Questions answered this episode: When JPII talks about using another person as a means to an end I always imagine a couple but what happens in the case of a single person who seeks to give pleasure to him or herself? Is the person using him or herself? To what extend does that affect the person or others? Why does this sin leaves a feeling of loneliness? How do I make steps to open those places to the Lord and to know that Heโs not repulsed by what will come out and not ashamed of me because of my porn & masturbation addiction? What does TOB have to say about arranged marriages? Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul IIโs beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. ๐ฅ Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body ๐ Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) โก๏ธ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: Our Lady of Divine Graces COURSE SCHEDULE ๐ฅ Check out our YouTube Channel ๐ View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! ๐ GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. ๐๏ธ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here ๐ For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. So when do you know that we recently returned? You weren't there, but I say we as in the team of the TOB Institute, we returned recently, last month, September, from our pilgrimage in Italy. And I just wanted to share a really special highlight from that pilgrimage. We were in San Giovanni, San
Giovano, San Gio. I always get these names. San Giovanni Rotundo sounds right. I think I got it right, which I think means Fat Saint John. OK, that's fine. I don't know why you name a city fat Saint John, but anyway, rotund St. John. And this is where Padre Pio is buried. And what was a a beautiful surprise to me, I'd never been there before, was discovering Padre Pio's favorite work of sacred art, which you see Prince
of all around town. It's called Our Lady of Divine Graces, and it's an image Right before you go in to see Padre Pio's tomb, there's this large icon again. It was Padre Pio's favorite image of sacred art. And for those who don't understand the theology behind it, you'd might be shocked, stunned, scandalized by it. But there is the Christ child sitting on Mary's lap and he's
squeezing her breasts and her breasts are exposed. And there's the Christ child squeezing her, her breasts. And what is this an image of? He's saying this is where the graces flow your your spiritual mother's spiritual milk. This is the grace that comes through the church. What is the final act of Christ on the cross? He says, behold your mother, behold your Mama.
The very word Mama comes from breast Mama, mammary gland, right? That's what we get in English from that Latin for breast Mama. The the most tender name for our mother is breast, breast. And in our culture that is so perverse in its approach to the female body, this image of Our Lady of divine graces where the Christ child is saying, come to your Mama, drink of these graces.
And it's it's an image right out of of the scripture, Isaiah 66, where heaven is described as where we will all drink from the abundant breast of the New Jerusalem and find comfort in the overflow of her milk. The churches are mother, the churches are Mama, and the graces of Christ that flow through the church to us. The fitting image that the church has used in her sacred art is the breastfeeding mother. So that was really beautiful to me. It's an image I'll take with me for a long time.
I, I, I have, I took a picture of that icon right before Padre Pio's tomb. And I'm going to use it now in my, my courses and lectures. And we'll have a, a link to it in the show notes here, just so you can pray with it yourself. And I'll see if I can also insert the actual picture I took and a picture of Padre Pio paying devotion to this beautiful icon. Yeah, it is such a gift to to go to these places that that, you know, we get busy with our
modern lives and don't pause and that seeing something like that is an arresting. It's a. It's a good word. Something that makes you stop and ask, what is this saying? And I just think that's so profound in it. It can affect us in a very deep place and it can expose our woundedness and our need for healing and, and and restoration of innocence to see the beauty
in God's plan and and how seeing that beauty can restore something inside us that needs to be restored. Yeah, We have so many diseased images of the human body and our minds and our hearts from this pornographic culture. And the way we overcome evil is with good. The way we overcome unholy images of the body are with holy images of the body. And it is, it's a resting and it's a call to conversion and deep inner transformation.
So Lord, let it be in Saint Padre Pio, pray for us that we would learn how to bring our thirst in the right way, in the most sacred, holy way, to those graces that flow through our Mama, our Mama. Thank you for sharing that from the pilgrimage and I'm so grateful to the Lord. I always pray when you are leaving on a pilgrimage. I know you have a lot to offer to the pilgrims, but I, I'm
always praying as your wife for what the Lord has, particularly for you. And I believe that was for you. I know you're sharing it with our listeners and you've shared it with our family, but it was also a gift for your heart and I'm so grateful for. That and a shout out to all the pilgrims who who came. We had about 60 people crammed on a bus traveling all over Italy. It was it was a beautiful experience. Yes. Do you have any updates for us about the Toby Institute? Yes, we have some courses on the
horizon that people need to know about. We, we always have online courses. Every month we offer an online course. So check those out in the link below in the show notes. But I want to give a shout out for the live courses. We have one in November that I'm teaching with Jeanette Clark on John Paul the Second's book Love and Responsibility. This is the philosophical foundation of his theology of the body and it it really takes us on an in depth exploration of
what is the human person? What is the difference between a person and an animal? And what is this push in the modern world to equate human beings with animals? Really in the final analysis, this equation of of, you know, chickens are people too. We're just animals. It's it's really an attempt to justify behaving like animals sexually. Well, where does that get us? I'd say 60 to 70 years of the sexual revolution has demonstrated is not taking us to a good place.
John Paul the second wrote this right at the beginning of the sexual revolution in the late 1950s, early 1960s. And you will see how prophetic he was in understanding what was going to befall humanity and what the solution was. This book, Love and Responsibility, will go down in history as an absolute masterpiece, and if you haven't been exposed to it, or you've tried to read it yourself and found it too difficult, please, please come to the Love and Responsibility course in November.
That's actually very appropriate to our first question. So I'm excited to share this with you. This is from a patron named Deborah. Hi, Deborah. Hi Christopher and Wendy, I've just taken the Love and Responsibility online course. Well, what do you know? Right, which has really helped me a lot and I pray that God will give me the grace to discover the true value and dignity of the person, including myself. When John Potoo speaks of using another person as a means to an end, I always imagine a couple.
But what happens in the case of a single person who seeks to give pleasure to him or herself? Is the person using him or herself? Does it mean that the person is not capable of loving him or herself? To what extent does that affect the person or even others? From experience, I know that this sin leaves a feeling of loneliness, but I would like to know more deeply why and why we always fall back into it. Thank you.
Bless you, Deborah, for your honesty and just forthrightness and putting this question out. I, I want to begin with this idea of, of using and, and yes, there is in John Paul's love and responsibility, this particular sense in using where you're using someone else for your own pleasure. But when we fall into masturbation, we are training ourselves in our psychosexual development, in our psychosexual
being. And psychosexual I mean the link between our soul and our sexuality, psychosole, sexual, our our whole process of arousal, which is a spiritual and a physical reality. Masturbation trains us in an attitude and a disposition of pleasing myself because that's precisely what it is. It's it's self pleasuring, pleasing myself. And I know because I trained
myself in that way as a teenager. I fell into the habit of masturbation as a young teenager and it it followed me. It was part of my teenage experience. I became addicted to this habit. I felt I needed sexual release on a daily basis, like I needed three meals a day. And I forgive me if that's TMI for people, but I'm just trying to be honest and real about what people really go through. This is a very common experience
for men and for women, and it trained me to pursue my own pleasure. And so I brought that same mentality of masturbatory self pleasure. I brought that same mentality with me into my relationships with young women and sexual activity in my mind and in my attitudes. As I understood it was really just, OK, now I'm, I'm just masturbating, but I'm using
somebody else's body to do the same thing that I do when I do this myself. And again, forgive me if that's TMI, but again, I'm, I'm trying to be honest. I'm trying to be real. I'm trying to expose to the light what happens and why. Understanding the Church's vision and teaching here is so, so important when when someone enters marriage. Let's just take the typical pattern here. We're raised in a pornographic culture. We get exposed to pornography at
a young age. What is the purpose of pornography? Pornography exists for one reason, as fodder for masturbation. Really. That's at least in the male psyche. I can't speak directly to the female experience, but in the male psyche, pornography has one goal, to be masturbatory fodder. Fodder for masturbation please myself at the expense of this person. I I get stimulated by this image. I please myself. If that starts happening in a young age and our whole psychosexual development is
conditioned by that, and then we start getting sexually active in our teen years and then our 20s, maybe we're thinking maybe I'll get married. And then I get married after I've had sexual relations with any number of people. And if there has not been a major stop, a major pause, a major conversion, a major about face, a major reorganizing reorientation of my inner life in its psychosexual development, where I come to discover that erotic desire is not about
pleasing myself. It's about becoming a gift to another and becoming a gift that could also lead to new life and the call to sacrifice my flesh and my blood and my life for my spouse and my offspring. If there is not a major conversion there, I'm just going to bring that masturbatory attitude right with me into my marital relationship and I'm going to use my spouse for my own pleasure because that's all I've known psychosexual reality to be.
OK, that was a lot that I just threw out there, but that's the reality of it. The good news, the good news is that there is a path of conversion. There is a way we can be reoriented, redirected in our disposition, in our attitudes, in our psychosexual experiences, such that we can come to experience sexual desire as the power to love divinely, to love divinely. John Paul the Second says in Love and Responsibility.
His goal is to demonstrate the path by which sexual love can fulfill the law of the gospel. Love one another as I have loved you. How did Christ love us? This is my body given for you. Masturbation, if I may say so frankly, is the antithesis, informing us in the exact opposite direction of this is my body given up for you? No hope is lost. No one has sunk so deep that
they can never be saved, that they can never be converted, that they can never be healed. But we, we must listen. Listen to the cry of the heart. And Deborah, that cry of your heart, which you've expressed to your very honestly of loneliness, that cry of your heart of, of something isn't right here. Listen to that, Deborah. That is the Spirit blowing in your heart. That is the Holy Spirit inviting you up and out of yourself to
learn the way of becoming a gift to another. And marriage is not the only way to live this gift. In fact, it's not even the ultimate way of living this gift. The ultimate way of living the gift of our sexuality is to become a gift unto God. Think about this. Christianity begins when a young woman who's right at the age of all the temptations of the
world, saying please yourself, please yourself, please yourself, right? What was Mary? Mary was 141516 maybe when the Angel appeared. And I love what St. Ildophonzus of Toledo says. I don't know who that St. is, but I love what he says here. He says when the Angel came to Mary, he evangelized her by showing her the meaning of her ache that that ache that and,
and I'll name it what it is. It's Eros. It's the cry of Eros. It's the cry of her feminine heart to be bride and mother. The Angel came to Mary and said this is where you are to, to direct that yearning. Now Mary, of course, was immaculately conceived. She didn't experience concupiscence. She didn't experience errant sexual desire like we do. But she did have to freely open and offer her sexuality.
And by that I mean her being as a woman, her whole being as a woman. Christianity begins when one young woman at that tender age of feeling these yearnings and, and wondering what, what is this power in me? What am I to do with it? An Angel shows up in her life and says, open that to God, open that to the living God. Open all that you are as a woman, open that yearning to be bride and mother. Open it, open it, open it to the living God and the Holy Spirit will come upon you and you will
bear the Son of the living God. Christianity begins with the woman learning how to open all that she is as a woman, her being as a woman, her sexuality as a woman, her arrows, her longing for love, for union, to be bride and mother. She learned to open that longing of, of, of loneliness, that the cry where I'm lonely, I want to be, I want to experience communion. She opened it to the living God. She opened it to the living God. This is the pattern of what
Christianity is learning to open our entire humanity, body and soul. Learning to open our psychosexuality, the the the soul and body reality of being a man or a woman. That's what I mean by psychosexuality, the body, soul, reality of being a man or woman. Learning how to open that to the living God. That is the pattern of what it means to be a Christian. And that is the way up and out, dear Deborah, of that loneliness. That's beautiful.
I, I have just a little quick reflection to share the part where she says to what extent does that habit affect the person or even others? I think actually that she's asking to what extent does that using affect the person and others. And I, I just want to share a thought here that that we are all engaged in a, in a battle and many people are ignoring the battle and letting the forces
opposed to God's plan just have sway in their lives. And one of the ways I see this is that God has given us beautiful instincts and desires as you talked about Mary's ache. Like that's a beautiful instinct that the world mocks. Yes, and there is a thing that can happen in US in any person who is taking something a beautiful gift of God and
cheapening it and minimizing it and just renaming it something else. So it's just a physical reality it as if it has no meaning beyond some sort of just simple, almost funny physical experience. I don't know this the mocking spirits in the world toward what is true and beautiful that is devastating to our hearts.
And sometimes that devastation has come to us so early we don't even realize it, that we've been told that our deep and profound instincts are actually laughable and foolish or dark or all these other messages about something that is profoundly beautiful. So that is a dark influence on a person's own life, and their instincts to give of themselves are affected by that.
And they sometimes it is part of what causes someone to be cynical about others and to stomp on other people's dreams. Because they've already been stomping on their own dreams. So I just think it's a profoundly spiritual reality. And I don't want to say this as if any person who's currently struggling against this somehow should feel doomed or ashamed or like somehow you are not lovable.
That is the opposite of what I want to say. Yes, you are capable of receiving God's love and mercy, and you are capable of honoring your own body and your own heart because of God's grace and mercy and learning. What are the things that are cross a boundary for you and how can you avoid those things? And how can you seek what is true and good and beautiful and Orient your heart toward those things? It is so possible, so beautiful.
There is hope for every human heart. So that's what I most want to say. Wendy, you are putting your finger right on it. And it reminds me of what JP 2 says, that in this realm of sexual desire and yearning, we are in a battle. We are at the heart of the battle, he says, between good and evil. Yes. And we've been taught by our culture. Well, it's just an I'm, I'm reminded of something Wilhelm Reich said in 1936 in a book called The Sexual Revolution,
where he said the goal of the sexual revolution is to rid people of the idea that these stirrings in the body are a yearning for God. No, that he says they are bioelectrical impulses that just demand release. Oh, my word, is this not the world we live in now? No, Deborah, that yearning you're feeling in your body at its deepest place. It is a yearning for the living God. And when you feel that temptation to just I just need to release it by masturbating
right then right there, right in that place, cry out to the Blessed Mother, say, Mary, show me. Show me what the Angel showed you. Show me how to open my ache to the living God. She will, she will stay in the ache without trying to satisfy it yourself. This is how we become a longing for God. Stay in the ache. Do not take satisfaction of that ache into your own hands.
Learn how to endure that ache. Open to the living God wherever it may take you. Stay open to the living God. Come, Holy Spirit, come Holy Spirit. Redirect my desire. Redirect the orientation, my yearning, redirect the stirrings in my body to something sacred, holy, and beautiful. This is a cry of your heart for conversion. And the living God who loves you will hear the cry of your heart. Be not afraid to pour out your
heart to the living God. That's the psalmist, right? I pour out my heart to the living God. Pour it out. Pour it out, Deborah, He will hear you. Next question is from a listener named Megan. Hello, Megan. I'm a 24 year old Catholic and as I'm writing this question I'm 4 1/2 months free from porn and masturbation, which I was addicted to for eight years. Glory be to God, Glory be to God. This podcast, your videos, and your books have been a real lifeline for me on my journey to
freedom. I've been working on taking what I'm learning from theology of the body into my heart, but I'm sometimes hesitant because I know all the sludge from my addiction and my sins will come out. I'm tempted to keep the algae of the body in my head so you don't have to open those painful places I've kept hidden. My question is, how do I make steps to open those places to the Lord and to know that He's not repulsed by what will come out and not ashamed of me because of my porn and masturbation addiction? Any advice you have would be
greatly appreciated. Thank you for the gift of this podcast. Megan, bless you, bless you, bless you. I just want to praise God for the work of grace in your life, Megan, and for your heart that has been open to that work of grace, Megan. And I know, I know, I know from my own journey, it can be so scary to go to those places. And I, I want to share an experience I just recently had in my, my own prayer life that
was really, really scary because I was stumbling on a deep, deep pocket of nastiness in my heart from my broken life. And the image that came to me was like, I am just in a puddle of my own diarrhea and nobody wants to be near me. Nobody wants to be around me. I'm foul, I'm disgusting. I'm I'm just riddled with shame and ugliness.
How could I possibly, how could I possibly be lovable here? And I, I'm bringing this to my spiritual director. And he said, he said, Christopher to stay, stay right there in that puddle of diarrhea, right in it and say, Jesus, where are you? Jesus, where are you? So this was this was my experience. I'm in a place of prayer and I'm just sitting in that puddle of my diarrhea, not fun. And Jesus shows up and he
doesn't hold his nose. He doesn't keep his distance. He's coming closer and closer and closer, and to my utter astonishment, he sits down with me in the puddle of diarrhea and I'm like no Lord, no Lord, no Lord, no Lord, I don't want my diarrhea on you, Lord, no, Lord, no. He's like Christopher, unless you let me be with you in your
mess, in all the mess of your life, you have no part of me. This is why I came. This is why I came to be with you here, to take on your own mess, your own, the foundness of your own sinfulness, to take it on myself, to be with you here and to show you the way out and to show you that you are loved right here. And, and it's as if I don't know how to really put it in words, but Jesus and I became one
sitting in that puddle of diarrhea. And then the love of the Father showed up and Jesus was rejoicing even in that puddle of diarrhea. He was rejoicing. Why? Because of the love of the Father Jesus became this was a lived experience in that imagery. It was a lived experience for me of what it means that scripture says Jesus who knew no sin became sin and offered it all to
the Father to be redeemed. And it became an experience of learning the hard Rd. of knowing I'm loved in my SHIT, knowing I'm loved right there, knowing Jesus is with me right there. And we can open all together to the Father. And the Father does not hold his nose. The Father does not turn away. The Father absorbs it all to redeem it all. The resurrection is the proof
that when Jesus bore in his body all the sin and shame and foulness of humanity, that the Father did not reject him. The resurrection is proof of that, and he does not reject us. Our sin belongs to Jesus. That's what the redemption tells us. He became our sin. Our sin belongs to Jesus. It's not yours anymore, Megan. All of that shame, all of that sin, all that you did, it is not yours. It is Jesus's. Give Jesus the privilege of letting him take it and offering
it to the Father so that you can be transformed. This is the gift of redemption. This is the gift of His love, that while we were still in all of our SHIT, in that foul puddle of diarrhea, He loved us there. He loved us there. This is the proof of His love, that He loved us in our sinfulness. We have to let them love us there. And I know, I know how treacherous a journey that is. I know how scary a journey that is. We have this idea that we got to get our SHIT together to be lovable.
It's a lie from hell. The journey is opening our SHIT to the merciful love of our Savior and our Father and the Holy Spirit and our Blessed Mother. Let Mary change your diaper. Let Mary come right into it. She comes with love and tenderness. And where does all the SHIT get when we have a blowout diaper? It gets in all the crevices of our tender places down there.
And Mary, like any loving mother, goes right in with a warm wet wipe and just spreads those little folds, those tender folds of skin, and cleans out all the butterscotch pudding, gets it all out with love and tenderness. And she'll sing a little song to you, She'll tickle you, She'll spread. Once you're all cleaned up, she'll spread a little sprinkle of powder on there and she'll smile and make you smile and you'll be be like, ha ha, ha, ha, ha, delight light. These are images of the spirit,
right? This is also called theology of the body. Our body and all the realities of our body reveal these deep, profound spiritual mysteries. Be not afraid. You're loved right there, Megan. You're loved right there. Praying for you, my dear sister. I know it's a hard journey. Please pray for me too because I'm still on it. Megan, just a thought from me and I, I so appreciate your honesty, Christopher, sharing about different very important prayer experiences that are
healing stories for you and helps to others to experience their own journey in, in prayer and revisiting their their sense of themselves I think is a big part of this. Yeah, that's my goal. I just want to clarify that, Wendy, if I may, that that's that the goal in sharing a story from my own prayer life is not to draw attention to me, but to prime your pump in, in what a similar experience might be, what it might look like. It might look something like
that. And if that imagery is coming to you when you're in a place of quiet and prayer, don't shut it out because it might be foul and disgusting, like the Lord might be bringing it to your heart to show you that He loves us in our foulness and what we find disgusting, He. He already sees us through the lens of what He did for us, which is redemption. Megan, I just want to add there's there's a a complex story in our every human heart
because we we may not know all the forces that have been at work in yeah, in the ways that we've acted or the thoughts that we've held onto that the patterns in our lives. The forces are many and and there are they're dark forces, as we were talking about in the last question that are after us and in the process of looking at the sludge that yes, there's a
looking at your own sin, but there's also the Lord shining light on the ways that the evil one has been after you and his the power of his suffering to set us free from the evil 1. So I, I want you to know that letting things out isn't about just kind of feeling pain and shame. It's also about experiencing a new vision, a new sense of
really how loved you are. And when they preach it. When they preach it. And how it pains the Lord's heart that the evil one has come after you. And I will just say this as well, that the Lord also for real loves and died on the cross for every person involved in the pornography industry. So as as awful as that whole industry is it there are people and they're human beings that
Christ died for, died for their sins. And so as you would revisit things and this should be led by the Spirit. And I think what you're asking for is, is the courage and some of the steps to go about that. But as the Spirit leads, there is also a part of you that needs to pray for the people whose images have been part of that story for you and for the Lord's mercy to extend to them. And, and a suggestion I have for you that has been a help to me
is to go to a church with some beautiful stations of the cross that speak to your heart and pray through those stations, seeing not just the Lord being condemned to die or forced to carry a cross, but yourself in that story because the Lord came to enter into our story. And every step along the stations can be reflected in our journey as well, or it can be reflected in the lives of people we know, people we have wounded
or people we've been wounded by. So it can be so fruitful to take time apart and look at that. And it, it's so grace filled because every step of the stations of the cross, we know our steps of salvation of grace entering into the human story. So I just want to encourage you to consider that as a as a way to address some of these painful parts of your story. Powerful. Wendy. I just felt such grace flowing through your words there.
Yeah. When, Megan, were you condemned to death? That's the first station of the cross. When did you take your cross? When did you fall under its weight? When did you encounter the Blessed Mother on the journey? When were you stripped? When were you nailed? When, when did you die? When were you placed in the tomb? When were you raised? Who came along your side and wiped your face in a in a moment where you needed consolation, walking through the stations of the cross as Jesus. That Jesus is one with you and
you are one with Him as Wendy's saying can be so so liberating and healing. We we hope you find that that helpful and we're so grateful for your honesty and asking this very delicate and and tender question. Jesus, we lift up to you all the people in the pornography industry. They do not know who they are. They are under the sway of the enemy and you came to crush the head of the enemy to undo the work of the devil. Jesus, may it be done, and may the triumph of Mary's Immaculate
womanhood be revealed to all the world and cast out all those pornographic spirits that mock and and degrade the beauty and glory of the human body as male and female. We ask this in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Yes, Amen. Our next question is from a listener named Christopher. Well, hello Christopher, good name. Christopher says my parents, among others in my family, have had arranged marriages as they
are prevalent in our culture. What, if anything, does theology the body have to say about arranged marriages? On one hand, I can see the fruit of less divorce from prioritizing the commitment over the feelings. But on the other hand, I can't help but wonder if it's settling for less than what God has planned. Christopher, thank you. Thank you for sharing this question. And Wendy, I know you have something to speak into this because of your own experience in college with somebody who who wanted to marry you.
May I don't know if you feel like sharing that when it's when you're up. But yeah, I do want to speak into this because it can be puzzling and it it shows. I'm so glad Christopher as to say shows we really have a global audience here. This is a very uncommon experience, practically non existence in non existent in America and much of the western world. But I wonder he might be from India somewhere in the east where this is still a common practice. Even in Catholic cultures of of the east this can be still a
common practice. The church allows it so long as the couple getting married freely, freely accept the choice of their parents. It has to be their freedom. It can't be, in the final analysis, the choice of the parents. It would have to be we as the couple getting married have freely, freely accepted the choice of our parents as our own choice.
If freedom is not there in the couple getting married to marry each other, then it's not a valid marriage. If they are there only because their parents forced them into this arrangement and they don't want it and they don't trust their parents and they wish they could have made a totally different decision. And I'm only here because my culture is forcing me to be here. And this is the custom of my culture. But I hate it. And inside I'm rebelling against it. I don't want this to happen. That's not a valid marriage, but it is possible to have a culture
of familial relationships from generation to generation, where the family is healthy, where the culture is beautiful and the love is trusted and the wisdom of the previous generation is trusted as what is good for me. That's hard to imagine in a lot of the world, but it's not impossible, and nobody's perfect. There's no perfect culture where all this works out just perfectly, but it is possible for a couple to give a free choice to their parents, choice
for their spouse. So it's possible. But yeah, the freedom is the key to all of it. So is it settling for less than God has planned? Not if one's freedom is truly engaged. Now you asked what does theology, the body have to say about this? And I, I just want to throw out a, a general clarification here. John Paul the second at the end
of his catechesis called theology the body says I've given you a foundation. Now go apply this. Go apply this. So does he say anything directly about arranged marriages in the theology, the body itself? No. Does he give us the foundation for understanding how to answer this question? Yes. So I'm not quoting directly from JP 2, but I'm taking all the principles I've learned from his teaching. And at the core of all of it is love is not love if it doesn't come from freedom, right? Freedom is the means, and love is the end if love.
If the end of love doesn't come from freedom, it's not love. So the way Western culture has developed, it would be a it would be largely in our current culture here in America. I'll just speak for my culture, for my parents to have said, I want you to marry XI, want you to marry this person. It would it would be a hard pressed in our culture, the way it's arranged, the way it just works for for for me to say in that circumstance freely, yes, that's what I want to do too.
It would if it's an imposition, if it robs of freedom. It doesn't. It's not in accord with what God desires for us. In the Western expression of the way we understand freedom, We've gone to another extreme right and and that's a problem too. But the key is to to live an authentic gift of self, to live from a place of authentic freedom in giving my life to another. That's where love originates. It's possible in an arranged
marriage for that freedom to be present. It's possible for it not to be present. It's also possible, as we know well in the Western world, just because your parents weren't involved in making the decision doesn't mean you're making a free decision. Could be all kinds of influences, including certain addictive things, pressures that are put on us that that come from sexual addictions or what have you, psychological maladies that that compromise our freedom. But again, the bottom line is, does it come from freedom? It is such a powerful thing to reflect upon.
And I can appreciate for Christopher himself, he has his own life flowed from an arranged man. Yeah, how about that, you know? So what a thing to reflect on and say, OK, Lord, my story is so connected to this. I wouldn't exist if it weren't for this. Nor would my parents, nor grandparents were great. All the whole way back. So that's, it's a, it's a place of very personal reflection. And, and I, I see what he's kind
of looking at as far as well. There's a stability. I didn't use that word, but he said the, the prioritizing of the commitment. And so there's a stability in a culture that that trusts the wisdom of the elders that just has a certain less self focused receptivity to that process that that has given a certain stability to families.
And I think that's a powerful testimony. And yet, you know, Christopher himself is asking is, is that what does God think of that? And you know what we'll find out on the other side. We'll have our theories, but the Lord will, will make things more clear to us. And, and that's a beautiful question. I, I really am grateful for him sharing his heart in this way. And I mean, just the experience you were mentioning is that I did have a friend in college who was from India who.
Committed Catholic. Yes, absolutely. Family all, all. Yeah. Had actually lived in a religious community for a time before coming to the United States in in India. He had who you and I recently spent recently, might have been two years ago now, but spent some time with him and his wife. They did have an arranged marriage and it just happened that we had reason to go to a wedding in the town where they live. And so they opened their home to us and it was a beautiful experience for us.
Thanks shout out to Sebastian and Sheila. Thank you for welcoming us and sharing your story and your home and your culture with us. And I remember his wife specifically just wanting me to know he, she texted me after our visit about this. She said, you know, our love wasn't present at the beginning. It grew over the time of our marriage, but it's a real love. And I, I, I could tell that she felt like, just to reemphasize, like she's experienced a
different gift than many people in this country have experienced, but it's, it's one to honor. And I thought that was just a beautiful testimony. And can't every couple say something similar? Yes right, that's true that love matures and grows over time. I love this line from JP two. He says love never is. It is always only just becoming. It is always only just becoming. Lord, we thank you for the ways that you are at work in all of
our lives, teaching us how love becomes what it is and it becomes what it is by learning to be a gift. You, Lord, have made each of us a gift. And you, in your generosity, you give us the grace. To become what we are. Thank you, Lord. Thank you, Lord. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike
Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
๐๏ธ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! Signup for Ascensionโs Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
๐๏ธ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! Signup for Ascensionโs Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
๐๏ธ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! Signup for Ascensionโs Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascensionโs Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...