Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Seeing the Naked Body as a Physician, Knowing God's Will With Certainty, and St. Joseph in TOB | ACW349

Sep 8, 20251 hrAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: 1. I was addicted to pornography until my mid-twenties but have lived chastely for 12 years. Still, I struggle with scars: working as a physician, I get tempted by seeing women’s bodies. I pray in those moments, but I still desire to look, searching for a “moral excuse.” I’ve been dating someone who knows in general, but I can’t tell her every time. Why hasn’t this stopped, even though she fills my heart? Is this from pornography, or something deeper? 2. I’m dating a man who loves TOB, and we’ve built a childlike friendship where we can be ourselves. We both think God may be calling us to marriage, but how do I know for sure? My past dating has often ended in disappointment, but this relationship feels different - we strive for virtue together. I want to balance my desire to be a gift in marriage with God’s plan, but I’m afraid of the future and struggle to surrender completely. 3. I understand Mariology is deeply tied to TOB, but what about Saint Joseph? I rarely see his role explained. How is his mission interwoven with TOB? Resources: Are you ready for marriage? Check out Next Step: A Course for Discerning Marriage CONSECRATION TO JESUS THROUGH ST. JOSEPH: AN INTEGRATED LOOK AT THE HOLY FAMILY REDEMPTORIS CUSTOS by JPII PATRIS CORDE by Pope Francis Symposium | The Josephology Society Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠ ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Hey, Wendy. Yes. We're doing some really complex math before we hit the record button. Oh yeah, maybe you could share that deep complex math problem with everybody. Well, you're being a little bit sarcastic, so I just want to share that with the group

because all I said was we're recording episode 349 and I said what's 349 + 1? And you said, wait, let me. I'm trying to, you have to think about, I have to think about that like 349. It was 350. Which is not now, not now next. Week. But everybody guess what? Next week is our 350th episode. Yeah, that's it. Just feels fun. It does feel fun. We've been doing this a while. Do you know, I, I feel like it's been kind of over the years now

it's almost seven years, obviously weekly episodes. You know, it's been a journey for us personally, and I think it has, it's been a deepening of our marriage. It has been I without a doubt, I can say that. Yeah, and I think we are just so grateful for that. I mean, I know we are. Yes, we are. Yeah. And maybe we could say more about that next week when we hit 350. We can we can talk about how we've grown. OK. That would be fun.

That'll give us a week to think about it. But on this episode, you were going to tell people about a movie. I was. Going to tell people about a movie I saw recently I re watched a movie you and I watched oh gosh 15 years ago I don't know when did that come out I. Don't know a long time. Ago Yeah it's called smoke signals and it's about two Native Americans on a reservation in Idaho who have to go on a kind of pilgrimage together and I I I came up you know on the I'm flying this 8

hour flight from Brazil and it was on the list of movies. I was like, oh, I remember really liking that, but I can barely remember a darn thing about it. That's a good thing about losing your memory when you're in your 50s. You can rewatch movies that you knew you liked and it's like you're watching it for the first time. It was kind of like, although I once it unfold, I was like, Oh, yeah, oh, right. But there's still parts of the movie. I was like, oh, I didn't remember that at all. I remembered I liked it. I rewatched it and it spoke

right to something I'm I'm looking at in my own heart lately. And I just want to say to everybody out there, if you're looking for a good movie to watch, it's not like entertainment, although there's some funny things in it. But it it's a great movie reflecting on the relationship of fathers and sons and the pains and the sufferings there. And how do we forgive our fallen fathers? Everyone's father is a fallen father. Some of us have fathers who

wounded us more deeply than others, but there's nobody who has an earthly father who is perfect. And so there are wounds there. And this movie, not in a heavy-handed way, but in the in the way of good storytelling, it takes you on a pilgrimage to look at forgiving your father. If you're in that situation where you need to forgive your father for something, this could be a really, really good movie to watch. I I recommend it. I know our listeners love a good movie recommendation and I'm

glad you shared. That yeah, it actually really helped me. I, I've worked through a lot in terms of forgiving my father for for things, but it took me to a new level of just wanting to show him mercy. Because as a father myself now of several adult children, I know, I know how desperately in need of mercy I am. And when you know how, how much in need of mercy you are in your fatherhood, you're ready, more ready to extend that same mercy

to your own father. So that's where it kind of landed for me. I thought it was, it was a really helpful. It's it's amazing how good art can take you to places in your heart where you need to journey. Yeah. That's the gift of good art. This was good art. Yeah. Do you have an update for us from the Dubey Institute? I don't want to share like anything on the horizon right now, although they're things on the horizon. And you can check out our links in the show notes as you always do for upcoming courses and events and all that stuff. But what I want to say today is just one big, sincere, heartfelt

thank you to our patrons out there. We have so many people who who offer us a little contribution month after month and you know, on your credit card, it just shows up as 20 bucks or 30 bucks or 50 bucks or whatever you've pledged and you probably don't even notice it. You probably don't even look at it. You and you just keep doing it month after month. And that enables us to do what we do honestly and truly, we would not be able to do what we do without our patrons.

So I just want to shout out to everybody out there who's month after month paying that credit card bill and, and probably not even thinking about it, or maybe you look at your credit card statement and you send up a little prayer for us. Please continue that. We need the prayers and we need the financial support to, to do what we do. So we're, we're very, very grateful and we have some exciting things on the horizon for our patrons. I'm going to hold off on that. I've been talking about it for a long time and it's just not yet finalized.

We have so many irons in the fire at the institute and our our staff is small, but we have some exciting things on the horizon for our patrons. And when the time is right, I'll make that announcement here as elsewhere, you'll get an e-mail from us about some very exciting, just new things happening that I think our patrons will be very happy about. I just wanted to say thank you to everybody who supports us. I don't take that for granted. My team and I, we don't take that for granted. We, we just couldn't do what we do without the people who

believe in what we're doing and support us. And if you're not a patron and you want to be part of our community of patrons, would you please click that link, $20.00 a month, $30.00 a month, $50.00 a month, whatever you can afford. That really, really does help us. We're we're so grateful. Yeah, we really are. And transition patrons get first dibs on questions on our podcast. So you get your own little profile where you submit your question and you have a much

higher chance of having your question answered. So that's just a little incentive. And we have a whole, whole list of of exclusive benefits for our patrons that I hope you patrons out there are taking advantage of that. From. A patron? Let's do it. Yes, this is from an anonymous patron. Thank you, dear anonymous patron, for your belief and support in what we're doing. Hi Christopher and Wendy, I've followed your podcast since the beginning. Wow. And it has been a huge blessing

in my life. Now I'm struggling with a scar in my soul that I can't understand, so I wanted to ask you for some light. In my teenage years until my mid 20s, I was addicted to pornography. Bless you, bless you, bless. You By God's grace, I was healed and for about 12 years I've been living chastely. Thanks be to. God, and this is beautiful, but I still have some scars in my soul that cause me suffering. I still get really excited whenever I get the chance to see

a woman naked, and this is a problem because I work as a physician so it happens quite often. Bless you, brother, bless. You, of course, in those moments I stop and pray to stop the thoughts in my head and to ask God to make my eyes respectful and I go on. It's like I really want to see that beauty and I'm trying to find a quote UN quote moral excuse to look at women's bodies since I don't use the immoral means anymore.

I've been dating a woman for a few months and she knows in general about this problem but I can't tell her every single time otherwise she'll suffer. I don't understand why all of this hasn't stopped since I met her because she always fills my heart only looking at her face and yet the scar is still there. Is that from pornography or is there something deeper about it? God bless you, good brother. What a pilgrimage you have been

on and as a physician, it's a pilgrimage that you are, you are compelled to continue on. And, and I, I think you, you already have experienced many, many graces and I, I do think that we can provide some food for thought for you that will, I hope, put your mind and heart at ease on the one hand, and on the other hand, spur you on to further integration and growth.

I was really struck by what he said about the woman he's dating, that her face, how did he say it? Her face fills him with joy. Or how did he put it? She always fills my heart only looking at her face. She fills your heart, looking at her face. OK, OK, let's start right there. Let's start right there. The face. Even after original sin, the face has retained the ability to communicate the person in a way

that the entire body before original sin communicated the person. It was as if the whole body. Before original sin, it's as if the whole body were a face. And I, I remember I've probably shared this on previous episodes, but I remember years ago I was sharing this with my students at the TOB Institute. I said it's as if the whole body in the beginning were a face. And one of my students raised a hand. He looks so puzzled. He said, what are you saying? Are you saying they were just

like Mr. and Missus Potato Head in the beginning, like their whole body was a face? I said no, no, no, no, you got the wrong picture. What I'm saying is what the face is still able to do communicate the mystery of the person, right? The whole body was able to do so. Keep that in mind as I shared this quote from John Paul the second he says in our reactions, both are sensual and effective, meaning on the emotional level, both are sensual and effective reactions to the body of

another. He says chastity calls us not to pretend we aren't having those reactions, not to shove or push those reactions into the subconscious where they await an opportunity to explode. No, he says, this is not chastity. Chastity, he says, is a matter of long term integration where we, with the help of God's grace, are able to raise to the personal level all of our

effective and sensual reactions to the body and sex of another. This is the path of integration, not annihilation of our reactions, not the the repression of our reactions. But this is the word JP 2 uses, the sublimation of our reactions. Now what does that mean? To make it sublime, to raise it to the level of the dignity of the person. Now you as a physician and thank

you. Thank you for your honesty. Thank you for your honesty. I, I often think of physicians. I'll tell a story of 1 physician I, I spoke to years ago. It always stayed with me because it disturbed me. I was asking him from, you know, one man to another. He was an OBGYN. So his whole profession had to do with the very intimate realities of caring for women's bodies. And I asked him just man to man, you know, what is that like? Have have you reached a, a, a, a

stage in your life of integration where you're able to honor the dignity of, of the women you serve? And his, his reaction troubled me. He said, he said, oh, I, I, I this, I would rather not see the nakedness of a lot of these women. It's just so disturbing. And I thought, oh, oh gosh, that your buddy, you're going the wrong direction here. The the way the way to deal with with the temptation to lust or

or that temptation to disintegration is not by by dismissing women's bodies because they don't fit into your model or ideal of attractiveness. That was basically what he was saying. Like I'd, I'd rather I not have to see the, the kind of bodies that I have to deal with because they troubled him. Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. That's a person sitting on your physician's table right there very vulnerably up in the

stirrups. That's a person. That's a person made in the image and likeness of God. And the way you safeguard your heart is not by saying, oh, isn't that disturbing to look at? I wish you would lose some weight, or I wish you weren't XY and Z. No, no, no, no, no, no, no. The path is to see every person as a person. And, and I'll tell you an experience I had just the other day. I was walking through the airport in Brazil. And, you know, there's some

billboard with some woman's breasts, like, right in my face. It's this huge billboard. You can't ignore it. There it is, right in your face, this woman's breasts. And, and I'm always looking for little things I can say to my heart that take me in the direction of seeing images like that as a picture of a person, not just a picture of breasts, right. There's no such thing as breasts. That's an abstraction. The only thing that it exists is a person's breasts.

And, and so I'm always looking to integrate body parts with persons. This is the path we must go on. And so this, this landed on me like a new way of saying it. I said, those breasts are part of your story. Those breasts are part of your story. And I looked her in the eyes. I mean, this isn't even an actual person. This is a photograph of a person. But it's really an internal exercise. I looked the person in the eyes and I said those breasts that just confronted me on this huge

billboard right in my face, those breasts are part of your story. And I saw her like in the flash of an eye or in the wink of an eye. I just confused 2 little phrases in a flash or the wink of an eye. I saw her as a little girl before she had breasts. And I just sensed her story and I wondered, gosh, what was it like for her to mature? What was it like for her to go through puberty? What was it? Was she picked on by the boys? Did she have older brothers who made fun of her?

Did she have a father and a mother who could tenderly guide her through that that experience of puberty? Probably not. In our broken world, that's not typically the way it goes. And I, I, I just sensed some of the sadness in her heart of not knowing what to do with the attention of the boys in fifth grade or 6th grade when she was first developing. And I, I kind of all in a flash, had a sense of her story and that here she is on a billboard selling her body or using her body to sell a product.

And it told me it was a sad story. It was a sad story. And, and all in a, in a course of a few seconds, I walked away from that billboard, not overwrought by some temptation to treat her breasts as objects for my pleasure, but with a sense of a person who has a story that's very painful. And it just, it rooted me in that, that path that JP 2 talks about of raising our reactions

to the body and sex of another to the level of the dignity of the person and that person's story and that person's history and that person's pains and joys and sorrows and difficulties. And here you are as a physician where your patients are in a most vulnerable place, a most vulnerable place. And you have the opportunity in the moment to to seek that

integration, to realize that what you're attracted to in that person at its depth, right? We have surface attractions that are, are disordered and we can just zoom in on body parts for our own selfish pleasure. But below that, at a deeper level, you can walk that path of thinking of the vulnerability of this person, thinking of this person's story, thinking of this person's hopes and dreams and sadness. And especially if they're there because they have some chronic

illness or difficulty or, or what have you, they're coming to see a physician that makes them very vulnerable. You can love them there. You can give them a, a glance, a a gaze of love that takes sustained and long term integration. And I want to share this quote with you from John Paul the 2nd. And what I'm drawing from here is his marvellous work, Love and Responsibility. And I urge everyone out there, if you want to go on this

pilgrimage, we have a love and responsibility course coming up online in September. And we have an in person love and responsibility course that I and my colleague Jeanette Clark, we'll be teaching in person November 2nd to the 7th here in Pennsylvania. So please check that out if you want to go on this pilgrimage. I cannot think of a better way to do it than diving head first into love and responsibility. But but here's what he says, a readily roused sensuality, which

I believe you have. A readily roused sensuality is the stuff from which a rich, if difficult, personal life can be made because it makes us more sensitive to the richness of true interpersonal love. Brother, you asked, is this the result of pornography? You, you spoke of a a scar or a wound that is still there. I, I, I can't answer the

question. It's kind of a chicken and an egg thing. Certainly the way pornography programmed you to think has contributed, that's no doubt. But but don't the the danger here would be that you would blame your own sensual reactions, meaning your own body, or that you would blame the body of these women whom you are privileged to serve. Both of those are cop outs,

right? This is what JP 2 describes as a loophole. To avoid the requirements of the gospel, if we blame the body, someone else's body or our own body for the temptations we experience. The loophole that JP Two is talking about is we are no longer looking at the real place of the dysfunction which is in our hearts and we have stepped out of the path of interior integration. I know you are on this path my

brother. How do I know it? Because you you rejoice in your girlfriend's face. You see her as a person, and you have the opportunity to see everyone who comes to you for medical care. You have the opportunity to see every person, male or female, as a person. But you must stay on that pilgrimage, and right in the moment where you sense that sensual reaction or that little bit of excitement, you can say,

Lord I, I ask you, please, by the power of your death and resurrection, to untwist what sin has twisted in me so that I might come to experience my attraction to this person's body as an attraction to the real person. Not as some sexual eroticized attraction, but as a desire to uphold the good and dignity of this person.

You are in a privileged place as a doctor to to minister to people in a very vulnerable place. And that path of integration, that task. John Paul the second says sometimes we can confuse the inner movements of our hearts. Is this lust? Is this an honouring of the person? Sometimes those inner movements of our heart, he says, can be confused with one another. But we have been called by Christ, he says, to acquire a mature and a complete evaluation of the movements of our hearts. And this task can be carried

out, he says. And it is truly worthy of man. Yeah, I really love all that you shared with this patron and I I was struck just it kind of got some thoughts going in my mind about healthcare. And I used to be a nurse. So I'm familiar with that kind of life where, yes, there's, you know, an unusual exposure to human bodies compared to other

people's work. And yeah, just the different things that can go on in our minds to kind of get through the day and get through our tasks and do our job, so to speak. And I was, I was as you were, I was troubled by that one physician you mentioned who had just kind of what I sensed in what you were sharing from that other person was kind of a, I'm

going to cope with this uncomfortable reality by being dismissive. And that's that's what. You said yes. You're putting your finger right on it. And I just want to say, I think that there are many physicians and healthcare workers, physical therapists, all, all kinds of people who, you know, they have to handle these things as part of their work. But I think there are many who have learned theology of the body and have incorporated it. The things you're talking about have sunk deep into their hearts.

And I can remember also a time when a doctor spoke to you of the just awe and wonder that learning TOB had caused them to have in doing their work. And I I don't remember if it was a man or woman. It was, I think I know the story you're talking. It was a nurse's aide. It was a man. OK, and and if this is the story you're thinking of, this one stayed with me too in for the opposite reason, because it was so beautifully integrated. He, he had to shave a woman's pubic area before a surgery.

And, and he went with such reverence because of what he had learned through John Paul the Second's teaching. And the woman whom he was shaving was struck and and, and thanked him for his. I don't know if she used this word, but she was trying to communicate that she felt appropriately cared for and not treated as an object. And, and I remember when I was in the hospital for my my broken femur and I had to be catheterized here.

We're getting pretty personal, but this such is the nature of this question. And, and there was a female nurse who had to catheterize me and I felt, of course, incredibly vulnerable. I'm in extreme pain. I hadn't urinated for a very long time. And I didn't, I mean, I, this woman came in, I'm so vulnerable and she had to obviously handle my genitals to catheterize me. And I remember, and you were with me.

She just treated me with, with respect and reverence and put me at ease. And even as I recall the story, I could tear up because it was not weird or funky, or I mean, it was a little weird to have another woman holding my genitals. There was nothing funky about it. It was just a loving care from a medically trained professional who needed to help me in a very desperate situation. And I wrote an article after that called Theology of the Hospitalized Body, in which I

spoke about that experience and just how grateful I was in that very vulnerable position to be properly seen and cared for. And there are other nurses and nurse assistants who weren't so loving, weren't so attentive or reverential in towards me and my vulnerability. And you can tell the difference. You can smell the difference. I just want to say a little bit more to this questioner that I think like just the way the question comes across there, I have a lot of respect for him

for just looking honestly at what's in his heart and continuing to do his work. And that he prays that he doesn't just dismiss or try to distract himself, that he prays when he encounters this reaction that he probably wishes he didn't have. And he does. And so I think that's, you know, a very powerful and beautiful thing. I think there's a, a way in which in his journey, as you're talking about journey of

integration, there's a way we can also show care for ourselves. And he used that word, a scar on my soul. And, and here he is a, a doctor. So he's familiar with healing, the body's healing and the formation of scars and the kind of toughness of a scar, the way it can be less the way the rest of that, you know, body part is because of the scar. I just, I feel like there's a

need in his own prayer life to maybe try to visualize the scar and just it visualize the Lord placing his healing hands upon that within himself. You know, the Lord is the divine physician and, and that really could be just a powerful way of knowing his own vulnerability and need for grace that he shared with us. You know, he shared with us in

his question, but like share it in a in a beautiful encounter with the Lord and and see if he, you know, if you can allow him to just look at you there in that wounded place and and touch you and tell you of his love for you and and his affirmation of your work and how beautiful it it already is. Wendy that is inspired that's inspired, that's the Holy Spirit. I, I sense it and the the sense

of that I have is as you speaking to this questioner, this doctor, as you allow your vulnerable places to be touched by the divine physician who will gaze on you with utter love in your naked vulnerability. He will give you that is the power to to do likewise, right? Love one another as I have loved

you. You can fulfill that commandment here, but you must let Jesus love you in your naked vulnerable places. And you are in a very naked, vulnerable place in this wound, in this scar, to expose that naked place in your heart, that wounded place in your heart to the divine Physician and to receive His love there. Then Jesus's invitation, love one another as I have loved you,

becomes just a passing on what you have received. You will be able to meet people in their vulnerable naked places with the same love that's you. Put your finger right on it, Wendy. That's our prayer for you, dear brother. That's our prayer. Hey everybody, this is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on tour this year. We're going to places like Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Michigan, and also other countries like United Kingdom, Germany, Ecuador, and Brazil.

We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our events schedule in the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Peace. Our next question is from a listener named Carrie. Hi, Carrie. Christopher and Wendy, I first would like to sincerely thank you for your ministry of teaching about theology of the Body. It has been a beautiful journey over the last five years, uncovering St. John Paul 2's teaching on what it means to be male and female and how to become a gift to another. Thanks be to God.

I'm dating a man who loves TOB too, and from the beginning of our relationship, a childlike friendship formed where we can truly be ourselves together. We both believe God may be calling us to marriage, but how do I know for sure that this is what God wants for me? My past in dating has often been trusting God and then it not working out, and this current

relationship is one that I hope lasts because we're striving for virtue together and it's not one sided like in the past on my part Beautiful. I understand that part of discernment is the freedom to choose wisely, but how do I balance my desires to be a gift and to enter into marriage with the plans God has for me and my boyfriend? I seek to do God's will, yet I'm afraid of the uncertainty about the future and I'm struggling with giving these desires

completely to God. Oh, bless you, Gary, bless you. Welcome to the human dilemma. Do we trust in the goodness of our Father? Do we trust in the goodness of our Father? John Paul the second describes the original sin as casting doubt on the goodness of the Father, casting doubt on the reality that he wants to grant

us the deepest desires of our hearts. And so we, we find ourselves in a defensive posture before God, clinging to our own desires, afraid to surrender them, because somewhere in there that inheritance of original sin is operative. And we, we, we don't really believe that what God wants from me is for my greatest good. And so we, we, we kind of take what we think we want and we

kind of keep it apart for ourselves and we're afraid to let it go. And this is not a theory to me. This is from my own lived experience. So I can very much relate my, my main invitation to you, Carrie, is to just in your own way, however you pray, however you find yourself being honest with God, be as honest with him in your prayer as you're being with us, and just put it out to him. Like write a letter to to God where you are without censoring

anything of what you feel and giving yourself permission to feel what you feel as you feel it. What are your fears about surrendering this relationship to the Lord? What are your fears about surrendering your desire that this relationship would last to the Lord? Is it the fear that that's not what the Lord wants for you? Is it the fear that you won't get what you desire? I mean, all, all that is related to I, I don't, I don't in the end, I don't trust.

I don't, I'm afraid. I want to stay in control. I want to cling to what I want to cling to. And, and that's just the human condition in our fallenness. That's, that's what we all have to wrestle with before the Lord. I'll often put it this way, we, we stand before the Lord with one of two postures or maybe a combination, and it's either open receptivity to God's gift or grasping, right? And this, this is again the nature of original sin.

It's not that God didn't want us to have a knowledge of good and evil, right, eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. It's not that God didn't want to grant us that fruit. He simply didn't want us to grasp at it on our own terms, right? He didn't want us to think we knew better than him what is good and what is evil. Which is another way of saying God wanted us to trust him with our happiness. Because if God is God and we are his creature, and if the force

at the center of the universe and the force that brought the universe into being is love, what is love? It's to will the greatest good for the other. God desires our greatest good. He knows better for us what is good than we know what is for us. And you can, if that's true, you can trust that if this relationship is what is best for you, then that's what God desires for you. And Carrie, I'll give you a little hint as to what I think's going on here.

I think God's will is being revealed through your desire, through your desire. And I'm hearing those words of Jesus. What do you want and how does that line up with what this man, you're in this relationship, What does he want? Do you both want to be husband and wife with each other? Is that what you want? Have you had those conversations? Are you kind of fantasizing about it in your own mind and have never really had that conversation with the man you're

in this relationship with? Well, I would, I would, I would wave a flag of caution there. If this is just something you're kind of fantasizing about and you haven't had that conversation with him. But if he's of the mind and you're of the mind that you want to pursue this relationship and you're pretty darn sure you want to marry this man and he's pretty darn sure you want to marry him. Well, guess what? That's a pretty darn sure sign that God is in this because you're, you're seeking it with sincerity. You're not, as you said, you're both seeking virtue together. Those are all good signs.

We try to read the signs. God speaks to us in sign language. And, and I and I think you're reading the signs correctly. If I'm reading the signs that you've given us in your question correctly and what I'm saying is resonating with you in your reading of the signs, I think you're reading the signs correctly. I think also one of the signs that we can properly read is that the Lord is asking you to trust, to trust and a surrender. If you cling to your life, you'll lose it.

If you surrender, if you surrender, you'll find it. If you let loose your grip, you'll find it. That's the paradox of the gospel. So many paradoxes in the gospel. You want to be rich, sell everything. You want to live, you got to die. You want something badly enough, you got to let it go. As soon as we're clinging, as soon as we're in that posture of, of grasping, maybe grasping is a better word than clinging. As soon as we're in that posture of grasping at something rather than receiving it from God as a

gift, we're, we're in the wrong posture. And you can trust. That's the invitation. You can trust. I think I, I hear in Carrie's question, oh, what a struggle it is just we, we see the suffering in this world and we see people who have married and then

separated or divorced or regretted their decision. And, and oh, how that can cause us to pause and think, I don't, I know I don't want that to happen. I know it. We don't, we don't. And there's a place in scripture in the Old Testament that says God hates divorce. And I, when I hear that, I hear

it not as a judgement against those who are divorced, but as an affirmation of, of all of our hearts. We want that which is lasting and can be a solid, reliable reality of, of a true bond being formed that will last. And you know, when Carrie said sort of afraid of the uncertainty about the future, she didn't say exactly what that was, but I just, I felt like, well, it could be something like

that uncertainty about what would this, how can I know that that's not going to be my story or that. And I feel like the the evil 1 can kind of jump on to our own natural anxiety. And I don't want to make it sound like the whole thing is like from the devil or something, but we naturally, understandably, looking at the world, can't help but have some concern. You know, as we're talking about making this commitment, this is

an important decision like. Your whole story takes a new direction with that Sacramento union. Like my whole, like who I am, is formed by our being married to one another. Like because of all the growing and into myself over the years it has. That's the context. That's the context of it all. So, yeah, it is a big decision and I, I feel like there isn't,

there isn't one way to say, I know for sure this is God's will. There are many ways and some of them are what you were talking about, Christopher, about looking at the the signs in their relationship and in each of their own hearts. And yet there are some other things too, you can look at if you know your own life circumstances, your readiness for responsibility, the the thoughts of people who've known you for a long time and care about you, what do they see in the relationship?

And also the TOB Institute has a course called Next Step that is intended for couples who are not engaged to participate in together to kind of discern about their relationship. So there are, yeah, different things that can help to make a give clarity about your choice. And I you acknowledged in there that, you know, there's a freedom that the Lord has given

us that that we get to choose. And that is so true. And I, as much as we would wish that God would just like stand knock at our door and say, Yep, Carrie, that's the one, go for it. He probably isn't going to show up quite in that way. And he, he loves you. I'm so happy he's given you the gift of this relationship and happy about the joy it has brought to you both and the just

hope that it has given you both for the future and the, the sense of partnership. That's what I feel in which he's saying like here is a partner and that's such a gift. So I, I do encourage you to acknowledge that in this broken world, there are anxieties that we have to invite the Lord into. We have to acknowledge before him. This is a concern. And just as Christopher was talking about an honest letter, like here are my anxieties and

and to then listen like not just to dwell in your anxiety, but to kind of like see yourself giving them over to the Lord that he would take them from you and speak to your heart about them. Nothing is going to make your life not have suffering in it. All of our lives have suffering. I suffered once. Yeah, I know. But I think there can be a sense of peace and trust that can be foundational for moving forward.

Yes, that's what we desire. And in the midst of the suffering, in the midst of the questions, we can have confidence in the Lord's plan for our lives and and look at the word confidence. Confide means with faith, with faith we can trust and guess what it's it's not like there's thus saith the Lord, this is my will for your life. And if you screw it up, you're going to hell. We choose when we're choosing A vocation, we're choosing between goods this good or that good. And I remember, I'll just share

the story quickly that I met a man years ago, he brought me in to speak and he was, he was 20 years married, had several beautiful kids. And he was showing me all the pictures of his kids on the wall. And he said, you know, Christopher, 20, whatever. Years ago, I really felt like the Lord was calling me to the priesthood. And then I was called to live celibacy for the Kingdom. And I said, Lord, thank you for that confidence in me. Thank you for that calling. But I, I want to be a husband and a father and I'm going to choose marriage. That's a choice between goods.

That's not a matter of sin. That's a choice between goods. And what I like about that story is just his, his confidence. He, he went into marriage with faith. And guess what? The Lord honored that. That's the crazy relationship the creature has with the creator that God respects our freedom and, and, and he, God has honored his choice to be married. That's how gracious our God is. That's how big his heart is.

You're, we're always asking God, what do you want? What do you want? What do you want? What do you want? And sometimes God's answer is just, well, what do you want? What do you want when it's a choice between goods. Well, I'm not talking about God wouldn't say, what do you want with sin? Go ahead and sin. No, no, no, but a choice between goods. God will often just say, what do you want? And we take the next step. We take the next step. Speaking of which, I'm glad you brought up the Next step program.

So Carrie, that could be a great next step for you and this man you love. Check out the link in the show notes to learn more about that. And you are in our prayers. Bless you, bless you, bless you. Our next question is from a listener named Lorene. Lorraine or Lorene. Lorene. Lorene. Hi, Lorene. Hi Christopher and Wendy, I've been a faithful listener of your podcast for a few years and it has had a big impact on my understanding of our beautiful faith and the Magisterium I'm. So glad Loreen, that's beautiful

to hear. I understand that Mariology is deeply tied to theology of the body, but could you speak to the role that Saint Joseph plays in it as well? I feel that I've not come across many readings on how his role is interwoven with TOB, but I imagine he is a significant one even if it's not discussed in depth. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. I love your intuition, Lorraine. You're putting your finger on something very, very significant.

And I would point you, if you're not already familiar with a document written by John Paul 2 called Redemptoris Kustos, Guardian of the Redeemer, I'd highly recommend that. And Pope Francis also wrote a letter on Saint Joseph that is very much worth reading. So look at either of those resources to go a little bit deeper. And we do we have a resource that one of our staff members at the Theology of the Body Institute Co wrote called

Consecration to Saint Joseph or Consecration to Jesus through Saint Joseph. I, I don't have the exact title in my brain, but any we'll have a link to that in the show notes as well, where she and Doctor Greg Butaro, he's a a graduate of ours. They, they together wrote this book about the role of Saint Joseph and they bring in the themes of the theology of the body to to show how it's all interwoven. The most extensive treatment I

give to Saint Joseph is in the Mariology course, what we call Theology of the Body and the Marian Mystery. If you haven't taken that course, I'd highly recommend you do check out our our link to our courses in the show notes. In there I talk about Saint Joseph Mary's Most Chaste spouse. So this is one of the titles that the Church gives to Saint Joseph Mary's Most Chaste

Spouse. Well, guess what? If we don't have an integral understanding of chastity, we're going to get Joseph all wrong under that title. If we have an understanding of chastity as repression of sexuality, if we have an understanding of chastity as one big NO to all things sexual, we will never ever understand what the Church means when she proclaims St. Joseph Mary's most chaste spouse.

What is chastity? Chastity is the integration. I'm quoting from the Catechism of the Catholic Church here, the integration of all that is physical and all that is spiritual in us. It is the integration of sexuality into the dignity of the person. It's what I was saying earlier to that physician who asked his very important question. It's it's the long term sustained integration of all of our reactions to the body and

sexuality where they get raised to the level of the dignity of the person, right. Chastity is not is not a negation of sexuality. It is the sublimation of sexuality so that it becomes sublime, so that it is raised up to something heavenly. So that that our experience of sexuality, our attractions, our emotions, the stirrings of body and soul that are related to our sexuality become the power and

desire to love as God loves. And Saint Joseph, as Mary's most chaste spouse, experienced his sexual desires in the highest degree, as the desire to love Mary rightly. He was the most chaste. That means to the superlative degree he experienced his sexual being as as the desire to love

Mary rightly. And this led to not some You sleep in that room. I'll sleep in that room because how could I handle sleeping in the same room or the same bed with the most beautiful creature God ever created? Because I don't know what to do with my sexual desires when I'm around the most beautiful woman in the world. I can't control myself. So you have to sleep over there, and I have to sleep over there. Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong. Let me quote here from Bishop Fulton Sheen, who I think puts his finger on the question of Joseph here in the most potent

and powerful way. OK, this is under the heading in my study guide for the Marian Mystery Course. This is under the heading Saint Joseph, her most chaste spouse. Listen to this from Bishop Fulton Sheen. When one searches for the reasons why Christian art should have pictured Joseph as an old man, we discover that it was in order to better safeguard the virginity of Mary. Somehow the assumption had crept in that senility was a better

protector of virginity than adolescence. Art thus unconsciously made Joseph a spouse, chaste and pure by age rather than by virtue. To make Joseph appear pure only because his flesh had aged is like it's like glorifying a mountain stream that has dried up the Church. The Church will not ordain a man to the priesthood who has not his vital powers. She wants men who have something

to tame rather than those who are tame because they have no energy to be wild. It should be no different with God. Instead of being a man incapable of love, he must have been on fire with love. Instead then of being dried fruit to be served on the table of the King, he was rather a blossom filled with promise and power. He was not in the evening of life, but in its morning, bubbling over with energy, strength, and controlled passion.

That's the key. I'll come back to that in a SEC. Here's how he concludes. Mary and Joseph brought to their espousals 2 hearts with greater torrents of love than had ever before coursed through human breasts. Love it, love it, love it, love it, love it, love it, love it, love it, love it. Controlled passion. What does that mean? It doesn't mean passion that's dominated and crushed. And what does it mean to to tame something that could be wild? It doesn't mean you rob the

vital energies from it. It's not like breaking a horse, it's rather channelling the energies of that wildness towards the wildness of love, what I call vertical wildness, right? If we take our passions, those wild passions, if we go horizontal with them, you end up at a frat party. But if you go vertical with those passions, you end up with the marriage of Joseph and Mary, whose passions were aimed towards heaven.

And so they were on fire with the passion of divine love. Theirs was an Eros that expressed beautifully divine agape. That's a picture of Joseph that we get from theology, the body. And John Paul the Second himself confirms this in a catechesis he gave on the Blessed Mother collected in a book called the Theotokos. He says this very similar to to Fulton Sheen. He says the difficulty of accepting the sublime mystery of

their spousal communion, meaning Joseph and Mary, has LED some since the 2nd century to think of Joseph as advanced in age and to consider him, Mary as Mary's guardian more than her husband John Paul. The Second goes on. It is instead a case of supposing that he was not an elderly man at the time, but rather that his interior perfection, the fruit of grace, led him to live his spousal relationship with Mary with virginal affection.

And virginal affection here does not mean I'm never going to touch you. I'm never going to hold your hand. I'm never going to embrace you. I'm never going to kiss you. It, it means he showed her affection that was was virginal in no way selfish, in no way tainted by our fallen humanity, right. That's that's the virginity of Joseph and Mary. Not something cold and stoic, something pure and on fire with divine love. Just as you've been talking,

I've just had this image of both of their eyes and like them, them locking eyes, you know, as you talk about the vital energy and the, the, just the holiness and the, the divine love that is in their hearts. And just, just this beautiful image of their, their eyes on one another, their knowing of God's beautiful plan and the joy and honor of being at such an

incredible place in God's plan and, and of helping one another with their unique gifts to live this like, like any married couple, they each have unique gifts and they, they relied on one another's gifts. And but just that knowing and that vitality of their gaze was just striking me. I know you yes, you talk most in the merry course, but also I know in in T OB one when you're teaching on celibacy for the

Kingdom, you spend time with Saint Joseph as well. So yeah, it's it is a good instinct that she had to ask that question. Yeah. And I, I was recently invited, there's a new symposium of of scholars on Joseph and and I was invited to speak at their conference recently. It was an online event. It's called the Saint Joseph Society, I believe, if I'm getting that name correct. And we'll, we'll put a link to that symposium in the show notes if you want to listen to my talk

and the talks of many others who gave beautiful presentations on Saint Joseph. And I'll just say this very quickly. I know we're, we're wrapping up, but I know the question lingering out there in a lot of minds is, well, why then didn't they have intercourse and, and again, the celibate marriage of Joseph and Mary, it's not a negation of sexuality. It's a living out of the ultimate fulfillment of sexuality. Well, what does that mean? What is the ultimate fulfillment of sexuality? It's not to be found in, in the marital embrace of a man and woman here on planet Earth.

That's just a little little little little glimmer of the ultimate fulfillment of sexuality, which is found only in the marriage of the Lamb, the marriage of eternity, the marriage of Christ and the Church. Mary is has already consummated that reality with the living God. If she would have had intercourse with Joseph, it would have been a step backwards. Instead of stepping back to the book of Genesis with Joseph, Mary grabs Joseph's hand and jumps forward to the Book of Revelation and says, Joseph,

come with me baby, into the ultimate reality. That's what they lived. That's why their virginal marriage, their celibate marriage was the Super abundant fulfillment of sexuality. They lived the earthly marriage and the heavenly marriage at the same time. So we could say their marriage was a marriage of heaven and earth. And guess what? The fruit of their marriage was the marriage of heaven and earth, the person of Jesus Christ, the God man born not just of the Virgin Mary. Joseph was not a tack on here.

I think this theological development is on the horizon. Saints have hinted at it. John Paul the second hints at it. Joseph was not a tack on his virginity. His virginal gift of self played some role. It's mysterious. I don't know what it was, but mysteriously, Joseph's virginal gift of self, I believe also played a role in the incarnation. Jesus was the issue of their virginal marriage. I'm going to say it boldly because I believe it to be true. And I think theologians will be

unpacking that for a long time and developing it and giving the church a fuller understanding of it. But here's the bottom line. Joseph and Mary lived the gift to each other. They became a gift, virginal gift to one another. And that virginal gift brought us Jesus Christ. And so we can turn to them in intercession, and we can say, Joseph and Mary, please pray for us that we would have the grace. To become the gift we are. Amen. Hallelujah.

Hallelujah. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode