Is Latin Mass superior?, He wants me in revealing clothes, and Coming back to Church risks my marriage. | ACW388
56 minAudio
Questions answered this episode: I just wondered about Latin Masses in the Catholic Church. I live in the United States, and no one speaks Latin here, so I wondered what the draw is to go to Latin Masses. It feels like in Catholic circles those who go to Latin Masses are considered more Catholic. If God made our bodies and speaks to us through our bodies, shouldn't it be more helpful to go to a mass that we can understand using our sense of hearing? Or am I just not as far along in my faith life as those who appreciate Latin Mass? My husband and I have been married for almost four years. We're both Catholic, but my husband doesn't think I look beautiful unless I wear tight, revealing clothes. We struggle a lot when he suggests I wear something with a lower neckline or that's skin tight. I'm not comfortable wearing stuff like that, but he feels that I'm not trying to be beautiful for him, even if I wear nice, slightly more modest clothes. How can I love my husband and not be hurt by his wanting me to wear more revealing clothes? And how can we find a middle ground here? My wife and I were married outside the Catholic Church. For the past eight years, I've not practiced my faith. However, as of late, I have had a deep and real call back to the church. In some way, my wife was blindsided by this decision, and not thrilled. I've taken a step back from re-entering the church out of fear of conflict between my wife and me. This has made for some serious challenges in our marriage. Is it sinful for us to come together in our nuptial embrace outside of the church where I've found the truth to be? Is our marriage invalid for this same reason? Resources: TOB I Course: Head & Heart Immersion - Summer of 2026 Course Schedule for other courses Pierced by Beauty: Encountering God In the Flesh Mexico Retreat Love & Responsibility YouTube Series with Matt Fradd Good News About Sex & Marriage Our Bodies Tells God's Story Book --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 📩 Submit your question here! ⚡️ Want to have a better chance of us answering your question and support the Theology of the Body Institute? Join our Patron Community! 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body --- 🎟️ Event Schedule 📚 Course Schedule 🏔️ Pilgrimages 🧠 List of trusted counselors & psychologists *If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, Wendy. Yes, Christopher, I'm going to ask you a question so that our listeners can get to know you a little better. Oh no. Yes, and then you get to ask me one. OK. Tell our listeners something strange and unusual about you. Something strange and unusual about me is I'm going to try to finish that sentence. That's my prompt. Something strange and unusual
about me is see that you repeat the question when you're trying to think of an answer. Right. That's what I'm doing right now. I I said, oh, no. And you said you're gonna ask me a question. Darn it all. It's hard for me to be on the spot. Like, no, I, I'm oh, oh goodness, what I keep thinking of, but I don't know if it's really strange and unusual, but I guess some people have told me
that it is. So I'll go there is that I like to look at catalogs and are like, when I was a little kid, I used to like there were these big catalogs that would come maybe like twice a year or something that from JC Penney and Sears. And I was really into this, paging through them and seeing the sections and the things that were for sale. And now I don't like big catalogs, but I like homeschooling catalogs. I like, you know, like linens. I like clothing.
I used to like this catalog that I don't see any more, but it's like solutions. It was like weird things that people had invented, like, you know, to keep your you from hurting your knees when you're kneeling to give your child a bath or to keep like fix some gutter problem or, I don't know, just weird things that people had invented and they were sold in this catalog. So I don't know, like it's just a very relaxing thing to me, just to page. Their catalog like that you like catalogues.
I it reveals something of your person. Can I share something strange and unusual about you? About me? Did I ask you? I got something that I want to share. Oh. My goodness. OK, Pause, Christopher. Now it's my turn. OK, What do you think is strange than usual about me? Well, there are other things I think, but I'm not going to. This is the one I wanted to share 'cause I I think it's really cute the way you hold your breath in the pool.
In a pool. Can you describe that to everybody? OK, it's it's an anatomical gift. Yes, it is an anatomical gift. Because few people can do. This one, can you do it for me? I mean, there it is there. It is when I hold my breath. It's amazing. I wish I had this gift. I My upper lip covers my nostrils so that no pool water gets in my nose and I. Like you make a seal. They do, and actually my grandmother could do it and our
daughter Grace can do it. So it's definitely genetic. Yep, and. And it's not like you have oversized upper lip. It's just a certain thing. I don't know. It's pretty amazing. The funny thing for me is that I just instinctively did it as a child and didn't even. Realize that this was a special. That it was strange, except that other people would pinched their noses and I couldn't figure out why they would do that. See, I just blow water out my nose. That's the correct thing to do. No. Well, that's just what I have to do.
I wish I could do what you did. I do. I do both. I do both. Now it's. It's pretty amazing. Strange and unusual. OK, well, would you like to share something that is strange and unusual about you? So there are some things I cannot share publicly that you know about me, but I'll share this one. I've not been to a Barber since 1988. That's why your hair is just dragging on the floor all the
time. No. And the reason is because I cut my own hair. That's right. And that seems strange and unusual to a lot of people. I. Guess it does. But I haven't, yes, I have not been to a Barber since 1988, since I was 18 or 19 and. Tell me this, like what if something should happen and you couldn't cut your own hair anymore? Don't like to think about that. I just wondered if you've ever like pondered like will there be a point when you do go to a? Barber, you you have just introduced a new concept.
It never dawned on me, but it probably will happen that I won't be able to. But you know what? I'm losing my hair. So by the time I lose the use of my arms, maybe I won't have any hair to cut. I don't know. That could be OK. Well, thanks for that little sharing of selves that we just. That was totally unexpected. Wendy had no idea I was going to plop that on her, but that's what just happened. That's fine, and I will share something about the Institute.
Oh, right. That's 'cause you were about to go to a question. I think you no. No, no, no, I I was going to ask you. Oh yeah, for an update. Go ahead then. Do you have any updates for us from the TOP institute? It's summertime, everybody knows we have our live summer courses, so by the time this airs, TOP one will probably be closed out. But if you want to try to squeeze in, you can June 14th to the 19th. Then we have The Way of Beauty in July and then TOB 2 in August. But what I want to zoom in on right now is a special event I'm
doing in Mexico at the end of August, the final weekend of August. I'm doing a three Well, we start on a Thursday night. We end Sunday morning. So it's 2 full days and two half days basically of special retreat. We are calling Pierced by Beauty, and then the subtitle is Encountering God in the Flesh. And what we're going to do is we're going to put on our TOB glasses. And if you don't have TOB
glasses, I'm going to give some to you and we're going to look at the four pillars of the Catechism. This is a mini version of a course I teach for the institute, which we just called TOB in the New Evangelization. This is a mini version and it will be outside of Mexico City at a retreat center. I've already done some events there. It's a really pretty spot called Mecca Mecca and we will have a link to this in the show notes. If you live in Mexico or want to fly to Mexico City and be part
of this, it's going to be a wonderful 3 1/2 day event. Are you ready for a question? I am. Let's do it. OK, this is from an anonymous patron. Hello Christopher and Wendy, thank you for taking the time to answer my question. I just wondered about Latin masses in the Catholic Church. I live in the United States and no one speaks Latin here, so I wondered what the draw is to go to Latin masses.
It feels like in Catholic circles, those who go to Latin masses are considered quote UN quote more Catholic, so to speak. If God made our bodies and speaks to us through our bodies, shouldn't it be more helpful and useful to go to a mass that we can understand using our sense of hearing? Or am I just not as far along in my faith life as those who appreciate Latin Mass? Bless you, dear listener. I, I, I just have a certain
tenderness towards your heart as I'm hearing your question. And I, I want to disavow you right away of the idea that you are not Catholic enough, or if you were more Catholic or more advanced, that you would all of a sudden want to go to the Latin Mass. Yeah, you could. Please, please, let's not go down that path. I will give you my take, my short take on why people are
attracted to it. And it is very attractive. It's a legitimate, beautiful part of the Catholic tradition and those who appreciate it I have a a respect for. But what I think is going on in a certain movement in the Church today, where larger and larger numbers seem to be drawn to the traditional rite, the Latin Mass, I think it's a response to
what has been for the last 55 or more years, a period of real liturgical chaos in the Church. And I want to put this in perspective. This is very important for us to understand. There was a promise of liturgical renewal coming to the Church at the Second Vatican Council, and if you're really Catholic you have to believe
that the Council was inspired here by the Holy Spirit in this prophecy of liturgical renewal. But the prophecy has yet to be fulfilled. If we look at the last 55 plus years of so-called liturgical renewal, what we have experienced is what historians call post conciliar chaos, right? If you look back at church history, whenever there's a major council, it usually takes about 100 years or more for that council to bear its fruit in the
body of Christ at large. We're only halfway there, folks. We're only a little over halfway there. I don't think in my lifetime I'm going to see the prophecy of liturgical renewal fulfilled. I'm going to be dead and gone. Younger generation, our children will see it. I believe, I hope, I pray. But the attraction to the Latin Rite Mass is my take on it is a a very understandable seeking of
structure, seeking of correction to some of the craziness that has gone past for Catholic liturgy in the last 50 plus years. One of my favorite books on the liturgy, maybe my favorite on the liturgy is by Pope Benedict the 16th before he became Pope. The book is called The Spirit of the Liturgy. Read it, read it, read it, read it. If you're interested in the liturgy, please read it in there. He said liturgical formation of both priests and laity in recent
decades has been deficient to a deplorable extent. Deficient to a deplorable extent. And one of the reasons this has been deficient, the liturgical formation has been deficient to a deplorable extent, is because we don't know what it means that we're male and female anymore. Well, what's the connection between that and the liturgy? What is the liturgy? The liturgy is the consummation of the marriage of Christ in the Church. The liturgy is the consummation of Christ the bridegroom, and
the Church the bride. When we don't understand the meaning of marriage, When we don't understand the meaning of our creation as male and female, when we don't understand the meaning of the two being called to become one flesh, we don't understand the meaning of the liturgy. St. Paul tells us in Ephesians 5 for this reason, a man will leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and the two will become one flesh. This is a great mystery, and it refers to Christ and the Church.
It refers to the Eucharist. It refers to the Mass, it refers to the liturgy. John Paul the Second described the Eucharist as the sacrament of the bridegroom and of the bride. Look back at the last 50-60 years. What has the liturgical chaos coincided with? Total sexual chaos. This is not merely A coincidence. It's kind of a chicken and an egg thing. What comes first? Is it liturgical chaos that leads to sexual chaos, or is it sexual chaos that leads to
liturgical chaos? Yes, both. And if you're interested in this, please, I beg of you, read my book, Eating the Sunrise. The subtitle is Meditations on the Liturgy and Our Hunger for Beauty. And make sure you get the bonus chapter, which you can get online, which is all about the liturgical chaos and how we bring about the fulfillment of the prophecy of liturgical renewal. All of that to say, in a world of liturgical chaos, you're going to look for something you
can stand on that's solid ground. And, and when we go to 1 extreme with chaos, we're going to go to another extreme. That's just human nature with the pendulum swings one way, the pendulum is going to swing the other way. And so there can be, I'm not saying everybody who loves the Latin Mass or goes the Latin Mass is this way, but there can be a certain rigorism, rigidity, clinging to rubrics and laws and rituals in an exterior way
without a, an interior conversion. And what do you get when you cling to the externals without the interior conversion? You get a Pharisee, You get that Pharisaical element in the church. Again, I'm not accusing everybody who loves the Latin Mass of this, but I'm it, it's prevalent. It is, it is just part of human nature. We go there. Why? Because we've gone the other extreme, the loosey goosey there, there are no rubrics, there are no rules. Throw it all out the window. Well, that's going to lead to a backlash. And that backlash is, is
certainly underway. It what we're called to is integration. Integration, where we experience the fulfillment of the law, the fulfillment of the ritual. Not ritual for ritual sake, not rubrics for rubrics sake, but ritual and rubrics for the sake of true freedom of expression. And it's the same principle of freedom from the law. It's not freedom to break the law, it's freedom to fulfill the
law because we don't desire to break it, right? The rubrics are there not for the rubrics sake. The rubrics are there so that we can be free within the bounds of authentic Catholic public worship. And why do I say public worship? Because that's what the liturgy is, right? Private prayer is one thing, Public prayer is another. Thank God we have a Magisterium who's who can say with authority when we gather to pray publicly, this is how we're going to do it. Because if we didn't have that, you'd have chaos, right?
But private prayer, when you pray, go in your inner room and close the door. And there are many, as many styles of private prayer are there as there are individual human persons, right? Because private prayers, just that it's, it's private. No, the church can be the judge of whether our private prayer is authentic or not. I'm not saying anything goes as prayer if I mean, if you're blaspheming God in your private prayer or you're justifying sin in your private prayer in any way, that's not really prayer
now, is it? But I there's, there's freedom there. There's a freedom in private prayer that when we pray publicly, we need the church to tell us how we're going to do that. So that's not chaotic anyway. When you go to 1 extreme, you're going to go to the other. And I think we're living through that tension of the imbalance on both extremes, and the renewal will come as we seek what's true on the one side and what's true on the other, and we learn to hold them together. That will be the true liturgical renewal that was promised and prophesied at the Second Vatican Council.
Yeah, I think one of the things I felt when I read this question was wondering if the if the person asking the question is significantly younger than we are. And maybe not, I don't know. But I was realizing that I grew up at a time where my parents and of course my grandparents, but definitely my parents had grown up going to every church. Mass was in Latin. That was just what they what you
experienced when you went to Mass in every country. So they to hear of the Latin Mass growing up as kind of a historical reality is, is not mystifying that there is such a thing as a Latin Mass because I knew people who that. Was that was their? Experience growing up so I, I just wondered if like hearing there's a mass in Latin like why
why would you have a mass in Latin that just sounds kind of snobbish. You know, it's for like super educated people who studied Latin or something, you know, versus actually seeing it as a little bit more organic than that because. That's a very good point. The, The Histories of the Church and I think it's also just a good idea to go experience 1, you know, just to kind of understand a little bit of what's going on, especially if
you can, you know, be slightly prepared in some ways for what it's going to be like. Maybe talk to someone. But I think it's, it's a good idea to experience it and to kind of see how much is the same as what you experience in masses that you go to in, in English and what's different. And just kind of let your heart and your mind kind of explore that territory a little bit so that it's not just something
mysterious and out there that doesn't make any sense at all. I think, you know, you and I have gone to a few Latin Masses. One was a wedding Mass, which was an interesting experience as well. And I, I understand the words you're saying when you say we're living in post conciliar chaos. I also think I love to go to Mass and I don't experience it as personally chaotic for me. So I'm like, OK, whatever the
church is doing here, yeah. Let me clarify what I mean by that. I'm not saying every parish on the planet is experiencing chaos, but there has, there has been a there've been some radical changes in the liturgy that have caused confusion. There's been great license taken by some in saying the liturgy that has caused real confusion.
In the early 70s it just seemed like a free for all with the liturgy. That caused a lot of pain and confusion. I'm not. I'm speaking in generalities. I'm not speaking about your specific parish is in liturgical chaos, but a general experience in the air where the Church is still trying to get its feet under it in terms of what the Council taught and didn't teach about liturgical renewal. And that will take at least a century. Yeah.
So I'm glad you you you said that so I could clarify. You know, I have my own ideas of what I mean when I'm saying something that I think everybody else understands. And I need you, my wife, to say, wait a minute. What about this? So thank you for saying that. Sure. And I will just throw this out, too, about Latin as the universal language of the church. It's still the official language of the Latin Rite of the Church. The Eastern churches, in my understanding, if I'm correct, they've always prayed the liturgy in the vernacular of their own countries.
It's the Latin Rite of the Church. That Latin is the official language. And it it there was something beautiful about in ages past. You could go to any country in the world and you would be familiar with the liturgy because of the Latin. Not even, I'm not even saying that because everybody knew Latin. They didn't know Latin, but yeah, there's it's both traditions in the Church are are valid and and legitimate praying in the vernacular or praying in the universal language in the Latin rite of of Latin.
Yeah. All right. Ready for next question? This is from an anonymous listener. My husband and I have been married for almost 4 years. We're both Catholic, but my husband doesn't think I look beautiful unless I wear tight, revealing clothes. We struggle a lot when he suggests I wear something with a lower neckline or that's skin tight. I'm not comfortable wearing
stuff like that, but he feels that I'm not trying to be beautiful for him even if I wear nice, slightly more modest clothes. To be clear, even though I have some baggy clothes, I try to wear something nicer, non baggy, that emphasizes my waist. That just doesn't cut it for him. I'm also breastfeeding, which makes finding accessible yet appropriate clothes really difficult. How can I love my husband and
not be hurt by his wanting me to wear more revealing clothes? And how can we find a middle ground here? Oof is is I'm missing a certain detail here? So I'm going to have to assume the detail. The detail I'm missing is, is the husband asking her to wear these revealing clothes publicly? It seems like yes, just her normal. Her normal attire. Her normal attire. Yeah, that's I think so. Yeah, that's that's the way I'm
going to take it. Dear sister, this is a, this is a difficult situation you're in. I think your husband is seeing the world incorrectly. I think he's seeing your body or wanting to see your body incorrectly.
Your Your body is not an object to be gazed upon by anyone, including your husband. As a thing for titillation, as a thing for the stirring of concupiscence. And concupiscence isn't a word we use every day. But in the language of the church, concupiscence refers to our disordered passions and desires.
And it seems to me I, I, I, I don't have some crystal ball into your husband's heart. But based on the world that I live in, based on my experience of the world that I live in, based on the way I was formed to think about tight revealing clothing and the way the culture teaches us to think about tight revealing clothing. The one purpose of tight, revealing clothing in the cultural context in which we
live is to be sexually provocative. And when I say sexually provocative, I mean to to stir disordered passions. I don't want to accuse your husband, but I'm just, I'm speaking from the perspective of the world in which we live. And it seems to me the ideas coming from your husband are are in need of real purification.
And you have been called as his wife to be his main intercessor. And the pain that he's causing you, the friction that this is causing, the discomfort that it's causing, I want to affirm the discomfort this is causing you. Now, I don't know all the details here, so there may be some tendencies in you, some aspects of the way you're
thinking. Maybe there's a certain rigorism going on here that needs to be purified as well. Maybe there's a certain, I don't know what fears you might have of your own body, But if your husband is asking you to sport really tight, revealing clothing where your breasts are exposed to the public and not much is left to the imagination in terms of your figure and shape. And he says, please, I want you
to wear this publicly if that's going on. I, I, I, I some he, I can't, I can't wrap my head around that. And the only way I can begin to approach it is to imagine and to conclude that your husband's in need of some real inner purification. To see your body rightly and to see the body of every woman rightly. That he's been formed and shaped by a culture that has really
warped his thinking and the pain he's causing you there I think is legitimate. Your, your resistance to wanting to dress that way I think is legitimate. Again, there may be some aspects of your heart that you need to look at and ask the Lord to shine light on. And of course there are we all, we all have healing we need to go through. We all have warped images and senses of our bodies. And you can go from one extreme to another. You can go from, you know, really libidinistic, even semi pornographic ways of thinking
and dressing. And then you can go to the other extreme, to a puritanical fearful repression. And here let me just throw in some JP 2 here that he says accentuation of sexual values in the way we dress is inevitable, and it is not entirely incompatible with modesty and purity, right? He says the sexual characteristics of the person should be veiled in the way we dress, but only to a certain extent, he says, because it's
those sexual characteristics that also can awaken the journey towards authentic love in our hearts. So I, I want to also affirm that in the heart of heart of your husband, in the heart of hearts of your husband, there's a desire to love you. I'm certain of that. And your body, your figure, seeing you, your figure in what he's been conditioned to think is an attractive way of dressing
what he's really after is to honor your beauty and be attracted to your beauty and to be stirred to love. I believe in his heart of hearts that's what's going on. But I believe something's got in there and has twisted that beautiful equation up. And that's what you're, that's why you're resisting it. You, I think. And I think you're right to do so. And the pain that it's causing your heart offered as intercession for your husband. It could be as simple as, Lord, I'm really pained by the way my husband is asking me to dress.
It has pained me. It's caused real friction and tension in our marriage. And I I don't even know exactly how my husband sees me and I'm concerned about it. And I ask you, please, Lord, Ioffer this pain. And I ask you, please, through this pain, united to your suffering on the cross, bring about the conversion in my husband that is necessary for him to love me in a in a purer way, to see me in a purer way, and for us to find a peaceful
way forward. That suffering offered as intercession for your husband is potent and powerful and will bear its fruit. I can't tell you when or how long it'll take, but a spouse who prays in that way, for a spouse, that's an effective prayer. Yeah, I I sense that just from the way that question is worded, and maybe sometimes we get it wrong.
We know that. We're sorry, listeners, if we misunderstand your question. Please pray for us and pray for all the listeners that something good comes from that. It's not obviously not intentional on our part to misunderstand the question, but one of the things that kind of is striking me is that this wife is, is saying not so much that she's had length like like kind of good conversations with her husband about it, but more like she knows it's what he wants and
she tries to find what will work for her and for him. And then there are painful times when he is kind of critical, wanting her to dress differently, she said. We struggle a lot. And I think, you know, we struggle a lot is an understandable phrase for married couples to hear. We, we struggle, we're hurting each other. We're not happy in this situation. And maybe we're arguing and maybe, you know, all those things.
So I, it feels like there maybe hasn't been like really good heart to heart conversation about this topic yet. And I, I think there could be a, a lot to learn about one another through this is like the outward expression of things on the inside that you're missing each other. And I'm not trying to say that all of it is good as Christopher was, you know, saying there is an instinctive caution about
just this. Yeah, The the type of, I don't know, the the way that he wants you to dress that isn't instinctive for you, the fact that he's asking you to do this for him. And even that phrase you used, he feels like I'm not trying to be beautiful for him. That it just there's a certain expectation of I don't know of
what your role is as a wife in his eyes. That feels a little off. And yet all of it, it feels also like, can we press in? Can we like with a just a sense of acceptance and curiosity? Can we like just get to the deeper thing, You know, where did that kind of belief come from in that the belief that it's important for my wife to
look beautiful because and he can finish that sentence. And I would add there, if I sorry, I wouldn't even jump it, but what's his concept of beauty? Where did that come from? Right. Yeah, yeah. And yeah. And So what are, what's the history in his, in the journey of his heart that led him there. And at the same time, I think he needs an education about your heart.
And I, I feel like maybe there's a, there's a level of kind of just being frustrated and that's being expressed here, but that I suspect there's also some more pain underneath that frustration, you know, of just being valued in not quite the right way and you know, your true value.
And so that's, that's painful. And so I just, I hope that after kind of wording this question for us and, and you know, it's on the podcast, you'll hear our answer, but even in writing it out, like already you, you took some steps to put it in the light and ask the Lord into it. And I, my hope is that and our hope is that it leads to real growth for you both in understanding one another. Like it's, it's very popular
right now, I think in the world to kind of label things as bad and rejecting them. You know, very quickly, you know, he said that that's wrong. Reject that person. You know, he believes that she does this. Reject that person. And there's like a a trigger happiness in that kind of way in our world as a married couple, you cannot live like that. You have to be curious about the story and the deep, truly deep heart of one another.
And that can be threatening. And I know we've had times in our relationship where maybe we felt scared of kind of, I'm not going to understand. You're so different from me here and I don't get it. And you're expecting me to understand and you're upset that you have to explain. And you know, those are fearful times. And yet, like there's growth, there's such growth when we go into that understanding that it's kind of challenging the other one. You know that it's not easy and
and being patient sometimes pausing the conversation saying maybe let's just think and pray about this for a while and and talk again at another time, like but I do think that that this is I just feel like we're seeing something on a certain level and there's a lot under yes, and that is going to be where you want to go together with the Lord. Wendy, This is why it's so important that you and I do this podcast together 'cause you're what you just brought in your
answer here, I think is so, so important. I, I, I realized that in oftentimes, I'm assuming our listeners out there have some foundation in John Paul's vision, but this guy, I don't believe he does. And I would just say to this dear wife who's written to us, dear sister, please, please invite your husband and go on
the journey with him of diving into what John Paul the Second has given us. Please, please read theology of the Body for beginners. Maybe do 15 pages a week separately and then just set a time aside every week, couple hours just to talk about what you're learning together. Do a just start binging on YouTube. On our YouTube channel. I have countless videos where I
talk into these themes. Matt Frat and I did a series on Love and responsibility, 3 videos on our channel and three videos on his channel. That would be a great place to start, just to begin to enter into the vision John Paul the Second has given for us. He gives us the map to navigate these really delicate matters of the heart, as Wendy was saying. And they're they're behind every distorted reality. There's a beautiful reality that got distorted.
So something beautiful in your husband's heart has been distorted here, and the journey of marriage is the journey of straightening those things out as we let God's grace have its way with us. But it always comes through the cross. And that means there's going to be suffering, there's going to be bleeding hearts. If there's any truth about following Jesus, it's certainly that it's going to be a bloody mess on on occasion, but it
leads to glory. The bloody mess leads to glory for those who are willing to stay on the cross. It leads to glory. Bless you, dear sister, bless you and come come to TOB one come to TOB one in June. Can you do it? June 14th to the 19th can you come I know that's only like what a week away from when this podcast airs. Here's the here's the deal, if you want to take TOB One online this summer, if you can't come
in person, you could then come to TOB 2 in August. We go deep into the deep waters of healing here. The healing we need, it's the vision we need to be to be healed from all these lies. We believe. If we're not availing ourselves of what John Paul the Second has given us, given us, we're we're in the boxing ring with our hands tied behind our backs and the enemy doesn't have his hands tied behind his back. He's pummelling us and we can't
even defend ourselves because we don't know the vision. Without a vision, Scripture says we perish. There is a vision here of why God made us male and female. There's a vision of what went wrong with the fall that you are now experiencing in your marriage. You're experiencing what went wrong with the fall. And there is a vision for entering into the grace of redemption, to untwist in US what sin has twisted. JP 2 gives us that vision. The mission of the Theology of the Body Institute is to translate that vision into
categories, language, story, art that allows that dense scholarship of JP 2 to resonate in our hearts. Please take up the resources and enter in. Yeah. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Hello, Christopher and Wendy, I've recently stumbled upon your podcast, and I've found so much joy in listening and learning more deeply about the truth and
beauty of the marital embrace. However, I've also found much sorrow, not due to any of your content, but rather as it pertains to my own marriage. I was raised Catholic and practiced the faith through college, but I did not recognize or understand the fullness of truth and beautiful mysteries held within the Church. Out of my own fault, lack of understanding and selfishness, my wife and I were married
outside the Catholic Church. She, though a Protestant, still had a deep love for God and strong faith that I felt was enough. For the past eight years I've not practiced my faith. However, as of late, I have had a deep and real call back to the church. Bless. You. Brother, this is due in part to prolonged sinful behavior, particularly pertaining to lust. Without access to the sacraments, I'd lost my way and felt myself longing for our Lord
and something deeper and I knew exactly what I needed to do. I felt a strong conviction to go to confession and get back to Church. I was so excited to get back and ready to dive head first into a deeper relationship with Christ and all He has to offer through His Church, especially the Eucharist which I had lacked for so long. In some way, my wife was blindsided by this decision and not thrilled, to say the least. I was thoroughly disappointed
and I'm ashamed to say I've taken a step back from re entering the church out of fear of conflict between my wife and me. I love my wife dearly, she's a beautiful woman of God and I truly believe for God. I do not understand where this opposition toward the Catholic faith stems from, but it has made for some serious challenges in our marriage, and out of my own weak and timid heart, I've found it hard to bring up in conversation.
I'm in no way blaming my wife for any of this. In fact, the fault is upon me. All of this has left me questioning many things and made it hard for me to embrace her without some sort of resentment, especially within our marriage. Is it sinful for us to come together in our nuptial embrace outside of the church where I found the truth to be? Is our marriage invalid for the same reason? I know there's so much to unpack here, but I could and would
greatly appreciate your advice and clarification on some of this. God bless your brother. Wow. Wow, Wow. First, I just want to praise God at the mighty work of grace underway in your life. Yeah. Wow, Wow. There's a tsunami. I just. I sense a tsunami of graces, brother. And tsunamis can be overwhelming. Yeah. I I, I, I Yeah. Wow.
Wow, there are so many layers to your question and we would have to do like 3 episodes to begin to do justice to the multiple layers here. But brother, may I point you in the direction of my question and answer book, Good News About Sex and Marriage. You will find very, very clear and I believe helpful answers to virtually all of your questions. And if a specific question you have is not specifically
answered in that book, you will have the tools through that book to arrive at the intelligent and proper answer. What I, what I want to invite you to and encourage you to, to have hope. There are, I believe, prejudices in your wife's heart that come from a Protestant upbringing. I don't know if it was a specifically anti Catholic Protestant upbringing, but let's face it, whatever brand of
Protestantism there someone is, part of what they're protesting is the Catholic Church. And to greater or lesser degrees, that protest can go very deep and become a hardened prejudice, fear, rejection. And I'm sure to some degree that's what's going on here. And obviously that's causing waves, that's causing problems. And you are trying, I can tell
you're trying to navigate this storm. You're trying to navigate some really rough waters here. And there are delicate questions. And how to apply the church's teaching into these delicate matters is not always just straightforward. In black and white, the church's teaching is clear. I am not saying there's room for compromising the church's teaching, but how to navigate in very sensitive places like you
are in? That's tricky business. Here's what I would suggest there again, I want to just be a voice of hope. Brother, there is a mighty work of grace here and I invite you just to stay aware, stay awake. There's that expression in scripture. Remain awake, right? Don't fall asleep and obviously that does not mean don't go to bed at night. It means keep your heart attentive to what the Lord is
doing. He's doing something mighty for you and for your family. Here. Here's what I suggest. I've written a book for Protestants called Our Bodies Tell God's Story. Our Bodies Tell God's Story. Is that the title of that book? Because I have a study series called Our Bodies Proclaim the Gospel and I sometimes get them mixed up. Me too, You got the right way. OK, our bodies tell God's story.
What that book is. It's the theology of the body for beginners book translated into Protestant friendly language without compromising any of the truth. I I just share it in a language that Protestants can understand and can relate to 'cause I speak both Catholic and Protestant. I bilingual in that sense. And Saint Paul says be all things to to all men. So that's why I wrote this book.
Read that together. Ask your wife, can we please, can we please explore this together? Can we, and, and here's another thing I would suggest to you, brother, educate yourself in the Catholic teaching so that you can speak intelligently, so that you can answer her questions, her objections with tenderness. And you don't have to know everything inside and out. You don't have to become like some, you know, star apologist or something, but become
knowledgeable, have a working knowledge. And you can humbly say, honey, I, I, maybe I don't know the answer to that question right now, but can we explore together? Can we find answers together? I think the with the emphasis on together, can we explore together? Because I think she sees you're getting involved and returning to the Catholic Church as threat to your relationship. If you can under score the let's explore together, let's talk together, let's learn together,
let's find answers together, I think that will ease some of her concern and some of her fears. Would she be open? I don't know, I don't know. Would she be open to coming to a course here at the Theology of the Body Institute, The two of you together? I don't know. Share with her what's exciting you. Share with her what's stirring in your heart. Wendy and I often talk on this podcast about how important it
is, even when it's scary. And I get it. I get it why it's scary. You don't want to rock the boat. You don't want to cause tensions. But you know what? Sometimes we don't rock the boat intentionally, but in being humbly honest about what you're really experiencing might cause unavoidable tension and conflict. And that's OK if you approach it
humbly, if you say, honey, I, I need this might be difficult, but I need to learn how to express to you what I'm experiencing. And I know that you desire for me to be closer to the God who made us. I know that you desire for our marriage to be sanctified and under God's graces and in his graces. And I'm, I'm in a stage in our lives where I need to explore, I need to seek and I want to do it together.
If you're willing, but share what's really going on in your heart and let her share what's really going on in her heart like honest naked communication. Honest naked communication, probably with your clothes on, but you know what I mean. Naked in the sense of really exposing your heart. Honest communication, naked communication, humble sharing of your hearts in a way that makes you feel exposed.
I believe this is the way forward. And trusting and calling upon, trusting in and calling upon God's graces. Brother, we all have to get down to a fundamental place in our hearts where we live, the first commandment where we understand that God is God and He deserves the number one place in my life, even if it ruffles feathers.
Fidelity to God first. Fidelity to God first, even if it ruffles feathers, will always bear good fruit in the long run. Compromise in your relationship with God to keep the peace. Compromise in pursuing the Lord's face to keep the peace. Might in the short term, have some benefit.
In the long term, this is not the way to go. And that that can be. Yeah, I can really rock the boat. It can really ruffle feathers. But you're choosing God above all else is also a mighty, mighty, mighty witness. And in your wife's heart of hearts, she will admire you for seeking the Lord above all else. Seek first his Kingdom. Seek first His Kingdom above all
else, and all else will be granted to you. That's the promise of the Lord. The one thing that's just sitting in my heart as I'm praying for this couple is a sense of of the husband clearly, as you were saying there at the end, needs to put God first and and needs to follow what the Spirit has been putting on his heart.
Some of it is really important, you know, to be in grace in order to live the life he's called to live. But something that was just in my prayer for them was for him to pray that the Lord increase his gratitude for his wife, for who she is, as an unrepeatable and irreplaceable gift to him.
That as if he would keep that as part of his prayer and his journey, that the Lord would increase the way he sees her and increase his gratitude for her. That will inform how he lives with her. You know that she will know his gratitude for him, his gratitude for her. She can't miss it because it will just flow in the way that they are living. Even if there is conflict and
difficulty. I think that praying to be grateful for the gift of this person will bear good fruit in the midst of a time that is different and there's change and there's adjustments that are going on, but that's just my sense. We lift you up, brother. We ask Lord, that you would shine your light in these difficult places in their relationship, bring about true
conversion of heart in both of them. We ask this in your name, Jesus. Thank you, everybody who submitted questions. We know we can't get to all of them, but we're so grateful that you continue to send them our way. And we don't have a podcast without you guys, so that's right. Thank you so much. You're a gift to us. It's a joy to be a gift to you. Lord, we ask for the grace. That we would all become the gift that we.
Are Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...
🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...
This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...