Is Physical Beauty a Distraction or a Gift?, Should I Refuse a Bridesmaid Dress That Violates My Modesty?, Is Trying to Conceive Killing Our Intimacy? | ACW338
If spiritual beauty is deeper and more important, does aesthetic beauty still have value? And why do we emphasize it with fashion or makeup? After embracing modesty through TOB, I feel convicted not to wear a revealing bridesmaid dress for a Catholic wedding. How do I honor my conscience without offending my cousin? Sex feels clinical and disconnected while trying to conceive. Am I wrong to want emotional connection even when we’re being practical? Resources: TOBI Event Calendar Love & Responsibility YouTube Series --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! --- Submit your question here! --- 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ Join us on one of our pilgrimages! If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org List of trusted counselors & psychologists
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Welcome everybody to another episode. We're happy to be with you today. And yes, we are. I had a very great gift given to me recently. Yes. Who did? I did, I did. Anybody who knows me well knows that I just can't understand my
life apart from the music of You 2, Bono, Larry, Adam and The Edge, These four guys from Ireland who've been making music now for almost 50 years. They first came together as a band in 1976. I discovered them in the early 80s as a teenager and I feel like I've been on a journey. Well, I have been, I've been on this. Any U2 fan will know this reference. It's a musical journey. I've been on this musical
journey with U2 since the early 80s and, and their music has just meant so much to me. You know, of course, anybody can pick apart Bono's politics and his theology, but this man's a believer. He, he, he believes in Jesus. I, I met Bono in 2005. We had a great exchange. I gave him a copy of Theology, the Body for Beginners. We had a lively conversation. Every other thing he said could
have been taken out of one of my books. Of course, every other other thing he said was wacky and weird and I don't agree with kind of comes with the territory of where he lives in the world he's part of. But here he is one of the biggest rock'n'roll stars in the world. And he he still confesses his faith in the incarnation of the second person in the Trinity boldly. And my gift was recently that there's a new movie called Stories of Surrender.
Bono did this stage play in which he enacted stories from his life and, and told stories about where the music comes from. And it was filmed and it's was released on Apple TVA few weeks ago, last month, at the end of last month. And I, I recently watched it and Oh my gosh, was I moved. He he, he just tells stories about his childhood growing up. His mother died when he was 14. His his dad never mentioned his mother ever again.
Like never mentioned her name again. And the pain of that in his teenage years is where the music was born and seeing him enact these stories on stage and and profess his faith to this. You know, this is Apple TV. This is a secular world that's going to be watching this. And he got a remember Wendy. We watched that interview or not interview, but a a little clip on YouTube. Where where? He was at an award ceremony. Yeah, it was at the the Cannes or Con Con movie Film Festival,
Film Festival, Cannes Film Festival. And he got a 5 minute standing ovation after the screening of this movie Stories of Surrender. It's it's striking a nerve and especially if you're AU 2 fan, you're going to want to see this. But if you want to just just see a human interest story told by an artist par excellence, the way he acts out these stories from his life and and yeah, the
way he professes his faith in the midst of it, it's very compelling. And it it brought me to tears. It was. Beautiful it was. It was very deep, meaningful gift. Christopher watched that on his own. I was just busy at the time and he just was. It was part of sort of a recovery from a trip. Often something artistic helps him to recover from a trip. But I remember you told me afterwards that it took a long time because it kept pausing because it was impacting you so much. It's so beautiful.
Yeah, it was It was profound. Yeah. I'll share just one more thing. There's this this story he tells of, of being on an operating table. This was 2016 when Bono had open heart surgery. And he he said it was the most frightening moment of his life. He said, I reached out for the one in whom I had placed my faith my whole life and he has his hand like reaching way out and he whispers Yeshua, Yeshua, Yeshua, the the Jewish word for
Jesus, Yeshua. And he said it was empty. There was silence. There was no response. And this is an experience of a lot of a lot of people who cry out to the Lord. And it just seems there's nothing there. Saints even talk about this. I'm not trying to say Bono's a St. but he had an experience that is not unusual in the life of of Saints where you cry out and you receive nothing in return.
And you might have thought this would be the end of Bono's faith, but then he sings a song right after that called Beautiful Day. But he changed the bridge and and in this bridge, it's a bold all declaration of I still got my faith that that that shook me. But I still believe there's there's an abyss that that we encounter when we encounter God. And his silence does not mean his absence. It can mean his presence in a different dimension than we ever imagined.
And and Bono in his own way, professes that kind of encounter. It's powerful, just saying. Yeah. Thank you for sharing about that. I wonder if you could share some updates from the TOB Institute for us. Yes, I will be making some international trips in the coming months and I just wanted to give our listeners a heads up because I know we have listeners from around the world. I am going to be in Brazil from August 21st to the 24th.
Check out in the link below to see if I'm coming to your town. And even if I'm not coming to your town, maybe I'm coming close enough that you could drive and come see us. We're going to be doing an all day seminar on love and responsibility and a few other events, an event called The Well. So this is brand new content that we're bringing to Brazil. We've been to Brazil many times in the past, but this is brand new content. So if you've seen us before, when we come to Brazil, come out again, we're going to take you brand new places.
Then in September, September 11th will be one night in London doing our event called The Well, which is about Eucharistic revival and how the theology of the body opens our eyes to the beauty and splendor and source and summit of our faith called the Eucharist. So check out that in our show notes. And then we're going from London to Germany that weekend. So the weekend after September 11th, we'll be in Germany doing a conference there.
Check out the link for details. Then I will be one more international trip before the end of the year. We'll be in Ecuador in early December and you can check out the dates and specific information about the events we're doing in Ecuador in the show notes as well. This is our first time ever to Ecuador. Never. We've been in many places in South America, but never to Ecuador. So we're very much looking forward to coming to to all those locations. And of course, we're doing our
tour in the fall for both our made for more events and our, we call it the well event. We will be all across the United States. So check out our whole calendar there for anybody living in the good old US of A. Very exciting it is. And now I have a question for you from a listener. So it's from a patron, an anonymous patron. Thank you, dear anonymous Patron, for all of your support of our mission. We're so grateful. Our first question is from 2
patrons. Father Daniel and Deborah are asking this together. Well, have we ever had such a joint question submitted? I'm not sure, but here it is. Thank you, Father. Daniel and Deborah, thanks for your support. Dear Christopher and Wendy, this is a question we've been discussing after taking the Way of Beauty course. What is the meaning of aesthetic beauty in the human person, in terms of proportions, shapes, colors? It is clear that there's a
difference from the rest of visible creation, and that the person owns a deeper beauty, the spiritual one, and a bodily 1 which is the fruit of love. Like the signs of motherhood or Christ's wounds, aesthetic beauty in the human person seems to be rather an obstacle to be skipped to see the real beauty. Does it still have a value in itself, even if embedded in a
deeper, integral beauty? Oh. This is very interesting. And what is the purpose of emphasizing it with makeup or nice clothes? I love this question because it gives us the opportunity to talk about one of my favorite subjects in the teaching of John Paul the second, which is what he describes as integral beauty, beauty of body and soul, united and integrated. And in this fallen world we are so prone to speak of.
And he, his, some of his language, their language kind of lended it to lend, lent itself to this interpretation that we have spiritual beauty over here, which is the deeper and more important kind. And then we have physical beauty over there, which is OK, How do we deal with that? Let's try to recognize it. We don't want to just throw it away, but it's this other thing. What I want to just shout from the rooftops is in the beginning it was not so right. This is the result of the rupture of original sin, this
rupture of the spiritual and the physical, where we think spiritual beauty is one thing over there and physical beauty is another thing over there. In the beginning, they were naked without shame, John Paul the Second tells us, because they experienced and appreciated each other's integral beauty as Incarnate persons. See, even some of the language in that question lent itself to the to an interpretation that
the person is the spiritual part and the person is kind of has this appendage called a body. Now, I don't, I don't want to accuse them of being guilty of, of that. Maybe they're not and maybe their language just wasn't nuanced enough. But, you know, maybe if I pushed him on it, they would say, no, no, no, that's not what we meant. But some of the language, we got to be really careful here. And it's really tricky to talk about this in such a way that we hold it all together.
The union of body and soul in the human person is so profound, says the Catechism, that the soul is the form of the body. It's, it's not, it's the, the body does not house the soul. It's more that the soul houses the body in the sense that it, it's the soul that, that, that that maintains the form of the body. You can't, you can't point to your soul other than to point at your whole body.
You know, symbolically, we might put our hand on our chest or something as a symbol of the heart, as the core of our humanity. Fine and dandy if that, if you understand that it's just a, a symbolic gesture, but you can point to your your left butt cheek and you're pointing to your soul. You can point to your pinky toe and you're pointing to your soul because your soul is the form of the body. And here's one way into that, one way to understand it. When the soul separates from the body at death, which by the way is horrific, was never meant to
happen, entirely unnatural. This is not normal. This is a cosmic obscenity that this ever happens, that body and soul ever separates. It is a cosmic obscenity, but it does happen in this fallen world. And when it does, when the soul separates from the body, the body deforms. It returns to dust. Why? Because the soul is the form of the body. Hmm. What we yearn for as human beings is integral beauty, the
integral beauty of the Incarnate person, the integral beauty of the unity of body and soul. This yearning is thwarted in a disintegrated world. And what happens in this disintegrated world is we tend to, to flip flop from 1 extreme to the other because we don't know how to, to, to integrate. We will cult, the cultural pendulum will swing from 1
extreme to the other. We'll, we'll, we'll go from just emphasizing the spiritual reality of the human being where we think the body is not significant. And we can see this in a lot of so-called Christian circles. The spiritual, let's just focus on the spiritual because why? Because we're responding to the secular culture, which has the pendulum away on the other side where we've idolized the body, where the body becomes a, a, a, a thing to be worshipped. And then in order to keep worshiping, worshipping it, we
have to pretend it doesn't age and it doesn't decay. And so we come up with all these medical procedures that aren't even real medicine. They're plastic surgery to to make a, a 65 year old woman look like she's still 25, which is odd. But all of that is fear of death, which is understandable because death is the ultimate disintegration. And our fear of that demonstrates that we really desire integration and we're afraid of the rupture. But we don't realize often times
that we're living in the rupture every single day of our lives. We live in this rupture. And that kind of worshipping of physical beauty can can make us want to go to the other extreme and just emphasize the spiritual. John Paul the Second says no. Both are integral to the person. Beauty of body and soul. Beauty of the marriage of body and soul. The beauty of the human person is the marriage of body and soul. And when we have eyes that are contemplative, what do I mean by
that? A contemplative gaze upon the world is what we lost with original sin. We, we, we came to have a profane gaze on the world with original sin. And let's look at both of these words. Profanum means outside the temple be or before the temple outside the temple. To profane something is to take it outside of the sacred right? We, we profane it well. A contemplative gaze means to
see within the temple and to even see all of creation as a kind of temple, especially the human person. Do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit? Now that use of the word body does not just mean the physical reality, it means the whole person, right? So when scripture speaks of of the redemption of the body, it's not just the redemption of the physical aspect. The body expresses the whole person in in scriptural
language, body refers to the whole reality of our humanity. So we are after what we seek. Is that integration Now, one of the questions was what role does makeup and accenting physical beauty? Can you read that part of the question again, Wendy? What is the purpose of emphasizing it with makeup or nice clothes? OK, So what is the IT? What does it refer to there in that? Question.
Aesthetic beauty. Aesthetic beauty. And so here he's Speaking of physical beauty. That which is visible that. Which is visible. But remember a contemplative gaze. When it looks upon what is visible, it also sees what is invisible. The body becomes transparent in such a way. John Paul the second says that that we we experience what he calls the peace of the interior
gaze where where the body itself becomes the window into the inmost mystery of our humanity. This is what we mean by integral beauty. A A world that is ruptured here will end up emphasizing one or the other. This is the point I've already been making. And and yeah, a world that focuses merely on externals is going to want to accent that to the extreme.
And we've already mentioned plastic surgery would be one of those extremes. But this does not mean accenting our physical beauty is itself a problem, right? It can lead, John Paul the second says, to an integral view of the person. If you are trying to accent your physical qualities in order to reinforce the rupture, in other words, in order to attract the kind of gaze that only looks
upon the physical and remains disintegrated, well, that would be the very definition of immodesty. But if you are dressing in such a way, doing your hair in such a way, caring for your appearance in such a way, including makeup, jewelry, etcetera, with the intention that the gaze upon the physical would lead to discover the integral beauty of the
person in the unity of body and soul. John Paul the second says, well, this is the raw material of love, right? That that attractiveness, that that initial attraction to the physical can become the occasion of going on the journey of integration. And, and I'll just speak as a man here. A man has a certain ability if he's in touch with his own heart and he's really on that journey of integration within himself.
A, a woman who is sending the signal of I just want you to objectify me. A man can pick that up or a, a, a, a different signal coming from the way a woman dresses, the way she holds herself. You could, you could have two women. Let me put it this way. Let's for the sake of the example, let's just say they're twins, right? So they look physically very, very much the same and they're dressing exactly the same. They have the same makeup on, they have the same hairdo, they have the same amount of jewelry, and they look the same, but
one's heart is immodest. One of the twins is intentionally dressing that way to elicit an objectivizing gaze that just stops at the physical and is not inviting the piece of the interior gaze. Where the other twin has been on a journey of integration. And her intention in wearing the very same outfit and the same kind of makeup and the same hairdo is to attract the integral gaze, the interior
gaze. A man who himself is on the journey of integration will be able to tell the difference in the very way that woman holds herself, in the way that that that very woman exudes her beauty. Is she using it to be objectified or she inviting subjectification, meaning to see her as an integral person? I just hold that out as as food for thought.
It's tricky to navigate all this stuff because we're ruptured. I've never seen a more nuanced and and and insightful description of what the journey towards integral beauty looks like and honoring the person rightly than in John Paul the Second's book Love and Responsibility. So please, please, if you want to do a deep dive on this dive into John Paul the Second's book Love and Responsibility. And if you find him reading him directly difficult, check out
the series that Matt Frat and I did on YouTube on Love and Responsibility. It's a six part series, each episode's a little over an hour, so you get close to 7 hours there. But if you really want to do a deep dive, the Theology of the Body Institute teaches a full 30 hour course on love and responsibility. We're doing it live. I Co teach it with Jeanette Clark. We're doing that in November this year, 2025, and you can also find it in our online schedule. One of my one of the things I
wanted to say was you keep saying what John Paul the Second says. Where does he say it? So now I'm thinking you revealed the answer in love and responsibility. But the the phrase integral beauty is also in theology of the body. Mm hmm. And do you remember what part of that? Yeah, it's in his reflections on the Song of Songs, where the bridegroom desires the integral beauty of the bride, and the bride desires the integral beauty of the bridegroom. And he has a beautiful reflection on how in our disintegrated humanity, it's
typical for the male to emphasize the physical beauty, and it's typical for the female to emphasize the interior beauty. But both are disintegrated, right? We can have this thought that the female perspective here, the typical female perspective, not that women aren't attracted to physical beauty and men aren't attracted to the interior beauty, but there's a, a, a general tendency in men to be more drawn to the physical, a general tendency in women to be more drawn to the interior beauty. John Paul is careful to point out that both are disintegrated, and men need to learn how to see
the interior beauty from a woman, right? Women, women can teach us how to see that, but women also need to learn how to appreciate the physical from a man. And you and I, Wendy, can attest to that in our own marriage, how we've helped one another toward that integration. No one can ever claim we've arrived, but we're journeying toward that integration. I've learned so much from you in that regard and has blessed me profoundly. I find questions like this where I feel like we're talking about
categories in philosophy and theology that are my brain isn't fully able to compute. I find them a little threatening. So I'm so glad you weren't threatened by their question because for me, like, oh boy, I don't know, I don't know how to speak on these things, but I, I just feel like, you know, sharing for myself that I, I think that it can be easy because of cultural messages for us to, if we're not the peak of beauty according to the culture,
to feel somehow inferior or envious of those who are that. And I think that is just a sign of our hearts being off, that we're believing a message and that message is communicated to us because it can 'cause us to spend money. I mean, really. Absolute at the bottom line. You know people want you to feel like crap about yourself. Some inferior money to that you want to remedy right and so that
I just see that you know the way that the desire of someone to make money ends up causing such pain in our interior. That's so unnecessary because the whole message that you have to match a certain standard of your appearance in order to have value is a lie and to to own yourself to say, Lord, you made me. You didn't give me that person's
body. You didn't give me that person's intelligence. You didn't give me that person's artistic gifts. You've made me, I'm, I'm myself and to trust in the goodness of that and to care for our bodies and our physical appearance out of a place of that dignity and desire to be a gift that we so often talk about. To be able to connect with other human beings, to be able to be trusted. Those are things that our physical appearance can facilitate that connection, that
trust, that interest, you know, whereas our physical appearance can kind of cause distance and disturbance. Well, like, where is that coming from? Like as the Lord works in our hearts, I hope that we come to a place of desiring to be connected to others because we're all part of the body of Christ and we have that sense I'm meant to be a gift of others. And I, I hope that our care for our appearance, knowing our, our
uniqueness is all part of God's beautiful plan. And if we come from that place of peace and trust in His gaze of love upon us, then, then we will care for our appearance in a way appropriate to our circumstances that enables us to be fully members of the body of Christ. That's how I see. It and these things go so deep. You talked to Wendy about coming to trust in the the good and the
beautiful person God made me to be. Whether or not I I meet the standard of the culture and that that's standard of the culture. Those messages from the culture get in at a very, very young age. If you don't look like this, if you don't have this type of physique, male and female, those things, those messages go deep. Lord, we ask you, please, please cast out the lies that we have
believed about our bodies. Cast them out and show us how you see our integral beauty and give us that contemplative gaze to see ourselves and to see others as you see them, and even to see the beauty of the person in the ugliness of this world. Like Mother Theresa, I'm thinking of who, who had to overcome the natural aversion to that maggot infested person who
was dying in the gutter in Calcutta. Of course there's an, there's a, a natural aversion to that. But she prayed for that contemplative gaze that she could see Jesus in that person. And that enabled her to bend over and pick up a, a maggot infested, rotting, of course, horrifically smelly, rotting human being and love that person and see Christ. That contemplative gaze becomes
a way we see everyone, everyone we come, we. The goal should be to see others as Christ sees them. I, I, I had this experience a few weeks ago. I'll just share this and then we'll move on. And I may have shared this recently on another episode. I can't remember. Forgive me if I've already shared this, but I, I was dealing with this vision, my own false vision, profane vision of the body where you take it out
of the realm of the sacred. And the song that kind of came to my mind that epitomizes the way the world teaches me to see or fail to see is I wish they all could be California girls, right? I wish every girl looked like this. Well, the prayer should not be, I wish they all could be California girls. The prayer should be, I wish that I could see God in every
girl. That's the contemplative gaze. That's the contemplative gaze, and that's the conversion that has to happen in our hearts. Lord, open my eyes to see your image in every human being. Give us that contemplative gaze. Yeah. And I also just encourage every one of us, as we've heard this discussion, like to look at yourself and and ask the Lord to help you to see yourself and as
he sees you, that beauty. Hello. Hello everybody. This is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on tour this year. We're going to places like New Mexico, Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Illinois, and also other countries like Ecuador and Brazil. We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our event schedule in the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Peace. Our next question is from a listener named Jess. Hi, Jess. Hi Christopher and Wendy. I attended TOB one and two in
person last summer and I'm so excited to be attending TOB in the New Evangelization this July. See you. Very soon, Jess. Though I'm a cradle Catholic, my deeper conversion came a few years ago after discovering theology of the body. Before that, I often dressed in more revealing clothing, but during TOB 2 during Adoration, I had a powerful moment of prayer where I felt called to begin wearing a veil at Mass and whenever I'm in the presence of the Eucharist. While veiling wasn't explicitly touched on in the TOB 2 course,
the beauty of Christ's spousal love for the Church and the way women reflect His bride moved me deeply. That moment marked a shift not just in how I dress for Mass, but in how I live out the dignity of my body day-to-day. Since then, I've found deep peace in dressing more modestly, not out of shame or prudery, but out of love, reverence, and a desire to witness to the truth of the body. Recently my cousin asked me to be a bridesmaid in her Catholic
wedding. The bridesmaids dress she chose is extremely revealing with a low neckline, open back, and high slit. I don't feel comfortable wearing it at all and especially not for the sacredness of the mass. She's not a practicing Catholic and may not understand my concerns. I'm torn. If I asked to alter the dress, wear something different or cover up, it may upset her or ruin the aesthetic look in pictures, but staying silent feels like compromising my
conscience. Do you have any advice? How can I navigate this with both charity and integrity, not as a holier than thou conversation? Bless you, dear Jess. And I'm I'm amazed at how what I was sharing in the previous question is applicable here. No, Jess, I, I don't, you didn't send in a, a picture of the dress. I, I, I don't, I'm so I'm kind
of just speaking in the dark here. So it could be like, I could imagine a, a type of dress that would just be not appropriate. It would be like not appropriate. And and that would, that would, that would call forth a different response from me. But I am guessing that this might be one of those borderline situations where where the dress might reveal a little more skin
than you would naturally want to wear. But I, I'm, I'm, I'm going to just hope and assume it's, it's not horrifically revealing. I don't even like that expression. Horrifically revealing because there's nothing horrifying about the human body. The the horror is not the human body. This is this is a really important point. I'm going to spend a moment on this. The horror here of immodesty is not that the body is being revealed. The horror of immodesty is that
the true beauty and sacredness of the body is being put before those who don't know how to uphold that true beauty and sacredness and is being most likely, you know, put before. Let's put it this the way we discussed in the previous address, those who do not see with a contemplative gaze, those who see with a profane gaze, right? We veil what is holy to protect the holy from those who don't
know how to honor the holy in the right way, right? So we must never, must never assign immodesty to the body itself, or shame or sin to the body itself. The body itself is not immodest. The body itself is not shameful. The body itself is not the problem. The problem is the way we, as fallen human beings, fail to appreciate the value, dignity, and sacredness of the human
body. That just needs to be plainly said. So remember Jess in the previous question when I was talking about that hypothetical situation of the the twin sisters who were wearing the same outfit and dressing the same way and all the makeup and jewellery was the same, but one was modest and the other was immodest because of what was going on in the heart. Perhaps the intention of your cousin is not well informed. Perhaps her intentions a little off. She just doesn't know. Can you imagine wearing this
dress with a a modest heart and a modest disposition and exuding that invitation for others to gaze upon you in an integral way? Can you imagine that it could be possible? Now, you might. And this is a decision that only you can make because I, I don't, I don't have a picture of this dress before me. And I don't know exactly how much of it is, you know, how revealing it is. But if, if, if you come to the conclusion, no, even with my modest heart, I would be
inviting gazes that are inappropriate, then I think you would have to, I think you would have to bite that bullet and, and endure whatever persecution might come to stand up for your own dignity and say, I'm just not comfortable wearing that. Or perhaps wear the dress with a, a Shaw over your shoulders or
some. Can you wear the dress and something in addition to, to aid your own conscience there and your own proper sense of propriety, not knowing enough about the dress? I would, that's all I can say. It's it's going to be one or the other. I think it's in as much as you could go with a modest heart and attract the right kind of gaze just by exuding a proper heart. If you can go that direction, go that direction. If you can't go that direction because too much of your own
beautiful feminine humanity is on display and you just feel fundamentally uncomfortable with that, could you wear a Shaw? Could you, could you accent it in such a way? If not, I think you would have to deal with the, the fallout and, and, and witness to your cousin in a gentle way such that you're not holier than thou. But it could spark a, a really important conversation. Like maybe you could go out and and spend a day with your cousin where it's not just a Hey, I
need to talk to you about something in in a 10 minute conversation. But day where you, you just say, I want to share more of my own heart, some of my own story, some of my own journey and tell her, tell her the story that you've told us that you used to to dress more revealingly and you've come to a new appreciation. And you're not coming from a place of prudery. You're not coming from a place of shame, but Share your story. Share your experience of the dignity that you have come to discover about your own body and see if that ignites a a a
conversation where she can understand where you're coming from and is willing to meet you there. You know, I, I feel like that was really just a helpful word about sharing the story that really struck me because that is her concern is, you know, how do I bring this up to her? And I, I do think if she concludes that she can't wear it
or needs to change it in such a way that it could, you know, be noticed and bring, you know, some stress or conflict in the relationship, I think she will need to talk about it. And but I love that about sharing the story and, and building the relationship and, and being known. I think something that can also be helpful, at least it's helpful to me, as is the acknowledgement that like the
desire to be pretty or beautiful is, is a good desire. Like it's not something that is just all from the fall. Amen. It's gotten twisted, but it's it's good. Like it's just as we want to, you know, plant flowers or clean our house or anything that we want to make beautiful. There's a nobility to that. There's a sense of just the high calling of humanity to reflect
God's beauty that we feel in us. So I know it just got a little theological there, but I I say it for your sake that you can acknowledge a goodness in your cousin's desire to have everyone wearing. This pretty dress because I assume to her it is pretty and I think whatever her mindset is, you know, you said she's not a practicing Catholic. So you know, it's probably not informed by the same things that
are informing your sense of beauty. But but there is something to affirm and to say like it's I want your day to be beautiful. And I see this is so pretty and different things that you can say that speak to that heart where it is on its journey and it's not false. You know, it's it's affirming God's image in her that yes, is twisted. But I think it that in combination with sharing your story could be fruitful if you
conclude that it even needs to be talked about. And that's a very good point, Wendy, that there even when we're off and and I think it's probably safe to assume that your cousin is to some degree off here, but it's the distortion of a good, there is a good desire underneath it that can be affirmed and that can help and go a long way in your cousin realizing she's not coming at me. She's not holier than thou. She's not condemning me.
She start with those affirmations and then tell your story. I think it'll go a long, long way. We lift up Jess and her cousin and all those bridesmaids in this wedding. We ask Lord that you would speak to Jess's heart and showing her the proper path forward and that her cousin would know that Jess is coming one way or the other. She's coming with love in her heart and a modest heart that wants true feminine beauty to
shine in all the right ways and never for true feminine beauty to be looked upon as an object for fallen humanity's selfish desires. We place these intentions in the womb of the Blessed Mother, and we ask all of this in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Yes. Amen. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Dear Christopher and Wendy, thank you both for your beautiful podcast. It has been such a blessing in my life and offered compassionate and loving answers
to so many questions I've had over the years. Oh good, that warms my heart to know it. My husband and I have been married for a year and a half. We've been intentional about trying to conceive for a few months now and I'm struggling more than I expected with how different sex feels mentally and emotionally when we're trying to conceive. It feels very medical and practical when I know I'm ovulating, and it makes me sad to think about a child resulting from a union that wasn't special
when they have two married parents that love each other so much. It also scares me because sex with my husband has always been loving and fun and a source of connection in our marriage and this feels different even though we've never used contraception and have been open to life from the start. I brought this up to my husband and he was confused and frustrated. He says sex can't always be like the movies. Sometimes it's practical or quick or for the purposes of
trying to conceive. I was left feeling misunderstood and even more unsure about how to come together when I next ovulate. My question is this, is there anything wrong with coming together practically to have a baby or is that using your spouse? I can be a perfectionist, so am I expecting too much here? Christopher, I love when you acknowledge that Wendy's heart intuits things. As a woman, is my heart trying to tell me something? Thank you so much for this very
honest question and I, I can just feel all the practical realities of the marriage bed coming to the fore here. Every married couple journeys through these kind of questions. Every married couple who has a sensitive heart, put it that way, journeys through these questions. And I do believe, I do believe your heart is sensitive to something very important. Now let me just also affirm
something your husband said. I think there's at a minimum an element of truth in what he's saying that might be an important corrective to your tendency towards perfectionism which you've admitted that you know, every marital embrace is not going to be skyrockets in flight afternoon delight, to quote an old 70s song. There are, there are, there are times when for whatever reason, you know, physiologically,
emotionally, it might not be as emotionally bonding or ideally pleasurable as we might hope or desire to be. And we can draw an analogy here. Think of the consummation of the marriage of Christ in the Church, in the Eucharist. When we go to the Eucharist, there are occasions when we have profound interior experiences of consolation and spiritual delights and joy, and our faith is alive and it feels deeply
affirmed and confirmed. There are other times we go and we receive the Eucharist and the feelings are not attending to the experience, and that does not diminish the profundity of the experience. The profundity of the experience and the power of the experience and the beauty of the experience of receiving the Lord and the Eucharist is not dependent on our emotional experience of receiving the Eucharist. There is an analogy here with the marriage bid and and I think
your husband is getting at that in his saying hold on, hold on it. It doesn't always have to be this you know I ideal reality. There are different occasions and experiences of the marital embrace and married life and and that doesn't Rob essentially from the sacredness of it all. I would affirm that. However, I would also affirm, dear sister, that you are on to something very, very important. John Paul The second says if the only reason a married couple is
coming together is to conceive, if that is the motivation and that is what's bringing them together, we want to conceive. Today's a good day to conceive. We're coming together now in order to conceive. There is a danger, that's his word, a danger. It's not a certainty, but there is a danger that a husband and a wife would end up using one another as a means to an end. And in John Paul the Second's
language, the opposite of loving is not so much hatred. The opposite of loving is to use another as a means to an end. I want you to listen to this. This is from John Paul the 2nd and his book Love and Responsibility. He says the spouse's intention and attention in conjugal intercourse should be directed toward the other person, toward the spouse's true good. And my intention as a spouse should be that of affirming my spouse's true value.
It is not proper, he says, to direct this intention and attention toward the possible consequences of the act of intercourse that is conceiving a child, especially if this means turning 1's attention and intention away from one's spouse. So I think your heart is sensitive to that. The marital embrace should always be the expression of a desire to affirm the goodness of
the other and to deepen the marital bond. Whether or not a child is conceived is always in the hands of God. If the explicit intention is solely, we're doing this to conceive, there is a danger that one or the other is going to be treated as a means to an end, and a sensitive heart will feel that and rightly resist it. So I think you probably are feeling that and you you are rightly resisting that. And I think also, if I could
just add, like so often, what Christopher and I can see in the stories that are shared, that can be hard to see when you're living the story. And by the way, we have that same problem. We can't always see what's going on in our own lives, but as outsiders, we can see the opportunities for grace. And in my sense also, if you're sharing, if you've been maybe having reason to avoid pregnancy
up to a certain time in your marriage and are newly no longer avoiding that fertile time, just in your growth as a human being. Like this is a first. This is a it's a new thing, even though it's it's been the expression of your marriage from the beginning. There's something new here and it on unconscious levels of your being. It could be deeply, you know, just attention getting like,
wow, this is different. We are uniting and we know that I could be fertile. We could be fertile, like, and I think there can be like just a part that's kind of adjusting to the newness that is finding that a little difficult to adjust to. So I just want to mention that as well. Like if you are feeling these concerns and cautions and oh, Oh no, I don't want to conceive a baby if I was distracted and distressed in the union because like that's not as beautiful to
me or somehow like to let all of that be an opportunity for grace to just to know yourself more to let the Lord show you like what's what is going on in my heart? Why am I sort of feeling like this is a an attempt to accomplish a goal of conceiving a baby, which in our world has gotten more and more removed from the expression of married people's love so far removed. It's so perverted in the culture
at this point with, you know, all this talk about promoting in vitro fertilization and surrogacy and just these removal of the conception of life from its proper context, that it is not surprising to have a, a maybe somewhat different view of what you are doing and not see the continuity with the expression of your marriage throughout your whole marriage. So I just want to acknowledge like there could be things the Lord is pointing at your own heart to uncover and discover.
Let him speak to you about what's inside there and and help you in your journey into just this new stage of your marriage where there is an ability to come together during all phases of your cycle. And as Christopher read from the Our Holy Father, John Paul the Second, the the continuity of that intention to be focused on loving your spouse and leaving the result of that in the hand of God is so helpful.
And she said something about not not even wanting to conceive or sad that she might conceive under these circumstances. How did she? Yeah, it makes me sad to think about a child resulting from a union that wasn't special when they have two married parents that love each other so much. Yes, yes, yes. Every conception of a child is incredibly beautiful. Every I That does not mean the act wasn't necessarily beautiful. We all know children can be conceived in very ugly acts.
But when that sperm meets that egg, there is a decision by the living God to bring a new life into being. And that God, everything God does is beautiful, especially the creation of a new human life. And guess what? None of us were conceived in an ideal marital act because there is no ideal marital act on planet earth. In this fallen world, we're always bringing our fallen humanity into the marriage bed with us. That's not some excuse not to
look at it or not to open it to God's mercy. But we can trust in our own goodwill. You can trust in the goodwill of your husband. You can trust in your own goodwill. You're not perfect. Your husband's not perfect, but you're coming together in goodwill and you're coming together with an openness to God's life, giving power and love. And he can, he can write straight with our crooked lines. And he does. And he, he longs to bring about his most beautiful creative act,
even when our marital embrace is not ideal. Again, and this is not it's to say we shouldn't strive to grow in in perfection. We absolutely should in the marriage bed should be a place where we really strive to grow in an ever deeper love. But don't let the fact that you're not there yet be a source of discouragement. John Paul the second puts it this way. He says love never is. It is always only just becoming.
So there's that's the journey, that's the pilgrimage. This is why we, we, I, I love this song. I love the sentiment of the song. I love you more today than yesterday, but not as much as tomorrow. That's a right sentiment. That's that's a person on pilgrimage. That's a person whose love is becoming. So be confident. Your love is becoming. The Lord is with you. And what it's becoming is more
and more the gift that it's meant to be. This is who we are. This is what we are. This is who God is. God is gift. We're made in the image and likeness of God, who is gift, who is love. This is the deepest meaning of masculinity and femininity, to become that gift. We all know we fall short of it, but God's grace is abundantly present to enable each and every one of us. To become what we are. Let's do that. Yeah. I love you more today than yesterday, Wendy. Thanks. Not as much as tomorrow. I believe it.
I'm looking forward to tomorrow me. Too. Ask Christopher W. It's brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...