Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Proving Recovery from Porn to a Partner, Re-evaluating Male Shirtlessness & The Ethics of Menstrual Cups | ACW383

May 4, 202650 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: I want to fully understand Theology of the Body but struggle due to a history with porn addiction. Exposed at 13, I fell away from the Church and entered an ill-advised marriage where porn use was encouraged, ending in divorce. Now, by the grace of God, it’s been several months since I’ve slipped. Resources like the Matt Fradd show, Internal Family Systems, and Covenant Eyes have helped immensely. I’ve met an amazing woman, but when I told her about my addiction, she expressed concern that I haven't done enough to address it. How do I know if I’ve done enough? What resources would you recommend? My fiancé and I have been discerning swim modesty, particularly for men. I love swimming and see many modest options for women, but what about men? I felt like seeing my fiancé without his shirt for the first time was a big deal, as a level of nakedness would be revealed that hadn’t been before. We discerned him wearing a swim shirt, as I want to wait to see this nakedness until marriage. He has struggled with it, and I didn't want to force it. Should men have a level of modesty and cover up while swimming, or is it modest for men to swim shirtless since that’s acceptable in our culture? Are there any feminine hygiene products that are not acceptable? Tampons are required to go into the body, and menstrual cups or disks even require a woman to actually reach her hand up her vagina to insert and to remove. This feels a little bit like the line towards masturbation is being pushed. Resources: Way of Beauty Course with Bill Donaghy Course Schedule Freedom Coaching TOB Institute Store John Paul II Healing Center Desert Stream Ministries --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Hey, Wendy. Yeah. I'm going to ask you the question that I begin my maid for more seminar with. First of all, do you know the question I begin my maid for more seminar with? I think I do.

What is it? I want to see if, you know, if everybody could see Wendy's face right now. She's cringing. She's like, oh crap. She just, no, I mean, I think what are you looking for something like that. Close, but no cigar. Oh. Darn, it failed. I will typically begin a made for more seminar with this

question. Can you think of a time in your life when your heart was pierced by something so beautiful that it made you ache inside because of it? OK, Yes, I've heard you asked that question before. Yes, you have. Are you asking me that question? I absolutely can think of such a thing. In fact, many times when I hear you ask that question, I revisit certain very. Yes, tell me, tell me, tell me, tell our listeners. Hi, podcast listeners. We didn't even say that yet. We're just banting about here.

What? Think of a time in your life you're pierced by something so beautiful it made your heart ache. OK, but first I have to say this, if I have told you this before in the podcast, please forgive me. I am so sorry for repeating myself. Christopher made me do it so amazing. God is so good. I was just driving on a winter morning and I'm not a morning person so. Nor a winter person might I. Add I'm not a winter person or morning person, but I was and

helping out a friend and I was driving to their house to pick up their children. So on the way early morning in the winter, I drove past this part of just the landscape near us down this road, because for you, we'll know this area, but not our listeners don't. It's kind of like a little bit of a lowland, like with a Creek and and then at the edge, the

far distance there woods and there are a few little trees kind of closer to the road. But there's also just this kind of open area with a Creek running through it. So you can kind of picture what I'm talking about. Well, on this winter morning, that field was covered in snow. The the trees close to the road, like these pine trees had been utterly coated with ice. Like that was just glimmering

crystals. You know how the needles can sometimes just like you can't even believe it. But then there was this amazing mist just hovering over the. Can you say the word mist one more time? Mist. I think I pronounced it wrong, no? No, no you didn't. I just like the way Wendy says certain words and that was one of them. The field with the Creek, it has this kind of tall dead grass in it so that even though there was snow, it wasn't all beaten down. So it was just like this

interesting landscape with mist going over the Creek and the glittering on these trees was just magical. And the morning sunlight was amazing, shining through this landscape and I this is literally what I felt. I want everyone I love to be here with me right now. That we could all see this beauty together.

That was the longing. Like it was like a it made me cry how much I wanted everyone I love to witness this with me. And I know I don't describe it as well as it. It was so beautiful. It's time to end this episode. That's all we need. You are a gift. Not ending. Yet but. Thanks for and I, I definitely revisit that scene and I've even done some prayer meditations where I imagine that I stop the car and get out and walk and, and smell it and crunch on the

snow. Like all of it, like feel the cold on my face, like all of it. Like, it's just beautiful. Yeah, it is. And it's winter and it's morning. Who knew? I I'm either having the biggest brain fart of my life or you've not told me that story. Oh, believe me, I've told you. Well, I mean, I told you the day it happened, of course. Which? Do you? How long ago was that? Oh, probably 15 years ago. OK, so I'm I'm I can excuse myself for the brain fart I'm having because I don't retain much from 15 years ago.

Were we married 15 years ago or what? No, the reason I asked you that is this. What you experienced is what we call in the language of the church, primarily the the Eastern Church. Although we in the West here we borrow some language. We call that a theophany, an encounter with God through the beauty of his creation, where small B beauty opens the heart and leads the heart to capital B beauty.

We call that theophany. And I'm going to tie that in with my weekly promotional piece because in July this year, my colleague Bill Dunahy is teaching our course called The Way of Beauty, Theology of the Body and The Way of Beauty. And it's 5 1/2 days of sitting at the feet of a master. Bill Donaghy is a master teacher and letting him teach you how to

see the whole world the way Wendy just described that morning, allowing creation to speak the mysteries that God has placed within creation to speak to us. God speaks to us in sign language, and very few of us have ever been trained in how to understand God's sign language. Imagine if, if somebody's doing sign language in front of you, but you don't know what the heck the person's doing because

nobody trained you how to understand sign language. It'd just be meaningless. You'd go through your day if somebody's wagging his fingers at you and you don't know what the heck he's saying. Well, God's wagging his fingers at us, so to speak, all the time. God's speaking His sign language to us all the time in everything, in all of creation, and we need to be trained to understand what He's saying to us. We need to be trained to understand God's sign language, to recognize theophanies on display everywhere, even in the painful stuff, hard stuff, difficult stuff. There are theophanies come to the way of beauty in July.

Check the link in the show notes if you want to see the world that way. You will not regret it. Awesome. Well, thanks for that. Thank you, Wendy. I was you just took me on an awesome, awesome pilgrimage into your own theophany. That was that was beautiful. Thanks. Maybe next time I should ask you the same question. OK, OK. Are. You. Ready for in my Forest Gump accent? OK, Jenny. Are you ready for a question from a patron?

Yes, I am from an anonymous patron. Thank you, anonymous patron. Bless you, Bless you. Thanks for supporting our work. He says. Hi Christopher and Wendy, I've been listening to your podcast for years now and it has been eye opening. I want to fully understand theology of the body, but I struggle hindered by my history with porn addiction. I'm in my 40s, a cradle Catholic, but I was poorly catechized on sexual issues and exposed to porn since age 13.

I fell away from the church for years, entered into an ill advised marriage where porn use was encouraged and which ended in divorce mercy. Before and during the pain of the divorce I was being drawn back to the church. My porn addiction has been the most difficult struggle through this, but now it has been several months since I've slipped. Thanks to the grace of God. I believe that what I've learned from you and Matt Frad's show about TOB and internal family systems have helped me

immensely. I have covenant eyes on my phone and I roped my friend into being my accountability partner. Now I've met a woman. She's amazing. We both have annulments and are on fire for serving the church. In a short amount of time, we've opened up to each other so much. I told her about my addiction. She seems concerned that I haven't done enough to address it. She might be right, whether she and I have a future or not.

How do I know if I've done enough to address it and what resources would you recommend? Bless you, good brother. Bless you good brother. Above all else, dear brother, I'm going to say something that may be surprising to you and our listeners. I don't know, I'm going to say it. I want to bless and affirm your erotic longings. I don't want to bless and affirm

where you've taken them, but I want to bless and affirm them. At the core of your being, something beautiful has been twisted into something ugly. Something true has been twisted into something false. Something good has been twisted into something distorted and perverse. But know it, my brother, know it. In the core of your being, what resides in the deepest place of

you is not ugly, false, and perverse. What resides in the deepest place in your heart is beautiful, true and good, and it's called Eros Eros. Eros quoting Pope Benedict the 16th is the Holy Passion. It is the desire in us that seeks God.

Eros, quoting Saint Francis de Sales, is that drive, that longing at the core of our being that rushes? He says This is his quote that rushes towards divinization. You're looking for God. You've heard me say it before. I'm sure I'll say it again for those who may not have heard me say this. God gave us erotic longing. God gave us erotic desire to be like the fuel of a rocket that

has the power to launch us towards the stars. But there's an enemy who doesn't want us to reach the stars. He wants to make our lives a disaster. And I mean that literally. What do you mean? You mean that literally? Literally The word disaster. Disaster means to be aimed away from the stars. Disaster. Aster means star in Latin.

Disaster. When our rocket engines are aimed away from the stars, our lives are a disaster. And here's the good news, my brother. Here's the good news. Christ came into the world to reaster our erotic longings, to redirect our rocket engines towards the stars. You're on this pilgrimage, brother, You are. Have you done enough? Can you ever say you've done enough? Is there? Let me put it this way. Is there more work to do? Yes, there is.

Will there be more work to do tomorrow? Yes. The next day? Yes. The next year? Yes. 10 years from now? Yes. 20 years from now, I'm still going to have to Yes. 40 years from now, I'm still going to Yes. Until you die, you will be on the pilgrimage of undoing what sin has done in your life. Have you done enough up to this stage of your journey? You've certainly not done enough for the like. You haven't arrived. There's way more to do.

Have you been on par with where you should be in this life, given your circumstances and given your history? I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I, I can't answer that question. Can anybody ever say no? I'm, I'm pretty darn sure that I'm exactly where I'm supposed to be and none of my weaknesses have gotten in the way of my healing and therefore I'm right on track. I don't think anybody of us, any one of us can say that. So probably you can't say that either. So probably the humble response to this woman you're getting to know is please pray for me.

Please pray for me. I know I did a lot of damage to my mind and my heart and even my body, my muscle memories in my body. Please pray for me. I'm, I'm on the pilgrimage. I'm committed to the journey and I, I want to keep going. That's the humble response. If if we're trying to justify ourselves by saying things like, no, I've done pretty much what I'm supposed to do, Yeah, I think I'm in the right. I think the paradigm needs to be shifted where we need to recognize we're just, we are

poverty. We are in poverty. We are, our lives are a disaster, right? They are. That's what sin is. That's what sin does. It makes our lives a disaster. Now the, the reason we don't want to say those kind of things, the reason we kind of, I don't know, soft shoe around it all is because we think that if our lives are a disaster, that makes me unlovable and I can't conclude I'm unlovable, so I have to conclude my life's not a disaster.

Well, that's a lie that you're not loved in the disaster of your life. Our lives are a disaster. If our lives were not a disaster, we don't need Jesus. No, the reason we need Jesus and the reason the price of our salvation is His passion, crucifixion and death is because our lives are a disaster. The good news is, while we were still sinners, while our lives were still a disaster, God sent His Son into this world to save us.

That work of salvation is evidently underway in your life, brother, and that's a beautiful thing. Rejoice in it. Praise God for it, but there's a long way to go for all of us. The catechism says this for everyone. Just to hear that. Those first 2 words for everyone. I don't care if you were Mother Teresa, John Lacrosse, JP 2, Catherine of Siena, the holiest person on planet earth. For everyone. The wheat and the weeds grow

together in us until the end of time, until the end of our lives. The wheat and the weeds grow together in us. We can learn not to water those weeds. We can learn how to water the wheat, and we should all learn that. But they grow together. They're in there together. So keep going. That's my advice. In terms of the first part, what would I recommend in terms of resources? Here are a few things. Please, please, I beg of you, keep immersing yourself in John

Paul the Second's theology of the body. If, if you appreciate the way we present his teaching at the Theology of the Body Institute. If you appreciate our charism, please come to our courses. Please, please have you, have you taken our courses either online or in person? Please do so. Please jump in. Please immerse yourself in our YouTube channel. We have hundreds of videos available there that are going to lead you in the right direction. Please read our books and our resources. If you haven't, start with Theology of the Body for

Beginners, go to Good news about sex and marriage. Go from there to Theology the Body Explained. Go from there to Heaven's Song. Go from there to Eating the Sunrise. Just go online and on our website and look at all the resources and books we have and just read them. Just read them. Make them your daily bread and butter of what you're reading. Take it in, take it in. Let it inform you. Let it transform you to want to grow in what it means to be a man or a woman made in the image and likeness of God, to want to

detox from all of the lies of a pornographic influence and not immerse yourself repeatedly continually throughout your life in the gift that John Paul the Second has given us is is a disservice to yourself. It's a disservice to yourself. Another resource I would recommend High, High, highly recommend, wholeheartedly recommend is that you sign up for coaching sessions, sessions with Freedom Coaching.

They're not paying me to say this. I believe what this organization is doing. If you can possibly sign up with my dear friend Steve Motel MOTYL make a personal request for Steve Motel and if not Steve Motel, Steve Percorny. These are two, I mean, I, yeah, it's hard to say. I recommend Steve Motel above Steve Pocorny. They're both equally good and, and equally trained and they'll, they'll, they'll both help you

tremendously. Everybody on their team. They have more people than just two of the two of them on their team to help. But those would be my first two recommendations if you could get Steve Motel or Steve Pocorny to to be your coach through their Freedom Coaching program, which is aimed specifically at men and how to help them overcome and detox from porn addiction. Yeah, I two other things I'm thinking of everything you're saying there is able to be done

in in our normal life, which is so important, right? To just to realize there are little things you can do in normal life. What are you filling your mind with as you're talking about reading and and coaching? It's like a a weekly meeting that keeps you on track in new ways with new just insights and help to kind of overcome and heal from things that are hard to address sometimes on your when on your own is what I mean to say.

So all of that can like be incorporated into daily life. I was also thinking of two things that are sort of kind of spend time away, particularly kind of away from your normal life to give God that extra space, you know, that maybe getting out of normal routines can be helpful for and. One of them was the John Paul to Healing Center that does healing

weekends. You know, basically just. Healing the whole person. Yeah, that we don't we cannot just come up with it ourselves if we sit and think real hard. God, what are the wounds in me that I'm going to figure it out. I I know my story. I know like we really need to be in that yes. Why did opened state where we can hear what Jesus wants to tell us about our story and where we can experience his loving presence in parts of our

story that are very painful and already in your question, you shared tremendously painful parts of your story that you're aware of. But like like when the Holy Spirit really gets in on it and you know, it's so powerful. So that's that's a thought or also Living Waters. Living Waters, Yeah, I was going to suggest that as well. So so gifted that specifically towards things in our sexual development and sexual expression that I like to really

untwist in our hearts. So like just those are, there are so many good things out there. And I know when we say too many things, you might think, what am I going to do? Like just listen to our reply a few times and then and ask the Lord to to direct you about your next step. And, and maybe the very first next step was the first thing Christopher said, which is to tell this woman, please pray for me. Like that's a beautiful next step to not to not grasp at some

kind of, you know, making the grade or. Something right? Oh, that's a good way to put. It just to like just acknowledge like, yeah, this is this is this has been so hard and I'm so grateful God is helping me, but I need more so. Yeah, that's so. That's such a good word, Wendy. There's no grade to make here. The goal is just to recognize more and more our poverty and God's riches, our poverty, God's riches.

Our poverty is the shape of God's riches. So the more we open our poverty to him, the more his riches can enter into our poverty. Be not afraid, brother. Keep going. You're in our thoughts. You're in our prayers. Thanks for writing into us. Yeah, and for being a patron. Yeah. Thank you so much. Our next question is from a listener named Maria. Hello, Maria. Hi Christopher and Wendy, I recently got engaged. Congratulations, Maria. That's awesome.

And now my fiance and I have been discerning a unique topic since our early dating relationship, swim modesty, particularly relating to men since it is pre swim season. I'd love to hear your opinion on this before we jump back into the time of year that we have to live this out. I love swimming and I've seen a lot more companies designing beautiful swimwear that is modest for women. From one pieces to even swim dresses.

Women have options, but what about men? I remember speaking with my fiance about potentially seeing him for the first time without his shirt while swimming and I felt something in me say that it was a big deal. There was a level of nakedness that would be revealed that hadn't been before. For some reason, it felt different to think about this regarding someone I love deeply. We discerned wearing a swim shirt as I shared. I wanted to wait to see this nakedness until marriage.

He has struggled with it and I didn't want to force it. So what are your thoughts? Should men have a level of modesty and cover up too while swimming? Or is it modest for men to swim shirtless, since that's what's acceptable in our culture? Bless you, Maria. It's a very honest question and I am happy to give you some thoughts. I I want to express first how much I love the fact that you said it was a big deal for you

to see your future husband's naked chest. I like that. That's, that's cool. That's, that's it shows a a it shows a sensitivity in your heart that I really appreciate and I just want to bless that first. That's I just want you to hear me blessing that your sensitivity to your future husband's naked chest. What man, what man would not

want to receive that? Like I that's just somehow I feel affirmed by that. I don't, I yeah, that my chest, my chest, my chest expresses something of my humanity and, and my naked chest does and it's different. Obviously there's a different reality for a naked woman's chest than a naked man's chest 'cause we're different. I don't think I need to explain that one, but I I feel an affirmation in in the revelation of of the person in your

reverence for your husband's future husband's naked chest. I like that. But let me quote to you from John Paul the second, or at least paraphrase. I know this content quite well, but I might not get every word exactly the exact word that JP 2 uses. But he says this in his book. Love and Responsibility says there is nothing unchaste about wearing swimwear when one is swimming. But if one were to wear swimwear

out of that context, like just going for a walk down the street, then that would be a sign of immodesty. So modesty, immodesty in clothing has much to do with the function of the clothing, right? And what 1 is doing wearing such clothing? It's not immodest in any way inherently immodest for a man to expose his chest when he goes

swimming. It's not even immodest for a man to expose his chest on a hot day when he's working outside on a construction site or mowing the lawn or whatever. In fact, I'm thinking of a picture of John Paul the Second as a young man working on a construction crew, some kind of crew. Maybe it was when the Nazis had taken over and he they were forced into forced into labour. But there he is, bare chested with his scapular on standing next to a work crew at A at a site where they were all

working, labouring hard. And I like that picture. It's it's there's nothing immodest about it. So I'm going to affirm your reverence for your future husband's chest. And I'm going to say I think you're overthinking this. I I think you are. Are I? Yeah. I just think you're overthinking it. And I would invite you to listen to what your future husband has to say. This is kind of troubled him, it

sounds like, And I can understand why. And I would invite you to listen to his heart, and I would invite you to maintain the same reverence for his chest when you see it exposed. When you go swimming, 'cause I think you're going to 'cause I think that's, I think when you and your fiance talk this through, I think you're going to understand where he's coming from and why he's coming from, where he's coming from. And I hope he can also appreciate where you're coming from and affirm what you're

saying and feel loved and honored in his chest. But I, I, I think the direction this goes in is not to make a big deal. It would be, it would be, I think it would be a sign of something unhealthy if all of a sudden Catholics around the world started saying, you know, men should really cover their chests when they go to swimming. No, what should really happen when we go swimming or in any other situation is we should come to a profound reverence for

the mystery of the body. We should have a great reverence. And wherever lust is kicking in, wherever we have a a lack of reverence for the body, the solution is not merely cover that up, right? JP 2 talks about this. Modesty or immodesty cannot in themselves be determined by the use of clothing, nor the lack thereof, right? We have to look at the circumstance. We have to look at what's going on. We have to look at the function

of the clothing or lack thereof. There's so many factors that come to play here and my invitation to you would be help me to maintain that reverence for his chest when I see it exposed and and if it stirs something in me that that I, I need to look at, then then look at that. Say, Lord, I give this to you. Integrate my arousal and attraction to my husband's future husband's exposed chest.

Integrate that with my reverence for his person. That would be my suggestion. And that's my guess as to where it will the direction it will go once you talk more with him. I think I really loved the same thing that just struck you was that that the thought of as she realizes, like I've never seen him with his shirt off and and we're I probably will before we're married like that sort of inner knowing.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. This matters to me. This is the man I'm marrying. Yeah, yeah. And even that, she said. It feels different because I love him so much. You know, this, it's beautiful. And there's something just, you know, about that setting up and when we're swimming or amongst other people who are swimming kind of, I think that it will, as you're anticipating, be like just a kind of a happy new experience for her.

I know sometimes when we're in a a large group of people and maybe we're not standing next to each other or something, you'll tell me, you know, at some point, you know what? I love to look around a room and and then see you there. Like because I know you and I love you and I and it just makes me happy that you're here. I'm not right with you, but I see you and my heart says something to me about it. I feel like it's kind of going to kind of be like that. I I think that's a great thing. You know that that kind of like,

oh, that's the one. I. Love. That's the one I love. That's right. That's beautiful. Yes, may his chest amongst all the other bear chests wherever you go swimming, may his chest be especially attractive and and beautiful to you because you know his person. See that's that's the path of integration that the body reveals the person. Our next question is from a listener named Maggie. Hi, Maggie. Maggie asks. Are there any feminine hygiene

products that are not acceptable and she gets into it? Here, OK, this is I just have to say this is this is I we, this is a unique question. Nitty gritty. OK, we're going to get into some of the to quote from the prophet Nacho Libre. Let's get into the Nitty Gritty's. Here we go, people. There's a little warning here. Getting some Nitty Gritties. I haven't heard this question. Wendy knows what's coming. I don't. Here we go. She says tampons are required to go into the body, and menstrual

cups or discs even require a woman to actually reach her hand up her vagina to insert and to remove. This feels a little bit like the line towards masturbation is being pushed. OK, let me just answer the question outright. No, there is nothing inherently wrong with tampons or menstrual cups or anything else that you

are inserting into your body for the sake of hygiene for your monthly cycle. I said that. Now let me address the underlying question about temptation to masturbation. We shouldn't blame other things for our own. Let me put it this way, we shouldn't blame outer things for our inner temptations.

It would sound to me like using these products may have caused some temptation for you in the past. I don't know if that's the case. I may be reading into it, but that's that's how I'm kind of imagining your question here originated and I see it as an opportunity. Now, let me say plainly, if if this is a source of temptation towards masturbation, well then choose another path.

There are times when the building is burning and you got to run out of the building so you didn't don't get burned. But again, don't blame those products, those methods of maintaining your hygiene and your cycle for what is really an internal lack of integration. So I would invite you to just ask yourself, Lord, am I, am I resenting my, the design of my

body? Am I resenting the fact that sometimes when I've used a tampon, it had caused arousal and I didn't know what to do with it? And I I may have fallen into sin. Or maybe I'm uncomfortable with my anatomy. The thought of inserting something there makes me just feel uneasy, makes me feel fearful, makes me feel, I don't know, uncomfortable with myself. We have deep fears, deep

ambivalence aimed at our genitals. It's right there in the first pages of Genesis. After the fall, I was afraid. I was afraid because I was naked, so I hid myself. They made fig leaves to cover themselves. They weren't covering their kneecaps or their big toes or their elbows. They were covering their genitals because that's where the discomfort was. Registering that discomfort,

that fear, that ambivalence, that that struggle goes really deep psychologically, emotionally, even physically. And it is a mistake. It is a mistake to think the solution is to blame something outside of myself for my own discomfort, which comes from within myself.

And we can go from one extreme to the other. We can go from you should. I mean, I've heard the craziest things said like you should never even wash your genitals because of the temptation to masturbation. Oh my Lord, we've got other issues we got to deal with before we can even address that one. So that's one extreme. You can't even, boys, you better not touch your penis when you have to urinate. OK, well, why? Because of this fear and weirdness that we have around sexuality. That's one extreme. And then we go to the other

extreme. We think we're correcting that extreme of fearful puritanical prudishness by going to another extreme of saying touch your genitals however you want, go ahead and masturbate. It's all great. Nothing wrong. OK? Those are two sides of the same coin, and the coin is called rupture. The coin is called disintegration, right? The the coin that we want to be cashing in, if you will, the the path we want to be walking on is

1 of integration, integrate. And what do I mean by integration? The Catechism defines chastity as the integration of body and soul. We could also say this is not a direct quote from the Catechism, but a different angle on the same idea. Chastity is the integration of that which is spiritual with that which is sexual. It is the integration of spirituality and sexuality. Lack of integration rupture

would be on the one hand, keep your sexuality away from my spirituality and on the other hand, keep your spirituality away from my sexuality, Right. Neither one is purity of heart. Neither one is the path of holiness. To think holiness is keep your sexuality away from my spirituality. Well, you just gave the devil his own clay and you just surrendered sexuality to evil.

No, God created sexuality. God created the sexual difference. God created our genitals. God created the process of arousal. In this fallen world. It's become distorted. But in the beginning, God looked at everything he made and said, behold, it is very good. And what happens with original sin is that the good thing gets distorted. The good thing is still there, it's just been twisted up. And the path of integration is, is the one of restoration.

Christ came into the world, the Catechism says, to restore creation to the purity of its origins. Doesn't mean we're going to arrive at that purity of our origins in this life, but we can go on the pilgrimage and we can make real progress. And so I say to you, my dear sister, if there is an occasion where you are using some feminine hygiene product and it stirs something in your heart like fear or ambivalence towards your own body or arousal that

makes you uncomfortable or afraid, or you think, oh, I, I, that's all bad. It's all bad. It's evil that I, that, that just happened. I need to shut it down. I should never use a tampon again in my life. I don't think that's the path of in fact, I know it's not the path of integration. The path of integration is Lord. When I use this product, it causes a a certain friction in my body that stirs something in me that that that makes me afraid. I open that to you, Lord, I give you this fear.

I, I, you look at what you've made and you say, behold, it's very good. And I look at what you made and I think occasion of sin. So, So what do I do, Lord? How, how do I become the woman you're you're creating me to be? I surrender my fear to you, Lord. I surrender my discomfort to you, Lord. I surrender my, my ambivalence towards my own body towards you, Lord. And, and here's here's also what I'd recommend. Ask Mary, ask the Blessed Mother to teach you how much she loved her feminine body.

Mary was never ruptured. She never experienced this disintegration of her body and her soul, of her spirituality and her sexuality. Thank God for Mary's sexuality. Without it, we wouldn't have the incarnation, right? It is, it is. We don't even tend to think this way because it scares us. But it's absolutely bedrock biblical truth that Christianity begins when a woman opens her

sexuality to the Holy Spirit. When a woman opened her womanhood, opened her femininity, opened her womb, opened her fertility, it was peak fertile day. We can rightly conclude. When the Angel Gabriel showed up, it was peak fertile day. Mary loved her fertility. Mary loved her cycle because her cycle is what brought Jesus Christ into this world in the flesh. Ask Mary to teach you how to love your body and how not to be

afraid of your body. And most importantly, ask Mary how to open your sexuality to the Holy Spirit and watch what miracles will happen in your life. Christopher, I love that journey that you just took us on. It really lifted my heart and it's so interesting. You know, I do choose the questions. I know our listeners probably have heard that before. When I chose this question, I did not anticipate that you

would, you know, go the directions that you went in your answer, but really blessed my heart as a woman just to hear you Speaking of, of reverence and integration and also the ambivalence and disintegration that we've inherited. And it's it's deep stuff. It's deep stuff. There's a an expression that Pope John Paul the Second used that I think could relate to this question when he talked

about people who basically are projecting their own issues onto other people. Like they struggle with something. And so they imagine or believe firmly that somehow it's a problem for everyone. And there's some instinct I have that this fear that feminine hygiene products are crossing a line towards masturbation actually comes from a man who doesn't get it.

Oh boy. Do you know what I'm? Saying, Are you imagining that some man, maybe even an authority figure, has said this to this person? That is what I'm well. That makes me want to puke. But I I I feel that that could. Be the I think you might be right. Yes, I think you could be right about that, Wendy. So the the expression Pope John Paul the Second used was that of masters of suspicion, yes, meaning holding everyone in a state of you're in danger of

being in sin right now, you know, all the time, rather than just a, a sense of like grace is real and and the inheritance of goodness that God placed in US is real and we we can't experience it. Can I proclaim this line from JP 2 that's so bold and beautiful? He says this is from memory, but it's probably 97% exactly the words he said because it's important. It's so important and I've, I've

been teaching this for years. He says we must not hold the heart in a state of continual and irreversible suspicion due to the manifestations of the lust of the flesh. Redemption is a reality. Redemption is real, and there is a real possibility of passing from error to truth here. There is the real possibility of living chastity as life according to the Holy Spirit. Redemption is a truth, a power

that is at work in the heart of every human being who opens to it. And we truly can become free with the freedom for which Christ has set us free. Now I will say this because as I started spouting it, I started realizing I'm really that was an amalgamation of about 5 different quotes from JP 2. But that is, that is JP two. That is not my teaching. That is JP 2's teaching. That is what he teaches. There is real power. We must not hold the the human heart in a state of continual

and irreversible suspicion due to the manifestations of lust. Redemption is real, and there is real power through the death and resurrection to transform the way we experience our bodies. That's JP 2's teaching. So given my little theory that I put out there about maybe, maybe a man who's fearful. Projected his own fear onto this dear person. Yes, this person and women in general.

You know, I just, I want to pray for those who would approach our our our feminine bodies with that suspicion and just ask the Lord's mercy upon them and let us just rejoice in the goodness of our bodies of male and female. Like, what are we about here? Theology of the body, like it reveals God. It's really good. That's what I want to say. Amen to that and I just grabbed

my TOB One study guide because I wanted to quote this directly. This is the I could quote like the five different ones that were the amalgamation, but I won't go to all five of them. I'll just go to the one I wanted to go to before my brain switched over to going in those other directions. Here it is. Man cannot stop at casting the heart into a state of continual and irreversible suspicion due to the manifestations of the concupiscence of the flesh. Redemption is a truth, a reality in the name of which man must

feel himself called, and called with effectiveness. There it is. And of course, when he says man here, he means all of us, right? All of us, the human person. We are called with effectiveness, he goes on to say. When the human heart is fixed in permanent suspicion, man is unable to tap into his deepest and yet most real possibilities. He's unable to give voice to the deepest layers of his potentiality.

The ethos of redemption, by contrast, is based on a strict alliance with those deepest layers of our real possibilities. So what are the real possibilities? What what? What are we capable of? JP 2 asks this question. This is what he says. What are the concrete possibilities of man? And of which man are we speaking? Remember, this is all of us, male and female, of man dominated by lust or of man redeemed by Christ. This is what is at stake.

Really, really. This is what is at stake in this question. This is what is at stake in the question of are certain feminine hygiene products bordering on masturbation. This is what is at stake. The reality of Christ's redemption. Christ has redeemed us. This means he has given us the possibility of realizing the entire truth of our being, says John Paul the Second. Christ has set our freedom free from the domination of lust. And if redeemed men and women

still sin, this is not due to an imperfection of Christ's redemptive act, but to our will not to avail ourselves of the grace which flows from that act. So let's avail ourselves of the grace of redemption. Let's avail ourselves of the real power flowing from the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ to enable us to journey on that pilgrimage of healing from the rupture, so that spirituality and sexuality can become beautifully and ever more integrated in our experience of

being human. As we live that way, as we walk that way, we learn to be truly a gift. We learn. To become what we. Are Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that

the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode