher W

is brought. To you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode