-This episode is sponsored by Truthly- Questions answered this episode: About 10 years ago, my husband and I rushed into a vasectomy after my third child in 3.5 years and intense anxiety/depression. I wasn’t in favor, but agreed thinking he’d reverse it if we wanted more kids - then I learned he never intended to. For eight years I felt despair and our union felt unrepairable. In recent years, Christ has healed me, and discovering TOB helped transform my husband’s heart; he’s apologized and wishes he could take it back. But he fears reversal because of painful complications. Should I ask him to reverse it for me, or leave it up to him? How does this relate to TOB’s “special responsibility” of the man to reestablish the balance of the gift? My question is about where the marriage imagery of Christ and the Church can fall short. Sometimes I find it hard to love God when I know that if I don’t, He has the power and authority to cast me into hell, and if this were a relationship between two sinners, it might seem abusive for one spouse to punish the other for lack of loyalty. Ezekiel 16 portrays God doing this in a spousal context, and it deeply troubles me. When I struggle with this, I shy away from Christ as Bridegroom and turn to other analogies, like Him as the vine. Can you shed some TOB light on this? I’ve been in a relationship for four years. We’re both believing Christians and try to live our relationship in the light of theology of the body, but lately we’re struggling with physical affection - never knowing what is too much or what is healthy since we’re not married. We’ve talked a lot, and it seems I’m having a harder time than he is. My problem is that I often find myself troubled after the fact. I’d really appreciate some advice. Resources: Colorado Ski Retreat with Christopher events@tobinstitute.org --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? Join our Patron Community! --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 List of trusted counselors & psychologists *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Our faithful listeners know that I've been of late sharing with you guys an app called Truthly. Truthly. We've entered into a partnership with Truthly. I believe in what they're doing, they believe in what we're doing. And our audience who is familiar with asking questions about the Catholic faith, you guys should really know about this app called truthfully, TRUTHLY faithful to the Magisterium, rooted in Scripture, thinking
with the mind and heart of the church. You can go on truthfully and ask any question about the Catholic faith and you'll get an orthodox answer using all the technology of artificial intelligence and putting it to very good use. I've been using Truthfully just to poke around and see what kind of answers they come up when when I type in certain questions and I've been impressed. I've been impressed. They're doing good stuff and I think it is definitely worth our just shouting out to our audience and say give it a try.
You can get a 7 day free trial by just going to wherever you get your apps, the Google Play Spot if you're an Android person, or go to the App Store on the iPhone and learn more about what the good folks are doing at Truthfully. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Hey, Wendy.
Yes. Remember the time we were recording a podcast and a mouse ran across the? Floor. Yes, I do. How many listeners out there remember that? Do you remember the Mouse podcast? Welcome everybody, to another episode. Yes, I don't know what made me think of that mouse, but you know what I realized later? It wasn't a mouse. It was a mole. It was a mole. Are you sure? Yeah. OK, yeah, because it had a long body with a short tail.
Oh, OK. Mice around here have short bodies with a long tail. That's true. It's true. Mice are cuter moles. I don't know. What does the mole remind me of? Sort of like when I, you know, do laundry and I'd like, take the socks and fold them together. That's what a mole's body kind of looks like. You know, yes, I see it. It's just the mouth. The the like the socks when they. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it has. Yeah, I know what you're talking about. I will never see socks in a ball the same way again. You know, a friend of ours from
Australia stayed in this office and saw a mole and he didn't even know what a mole was. I guess they don't have moles in Australia. Speaking of Australia. Yeah, let's speak of it. I just got back from Australia. Well, it according. According to the time frame of when this will air, actually we're recording this right before I'm leaving for Australia, but when it comes out I will have just gotten back. Just gotten back. It was an awesome trip. Yes, thanks for that trip.
I'm just saying that because I know it will be. Actually, I am very much looking forward to heading Down Under and seeing all the fine people. I've made so many good connections down in Australia over the 26 years I've been travelling there on a sort of regular basis. You can't go to Australia all the time. It's like the other side of the world and stuff. I think this is my 7th or 8th trip to Australia. I've been there quite a bit. Beautiful people, beautiful
hearts. And we, we are really blessed at the TOB Institute to have a relationship with the Archdiocese of Sydney. And they've, they've commissioned us to come down. So somebody from the institute is going down there every year to teach a course. I go every other year now and yeah, what a blessing. What other updates do you have for us from the TOB? Institute upon the airing of this episode, the ski trip is about a month and a half away and I'm going to guess, although
I don't know for sure upon the recording of this episode, that we still have some spots left. So that is getting down to the wire. If you are a skier, if you love the idea of skiing all day and partying all night, the party I'm talking about is the party of entering into the glory of JP 2's vision of what it means to be a human being. Which if you haven't ever really taken a retreat, like given
genuine time to it, please come. If you're a skier, come on the ski retreat. It Will Rock your world. So check that out in the show notes. And also, I want to encourage anybody out there, if you are interested in bringing the Theology of the Body Institute to your parish, to your university, to your community, consider it. We have these three major live
events that we do. The first is called Made for More. The second is called the Well. The third is called the Way of Wonder and they're all ticketed events, which means you can bring us to your area without it costing you or your organization or your parish if it's promoted well, it doesn't cost you anything because the the money to fund it all comes through the ticket sales.
So if you want to learn more about that, check out the e-mail in the show notes events at tobinstitute.org. Both the Made for More event and the event we called the Well has the live music of Mike Mangione and yours truly as the presenter. We always bring big screens. There's lighting. It's more like a night at the theatre than it is any kind of talk you've ever been to. It's, it's interactive, it's a full sensory experience.
It's entering into all the glories of, of the Catholic faith through a very engaging full sensory experience. So yeah, check that out and we would love to come to your area. Are you ready now for a question from a patron? I'm ready. Let's do it. OK, this is a question from an anonymous patron. Thank you for continuing to give your time and energy in order to minister to all of us through this podcast. You are welcome. About 10 years ago, my husband
and I made a rushed decision for him to get a vasectomy. I had just had my third child in 3 1/2 years and was experiencing intense mental health struggles, including anxiety and depression. I was not in favor of the surgery but agreed to it with the understanding that he would later reverse it if we decided to have more children. A few years later, I learned that he never intended to reverse it. For eight years, I felt deep
despair and our marital union felt unrepairable. I pleaded with God for my husband's heart to change and for his body to be healed. In the last few years, there has been a miraculous healing in me. I feel like a woman made new by the love of Christ. Part of my healing was discovering the theology of the body. My love for this teaching has spread to my husband and his heart has been transformed. He's apologized for getting the
vasectomy and wishes he could take it back. Oh my word. I think he's afraid to have it reversed because he suffered painful complications after the vasectomy itself. This raises a question for me. Should I ask him to have the reversal for me or should I leave it up to him? I was struck by this sentence in Theology of the Body. Although maintaining the balance
of the gift seems to be something entrusted to both, the man has a special responsibility as if it depended more on him. Whether the balance is kept or violated or even if it has already been violated re established. How does this relate to our situation? Wow, wow, wow. How privileged are we, Wendy,
that we get to hear such astonishing miracles of grace. Salvation has come to this couple. This is an explosively powerful work of grace in a, in a wounded marriage, in a marriage that as it's so easy to be and all of us to 1° or another are caught up in the lies of the culture. And this is the living God visiting this couple to bring
new life and restoration. It is truly astounding. And I, my heart is just singing God's praises. Thank you, God, thank you, God for the work you're doing in this couple. Astonishing. I, I, I want to address the question that preceded that quote. Can you read that question? That was right before that quote from JP 2, and then I'm going to get to that quote from JP 2. She said should I ask him to have the reversal for me or should I leave it up to him?
Here would be my advice, dear sister. You can and I think you should speak to him about how it would bless you if he would have that reversal. You, you, you can hold that out to him, but it must be an appeal to his freedom. I don't think you can demand this of them, but I do think you can and should share your heart. Share what happened in those years in your own heart.
Share the torment, share the pain of those years and, and, and however you would put it. I don't want to put words in your mouth, but honey, it would bless me. I know it might be painful, there could be complications, you might go through some weeks of real difficulty, but it would bless me if you would, if you would be willing to do that. I, I leave it to you, but it would bless me. Something like that. Just what, what comes to me.
And, and let me give some some background here just for people who don't know the church's teaching or understand it, or those who are wondering, what are you obligated to get it reversed? OK, so here's the analogy I often use. I'm sure we've, I know we've addressed this question in the past. So this might be repeats for our, our loyal listeners. This might be a repeat. Here's my analogy. If, if you break your neighbour's window and you say you're sorry, but you don't repair his window, are you
really sorry? I I think we all know the answer to that. But what if it's $1,000,000 stained glass window and you don't have the money to fix it? OK, you, you, you can't be obligated to do something that you don't have the ability to do. There might be good reason that you can't or are unable to fix the window. OK, then do something else to show your sorrow. Mow his lawn for a year or
whatever. Here's the analogy, the vasectomy. 2 things are going on here. Not only the sin of contraception, not only the sin of rendering the sexual union sterile. If you don't know why that's a sin, please go on to AI and and ask truthfully why that's a sin. Or, or look at some of our old podcasts where we've addressed that. Or read my book, Good News about Sex and Marriage, where I go
into great detail about that. But not only is the vasectomy a the sin of contraception, of rendering the marital embrace sterile, it is also the sin of bodily mutilation, right? It's, it's taking a healthy, functioning body part and destroying its function, right? The purpose of medicine and technology is to restore bodily functions that aren't functioning properly. If you were to use medical
technology to render someone blind, you're going in the exact opposite direction then you then health. But if you use medical technology to give someone sight, you're working in the right direction. To use medical technology to render someone sterile, we must call things by their proper names. It is bodily mutilation. If you chop off your arm because you hate your arm, and then you come to your senses and you go to confession and you confess the sin of bodily mutilation As
far as the East is from the West, so is your sin from you. The moral evil is gone. However, the physical evil, meaning the lack of your arm, you may still have to deal with that for the rest of your life. If you can restore your arm, if it's been on ice and you can reattach it, you should. My point here, if you can get a vasectomy reversal, you should. You might not be able to, might not be possible, might be all kinds of medical complications that could put your life at
risk. You're not obligated to get it reversed, but if you can, you should, even if it's going to be painful, even if there's going to be sacrifice involved. So, so all of that needs to be taken into account. I don't know the specifics. If if you were to tell me your your husband has a major health risk in going under anesthesia and he might die, well, you would have a good reason not to have the reversal. The physical evil is still there, but the moral evil is gone.
You can engage in the marital embrace and there's no moral evil because you have repented of that moral evil. As far as the East is from the West, so is your sin from you. All of these things need to be taken into account in in a, in a approaching your husband with these questions. Now I want to bring up this quote from JP 2, which I find the fact that she brought this up is very insightful. Very insightful. Can you read it again, Wendy?
Sure, it's a beautiful quote. Yeah, it's one of my favorites from the whole catechesis. Although maintaining the balance of the gift seems to be something entrusted to both, the man has a special responsibility as if it depended more on him whether the balance is kept or violated or even if it has already been violated re established. OK, there's so much going on here. I could write a doctoral dissertation. I don't have time for that, but here's just some a few thoughts.
What does JP 2 mean by the balance of the gift? Look at the very beautiful, glorious, fascinating design of our bodies as male and female, male and female. He created them and he blessed them and said be fertile. The human heart is, is, was and always will.
Be fascinated by the mystery of the sexual difference, and we all know if you take that in the wrong direction, you end in a pornographic hellhole. That does not mean the fascination itself is the problem, it's that we're taking the fascination in a hellish direction. That fascination can also be taken in a heavenly direction and this is the design of God for creating us, male and
female, to launch us like a rocket to the stars. With original sin, those rocket engines became inverted and that's why so often our fascination with the body and sexuality ends in a massive blast of self destruction. Christ comes into the world not to condemn those with inverted rocket engines, but to redirect our rocket engines to the stars in the design of male and female. It is the man who is designed to pour a gift from within himself,
out of himself, so that the gift that was deeply within him is now deeply within his wife. This is not just poetry. This is this is, this is a poetic description of the very physical reality of the marital embrace. Something deep from within the man is now deep within the woman. It's the very seed of life. And in this mystery that it is the male who gives the seed of
life and it is the female who receives the seed of life. We're not talking about the male is active and the female is passive, right? That would be Aristotle's half truth that has led to all kinds of problems in philosophy and theology. It it's, it's a half truth. JP 2 corrects that or or fleshes out that half truth with the full truth that it's the man who gives, but he gives in a receiving way. It's the woman who first receives, but she receives in a giving way.
And so JP 2 says the the giving and receiving of the gift in the marital act interpenetrate so that the very giving of the gift becomes receiving and the very receiving of the gift becomes giving. We might say that the man gives first, He initiates the gift. That's what the anatomy calls him to. I'm not saying, to quote Back to the Future, that it's wrong for a girl to call a boy on the phone. I'm not saying that it's wrong for a woman to initiate lovemaking.
I'm sure there's not a husband on the planet who would who would would would not like that on for a woman to initiate lovemaking more often. What I'm saying could be summarized in something like this. It is not merely social convention that leads a man to propose marriage to a woman and not the other way around. It's it's a testimony to the way we're wired. Right? The man is called to initiate
the gift and this means there is a particular responsibility on the man's shoulders. Doesn't mean he bears all the responsibility. But JP 2 says there's a particular responsibility here for the man to restore the balance of the gift, to maintain it in the first place, and if it's been broken, to restore it. So this dear wife is making a very appropriate application of JP 2's teaching here to her own
situation. And isn't it interesting in the story she told, it was her intention that in the future he would have it reversed, whereas the man, the husband's intention would I never intended to have it reversed. And so there's there's in his own fallenness, he kind of hid that from his wife. And, and so he, he bears a particular responsibility in having lost the proper balance of the gift to restore it, to restore it.
And with all the qualifications I've already given about, you know, we're not obligated to restore the vasectomy. There might be good reason not to. But all those qualifications, if he can restore the integrity of his own body, he has a special responsibility to restore the balance of the gift. Even in that way, given all of the previous qualifications are taken into account. I think it's a beautiful appropriate application of the
theology of the body. And High 5 to you, my dear sister, High 10 to you, my dear sister, for seeing that and recognizing your own situation. Right in JP 2's teaching, that is how to read the theology of the body to say how do I apply this? How do I see this as applicable in my own life? Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful. A+ plus. Plus. If I were grading you for a class or something, which I'm not, but you know what I'm saying, That's my, my kudos to you. That's what I'm trying to say.
Yeah, it's, it's so I think one of the things that's such a gift for our hearts is, is the direct quote from theology of the body. Because, you know, we of course theology of the body is informing us and often, but maybe not quite often enough, we reference the algae, the body in answers. But to have a question that's so specifically quotes, such an applicable thing. Yeah, it's really beautiful. The other amazing thing just blew me away is, is the in the
painful part of her story where she's talking about first of all, experiencing tremendous anxiety and depression, which are very, very painful realities. And then later she talked about despair and pleading with God for her husband's heart to change and for his body to be healed. That's a lot of years of a very deep personal suffering. And what she said happened was the miraculous healing was in her own.
I feel like a woman made new by the love of Christ. It makes me want to cry. Yeah, it's awesome. It's so amazing because she experienced that even before her husband's heart changed like that. God can come into such suffering and His love can make such a huge difference. Is so hopeful, so beautiful. Oh, you know, this is grateful, Wendy. Of course, yes. I'm just so grateful for our listeners to hear this particular story because it we
need that encouragement. It's so beautiful. Yeah. Thank you, dear sister, for sharing these miracles in your marriage with us and enabling us to share them with our listeners all around the world. Be encouraged everybody. Grace is real. The death and resurrection of Jesus Christ is real, and it has a real impact on our lives. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Can I, can I just say one more
thing, Wendy, I'm so sorry. And we will, we will get to this next question. But I know there are people out there, listeners of ours who are hearing this right now, who are in that place of torment, that place where she was for so many years just crying out to the Lord. And I, I, I want to say to all of you out there who are in that position, keep crying out. Remember the parable of the persistent widow? Keep crying out. Keep crying out, and let the story that we've just heard be a
source of encouragement. That's all I wanted to say and now I'm ready for the next question. OK, from the Anonymous. Listener. Anonymous listener. Thank you for what you do. Your podcast has blessed me so much. My question is about where the marriage imagery of Christ and the church can fall short. Sometimes I find it hard to love God when I know that if I don't, he has the power and authority
to cast me into hell. If he weren't the Almighty God and this were a relationship between two sinners, I feel like we might call it abusive for one spouse to punish the other for their lack of loyalty. Ezekiel chapter 16 portrays God doing this in a spousal context, and this deeply troubles me. When I struggle with this, I tend to shy away from thinking about Christ as the bridegroom and turn to other analogies such
as Him as the vine. Apart from whom we can do nothing. Can you please shed some TOB light on this? My dear sister, I hear thee human struggle in your heart. This is the struggle with God. It's not just a struggle with God, it is the fundamental struggle with God. JP 2 says in his book Crossing
the Threshold of Hope, that the goal of original sin is to change our understanding of God. This is the serpent's goal. This is the enemy's goal. This is what he has done to all of us with original sin. He has changed our understanding of God from loving Father, from loving bridegroom to tyrant, to
one who wants to dominate us and control us and throw us into hell, cast us into hell. He's changed the relationship from father, son or father, daughter or spouse, bridegroom and bride. He's changed it into master slave. If you don't do what I tell you, you will be punished. This paradigm, this concept of
God, comes from hell. It comes from the deceiver. There is language in the Old Testament that can reinforce that scary understanding of God. And the passage you're referring to in Ezekiel, I'll just summarize.
It's, it's a very long passage. I'm familiar with it. The passage in Ezekiel is where God confesses his spousal love, the love of a bridegroom for for humanity. As bride, He takes pity on our humanity. He sees us as as destitute, as cast aside, as rejected, as yearning for love. But we're we're in a desperate
situation that we can't save ourselves from. So he comes and he bathes us, He cleanses us, He clothes us and he awaits the maturing of our humanity. He the analogy here with the bridegroom and the bride. It's it's like a lover who's who's fallen in love with a a young girl and he's waiting patiently for her to grow into a
woman who's ready for love. It says in Ezekiel that the bridegroom here, which is the Lord waits and sees that the woman he loves, the bride he loves, has now developed. Her breasts have grown, her hair has grown. This is very explicit imagery of puberty, of what happens to a a young girl as she's transformed into a woman. And the bridegroom here is taking delight in her.
And he showers her with tenderness, with love, with gifts. He clothes her in splendor. And then, yeah, where it goes from there, there's a warning. And, and keep in mind, this is, this is a, a prophetic warning of what human beings are capable of in their fallen humanity. I'll just speak for myself here. I know God has given me many, many gifts. Many, many gifts to to teach the
gospel, Many, many gifts to share the riches of of Christ and his church with the world. And there are times in my own fallen humanity where I have used my gifts, which God gave me to glorify him and to bless others. And I've taken those gifts because I'm a prideful SOB as a fallen human being. And I've used my gifts that God has given me, bestowed on me to glorify myself.
This is the proper application of this imagery. Because what happens in Ezekiel here is that the bride who's been made beautiful, she was destitute, and through God's tenderness she was made beautiful. The bride then uses her beauty for her own vain gain. She uses her beauty to seduce men. She becomes a prostitute and she doesn't even become a prostitute
out of destitution to to get payment for it because she's in some terrible situation. She uses it for her own vanity. She doesn't even accept payment. She just wants to revel in her own beauty and vanity. And what God is saying, if you do that, there will be a natural consequence that you not not that God is going to throw us into hell out of some venge. You didn't follow my rules. I'm casting you into hell.
That's the paradigm from hell of who God is. A proper interpretation of the Old Testament story here, which we must view always in light of what Christ definitively reveals about who God is. I'll get to more of that in a minute. We must interpret this in light of what Christ reveals about who God is. And what we must conclude is that God casts no one into hell
out of vengeance. The warning here is do not let your pride and vanity get the best of you with the gifts that I bestow upon you. Because if you go down that road, the consequence of that road, the natural consequence of that road is that you will break covenant with me. Let me put it to you this way. If marriage is a an image of heaven, which it is, and if heaven is going to be a
marriage, which it is, it's not going to be a shotgun wedding. What do I mean by that? God forces no one to marry him. Why? Because if he forced us to marry him, it wouldn't be love, right? So often people will say, well, if God is love, there couldn't possibly be hell. And if we're thinking soundly, we must conclude precisely the
opposite. It is because God is love. It is because God loves us that hell must be a possibility. Why? Because love respects freedom, that's what. If God forced us to say yes to his marriage proposal, If the eternal marriage of heaven were a shotgun wedding, we were forced into it.
It couldn't possibly be love. The possibility of hell exists, and that's the way we have to phrase it. The possibility of hell exists precisely because God respects our freedom, and God respects our freedom precisely because God is love. Satan wants us to think that God is not a loving bridegroom, but I hate this word.
I'm going to spell it. He wants us to think God is an RAPIST. The fact that hell is a possibility demonstrates beyond any shadow of a doubt that God is not an RAPIST, but that he is a true, loving bridegroom who honors our freedom even to say no to Him.
Christ has revealed the full truth about who God is and the full truth of who God is. God is love. He is loving Father. He is loving bridegroom. Christ's entire life is declaring you think God is a tyrant who wants to dominate and control you, and if you break the rules, cast you into hell. You think that's who God is? I will let you dominate me. I will let you nail me to a
tree. I will descend into hell myself to demonstrate to you that God has no desire to dominate, control, harm you, or throw you into hell. You think God is an RAPIST? This is my body given up for you in love. I will let you RAPE me in the
sense of wreaking utter, utter violating havoc to my body to demonstrate to you that God has no desire whatsoever to wreak utter havoc and violate your body. You think God would whip your back if you gave him the chance? I will let you whip my back to demonstrate to you that I have no desire whatsoever to whip you or stop persisting in this lie from hell that God is a tyrant who wants to dominate and
control you and violate you. Stop persisting in that unbelief. Repent and believe. Believe I am love. I am love. I am love. This is my body given for you. This is my body given for you. We must let the paradigm of the love revealed on the marriage bed of the cross cleanse us of
any such notion of God as some vengeful God who wants to throw us into hell. That is a long journey, my dear sister, and you're already on it. How do I know you're already on it? Because you never would have asked this question. If you're not already on that journey, keep going, keep going, keep going. That lie has very deep tentacles in all of us, and it can take a lifetime to uproot that tenacious lie. But This is why Christ came into the world, to undo the work of the enemy.
And that work is already being done in you, my dear sister. It's happening, it's underway. Glory be to God. I want to address 1 more thing here before I, I, I, I. I'm so excited to hear whatever you might say here, Wendy. The one more thing I wanted to say was can you? She asked. Can you explain where the analogy doesn't work, where the analogy of the bridegroom and the bride isn't, isn't adequate? And, and we do have to
acknowledge this. Every analogy limps, all analogies are inadequate. The spousal analogy is the least inadequate, but it's inadequate. And, and here's an inadequacy. She touched on this idea of the the equality of spouses, right? That's, that's a very important point. You and I, Wendy, are equal in nature and dignity. I am your husband. You are my wife.
We are equal in nature and dignity as human persons. In the analogy of the Bridegroom and the Bride, where God is the Bridegroom, this is where it breaks down, because we are not equal to God in nature and dignity. He is an infinite divine Christ. Here I'm Speaking of Christ. He's an infinite divine person. He is not a human person.
And if there's something going wrong in the marriage between Christ and His Church, we know with absolute certainty the problem is always with the Bride, right. It's not possible to extrapolate from that that the problem in our marriage, you and me, Wendy is always with you. Although my pride sure would like to think that sometimes that ain't the truth because I am a fallen imperfect bridegroom. Jesus is not a fallen imperfect
bridegroom. He's a divine bridegroom. So so yeah, the the analogy breaks down. That would be one example. I could point to many others, but I just wanted to acknowledge she's on to something very important there and I just I'll throw this out to. If the vine and the branches helps you, praise God, stay there. Stay there. But but you can't look at any of these images in scripture and think 1 corrects the other. What what it corrects. What this Vine branch thing might correct is your faulty
notion of the bridegroom and bride image. So let that vine and branch image correct any faulty notion you have of the bridegroom bride image. But don't think it it's, it's the image itself is needs to be corrected. Our faulty understanding needs to be corrected. And of course, in the bridegroom bride image, let's never forget the curse. Your desire will be for your husband and he will dominate you. This is a curse. This is not God's plan. And when we're in the mode of of
the bridegroom dominating the bride and we project that onto God, we are in trouble, right? The correction for all of that is Saint Paul saying husbands, love your wives as Christ loved the Church. One of the things that was coming to me in this just reflection on Christ as Bridegroom. I'm looking around in your office where we're recording and you have a several different
Eastern icons on the walls and icons are not something that everyone is familiar with. They are beautiful, traditional, painted, prayerfully painted images that depict important scenes and realities of the faith. And there is a particular icon that is called Christ the bridegroom and it's an image of Christ carrying his cross,
right? So there's the the beautiful, just, I don't know, confirmation. You may want to look up that image, Christ the Bridegroom as an icon to recognize it's it just kind of confirms a lot of what you were saying that here is here is our bridegroom. So not punishing, but taking the punishment right. It's the opposite. That's right. That's exactly right. Not thank you, Wendy.
That summarizes everything I wanted to say in one sentence. Thank you, Wendy. That is the Holy Spirit. This is what Christ reveals. This is what Christ reveals. Say it again, Wendy. It's so powerful. This is loaded with the full glory of the reversal that Christ came to give us of our image of God. Go ahead, say that again. The image of Christ the Bridegroom is not of God punishing us, but of God taking the punishment. Hallelujah, Hallelujah,
Hallelujah. It makes me want to dance. It makes me want to cry. It makes me want to leap for joy that I never heard it said so. Well, it's beautiful, Wendy. Flesh and blood has not revealed that to you, Wendy, but your Father in Heaven has revealed that to you. That is so powerful. Thank you, Lord. Thank you, Lord. Thank you, Lord. You came not to punish us, but you came to take upon yourself
our punishment. And, and, and by that I don't even mean that we were supposed to be punished by God and Christ took it on. Rather, I'm saying Christ took on the punishment that we dished out. We crucified Jesus, not God the Father. It's not some vengeful God casting on his Son the punishment that he wanted to cast on us.
This this is fallen humanity rejecting God in the extreme and God saying, go ahead, go ahead, get it out. Get it out. I came to absorb it. It's not that it's not that Christ comes to punish us. It's that he comes and says, go ahead, punish me, punish me. Get it all out. Get all your hatred out. Hatred aimed at God. Get it out at me. I'm God. I will absorb it, and I will
show you in the midst of it how much I love you. I've come not to punish you. I've come not to condemn you. I've come to save you. Astonishing. Utterly astonishing. Our next question is from an Anonymous listener, just in the Anonymous. We are. This is 2 two episodes straight. Bless you all, you anonymous people. We love you even though we don't know your names. In heaven we will. I've been in a relationship for four years now. We are both believing Christians
and try to live our relationship in the light of the theology of the body. Glory be to God. Lately we're struggling with our physical affection, never knowing what is too much or what is healthy for us, not being married. My boyfriend and I have talked a lot about this and it seems that I am having a harder time with it than he is. My problem is that I often find myself troubled after the fact. I would really appreciate some
advice. Bless you, my dear sister. Such tender stuff. Yeah, it is. It is really tricky to navigate authentic purity of heart when we are not authentically pure of heart. There's there's always a gap. There's always a gap. And guess what, We've been married 30 years and there's a gap in our marriage between what we experience and what we're
called to be. Yeah, just because Wendy and I can articulate the teaching of the church does not mean we're living it to the full. I I was reminded just recently of a quote from Saint Therese. I was sitting in on Bill Donahue's course a couple weeks ago on the writings of JP 2, and Bill Donahue pulled up this quote on the screen that where Therese says I something like this. It might be a paraphrase, but this is the point.
I assure you, I, I, I am not close to living what I understand something like that. So that all of us can say that I'm I'm not close to living what I understand I have a long way to go. So just be tender with yourself in the gap and be tender with your boyfriend or this. This is a woman, right? Be tender with your boyfriend in the gap. And that's not to justify our
sin, that's not to make excuses for ourselves, but it's just to be realistic. We are called into a scary territory. Chastity cannot be reduced to something that you know, you could write on a chalkboard. OK, one column here are the acceptable behaviors before you get married. Other column here are the unacceptable behaviors before you get married.
There might be truth in that. Obviously, if you put intercourse in the column where somebody says this is OK before you, No, that's not that's the wrong column. So I'm not saying that there's not a place for the this column and that column, but when we reduce morality to something you can write on a chalkboard, guess where we are not dwelling in the realm of the heart. We're still in the head. And chastity is not ultimately a matter of the head.
It is a matter of the heart. Blessed are the pure of head. Is that what Jesus said? No, Blessed are the pure of heart. Blessed are the pure of heart. And that navigating that is not easy business. It involves getting out of the boat with our eyes fixed on Jesus and walking on water. And that is not something we are
in of our in and of our own humanity. It's not something we are capable of. You take your eyes off Jesus and you will sink. That's what happened to Peter. He got out of the boat. He did something he was not humanly capable of doing. He was walking on water. And he's like, oh, snikey, I'm walking on water. I don't. I was about to say something else. Oh, Snike, walking on water. I can't do this. He took his eyes off Jesus. He sank. And then Jesus said, you idiot, what are you doing out here?
Get your ass back in the boat. No, that's not what he said at all. He said, Jesus, excuse me, He didn't say Jesus. He said, Peter, why did you take your eyes off me? Which is another way of saying, why'd you doubt? Why'd you lose faith? He doesn't say, get your butt back in the boat. What the heck are you doing out here? And what's my point here in this story? It's better to get out of the boat in sink than never to get
out of the boat. The drama of the Christian life. And what is the Christian life? It's not following a list of rules that somebody wrote on a chalkboard. It's about learning how to love as Jesus loves. This is my commandment. Jesus says I give you a new commandment and then he diagrammed it on a chalkboard. No love one another as I have loved you.
Now you can put some things on a chalkboard that can you tell I grew up in Catholic schools in the 70s and 80s. I'm talking chalkboards. I'm sure the younger generation. I mean, this is like historical stuff. I have to remember that how old I am anyway. On the PowerPoint. On the PowerPoint, right? It's not that you can't put things on a chalkboard or on a PowerPoint that that can be helpful to us in learning how to love as Jesus loves. But ultimately learning how to love as Jesus loves is a question of the heart.
And this means we must expose our hearts to Jesus. We must make ourselves very vulnerable. We must put all of our questions and hopes and fears and sins and disordered desires in the light with Jesus. We must put our very bodies in the light with Jesus. Jesus himself says this. He says, put your whole body in the light. How much of your body needs to be in the light, Wendy? Your whole body? How much of my body needs to be in the light, Wendy? My whole body And, and, and, he says, don't let any part of your
body remain in the darkness. How much of my body should never remain in the darkness, Wendy? That was a weird question. What did I say? How much of my body should not remain in the darkness or what, how much of it, the entire thing, every part of my body should be in the light and no part of my body should be in the dark. That's true for you, Wendy. That's true for me. And that's true for my the person who has this question. And it's true for everybody listening this podcast, and it's true for everybody on the whole planet. If we want to learn how to be pure of heart, if we want to learn how to love as Jesus loves, we must bring our whole
body and every part of it into the light and every memory connected with every part of our body into the light. Now, I don't have a whole lot of memories connected with my pinky fingernail that I have to put in the light with Jesus, right? Maybe I could have some trauma associated with my pinky fingernail that I need to put in the light with Jesus. But the point of Jesus saying your whole body is he's, he's after the parts of our body where pain and memories and shame get stored. And he's saying, open that to
me. Open that to me. Let my light in. Let my love in. I want to reverse that shame you feel. Remember that experience you had when you were six years old and you first touched your genitals and and you felt pleasurable feelings. And then your mom walked in because you were sitting in the bathtub and she scolded you and she said, don't ever touch yourself there. That's dirty, that's bad, that's wrong. And you were like a turtle that went back into its shell. And and then, then the curiosity and the pain went underground
and it came out now in your bedroom when when it was late and your mom was already asleep. And now you're 12 years old and your your genitals are full attention and you didn't know what to do with yourself. And all that shame and pain was connected to it. And you started to masturbate and you learned how to masturbate and it felt good. And then you felt shame and pain and all that horrific stuff descended upon you. And then you discovered pornography. And then your heart got stirred and you don't know what the heck was up or down or backwards or forwards. And you just fell into addictive
behaviors and attitudes and diseased images and ideas in your body. Remember all that stuff? Yes, Jesus, I do. Open that to me. Open that to me. Remember that that night you were with your boyfriend and, and, and it felt good at the time and you thought maybe this was a genuine way of expressing affection. But then the next day you felt really shamed and, and, and, and didn't know what to do with yourself. Open that to me. Put it in the light with me. I want to enter into a loving
conversation with you about your heart and what you really long for and what your needs really are and what you were really looking for there and how the enemy got in the mix and confused you. Come to me, come to me, all you who are thirsty, come to me with your hunger and your thirst. Let me show you. Let me show you who you really are. This is how we grow in purity. You see how different that is, that journey, how different that journey is from here are the lines that you can never cross.
In this column, we have behaviors that you can do before you're married. In this column, we have behaviors you can't do. In this column, you can hold hands. In this column, you can maybe give a kiss. In this column, you XY OK. I don't care if all you're doing is holding hands. If you're holding hands because you have a selfish motive to get some kick out of it for your own selfish gratification, even if on the chalkboard that behavior showed up in the column, that
was OK before you got married. If you're doing it to please yourself in a selfish way, it's wrong. It's wrong. But we can't see that on a chalkboard. We have to expose our hearts. We have to come into the light. And what happens if we come to the light? Listen to this. Listen to what Jesus says next. Bring your whole body into the light and make sure no part of it remains in darkness.
And then your whole body. How much of your body, Wendy? Your whole body. Your whole body will illuminate you like a burning lamp. You see, when the Word became flesh, your flesh became Word. What the heck does that mean? When the Word became flesh, your flesh now brought into the light
of the world, which is the flesh of Jesus Christ, shining with all the glory of God. Your flesh now has the power and ability to reveal the Word of God, and that Word is the lamp unto your feet. Follow that lamp, Follow that light. Come into the light and you will not stumble. That's the path. Go for it. You know, in this episode, I I feel like I'm like encountering some of the like just the the
inspiration that can come on you when you're like speaking at, I don't know, like made for more or something like there's like an added juice. There is some juice going on. I don't know. Thank you Lord, for the juice. It's really beautiful. I felt it. I felt the juice. Yeah, I felt it. I'm so grateful to just, you know, that you're you're tuning into the Holy Spirit in those ways. It's really powerful. I just I do have, as you do,
just a gentleman love for this couple and all couples who are struggling with these very questions. And there's just a beautiful calling out of like, don't be in that legalistic mindset, but on the journey of the heart. And I think that in some ways, the question illustrates a certain being on the journey of the heart and you're just calling like the next several steps on that journey.
There's something amazing about them just having conversations about this because how many people are afraid to even bring it up? Like there's such a sincerity there of like we, we kind of have this shared value of wanting to really live theology of the body and we're not experiencing the freedom that we are hoping for where there's confusion or pain and, and even the very fact of like they
aren't both experiencing exactly the same reaction. You know, there is a gift there in that experiencing different reactions, although it can be kind of frightening, like, oh, wait, does that mean one of us is wrong since we don't feel exactly the same? I think the gift all in your relationship is that learning to honor one another and your differences and to be honest with one another about what you're feeling, even if it's not what the other expected or
hoped. Like, that's that's gold in the bank. Oh, you know, yeah. It is well said, Wendy. That is gold in the bank. To be able to communicate about those things. And certainly like, I think a loving response, at least in part, of all the things that you're talking about is, is the boyfriend taking like really taking that to prayer, praying
for the girlfriend and asking the Lord to give him a desire to just honor her heart and not. Not to be afraid of the difference that is coming up here. So I I just want to share that for further furthering the steps on the journey. Is that to recognize the gift that is here in this troubling situation. Isn't it beautiful when we recognize a troubling situation
as a gift? I need to hear that myself. So do I. So anyway, that's just what I wanted to share. I'm thinking of our listeners out there who are like, well, what about this and what about that? And I know how answers can stir more questions. And I just want to point you to a resource called Truthfully. Truthfully. Truthfully is a Catholic platform that is using all it is
good in modern technology with culling vast databases of Catholic teaching to give us solid answers to our faith. And I've said this before, I have some issues with artificial intelligence and I'm actually writing a book about some of the dangers of artificial intelligence. I'll say more about that on another podcast, but check out Truthfully if you have a question. They're a sponsor of our podcast and and they're doing really good work. They're putting that technology
to very good use. So check that out. If you are blessed by our show today, hit that share button and share it with somebody who needs to hear it. We all need to know that we're a gift in this world and that there is grace poured out from Christ to us that can enable us. To become what we are. Amen.
Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty. A list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found. In the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...