Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Male fertility & TOB, Should I read things that trigger my sexual wounds?, and Exposure therapy for modesty? | ACW359

Nov 17, 202551 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: Right now, I'm learning about cycles and fertility using the Creighton method. One main point is that the man is always fertile while the woman is infertile most of the time. I’m wondering if there’s a theology behind that - especially since the man typically initiates and is constantly fertile. What do you think is the significance of this? I'm dating and love your podcast. I'm in a serious relationship but still in college, so marriage is likely two years away. When do you recommend reading Good News About Sex and Marriage? I viewed pornography in early high school but, with God’s grace, have been free for years. Still, twisted ideas about sexuality linger. I long for God’s truth - could reading these sources bring healing and help untwist what remains twisted in me? I feel like modesty conversations are objectifying. Why talk about me as if I’m just pieces to cover? Secular friends see me as a whole person, but religious people seem to see only skin. You say there are no abstract breasts, yet I’m told to cover mine because they “distract” from me - even though they are me. If the body isn’t bad, why hide it? If others can look purely, why must I be my brother’s keeper? Can’t we stop sexualizing everything instead of keeping it taboo? Resources: Course Schedule JPII Legacy Foundation Website Good News About Sex & Marriage Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 ⁠⁠Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠ *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Welcome to another episode, everybody. Yes, hello, podcast listeners. We are happy to be with you. Thanks for being with us. Yeah, thanks for those that said hello during the 11 responsibility course that just happened. We just finished that last week. It was a rich, rich blessing.

We had people from, I don't know, 5 or 6 or 7 different countries, lots of different states across the US. We did a deep dive into JP 2's what could be called his philosophy of the body, which is the the philosophical foundation for his theology of the body and love and responsibility. It was really a gift for me to teach with our dear friend Jeanette Clark. This is one of the courses that

is Co taught so you get the male and the female perspective. And she's such a gifted teacher and has beautiful insights, and we've known her for 30 years. And I know the students always rave about Jeanette's particular gift. So if you've not taken the Love and Responsibility course and it's of interest to you, we do offer it online. So I encourage you to check out our schedule of online courses. And if there's an issue with money, we never want that to be

an issue thanks to the generosity of our patrons. So a shout out to all of our patrons out there. You enable us to provide scholarship funds. If you want to help us to grow that scholarship fund, that's our goal. Like I said to the students last week, I don't know if you're in the room or not, Wendy, when I shared this, that we are at a point in history kind of like the time when Thomas Aquinas had just died. And the first disciples of Thomas Aquinas knew that the gift they had been given in this man's theological insight was

meant for the whole church for centuries to come. And people financed it and took it up and passed it on. We're at a similar time in church history. We are the first generation to receive the gift of John Paul the 2nd. And that's why we have what we call the John Paul the Second Legacy Foundation to, to ensure at least to play our role in ensuring that this legacy gets passed on to the next generation, the next generation, the next generation. And we really want to build an endowment to ensure that that happens.

So if you want to be part of that for generations to come, supporting this effort for generations to come, and you're not already a patron, would you please consider becoming a patron and clicking the link below in the show notes to, to learn how to do that? I, I said to all the students, I asked how many of you are here by scholarship last week and I'd say 1/3 to 1/2 of the class raise their hands. And we did run out of money on this one. We weren't able to, we, we had people who would have been

grateful for scholarships, but we ran out of money. I want to be in the position, I hope and pray we get there where we never, ever run out of scholarship funds and we're never turning anybody away just for financial reasons. If, if that resonates with your heart and you want to help us either with a large gift or a recurring gift, we sure would be grateful. You can check out that info in the show notes. Yeah. And I'm just wondering if you want to give us an update from the theology of the Body Institute while we're at. It while we're at it, yes, we have some courses coming up if

anybody's interested in the flesh courses. Bill Donaghy is teaching the writings of John Paul the Second on gender, marriage and family. So these would be writings that came after the theology of the body, where he's applying the theology of the body in later documents. We have the document on the Christian family in the modern world. We have his letter to families. We have his letter on the dignity and vocation of women. We have a little meditation called Meditation on Givenness,

which I just reread and it's so rich. This is JP 2 at his finest. And there's also a his letter to women that he wrote in the 90s. So that's just a sampling of some of the additional writings that we at the Theology of the Body Institute believe our students need to be exposed to, need to do a deeper dive in, need to have them unpacked. Bill's going to be teaching that course in January. I'm going to be heading to Sydney, Australia to teach the

Theology of the Body Level 1 course in conjunction with the Archdiocese of Sydney. So if anybody is from that part of the world and you want to come to a an in person TOB level 1 course, please check out the link in the show notes for that. Great. Are you ready for a question from a patron? All right, this patron actually gave me this question at the Love and Responsibility course. Yeah, she came up to me and said I have a question for the podcast, so I just turned up and record on my phone and that's

where we got. This question that's never happened in a whole history of our doing this. Podcast, here it is. Here it is. That's pretty Dang fun, yes. This is from an anonymous patron. All right, but you know who it is. I do. I just learned about your podcast recently. I'm listening to all the new episodes and catching up on the old ones. It's so exciting for me. Right now I'm learning about cycles and fertility using the Creighton method. One of the main points is that

the man is always fertile, but the woman is the one who's infertile most of the time. So I was wondering if there's a theology around that? Love it. Because the man is the one who usually initiates, right? And he's always fertile. What are your thoughts about the significance of that? Yeah, I do have some thoughts and I really like this question. This is a thinker I love, I love

questions. You can tell people are pondering this stuff and what about this? What about that? So these, this is one of those questions I just love to reflect on. So here's what rises up in me as I think about it. And I, I thought on this previously. It's not the first time I've thought about it, but I, I've not, I can't say I've spent a lot of time here. So this is a little bit off the cuff, but I think what's going on here is the constant fertility of the male is a sign

of the infinite generative power of Godfather. This is a truth I've spoken, I'm sure in previous episodes on this podcast. It's it's a delicate truth to talk about because we're not used to talking about testicles and I'm sure there is a little flinch among many of our listeners even to hear me say the word testicles. But the word I'll say it again. The word testicles shares the same root in in language as the as words like testify,

testimony, testament. What is the purpose of the Old Testament? What is the purpose of the New Testament? It's to testify to the eternal loving fatherhood of God. Why did God? Can I just interrupt that for a moment? Testify, it means like to give evidence in support of, right? So I just 'cause you're saying the root is shared with testify. So I just wanted to use like a different phrase to like illuminate that a little bit more to give evidence in support

of something. Give evidence in support of something so the male's constant fertility is giving evidence in support of in other words, it is testifying to the eternal fatherhood of God. What do we mean by the eternal fatherhood of God? God is not sexual. He does not generate sexually, but in a purely divine and spiritual way. The Father is eternally meaning as it was in the beginning, is now and ever shall be.

And even, as we say, as it was in the beginning, there's no beginning for God. God is infinite eternally. The Father is generating the Son. Eternally the Son is being generated by the Father so that they can share in the exchange of love that we call the Holy Spirit. This is who and what God is. And truly, our bodies are theological. A man's body reveals this mystery of eternal generation,

and it does so in as much as the the generation of sperm in in the male testicles is, is quasi, quasi infinite, right? You can count the number of eggs that a woman will ovulate in her lifetime, something around the neighborhood of 500, and she has those 500 eggs from when she's within her mother's womb. Those eggs are already there. She'll never have any more. She'll never produce any more. The number of eggs that that

female is going to have is already present when she's a a, a, a, a baby in her mother's womb. Well, the male does not produce sperm until he hits puberty and he produces upwards of 1500 sperm every second. Every second 1500 sperm in every act of intercourse. There's something like between 300 and 500 million sperm

released from from the male. This is this is what I mean when I say the the the degenerative process in the male is quasi infinite 1500 sperm a second throughout his lifetime. And that varies with age and, and other factors, but it is a pointer to a testimony to giving account of telling the story of the infinite fatherhood of God, where whereas female fertility

is a testimony in a different sense, it's, it's a witness to our creaturely status that we are sharers in God's life giving this we, we, there's, there's something finite about our humanity. I'm not saying men are infinite and women are finite. I'm saying that within our finite humanity, within the mystery of male and female, there is a sign, a revelation of the relationship between God and

humanity. And in that relationship between God and humanity, God is always the bridegroom and father, and we are always the bride and mother. And that is the case whether you're male or female. We are as humanity in relation to God, we are always bride and a fertile bride, which leads to motherhood. But motherhood comes in this cyclical reality of a time of fertility, a time of infertility, a limited number of

eggs that will be released. And I think that's a testimony not just to the creaturely status of a woman, but rather that woman is the model and the archetype here, as John Paul the Second says, of the whole human race. So that finitude of female fertility points to the finitude of, of, of being human, whereas the quasi Infinity or the plentitude of male fertility is an indication of the eternal

fatherhood of God. And yet, you know, a man is only fertile in relation to a woman. So we say the man's fertile all the time. But what does that even mean? I'm not fertile by myself. I can only be fertile in relation to you, my wife. I mean, I could be fertile in relation to other women, but I'm not going there. Because. I am utterly committed to you. I've committed my fertility to you and you alone and I like it that way. So that's that's my initial

thought and reflection on that and I'm very grateful for this person's question. Yeah, that's beautiful. What are your thoughts, Wendy? One thing I felt like adding is that there I think there's a great beauty in understanding the woman's cycle and a little bit more descriptive way than just usually infertile, small time fertile because her our bodies are continuously focused on accomplishing that time of

fertility. And so there's a there's there's a preparation that goes on that is beautiful and intricate and just preparing everything just so for the possibility of new life. And there's something to me that just feels very central to a woman's heart and being that sense of being able to carefully make space for another person to

grow. Like, yes, physically we're carefully making that space. We don't have to consciously choose to. That's just the way we're designed. But that instinct in femininity and what John Paul the Second calls the feminine genius has to do with that awareness of another, of a person outside of oneself, and many different ways to honor and make room for that

person. And I, I feel like that reflection of that in our fertility is just a, a beautiful theology of our bodies that is not just physical, but is emotional, spiritual. It's part of the gift that God designed women to be. So I just wanted to reflect on that aspect of the theology of, of fertility. And then also in a man, our questioner brought up the fact

that it's usually the man who initiates. So I feel like that was kind of capturing her attention a little bit. Like what is this male female dynamic? It's there's something like in the physical reality, the emotional, the spiritual of the man, that readiness, that like call to action, I'm here kind of

reality of masculinity. You know that is true of his heart and true of his fertility. That's. And true of his anatomy. Yeah, Wendy, I am so blessed by what you shared about that preparation that it's not just a light switch for female fertility off on the body is throughout the cycle is preparing itself, kind of making

the bed, if you will for and and preparing the room. And the meals and the. Meals to, to to nourish and nurture life. That reminds me of what JP 2 says. I mentioned this meditation on givenness and I love this line. I I have it right here so I'll read it. He says a long road led me to discover the genius of woman and Providence itself saw to it that

the time eventually came when I really recognized that genius of woman and when was even dazzled by it. And I just want to say, Wendy, what you just shared there, I was dazzled by it. I was dazzled by you gave me a whole new, not whole new. It's not like all new, but it gave me a new level of dazzlement at the mystery that you are, you are in every woman's body proclaims.

And how sad that we are so casual about that. And we, we, we literally poison it. We seek to thwart that preparation. We, we seek to poison that room so that that, that the child cannot be either conceived or if the child has been conceived, poison the bed, so to speak, so that when the baby goes to lie in the bed, this is my metaphor for the implantation in the womb

that it's inhospitable and spits him out, spits the baby out. That makes me want to vomit. But it just goes to show we, we don't know who we are. We look, but we don't see the glory revealed through our bodies. JP 2 says purity of heart is the glory of God revealed through our bodies. It is God's glory in our bodies revealed through our bodies. And it is our ability to see that glory revealed through our bodies.

And the more we see it truly, the more we are amazed and even dazzled by that glory. Thank you, Wendy, for dazzling me. The glory of God revealed through your body. Awesome, makes me want to testify. Our next question is from a listener named Jonas. Hello, Jonas. I'm currently dating and I love listening to your podcast. I'm in a serious relationship but still in college so marriage

seems like it will be at least two years away. When do you recommend reading your book Good News About Sex and Marriage? I had a past of viewing pornography in early high school, but with the help of my parents and the grace of God, I've been free for many years. Still, there are so many twisted things about sexuality in my head. I have a great desire for God's beautiful truth about sex. Do you think reading these

sources could bring more healing and allow God to untwist what is twisted in me? Bless you, Jonas, I, I appreciate your sensitivity to your own inner life. And I think the question comes from a place of, OK, I'm going to be reading a book about human sexuality that gets into some nitty gritty details. And am I in a place where reading this will stir up painful images, memories,

wounds? And the answer to that is almost certainly yes, it will. But if it does, and I'm saying it probably most certainly will, do that the invitation of the book throughout is to let the light of Christ come into those dark places in our hearts. How do we overcome evil? We overcome evil with good, Saint Paul tells us.

We overcome evil with good. We have all been lied to about the meaning of our sexuality. The healing that we need is not ultimately silence about sexuality. We don't go from lies to to nothing to silence. We must go from lies to truth. But there is wisdom in recognizing, OK, I'm kind of raw.

I, I need to be aware of my heart. I need to be aware of wounds that I have. I need to be aware of these lies that I believe. And I, I don't want to get triggered in a way that would take me in a, an untoward direction. I honor that. I reverence that. But I say to you, Jonas, be not afraid. This book is written in such a way as to invite a prayerful. And what do we mean by prayerful? We mean united with Jesus. That's what prayer is.

Prayer is union with the Lord. To to enter into this book with a with an honest, sincere heart, which I know you have, is to enter into deep union with the Lord and to come away dazzled. Just as we were saying earlier, dazzled by the beauty and splendor of God's plan for sexuality, we overcome evil with good. The John Paul the Second says in his theology, the body, the main antidote to sexual sin is to

come to a true evaluation of the beauty, dignity wonder of God's plan for sexuality and to be amazed by it. That amazement, that wonderment, that awe and reverence for the beauty revealed in sexuality. This is what prevents us from going in an unhealthy direction. So Jonas, again, I admire your knowledge of yourself. I I reverence your question and

where it's coming from and I say, brother, be not afraid. The Lord will lead you and take you, I pray, into that dazzlement, and that will be the antidote to falling into sexual sin. Yeah, I just want to join you in that and and just offer a prayer for Jonas and you know, everyone who's reading any of your books right now. Lord, I lift up all those people that they would really experience exactly what Christopher was just talking about that that reading this is, is a a path and a doorway to a

closer relationship with you. A a sense of your infinite goodness and your goodwill towards us and your desire that we would share in your infinite goodness and how the way you've made us as a gift is, is our invitation to be close to you. And but this title, good News about sex and marriage isn't just a cute phrase. It's genuinely true.

Lord bless all those who are reading any of Christopher's books, encountering his videos, whatever it may be. Lord, open their hearts. Let them encounter you. Amen Jonas. Here's this one simple way to to put what I was trying to say earlier, but an image I use. You know, Christianity is not a starvation diet. And if we think it is, then we, we take our hunger to the fast food and that's what you have done. That's what most of us do. We take our hunger to the fast food. But the antidote to the fast

food is not starvation. The antidote to the fast food is the wedding feast, the banquet of God's plan. Come to the wedding feast, my brother, come to the wedding feast. That's the invitation of the Lord. That's the invitation of the Gospel, and we are to go out into the main streets and invite everyone to that wedding feast. That's what this book is about. So again, be not afraid. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. I feel like the conversation

about modesty is always objectifying. Why are you talking about me as if I have just a bunch of pieces that I need to cover? Why do the pieces take away from the hole? I have plenty of secular friends that look at me and they just see me, but I feel like religious ones look at me and just see skin. You say there are no abstract breasts and yet I'm told to

cover mine because they distract from me. When they are me, just like my eyes are me, they reveal me. If nothing about the body is bad, why does it need to be hidden? If secular people can look at me purely, why do I need to play Brother's keeper? Can't we just get over it and do exposure therapy and not keep everything sexualized and taboo? I love this question. I love it. I love this person.

She's a thinker and and she is feeling deeply in her own heart the pain of not being seen. I want to. I want to affirm first before I say anything else. I just want to affirm her rightness in saying my eyes are part of me. My my elbows are part of me, my breasts are part of me. My eyes reveal me, my elbows

reveal me, my breasts reveal me. Why can't we see this? That's, that's the cry of her heart. Why? Why am I playing brother's keeper here? And why is it that my secular friends seem to be able to see me and these religious people can't? These are all great, great questions, and it would take a doctoral dissertation to do the answer justice. I can only give some initial food for thought. But what you are desiring, my

dear sister, is Eden, which is a very good desire. What you are desiring ultimately is the new paradise, heaven, which we will experience through the resurrection of our bodies. And it's in the beginning and it's in the end that we have a true taste of the purity and innocence, or let me put it this way, a full taste. We can have a true taste even in

our fallen state. I'll get to that in a minute. But in the beginning and in our destiny, we have a full experience of nakedness without shame. And nakedness without shame means my body's revealing my person, and everyone sees it rightly, right? That's the state of innocence. That's why they were naked without shame, because their nakedness, the entirety of their nakedness, revealed their person.

That's what you are longing for, my dear sister. And I bless that longing, and I affirm that longing. I bless it and I affirm it, and now I must also inject some realism into the state in which we are born and the world in which we live, which is a fallen world. Why did nakedness without without shame not last very long? In the beginning, nakedness

without shame did not last long because they lost the ready ability to see the body as the revelation of the person. Shame enters with original sin, and with original sin we go blind to a certain extent. To a large extent, we are no longer in our fallen humanity. We are no longer readily able to see beauty and dignity of the person readily.

We have to fight for it now. We have to fight for it now. This is a reality that we cannot just wish away. It's part of our fallen experience. We cover our bodies in a fallen world not because our bodies are bad. That is a lie from hell and it is a heresy known as Manichaeism. Spirit good, body bad. Cover that up. That's foul and dirty and disgusting. No, that is a lie from hell. We do not cover the body because

the body itself is shameful or offensive or dirty or perverse. We cover the body in a fallen world because it is so good, and we feel, or should feel, an instinctive need to protect the goodness of the body from the degradation of lust. What is lust? Lust is the rupture of the body

from the soul. Lust separates the body, turns the body into pieces that a lustful person zooms into certain features of the body for his or her own selfish gratification. But as persons, we are never, never, ever meant to be treated as an object, a thing for someone's selfish gratification. So in this fallen world, again, we have to say it. We cover the body not because

it's bad, but to protect the body's goodness from the degradation of lust. Lust is a reality in this fallen world. We have to protect ourselves from it. It's tragic because every day when we put on clothing, I'm abstracting from the weather here. I know we put on clothing because it gets cold, but let's assume we all lived in around that by the equator and it was warm enough that we didn't need clothing for cold sake. Every day we put clothing on our

bodies. We are telling ourselves my dignity is threatened in this world. People don't know how to see me. People don't know how to honor me. And sending that message to our hearts every day of our lives is very painful. It is a constant reminder that we are not in paradise and we have not arrived at our destiny, but we can go on a pilgrimage here and now with the help of Christ, where we can regain

something of the vision of original innocence, something of it. We can't return to the state of innocence, but I'll just quote the Catechism here. Christ came into the world to restore creation to the purity of its origins, and we live now in the state of what the theologians call. And isn't it funny that even theologians speak of the theologians, right? As if there's some group or, OK, I'm a theologian, so I'm going to call it myself, the state of the already, but not yet of redemption. We are already redeemed.

And those who enter into that already do regain to a significant degree, can regain to a significant degree if they allow themselves to go through what amounts to very painful purifications. They can regain something of that purity of heart that enables us to see the body rightly. But I don't care if your Mother Teresa or John Paul the second, there will still be something of a, a tension there, a battle. It won't simply be with total

ease. In every situation that I see rightly, I can get there, but I, I have to work at it. I have to battle to get there, and every person is worth that battle. Absolutely every person is worth every other person going through the battle to see that person rightly. But the truth of the matter is a lot of people don't take up that battle. A lot of people don't go on that journey and they simply indulge in treating the body as an object and what can end up

happening is not so much an experience of nakedness without shame, but an experience of shameless nakedness. What's the difference between nakedness without shame and shameless nakedness? John Paul the Second spends a lot of time talking about this in his book Love and Responsibility, and he says nakedness without shame is the experience of love where I'm seen and honored rightly.

And I trust that the others gaze will see and honor me, relatively speaking. And I say relatively speaking because we never do it perfectly in this life, but to a large extent we can learn how to see another person rightly. The husband and wife is the most obvious example. Nakedness here can be a genuine experience of nakedness without shame because they are trusting in the gaze of the other to see rightly. It's an obvious example. It's not the only example. Medical examinations could be

another example. I remember a student years ago shared with me an experience as an art student when the model came into the studio and she dropped her robe in front of the students. But then she realized the curtain had not been pulled over the window and she immediately put her robe back on. Why did she do that? It demonstrates that when she dropped her robe for the students, she was trusting their gaze. But when she realized her nakedness was exposed to an

unknown audience whom she didn't know if she could trust, she rightly put the robe back on. Not because her body's bad, but because her body's good and she knows its value, and she doesn't want her nakedness to be exposed to an unknown audience. If she had been behaving shamelessly, if that dropping of a robe for the students had been shameless nakedness, she would have paraded in front of that window without caring at all.

Because shameless nakedness is the experience of a nakedness where I know I'm going to be objectified, but I suppress my desire to protect myself from that because I've just accepted it as the way the world is and it's normalized, right? Pornography would be an example of this. Pornography is a shameless nakedness. These people know that they're posing in pornography, and they do so knowing their bodies are going to be objectified by the

viewer. That's the whole point of pornography. They should manifest a shame, but they behave shamelessly. So I don't want to in any way accuse any anyone in particular here in your life. I don't know your friends. I don't know to whom you're speaking or about whom you're speaking. And it could well be that these more secular friends have some level of a deeper integration than even your religious

friends. That may well be the case. I don't want to dismiss that as a possibility. Religious folk, by and large, we are a peculiar bunch. And very few of us, sadly, are on the road to authentic integration. And we get hung up on all kinds of rules and rigorisms and legalisms and we project our issues onto everybody else and, and, and there can be a lot, a lot of sexual dysfunction among religious folk.

And JP 2 addresses this. He says this is what happens when we confuse Christian purity with Puritanism, right? Purity, As I said earlier in this podcast, purity is the glory of God revealed through the human body, and it's the ability to see that glory revealed through in the human body. Blessed are the pure of heart, for they shall see God. Puritanism is a fearful rejection of the body and sexuality because I don't know

how to deal with my lust. So I just project onto everybody else that you got to you got to be responsible for my lust. Don't dress that way. If you just wouldn't dress that way, I wouldn't be dealing with my struggles. I remember a classic example here of this. A woman once told me this story. A student of mine told me the story that she was at mass one day and at the end of mass this angry man came up to her and said thanks to you, I wasn't able to receive communion today. Oh my goodness. Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, dude, you got issues.

Bless you, I love you, but you got issues. And it is not that woman's fault that you have lust in your heart, even if she may have been dressed in such a way that the average person might say that's not appropriate at Mass. Even if that is the case, we as human beings have a responsibility to learn how to see everyone rightly. And for that man to start blaming that woman for his own lust is totally out of line. And I think our our questioner

is, is feeling some of that from the the so-called religious crowd. But that is a false religiosity that is a that is confusing purity with puritanism and it's very dysfunctional. And I am so sorry you have endured that. At the same time, I would hold out the possibility that some of your more secular friends may. Maybe. I have no way of knowing for sure, and I hope I'm wrong, but it could be the case that they are so immersed in the pornographic culture that

they've been desensitized to the meaning of your breasts. And it may seem that they're not offended by them, but it may be in the direction of a kindless kind of shamelessness rather than a nakedness without shame. And making those distinctions between shameless nudity and nakedness without shame, that demands a very fine toothed comb and a a very nuanced, thoughtful

analysis of of what's going on in your heart, in the hearts of others. And we can't always make that those calls. So again, we live in this broken world and we, we, we need to offer that yearning for purity to be seen rightly. And to see rightly, we need to offer that as a prayer for the redemption of the world. One thing I just think could help our listeners for you to clarify, and I understand how you are using the words nudity and nakedness. There may be some people hearing

this and thinking, well she's not talking about being naked so just explain that a little. Bit I'm so glad you you did, Claire. I'm so glad you are asking me to clarify that 'cause I I'm catching how that language could be misheard. When I say nakedness, I don't assume total nakedness. Obviously I am not assuming this woman walks around totally naked, but but any, any exposure of of flesh is to some extent even semi nakedness.

It's a kind of nakedness, right? There are cultures in the world we know where especially the women cover everything. You can't see one ounce of flesh. That is not healthy. This is not healthy people. This is this is, this is rigorism and legalism to the extreme. And, and it comes. It's not a demonstration of purity. It's a demonstration of the lack thereof, right. The fact that we have to wear clothing in this fallen world at all is a demonstration of our lack of purity.

And we will lack purity in its fullness until the resurrection of the body. I, I would ask this listener please to, to read Love and Responsibility. And if you find it difficult reading John Paul the second directly, I think you could at least go into his chapter. It's it's in the section called The Person in Chastity where he talks about shamelessness versus nakedness without shame. And what is modesty? What is in modesty?

Modesty means not a fearful rejection of the body. Modesty means a a proper balance between veiling and unveiling the body such that we can learn to see one another as persons in this fallen world. And this does not mean dressing in a frumpy way. John Paul the Second says accenting sexual values is inevitable in dress, and it is

not necessarily incompatible with modesty. What is immodest in dress, he says, is that which intentionally seeks to arouse lust in others. Right. When a man or a woman dresses or behaves in such a way as intentionally to arouse lust in another, this is immodest. But even accenting sexual values, John Paul the Second says we must learn the proper

balance between veiling and unveiling our sexual values, because sexual values themselves can and should stir authentic love. And so we have to find that balance where we are veiling enough so that we're not seen as an object, but we're unveiling to a certain extent so as to reveal. That's what unveiling means, to reveal the beauty of our person as a man or woman.

That's not an easy balance, John Paul the Second says. But this task can be carried out, John Paul the Second says, And it is truly worthy of man. I liked your expression, by the way, our questioner. I like the expression. Can we do exposure therapy? And I think there is a yes in my heart to that in a in some way. And I feel like I'm like taking from all that you've shared Christopher and just you said

several times and I think it's so true. We don't know the people she's talking about and there are many different contexts. But to me, if you are encountering a lot of religious people who bring up modesty as a topic and are kind of rule oriented and judgmental about it, then I'm kind of picturing a certain type of person that I feel like does need a little exposure therapy, honestly. And I'm not saying that to it's a good idea to provoke people or

to be disrespectful of the state of their hearts. But in a very, if a person is a woman is at peace with herself and truly desires to present herself in a way that reveals her femininity, that expresses her person. That is not seeking some kind of thrill of knowing you've aroused someone you know, but you're not looking for those kinds of

second looks in kind of a way to boost your ego or something, but just a genuine, I want to be the person God made me to be. I think that my beauty is an important aspect of who I am. I don't want to conceal it. I want it to be a parent because I know that I'm a gift and I want to encounter people and I want others to encounter me. Like all of that is like can be in a good place for a person that has, you know, just a good

sense of yourself worth and respect for others. If you dress according to that, it will probably be exposure therapy for some of your repressed and, you know, legalistic friends and it's probably good. Exposure therapy here is not so much I, I, I don't imagine you're saying like exposing more and more cleavage just to, to, to say, hey, you need to deal with my cleavage. But what's, what needs to be exposed?

And what do we mean by expose? That word can have various connotations. Expose to reveal the beauty of your person. What is needed here is a proper both veiling and unveiling of the person. I'll just say this briefly, but there is a statue in Saint Peter's Basilica that depicts the virtue of chastity. All the Christian virtues are depicted in marble statues at Saint Peter's in the Vatican. And the virtue of chastity is

depicted by a woman who has one breast veiled and the other unveiled. And I I'm not suggesting this is the solution that women walk around with one breast veiled and the other unveiled. But the church is making a point right here in her art that we are called to this proper veiling and unveiling at the same time. It's a both. And we reveal enough we and if that's what you mean by expose, I agree.

We we reveal enough to so that the beauty of the person can inspire love. We veil enough to to to protect ourselves from being treated as sexual objects, veiling unveiling. Here's an example of, of, if we're going to use that phrase, exposure therapy. Here's an example that I think is fitting the Sistine Chapel right. If you have difficulty going into the Sistine Chapel because there's nude art there, OK,

don't blame Michelangelo, right? Michelangelo painted those nudes with with an integral intention to reveal through the human body the glory and mystery of God. And so Saint John Paul the second dedicated the restored Sistine Chapel and as as a sanctuary of the theology of the human body, right. And he said Michelangelo allowed himself to be guided as an artist by those evocative words from the book of Genesis. The man and his wife were both naked and felt no shame.

That's beautiful. That's beautiful. This is, this is exposure therapy to the beauty of the body that could serve us well. That could serve us very, very well. Exposure therapy couldn't, couldn't, would not serve us well. If we're thinking that means, you know, looking at some pornographic movie or something, No, no, no, no, no. Because that is just pushing us in the direction of lust. But in exposure of the integral beauty and dignity of the person, yes. And I just want to say we both

had an opportunity in this answering this question to kind of clarify for the listeners the meanings of words. And I'll just say like my understanding when she said exposure therapy, I was thinking of like treatment for anxiety disorders and obsessive compulsive disorder where a person who's very fearful of something voluntarily goes into that place in order to like not remain so anxious or obsessive or something. So I was using it that way.

But you are right in realizing our listeners might hear it, you know, like, hey, expose everything to these people. That's. Isn't it painful when you realize words mean different things to different people and you have to make sure that you're on the same page as to what the words mean? And we're not communicating. So we hope, we hope that we have helped in in using our words. That's right, in such a way that we have communicated what we intended to communicate. And Lord, please dot our IS

cross our T's here if anything is left dangling. Yeah, in the words of the prophet Forrest Gump. That's all I have to say about that. That's. All I have to say about that for now, until the next episode when we'll have much more to say about many other things, but keep the questions coming. Brothers and sisters, we're so glad that you trust these questions to us. We hope the answers we provide shine some light in your life. And if you've been blessed by what you've heard today, could you please push that share

button and share this episode with somebody else who could also maybe use a little light in their lives? We sure do appreciate you helping us to grow our podcast family around the world. Until next time. Remember. You are a gift. Become what you are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body

Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counsellors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode