Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Worried I’ll disappoint him on our wedding night, Still loving her after goodbye, Does heaven erase male and female? | ACW331

May 5, 202554 minAudio

Questions answered this episode: How do I overcome fear and insecurity about sex before marriage, especially since I’m a virgin and my fiancé isn’t? How can I love someone well when she ended our relationship but I still care deeply for her? How do I reconcile Galatians 3:28 with TOB’s teaching that we remain male and female in eternity? Resources COURSE SCHEDULE Love & Responsibility YouTube Series --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? ⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠ --- Submit your question at ⁠⁠AskChristopherWest.com⁠⁠. --- Resources mentioned this week: View our ⁠⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠⁠ --- 🎥 Check out our ⁠⁠YouTube Channel⁠⁠ 📚 View our ⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠ to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 ⁠GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE⁠ by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ ⁠Join us on one of our pilgrimages!⁠ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠ List of trusted counselors & psychologists

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello. Hello everybody. This is Juan, producer of the podcast. I just wanted to give you a heads up. We are changing our podcast host so you will stop seeing new episode updates in the Ask Christopher w.com website. The podcast will still be available on major streaming platforms, but no longer on the website. So if you want to submit a question, just go to the show notes and you will find a link there to do so. God bless. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast.

Hey, Wendy. Yes. Why are you laughing at me? Because. That's not how we usually start. I know I was just throwing you a curveball to see what happens. I got a question for you. OK. Did you know before last night what a pangolin is? I actually did. That's why I wanted to watch that. It's because I've I've known of Penguins and I. Want known of Penguins? Absolutely. I saw one at the North Museum in Lancaster. Are you? You're not for real, Yeah.

Not a living one. I mean, it's it's just a a mounted oh Penguin. Well, Wendy and I watched this weird Netflix documentary last night about Penguins, right? And it sounds kind of like a Penguin, but it's not at all. It's some strange creature I had never known about ever before. You didn't even tell me when we started watching it that you knew what a Penguin was. I thought we were both discovering something about the world that we didn't know. Not only did you know, you've seen a stuffed one at the local

museum. Yes, yeah. Tell the world right now you're you're live to our whole, not the whole world, obviously, but our podcast listeners. Yeah, tell our podcast listeners for those who do not know what a Penguin is. Yeah, amazing. Wow. God makes such strange. Features yes, it looks a lot like an anteater or an echidna. Like has some a who to what? An echidna I. Don't know what that is either. It's an Australian.

They call them spiny anteaters. That's another one. Just yeah, it just has you. Must be a homeschooling mom or something. Got some biodiversity in my brain or something. So yeah, it's this small mammal covered with spiny covering that look like, as you said it, it looks kind of like a pine cone. It's a pine cone and it has this really long, broad tail and really small little face with

the Super long tongue that it sticks in. The tongue is Let's just. You just have to see it for yourself. But amazing and just that, you know, it's totally, you know, just it's it's built to defend itself by its by its covering and curling up in a ball. It's totally not an aggressor, except to ants. Why are we sharing this on the Theology of the Body Institute podcast? Is the question #1 the answer is because we're weird. And #2 the answer is because all

of creation is a revelation of the mystery of God in one way or another. And this crazy creature came from the heart of God. Lord you, you're sometimes I it's just you, OK? You're pretty crazy. It was fascinating to see. It is fascinating and the fact that it as it matures it, it walks only on its hind legs with its front legs sort of curl. That was that was, I was about to say, cute. I'm not sure if it's cute. Peculiar. That's with that long heavy tail, kind of gives the balance, you know, It's amazing.

Check it out on Netflix if you want to. Yeah. So do you have an update for us from the TOB Institute? Yes, I shared this last week, but it bears repeating because we continue to have people who are very disappointed that they didn't get into our TOB One course in June. It's sold out. We have a waiting list, but here's what we're doing. A little special offer if you want to come to a live course this summer, even if you haven't already taken TOB one, where we

can arrange for you to take it online and then come to our Theology of the Body in the New Evangelization class. TOB 1 is a prerequisite for that class, but we have a special deal going where you can take it online at half price if you also register to come to the New Evangelization course. In the New Evangelization course, as I shared last week, it's one of my favorites to teach because the whole Catholic faith comes alive. We go through the catechism with our TOB lenses on, and the faith just comes into focus.

The words that we've heard our whole lives about the Creed, right? We've been praying the Creed since we were little kids in Catholic school. The creed will come alive. The sacraments will come alive. The moral life will come alive. The life of prayer will come alive. These are the four pillars of the Catechism Creed, sacraments, more moral life, Life of prayer, 4 pillars of the Catechism, 4 pillars of our faith. The faith comes alive and it resonates as a as a response from heaven to the deepest cry of my heart.

That's what was missing in my Catholic upbringing. What I learned in religion class I could summarize with one word, bow ring. Nobody connected the dots between the doctrine I was learning and the the yearnings I was feeling in my heart as a boy. To want to just go home, burst out of class, religions class, and run home and grab my transistor radio and climb my favorite tree and sit up there in this spot in the branches.

They were perfect leg rests and armrests. And I'd have my transistor radio on and I'd wait for my favorite song to come on. And I didn't know until decades later, those were sacred moments that those yearnings in my heart to be up in that tree in the field of breeze blowing and to hear my favorite song on the radio, that that God was wooing me more through that experience than through what I was learning in religion class. Because what I was learning in religion class was just dry doctrine presented in a way that didn't connect to my yearning to climb a tree and hear my

favorite song. This course Theology of the Body and New Evangelization has one goal for the doctrine that we've heard about what Christianity is our whole lives to resonate as truly what it is heaven's response to the deepest yearning desires and cry of our hearts. Yeah it's that's why it's one of my favorite classes to teach. So you need to have taken TOB one to take the new evangelization class.

If you wanted to take TOB one in June and you're sad that you're on the waiting list because we sold out, take it online in June and then come in July to the in person course. There are still spots left for that. And one more thing I want to share is that the TOB One course online is also open to people who aren't coming of course to the new evangelization. It's just the the special pricing that's. Correct special pricing for those who want to come in July. Yes, all. Right. And I'll also say, I mean, we,

this is just our policy at the institute if, if money is the only thing preventing you from coming to our courses. We have a new website now, it's up and running a new process with the new website up and running to apply for scholarship. We have a foundation that's supports students who can't afford to come to our courses because we never, ever want money to get in the way. And please pray for us as we are still seeking to raise funds for our foundation. If you want to support us in that regard, we'll be so grateful in the links in the

show notes. Yes, all right, here's a question from an anonymous patron. I'm engaged and will be married this summer. We're both devout Catholics who love the Lord and desire to live TOB in our marriage and family life. Your podcast has been a rich source of connection for us throughout our relationship. Oh, that's great. Helping us discuss many important topics regarding God's plan for our lives and bodies. Thanks be to God. Thank you. My question has to do with

preparing for our wedding night. Well, I'm very much looking forward to being married and coming together with my husband. I'm realizing that I have a lot of fear. I am a virgin, my fiance is not. I'm worried about disappointing him sexually, especially on our wedding night and throughout the honeymoon phase where there will inevitably be lots of learning how to love him in this new way. I also sometimes feel insecure

that the gift of my body will not be pleasing to him, fearing that when he sees me naked for the first time that certain features will not be what he had hoped. He has never given any indication that I have a reason to be afraid. In fact, he expresses his love and affection for me very frequently and freely, but I can't seem to shake these fears and worry that they will rob me and him of the joy and delight that can come from embracing one

another fully on that night. Is this something I should talk about with him now? Is it crossing any sort of boundary to share these fears surrounding sex with him before we are married? Do you have any other advice for how I can stop feeling so fearful of rejection? So vulnerable. Bless you, bless you, my dear sister. And I, I was also going to say I

feel a fatherly love for you. I, I feel you as a spiritual daughter and I just have a fatherly tenderness towards you in that very vulnerable, scary place. I mean, it goes the whole way back to the fall, to original sin. I was afraid because I was naked. So I hid myself.

What were we afraid of? What is that fear? It it's, it's deep in our bones as fallen human beings. I was afraid because I was naked. OK. I was afraid because I was naked. And you're expressing this fear of, of. Of being naked, of unveiling yourself to your husband. And the the nakedness, the fear connected to nakedness, is exactly what you've expressed. That I won't be loved, that I won't be truly seen.

That I'll be a disappointment, that I'll be displeasing in some way. That I won't know how to perform sexually, That he has sexual memories that will come to his mind and he will be comparing me to somebody else. And why is that so painful? Why is it so painful? Because we know in our bones, at the same time we know we're falling in our bones. In those very same bones, we know we are indispensable, irreplaceable and unrepeatable.

And the thought that's we're being compared to somebody else is an attack against that knowledge we have of ourselves, that I'm never meant to be compared because I'm a unique, unrepeatable human being. We have this fear that will be compared and then rejected. And why does that hurt us so much? Because we're indispensable as human beings there. There's no other you, which means to throw you away is to fail to see the unique, indispensable, irreplaceable, unrepeatable person you are.

And the rejection of that is, is unbearable. The thought of being rejected is unbearable. We can't bear it. We can't bear it. It touches us at the most vulnerable place in our in our inmost being that fear of rejection, that fear of rejection. It's so human to feel that. Bless you there, bless you there, bless you there. Thank you for your honesty there. You're giving voice, very articulately I might add. You're giving voice to the fundamental fear of every human

being right there. And it goes the whole way back to the beginning. I was afraid because I was naked, so I hid myself. In juxtaposition to that fear is this marvelous line in the New Testament. Perfect love casts out all fear. Perfect love casts out all fear. Now here's the rub in married life, and it's real, and there's

no getting around it. There's no sugar coating it. There's no pretending otherwise. It sounds like your fiance loves you beautifully, and what a gift. But this is reality. He does not love you perfectly, and in this life he never will, and you will never love him perfectly. This is the reality of our fallen humanity. We are riddled with imperfect realities. We are imperfect. We show imperfect love. It may be a beautiful love, but

it's not a perfect love. So that element of fear is not altogether unwarranted. You are going to be making yourself very vulnerable to an imperfect human being. But here's the consolation. It's real and beautiful and something to rest in. So is he. He's going to be making himself very vulnerable to an imperfect person. And what you're promising each other at the altar is that together we're going to leap.

Together we're going to leap into this. We know we're imperfect, but together we're going to nonetheless make ourselves vulnerable to each other and learn painfully at times what it means to love ever more perfectly. That's the journey, that's the bargain, that's the commitment. That's what Wendy and I did almost 30 years ago when we stood at the altar in November of 1995 and said we're going for it.

We're jumping together and we've made ourselves vulnerable to each other and we've heard each other a lot and we've forgiven each other a lot and we've had to show mercy to each other a lot. And we've need needed to open those painful places where we've heard each other a lot to God's mercy and experience healing from the Lord who does love us perfectly. And that's what makes it work.

That alone is what makes it work. There is a perfect love, there is a perfect man who loves you perfectly. His name is Jesus Christ. And there is a perfect woman who loves your husband to be perfectly. And her name is Mary. She's the bride. He's the bridegroom who love perfectly. And your husband, in the wounds that you caused him as an imperfect woman, will need to

learn how to take his wounds to the perfect woman, Mary. And you in the wounds that your husband will cause you as an imperfect husband, you will need to learn to take your wounds to the husband who loves you perfectly, Jesus. And in that way we are, we are learning what it means to love through God's perfect love, through the Blessed Mother's perfect love. We are learning to love more and more perfectly ourselves, our imperfect spouse.

But there is no taking the fear factor away totally. You have good reason to trust you're, you're marrying a good man. As you've already said, you have good reason to trust that. And I don't question that. But he's not perfect and he has good reason to believe he's marrying a good woman. And there's no reason to doubt that. But he's not marrying a perfect woman. So there's going to be pain for each and every human being. The journey of the interior life

with Jesus, with Mary, becomes reversing that original shame and fear. I was afraid because I was naked, so I hid myself. It has to become I was at peace because I knew Jesus loved me. Or, as the case may be, if we're looking for the sexual complementarity for a man. I was at peace because I knew Mary loved me perfectly. I knew Jesus loved me perfectly. So I exposed myself.

I exposed myself In a good marriage, we can approximate that. That full, vulnerable exposure to one another in good faith. That even in our imperfections, we're committed to learning what it means to love. It's going to hurt. It's going to hurt. There's no getting around it because we're imperfect. But through that pain, opened and offered to Jesus, we grow. We grow in love, We grow in perfection, we grow in loving

more perfectly, and we we can become more and more naked without shame before one another. 30 years into married life, I can say we're still learning this. We're still learning. There are still places in our hearts that we need to learn to open to one another more vulnerably. And we've been through painful places, painful realizations in our own marriage where we realized I've been hiding from you because I'm afraid you're not going to love me here. And that's gone both ways in our relationship. And that's that's because we're

both broken. But there is grace through all of it to grow and to heal. All of that is kind of background to get to your real question or, or a, a big part of your question was do we think you should share it in advance with your fiance, what you're going through? And as Wendy was reading your question and you were articulating so well and so honestly your genuine fears and

concerns, I was thinking, gosh, I wonder if she's been this open and honest and articulate with her, articulate with her fiance. And I think you should be, I think you should be. This is how we prepare for the wedding night. And that's, that's integral to your question. You're, you're looking for advice on how we prepare for, for, for our wedding night And that kind of spiritual nakedness and seeing that he will love you and receive you there, God

willing, he does. We have reason to believe He will from what you've described of him, that spiritual nakedness. Prepares you for the physical nakedness that spiritual nakedness is and being loved there by your fiance will give you. We can't claim perfect piece of art because as I've already explained, that's just not reality. But we you can approximate a real peaceful presence of heart, trusting I can reveal my true self, my naked self to him,

because you already have by revealing your heart right when when we when we have been naked in spirit, keyword in spirit and we've been received there, then the physical nakedness is the sacrament of of that spiritual vulnerability that we've already experienced and tasted genuine love there. So yes, I do think you should share this with your fiance and it will be scary, but his his I think you have good reason to

believe he's going to love you there. I am in full agreement with that. And I, I was struck by some of the things that she shared that were her specific fears and also that she said that they have benefited from our podcast in their marriage preparation and just in their lives. And I, I was thinking that something struck me about the fears that they kind of

illustrate that we are very much educated by this fallen world about the purpose and nature of a man and woman coming together in a false way. That the, the message is one of we are coming together for pleasure and to experience this like pleasure with one another. And that coming together for

pleasure involves a certain level of beauty of both people. Maybe unfortunately in this pornographic world, it also there's an implied sort of skill set or something that is all sort of necessary for this maximization of pleasure. And even when you're a person of faith and you have, like, you know, been informed and educated about this whole other reality

of coming together to express the deepest truth of our self gift to one another. Coming together as a, a, a particular ministry to the other person. A sensitivity that grows over time that allows like profound consolations that are strength for the difficult journey of life. Like when we learn those things, we, we are given a certain peace, but it's almost like that

other learning is nagging there in the background, you know, And I think as you come together to discuss this with and, and as you just pray over your fears, I think if you can recognize like that there is a there's an enemy who wants to rob us of that true gift of self, that true journey together of growing in that sensitivity and tenderness toward one another.

If we can see how even despite ourselves that those messages have have influenced us, it it can help to make sense of where the fears have come from and how as a sacramentally married couple, part of your calling is that to be warriors against those forces. So like that this is coming up can be so fruitful in what God is doing in your marriage.

So I just want to encourage you in that way. That's awesome Wendy, Warriors against those forces that are trying to rob us of that true vulnerable gift of self that is the marriage bed. Well, well articulated, Wendy and I, I, I, I, I sense that battle in our culture is particularly over 2 things. You brought up a sense of beauty and technique, right? That's what the culture focuses

on. And that the sense of beauty has been so plasticized, commercialized that, that we've, we've lost sense. Let me put it this way. There's nothing more beautiful in the marriage bed than a husband and a wife who are naked with each other in both the

physical and spiritual dimension. There's nothing more beautiful than that nakedness that what what we could call integral nakedness and integral beauty, beauty of body and soul vulnerably entrusted to the other as we are with our real humanity, which is not perfectly beautiful. That has blemishes. And I mean blemishes here, not just in the physical sense, but

but even more so in the spiritual sense, that that we come to each other as we really are as warriors against those lies that you're not lovable if you don't meet XY and Z standard, whether that's some standard of impossible physical beauty or some standard of sexual technique. These things rob us, rob us of the true experience of marital

relations because they put the emphasis in the wrong places. There may be elements of truth in what you can learn from some various quote techniques. There may be some value, some value, but Oh my gosh, if it's coming from the secular world, it's going to be just caked with crap and garbage and lies that you have to work through and work through to find some, maybe some buried help in there. What we need much more than than

what the culture is teaching us when it comes to technique or or idealized images of beauty. What we need, John Paul the Second tells us so insightfully in his book Love and Responsibility. What we need is a culture of marital relations where we make our hearts vulnerable to the other and we expose the the other world of each other's hearts to each other. A woman's heart is another world from a man's heart. A man's heart is another world

from a woman's heart, and we need to learn to expose those other worlds to each other. That naked vulnerability is beautiful and And from that naked vulnerability comes what John Paul describes as a tenderness in marital relations, a tenderness towards the other that leads to authentic intimacy and and intimacy here I heard years ago could be cleverly

understood as into me see that that opening up of what's really going on in me for the other to see and cherish and love. Who's going to do that? Perfectly Nobody we have not. But through it all, we grow, we learn, we heal, we forgive, we bring Jesus in. And the adventure, as difficult and painful as it is, is glorious and worth it. So yes, share your heart. Share your heart with your

fiance and invite him to do the same. And I know he will be inspired if you, if you would share your heart in that way, He will be inspired to share his own heart vulnerably with you. And that vulnerability of heart ahead of your wedding night will make your wedding night all the more honest and true and safe and beautiful. And I just throw out one more thing to this dear, vulnerable, engaged woman, John Paul. The second.

I've just just talking about his insights from love and responsibility. His, his insights there are stupendous. And there's a series on love and responsibility that Matt Fratt and I did. We'll put a link in the show notes to it. 3 episodes were on our channel and three episodes were on Matt Fratt's channel where where we unpacked some of the main themes of love and responsibility. And that could be great marriage preparation for you too guys as well. I hope that you hope you find that helpful. Bless you, bless you, bless you and and all that you're going

through preparing for your wedding in your wedding night. Hello. Hello everybody. This is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on tour this year. We're going to places like New Mexico, Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Illinois, and also other countries like Ecuador and Brazil. We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our event schedule and the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Peace. Our next question is from a listener named Matthew. Hi, Matthew. Thank you both so much for your

ministry, your marriage, and your witness. I'm a university student and met the most wonderful Catholic woman while studying away from my campus this past winter. Wasn't that special? Our Lord and Lady were beautifully at work in our meeting and budding relationship in so many ways, but after some weeks of long distance dating and trips to see her, she called and told me that she could not continue in a romantic relationship. My sense is that a deep wound had reopened in her life and I

wish that I could bear that pain and hurt for her. Even so, I know it is not my place to try to grasp at some unknown 'cause that would be rightly unveiled by God's hand, not my own. In many ways, I'm heartbroken, yet God's healing has been powerful. Amidst my sorrow, I know that His plans for our lives are so much greater than mine, and He loves her so much more than I ever could. It is a daily prayer that my

desires and actions toward this woman may be pure and not self-serving. Still, I feel a deep longing to lay down my life for her and to love and honor her, even if outside a romantic relationship. How can I love as God loves in this situation? How do I best reverence our relationship as holy friendship that respects her heart and does not create false hope? And how do I guard my own heart to be open to whatever God calls us to, beyond what I might see

or desire? Matthew, I love your heart, brother. You have a beautiful heart and you're asking all the right questions, you're pressing into the right places. You are wanting to learn to love and that is a beautiful, beautiful desire of your heart. Wanting to learn genuine love, beautiful, beautiful work of grace. There is nothing whether you are

meant to have a romantic relationship or not, whether you are meant to have any relationship in terms of contact with this woman ever again in your life, whether or not, none of that will prove. Let's just go. Let's go with the scenario that you might not ever talk to her again in your life or never be in a romantic relationship with her ever. Have a friendship and maybe you marry somebody else, she marries somebody else. Nothing, nothing can prevent you or should prevent you from

loving her rightly and learning through this experience more deeply what it means to love another human being. And, and you're going through all the steps already and asking all the right questions already as to what does that mean? How does that look? And, and here are some just thoughts to give it. I don't know. I'm, I, I, as I said that I, I had like an image of a canvas and, and on the canvas there were some colors just to, to

give you some sense of the, the way it looks or feels or the shape of it or the color of it. But it it, it means willing her good no matter what it costs you, willing her good, desiring her good, working for her good in your own heart, working for her good even in your, your actions and the way you either

interact or don't interact with her. I don't know the status of whether you're still in contact with her or not, but in your heart to say, Lord, I desire her good. Teach me how to offer my own disappointment that we're not in a relationship, sorrow that our relationship ended, questions about what might have caused this relationship to end. And and I I brother, I just have

a sense of your heart that you you may be right. It it may be a a kind of holy intuition you have that some wound surfaced in her life. And if indeed it is a holy intuition, I have the sense that it might be. The Lord grants us these holy intuitions to teach us how to love, to teach us how to pray, to teach us how to intercede, to teach us how to desire the other's good and to act according to that other person's good, no matter the sacrifice it

demands of me. So let's just go down that path for a little bit to give some color to this canvas, so to speak. Let's say you were given a holy insight that some wound was resurfacing because of your relationship, not a wound necessarily that you caused, but some wound from her past and that the Lord's giving you a holy intuition that that's what's going on. How do you love her? She has said I need to end the relationship. So you need to respect that

decision. Now that costs you. That hurts, but respecting that is a way of loving her and offering that pain that that real sorrow that the relationship is not going the direction you hoped and desired it would. Offering that in prayer as intercession for her good and out of respect for her good and for what she has expressed she has desired. Honoring that in the pain of what it costs you.

You are learning to love. That's what look love feels like. That's what love tastes like. That's what love smells like, sacrificing my own desire for the good of the other, sacrificing what I might want and feeling the sorrow of that and not resenting it, but offering your heart in that place of rawness and pain. Lord, I unite my pierced heart with your pierced heart. I unite my bleeding heart with your bleeding heart.

I say yes, Jesus, to your desire to unite your bleeding heart with my bleeding heart. Now we have a union of bleeding hearts, Jesus, for this precious, unrepeatable woman. And with you, Jesus, Ioffer my bleeding heart with your bleeding heart for her bleeding heart. You're learning to love, brother. You're learning to love. You stay in that posture with all that it does emotionally to your own mind and heart. You stay in that posture for her good.

You are learning to love and you will bleed. You will bleed for her and that bleeding for her. You are learning to love and that kind of love bears fruit. And that kind of love you can take with you through your whole life. Not that, you know, suppose you marry somebody else, not like every day of your life, you're going to feel this bleeding heart for your, for this old flame you had. I I don't mean it in that sense, but you can carry with you that the the memory of that sorrow.

There's a a woman that I loved before I fell in love with Wendy. She and I dated for four years. I thought I was going to marry her. She still has a place in my heart. That was 30, whatever, 37 years ago or something, I don't know. It was a long time ago, 40 years ago almost that I started dating that girl. That's a long time ago. There's still a place in my heart in there where where I Ioffer her up to the Lord. Lord that I loved her. She loved me. We thought we were going to marry. It didn't work out. There's a there's a there's a place in my heart where I just,

yeah, Lord, I give her to you, give her to you. I, I give that whole that the breakup of that relationship, which even as I describe it, gosh, there's still pain in there, still hurts freaking that hurt. Jesus, I give it to you. I give it to you. I and I can love her from a distance and, and trust that yeah, the Lord's going to work all that out in the in the next life. And Wendy and I and her husband and she will, will rejoice in what the Lord has done.

It'll all be healed. It'll all be worked out. It'll all be glorified. Can't wait for that. So yeah, there's a way we can rightly, there's also a way we can wrongly, like pine over someone over a course of a lifetime, you know, in an unhealthy way. But there's a healthy place and a healthy way to carry those those things in our hearts. There's a healthy way. We don't just need to, you know, stuff it, repress it, forget it. We can, we can open those pains to the Lord and, and give them

to Jesus and they can become a love, a genuine love that we carry in our hearts throughout our whole lives. It's real. It's a real deal. It's for real. It really can happen. I loved Matthew's way of just having a caution about his own, you know, the the possibility that he could be grasping and his desire not to grasp. I think that there's a great wisdom in him. He is a very young man to

already have that wisdom. And I just want to affirm that Matthew, so so honoring to not kind of desperately, you know, as she's saying she wants to end the romantic relationship, like kind of tell her, you know what, why you think she's saying that and why that's not a reason or, you know, all those things that are certainly understandable human experiences, but they do

come from a grasping and there is something really just honouring of her that I I sense in your. Your response especially because it wasn't a very long relationship, you know, where you know, she maybe you know, hadn't already talked about all these things to you in the past, but they were just things you had a feeling about to keep trusting that to the Lord is is a beautiful thing and and there

is an expression in in theology of the body that sometimes confuses people. It's this term disinterested tenderness. Am I saying that right disinterested tenderness and I I feel like that the grace of disinterested tenderness is what I'm sensing in your heart, Matthew that disinterested means not self-serving. So there is just a a genuineness of desiring what is good.

I also sense like a desiring rightness in relationship that is really beautiful. And I, I can relate to that as just like a guidepost of the heart, you know, to say this, this is now if it's anything, it's just a friendship. And so let that be a guidepost in my heart as to how I relate with her. But it is it is not more than a friendship and therefore what we share and how we interact

shouldn't be include some pressure to change from that what it is. And I I think that's really beautiful and I want to affirm that as well with that disinterested tenderness. That tenderness inspires sincere prayer. And I, I encourage you, Christopher, use that image of a, a canvas with colors. I encourage you in your prayer for her to call upon that, that

gift of holy imagination where maybe you are imagining just giving her to Jesus in a very real way. You know, like like as if you're you're walking together to the Lord and you're leaving her there with him as a part of your just praying for the Lord to minister to her heart and her life in in the ways that she's ready to receive and be challenged to grow and heal. Like to really have that

experience in your own prayer journey of whether it's a one time or or many times of surrendering her to the Lord. I know Christopher did this in relation to a past relationship he was just talking about, and I have borne the fruit of that in my whole life. If he hadn't been willing to say I trust you Jesus and and trust her to Jesus, I mean, I wouldn't be married to Christopher. We wouldn't have our life like

the fruit that has been born of. That is incredible to me. And so I just encourage you to know that that can bear remarkable fruit in your story and in her story. Those are my thoughts, beautiful. Thoughts, Wendy. Thanks for sharing them and thank you Matthew for sharing your heart with us. Bless you brother. Our next question is from a listener named June. Hi, June. I'm reading Theology of the Body and enjoying it so much.

John Paul 2 repeats often that our resurrected bodies will continue to be distinctly male or female. But in Galatians 3 verse 28, it says there is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female. How do you account for this? I'd really love an answer to this. Partly I fear this verse in Galatians might be used to give some fuel to the arguments of trans, non binary, etcetera

activists and allies. Thank you for helping me with this. And by the way, Christopher's preface is 2 thumbs up. Well, thank you, June. She's actually reading the Wednesday audiences herself, like directly. Way to go. There are a few people who have the aptitude to go directly to JP 2, and she's really seems like she's really like sucking the nectar out of it. So that's really exciting. Good for you, June. Yes, it it, it can be puzzling.

A lot of what Saint Paul says is puzzling and can be difficult to understand. In fact, did you know that that's a biblical truth? Because in one of Peter's letters, he talks about all these letters that Paul has has written that can be very difficult to understand. So it's it's an inspired biblical truth that Paul's letters can be hard to understand. So what's he getting at? There's no longer Jew nor Greek. There's no longer slave nor free.

There's no longer male nor female. He's talking about the fruit of life in Christ that brings unity out of distinction, right? And the unity that comes out of distinction does not erase the distinction, but recognizes recognizes it is the distinction that brings about the unity, right? Just as differences in race can

cause conflict, Jew or Greek can cause conflict, can cause 1 to dominate the other, can cause one to think I'm better than you are, right. In that sense, there will no longer be Jew or Greek, Just as differences in class and race can lead to such a sense of superiority of one over the other that one might enslave the other to serve his or her own needs and fail to recognize the true dignity of those persons in

Christ. That whole domination and enslavement no longer exists. And just as in a fallen world, it's right there in the book of Genesis, your desire will be for your husband and he will dominate you. Now that does the word desire in the Hebrew is a manipulative desire, right? This is this is Scripture talking about the effects of the fall on the male female relationship. The woman will manipulate her husband might be a more accurate way to put it. And the husband will dominate and try to control his wife,

right? That's what happens in a fallen world and what Saint Paul is saying in Christ. All that fallen crapola gets healed if we really walk the way with Jesus. And in that sense, there's no longer these the sense of a difference that causes these divisions, dominations 1 ruling over the other. Those are gone in Christ. The distinction itself becomes now the way of living, a new unity, right?

We become one body in Christ, one body in Christ. But how is it that we become one body in Christ precisely through the distinction, right? Male and female. He created them and he blessed them, and he called the 2 to this beautiful unity in one body. So what Paint Saint Paul is saying is not that the distinction of male and female is erased, but rather the distinction of male and female comes to be lived according to God's design in such a way that it brings about an authentic

unity, an authentic oneness. And this oneness will be manifested perfectly in the resurrection of the body. And that's why John, John, Paul the Second can say that in the resurrection of the body we will live. We will be male and female. We will live fully as the man or the woman God always designed us to be. And what he has always designed us to be is that the difference leads to a perfect and a Holy Communion, a common union, a

unity that doesn't obliterate the distinction but lives the distinction in such a way that unity is possible. But in the resurrection of the body, the unity that we are now living, just to put a bow on this, the unity that we are now living is not so much in the, the, the marriage of a male and a female. That is just the glimmer. That's the sign that that leads to and is fulfilled in a much more profound reality, which is the unity of divinity and

humanity, God and man, Christ and the church, right? This is why the Bible begins with the marriage of of male and female, man and woman, but it ends with the marriage of Christ and the church. The beginning of the story is leading us to the end of the story. And This is why Jesus says in the resurrection we're no longer given in marriage. That's not the obliteration of the sexual difference. That's the ultimate fulfillment of the sexual difference where the sign becomes and enters into

and reveals and leads us into the ultimate reality, which is the marriage of Christ in the church. That's the destiny. And so male and female will not be erased or deleted. They will be fully embraced and completed in the marriage of the Lamb. Glory, glory, glory, glory. I hope that's helpful to you, June. Just remember, he's not eliminating the distinction. He's point St. Paul in Galatians. He's not eliminating the

distinction. He's eliminating the distinction in the distinction that led to disunity and rupture and pain and domination. But in Christ that gets healed and the distinction leads to authentic oneness. Glory be to God. Yeah, I think that's that's really beautiful. And I can relate to what June is saying about kind of having something in Scripture or Yeah, especially in the scripture kind of feel like it has a a

possibility of being interpreted in a way that would be contrary to truth. And that's just painful. It's painful to know that in this fallen world that reality occurs and exists. And so it is good to like open that up and seek answers, whatever those concerns are, to allow the Lord to speak truth into the places where those kind of agendas have wounded our hearts, You know, because they

do and they cause confusion and they can cause, you know, lack of faith. So Lord, build up our faith. Lord, show us that Your light of truth shines through all that You have revealed and and allow that power of your truth and Your revealed love and desire to reconcile all that is broken in this world. Let that penetrate us even in the smallest ways in the simple scripture that causes confusion.

Lord, we open our hearts to You. Thank you, Lord, thank you, Lord, for the promise that Your Word is always for us, not against us. We need to understand Your Word correctly, and that just shines a light on the great gift of the Magisterium. Thank God we have a magisterium in the Catholic Church to tell us what the Scripture does and doesn't mean. Otherwise, it's up to you and up to me to come up with our our best guess. And if I don't like with the way you interpret the Bible, I'll go start my own church that does that.

That leads precisely to the disunity that Saint Paul is saying here. We are meant to overcome, to find true unity, true oneness through distinction. Unity in distinction. It goes the whole way up to the Trinity, right? The Father's not the Son, the Son is not the Father, the Holy Ghost is neither, but all three are one God in three distinct persons. It's the distinction that affords the unity, and that passes over to us too, because we're made in the image and likeness of this very God, and because we're made in the image

and likeness of this God, we're a gift. And through Jesus Christ, in his death and resurrection, we have been given all the grace we need to. Become what we are. I think we should go do that. Let's go become what we are, Wendy's. Do it. Let's keep going. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione.

Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode