Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Why is Jesus clothed on the Cross, I'm terrified my baby will see us, & I feel grossed out by intimacy | ACW387

Jun 1, 20261 hr 2 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: While meditating on the crucifixion, I wondered why our Lord is not completely nude in art portraying it. My research pointed to reverence for Christ and preserving his dignity, reading that he "voluntarily accepted humiliation, but it need not be perpetuated." While this makes sense, I wonder how to look at this through a TOB lens. Why does it feel irreverent to depict Jesus nude, when other art depicting naked bodies, like in the Sistine Chapel, is praised for showing the beauty of the human body? Is it because of our fallen nature, or is there something more theological I'm missing? As a newlywed, my husband and I just celebrated our two-year wedding anniversary. Six months ago, we were blessed with a beautiful baby girl. My postpartum journey was difficult, and we are trying to navigate intimacy in this new stage of life. I especially struggle with a new anxiety, petrified that I will do something wrong and mess up my daughter. This has translated into me showing less attention to my husband. My brain does not seem wired towards the same level of intimacy as before. Also, our daughter's crib is right next to our bed. I am terrified she will wake up, see us in the marital embrace, and it will scare or scar her for life. Any advice? I'm 25, serving full-time in college ministry. One thing I've been terribly afraid to address is when my dad had "the talk." Instead of discussing marriage, he simply said of masturbation, "It's normal and natural, just make sure to clean up after yourself." At 12, this left me with a view of my sexuality akin to pooping - just a natural thing you clean up after. Now, called to marriage, I see the beauty of the theory, but I frustratingly feel grossed out by the reality of the marital embrace. How can I partner with Christ in untwisting this in my heart? Resources: Pierced By Beauty Mexico Retreat TOB I Course: Head & Heart Immersion - Summer of 2026 Course Schedule for other courses Slovakia & Slovenia Event Event Schedule --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to another episode, everybody. Yes, Hi, podcast listeners. Wendy, tell everybody what's different about this recording. Here we are. We're recording in our home rather than in your Home Office, which is part of our garage, right? Because nobody else's home and we just decided to be in our house. Nobody's going to disturb. Us, it's different. This is the first time we've we're in our kitchen, yeah. We did record once in the house, but it yeah it. Wasn't in the IT was in our bedroom, I think. And remember, we recorded that

episode on my phone in the cruise ship I do in France. Fall of 2023, we sure did. I remember that we just watched an interesting documentary. You guys know if you're a regular listener, if you're a new listener, welcome to our show. Yeah. So glad you're here. But if you're a regular listener, you know, we like to talk about movies we've seen. And we just watched a documentary called the AI Doc, The AI Documentary. And I am writing a book right

now. It should be published by the end of the summer 2026 here. And the book I'm writing is called The Truth and the Lie, what it means to be human in the age of AI. So I've been doing a lot of research about artificial intelligence, and I have some things that struck me about the movie Wendy, but I want to hear what you think first. Yeah, it was certainly very interesting. And they were starting out just

with a very basic question, what is artificial intelligence? And I kind of liked how it just kind of kept pressing into that for a while, Like let's not just skip over that. That was helpful and they used images to kind of carry through that question trying to get it answered along the way of the film, which I found interesting as well. Yeah, I was taken by the movie makers or a married couple, newly married couple with their first baby on the way.

And the whole guiding thread of the story was about they're welcoming a baby into the world. And there's, it's replete with home movies of their own childhood growing up and, and then the announcement that they make to their parents that they're having a baby and marriage and family is at the center of it. And the, the, the thing that guided the conversation was how is this going to impact our child? And I found that really

compelling. And I don't think it's, it's random. Like there, there is a this, the question of AI has to do with what does it mean to be human? And you can't understand what it means to be human if you don't understand that the human story passes through the generations from generation to generation, through the act of generation. And that's was the backdrop of the whole from start to finish this documentary was, was looking at the family, this baby

coming into the world and what's the world going to be like for this baby. And one of the questions he asked all these high-powered world renowned experts on AI was do you want to have, if you don't already have children, do you want to have children? And the answer that people gave revealed really whether they thought AI was going to give, was going to bring about more of a, a promise of hope or a, or peril. That was kind of the, the way

they looked at it. Is it is it, is there something promising here or is there something perilous here? And there's a lot of reason to think there's a lot of peril. There are good reasons to think there's some beautiful things that can come from AI. But yeah, the, the approach I'm taking in my book is one of embodiment versus disembodiment and the fact that those who are pushing an agenda in the world of disembodiment, that they see AI as an ally in their 'cause

that is very concerning to me. But you know, some are saying it's going to be the end of the world. I don't, I don't go for any of that stuff. I mean, may I don't it's going to be the end of the world sometime. Whether AI brings it about or not, I don't know. Others are saying no, it's going to be a a time of unprecedented opportunity and advancement and what whatever it's going to be the promise or the peril. I don't know how people live their lives without faith,

without trust that we both said this at the end of the movie. Like, OK, there was this ominous feeling in the movie, where's the world going? And we both said, well, we know it's in God's hands and we know God is love and we know certainly there are going to be things we suffer in this life. But in the end, there's a loving God who works everything for the good and he has a perfect plan to bring about the fullness of our redemption. So that's that's what keeps us

going. Yeah. And that there really wasn't a faith component to this documentary other than, you know, the sense in which some people have a lot of faith in technology, you know, but they didn't call it that. But that is, in fact, true that some people do. Yeah. But lots of, you know, very thoughtful human beings really trying to be aware and considering this time in history

and the ways that technology is impacting things very quickly. And I, I just appreciate all those people and the hard work that they're doing. Yeah, yeah, I did too. If you guys are listeners, meaning are interested in this AI topic, I think we would both say yeah, you should watch this documentary. It's eye opening. Yeah. Do you have any updates for us from the TOV Institute? Well is on the time of the air date of this episode, it's June 1st.

We are turning the corner towards summer. I don't see a corner really. I don't know why we say we're turning a corner towards summer, but everybody knows what I mean by the expression and. In the northern hemisphere. In the northern hemisphere, we're headed towards summer and that means it is the summer season of TOB Institute. In person courses, June we have theology, the body level one that's June 14th to the 19th. It's not too late to sign up. There are a few spots left. You can check out the link.

In July. We have The Way of Beauty with Bill Donahue if you want to see the world as God created it to be, as the revelation of his own glory and beauty. Whether you're looking at a flower or an Ant or the smile of another human being, or the beauty of the moon, or hearing the Sound of Music, or listening to a poem, or just feeling the breeze, living a Sacramento life, encountering creation as

the revelation of divine beauty. That's what this course, the Way of Beauty, is all about. And then I will be teaching the TOB 2 course. You have to have taken TOB 1 to come to TOB 2. That's the first week of August. You can check all that out in the show notes. Also check out where we're traveling the first week of June. So just a few days after this episode is airing, I will be in Slovenia and Slovakia. We're doing the event called The Well in both of those countries

in early June. If you're in that part of Europe and you want to come out to see us, check out the dates in the show notes. And then in September, I'm headed to Croatia, Romania, and we're working on finalizing a stop in Austria. We'll see if that comes through. So yeah, check out our calendar of events. And if you ever want to bring us to your area, you can check out the link on that. Awesome. Are you ready for a question from one of our patrons?

This is from a patron named Catherine. Hello, Catherine. Thank you, Catherine, for your faithful support of our mission. We're really grateful to you. I was meditating on the crucifixion during Holy Week and had the question come up again in prayer about why our Lord is not completely nude in art portraying the crucifixion. I've wondered before but assumed it was the same reason the nude paintings in the Sistine Chapel were covered at one point.

Then I did further research and everything I found pointed to reverence for Christ and preserving his dignity as the reason he is not depicted completely nude. I read that he quote voluntarily accepted humiliation, but it need not be perpetuated. End Quote. Which makes sense, and I'm sure it would be more distracting for most people than helpful. But I do wonder how to look at this through ATOB lens. Why does it feel like it would

be irreverent to have art depicting Jesus nude, but there's other art depicting naked bodies like in the Sistine Chapel that's praised for depicting the beauty of the human body? Is it because of our fallen nature that sacred art does not depict this? Or is there something more theological that I'm missing? If you could help make sense of these fragmented thoughts I would appreciate it. Catherine, it's not as fragmented as you might think. I am following your train of thought. And I can tell you our being in

your train of thought, very thoughtful about this. Yeah, it's a it's an important question. And I, I'm thinking of this scripture from Saint Paul that to the pure, all things are pure. There's nothing, nothing irreverent about nakedness other than what we bring to it in our own irreverence, right in our own lack of purity. We project all kinds of

inappropriate ideas onto the naked body that are not part of God's view of the naked body. There was, yes, an intention to humiliate in the Roman experience of crucifixion, in which they stripped the victim completely naked. That is part of the gruesome spectacle of Roman crucifixion, for sure, and Christ endured that. But there's a great and powerful and beautiful theological

significance to Christ's nakedness on the cross. He is reliving all of the experiences of Adam in order to redeem them. And so we could say he goes to the cross naked, enduring the gruesome spectacle and humiliation of Roman crucifixion. But he comes out the other side in the resurrection and the Gospel accounts make this very clear.

The grave clothes were left behind, and the Catechism says, commenting on that, that this is a sign of him escaping the power of death and corruption. The new Adam comes out of a garden, out of the ground, just as the first Adam did on the first day of creation, naked without shame. Naked without shame. So he endures shame, if you

will, on the cross, although for for him he, he's only enduring the perverse gaze of a perverse world to Him. He's not humiliated by being naked. He created nakedness. He loves the naked body. He knows exactly what the naked body is and what it's for. And in fact, we see in the naked Christ on the cross, we see the sign of the old covenant being fulfilled in the gift of his

flesh and blood. What's the sign of the Old Covenant? It's circumcision. What would they have recognized? The bystanders. What would they have recognized about the guy crucified in the middle? He was a Jew and not any Jew. He's king of the Jews. And what is this promise given to Abraham? It's the sacrifice of flesh and blood right where it hurts. For what purpose? Fruitfulness. Fruitfulness.

Fruitfulness. What was the promise given to Abraham? Offspring more numerous than the stars. The promise given to Abraham is fruitful nuptial union. Who's going to see the sign of circumcision and when? Well, the person himself, the. Person himself for sure. His wife. His wife and particularly she will see it whenever they come together and this will be the reminder of the promise fruitful nuptial union. What happens at the cross, the

Super abounding fulfillment of fruitful nuptial union. The new Adam says to the new Eve, behold, your son, the beloved Disciple at the foot of the cross is the mystical offspring of the mystical marriage of Christ and the Church. This is our faith. Obviously the woman at the foot of the cross is Mary. That's his mother in the flesh. But as the Baltimore Catechism says, in the flesh she is his mother. In the Spirit. She is his bride, right?

There's this deeper dimension of what's going on. There's this virginal union of their hearts that presents and effects a new supernatural fertility. The New Eve. Mary becomes the mother of all the living at the foot of the cross. This is the Super abounding fulfillment of the promise given to Abraham. Christ's nakedness on the cross, His circumcision in the flesh, and then the piercing of his heart. Now we have the circumcision of

his heart and the New Testament. As we read in the New Testament, the circumcision of the flesh was just a foreshadowing of the circumcision of the heart. What is the circumcision of the heart? It's the heart that is open and exposed to the divine. That's the circumcised heart, right? We covered our genitals with original sin out of shame. And it's as if God is saying to Abraham, OK, you've been covering your genitals with fig leaves and loincloths and animal skins now, but I'm asking you to

remove even the natural covering of your anatomy. I want you exposed. I want your heart. That's ultimately what he's after. He wants the exposure of the heart for your hardness of heart. Moses allowed you to divorce your wives, but from the beginning it was not. So the actual translation there, the more fitting 1, is for your uncircumcision of heart. Moses allowed you to divorce your wives, but from the beginning it was not so.

The the circumcised heart is the heart that is open, exposed. The uncircumcised heart is the hard heart, the one that's covered over, the one that's hiding from God. I was afraid because I was naked, so I hid myself. All this is to say, Christ's nakedness on the cross is theologically critical because he is revealing what it means to be a son of the Father, to be exposed, to be naked without

shame, to stop hiding, to have the insides come out to to, to have one's heart circumcised. That that that's what's going on at the cross. So if there's any irreverence in Christ's nakedness on the cross, it's only the irreverence that we bring, right? And so we should be praying, Lord, open my eyes, open my eyes, open this.

I don't really subscribe to this idea that we cover the, the, the crucified in our art because we're, we're trying not to perpetuate the humiliation. We cover the crucified in our art because we can't handle the glory we we are. We cover the crucified in our art because we can't see, because we're blind to the glory revealed through the loins of our Incarnate Savior. It is the male body that is

designed by God to reveal the eternal fatherhood of God. That's what the male body is designed to do. Indeed. Indeed, people have heard me say this before on this podcast. It can be jarring if you're not familiar with this, but it is true. We we're not familiar with it because we don't know how to talk about it because of our own impurity. But to the pure, all things are pure, The very word testicles essential to the male anatomy, to the power to be a father.

The very word testicle shares the root as of words like testify, testimony, testament The purpose of the Old Testament The purpose of the New Testament is to reveal to testify to the eternal fatherhood of God. And the ultimate testimony in this world of the eternal fatherhood of God is the naked Christ giving up his body on the cross, where Mary becomes the mother of all the living and Christ reveals the perfect love

of the Father through his naked flesh. And as Adrian von Spire says, she's a modern Mystic. Her cause is up for canonization. She says when the church in her art began covering the crucified with the loincloth, it was the beginning of the church's refusal to see. Now, that said, there are many depictions throughout Christian history of the naked Christ on

the cross. Michelangelo did a famous one. Michelangelo also did a famous resurrected Christ, the risen Christ, naked without shame. This is also part of our tradition, something we mustn't forget. And there is so much we can gain by prayerful meditation on the naked Christ. A St. after St. speaks of this Saint Francis himself. His whole motto? Naked to follow the naked Christ.

I could say so much more. Were there were there any dangling things in her question that I I didn't at least touch on? Wendy, before you share any of your thoughts. No, I think you really. It seems to me that you spoke to a lot of what I've underlined in her question. I'll just say this one last thing. We overcome evil with good, right? And there's so many perverse depictions of the naked body in the world.

How do we overcome that? Is it only by covering that up? No, it's by learning to see the naked body rightly. We overcome unholiness with holiness and holiness is not the repression of of the body and sexuality, it's the redemption of the body and sexuality. It, it is it it Chastity knows when to veil to protect the dignity of the body.

And chastity also knows when to unveil and how to unveil the body without violating its dignity. So important, so important that we understand that the way we overcome perverse attachment or attraction to the body is by allowing Christ in there to redeem us, to give us sight, to open our eyes to, to Pierce our hearts, to allow our hearts to

be circumcised. We let our sinful passions be crucified. Not so we go into nothingness, but so that our eyes get open and we can see the glory of God revealed through the human body. That's how JP 2 defines purity. Purity of heart, he says, is the glory of God in the human body, through which masculinity and femininity are manifested. There is just one thing that was striking me as you were speaking

there. When you were speaking about a few times you mentioned circumcision of the heart and Christ's circumcision of heart and Paul calling us to have circumcision of heart. Even Jesus, you know the accurate translation, your uncircumcision of heart. I was just thinking about the the Catholic tradition of images of Jesus showing us his physical heart organ.

And, you know, when you're Catholic, you kind of just grow up with that and it doesn't strike you strange. But, you know, other people might find that really weird. Like, why is he pulling back his, like, robe and pointing to his heart organ? What's it doing there sitting? Outside, or even sometimes he has it in his hands. Right. But I was just feeling like that is really obviously tremendously.

There's a lot of symbolism and art does contain so much symbolism in it. It can be a very symbolic language and and I was just feeling in a new way that the symbolism of Christ's circumcision of heart being what we're seeing when we see an image we might call the Sacred Heart. That's right, Wendy, that we're seeing his circumcision of heart and as much as we might kind of experience a certain message of here he is showing me the depth

of his love. I think what was striking me was he also wants me to have a circumcised heart like he wants my heart just as exposed. And so that that sense of that important kind of powerful nakedness in a different way in the symbolic language of art that is just a beautiful complement to a lot of other art.

There's just seeing that significance in a new way of of circumcision, of heart and nakedness in in those images was what was striking me. I read a book years ago. You'll remember when I was reading this, Wendy, because it moved me so profoundly. It's called The Sexuality of Christ in Renaissance Art and in Modern Oblivion. And the book is written by Leo Steinberg, and it does a history of sacred art that portrayed Christ's masculinity in

appropriate ways. And one of the paintings that was featured in this book was called the blood hyphen. And this was a tradition and you know the, the title of the book in Renaissance art and in modern Oblivion since the Reformation, a lot of this has been censored. But this is part of the Catholic tradition. The blood hyphen. It's it's when the artist connects the flow of blood from the open side of Christ, the flow of blood will go over the

Lord's loins in order to connect symbolically the circumcision of the heart with the circumcision of the flesh. It's, it's profound. It's so profound to the pure. All things are pure. And if anybody's out there thinking, oh, I just can't handle that. It's too much, That's just wigging me out. OK, just say, Lord, why is this wigging me out? You looked at everything you made. Man and woman were naked without shame. You looked at them and you said, behold is very good.

You made us in our nakedness to reveal your own glory. Open our eyes, Lord, Open our eyes, Lord. The naked Christ on the cross and in his resurrection reveals the glory of the living God in his naked flesh. To the pure, all things are pure. To the impure, nothing is pure. To the impure, even that which is pure appears impure because that's the lens through which

they see everything. Lord, open our eyes. Adrian von Spyer, pray for us that we would no longer refuse to see, but that our eyes would be open to behold the glory of God revealed through our bodies. Amen. Amen. Our next question is from a listener named Ashley. Hi, Ashley. Hi Christopher and Wendy, thanks so much for your podcast. As a newlywed, my husband and I just celebrated our two year

wedding anniversary. Congratulations, Ashley. Your insight and advice has helped me greatly to show love to my husband, my family and friends in a more Christ like way. Six months ago my husband and I were blessed with a beautiful baby girl. Woop woop. My postpartum journey was difficult and is still a learning journey for us. We're trying to navigate intimacy in this new stage of life. I especially struggle with a new anxiety that has popped up as a result of my postpartum.

I'm petrified that I will do something wrong and mess up my daughter. This has translated into me showing less attention to my husband. He's a very loving man and I want to express my love for him, but it is hard. In this new reality in which we live, my brain does not seem to be wired towards the same level of intimacy that it did before I gave birth. Also, our daughter's crib is right next to the bed my husband and I sleep in. I know she's too young to

remember it, but I am terrified that our daughter will wake up and see us in the marital embrace and that it will scare or scar her for life. Any advice? Bless you, dear Ashley. Gosh, I just hearing you read the question zooms me back to that stage of our lives. We had babies sleeping in our in a crib in our room for years. And yeah, that presents various challenges. I I do want to ask you, Wendy, are you?

She uses the word intimacy here. Now, sometimes we use that as a euphemism for sexual union. Intimacy can have broader and does have broader meanings than that. And I couldn't I it's obviously she's talking about sexual intimacy in some sense, but is she also talking about just not being close to her husband in an intimate sharing of hearts? Or is do you think the whole question is about sexual union and sexual closeness? I can't say for sure that that

towards the, you know, physical affection of marriage seems to be the. Main the overarching theme. Yeah, well, well, let's take it from that angle. Although I I do want to just acknowledge what what the heart really needs, whether physical and sexual intercourse is possible. What the heart really needs is just what we were saying from their other question, a nakedness of heart and exposing of the heart, a sharing of the

heart, a closeness of heart. When there are circumstances, and it's often times in married life, especially with little kids, when sexual closeness, sexual physical intimacy is not as easily accomplished. It should never prevent a sharing of our hearts that that special closeness of sharing our lives, sharing our pain, sharing our frustration, sharing our joys and sufferings and hopes and dreams.

That's it's so important that husband and wife do that. I wanted to say that first, addressing the question of physical closeness. There are seasons in married life when we have to commit ourselves to finding a way, finding the time, making whatever adjustments, sacrifices so as to give the marital embrace its proper place.

And, and I, I, I was going to say priority, but I, I don't want to, I don't want to say it in, in a sense that makes anybody think that I don't acknowledge. There are times in married life when it's, it's difficult. You go through different seasons in life, obviously, but it should be, it is a source of grace in married life. So long as husband and wife are truly open to that grace when it's just sought in a selfish way, in a domineering way, in a lustful way, when there's no tenderness, when we're

influenced by a pornographic world and we're bringing that into our sexual activity, that's not a grace. That's that's the opposite. That's a detriment. That's a, a robbing of, of our hearts of what we really need and desire. But what I'm saying is presuming a couple open to grace, a couple seeking God's will, a couple open to the presence of the Holy Spirit, a couple who understands

that the marital act is a renewal of their marital vow expressed through the language of their bodies. And so it becomes a unique opportunity to deepen the marriage bond. Nothing else in married life deepens the marriage bond in the same way. There are lots of things in married life, obviously, that deepen the marriage bond, but nothing deepens the marriage bond in this particular way. A couple open to the Lord and

Giver of life in their marital embrace, crying out for God's mercy and their weakness. Learning how to love, learning how to become a sincere gift to each other, learning how to tend to each other's hearts and minds and bodies in that particularly marital expression of love and union. That should be a priority in the normal course of events in married life. When Wendy and I, when you and I were in that stage, my love, we would, we would find a, a, a, a

quiet place in the house. We would, we would find other places where we would have a monitor for the baby and we'd go somewhere else. I I because of what you shared, which goes deep in your heart, obviously, Ashley, you're afraid that you're, you know, OK, she's she your your infant's young. Did she say it's a boy girl, a girl, six months daughter, your daughter's young. She wouldn't remember it anyway, but but you need and JP 2 talks about this in love and

responsibility when he gets into the to quote Nacho Libre, the nitty gritties when he gets into the nitty gritty details of what is required for what he calls marital harmony in the conjugal embrace. He speaks of the need for a safe environment where distraction is not present where you know somebody barging in is is you know there's a locked door.

There's a safeguard for your heart when when Jesus says when you pray, go in your inner room and close the door. We can also apply that to the to the marital prayer. The marital embrace is meant to be a true prayer. When you go to pray in this marital way, in the marital act, close the door, lock the door, make make a safe environment. So I would say find a way. I don't know what your the layout of your house is. I don't know the circumstances,

but find a way where you can make a priority of being alone so that you can renew your marriage covenant through the marital act, but also share with your husband what you're going through. Share the difficulty, share the struggle, share the concern, share the fear. What we're really desiring, I started off with this, what we're really desiring is the intimacy of heart that then allows the marital act to become the physical expression of an intimacy that already exists. Often times we we go for the

physical intimacy with the without ever opening our hearts and that creates A disintegration. So that would be my initial advice. And I'm, I'm eager to hear what you have to say, Wendy. I love that. I loved what you said. And I think it's just spoken with, yeah, wisdom and. Experience. Definitely we have some experience in this territory for sure. And just really I think part of what I hear Ashley is kind of

saying in between the lines is I wasn't expecting this and I wasn't expecting to experience a different level of physical interest in the marital embrace. And so that's, that brings a lot of confusing feelings. And that's what you were encouraging her to talk through with her husband. And it's an education for both of you, you know, and, and not

everyone's experience is the same. So I know that, you know, some people, you know, not everyone can relate to feeling exactly like Ashley, but lots of people can. And some I've heard people say, you know, it, it wasn't, it didn't kind of come around to what I remembered from before giving birth for quite a while, you know, and and someone I think once said, you know, it

took two years to feel to for me as a woman to feel like I did before. That's a long time of your marriage. We don't want to waste that time. We want to let it bear fruit. And I think that's what you're encouraging both in just talking about the sharing of hearts, which, you know, for us often that looked like a lot of talking because that's our way of kind of sharing hearts. But that's not everybody's way.

And that's OK. You know, sometimes it's just a, a resting together and maybe crying sometimes. Like not everything has to be articulated in words in order to be shared when you have such a, a person that you love so deeply. So I just, yeah, want to acknowledge that that that is part of letting this be a fruitful time, letting this not missing the gift that the Lord

is giving you in this time. And yeah, the the importance of a little bit of planning, you know, that is involved in making time and space, literal physical space for marital union when you have small children. That's also beautiful and kind of funny sometimes too. And just laughing about that is good as well. I mean, really.

A sense of humor is good medicine in all of this. Yeah, yeah. So I think, I think I just, I just received and was almost like kind of consoled myself in my in my memories, memories of those feelings that Ashley's talking about just by your encouragement of her to share her heart and to trust the Lord is in their marriage and desiring each of their good. And that, yeah, they're, they're

growing. They're growing through this different experience that that they didn't expect and deepening their trust in their love for one another because maybe their experience of marriage has changed. So does that mean the love isn't there? Right, right. And actually it's it's more. Yeah, there's so many seasons you go through in married life, different phases, different things you could never predict. And what what did she say? They they were married for how

long before the baby came around? Well. Did she say? She said they've been married for two years, so the. Baby's six. OK, so a year and a half you had without the baby and you know, you, you grow in a sense of, oh, this is what married life is like. And then kaboom, there's a major, major change. And it's a new time, a new season, a new adjustment to be made. And what you thought married life was for the last year and a half.

It's not that anymore. But that doesn't mean it's not married life. This is part of part of the pilgrimage of married life. And I would encourage you, Ashley, to be tender with yourself. The demands on your body now are much greater than they were at the the first year or so of your marriage, especially if you're breastfeeding. There your, your body is pouring itself out for this new life and know that that is the natural

extension of your marital embrace. This is the fruit of your marital embrace. This is not detrimental to your marriage. This is the fruit of marital union and love. And to receive it that way into oh, oh, this is, this is, this is normal. This is natural. We're in a different phase. We're in a different time. We need to talk about it. We need to learn how to communicate. We need to be tender with ourselves. We need to be tender with each other, understanding and patient and have a long term vision

'cause there are other phases and stages of married life ahead that you can't even dream or imagine are coming your way. But with an openness and a trust and a a willingness to to communicate whatever the the right language is. I think Wendy, you were right to say it's not always or only through words. It's there are many ways that we communicate our hearts to one another. Keep the lines of communication open, even if those things that need to be communicated are stressful or difficult.

Much better that they come out into the light in an in an environment of patience and understanding. Then they get buried and become resentments and bitterness that then explodes later on. So Ashley, you and your husband and your daughter, you're, you're in our prayers. And I'm going to ask all the listeners out there, would you offer some little sacrifice or big sacrifice? What, however, you feel LED for Ashley and her husband that they would find a a new rhythm in their current circumstances to

show each other the love and closeness that they desire? Our next question is from a listener named Justin. Hi Justin, I'm 25 years old and I serve full time in college ministry. I've been tremendously. That's in all caps. Grateful for your teaching and work. I'm so glad, Justin. It has helped me in my ministry to younger men, as well as, of course, in my own prayer life. One thing God has been poking at

for a long time that I've been terribly afraid to address is my memory of when my dad came to have the talk with me. Instead of saying anything about marriage or the marital act, he simply said of masturbation Quote. It's normal and natural, just make sure you to clean up after yourself. Oh. Mercy. At 12 years old, not having any

other education on the matter, that left me with a view of my overall sexuality that made it feel more can forgive me to pooping. It's just a thing that's natural and you got to do what you got to do, just clean up after. Yourself. I used to laugh at this story, but I feel the pain of it more and more deeply now. As a man who has been called to marriage, I see the beauty of the theory of marriage, but I frustratingly can't help but

feel grossed out at the reality of the environmental embrace. I know this is wrong, but I'm having a very difficult time disentangling the lie. How can I partner with Christ in untwisting this thing in my heart? Justin, my brother, you already are. And more to the point, he is partnering with you. That's the direction it goes. He always initiates our healing.

He always initiates our healing. When we find ourselves interested in that healing and wanting to pursue it and desirous of it, it's already the sign that an abundant work of grace is already underway. As I've said on many occasions and written in some of my books, all we can ever say to God is I love you too because it's always His initiative. The catechism says the initiative is always on the Lord. Our first step is always a

response. A response. So you are responding to a grace, Justin, that is being already lavished on you. It is evident that you desire this healing. That is the sign that it's already underway. The grace is already being poured out. Another sign of the grace is that your heart has seen that laughing at that story is a

mask. It's a mask for pain, right? I can think of very similar circumstances in my own life, A very painful reality from my childhood that was so painful I just would laugh. I'd tell the story to others and laugh, and that was a mask. That was a mask. The Lord is giving you permission to weep because that's the proper response. That's the proper response.

Your father would have given you the splendor of the truth had it been given to him. But he couldn't give to you that splendor because no one gave it to him. He passed on to you whatever he had learned and whatever he had come to believe. But it's just riddled, riddled with lies. Lies that were meant to cripple you. Lies not.

I'm not saying that your father intended this. He was, I'm sure, doing the best he could. That's what he understood. That's what he was taught. Probably that's what he's passing on to his son. He thought he was doing a good job, but he was, he was an instrument of the liar, of the father of lies. I'm, please hear me correctly, I'm not saying your dad's possessed or something, but the enemy can make use of other people's bad formation to, to really, really trip us up.

And this got into your mind, into your heart at a young age, and it formed and shaped you at a very vulnerable time in your life when you're psychosexual development was underway. And that formed and shaped and molded you in a way that now you're realizing as a young man that you, as you yourself said, you're entangled in a bunch of lies, a web of lies. Here's the good news. Christ came into the world to

undo the work of the enemy. Cling to that. Look up that scripture and rest in it. Meditate on it and ask the Lord to show you my my spiritual director would say, ask for the slow motion replay. Ask for the slow motion replay, Justin, of that experience with your father and ask Jesus, where were you in that memory and what

were you speaking? What were you feeling? What was going on in your heart when I was learning that lie? Even as I say it, I, I, I just feel the, the, the Lord's heart being pierced and the flow of blood and water from his heart just gushing all over you, Justin, just gushing all over

your mind and your heart and your body. And the mess that needs to be cleaned up here is not your semen. The mess that needs to be cleaned up here is the lie that your semen is a mess that needs to be cleaned up. Your seed has a destiny. Your seed belongs in the garden, the garden of your bride.

That's where your seed belongs. Your seed. If you're called the marriage, this is this will be the home of your seed. Your seed has a purpose, an end, a goal, a meaning. And it is not a mess to clean up, it is a glory to pour out in self giving love. Again. The mess that needs to be cleaned up is the lie that got into your heart that your seed

is a mess that needs to be cleaned up. Jesus, I ask you, please to reveal to my brother Justin the true glory, the true goodness, the true beauty, the true power of his seed, that you have called him as a man to be a true testimony of your eternal fatherhood through the gift of his seed. And I invite you also, Justin, to ask, as you ask for the slow motion replay, ask where the

Blessed Mother was. Mary is the New Eve. She is the woman who opened her garden to the eternal seed of God, the immortal seed of God, and conceived virginally the eternal Son of the Father. Her garden is the new Eden. Her womb is the New Eden. It's where all God's will is accomplished. The seed of God is brought to its full flowering in Mary's garden.

Ask her to teach you the true mystical meaning of your seed. She will, She will ask Saint Joseph to teach you. And if any of that sounds strange to any of our listeners, it's because we have projected onto Joseph and Mary and Jesus, our own puritanical crapola. Jesus and Mary and Joseph, they love, love their bodies because they understand what they're

for, to reveal the glory of God. Please Lord, Please Lord, we lift up our brother to you. Shine your light, Mary. Shine, Shine the light of Christ in your womb. Christ is in your womb. Christ is in your womb through the eternal, immortal, invisible seed of God. Christ is in your womb. Mary Show show Justin how he is meant to testify to that eternal immortal seed through his own body. I, It's so awesome to be invited

into just an experience like this and to share it with our listeners. And I'm so grateful to Justin for sharing this story, which clearly has been a really painful story that's it's not solved yet. You know, where he's looking for help because it's it's ongoing, but there's been a lot of light shone in his heart about this wound. And I think it's so helpful for everyone just to, to hear how the Lord can do this in our

lives that that things that we just feel instinctively have always felt that, you know, maybe just our part of our experience, that the Lord can shine a light on where that came from in our story. And that that's the beginning of a real healing that's possible. And, and Justin's kind of opening it to us in the midst of that. You know, his heart is open. He's been in ministry, he's seen

the Lord at work in people's lives and in his own life. And you know what, just because we say yes to the Lord and we desire to be close to him doesn't mean that all our wounds just instantly are healed. And there's a timing and a pace to that journey. And as you said at the very beginning of your answer, like the Lord is partnering and reaching out because this is the time for this healing. And something we've talked about sometimes on our podcast is just

a concept of a healing prayer or healing of memories. And a lot of what you were describing there to Justin and asking him for that to, to ask the Lord to give him that slow motion replay and to ask where is the Lord and where is the Blessed Mother? That's a path for a healing of a wound, of a memory that can absolutely have a lasting effect in our lives, where the pain that seems like wed to the

memory can actually be healed. And so we can have on the other side of that experience of of grace, we can actually remember the memory without having that pain and all of its effects still holding on to us anymore. And so that is a profoundly hopeful thing. And sometimes people experience that just in their own prayer life.

I know for myself, some like, I'll just say, Christopher is amazing and can just in his morning prayer time, just dig into things like this. I need set aside time. I need to know I have a couple hours and I can just be on my own and like, this is the thing. And so I'll take a memory and I'll just go and really give it some time and I'll, I'll just try not to anticipate the end of the prayer time that I need to

be where I am right now. I need to look at the pain I'm in right now from this situation and and invite the Lord to to show me the the details of the memory and especially to show me my own heart in the story and in that I'm inviting him into it and and overtime. And usually for me, there's journaling because it keeps helps me to keep my mind focused on what I'm praying about. Sometimes if I'm just praying

without keep journaling, it start, my mind starts to wander, you know, So I'll journal and I'll invite the Lord and, and truly he has ways of speaking to our hearts that are profound. I'll also say this, sometimes something like a retreat, like ones we've mentioned before, like the John Paul 2 Healing Center is an example. They do weekend retreats, which really can help with healing memories or even meeting with a

Catholic therapist. I found myself because I'm familiar with the work of Doctor Jerry Crete and of souls and hearts, Doctor Peter Malinowski. It's a, a Catholic therapist group that talk about internal family systems, which is just a, a approach to therapy that anyway, I think it's really powerful. And I could just see in your story this frustration about being grossed out.

Like I'm, I'm thinking from that internal family systems perspective like that, that part of you that feels that way is, is protecting you in some way. And there there has to be a gentleness toward that and not a not to be angry that that exists in your heart, but just to have have compassion on that part. It was a, a reaction to something very threatening and very awful to be, you know, invited into manhood with such

a, a weak and uninspiring message like that. Your, your heart needed to protect itself from that and, and to just be kind to that reality within you and not not upset with yourself. That can just be very freeing to recognize like the good intentions of your 12 year old self in all unconscious ways that it developed these

protective instincts. So some of those things are just on my heart to encourage, like Justin is revealing something so helpful to us and I'm so grateful that he invited us in there and, and that the Lord is present in this process and it's, it's exciting. I'm going to say a word here that might sound strange to people who just aren't familiar with the symbolism of the body, but just in the fact that you linked your seed and I'm, I'm glad you voiced it.

You voiced, you see, brought it out into the light that you're in your mind, in your heart somewhere. Your, your seed, the expelling of seed is connected to poop. You said those are symbols, man. Those, those symbols go deep in our souls. And there's a what you could call a symbolic confusion in your heart here. Poop is waste. The seed is for life, life,

life, life. Poop is a symbol of of a certain dying and decay. The seed is a symbol of life. Your seed is sacred. And blessing. And blessing the the Father, the Father from eternity, when he created male and female, he gave them the blessing of fertility, the blessing of fertility, the blessing. Glory be to God, the blessing of fertility.

Your seed is holy, brother. Your seed is not for shit. Your seed is holy. That is a lie. Your seed is holy. Your seed is sacred. Your seed is meant to give life and to bless. Lord reprogram our brother's mind, heart, and body to understand the true meaning and glory and beauty and dignity of His masculinity. We all need to hear this. We all need to hear it. We, we all have been warped.

The enemy is after us right here. This is where he goes because of how holy and sacred it is. This is where he goes to pervert and distort. Lord. The good news is what the enemy has pornified you Lord have purified so that it might also be glorified. Wow. Thanks Justin for your vulnerability. If you've been blessed by what we shared today and you know

people who could be blessed, could you please help us get this message out to others and share this episode? You are a blessing to us, Lord. We ask for the grace that we would. Become the gift that we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you

that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode