Heartbreak and God's Plan, Morality of Body Hair and Medical Ethics, and Understanding Foreplay in Marriage | ACW323
52 minAudio
Questions answered this episode: I'm a 25-year-old man, called by God to marriage. Two years ago, I met a girl who helped in the same parish as me, and I fell in love with her. After a few months, we spoke about it, but she kindly rejected me. We lost contact, and I went through a deep crisis of faith. I felt abandoned, extremely and hopelessly alone. After a time, I came back to her city, and we served again together in the same parish. Shortly after, she broke up with her boyfriend and asked me to continue our friendship. She made it clear that although she was open to us having a romantic relationship, I should not expect any concrete outcome to the friendship. I accepted the challenge, and for a year, we struggled to learn to love each other as close, tender friends, embracing with all our hearts whatever God would want from us. Together, we tried to follow the example of Francis and Clare of Assisi. Recently, she told me that she felt the call to consecrated virginity and decided to go to another country to discern this more intensely. My heart reacted to this news with immense joy. I experienced my friendโs happiness as my own and felt the grace of God flowing from her heart. This friendship has healed the wound of that hopeless loneliness I felt when she first rejected me. My deepest desire is her happiness, and I know she will find it - whether with Christ or even with another man. But somehow, the secondary desire remains - that she would be the mother of my children and the companion of my dreams. I know weโve experienced something rare and wonderful, yet I ask myself if any woman will ever fall erotically in love with me. What would your advice be to heal this wound? Is there any Catholic teaching concerning body hair? Is it immoral to be waxed in certain places, considering that it involves exposing oneself to the person doing the waxing? Secondly, I'm in law school and learning about criminal procedure. One of my classes was discussing a rape case and having to collect semen samples from several different suspects. That led to me pondering the morality of collecting semen samples, also like for medical purposes, and what a Catholic approach to that would be in light of our teachings. My husband and I have been married for 20 years, have four kids, and have always used natural family planning. I recently heard on a Catholic podcast that any type of making out is sinful unless it is meant as foreplay and must end in intercourse. I always thought foreplay was morally permissible as long as it does not lead to climax by either person or incomplete sexual intercourse. Could you please clarify? I would hate to think we've been offending God our whole marriage but would rather be corrected now than never. Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul IIโs beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. ๐ฅ Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body ๐ Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) โก๏ธ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: COURSE SCHEDULE JPII Legacy Foundation Website Good News About Sex & Marriage ๐ฅ Check out our YouTube Channel ๐ View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! ๐ GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. โท๏ธ Join Christopher on a ski trip to Utah Click here ๐๏ธ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here ๐ For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast Hi podcast listeners. Hey everybody. I want to tell you something. I'm sitting here with my favorite person in the world. Am I your? Favorite you are. I'm married to you and I'm so grateful. Just wanted to tell you that tell the world that that you're my favorite person. Thank you, Wendy. Yeah, that's giving me tingly feelings.
Like I felt like a little boy in school, like a girl just said he was cute or something and I got all tingly. You're cute. Well, thank you. Now I'm thinking of Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer. When? What was that other reindeer's name? Clarice. Clarice When Clarice tells Rudolph he's cute and he goes and flies for the first time, she said I'm cute, I'm cute. He has that thing on his nose. I'm cute, I'm cute.
I feel like I could fly. Thanks, Wendy. You're my favorite person in the world too. Thank you my love. You're welcome. We have a fun thing happened in our family right now. Our two youngest, Isaac, who's 18, and Grace who's 16, are in the local production at their high school of Godspell. Now they're homeschooled but are here in Pennsylvania. Our public school system welcomes homeschoolers for activities like the play. And all our kids have done plays
at the local high school. And the the director of these shows knew that this particular group of kids, this is a public high school, But this particular group of kids who are, you know, into theater there, most of them are, are very committed Christians, either Catholic or evangelical Christians. And this guy who's the director purposely chose Godspell at a public high school because he wanted to bless this group of
Christians, including our two kids. And our son Isaac got the lead role of Jesus. And our daughter Grace plays one of the disciples and has some lead role singing in this production. And we are really excited about it. Particularly for me, this was a big part of my childhood. My mom had the Godspell record from the 70s. And I was sharing with you, Wendy, as we're hearing these songs in the house because the kids are practicing them.
I think this was my first presentation of the message and teaching of Jesus was hearing the Godspell record in the early 70s. And those songs got into my bones and I'm really, really thrilled. By the time we record our next episode, we will have seen the production. So we're excited to share with you on the other side, everybody what what it was like. But it's just fresh in our minds right now because our kids are are off in rehearsal right now and they are working so, so hard
getting ready for this production. Yeah, it's, it's wonderful. Do you have any updates for our listeners about Theology of the Body Institute? I do. We are approaching our summer schedule of courses. We have some online courses between now and the summer. There is a sexual ethics course coming up taught by Father Koopman. He does a great, great job that that's an online course, but the courses we are offering live in person in our five day retreat
format. This summer I'm teaching Theology the Body level 1, June 15th to the 20th. I'm teaching Theology of the Body and the New Evangelization in I think it's the second week of July. I don't know what exactly those dates are, but that is a tour through the catechism with our TOB glasses on. This is one of my favorite courses to teach, cause the faith just comes alive when we go through the catechism with our TOB glasses on. So yeah, yeah, yeah, that's
please, please. Well, you have to have taken TOB one to take this New Evangelization course 'cause you have to have those glasses on going into that course. And then in August, my esteemed colleague and dear brother and friend Bill Donaghy is teaching his favorite class to teach. It's only the second time he's taught it. He calls it Poets for the Kingdom, and he looks at the stories of JRR Tolkien and CS Lewis through the lens of
theology, the body, and they come alive in beautiful, beautiful ways. I took that course when he he taught it the first time. It was amazing. You're going to love it. So check out the link for all of our summer courses. And if if money is an obstacle, please apply for a scholarship. We never want money to get in the way of people coming to our courses. And if you are able to support our scholarship fund through the Saint John Paul the Second Legacy Foundation, this is where we raise money for scholarships for our students.
Could you please click that link in our show notes? Show newts a show Newt. How about that? What is a show Newt in the show notes? And that will go a long way to enabling us to provide scholarships for students are who are really in need. Yeah, and if you're a podcast listener and you come to a course, you must come say hello to me and let me know you're a podcast listener because that is a great joy for me to get to me. Yes, I we. Live just a mile from the
retreat center where we offer these courses so Wendy shows up for meals and you'll get to say hello to her. You ready for a question? We are ready. I am ready. This is Are you ready? Yeah, We had that was like the Pontifical we we are ready. It's it's bad when we, like start out giggling because sometimes the questions are really serious. Yeah, I think think this this will be an OK transition, but I'm just acknowledging that sometimes that can be a little
rough. Sorry friends, if we we don't want. To throw we off us. This is from a patron named Louise. Louise. Bless you, Louise. I'm a 25 year old man called by God to marriage. Two years ago I met a girl who helped in the same parish as me and I fell in love with her after a few months. We spoke about it, but she kindly rejected me.
We lost contact and I went through a deep crisis of faith. I felt abandoned, extremely and hopelessly alone. After a time, I came back to her city and we served again together in the same parish. Shortly after, she broke up with her boyfriend and asked me to continue our friendship. She made it clear that although she was open to us having a romantic relationship, I should not expect any concrete outcome
to the friendship. I accepted the challenge, and for a year we struggled to learn to love each other as close, tender friends, embracing with all our hearts whatever God would want from us. Together we tried to follow the example of Francis and Claire of Assisi. Recently she told me that she felt the call to consecrated virginity. Wow, And that she'd decided to go to another country to discern this more intensely. Well, my heart reacted to this news with immense joy.
Wow. I experienced in myself my friend's happiness. Louise, Go. Go. Go, brother, go. And I felt the grace of God flowing from her heart. Yeah, I feel the grace of God flowing through your heart, brother. This friendship has healed the wound of that hopeless loneliness I felt when she rejected me a long time ago. My deepest desire is her happiness, and I know with Christ or even with another man
she will find it, but somehow the secondary desire that she be the mother of my children and the companion of my dreams. Oh. Man. Remains. Oh man, I know we've experienced something rare and wonderful, yet I ask myself if any woman will ever fall erratically in love with me. What would your advice be to heal this wound?
Wow Louise, brother, what a pilgrimage you have been on. What an amazing journey. He's only 25 years old. That's amazing. Yeah, I just want to sing God's praises for the generosity of your yes brother. I I hope our listeners are taking this in. What a what an amazing pilgrimage you have been on. I did not think it was going to go this direction when when you
Wendy, were reading the question and you were talking about his or reading his report of his falling into despair after being rejected by this woman. What an amazing opportunity for healing and and what an incredible purifying journey you have been on to get to a place of despairing that rejection and feeling that wound to allowing your heart to open again and
become one of generous selfless love for this woman. It's the real deal brother. That is the real deal and I feel it changing the world like like this is world changing love. This is how the world heals. This is how the world changes. This is how like tectonic plates are shifting. Like that's that kind of love because it's Christ's love. There's no human explanation for this kind of love.
This kind of love comes from a human heart that has opened to Christ. That's where it comes from. That's where that kind of love comes from, and that is tectonic plate shifting kind of love. Wow. But yes, of course I understand after all of this, and it's interesting how he put it, this, he called it a secondary kind of desire. Yeah, of course that's still there. That's human. Of course it's still there. In fact, I, I wouldn't believe
it if it weren't still there. So I thank you just for, for, for your humanity here, your humanity open to grace. That's what this is. This is humanity open to grace. So I can't even remember the question. Can you get to the can you reread? Reread the last sentence where he said he asked the question. I'm I'm so taken by all the other parts of what you read. Yeah, I ask myself if any woman will ever fall erotically in
love with me. What would your advice be to heal this wound? Who I well, I can't answer the question if a woman will ever fall in love with you and want to bear your children and and be 1 flesh with you in the marriage bed. I, I, I can't have any way of answering that question. But I do know this brother. And this is, this is not just a platitude like I even before I say it, I know the danger is that it sounds like I'm just
trying to spiritualize everything. And I am not trying to spiritualize anything. I'm, I'm trying to speak a truth that is more real than the reality in which we live day-to-day. Heaven is more real than this reality. And there is a woman already existing on the other side in her fully redeemed bodily humanity, right?
This woman, her name is Mary. She is participating bodily in the eternal ecstasy and bliss of the Trinity. She has a love for you, brother. That is everything you desire in a woman. And if that sounds weird, I'm sorry. We need to work through whatever issues we need to work through to get to the point where that makes beautiful sense and is not funky or weird or out of alignment with with all that we know to be true about purity and
chastity and goodness and holiness. But see, here's the problem. We often think of purity as the negation of sexuality. No, no, no, no purity. Chastity is not the negation of sexuality. It is the perfection of sexuality. Mary being the Immaculate 1 does not mean she had no sexual feelings, does not mean she never experienced erotic desire. It means she experienced her sexuality perfectly. She experienced it without any rupture or disintegration.
She experienced it without any disordered desires. She experienced an Eros that was perfectly directed towards its true object, which is the living God, which enabled her to love her husband Joseph with a tender particular spousal love. This is, this is just bedrock truth, right? It's a virginal love. But virginal here does not mean
the absence of something. Virginal here means the perfection of everything, right? They didn't engage in sexual intercourse because sexual intercourse is not the perfection of of Eros. The perfection of Eros is the marriage of the Lamb. The perfection of Eros is the consummation of the marriage between heaven and earth. And Mary is already living that marriage. To have had sexual relations with Joseph would have been a step backwards. Instead, she took Joseph with him, a step forward into that utterly glorious reality.
And here's the thing. I needed to say all that to get to this. There is a woman, Luis. There is a woman who loves you with a holy, passionate, unadulterated Eros, and her name is Mary. It's a holy, passionate, unadulterated Eros that is at one in the same time an Eros that expresses a perfect agape
that's sacrificial, divine love. She's real. She is more real than any woman walking on this planet. And she loves you in a holy, passionate way, my brother. And she wants to reveal to you in a holy obviously, she's Mary. She's the mother of God. She's holy in everything she does. She wants to reveal a holy vision of her passion and love for you.
She wants to show you the mysteries of her femininity that brought God to us in the flesh. Obviously there is a veil here. There's a veil here that we have to respect, obviously. But Mary, Mary, I don't. How do I even put this? She, she wants to show herself to you. She wants to reveal her glorified femininity to you.
She wants to reveal to you her Immaculate Heart. She wants to reveal to you the secret within her womb, where, where, where Christ was conceived, where we also are regenerated. She is truly our mother, obviously, but Scripture, this is the wisdom literature of Scripture. And this is this, this, this wisdom literature is embodied in Mary. It says wisdom will come to you like a mother.
That's Mary. And then it also says this wisdom will come to you like a bride. She will embrace you like a bride. Wisdom will come to you like a mother. Wisdom will come to you like a bride in Scripture and in the way the Saints have understood the Scriptures and as they apply to Mary. There is no contradiction here between Mary having a a motherly role and a spousal kind of role in our lives. If we are other Christs, we also
in whether we're married or consecrated or single. I'm speaking for men here. We are other Christs and we are to, to marry the Church, right? Just as every woman is meant to enter into a spousal relationship with Christ, every man can have a kind of a kind of spousal intimacy with Mary in, in a, it's gosh, even as I say it, I know I'm going to be misunderstood and it's going to be taken out of context.
And so I have to qualify it. And and I, all the necessary qualifications that make this something holy, sacred and beautiful are solidly in place in my heart as as I, as I try to explain this. Not that I'm perfect at at it all. I am not. But but I know what the I, I, I know what the dangers are here. And I also know that we are called to enter into a, a profound motherly and in some dimension sisterly and in some
other dimension bridal. She's a bride, she's a spouse, and we can enter into relationship with Mary at all of those levels. How do I know that? Because Christ did. Christ did. Mary's always going to be Christ's mother, but the fathers of the Church had no problem recognizing that in the flesh she's his mother. But in these deeper mystical dimensions, especially at the foot of the cross and at the wedding of Cana, whenever Jesus calls Mary woman, she's standing in the place of the New Eve. She's the new bride of the new
Adam. She's also Christ's sister in the same humanity. Mother, sister, bride. If it's true of Christ, it's true of each of us. We can have a motherly, a sisterly, and a spousal kind of relationship with the Blessed Mother where she she in a holy, beautiful, sacred way, reveals to us what Saint Louis De Montfort calls the secret of Mary, the secret of Mary. So, Louis, that's probably the best way I can put it.
Mary wants to reveal to you her secret. Ask her what that is and read a little booklet by Louis du Montfort called The Secret of Mary. Or read my book Heaven's Song, where I unpack the secret of Mary. Or take the Marian mystery course that we offer at the Theology of the Body Institute, where where we unfold all week long, the secret of Mary. And I think you will find what your heart desires in that woman. That's the only thing I can promise you that Mary wants to reveal her holy, holy love for
you, that I can promise you. I can't promise you that any other woman on this planet will do that. But I can also say this by opening your heart to Mary, by letting her reveal her secret to you, by opening that pain of of longing for that feminine love to marry. That's how you'll heal my brother. That's how you'll heal. I have this image of Luis going with Mary and and in this image Mary's kind of young to a garden
and and he's holding in his hand. Luis's like a a bulb that that contains all these amazing graces in this this relationship that like. The bulb of a flower. Yeah, yeah, the yeah, sorry, did sound like that could have been a light bulb. No, sorry. A a bowl, a flower bulb or plant bulb. Yeah. That it's all it's this beautiful, just like condensed,
powerful grace that is, is the story of God's working in this friendship. And and he's holding that and going with Mary to a garden. And together they're they're digging in the soil and planting that grace filled bulb deep in the soil. And then and then together, they're, they're putting the dirt back over it and trusting that, that in God's mysterious way, it's going to grow.
And, and it's that unknown. And yet it's, there's like a, a sweetness between Louise and Mary as they just trust all that grace that's been already poured into his life. And his story at this age is there's much more to come. And it's, it's not for Louise to to know yet what how that plant will grow, but but to be grateful for it and to be
grateful that it's it's safe that Mary and he are, are together keeping those graces safe and and prepared for their next step in his life. Awesome. That's the image I have. Wendy, I love, love that image. That image of the bulb is so potent and powerful. I, I want to rest with that myself for my own prayer. So thank you for that. I, I want to add one more thing
because what I'm saying here about a possible spousal dimension to our devotion to Mary as men may be new to you, Luis. It may be new to our listeners. And if that's causing any, you know, confusion or what, I've never heard that before. If you want to learn more, I'm going to have an article in the show notes here written by a Monsignor John Siak. It was written for priests, but it has application to any man in his devotion to the Blessed
Mother in that dimension of, yes, Mother, Sister, but also Spouse. And how Mary's holy, perfect, unadulterated Eros can heal the heart of a man. It's one of the best articles I've ever read. We'll have the link in the show notes. Awesome. Our next question is from a listener named Sophie. Hi, Sophie. My boyfriend and I have been using your podcast as a
wonderful source of discussion. Awesome, I like that idea. He and I are both very fascinated with the theology of the body and John Paul the Second's works and have found that to be a new, exciting and prayerful way to grow closer both to the Lord and to each other. Love it. Here's some questions that have come up since I began to listen to you. First, is there any Catholic teaching concerning body hair? Is it immoral to be waxed in certain places considering that it involves exposing oneself to the person doing the waxing?
Secondly, I'm in law school and learning about criminal procedure. One of my classes was discussing a rape case and having to collect semen samples from several different suspects. That led to me pondering the morality of collecting semen samples, even for medical purposes, and what a Catholic approach to that would be. OK, let's address the body hair question. And has the church ever said anything about it?
Didn't she say? Has the church ever said anything about it? Yes, she did. OK, so I'm going to refer you to a Vatican document called Heritis Folliculitis. It's not true. There's no such document. Sorry, that's just my weird sense of humor coming through. OK, moving right along. So the the question at hand is about the morality of going to
some place where I get waxed. Is that not I? I've never been waxed in my life, but where one would go to a place. Yeah, I'm, I'm feeling like she's maybe trying to get at us. You know, waxing, removing body hair from places that we normally keep covered. Tender places, yes. Yes. Well, there's nothing immoral in itself with the removal of body hair that we find we don't want. I mean, that would make shaving
your face immoral, right? Or cutting your hair on your head. Immoral if there was some, you know, moral stand. Note, thou shalt not remove thy body hair. There's no such thing. However, we do get into questions of motivation. Why are we removing certain body hair? There's cultural influence here, obviously. In some cultures women have hairy armpits. In other cultures, it's the custom to shave the armpit for a
woman. So there are, there are, there's a lot of leeway here in terms of cultural practice. What concerns me, and this is where I, I do think the, the motivation question comes up, what concerns me in the modern world is that we have been exposed to so much pornography. We have seen, most people have seen so many naked bodies that
this is just unprecedented in all of human history to have seen so many naked bodies. And we're seeing naked bodies that are, are shaped in a certain way, are groomed in a certain way. And often times body hair has been very neatly trimmed or utterly removed. And when we are motivated to, I want to look like that when it,
when that's our motivation, I want to look like the images of bodies I've seen in pornography in a pornographic culture. I would, I would invite 1 to reflect on where is my sense of self coming from? Where is my sense of self coming from? And man, are we all really wounded here. Whether you've been exposed directly to pornography or not, if you were raised in the modern
world and you have a smartphone, or you grew up watching TV and movies, or you lived in a city where you drove around and saw the billboards, there's not a single one of Unless you were raised on some deserted island or in some tribe in in in some remote village and you had no access to the media. We have been warped into thinking this is what a woman is supposed to look like. This is what a man is supposed to look like and we need to we need to go through detox here.
We need to go through major, major detox. So that's the morality that comes into play when it comes to waxing or removing a body hair by any means. There's an additional question about exposing your tender places to some stranger in at a waxing facility right now. There are places where we need to expose our bodies in medical treatments, medical procedures, etcetera, etcetera.
And we should have, and rightly so, do have most of the time, a general sense of trust in the medical community to treat our bodies with due reverence. There are abuses there, of course, 'cause human beings are human beings and fallen things, disturbing things, happen in a fallen world. But by and large we are able, rightly so, to trust medical professionals to show us the proper reverence when we have to be exposed in medical situations.
Waxing is not a medical situation. I imagine there's some sort of training you have to go through to be a professional waxer. Nonetheless, I could also imagine that the people who would want to get into waxing have also been majorly, majorly influenced by the pornographic culture and the thought of going into, you know, your local waxing facility to expose your tender places to some unknown
waxer to get waxed in your tender places. There's a real risk in my estimation that you're exposing your nakedness to someone who is not necessarily prepared to honor the true dignity and meaning of your body as would a typical medical professional. Now, there may be professional waxers out there listening to me and thinking I'm throwing you under the bus or something. I would, obviously, I would make exceptions for those who could demonstrate.
No, no, no, no, I, I'm not coming from that place. But then I, I would also wonder what, what got you into waxing? What, what, what is waxing? What is this whole waxing thing all about my estimation of it? And anybody could, could demonstrate otherwise and prove me wrong. And I I may be open to a different perspective, but my general sense of it is that the whole industry has been raised up and is in demand because we're in a pornographic culture.
That's problematic. That is, to me, problematic. Those are my thoughts on that. Regarding the do you want to say anything about that before I go to the sperm sample? Thing I think go ahead and say what you're going to say and I'll see my, my, I'm still formulating. OK, go ahead. So the sperm sample question is easy enough to address. Masturbation is objectively immoral, which means there is no circumstance. Not A1, not a single one. It does not exist.
There is no exception. One could never find any reason whatsoever that could turn something objectively wrong into something that is acceptable and right. Masturbation to A to to supply a sperm sample is always, always immoral, because masturbation for any reason whatsoever is always immoral. How could one in good conscience provide a sperm sample? There are situations that are
morally legitimate to provide a sperm sample. A husband and a wife who aren't able to have children, and it may be because the husband has a low sperm count and that needs to be tested. How could one provide a sperm sample in a morally acceptable way? There's something called a perforated condom, which allows a husband and wife to have intercourse and a certain amount of the husband's seed to enter his wife's body in the normal
way so that the ACT is completed and it's not contracepted. But with a perforated condom, some of the sperm is released into the woman's body, some is retained for the sperm count. So that's how that would be done in an ethically sound way. So clear on that, you know, the it's interesting to to look at like considering a moral question in two different situations in the same question, right?
Because you have one where it's very, you know, it's a looking at like, well, what's the motivation and kind of a, a deep dive and one where there's just like this is, yeah. One is objectively plain and clear, and the other is is not. Yeah. So that, that, yes, that's a good point. Yeah, And, and I'll just say I, I was actually moved by your, your heart there. I, I know that like just 'cause I know you and, and other people who, you know, listen to our podcast or, you know, our
students kind of get a hint of this. But I, I know it so well-being married to you that the ways in which you have prayed for the healing of our culture and prayed for these kinds of wounds that give you just a, an awareness that is of something deeper at work. That is a real blessing to me, even as it, as it blesses our listeners. And I was feeling that as you were talking about both like looking at our what is our
deeper reason if we would be pursuing that kind of waxing, but also what is the what beliefs, what messages of the culture have been absorbed by a person who's willing to provide the service? And, and what is that then context for a person, you know, in that exchange? It's an exchange, you know, and it's so I thought that was really insightful. And I can't say we've ever like
talked directly about. It we've never talked directly about it and I've never been asked directly about that. That was a new one. Yeah, but it it did. It just struck me that the fruit of just having a like a spirit that's like been tuned to the right channel for long enough to kind of pick up the, you know, pick up the messages that are kind of buried and and people could get angry about and defensive and that kind of thing. But but there's a beautiful way in which you're just calling us to like keep looking what's what's underneath, what's
underneath. So that really blessed me to hear that. I'll just say one other thing, like I know that we just live in a culture that just doesn't think anything about the morality of masturbation involved in these kinds of things. And it can be sort of like a kind of throwing your brain into a new space to hear what a strong, you know, clarity the church offers. Like it's a no, because people in law enforcement as she was talking about or people struggling with infertility kind of gloss over it.
Like, oh, somehow we're, we're not going to think about it. We just need the result of it. And that is like challenging to the heart to like hear like, wait, no, you can't just gloss over that. You can't make it seem like unnecessary evil or something. And so that's powerful. And I, I also want to say like, just something in my heart when you like the thought of, of needing to collect that sample for a medical reason. Gosh, my, I heart goes out to
couples in that circumstance and to men. And I just feel how even though there is like a morally acceptable way, it's still not something you would want to do. And I, I just feel for those who've experienced that. And I just wanted to say that because you're describing it maybe touches a painful place for some of our listeners, even if they have or haven't, you know, if they've been in that circumstances, like just, I just feel like praying for healing
for the, the pain that would be connected to that, even though it's, it's not an evil, but it's, it's not how we it's not what we desire in our marital embrace. So I don't know, I just felt like. Acknowledging that I'm, I'm moved by your sensitivity there that shows your heart in tune with to the right channel there, to use your analogy. And it is a very sensitive thing. And I, we've not been in that situation in our marriage. I've not had to do that. We, we did go through a time where there was a long time
where you weren't conceiving. And I do remember having thoughts like, gosh, how, how's this going to go? And I remember what, what would I do? What would I, would I even want to wear a perforated condom? It's not wrong, right? But man, that would make me uncomfortable. Right. Yeah. So yeah, it is a sensitive, tender thing. All these things are so sensitive and tender. I know we are vulnerable creatures and man, when you talk about sexuality, we're we're touching on some of the most tender places of our hearts.
Yeah. Our next question is from a listener named Emily. Hi, Emily. My husband and I have been married 20 years, have 4 kids, and I've always used natural family planning. I recently heard on a Catholic podcast that any type of making out is sinful unless it is meant as foreplay and it must end in intercourse. I always thought foreplay was morally permissible as long as it does not lead to climax by
either person or incomplete sexual intercourse. Could you please this is in all caps Yes, clarify. Yes, Emily, Happily. I would hate to think we've been offending God our whole marriage, but would rather be corrected now than never. Bless you Emily. I was just talking to somebody not a week ago about this moral line that people have drawn in the sand. Some people this, you'll find this in certain Catholic circles. Just like she explains here,
Emily explains where people think if you are sexually aroused, it is only permissible to be sexually aroused if it ends in intercourse. That is simply not true. It is not true. I was, I was in a conversation with somebody recently who was, was sharing this, that that he was, he teaches chastity and he has kind of made this as a line that he draws. No sexual arousal is permissible
unless it leads to intercourse. And what he was trying to do was draw a line for unmarried people where he's saying you shouldn't be. And I would agree with this. If you're an unmarried person, you shouldn't be arousing the other person sexually, intentionally. But he was like he was, he was so firm in his line. I said, well, I said to this person, what about a, a situation where a a couple they've been dating a few weeks
and they're they feel close to each other and they're just talking on the phone and they they feel aroused because they're talking to the person they love on the phone. Have they sinned? And he's a whoa. Oh, yeah, I guess I haven't thought of that. Yeah. So the the question is, what do we do if and when we are sexually aroused in a context that cannot lead to intercourse? We learn and should learn
whether it leads to intercourse or not. In married life, we should learn to be master of our sexual desires and that means to put those sexual desires at the service of authentic love, to put those sexual desires. And here I quote John Paul the Second that self mastery, properly understood, is putting all of our affective and sensual reactions to the value of the body and sexuality of another person are affective or emotional and sensual or
physical reactions at the service of the dignity of the person to become master of those impulses, master of those desires, master of those affections, master of those stirrings, master of those emotions so that we can put them at the service of the dignity and goodness of the other. Those who draw this this overly strict line, you mustn't ever
have any kind of affectionate kissing or touching if you're not going to end an intercourse. It's often because they can't possibly imagine authentic selfmastery. They can't imagine true virtue. They can't imagine sexual desire, sexual stirring, sexual arousal, sexual passion, sexual emotion, affective reactions. They can't imagine one who is master of them to such a degree that he or she can put them at
the service of upholding the dignity and goodness of the other person. And lacking that, all you can really say is, well, if I get stirred, I'm going to want to have intercourse and I'm going to be tempted to masturbate if I can't have intercourse. So I better not ever kiss you because it'll stir me. And then I want to masturbate and I can't masturbate. So because that's immoral and I can't have intercourse because we're abstaining, so I'm not going to touch you, so I'm going to go sleep in the other room. OK? Lord have mercy. There may be people who lack such mastery of themselves that they need to go sleep in another room. But don't call that virtue. That person is sleeping in the
other room because of a lack of virtue. Now there's a desire for goodness there that I want to acknowledge. They don't want to cross a line that they know they shouldn't cross, so they go sleep in the other room. I acknowledge there's some goodness there, but it's not virtue, right? Virtue is choosing the good with ease. It is. It is the ordering of our passions, the ordering of our emotions, the ordering of our sexual desires, mastery over them, and putting them at the service of your spouse, of the one you love.
So in married life, you may have very good reason not to bring another child into the world. You have very good reason to abstain. And if you are master of yourself, and your spouse is master of him or herself and your passions and your reactions, you can embrace, you can kiss, you can caress, you can hold each other, you can be close, you can be naked, you can be skin to skin. And that will involve, as it would for any normal human being, some amount of arousal. But as master of your arousal,
you can put that arousal at the service of the true good of your spouse and of yourself and not have it become a situation in which you're overrun by arousal and have an unintentional climax outside the context of intercourse, which would be not appropriate would would be which would be out of order. So Emily, be at peace, my dear sister, be at peace. You, you've been listening to somebody who is scrupulous, who is legalistic, who has not really entered into the realm of
real self mastery here and what that affords. And I have compassion on that person. I'm not here to to, you know, bark at that person or or shame or scold that person who that's where he or she is on the journey. But I will wave a flag of serious concern that people who are lacking virtue in this area and believe they've achieved it are now imposing their own lack of virtue on everybody else. It's like an alcoholic who, who,
who cannot imagine anyone enjoying a, a, a drink rightly and therefore condemns everybody who drinks a drink because he can't imagine it himself that, that that is dangerous. That is, that is not only misguided, it's dangerous. And, and so, and it causes real problems of conscience for good. People like Emily who's listen to this Catholic podcast and think, Oh my gosh, I may have been offending God. It's not, it's morality is, is reasonable, right?
Morality is not some arbitrary rule that that one cannot understand. That's just kind of plopped on you. If, if you're, if you are a person seeking the true, the good and the beautiful and your, your, your conscience is clear. And now we can dull our consciences. Let's be clear about that. We can dull them, right? But Emily does not sound like a person to me who's been dulling her conscience. She has been really wanting to live and embrace the church's teaching. Your conscience would have been
troubling you all along here, Emily, if in kissing your husband during times of abstinence or whatever affection you're showing in a tender, affectionate, beautiful way, if if it was not beautiful, if it was not good, if it was not sincere and genuine, your conscience would have been telling you so all along. And morality is not some arbitrary thing that gets plopped on us by some podcast. So you can tell I get a little, I can, I can get a little zealous here because I'm so concerned about people being
misled by by scrupulous people, by by legalistic people, by people who have not really made the pilgrimage into the self mastery to which we are called. It is impossible to read John Paul the 2nd and understand him rightly and the virtue he's calling us to and conclude whatever that podcast concluded so that that whoever did that podcast is just confused and in the dark and and ignorant here. And I'm not saying that's a
shame or skull and I'm just stating some facts. So Emily, be free, be liberated, be at peace. I hope that's helpful. A thing that just struck me too, about what Emily said is that if, if you look back at it and you, you, you kind of imagine that mentality where arousal, where things causing arousal must be sinful unless you use that word legalistic. And I think the the harm caused
by that starts to come into the light because the suspicion we feel then towards something utterly natural. And, and I love your example of like I'm talking on the phone and, and I'm excited. And and. My body knows it and it's like to add guilt to that when it's it's actually when we've studied theology of the body, we can
recognize this is like sign. I'm called to be a gift. I it would be a delight to me to be a gift. It would be a delight to me to receive the other as a gift. Like those are positive associations that that somebody's robbing people of that that are actually like so necessary for us to be able to these people make it sound like having sexual intercourse and marriage is, is just a
unleashing of a mutual physical reality without any just depth of humanity involved. And, and in those places, say in a marriage, when you're abstaining and you are affectionate with one another and you experience arousal, you are connecting with one another and the desire to be that gift. And in, you know, exercising yourself mastery, there's like
just a depth of honouring one another that's so profound and helpful. And and these people are are just really robbing humanity of something that could bear such good fruit, both in their abstinence and in their times of coming. Together well, said Wendy. Thank you. Yes, and it it is what JP 2 calls the interpretation of suspicion. If if what we're saying to any of our listeners here is new to
you or raising questions or what about this and what about that? And you want to get into some of the nitty gritties here. And there are nitty gritties that we we just prefer to refrain from speaking about in this forum. But I'm, I don't hesitate to write about them in my book, Good News about Sex and Marriage. I get into the nitty gritties there. And you will see a very clear presentation of the church's teaching there. And I think you will find it pastorally sensitive and appropriate. So, so please pick up a copy of that book if you don't already
have one. We'll have a link in the show notes. Emily, thank you for your question. It's, it's, I'm so glad you asked it. I hope we've shown a light on it and, and you are experiencing some peace there. And if you know anybody who needs to hear what we've shared on today's podcast, could you please click that share button to help us expand our listenership? We'd be so grateful to you. You are a gift to us. Thank you for being a gift to us. We, we hope this podcast is a gift to you.
And Wendy, I threw off our little queue here. It's all right. So you can say whatever you want, like about becoming what we are, but I messed it up, sorry. It's OK, sometimes that happens. You're still my favorite person. Thanks, Wendy. And we're all created to be a gift, so let's become what we are. Yeah, let's do that. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body
Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
๐๏ธ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! Signup for Ascensionโs Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
๐๏ธ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! Signup for Ascensionโs Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
๐๏ธ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! Signup for Ascensionโs Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...