Questions answered this episode: How does Theology of the Body relate to the apophatic tradition of imageless, silent prayer? If we're meant to go beyond concepts and detach even from meditation, how can a theology so rooted in the body inform contemplative prayer? Though I'm happily married, I still feel haunted by a deep emotional bond with a female friend from my past. Why does this longing persist, and how can I find freedom from it? My husband has been sober from porn for 8 years, but his heart remains closed off. After nearly 39 years of marriage, where can we find the outside help and healing we still need? Resources: JPII Legacy Foundation Website Freedom Coaching Hope’s Garden Marriage Missionaries The Alexander House
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Well, hey everybody. Hello listeners. Welcome to another episode. It's your turn to say something, Wendy. Yes. I paused and I was, I thought you were going to like join in with her. You did say hi to everybody, but then I said something else and I
thought you were going to like say keep it going, keep it going. And you just had that look on your. Face like OK, what's? Next. Well, here's what's next, and you don't know it, and I do. That's probably why I had that look. Looking at a picture of us sitting on my desk, which I've had on my desk for years and years, because it's very old picture. You and I are in our 20s. That's a long time ago, like 30 years ago. And when I look at this picture, I think, gosh, Wendy looks so young.
But I don't think, gosh, I look so young because somewhere in my brain I still think I look. It's not. You haven't changed just that. Yeah, it's you're right. It's like that's I know this is not true. I'm certain if if people looked at this picture, you probably a lot of people wouldn't even recognize me. Like I'm so young. I look like a kid. We were newly married and I look like a kid.
I think this is was this picture here? I'm not going to show it to Wendy. Was this picture taken in Saint Louis on her way to Colorado? Oh my God, am I right about that? Like circa 1997, I think it was. Wow. Oh, you would have been no. I'm not pregnant. No, you're not. I now what people are wondering why I said Burgannon aunt, it's normal to you. There is some, there was some video that our kid showed us
years ago of some guy reading what was he reading like real emails that this doctor's office had gotten or something about misspelling pregnant and people asking am I pregananant? Yeah, you would have been pregananant, which you're not here. So I don't know when that was taken or where we even are. But anyway, we're really young and if people saw this picture, they probably wouldn't. They would recognize you, and they probably wouldn't recognize me. That's true.
We do both look very different today. We saw someone in your hometown whom you knew as a little kid, and you were marveling to see him. Not that you've never seen him since then, but you were. Your brain was comparing him now to the child version. I knew him since I was four years old and we ran into him and I thought, Oh my gosh, am I that old? Like he and I are the same age. I was like, do I look that?
Do I look that old? And I said he doesn't look old. And you said, well, if you knew him when you said you were four years old, you would think, anyway, here we are all. Right, moving right along. Give me an announcement, I mean a promotion, something going on with the TOB. M OK, as soon as you said that, this is what came to my mind. OK, go ahead. When I was at camp as a kid, Camp Shand in Carlisle, PA, Sure this is what they would say when it was time for announcements. What announcements?
Announcements. Announcements. A terrible death to die. A terrible death to die. Something like that. Anyway, I hope this is not a terrible death to die. This is what came to my brain. Weird things come to my brain. If our listeners only knew how many things that come to my brain that I don't share, you would know. I'm very disciplined. But that one slipped out. OK, here we go. Yes, I want to share something we are hoping and praying for. We have been invited to Romania to give some talks on theology
of the body, to begin injecting the culture there with with more theology of the body that. Is super exciting. It is exciting. Wow. There's a, a group of people there who have been studying JP 2 and studying my work, translating JP 2 into more common language. They're very excited to bring us over there and they can't afford just the plane tickets even they're, you know, they have a little bit of money, but it's, it's, it's not a lot. And it's a poor country.
And we, we really want to go. And we are asking those who believe in what we're doing, believe in our missionary efforts to support us, to help us raise the money to get us to Romania. So if you want to see this message spread around the world, it's a very concrete, practical thing you can do. Click the link on the Saint John Paul the Second Legacy Foundation. This is why the foundation exists to help fund projects to spread theology of the body around the world for people who
can't afford it, to fund our scholarships for people who want to take our courses and can't afford it, and all kinds of other worthy endeavors we want to sponsor eventually. We have so many graduates of the TOB Institute who are on fire to spread TOB, and we want to. We want to say, OK, here's your salary, go do it, and here's the structure. We've learned so much over the 30 years we've been doing it. Here's here's how we're going to set you up to spread theology of the body in your country. We have a guy in Europe right now who's doing such good work and he really wants to to make
it as full time missionary work. And we said, we said we would hire you and we would fund you if we had it. So we're praying for funding for projects like this to fund missionaries, to fund our own missionary trips. This is why we set up the Saint John Paul the Second Legacy Foundation. If you want to fund Romania, specifically our our missionary trip to Romania, just make a note when you donate that you want that to go to Romania. If you want it to go to scholarships, you can make a note for that. If you want it to go to fund
other missionaries, you can make a note of that. We are, we are in need of the support of those who believe in what we're doing so that we can continue to do what we're doing. Very exciting. It is. It is. It is. Are you ready for a question from a patron? I am ready. Let's do it. This is from a patron named Andrew. Andrew, thank you so much for your support to our work. We're so grateful. Hope you're taking advantage of the benefits we offer our patrons. This question is a little bit long, but I think it's worth it.
All right, let's hear it. Andrew says Hello Christopher and Wendy, thank you for all that you do. To quantify just how much you have done for me and my spiritual and healing journeys would be hard to do. Just know that I am eternally grateful. Oh, that is a blessing to hear. I ask my question today in a spirit of faith seeking understanding, not with a hermeneutic of suspicion. Good, good point. I'm glad you said that. My question today is about prayer. I'm curious to know what the
relationship is between the theology of the body and the Christian contemplative tradition. Specifically, the contemplative tradition emphasizing silent, imageless prayer. This tradition is sometimes referred to as the apophatic. Tradition the apophatic versus the cataphatic for the. Does he mention cataphatic as well? Let me just keep reading, OK? I'm. Sorry to interrupt. OK, also known as the Via Negativa as it emphasizes the
will and intellect's inability to fully grasp the transcendent God. If Christian spirituality is always incarnational, how can we make sense of the long and storied tradition of non conceptual or better super conceptual prayer that seeks to annihilate our soul's capacities in order to remain in God's presence and experience Him beyond the media of words, thoughts and images?
I ask this because Saint Jean Paul 2 was greatly influenced by Saint John of the Cross and I'm struggling to find the bridge between these two towering figures in the churches spiritual tradition. How do we get something like JP 2 Theology of the Body from Saint John of the Cross, when John of the Cross says in a spiritual canticle things like a person should not bear attachment to anything, neither to the practice of meditation, nor to any savour, whether sensory or spiritual, nor to any other apprehensions. Individuals should be very free and annihilated regarding all
things, because any thought or discursive reflection or satisfaction on which they might want to lean would impede and disquiet them and make noise in the profound silence of their senses and their spirit which they possess. For the sake of this deep and delicate listening, is the simple answer just that the body is a sign of the invisible, and we are meant to pass through the visible to the invisible? If so, doesn't this make the body a handmade to the spiritual and therefore lower in the hierarchy?
At the end of the day, theory aside, what I'm most interested in knowing is this. How should theology of the body impact my prayer life? If I'm drawn towards silent prayer, how can I incorporate the truth of theology of the body into that spiritual practice? Andrew, you are a thinker, my brother. This is one of my favorite questions that we have ever received on this podcast. And I'm glad you are wrestling with these questions 'cause I have wrestled with this very
question for decades and keep wrestling. There's no real oh, there's the satisfying answer to that question I've been looking for because you're, you're talking about a certain tension between the visible and the invisible that never goes away. And let me clarify words. I, I mentioned earlier. I shouldn't have interrupted you, Wendy. I'm sorry. I have a propensity to do so. And I humbly ask your forgiveness. If I had just let you keep
reading, all would be well. But I interjected because I, I did want our listeners. Like if you've never heard this language of apophatic prayer, apophatic means without images, cataphatic means with images. So an experience of cataphatic prayer would be maybe you're meditating on an actual image, like an icon of Christ. Maybe you are in a state of prayer and you receive a kind of image in your mind where it
seems like you're dreaming, you're seeing things, but you're actually awake. You're kind of having a dream, but you're awake. That would be an experience of cataphatic prayer. Apophatic prayer takes us beyond images into what some Saints, including John of the Cross, would call nada. Nothing where it seems like you're just in the abyss of the mystery that is God, where no image suffices, no word suffices.
You are, you are caught up in an an experience of God that is beyond words and beyond images. And both of these experiences are legitimate and we have to hold them together in a certain tension. I, I want to, I want to disvalue Andrew, of the idea that images are something we move beyond in a some kind of definitive way. Like the prayer with images means you're still immature in your prayer.
And if you were really a super duper contemplative prayer, you would be in the apophatic way and you wouldn't need those images that the lesser folks who still haven't advanced very much need. And in response to that, I want to read to that idea, which is misguided. I want to quote to you from Teresa of Avila. And this came up just last week or a couple weeks ago when we taught the New Evangelization course. So listen to what Teresa of Avila says. She and John on the cross, of course, we're very close and and
had very deep respect for one another. She says some thinking themselves advanced beyond it no longer meditate on the mysteries of the most sacred humanity of our Lord, which is the main image of the invisible God. Right the incarnation and and Andrew brought this up. How do we square this apophatic beyond images understanding of prayer with the very principle of the incarnation that the
invisible God has made himself visible. Yes, that's why we have to live in the tension of the both and God remains invisible, and yet He's made himself visible, right? So we have to live in that tension of the both, and he's invisible, Invisible. He's visible and invisible. Live in that tension, Andrew, and we're going to find the answer. But this is what Teresa's commenting on. These people who think they're advanced beyond images and the humanity of the Lord, they believe it's better for them to
deal with things concerning the divinity and flee from corporeal things, physical things, images, she goes on. I cannot imagine what such souls are thinking of. To be always withdrawn from corporeal things is the trait of angelic spirits, not of those who live in mortal bodies. I cannot believe that these souls withdraw themselves from the sacred humanity of Christ, but they just don't understand, and they will do harm to themselves and to others.
And take notice that I dare say you should not believe anyone who tells you something else. Some quote what the Lord himself said to his disciples, that it was fitting that he go away. I can't bear this, says Teresa of Avila. I tell you, daughters, that I consider this a dangerous path and think the devil could make one lose devotion for the Most Blessed Sacrament. OK, so hold on to that in one hand, Andrew, right? The invisible God has made
himself visible through the humanity of Jesus Christ. Hold that, hold that tightly. Now hold this also in the other hand and hold on to this tightly. He remains God, remains transcendent. He remains an invisible mystery, Right? And we need to hold these two things together, the divinity and the humanity, the invisible mystery and the visible sacramentality of Christ's body. When we hold those two together,
we are in the the the truth of the marriage of the visible and invisible, the marriage of the divinity and the humanity. If you emphasize one to the neglect of the other, heresy, right? Or if you emphasize the other to the neglect of the other, zoom in on the divinity of Christ, the invisibility of God. Zoom in on that and cling to that and forget about the visibility of God and the humanity of God. And that it is, it is fitting and proper to have icons and images of God.
Indeed, the human being is the image of God, right? Male and female. He made them in the image and likeness of God. He made them cling to the divinity without recognizing the image, and we have a heresy. Cling to the image without recognizing the invisibility, the divinity, we have a heresy. Hold the two together in the proper tension, and we're in the truth. And when we hold the divinity and humanity of Christ together in the proper tension, we will also be able to hold together in
our prayer life the proper tension between cataphatic prayer, prayer through images, and apophatic prayer, prayer without images. But we never, not even in eternity, do we graduate from the incarnation, meaning we leave the incarnation behind. We leave the image behind. No, for eternity, the life of the Trinity will be communicated to us through the body of Christ.
Yeah. Let me quote one more thing from Teresa of Avila here, where she talks about the importance of images. Hold that together also with the the truth that some prayer does not involve images. But she says this, I could never really engage my imagination unless I had seen the thing I was trying to visualize. That's why I have always been so fond of pictures. She's speaking here of like religious art. She says. I really feel sorry for people who purposely abandoned images. Obviously they do not love the
Lord because if they did, they would enjoy looking at his picture. I love that. I love it. I love it. She's she's putting her finger on this danger of those who think we can abandoned images and when you experience prayer beyond images, that that's real prayer and the prayer with images is somehow a lesser prayer. That's a danger. That does not mean apophatic prayer without images is not legitimate. It it takes us into the mystery of God, the abyss of Infinity,
right? In the end, the God is an abyss, but also in the end, the God who is the abyss, the incomprehensible, the ineffable, the invisible, has deigned to make himself visible. It is that which I have seen, says Saint John. It's that which I've touched with my hands that I proclaimed to you the word of life. So it is difficult to hold this tension, but I want to get to the crux of Andrew's question. All of that is background
information about entering that tension. But at the conclusion of his question, Wendy, what does he say? What I'm really getting at is. Yeah, he said. What I'm most interested in knowing is this. How should theology of the body impact my prayer life? If I'm drawn towards silent prayer, how can I incorporate the truth of theology of the body into that spiritual practice? Yes, OK, How do we incorporate theology of the body into our life of prayer? Well, let me hear quote directly from Saint John Paul the second. This is from his document Novo
Millennial inuente at the dawn of the new Millennium. And he says we have a duty as Christians to show the modern world the depth to which the relationship with Christ can lead. It leads through many painful purifications, many painful purifications, but it leads to the ineffable joy of what the Mystics call nuptial union with love, eternal nuptial union. And then he cites Teresa of
Avila and John of the Cross as beautiful examples of this tradition of prayer. This very idea of, of nuptial union is itself an image, an image that helps us understand the ineffable. Teresa of Avila would have these these ecstasies in prayer of union with the Lord and stammering to put it in words. She would say it, it, it, it, it was, it was, it was nuptial union, right?
So what is nuptial union? It's the union of spouses. The two become one. The two become one flesh, one body. And Saint Paul says this union of husband and wife in one flesh, nuptial union is a great mystery. So right, there's the tension, right we have the 2 become one flesh. And we're, when we're talking about bodies, we're talking about something visible. And then Saint Paul says this visible reality, this concrete bodily union of a husband and
wife is a great mystery. There's the invisible, right? So there, we could say is the cataphatic, the image of the two becoming one flesh, the holy union of a husband and wife. That's a cataphatic reality. And then this is a great mystery. That's an apophatic reality, a reality beyond images, and yet it's beyond images. But we use an image. Scripture uses an image. This is a great mystery. It refers to Christ in the church. The aid that theology of the
body is in our prayer life is it is the call precisely to those painful inner purifications that enables us to understand the union of man and woman. Not as something pornographic. That's the enemy's work. Pornography is the hellish mockery of this heavenly reality. What heavenly reality that the union of husband and wife in one
flesh is the image the Scripture uses far more than any other to help us understand the life of intimacy with God, which is to say, the life of prayer. When a Christian prays, says Pope Benedict the 16th, he is seeking nuptial union with the Lord. Pope Benedict also says prayer is nothing other than becoming a longing for God.
The catechism says prayer is where God's thirst meets our thirst, and another name for that thirst is Eros, our thirst for love, our thirst for nuptial union. The union we are ultimately thirsting for is precisely the marriage of Christ and the Church. That is a mystery that in the end, no image can really properly or adequately contained.
So all images here are going to be inadequate. But the least inadequate image to help us get there is a purified understanding of our creation as male and female and the call of the two to become one flesh. And it's very important that we say a purified image. The enemy attacks right here to pornify our creation as male and female, precisely in order to block us from prayer, to block
us from recognizing the holiness of this image as the doorway to deep, deep union with the Lord. But here's the good news for Andrew and for everyone else on the planet. What the enemy has pornified, Jesus Christ has purified. And for what end? So that it, all of it would be glorified, right? This is the journey of the Christian life. In this fallen world.
The holy has been pornified, but through Jesus Christ it becomes purified and can become glorified. We never leave the body behind. It does. The Catechism says that the the journey of the Christian life goes from the sign to the reality that is signified. And the reality signified, as we've been saying in various ways, is ineffable and invisible. But again we reach it without graduating from the visible.
We hold the tension together, always, of the visible and the invisible, the catafatic and the apophatic. Good luck there, Andrew. It is not an easy journey, but that's the journey we are all called to go on. And and I could and should write a doctoral dissertation to give you an adequate answer, but I I hope that I've pointed you in the right direction at least. I've heard you speak, my love, about the possibility of having a class specifically on Jonathan
Cross, Teresa of Avila, and Pope John Paul the Second. Yes, that's a hope of mine for the future. Kind of their theological, spiritual connectedness and the themes amongst them, the Carmelites and and JP 2 and I, I feel like Andrew is kind of, he's got a heart ready for that, you know, ready to receive that those reflections. And, you know, he quoted kind of a long section from it seemed like Jonathan Cross giving some very specific advice to someone
seeking a particular development in his or her prayer life. So there was a lot of, you know, very detailed stuff. And sometimes, you know, we're, it's a hard thing with the writings of the of the Saints. Many things they wrote for a particular audience and then we pick up the book and we may not be that audience. And so we kind of find ourselves confused. I've often felt like, Lord, how could it be better that somehow I I received the life or the
writing of a St. that was just right for my heart at the time versus something that kind of created a a confusion or discomfort. Those are those are some of the challenges of the rich inheritance we have through many amazing Saints. And I certainly know and agree with your just the very cursory understanding that JP 2 and theology of the body is seeing the profound connection, as you
said, between the marriage of Christ and the church and the Sacramento sign of that written into creation as male and female. And the the connection of that to mystical Saints like Jonathan Cross is so clear. And some of the things Andrew is speaking about, it almost could seem like maybe an taking this little bit of advice John of the Cross gave as kind of as if that were John of the Cross's whole
mission, that he wanted everyone to focus on that or something versus an advice that given to a person or a group of people in a that he was very aware of them and how they would receive that versus US and how we're receiving it, which is just removed from the intimacy of that relationship and the the wisdom that guided him in saying all that he said. Very, very good point, Wendy. And I'm reminded of, of some of the wisdom of my own spiritual director here who has always
said to me, and it's been very helpful that you can have the experience of the union with the Lord without the image of it. And if you're clinging to some image of it, there's a real danger that the, the icon can become an idol. And so holding together in the proper tension, which only the Holy Spirit can help us do. It's not like if you think about it hard enough, you'll hold it together. Only the Holy Spirit can take us into that, that proper tension
between the visible and the invisible and holding that all together and with with without the the two, the invisible and the visible. There's the danger on the one hand of idolizing the visible. And then there's the danger on the other hand, of, of demonizing the visible, of thinking the visible is just some kind of stepping stone or or maybe even suspect an evil right. And and so I speak if you want to go deeper here, Andrew, I'd recommend 2 resources. One is Mikhail Wahlstein's
introduction to the theology of the body, which is right in the volume the theology of the body text itself. He wrote 130 page or so introduction. And a large section of that is rooting John Paul the Second's teaching in the teaching of John of the Cross. If you want to go deeper, go there. And a book that I wrote that may be of interest to you is called At the Heart of the Gospel, Reclaiming the Body for the New Evangelization. And I have a chapter in there which might be, if I were to say so, it might be the most
important chapter of any book I've ever written. And it is called this, the narrow way between iconoclasm and idolatry, the narrow way between iconoclasm and idolatry, these are two serious errors. And when we don't hold the visible and the invisible together properly, when we don't hold the apophatic and the cataphatic way together properly, we are either going to air in the direction of idolatry
of the visible, or iconoclasm, which is the heresy that burned the icons because they thought they were evil, because they people were. There is this human tendency to worship icons and people thought the solution was, well, burn the icons because people have the temptation to worship them. No, no, no, no. The truth is right in in the tension of holding the visible and the invisible together, beware of the error of idolatry of the visible, and beware of
the error of rejecting the visible iconoclasm. In fact, Pope Benedict the 16th said that iconoclasm is the summation of all heresies because in the end it dispenses with the Incarnation and says it's not needed. That's why it's the summation of all heresies. So Andrew, I can tell from your question, you are swimming right in that tension. Just stay right there. And if you stay in the, it's like 2 magnets so that you're trying to hold together with the opposite ends and you're like
how do I hold this together? Stay right there, brother, and you are going to be taken up with all the elemental force of Christ's ascension and Mary's assumption into that vortex that is right in the tension of of holding it all together and avoiding iconoclasm on the one hand and idolatry on the other. Right in there is where our bodies, visible images of God get taken up into the invisible mystery of God through the incarnation. That's about all I can say about
that for now without taking too much time. But thank you, Andrew, You Beautiful question. As I said, one of my favorite we've ever received here. Hey everybody, this is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on tour this year. We're going to places like Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Michigan, and also other countries like United Kingdom, Germany, Ecuador, and Brazil. We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our events schedule in the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Peace.
All right, ready for another one? Let's do it. This is from an anonymous listener who says Hello Christopher and Wendy. I originally sought out your podcast with the desire to answer this question that has persisted in my life for many years now. I am happily married with two children who are truly the light of my life. Many years ago, before dating my husband, I developed a friendship with a girl that grew into an unhealthy affection.
I convinced myself I was in love with this person and felt deeply bonded to her, though nothing physical ever occurred between us. I love my husband deeply, yet at times I still long to be with this person and I don't know why. The memories of our friendship linger and seemingly haunt me to this day. I don't know why I still feel so drawn to her and I hate that it
constantly hovers over my head. How can I be free of this longing that has persisted for years? Bless you, bless you my sister. Thank you for your honesty. Thank you for so vulnerably sharing your heart with us. I hope and pray we can speak into it in a way that is healing and hopeful for you. Here's what I sense as Wendy
read your question and I'm just trying to receive your heart here. There is an unmet need in your heart is my sense of it, an unmet need in your heart for closeness to the feminine to that which is feminine and and I I say feminine rather than female. These words are have different shades of meaning, right?
Feminine refers to a a broader category than female. Feminine refers to kind of an extension of that which is female into a wider dimension. And we all have needs, both men and women have needs within their hearts for closeness to that which is masculine, closeness to that which is feminine. For me to have a healthy adult identity as a male, to take joy in being a male and to be taking
joy in in an integrated masculinity, to get there, I need tracks in my life that allow my train to travel properly into an an adult integrated masculinity. And there is the track for each and every one of us, whether you're male or female, of gender identification and gender complementarity. For me as a male, that track of gender identification is going to be with other men.
For me as a male, the track of gender complementarity is going to be with women. And in the normal course of events in God's design for our humanity, the the main track in our development as children into men and women, the main track of complementarity for me would be my mother. And the main track of identification for me would be my father. For for you, Wendy, growing up, your track of identification would have been with your
mother. Your track of complementarity would have been with your father. For any number of reasons, and let's just start with the common denominator for all of us. For any number of reasons, those tracks can be warped and, and you can derail. There could be big chunks of those tracks missing and you can derail. And the common denominator for all of us, we all have warped tracks in, in our train traveling into integrated adulthood as men and women,
because we live in a fallen world and nobody has perfect parents, right? And you may have a, a big chunk of the track missing because your father or your mother died when you were young. Wendy, your, your dad died when you were eight years old. That's a big chunk of the track that that was suddenly missing. Maybe your father abandoned the family. Maybe your mother abandoned the family. You could have big chunks of that track missing that derails your train. We still have the needs that are in there.
And, and then we start to imagine this person and these are deep unconscious realities. Rarely is it a conscious thought. Oh, I have this unmet need and you can fulfill it, but way down in there, deep in the bones, in the bone marrow of our soul, if I could use that expression, we have these needs that motivate us and, and, and, and we end up forming certain attachments because we have believed in our minds and deep in our hearts, we have believed this person right
here. It, it, it is somehow going to be able to take away that ache, that pain in my heart that, that, that absence of something that I feel. And we latch on, we latch on. I've done it. It's so human in our fallen humanity to do this. We, we latch on and we create idols. We create idols. And, and I would venture to say that part of your healing will be, my dear sister, to, to
renounce any kind of idolatry that may be present in your heart towards this person. When we're being haunted by the memory of a relationship and it just nags at us and we can't let it go. And it's painful to us and we wish we could let it go, but it comes back and back and back again and again and again. I would, I would guess, this is my educated guess, that there's some form of attachment in your
heart that has to do with setting up a kind of idol. And when I say idol, I'm not imagining you like worshipping in the sense of bowing down to this person as if she were some kind of idol in that sense. But what I mean is taking a need of the heart that only God can fulfill and he wants to fulfill and positing the fulfillment of that need in a creature in something less than God. Now that person we, why do we fall for idolatry? Because that person is an image
of God. That person does image something holy. That person does symbolize something holy and important and even necessary for your heart. But when you when you posit the fulfillment of that legitimate need in the creature. Now we have an idol and and look what the Lord has provided for our needs. We all have either warped tracks or big chunks of the track missing, right? I love my mom. I love my dad. They will be the first to admit they're broken human beings and they brought a lot of baggage
into their marriage and that got passed on to us as kids. And, and, and I had real difficulty in some ways identifying with my dad. I had some difficulty forming that complimentary relationship with my mother. Well, check this out. We all need perfect tracks of gender identification and gender complementarity. Well, look what God the Father has provided for us. He's provided Jesus Christ the perfect man, and he's provided Mary a perfect woman. And for me, my track of gender
identification with a perfect man is Jesus Christ. And my track of gender complementarity with a perfect woman is Mary, the Mother of God, and my mother and my sister. And even in some way, this is unfamiliar to a lot of people, but it's in the spiritual literature. The Saints have used this kind of language. She is also in some way in the mystical realm, my spouse, in that feminine side and dimension of things, because she she stands at the foot of the cross
as the bride of Christ. And I'm called to identify the Christ so profoundly that I become another Christ. And so Mary's going to be at my, the foot of my cross too, in a mystical dimension, as as spouse, as sister, as mother, just as she was spouse and sister and mother at the foot of the cross to Jesus Christ. This this is the path that each in our own way must go on to find a true integrated
masculinity or femininity. And I am, I am again, this is my educated guess, but I'm get my educated guest tells me that you're haunted by the memories of this relationship because you took something to this woman that you should have taken to God's provision, which is Mary, and that Mary will meet you so lovingly, so tenderly in that need for for gender
identification. On that track. She will meet you so tenderly even in the disorder of whatever idolatry might have been present in that relationship, whatever unhealthy attachment to the creature might have been present in that relationship. Mary will meet you so tenderly and mercifully, and in her femininity she will minister to you, and she will lead you also in her femininity to the child within her womb who's the second person of the Trinity.
And he will become for you that track of gender complementarity in your womanhood and in Jesus And in Mary you will have perfectly straight tracks that allow your train to ride into an unhunted femininity where you can appreciate rightly what you were attracted to her what what you what in her you were attracted to. And you can detach from anything
unhealthy. And, and this is the image I have that we go to Mary as our mother. That you would latch on as an infant at the breast of Mary and drink deeply from the milk of her comfort. That's Isaiah 66. I would invite you, dear sister, to pray into Isaiah 66 and not be afraid to picture yourself as an infant at the breast of Mary, drinking in her perfect femininity as a way of ministering to that place in
your heart that that sought sought an illegitimate satisfaction to a legitimate need and it created an attachment that is now haunting you. The haunting will diminish and cease in as much as you direct the legitimate need that you have to the legitimate provision of the Father and of Jesus, which is precisely what He says at the cross to you and to all of us. Behold your mother. I just want to share with our
listeners my some of my personal story of related to my relationship with Mary, the Blessed Mother. Just because I sense in your answer, you're seeing like Mary because she loves us. She wants to be part of our healing. And yet there are kind of difficulties in that process of experiencing a bond with her
that that our hearts need. But there's like, how do I get there? So I just wanted to share a little bit about my own experience of that. It's not like directly an answer to this question, but indirectly it could be so helpful if it other people could relate to it. So I'll just share with you that when I was new, newly out of college, I was participated in this young adult retreat that was led by some priests who were teaching us Ignatian prayer,
meaning we were learning how to read something in the Gospel a a short passage and in prayer put ourselves in that scene from the gospel and begin to reflect on what was happening as if we were present at the time. It's beautiful. It was such an amazing opportunity. And yet this retreat had the theme of Mary. So we are the gospel passages we were looking at.
We're all about the Blessed Mother and going to that retreat. Huge blessing and something that stood out for me. I had graduated from college. I had moved far away from my family to start this job, didn't have familiar friends around, was working and, you know, with all strangers. And there was kind of this pain in my heart of wanting to be friends with these new people, but also longing for the comfortable people who knew me
at the time. And so on this retreat, that's just a little context. We had this prayer exercise that we did where, and it was toward the beginning of the retreat, actually, we were all kind of with our eyes closed and the priest was telling us to allow Mary to come and introduce herself to us. I like that. And as we were all, you know, silently allowing that to happen, I felt in me a little bit of my resistance to Mary,
that I associated her maybe with some people whose spirituality I didn't really relate to. Or maybe I saw her as a barrier in my friendships with Protestants. Like, so there were these things that were confusing my heart in terms of being comfortable with Mary. And we're doing this prayer experience, allow Mary to introduce herself to you, to come and introduce herself. Well, what I saw in my just inspired imagination, I just say
that because I believe the Holy Spirit was with me, was Mary said to me, I'm your trusted friend. And it was a powerful introduction because I needed a trusted friend in that moment. And she saw my heart. And then she, in this prayer experience, came closer to me and asked me to show her a photo album I had with pictures of
friends and family that I had left when I moved. So I had brought with me this photo album. She's she wanted to look at it. And so she asked me to show it to her and I and I imagined myself opening it and pointing out different people from my life. And her absolute interest in knowing about me and about the people that mattered to me was so consoling. And it was a truly a new beginning for me. And having just a, a much deeper relationship with Mary and was
very simple. But I share all that because. It's. Hearing Christopher talk about like how Mary can help us, it can seem like how do I get there? You know, and just for you, our, our listener who asked this question and for anybody else who can relate to these things, perhaps you need to ask Mary to come and and look at this particular story with you. You know, to visit as if you had a photo album of the important
moments in the relationship with this friend that you're talking about. Like, well, could you show her those scenes? Could you just gently open aspects of your life to her in not jumping ahead of where you are, but just allowing her to approach and experience the safety that she has because she loves so much? Wendy, thank you, thank you, thank you for taking us on that journey and with you and giving that window into your that new
beginning of your relationship with Mary. So beautiful. As you were sharing that, I heard Carole King singing. You've got a friend, but you know, a lot of people know the James Taylor version, but Carole King actually wrote that song. So I'm hearing that in a feminine voice. And, and I, I hear it's Mary. It's Carole King as Mary or Mary as Carole King. It's that feminine voice singing. You've got a friend and I think she's singing that to our listener too, who asked this question that you have a friend
in this woman, Mary, and, and she can lead you into the maybe scary terrain of your heart that has that attachment and, and bring about a deep healing. Be not afraid. Let Mary introduce herself to you as, as Wendy said, beautiful. We hope that was helpful. We're we're also aware these questions. Gosh, we could go on and on and on and answer to the questions And we, we try to give food for thought and try to respect the
time frame of the podcast without going on too long. So I'm just stuck right now because I'm going on long again. If I don't stop, it'll go on. There I am, I again. I'm making it longer. Stop it. Are you ready for another question? Yes. OK. This is from a listener named Mary Pat. Hello, Mary. Pat. Hello, Christopher and Wendy, thank you very much for your podcast and for all that you do. You are welcome very much. I greatly appreciate it. I just listened to your podcast episode from June 2nd about the gentleman who's having a
difficult time opening his heart after porn use. This is my story with my husband and his addiction for almost our entire marriage. We will be married 39 years in December. Praise be to God, he's been sober for the last eight years. Thank you God. But his closed off Stony heart continues to be a struggle for our marriage. The information that you gave is wonderful and I plan to share that with him, but in addition,
can you suggest where to go for outside help? I've suggested that he talked to a man who's been through this and is further down the road of recovery or spiritual direction with a priest. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Mary Pat, I'm so glad that you were reached and blessed by that episode from June. I I would imagine we might have mentioned on that episode, I can't remember and keep it all straight, but if we didn't mention it, then we should have. Freedom Coaching is an
organization that we very much believe in, endorse. I know the founder. He was an old student of mine years ago. I know one of the main coaches they have who's a dear friend and colleague, Steve Motel. Steve Percorney is the founder. If your husband is willing to seek help, please have him register for the services of Freedom Coaching. I think you are absolutely right. Spiritual direction could be very helpful provided, and this is a very important
qualification, provided that the person offering the spiritual direction has has deep experience with the journey that's required for healing from pornography. The the journey required of inner integration where we're not thinking the body's bad and pornography is bad because it shows naked bodies blaming the body, that Manichean fear of the body. There's a lot of puritanical,
Manichean, Jansenistic, Gnostic nonsense that passes for overcoming porn, right? We overcome evil with good, right? What is pornography? It is Satan's diabolical fury aimed at the fact that God's plan for the human body is glorification. So what's Satan's diabolic fury? Pornification.
That's what he wants. We have to. If you're going into spiritual direction, you need somebody who's been on the journey from pornification to glorification through purification. That's what you need. And and what passes for purity sometimes is just puritanical fearful rejection of the body. This is why I believe that freedom coaching is doing such a good job because they don't go down that path. They know that they know the path from from pornification through purification to glorification. That's that's the journey.
Yeah, I have a couple other thoughts from Mary Pat. And for any listener, 1 is for herself. We've also had connection with a ministry called Hope's Garden, so encouraging and helpful for the healing of women who've experienced the same suffering that Mary Pat has. I also wanted to mention marriage missionaries, which are kind of marriage coaches in that some of what Mary Pat is talking
about is, is how the deeper wounds in her husband's heart affect their marriage. Now you know that it's in some ways it's almost, it's not enough just to stop the sinful habits, but like to experience the flow of grace, which has been in some ways blocked. That image of a Stony heart is one that's impervious. You know, it won't won't let that flow of grace in. So I don't know which, if any of
those would be most helpful. There's also right if you look at the more information in our podcast, you can find a link to Catholic counselors so that are recommended by the theology of the Body Institute. Sometimes one person or the couple would benefit from counseling. There are definitely options available and I would encourage you to pray as you begin that search that that the Spirit
would guide you to the person that's most helpful and that what we're sharing is just kind of a beginning to access things that could be so helpful. And our prayer is that both of your hearts would become more and more open to grace. There are there are wounds in both of you that have formed kind of a scar tissue on the heart that that needs particular care in order to experience God's love for you and to share
that with one another. The Alexander House is also on my mind as another marriage coaching thoroughly Catholic. Yeah. Ministry that does great work. So we'll have the link to that as well in the show notes. Yes, Lord, we lift up all of our listeners to you, all of their questions that they've submitted to us, especially the ones we're not able to answer just because of limitations of time. We get so many questions from around the world. We lift up them. We ask that you would lead them
in the right direction, Lord, to find the answers they're looking for. We lift up in a particular way right now, the people whose questions we've answered in this episode. We ask the Lord that everything that we have spoken that comes from You would minister to their hearts and anything that was just from us that might not be pertinent would just float away and not be a problem whatsoever. Thank you Lord, for creating us male and female in Your image and likeness. Thank You for creating us to live the gift of Your love, and thank you, Lord, for giving us
the grace. To become what we are. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...