Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Finding Beauty in a Drooling Pope, the Sexual Desire of a Single Woman, and a Widow's Exhausting Loneliness. | ACW381

Apr 20, 202652 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: As a teacher of Theology of the Body, I was presented with a picture of Pope John Paul II by a former student. Before seeing it, I hoped for an image of his younger, energetic self - skiing, hiking, or writing. However, it was a close-up of him as an elderly man, hunched in a chair. I felt a wave of disappointment, realizing I struggle to see the beauty in the entirety of life and the aging body. I know I have healing to do in my heart; how do I begin to see the whole life cycle as a gift? As a single woman, is it wrong to have sexual desires? I don’t think about men lustfully; it’s more of a deep ache to be loved, married, and have sex. At random times, I wish I had someone to hold, caress, and embrace in the marital act. My body also shows physical signs of arousal, especially during certain times in my cycle - perhaps God’s way of giving me a foretaste of the New Jerusalem. I’ve tried offering my desires to God in prayer, but I still feel this ache in my heart and body. I am 60 years old and have been a widow for eight years. My husband and I were looking forward to a new chapter of intimacy after our children moved out, but then he died. In my anger and grief, I invited a deviant sexual spirit upon myself, feeling it was ridiculous to live without sex or marriage at my age. Though I have since repented, I feel heartbroken and betrayed by God. I feel I was created to be a wife, yet I am exhausted from being alone with no mate in sight. I simply want to know: why? --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠ Resources: ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ Love & Responsibility YouTube Series

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Welcome, everybody. We're happy to be with you today. Thanks for tuning in. Yeah, we have so many faithful listeners around the world. There's something like that. Today. 95 countries or something that listen to our podcast and we've been #1 religious podcast

in multiple of these countries, which is kind of crazy what technology allows us to do in the modern world. I know can. Could you have imagined when we were kids in the 70s and 80s that that we would have in our pocket ATV that I could watch any movie anytime I wanted anywhere in the world, pretty much anywhere or or listen to

I'd have I've had I have access not only to every movie, every made, every song ever written, every album. It's right in my pocket. What? What? I would not have been able to comprehend it. And here we are. And this technology allows us to reach the whole world. It's kind of fun. It is, and it's, it's a great like it's sort of, you know, can make you smile, like with wonder and it can make you feel a little serious, like, whoa,

that's a responsibility. OK, Lord, please let that let that reach people and and bring good in their lives because you wouldn't want it any other way, or at least I wouldn't. Yeah. So just the the faces of people that we've met, you know, who've told us they listen to our podcast are in my mind and my memory and my heart. And yeah, I just feel so grateful for the opportunity to talk with, talk to different people, hear your hearts, your

questions, and, and pray that something that we are inspired to share is a blessing. It's really amazing. In my travels, Wendy, you don't, you don't get to travel the world like I do. You'll come with me on occasion. But I meet so many people who've been blessed by our podcast and in a particular way, blessed by you. You have a lot of fans around the world, but I'm just saying I'm your biggest one. Hey, thanks. You're welcome. I, I, one of the things I love

about doing this podcast with you is how much I learn from you. Just I, I do my thing and then I just sit back and listen and I know I'm going to be blessed by what you share. So thank you. Yeah. And I obviously so blessed to hear what you have to say as well. Well, having said that, I'm curious what you have to say about this. Do you have any updates from the Theology of the Body Institute for us? The theology of the Body Institute, Yeah, is what was I going to say? I forget. I think before we hit record we talked about maybe sharing with

people about the patron. Community. Oh, right, right. I knew there was something that I was supposed to share and then I just had a brain fart and it went away. Went away. OK, So my brothers and sisters, you are so generous towards us. There are so many of you out there who are patrons of the work that we do. You offer us monthly support, you know, $10 a month, $20.00 a month. Some of you are offering $100 a month or more. We honestly rely on your generosity to do the ministry

that we do. We, we can't do it without your generosity. And we are at a stage right now we have maxed out our staff in terms of what we're able to afford in terms of paying staff. And we're, we're limited in what we're able to do. Our reach is limited because our funds are limited. And if that's the way the Lord wants it for the rest of our lives. Amen to that. And we'll, we'll just make it work with that. But we have the sense that the

Lord wants us to grow. We're turning away so many projects, We're turning away so many opportunities to spread this message around the world with events, with courses, with relationships, with diocese around the world. We just have to say no so often to media projects we have visions for, for some really exciting media projects. We just, we have to say no to so much because we only have, you know, so many funds to go around.

If you are not a patron of this work, would you please prayerfully consider becoming one? If you've been blessed by the work that we do on this podcast or through our other resources or courses, please, please consider becoming a patron. I'm not here to twist your arm. I just want to invite you to ask the Holy Spirit, does the Holy Spirit want you to become a patron of this mission? I, I heard this said years ago by a, a Bishop whom I trusted quite a bit. You know, we're all called to

tithe and that means to give 10% of our income away. And he suggested 5% of that should be going to your parish, 1% of that should be going to your diocese, and the other 4% should be going to causes you believe in. So I invite you to take that up, that that should be just normal for our lives as believers. Are you supporting your parish? Are you supporting your diocese? Are you supporting causes you

believe in? If you believe in this cause, would you consider becoming a patron? If you feel that little nudge from the Holy Spirit, I only ask that you not listen to me, but listen to the Holy Spirit. There's a link in the show notes so you can learn more. A benefit of being a patron is that you get to submit questions to our podcast in a special patron page and then our very first question of each episode is from is taken from those questions. So if any of you ever wondered

why do I say here's a question from a patron be before the 1st question, That's why. That's why the it's from someone who's given to our work and submitted a question in the patron page. So. Our patrons also support our scholarship funds. We sadly have to turn away a lot of people because we just don't have the scholarship funds to support them. So that's another motivation. If if you're interested in

supporting us, that's a huge help that enables us to allow people to come to our courses who wouldn't be able to come otherwise. From a patron named Michael. All right, Michael. Thank you, Michael, for supporting this work. So grateful to you. Michael says I love Saint John Paul the Second, or at least I thought I did. I teach theology of the Body to high schoolers and one of my former students brought in a picture of John Paul the Second. As she brought it towards me,

not revealing the picture, thoughts raced through my mind of which picture I wanted it to be Pope John Paul 2 skiing, a young Father Voitiwa shaving or holding a puppy or hiking. I got excited. Then she turned it around and a sense of disappointment entered my heart. It was a close up picture of an old JP 2 hunched over sitting in a chair. In my heart, I want to see a

young JP 2. I want an energetic priest who my picture and my thoughts. Writing, theology of the body, hiking and skiing. That's who I want to see and meet in heaven. Obviously I have a lot to work through, pray with, and heal in my own heart. Because I want to see an old picture of JP 2 and think, wow, he's beautiful. I'm just not there. Where do I start to see the entirety of life and the body as

being a gift? Oh man, I love this question, Michael. Your ability even to ask the question shows you're already on a beautiful pilgrimage. Really and truly I, I mean that I, I can relate to this just immediately it, I just jump right in and I know exactly what you're saying 'cause I have the same feeling. I don't like to see those pictures of JP, too old and having gained so much weight and hunched over and sometimes even

drooling and videos where he can't form his words. And yet, and yet those final years of his pontificate when he didn't just lock himself away, he, he was still in public. He was still very visible to the world. Those final years of his pontificate were some of his most potent years, and he became a witness to us all of what it

means to age, diminish and die gracefully. And that is to die gracefully, to age gracefully, to diminish gracefully, as the word indicates, is a grace. In other words, it's not something we can just muster up. It's not something if we just read enough or if we just reflected enough or we if we just thought hard enough about

it and we just reasoned with ourselves. Well, I know the whole of life is beautiful and I know everybody ages and I know it's supposed to be beautiful. So I'm going to see it as beautiful now because I'm reasoning my way into it. No, it's a grace and a grace means a gift, a gift we must open ourselves to a gift we should pray for. And you're already doing that brother, in your question is a cry to the Lord. Lord, open my eyes and, and the eyes that need to be open are

the eyes of our of our hearts. I'm thinking of that song. Open the eyes of my heart. Lord, open the eyes of my heart. I want to see you. Can we see the beauty of the ugliest thing that ever happened on planet earth? The ugliest thing that ever happened on planet earth was the crucifixion of the Son of God. And yet it was the most

beautiful thing that ever happened on earth because it was the explosive revelation of the love of God in and through the human body. But the eyes of our bodies don't see that. The eyes of our bodies, the eyes of our in our skull, they see just something ugly.

Scripture on Good Friday says his appearance was so marred that we couldn't even look upon him. We couldn't even look upon him and, and Good Friday, which wasn't that long ago. I, I went to the Good Friday service and during that line, his appearance was so marred. We, we couldn't even look upon him. I, I heard this cry of the heart. I think it was Christ's heart. I really do like, can anybody

see me? I, I'm still here. Does anybody acknowledge me? Does anybody right? Everyone turn from him. They he came to His own and his own rejected Him. There were those at the foot of the cross who remained the the Marys and John, but besides them people either mocked or or jeered or ran away. He was despised and rejected. There was nothing in his appearance that drew us to Him on the cross. And you know how I am, Wendy, with movie scenes or music that

comes to me in in places of prayer in the movie scene that came to me was from a a movie from the 80s. I I, I remember it when I was maybe 12 years old when it came out. The Elephant Man. Remember the Elephant Man? Yeah. The Elephant Man. If you don't know about this movie, it was a true story of somebody who had. I don't know what the technical medical term is, but we call it elephant Titus. Where the bone structure of the

person is, is grossly out of line and, and big welts develop. And this, this man's skull was so disproportionate and he, he looked like way beyond Neanderthal. He looked like an elephant. I call it Elephant Man just because he's so grossly disfigured. And the true story portrayed in this movie was of this man. I believe he lived in the 1800s. And the scene that just stays with me, haunts me, is the the town. Of course, you know, he's ostracized, he's rejected.

He's he's not treated like a human being. He's treated like an animal. He's tortured and and mocked and made fun of and rejected just his whole life. And there's this one scene where he's cornered and people, his veil has been removed. He usually walked around with a veil over his face and his veil has been removed and he's cornered and he, he cries out like from the depths. I am not an animal. I am a human being.

Oh gosh, gosh, that it rocked me on Good Friday. It rocked me. And it, it was, it was, it was the cry of the Lord. It was like, does anybody see me as a human being? I'm despised. I'm rejected. Yeah. Do do we see old people? Are we willing to see old people? I remember, Wendy, when I came to visit you in New Jersey is at the very beginning of our

relationship. And you wanted me to meet your great grandmother, who was 105. Was she? And you took me to the nursing home to meet her. And I hadn't been in a nursing home since my great grandmother died in 1976. And this was 1995. And I felt so uncomfortable. You know, there's a bad smell and people are bent over and hunched and drooling. And this is the smell of urine and soaked old people diapers.

And I just was immediately uncomfortable. And my body was tense. And you were not uncomfortable. Your body was not tense. You stopped and greeted some people in wheelchairs even before we got to your great grandmother's room. And the, the love you poured out on your great grandmother that day, it's no exaggeration to say it changed the course of my life. And I, we, we, we don't without grace, we're not going to see

that way. We're not going to love people that way. And, and here's the bottom line is we all go that way. I mean, unless we die young, we all go that way and what we really desire and, and I, I can relate Michael so much to, you know, I just want to see JP two young and skiing and hiking. And believe me, I can relate to that. But I want to suggest you're looking in the wrong direction for JP 2, right? You're, you're, you're looking for the youthful body, what you

really desire beyond JP 2's youthful body. You desire his resurrected body, you desire his glorified body, right? And I don't know if Thomas Aquinas is right about this, but I think he's got some basis for saying in our glorified body, we're all going to be the age of Christ when he was crucified and resurrected. 33 like that. OK, I can go with that. But but it's not a regression to youth. It's a fulfillment of our

humanity in the other direction. JP 2 is closer to glory than you or I are right now. He, he's, you know, we're all hoping for Christ's return and the resurrection of the body. But I, I want to invite you, Michael, don't look backwards to JP 2's youth or to your own. Don't lament as you age the loss of your youth because the glory you desire, the true humanity you desire, is full speed ahead. And that means the path to glory

must pass through diminishment, death, humiliation. And by humiliation I I mean the literal sense of the word, the return to hummus, the return to the earth. Unless the seed go in the ground and die, it just remains a seed. But if it die and is buried in that ground, it bears an abundant harvest. The harvest that will be born is

the glorification of our body. But the path to get there is the humiliation of the body. Open the eyes of our hearts, Lord. Open the eyes of our hearts, Lord, we want to see you. We want to see you. You know what I'm feeling. Just the gift we have, you and I, of having lived through the entirety of Pope John Paul the Second's pontificate. So, you know, he was already, you know, older than we are right now when he became Pope.

Only by a year and a half for me Can you believe it. But still, yes, he was. He wasn't young when he became Pope. He was a young Pope. But are you? Saying I'm not young. Is that what you're saying? Yes, that is, That is true. I am not. He was 58 when he became Pope. But we began to see pictures of him younger eventually, but we lived through it. And so I think our perspective is a little different from Michael's because we didn't get introduced to Pope John Paul the 2nd through the kinds of images

that he's talking about. Yeah, that's right. And, you know, I'm just feeling a certain gratitude for that as I'm reading Michael's question. Like, no, we saw it. We saw how young and happy he was at the first World Youth Day. Like amazing. Like this is the Pope. And we're so psyched. Like he's amazing. And we saw him age and we saw him, you know, he, for those who don't know, he had Parkinson's disease and it did affect his posture.

That's not something he had control over. That way that he appeared hunched was a part of the progression of his illness. Other things were as well. And and yet the incredible witness it was to see him continue to speak to huge crowds, to have all those cameras on him, the the willingness for someone who had been that, you know, camera worthy, you know, to put that in

quotes, you know, at a different time in his life that he continued to know that Christ had called him to this. And he was called to be a witness to hope. And he used that expression, a witness to hope that he was living that hope all the way to the end and continued an active ministry, continued to speak publicly and on camera. Like it was a beautiful witness. Like I can just say it from

having seen it. So he says, like, where do I start to see the entirety of life and the body as being a gift? JP 2 is a great place to start. And when I remember being challenged by him at that time when he was older, like he's so wise. Everyone's looking at him, everyone's listening to him. What about the old people in my life? What about the old people at my parish or in my family? Are we all paying attention to what they have to say? Are we looking for that wisdom from them like we are from JP 2?

Because he's probably not the only living old person that has something to give, you know, like they still have something to give. But but it takes a certain willingness to to enter into a different space, you know, with somebody who's limited by the changes that come with aging, they maybe struggle to hear. And maybe when they're in public, you know, all the noise around them kind of shuts them down and they get real quiet and withdrawn.

Or maybe that other struggles that they're having make them sort of easily irritated. And it takes a certain calm within us and patience within us to get to those profound gifts that they have to give us. We we have to be willing to kind of adjust to the pace of life that they're in now. But but the rewards are there, right? And I think the beauty of that witness for us from Pope John Paul the second was like, for me, it just spoke to my heart

like keep listening to the old people. Yeah. So that's those are my thoughts. Thank you, Michael, for your honest question. Keep going, brother. Full speed ahead towards the resurrection. That's what we're really looking for. Amen. That's the Lord's promise. It's coming. Our next question is from a listener named Maggie. Hi, Maggie. Hi Christopher and Wendy, thanks so much for this podcast. As a Lutheran, there are not many theologically sound resources that I have found to

answer my deepest thoughts and questions, and this podcast is a godsend to me. Oh, I'm so glad, Maggie. I'm so glad you found us. As a single woman, is it wrong to have sexual desires? I don't think about men lustfully per SE. It's more of a deep ache to be loved, be married, and yes, have sex. I find myself at random times of the day wishing I had someone to

hold and caress and embrace in the marital act. My body also has physical signs of arousal. I've noticed that this occurs a specific one to two weeks during my cycle, which is probably God's way of giving me a foretaste of what the New Jerusalem will be like. Yes, I preach. It I've tried offering my desires up to God in prayer, but I still feel this ache in my heart and my body. Maggie, bless you.

Bless your honesty, bless your willingness to feel what you feel. Bless your integrity, bless your yearning, bless your cry out to the Lord. The the question, how did she put it? Is there? Is there? Is it wrong? Yeah, is it wrong to have sexual? Desires. No, no, no, no. I, I, it would be, it would be wrong in the sense of something out of whack, something out of

kilter if you didn't have these experiences. This is the way God has made us male and female. He created them and he blessed them. He said be fruitful, multiply. Your body is designed by God, your mind and your heart as well designed by God to enter that holy life giving communion. John Paul the Second says in love and responsibility we should not expect.

It would be foolish to expect that we not experience certain desires, emotions, longings, and even physical reactions. It's asking too much of ourselves, he says, to expect that we would not feel such things. The question in all of this is, when we feel these things, what do we do with them? One can go down the path of just

selfish indulgence and masturbation. That does not sound to me like the path you are going down. You are going down the path it sounds to me from what you've shared of Lord. I open this to you. Lord, help me to integrate my humanity, body and soul. Prepare me, Lord, to love as you love. Thank you, Lord, for the reminders that I have in my very heart and mind and body that show me that, reveal to me that

tell me that. Help me understand. I am made for Holy Communion, and the ultimate Holy Communion for which I'm made is not just with an earthly husband through the sacrament of marriage, as wonderful as that is. But that's just a little little little little glimmer of what we're ultimately made for, which is infinite ecstatic bliss in union with God forever, what the Saints and the Mystics call

nuptial union with the Lord. And the Saints speak of this, that there is a, a, a bodily response even to that spiritual experience of union with the Lord. And we shouldn't expect it otherwise because we are a unity of body and soul. So my dear sister, it sounds to me like you are on the road of integration.

I would only say be aware, of course, when your body is aroused that you not foster that in the sense of arousing yourself more unto the point of masturbating or something like that. I, I, I don't hear that in what you're saying. I'm not suspecting that's what you're doing. I'm just saying for you and for all of our listeners, be aware. They can go that direction, and we shouldn't go that direction, but it can go the direction of

Lord, thank you for making me to be a woman. Thank you for giving me these desires. Thank you for this integration of my body and soul. Thank you that I know I'm made for love and union. Thank that you. Thank you that I desire love and union. Thank you that I long for union with my husband. Saint Paul says whatever is true, whatever is beautiful, whatever is pure, think on these things. Think on these things. And there is a pure and a beautiful way to ponder, to contemplate the the call to married love.

There's a beautiful, pure way to do that. The idea that the only way to think about human sexuality is through some pornographic, masturbatory lens is just from hell. It's a lie. It's not the truth. There's another way to see, there's another way to think. There's another way to feel. There's another way to experience our creation as male and female. And it sounds to me, Maggie, like you are already on that path. And I say rejoice. Rejoice.

You are not far from the Kingdom. Keep going. Keep praying for that integration. Keep opening your heart to the Lord whenever you experience those longings. The Lord is your true bridegroom. He's not ashamed of the way He made you and He wants to continue to integrate you more and more and more. I'm not saying you've arrived, that this is integration. Here you are. I'm saying you're on the pilgrimage. Keep going. There's always more. There's always a deeper integration to be had. There's always a new level of of

that entering into the truth of your womanhood in an ever more pure and holy way. And you're on that journey. And I say keep going. Yeah, I'm rereading this last line where she said I've tried offering my desires up to God in prayer, but I still still feel this ache in my heart and body And I I'm just pondering that kind of how she said I've tried this, but and I'm trying to just understand a certain like, is

there an expectation that somehow if you, if you offer this to the Lord that it would go away or I I'm, I'm just trying to make sense a little bit of that. Do you have any? That's how I heard it. I, I, I heard it as and that's why I said, well, first let me say I heard it as I've tried to offer this to the Lord, but it doesn't go away. And that's why I was sharing that from JP 2, from love and responsibility that we, we shouldn't expect that it go away.

What we should expect is that it becomes more and more integrated with our, our, our, our authentic humanity. And it becomes not a temptation to indulge in some selfish, masturbatory way. It becomes rather an integrated experience of, of learning what love is and how to love, how to love with our bodies and our souls. Right. She can offer that also as a prayer for her future husband. Yeah, that's an offering offer.

Offer your humanity as it is now for your future, for your husband. What might that look like? It could look like, Lord, you're my true husband, You're my heavenly bridegroom. I open my body and my soul to you as I am right now, feeling this tension in my body, feeling this arousal, feeling this longing to be held, to be loved, to enter into that marital embrace. I open that to you and Ioffer the suffering that I'm feeling, 'cause it can involve suffering. Ioffer the suffering of this in

not indulging it, in not masturbating, in staying in the ache and, and, and just holding myself open to you, Lord, in this ache. Ioffer that very suffering as a prayer for my future husband, wherever he is, as love for my future husband wherever he is. Teach me, Lord, through this suffering. Integrate me, Lord, in the suffering in, in, in the call of chaste, holy marital love.

Yeah. I think I think too, just a word I want to add is that as you let that sink in, Maggie, that that there's it's not wrong. You know, there's nothing wrong about the experiences themselves that I think that's that's a good thing to be able to just sit with for a while, just trust. And if the question comes up again, like to kind of just have that inner almost like conversation, like you know it, why am I concerned that this is

wrong? Like can I recognize like God's good design and how he made me and can I thank him and can I trust in his goodness? I think then there's going to be just next steps in in what things you begin to just explore with the Lord in your experience of your singleness right now and of your desire. But you know, it's, it's not good to kind of try to imagine yourself in a different place on

the on your journey than you are, but to to let the Lord lead you by steps in in where he wants to bring you. And so as you can be at peace with that. You have these experiences. All human beings just about have these kinds of experiences that we we experience them as certain little revelations of our own hearts that are a gift.

I just want to leave it that it's a gift to have a revelation of your heart and to invite the Lord to show you something about your heart in the instances of experiencing that, you know, longing and that arousal and those things. Lord, show me my heart and it can just be part of your prayer journey with the Lord that can bear a lot of fruit. Maggie, I want to hold out a resource to you, 2 resources to you that will expose you to John Paul the Second's book.

Love and Responsibility 1 is a YouTube series that I did with Matt Fradd. It's 6 episodes. We did 3 episodes in our studio and three episodes in his studio and we'll have a link to that in the show notes. That would give you about, you know, six to seven hours worth of exposure to love and responsibility. Of course it's a couple guys talking about it, but you'll get exposure to John Paul's teaching and you'll be able to apply it to your own feminine heart. If you also want to go even more

deeply, we have a 30 hour course on love and responsibility and I Co teach that with Jeanette Clark. So you would get the feminine perspective from her and she does a brilliant job opening things up from a feminine perspective and we have that online. We also have it in person and you can check our our list of courses in the show notes as well to learn more about that. You will not regret Maggie exposing yourself to John Paul the Second's Love and Responsibility.

It is a masterwork. If the world could take in what John Paul the Second gave us in love and responsibility, it'd be a different place. Our next question is from a listener named Janet. Hi, Janet. I'm 60 now. My husband of 26 years has been dead for eight years. Aw, bless you, Janet. We were looking forward to having sexual fun because our

kids were moving out after he died. I was angry with God about many things and I think I invited a deviant sexual spirit on myself. It just seemed so ridiculous to not have sex at my age, but marriage seemed ridiculous also. Now I have repented and I don't want any more sex out of marriage, but I'm still super heartbroken that God has allowed

me to be alone this long with no foreseeable mate insight. I feel like God created me to be a Good Wife and I'm so exhausted from living life alone. I don't even know what my question is besides why I feel betrayed and uncared for by the God who created me and knows the deepest desires of my heart. Gosh, I'm groaning here because I'm just feeling the cry of her

heart. It is the cry of Christ on the cross. She even used the very words of Christ on the cross. Why? In this feeling of abandonment, those are two words that Jesus cries, groans from the cross. My God, my God, why? Why, why have you abandoned me? You are living, Janet.

You are living in that cry. And there is a profound paradox here. So much of our faith is paradoxical, right? The virgin mother. What, what, what? The virgin mother, the God man what what? If you want to be rich, you got to sell everything and be poor. If you want to live, you got to die. If you want to be free, you got

to be the servant of all these these crazy paradoxes. And here's another one. It's at the crux. And listen to that word crux, right? The cross, the crucifixion, It's at the crux of it all this paradox I'm about to share when we cry out, my God, my God, why have you abandoned me? We are intimately united with

Christ, and Christ is intimately united with us in his cry on the cross. My God, my God, why have you abandoned me? We are so one with Jesus in this cry of abandonment that we, we, we don't even recognize how close he is because that's how close he is. It's the cry of Christ. It's not even our cry anymore. It's Christ in US. It's that kind of intimacy.

What I am hearing in every line of your question, dear Janet, I am hearing Christ in you. That's what I'm hearing. That's who I'm hearing. I'm hearing the cry of Jesus Christ. And if that is the cry of Christ, and Christ is God, and God who is Christ is with you in that cry of abandonment, then paradox of paradoxes in your cry of abandonment from God. You're closer to God than you ever realized. It's a paradox in the cry of

feeling abandoned by God. We are the closest to him we could ever imagine. And I invite you, dear Janet, I invite you to keep crying that cry and to say, Christ, if this is your cry in me, then show me. Show me how close you are to me. Show me how close I am to you and reveal yourself to me as my

bridegroom. It's a profound paradox, but in your in your yearning to be united with the bridegroom and feeling abandoned by the bridegroom, you are united with the bridegroom in his cry of abandonment. And you are experiencing, you are experiencing, Janet, in the very cry of abandonment. You are experiencing what the

Mystics call nuptial union with the Lord on the marriage bed of the cross. Let that one sink in. Nuptial union with Christ the bridegroom in the marriage bed of the cross. That's where you are. You are in the marriage bed of the cross. You are on the marriage bed of the cross. You are there with Christ. He is there with you. And a marriage has been consummated here, a mystical

marriage. It is Christ in you. Christ is in you. And who is Christ? He is the seed that is the Word. He is the Word, that is the seed of God. That seed of God is being poured out into your heart, your bridal heart, the seat, the spiritual seed of the bridegroom is being poured out into your heart, and it will bear fruit. This is how redemption works. It's a marriage, and that marriage is fruitful.

We all want to be one with God in the joys. We all want to be one with God in the glories and the ecstasies. But this is what Saint Teresa of Avila says. This is a paraphrase, but it's true to her teaching. She says in so many words, the Lord teaches us courage in the prayer of agony. And that's where you are. You are in the prayer of agony, deeply united with Christ the Bridegroom. The Lord teaches us courage in the prayer of agony, Teresa of Avila says, because we need even more courage to endure the

prayer of ecstasy. Prayer, the fathers of the Church tell us, is nothing other than becoming a longing for God. Every line of your question, Janet, is the fragrance from your heart of that prayer, of that longing for God, of of, of what Pope Benedict the 16th calls a holy Eros, a holy

passion for the living God. Stay there, dear sister. Stay there, dear sister. Be not afraid of the prayer of agony. It is preparing you for the prayer of ecstasy. It's real. You're on the pilgrimage. You're on the way. This is it. Yeah, the the thing that's striking me is is she, she concluded with the God who created me and knows the deepest desires of my heart.

And that the desires of my heart is reminding me of a a verse of Scripture that says trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding, but in all your ways acknowledge him. He will direct your path. There's something about that desire of the heart being

fulfilled with, with the letting go of the way we thought it would be fulfilled, that that is a call to a deeper trust. And, and I think it's that building of a genuine trust, not something that you just try real hard to muster up, but through the lived experience of the, the grief and the sorrow and the agony, as you put it, that meeting the Lord there, meeting

him in his ability to love you right there, that that creates this. I don't know. It's like a rising trust that can carry you through your life on a path you didn't foresee. You've already been living on a path that you didn't foresee. And as you acknowledged in sharing your story so humbly, you shared that there were parts of it where you were really trying to take control in your

anger and grasp at things that you thought you deserved somehow. And and you got, as you said, exhausted from it all. And it's not really meeting the desires of your heart. And so there's this empty handed, tired place you're in that I just believe is, is the Lord saying trust in me and, and acknowledge my presence. Acknowledge me in all your paths like like invite me into all

aspects of your life as you're able. You know, just to see him knocking at the door of new areas of your heart and your life and to open that door because he he will grant you the desires of your heart, because he'll show you your deepest heart in ways that you can't see it yet because he he needs to come in and fill you more and

more with his love and enable you to trust him more so that the joy that is coming will be more fulfilling than the path you thought was your path. And that's that's the exciting part of the story. You're it's what it's knowing he loves you that much that you he can even help you to let go completely of all that you wished would be and that you tried to obtain for yourself and to say like he even loved me as

I was doing all that he's he didn't stop loving me 'cause he understood and he was pained to see me in just causing myself and others more pain. And he's he sees me now exhausted and just crying. He still sees me and loves me and he's, he's trying to have me just receive that love so that I can trust him and let him show me what he has next for my life.

And that's hard, but it's really like the real deal journey of. Faith. Yeah, it is. It's the real deal journey of being a real human being in a fallen world where the Lord has entered in to redeem us. I love Wendy that you connected Janet with that what she's going through with that scripture about lean not on your own understanding. And as I as I'm just praying for

Janet here, listening to your reflections, I'm taking taken to a scripture from the song of songs. And Janet, I'm going to hold this out to you. I'm going to invite you to, to consider praying into this as if you are this woman, because I think you are. You're the bride in the song of songs, in that terribly aggravating scene in the song, when she's ready for union, she's gone into the bridal chamber. She's taken off all her clothes. She's in the marriage bed. And the bridegroom comes peering through the window.

And then he leaves. He leaves and she gets up, runs out into the street. Have you seen the bridegroom? Have you seen the one I love? Have you seen the one I love? And St. after St. reflecting on this, this tragic, inexplicable move of the bridegroom who just leaves has said the Lord appears

to leave us. He appears to leave us in order catch this to stretch our desire for union with him because he wants to give us everything he is and we don't have the capacity. Our hearts need to be stretched. Our hearts have have shrunk. Our hearts are are kind of closed up. And Saint Augustine uses the image of like a leather purse that if you have this leather

purse and you want to put a gift into it, but the purse is not big enough to receive the gift. The leather has to be stretched and it's painful. It's painful to allow our desires to be stretched. How far do they have to be stretched? Well, we're invited to receive all the fullness of God. Our hearts need to be stretched unto Infinity, and so the desire does not go away. If we're on the path of holiness, it increases unto

madness. Teresa of Avila says I die because I do not die. She knows that only dying will bring her union with the bridegroom. And so she dies because she does not die because she longs so ardently for union with the bridegroom. Lord, help us not to fear the stretching of our hearts. Help us not to fear these feelings of abandonment, but to recognize the paradox that you were with us there and you are

stretching our desire so that we might have the capacity to be filled with all the fullness of God. Let it be, Lord, as you would have it. Bless you Janet, thank you for your honesty in that question and thank you everybody for the questions you send us. If you were blessed today by our reflections, we hope you were. If you know somebody who who could be blessed by them, would you, would you hit that share button? Lord, we ask for the grace to know what it means to be the

gift we are called to be, and we ask for the grace. To become what we are. Help us to be that gift, Lord. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode