Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

When my students look like the walking dead, I’m no longer interested in the marital act, and Am I Loved as a Priest or as a Man?” | ACW364

Dec 22, 202547 minAudio

-This episode is sponsored by Truthly- Questions answered this episode: I am a theology teacher of high school students at a Catholic school. How do I joyfully proclaim Theology of the Body - or any Church teaching - when my students look like the walking dead? A coworker calls them spiritually dead. They don’t seem to care and they fall asleep in class. Satan has used all of that to make me question whether I’m in the right career. I think, if I was truly called, my students’ faith would come alive. How can I share this beautiful message with anyone who seems spiritually dead? At age 60, I’m no longer interested in the marital act, and it is most painful and unpleasant - therefore, not happening. I am TOB savvy and preach it to everyone, but I’m not living it. I know the marital act rocks my husband’s world, but I cannot tolerate it. I’ve had medical procedures contributing to the unpleasantness. I probably should seek medical attention, but would rather not. I am a priest and a religious. Throughout my formation, the emphasis was mostly on the challenging, sacrificial dimension of celibacy, but TOB has brought joy into living it. Celibacy feels like a continual discovery of God’s closeness and of living with the people entrusted to me. But I don’t know whether this fulfillment brings joy to the parts of me that desire a deeper, more personal gaze - and whether that gaze is reserved only for God. I’m not sure if I’m loved for my vocation or if I, Andrea, am worthy of love as a person. Can you help me understand this? Resources: JPII Legacy Foundation Website Donate to the JPII Legacy Foundation Colorado Ski Retreat with Christopher Writings of JPII Course Link TOB at the Movies eBook Litanies of the Heart by Dr. Gerry Crete Fr. John Cihak’s Article --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

We have a new relationship with Truthfully. Truthfully is a Catholic AI platform where you can harness all of the incredible technological power of artificial intelligence for the good of the faith. It draws from the writings of the Saints, Scripture, the Catholic Magisterium over 2000 years, the Fathers of the Church, what the Saints have said throughout the centuries, and you can put any question you have top type it right into

truthly. I'll give you an example. This is a a common objection. I'm just typing it into truthly. Why do Catholics worship Mary? OK, here's Truthly's response. Catholics worship Mary because she's the 4th person of the quadrantity. No, it does not say that. Oh my goodness. No, it does not say that Catholics do not worship Mary. Here's what truthfully actually says Catholics do not worship Mary, rather they venerate her.

Worship is due to God alone, while veneration or honor is given to Mary and the Saints. This distinction is rooted in the different types of honor expressed in the Latin terms latria worship or adoration, which is given to God alone, while dulia veneration is given to the Saints and a special veneration called hyperdulia is reserved for Mary due to her unique role in salvation history. There's much more that I won't get into in terms of what truthfully says, but I'm just scrolling here and it's quite

impressive how in one second when I type that question in, what came up. So we're inviting all of our listeners to give it a try. You can get a 7 day free trial. You can get it wherever you get your apps, Google Play if you're an Android person, or the Apple App Store if you're an iPhone guy or gal. So check it out. I think they're doing really good work. And we just want to let our listeners know about it. Since you guys listen to this and you're interested in answers to questions about the Catholic faith.

And we're grateful to Truthfully for sponsoring this episode. Thank you Truthfully. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. We are just a few days away from the grand celebration of the Incarnation. Thank you God for taking flesh.

Merry Christmas, everybody. A few days early on the release of this podcast, Monday the 22nd and today, tell everybody what we're doing, Wendy. Yeah, we are having a Christmas party with the staff of the Theology the Bodies Institute today. I am so privileged. The people I get to work with, these are dedicated souls. They have caught the TOB fire and given their lives to this mission. Everybody.

This is often the case in ministry. Everybody is overworked and underpaid. And we have such burning hearts to bring this message to the ends of the earth. And we we have to be continually accepting of our limitations. But it is a great joy today to gather with all the staff and celebrate God's good graces and the joy of of doing this work together. Thank you everybody out there who supports our mission. We're so grateful to you for just believing in what we're

doing and, and being a monthly supporter. If you are not a monthly supporter, would you please prayerfully consider that we cannot do this work without you guys. Help me to pay my staff a better wage and help us to hire some new people so that we can reach more people. Yeah, there's a lot to celebrate all of us at the end of the year. And obviously for us, a day of, you know, a party is just one of like, let's not always be working so hard because

sometimes we need to relax and laugh and sing a song and just enjoy a meal together and. Celebrate together what the whole point of what we're doing is, which is to proclaim to the ends of the earth the incarnation. Yeah, God took flesh. It never ceases to be astounding if we really enter into that. Please, Lord, expand our horizons this Christmas to accept at a deeper level what it

means that you took flesh, you were born of a woman. You took flesh, you were born of a woman. Christianity begins right there, right there. Thank you, Lord do. You have any updates on the theology of the Body Institute besides the fact that they're having a Christmas party? Well, I mentioned this last time, but I'm going to keep plugging it because it's one of the favorite things I do each year. This is only the second time I've done it, but it's going to become an annual thing. The ski trip.

We are following in JP 2's footsteps. He used to take people skiing and then reflect at the end of the day on the theology of the body. And that's what we are doing. A Colorado Ski Retreat Co sponsored by Jason Everett's group, JP 2 Trails. Also Wyoming Catholic Colleges core expeditions group. They are part of this. And of course yours truly from the TOB Institute. I will be leading it. We'll be skiing a couple days at Arapahoe Basin in Colorado and

then one day at Copper Mountain in Colorado, my old stomping grounds when we used to live out in that area, and I know there are people out there listening right now. He's like, oh, oh, that sounds really good. You know why it sounds really good? 'Cause it is. 'Cause it is. It's going to be really, really fun. Last year we had a. Jason is come. Jason ever? No, he's not even. Oh, Jason is not coming. He did come last year, that's what you're remembering, but his schedule didn't allow him to come this year. So I'm going to be leading all the teachings and it was life changing for lots of people last

year and we had great fellowship. We're going to be staying in a a huge house that sleeps like 30 people, so we'll all be under one roof. We'll be sharing meals together for I think it's four nights, five days, three days of skiing. It's March 9th to the 13th, so mark your calendar and check the link in the show notes to register. We only have 30 spots and they're going to go pretty quickly so. Yeah. If you're interested, come along. It's time to sign up. 01 more

thing. I'll say the writings on JP 2 course the first week, first full week of January, January 4th to the 9th. There are still some spots left for that. If anybody wants to come to Pennsylvania, Bill Dunnehy is teaching that course. This is where we dive into the additional writings of John Paul the second where he applied the theology of the body like the letter to families, his letter on the dignity and vocation of women, his meditation on givenness, all kinds of gems

that are life changing. So if that's of interest, check out the link in the show notes as well. Great. Are you ready for a question from one of our awesome patrons? This is from a patron named Michael. Hi, Michael. Hi, Christopher and Wendy, thank you so much for this podcast. You're welcome. Sorry I've learned so much and am so grateful to God to have discovered Jump Holt, the second theology of the body through your ministry. I've already attended TOB one in person and consider Christopher

to be such a gifted teacher. I've heard him talk before about how he loves seeing the faith come alive in his students. I do. I do. I do. I am a theology teacher of high school students at a Catholic school. My question is this, how do I joyfully proclaim the theology of the body or any of the church's teachings? When I look out and see students who look like they are part of The Walking Dead, A Co worker calls them spiritually dead.

They don't seem to care. They fall asleep in class. Satan has really used all of that to make me question whether or not I'm in the right career. I think to myself, if I was truly called to do this, all of my students would become those who truly see and have the faith come alive. How can I share this beautiful message of TOB with anyone who seems spiritually dead and doesn't care? Michael, my brother, my heart goes out to you.

I have been in that place. I have taught high schoolers. It is not easy. Truly, it you have one of the hardest jobs in the world, do not think that you are in the wrong place because your students aren't jumping up and down for joy and coming alive. They are a a hard, hard bunch. But here's just a a a a word of encouragement, a word of advice.

We must find a way, however we do it. We must find a way to appeal to the deepest yearnings of their heart. Meet them where they are. Talk to them about the music they listen to. Talk to them about the movies they watch. Talk to them about the viral videos that they're watching. Talk to them about the art that speaks to them.

Even if that art is really, really messed up, it can become a point of connection where you use it as a teaching tool, remembering and you've taken my, my classes. You, you know this principle. The devil doesn't have his own clay. So suppose you, you one day in class, you say today we're going to, or maybe you give them fair warning like you say next Monday. I want everybody to be ready and willing to share a movie that

you've watched lately that you liked, a song that you heard lately that you liked, a concert that you went to that that you enjoyed, and let them speak as to what it is and why they enjoyed it. And even if it's messed up, remember, the devil doesn't have his own clay. Something beautiful, something good, something that God made to lead us to him got twisted up in that song or in that movie or in that video or whatever. Obviously you, you got to be delicate here because you don't want them bringing something to

class that's going to cause scandal or or be profane or or what have you. But with good judgement, you could open the floor, let people share some art, and then help them untwist it. If it's twisted. Talk to them about why art is so important to our hearts. What does it stir? What does it awaken? Somehow, brother, somehow you can't just teach content. You can't just throw ideas at them.

You have to engage them. You have to meet them where they are. You have to come to their level, not to stay there, but to meet them there and raise them up. That's the direction of the Incarnation, right? Christ comes down to our level, not to keep us here, but to raise us up to his level. And he even descends the whole way into hell to bring us the whole way to heaven. There aren't a lot of teachers out there who are ready and

willing to descend into the Hells that their students are experiencing in their real lives. If you show yourself willing to descend as low as you must go. And when I say that, I don't mean obviously in your morals or beliefs or any such thing, but in your accompaniment of them, in your willingness to meet them where they really are. And a lot of them, I bet you are in a very deep, thick, painful hellhole. If they discover that you are

willing to meet them right there, show them compassion right there. Show them understanding right there. Maybe they'll follow you. Not all of them will. Not all of them will, but some will in the effort you make to do that. Even if just a couple choose to follow where you're leading them, it will be well worth all that you have suffered for those few. Yeah, that's a a lot of hard

earned wisdom that you're sharing there. And I I think it's it's helpful, you know, that you just started out with this is a hard group. You know, you have shared how much you love seeing the faith come alive for your students. We're talking often about people who are taking time out of their lives specifically because they want to learn. It's not the same as teaching reluctant students, right? It's. A huge difference. Yeah, and, you know, I'm remembering we used to teach

marriage prep together. Well, marriage prep couples are maybe not quite as difficult as high school students, but they're close. They're close. And they aren't eager to learn. They are. They're jumping through hoops to get married in the church. And really I would just share this with Michael. You need to be praying for spiritual protection because you're that spiritually dead reality that you're coming up

against. It doesn't want to be disturbed out of its sleep, out of its deep sleep and it there is a an attack that will come against you and probably is coming against you as you mentioned in your question. You know, you said Satan has used their reluctance to learn to cause you a lot of self doubt. So you're already seeing that really to have an intentional way of seeking spiritual protection.

That means like you go to confession more often. You start your day in earnest prayer, you bless your room with holy water every day like it's not just O start of the year. Let's bless the classroom like it's, it's a daily reality that you're asking for that protection for them and for you. So that, you know, it can seem like a silly ritual, but it's acknowledging and making our hearts present to the fact that

there is a battle. There's a battle for their hearts and for yours. And we need to open up every channel to grace that we can possibly open. So I encourage you to deepen your prayer and to not expect that you can be the judge of what is reaching your students. It will be a joy if one student expresses that they've had their hearts open, you know, 1 And so if you can realize that things

that you are doing may be reaching them in ways that because of their social dynamics in the class, they don't feel free to express, but it's happening. And that is a walk of faith and trust. And as you do that and you allow the Lord to really encourage you, there's, there's something that I think they will detect a certain new spring in your step, even if you know they're not springing into class, that will be also a beautiful witness to

them and a sign of hope. Like, do they even want to become adults? You know, they don't know. But if you're there as an adult who likes being an adult, you know, and likes living your faith, that's a sign of hope for them. They it will stick in their minds and hearts somewhere, and that's a good thing. I want to say one more thing, Michael, because it goes both ways and sharing art, not only inviting them to share art with you, but I want to invite you to share art with them.

Share with them the movies and the music that blesses you. You know how we do this at the institute. You might even hey, just perhaps show them the Truman Show. Remember, we we watched the Truman Show in TLB one we watched the kid in TOB 2. I used to show the movie I am legend with Will Smith in TOB 2. There's every TOB course we we show a secular movie to to demonstrate how good art can

awaken the heart and take us on this help us on our pilgrimage towards the true, the good and the beautiful. And gosh, I remember when I was in high school, if there was movie day, if all, if what we were doing in class was we were watching a movie, I'm like, OK, yeah, good. Show them movies. Teach, use movies to teach them the faith. And if you need help with that, you can download my free ebook TOB at the movies, where I review several movies and and enter into the lessons with the

TOB lens. Start there. Start there and teach through art. It's a way of awakening the human heart. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. At age 60, I'm no longer interested in the marital act, and in fact it is most painful and unpleasant, therefore not happening. I am TOB savvy and preach it to

everyone, but I'm not living it. I know the marital act rocks my husband's world, but I cannot tolerate it. I've had medical procedures contributing to the unpleasantness. I probably should seek medical attention but would rather not. Oh, bless you, my dear sister, bless you. This is really hard. It's hard on a marriage. It's hard on the individuals in

the marriage. I was struck by what she said, though, that I should probably seek medical attention. But I would rather not that. That is just a question to me. And I'll hold this out to you with with tenderness and gentleness and invitation. A tender invitation, a gentle invitation to take that resistance that I'd rather not seek medical attention. Just open that to your true

bridegroom, Jesus. Jesus is your true bridegroom. He knows every corner of your heart. He knows every secret place in your heart. He knows every pain in your heart. The gentle encouragement, the the gentle invitation is just to go to Jesus and say Jesus, Why? Why would I rather not when I

pledged myself to my husband when we married however many years ago? It was a long time ago in your case. Part of what you were offering to your husband was the opportunity of the two of you becoming 1 flesh. And there are of course reasons in a marriage where health reasons, any number of psychological reasons, deep emotional reasons that times of

abstinence or even in a serious enough situation, it could be for the rest of married life. The the marital act is not a possibility. But if it is a possibility and there are medical remedies that could help it to be a possibility and there's resistance to it being a possibility. Again, I would guess that there's some block, there's some pain, there's some sadness, there's some sorrow, there's some wound in your history here

that Jesus tenderly wants to bring to your attention, to bring about healing. That's my general sense of it. And knowing how tender Jesus is, I can invite you to that opening of your heart to Jesus, knowing He's not going to shame you. He's not going to scold you, He's not going to pour salt on any wound. He wants you to open that to

Him, to pour oil on that wound, to bring healing, and to bring renewal to your marriage. Give it a try. Give it a try. Yeah, such a gentle invitation to look at that with the Lord and not just be stuck in her own head about maybe I can just imagine sort of some anger or

just a certain I'm putting my foot down. I'm just feeling this way and I don't want to think about it anymore or something like I I appreciate your gentleness in in calling her to go deeper in that question. Can I just add this because I, I think maybe I'm taking something for granted when I say, when I hold out that invitation to open that to Jesus, What does that look like to open something to Jesus? Could you imagine writing a

letter to Jesus where you share what you really feel about it? I, I keep a journal. Wendy keeps a journal. This has been something very important for our interior lives with where we process stuff that goes on. And this is, this is a prime example of, of something. If I were experiencing it in my life, I would be taking that to, to my journal. I'd just be writing out what I really feel about some something difficult in my life. And then, and I've learned this through good spiritual direction

over the years, I've learned how to listen just to quiet myself. I say what I need to say to Jesus and then I quiet myself and I I try to tune in and I try to listen. Sometimes a memory comes to me, something from my childhood I need to look at. Sometimes a song will come to me and I'll pay attention to the lyrics and the lyrics speak deeply to me. Sometimes a scene from a movie will come to me. A scene from ATV show, a scene from a book I've read, a scene from something in nature

creation that that left an impression. The Lord is going to speak to you in the language of your heart. Sometimes I'll smell something like spiritually, it's like a spiritual sense of smell like, whoa, that smell reminds me of XY and Z and I'll follow that smell to a certain memory or but we, we are, we need to train our spiritual ears, train our spiritual sense of smell, train our spiritual sense of sight, train our spiritual sense of

feeling. We have spiritual senses that correspond to our physical senses. And as we train them, we really do. Heaven wants to communicate to us and we learn how heaven communicates to us and, and heaven knows us. The Lord knows us. He will speak to us in a way we can hear. I love that that just, you know, spelling out more what, what, what can be a very fruitful way of bringing things to prayer. I also just wanted to add like

a, a call to deeper marital communication because I think maybe my one of the things that struck me was that just not happening. And and, you know, I'm hearing that in my own head. I don't know, you know, quite how that's meant in her heart that she's saying not happening. But as married couples, and I'm not trying to make this sound

easy, but it is important to be communicating about things like this. And I certainly would think that your husband knows about the pain that is behind the not happening. But has there been communication about the effects on your hearts of that not happening or even a joint grieving of this time right now where it's not

happening? I just I just want to invite that, you know, some communication with your husband. One of the things that struck me was that in our marital embrace, we have an opportunity to communicate with one another in bodily, in profoundly meaningful way. And it's not necessarily what we're communicating maybe can't

be fully put into words. But if you're feeling an inability to enter into that embrace, I'm sure your husband would appreciate knowing that there are sentiments, they're still there in your heart that you would want to communicate to him. And maybe some of it needs to be put into words. Some of your appreciation of him and your affirmation of him and your commitment to him and your

trust of him. Some of those are the things that we communicate when we come together as husband and wife. And and he may still very much need to hear those things from you. So yeah, I. Can't imagine that he wouldn't still need to hear those things from you. Yeah. And and I hope also sorry, it might that's OK. I hope also that he he's understanding towards you and your physical pain that's being caused. And please, I hope you're understanding.

I'm not saying you should just continue to endure this physical pain without seeking some medical attention. And there there are remedies out there that I can't. I'm not a medical professional, but I know from my own pastoral experience with couples as they age, things can become difficult. But there are medical helps that can, maybe it's hormone therapy or something that can make it, if not remove the pain all together, make it much, much less painful. And if that's possible, I would

invite you again to to consider that. Our next question is from a listener named Andre. Hi, Andre. Thank you for the joy of the theology of the body and for the light it brings to my vocation. I am a priest and a religious, and throughout my formation the emphasis was mostly on the challenging sacrificial dimension of celibacy. But the theology of the body has brought joy into living it. Glory, glory, glory.

I notice in my life that celibacy is a continual discovery of God's closeness to me and of living with the people entrusted to me. But sometimes I don't know whether this fulfilment also brings joy to those parts of me that desire a deeper, more personal gaze, and whether that gaze is reserved only for God. I'm not sure whether certain friendships and relationships exist only because of my

vocation, or whether I, Andrea, am truly worthy of love as a person. And I don't always know whether God and people see the priest in me or the person in me, and which of these they see as worthy of love. I don't know how to bring the celibate man and the personal man within me into harmony, into that harmony of love which is an image of the Kingdom of God. Can you help me understand this?

Father Andre, bless you, Bless you. This is a beautiful question and it it shows a a searching heart, a heart that is in touch with the basic core need of our humanity, which is to be loved for who I am, Not what I am or what Ioffer, but just for the sake of my unique, unrepeatable

humanity. You are beautifully in touch with that desire of your heart, Father Andre, and your ability even to articulate this question and to recognize the question are are people loving me because I'm their priest? Are they thinking I'm lovable because I gave my life to the priesthood? Do they really see me? Do they only see me in my priestly roll?

Do they see the truth of my weakness, my need, my vulnerability, my poverty? And if they did, would they love me there? Father Andre, these questions are oh so human. And I'll speak from my own experience here as a public figure in the church and as someone who has a ministry role in the church.

I have, I have all these questions too. I, I sometimes wonder when I'm, you know, standing waiting for lots of people in line who, who want to meet me and have me sign their book and get my picture with them. And they, they pour out their hearts to me about how my work has blessed them, which I'm so grateful to receive. I make this part of my ministry. When I do a public presentation,

I make it a point to go to the book table and greet people and look them in the eye and shake their hands And if they want a photo, take a photo. And if they want a signature, sign their book. I, I actually consider this part of my ministry, but I know the difference between someone who is excited to meet me because there's like this, I don't know a certain perception of a public figure.

And I know the people who want to meet me because they know I'm just another Pilgrim and they want to say thank you. Not because I'm some sort of Catholic celebrity, but because I'm just a, a fellow Catholic and I'm a fellow human being. And, and my life has touched their life and they want to touch my life back in a way that I feel seen as a person. There's a big difference. There's a big difference there. And I'm so grateful for those who who see me.

So I'm just saying I'm sharing that to tell, to tell you, Father Andre, that I I relate to this question. It's for anybody in a public role. That's a question. And isn't it interesting how we can look at the attention that someone in a public role gets like the pastor of a parish or or a movie star or whatever, you know, fill in the blank. Somebody who gets a lot of public attention in, in any context we can think, oh,

wouldn't I like to have that public attention? But there we are confusing being well known with being no. Let me flip it around. What we really want is to be known well. But in that fame idea, the oh, wouldn't I like that attention we're exchanging being known well for being well known. And I'm sure you are well known

as a priest among those you serve, but being well known, being appreciated in that sense is not the same thing as being known well. And in reality, Father Andre, this is just a reality of our human limitations. There are only going to be a very small number of people in our lives who know us well. And if you can think of maybe 3 or 4 concentric circles, you're going to have people on that

outermost circle who I can say these are friends of mine. And they, they know me sufficiently well that I can say these are friends, even dear friends. And then you have another concentric circle that goes in from there. And that's going to be, I don't know, maybe on the outer circle it's 10 to 20 people. Maybe on the inner circle there it's 5, three to five people who who I can say know me at a more intimate level.

And then another concentric circle, you're going to have one or maybe 2. And it would be a spouse, It would be a spiritual director who who know us at the most intimate level possible here on planet earth. And then the inmost circle of those concentric circles is you and God, you and God. And only, only God can know us perfectly, know us completely, know us fully, and love us

perfectly, love us completely, love us fully. The more we live in that inmost circle, which is our life of prayer, our life of intimacy with God, where we are opening that need, which you are very beautifully in touch with that need. It's not an option. It's not a footnote. It is absolutely critical. We need to be known perfectly. We need to be seen fully. We need to be loved unconditionally.

Only God can provide that to us. The more we spend time in our prayer life receiving that kind of love, experiencing that kind of love, the more those circles that go concentricly outward, those other human relationships will truly flourish and become more and more a a a reflection, limited as they are, but nonetheless A genuine reflection of how God loves where we will.

Having received divine love, will learn how to share it. And when you have other people who are also spending their time in that concentric, most innermost circle of the concentric circles, you can establish genuine human communion that remains limited but is genuine and truly is an image of God. That's how we get those questions answered. I don't know any other way. And my spiritual director is continually pointing out to me

ways that I am seeking in those outer circles a love, an attention, an affirmation that I can only receive in that inmost circle with the Lord. And he'll just make this motion like a, a horizontal motion and then I'll make a vertical motion. And I know exactly what he means. Are you looking horizontally for the deepest affirmation of your person or are you looking vertically? Only as I'm looking vertically? Am I in right relationship with others?

Because when I'm not looking vertically and I'm looking horizontally, I'm going to be demanding of people in my life that they give me something that only the Lord can give. And that is not a recipe for healthy relating. And we need continually to be purified here because the default position of our fallen humanity is that we take the desire that can only be fulfilled vertically, and we go horizontally with it. And much of our lives will be

learning how to reorient that yearning towards the living God. Yeah, I similarly thought this was just a a really beautiful, insightful and articulate question. And I'm getting at some really just profound personal realities, living a vocation that, yeah, is demanding and yet

fulfilling and creates unique relationships and seeking to understand those relationships. Wow. Can I certainly relate to all of that. And it's it's very beautiful. I just wanted to share a book that I have found very helpful in looking at these different sort of aspects of the interior life in in the ways that Father Andre is describing it. He kind of just like, well,

there's this priest and there's this person he's kind of seeing, looking at himself and and seeing these these two realities of himself. And anyway, I read this book called Litanies of the heart. Christopher read it as well and it. I felt like some of the things in this question is especially when he says he's longing for those parts of himself, that the celibate man and the personal

man to come into harmony, the harmony of love, which is an image of the Kingdom of God. And I thought of how in that book Litanies of the heart, it really gets somewhat into that the inner harmony of the of the person as that image of the Kingdom of God within us. The Kingdom of God is within us and also just speaks to the reality of the, the good intentions of the different parts of us that can sometimes

get maybe overly needy or seek to meet a a need in a way that's not healthy or good for us, but but that it's still a good desire. And that was definitely all coming through and what you were saying, Christopher, But it was just just a thought that that book could also be a blessing for Father Andre. Yeah, I think it would be. And, and that reminds me also of something I wanted to say but forgot to say, that I understand how you could consider kind of

your public persona as a priest as something other than your inmost self. But through the sacrament of ordination, you have become a priest in your deepest reality as a self, right? There's an ontological alteration in, in a man's being when he's ordained through the

sacrament of holy orders. There's a, a, a, A at that level of your being, there's an alteration. And I would encourage you to pray into that, Father Andre, that yes, understood that the public persona as priest is one thing, but your identity as priest is is not some clothing that you wear on the outside. Your identity in this deeper sense as priest has to do with your inmost self.

And once a priest, always a priest, you are a priest in the order of Melchizedek, as scripture says, and you will be 1 forever. So, so I would invite you to pray into what? What bearing does your ordination have on your inmost identity on your on your personhood? It is not a something added on top, but it is an enrichment of your unrepeatable personhood from within. And and that is a treasure that

not only the Lord can speak to you about that, but you know who is really excited about your heart? Father Andre about your priestly heart and can help you discover it and rejoice in it and and live in this integrated place as priest and person. Mary. Mary holds something special in her feminine heart for priests because you are in a Sacramento way through the gift of Holy

Orders, you are another Christ. You are in the person of Christ. And Mary, in this sense, she's your new Eve. If you are to live as a new Adam, she lives as your new Eve. She embodies the church. And yes, Mary, of course, in the flesh, she's always Jesus's mother. But this is so deep in the Catholic tradition. I'm not just making this up. This goes way, way, way back in Catholic tradition that the priest could also rightly

recognize Mary mystically as spouse. She's the New Eve, she's the new Eve, she's the bride, she's the embodiment of the Church, and you have married the Church through your celibate gift of self. And that's not just an abstraction. The Church is not an abstraction. The Church is embodied, personalized in Mary, and in that sense she is mystically your bride, and you can enter into a kind of mystical spousal intimacy with her.

She wants to share her feminine heart with you, and you can share your masculine heart with her. And in that place you can experience a profound intimacy. I'm going to ask our producer Juan to place in the show notes of this episode the link to an article. I think I've promoted this before on previous podcasts for priests. It's called The Role of Mary in Priestly Celibacy, something like that by Monsignor John

Syak. Syak is spelled CI. Jeez, I forget CIHJAKI think something like that. But anyway, we'll, we'll put the link in the show notes and, and I invite you, Father Andre, to read this. I've never seen an article that articulates as well the role of Mary with her celibate priests in that place. Mystically, as spouse at the foot of your cross. I highly recommend you read that.

It'll take you places. It'll teach you Father, that you are a gift. And on that note, I would say you don't need to be a priest to read that article. It'll shine a bright light on the gift of all of our humanity and the path to living the grace that enables us. Let's become what we are. So let's go for it. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to

you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode