Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Sexual arousal in prayer, Did the Holy Spirit become a sperm?, Artist tempted by nude art | ACW343

Jul 28, 202555 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: I’ve broken free from porn and masturbation since returning to the Church, but now I experience arousal during deep prayer. It distracts and disturbs me - how can I pray through it without shame or confusion? My kids ask: If Mary conceived by the Holy Spirit, did the Spirit become physical - like a sperm? How do I explain this? As a virgin in an art class drawing nude figures, I feel shame, fear, and temptation. How can I see the body with purity and maturity without falling into lust or fantasy? Resources: ⁠⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠⁠ JPII Legacy Foundation Website What to Do With Your Sexual Needs YouTube Video Sexual Needs Into Prayer YouTube Video --- Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎥 Check out our ⁠⁠⁠YouTube Channel⁠⁠⁠ 📚 View our ⁠⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠⁠ to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 ⁠⁠GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE⁠⁠ by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ ⁠⁠Join us on one of our pilgrimages!⁠⁠ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠ ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Welcome to another episode, everybody. Yes, Hi, podcast listeners. Hey, Wendy. Yeah. I hear you just took this course by this guy named Christopher W, Who seems to think that the theology of the body can illuminate the whole catechism or something. Right, right. I did. It's true. Is it? Is it true? Can the can the theology of the

body illuminate the whole catechism like for reals? Absolutely. What did he say? Listeners, what we're talking about here is that I did get to go to the Theology of the Body and the New Evangelization course this past week. We had a hundred students from around the US and from multiple countries, Europe, South America, Canada. Where else? Across Europe, Croatia, Spain. Yeah, Poland, Australia.

Yeah, Australia. Gosh, it was a great, great week. But I'm going to stop now because I want to hear what you think. It was great and I did meet many podcast listeners. So if you're listening now, ah, I've seen your face, I've given you hugs and it's really awesome to be able to picture each one of you as we're recording. Just it's so good to know who's listening out there and just to feel that connection. And a funny thing several listeners said was I feel like

we're friends, but but my voice is familiar to them. I know you, but you don't know me. Yeah, but you know what? In the Lord we are, you know, that's that's a beautiful thing. I like that. What was the take away for you Wendy? Taking the course yeah, I you know it is called the LG, the body and the new evangelization. So not just and the Creed, but I think that kind of reflecting on evangelization, the need for the new evangelization, the the state of our hearts that have

become kind of crusty and stuck, you know, was kind of we're looking at that and looking at like, how do we how do we break out of that? And something that really struck me in that was reflecting when you were teaching on Jesus's encounter with the woman at the well and how how stuck she was. She was very stuck. And he, his personal getting to

know her and talking to her about really deep things unstuck her heart in a powerful way and changed her life. And I, I don't know, I just felt that was really beautiful image. Like I was feeling it almost more like as you talked about later in the week, the we are needing regular evangelization ourselves. And it was for me, like reflecting on that story was like a deeper evangelization of

my heart in believing in the depth of the Lord's personal interest in me and my story and what he can do in my life. So that was super powerful for me. Yeah, I one of the themes of the week was to become more and more effective evangelizers. We have to be more and more effectively evangelized. And I, I felt myself going deeper. There was a day Thursday in the week when I had to take my teacher's hat off and and

receive a grace that was an old wound from my childhood. I won't get into all the details of it right here, but it went so much deeper and I realized I had, I had been on a journey of a certain amount of healing there, but I need to, I needed to let Jesus come into a memory that from childhood that was painful. And, and I realized that I was trying to process my pain myself as a boy because I didn't know I could open my pain to Christ. So I, I was just managing it

myself and I, I went deeper. It was a really beautiful week for me. So thank you, Lord, for that. A deeper evangelization for me. And one of the main themes of the week was the idea of retrieving what the words of the Creed, what the Church means when she's talking about the sacraments, what the Church means when she's talking about the moral life, what the church means when she's talking about prayer. You know, we, we know all these words, one God, three persons. We can speak about, you know,

born of the Virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate. We can talk about the seven sacraments. We can talk about the 10 commandments. We can talk about a life of prayer. But sometimes, maybe even oftentimes, the words we used are not attached to the meaning that the church actually intends. And one of the real telling signs of that is the climax of the course is when we go through the Our Father having learned what what the Church means by

professing her faith in the creed, the sacraments, the moral life, the life of prayer. And on Friday morning at the end of the week, we go through the Our Father and I. I asked the students, how many of you knew that that's what the Our Father meant. And hardly any hands go up like we do. We think we know what it means, but we don't really know what it means. Please spend some time with the catechism's reflection on the Our Father. And if you really want to dive deeply into your faith, please check out our online course

schedule for the next time. We will be offering online the new Evangelization course 'cause we only offer it live every couple years. So it's not going to come up live again probably till 2027 or so, but we will be offering it online. So Wendy, I'll just take this opportunity to promote what's going on a little bit at the institute. Check out the online courses, but also some in person courses that I want people to be aware of. Yes, our online courses impact people beautifully. It can really change your life.

But there's nothing like coming to Pennsylvania and having five days immersed in this teaching. And you know, it's, we teach right in the Chapel. We, we have our courses at a Protestant retreat center. And one of the benefits of that is the local Bishop gives us permission to turn the classroom into a Chapel, which means you're getting 30 hours of adoration in five days. There's all the interaction with the other students from around the world. There's time for confession. We have a penance service on

Wednesday night during the course. We watch a movie together, it coming in person. There's just something about teaching theology of the body in the flesh that is life changing. We have a Theology of the Body Level 1 course in October in person, taught by my esteemed colleague and dear friend Bill Donaghy. He's excellent, superb. You're not going to want to miss that if you want to dive deeply into John Paul the Second's master work called Love and Responsibility, which is a philosophical look at the inner workings of the human heart when

it comes to love and sexual attraction, and where it can go off course and how we get it back on course. It is the medicine the modern world so desperately needs. Come check that out. I am Co teaching that with my esteemed colleague Jeanette Clark, November 2nd to the 7th. So yeah, check that out. And if money is ever an obstacle, if that's the only reason you're not taking one of our courses, please, please apply for a scholarship. We are building up our scholarship fund through the

Saint John Paul the Second Legacy Foundation. If there's any listeners out there who want to be part of enabling us to provide scholarships and fund what we do, please would you click on the link for the Saint John Paul the Second Legacy Foundation to make a tax deductible donation. We would be so, so grateful to you. Awesome. Are you ready for a question now from one of our esteemed patrons? Yes, let's do it. I said it that way 'cause you said esteemed twice. And now you said it three times.

Now it's like a Trinitarian esteemed. That's right, this is from an anonymous patron. Thank you, dear anonymous esteemed patron, for your monthly support of our work. We're so grateful to you and I hope all the patrons out there that you're taking benefit taking, taking advantage is what I wanted to say of the benefits, exclusive benefits that we offer our esteemed patrons. If you haven't been to the Patreon website in a while, go check it out. Mm hmm. All right, here it is. I have a long history of

pornography and masturbation, but have ceased engaging in these behaviors since reverting to Catholicism a few years ago, thanks be to God. In the intervening years, I've been cleaning up the unhealthy thought patterns and habits that I developed along the way, and I'm now in a much healthier place. Thanks be to. God. Recently, however, I've run into an issue in my prayer life. Often when entering into deep, meditative prayer, my body becomes physically aroused.

This takes me out of prayer and makes me feel dirty. I want to persist in prayer at these times, but don't want to entertain these sensations. I usually just end up frustrated and confused. Can you offer any advice? Oh, oh, can you tell if this is a male or female? Any indications? Doesn't doesn't matter. I, I can, I, I can, it's, it's applicable to either sex, of course. But yeah, I just thought there

might be a clue, but if not, I. Don't know. Dear, dear listener, dear patron, thank you. Thank you for being so honest and sharing this experience. What I was especially struck by was this person saying when I experienced those feelings of arousal, it takes me out of prayer. Mm hmm. It doesn't need to take you out of prayer. We were just in our course last week talking about this quote from JP 2 where he's talking about praying always.

And he says how can we pray always? Well, the truth is, he says every human experience. How? How many human experience there's to what extent the human experience, every human experience. Now, would every human experience include the experience of sexual arousal? That's one of the every. That's one of the every right, every human experience, says JP 2 and the Saints throughout the whole Christian tradition. Every human experience can be turned into prayer. Every human experience.

This was another quote from our study guide last week. Every human experience must be submitted to the Paschal mystery. What does that mean? Allowing the miracle of the death and resurrection to come into our experiences, to redeem them, to transform them. And what we have when we allow our sexual arousal to be penetrated and permeated. Those are words John Paul 2 likes to use. Penetrated and permeated by the

Holy Spirit, by the power of redemption, that very experience of sexual arousal can become the holy experience of longing for God. Now, a person who has a long history, as this person does, of pornography use and masturbation, there's going to be a need of a deep cleansing, a deep transformation, because the very psychological content, if

you will, of arousal, the connotation of sexual arousal for a person with a long history of pornography use and and masturbation, the connotation of that arousal, understandably in that context is, is lust something that does pop us out of prayer, something that does take us in a contrary direction. But remember this, my brothers and sisters, remember this. The devil doesn't have his own clay. Sexual arousal does not belong to him.

The only clay that exists is God's clay. God looked at everything he made and said, behold, it's very good. God made sexual arousal. It has become twisted by sin. It has become something selfish. It has become something twisted and distorted. But that twisted clay can be untwisted as we submit it to the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. We let the Holy Spirit in. It might be as simple as this. You're, you're in this place of prayer, you're in a place of deep meditation, and your body is having a reaction.

Instead of jumping out of prayer, stay right in it. Lord, I praise you and I thank you for the way you made me as a man or as a woman to experience arousal. What is your plan for arousal? Your plan for arousal is to teach me what it means to love in your image. Ultimately, the union of the sexes, the two become one flesh. This is a great mystery that reveals, proclaims, and enables

us to participate in the ever greater mystery of Christ's love for the church. Ultimately, the the all the yearnings of our hearts are meant to become a longing for God, meant to be open to the Lord. And so in that place of arousal, Lord, I recognize there's something lustful in me. I recognize there's something selfish in me, but I invite your Holy Spirit. Come Holy Spirit, come Holy Spirit, into my mind, into my heart, into my very body, into my desires.

Reorient them away from lust, away from selfishness, away from that self indulgent pattern I was immersed in for so long with pornography and masturbation. Redirect all of these energies, redirect these powers, redirect the very sentiment of my heart and my mind and my body towards the truth of self giving love and towards the truth of longing ultimately, not just for a holy

marital embrace, if I'm called the marriage, which is beautiful and wonderful, but it's only a sacrament of the ultimate embrace, which is the marriage of the Lamb. The Bible begins with the marriage of man and woman. It ends with the marriage of Christ and the Church and prayer. Pope Benedict the 16th says prayer, properly understood, is nothing other than becoming a longing for God. Pope Benedict the 16th also says that when the Christian prays, he is seeking nuptial union with

the Lord. Now what does that mean? It means we are destined for an ecstasy of love and union with the living God that the Bible compares more than any other image the Bible uses to describe the ecstasy that awaits us in heaven. Bible uses the love of husband and wife, the union of husband and wife. For this reason, a man will leave his father and mother, be joined to his wife, and the two will become one flesh. This is a great mystery. Saint Paul tells us this is a

great mystery, and it refers to Christ in the church. Really and truly, my brother or sister who wrote this question, really and truly in God's design, in God's plan, in God's purpose, in God's desire for you. That experience of arousal in prayer is a wooing from heaven of your heart, mind, and body toward heaven. Let the Holy Spirit come in. And if they're diseased images attached to that arousal, just say, Lord, there's the diseased

image. I give that diseased image, that twisted clay to you. I invite your Holy Spirit in and I ask you, please to untwist it. I'm going to have our producer place a link in the show notes to this episode for a a YouTube video. It's one of our most popular on our channel. I think it's called Turning erotic desire into prayer, something like that. I, I forget the exact title, but it's along those lines. Juan, you'll know the one I'm talking about. Could you please include that link in the show notes?

And I invite everyone who wants to take a deeper step here, especially this person who submitted this question, to take a look at that that link. Watch that video. Yeah. I, I think I just want to add like there are steps in our personal journey that we're all on. Each one of us is on this unique journey and in, in this listener's process of, of growth, which there's so much shared here about graces and

about just healings and new life being possible. And it's so encouraging. And I just wonder if this prayer experience has been introduced a little bit of an element of discouragement into the journey. Like, Oh, I, you know, I, I've been so loved by the Lord. I've seen God's love in the ways that I've grown here because I, you know, I've surrendered and I, I've chosen to follow him. And then here's this like

discouraging moment of like here I am like entering into a place of deeper peace in the Lord's presence. What's this? Why this reminder? I don't I don't want that reminder like that phrase that the listener used to. I feel dirty like like those reminders are kind of painful. And I just wonder if if as what you're sharing is such a hopeful vision of a genuine full

integration and a like a coming to love the body and its ability to sense the joy of being a gift, even you know what it's just hinted at. You know, that little bit of arousal is, is like, wow, Lord, like something in me, you know, registered. Like it would be a joy to be received as a gift. You know, that's, that's maybe one of the things that could like produce that effect in our

bodies or others, of course. But at any rate, like, I just think, you know, maybe there's, there's steps along the way that could just be like, OK, I have this physical sensation, Lord, I just show me my heart right now. Like am I afraid or am I consoled? Am I, you know what, What else is going on in me along with this? And can I stay in the heart space that I'm in?

Inviting you into my experience, Lord, inviting you to shine your light in my heart right now and not allow this feeling of disturbance and disappointment? Kind of. Negate the the beautiful relating that's going on. We talked about that in the course that conversation that both ways dialogue and and I feel like when you when this listener described like entering this deep meditative prayer, I

feel like the image I have is sort of a a receptive space. Maybe it's, it might be silent, but it's it's open and you know, isn't that beautiful to have some physical response to just being in a place of openness. So I just, I just encourage you, just as you did Christopher, to find ways to not reject your body, but to let that experience now that you're having be

another stage in this beautiful journey that you've been on. Not let any voice say to you, you can't progress, you're stuck. Those are untrue things. Those are lies. So whatever would allow you to stay present with the Lord, more deeply opening your heart, allowing more deeply His seeing of you as you're opening yourself, let Him see you, and let Him tell you the truth of

the goodness of your body. Amen to that. You'll remember Wendy last week at the course when I I said to the students, when you're experiencing arousal, it might be any time of the day, during a time of prayer or any other time. And the spiritual masters talk about this. This is not a foreign experience. You're you're in a place of prayer. There's a particular vulnerability, as Wendy was saying, an openness and it's it's there can be an integrated experience of the body

responding to spiritual touches. That's an integration. Now you have a history here that that needs some more healing, it sounds like to me. But here's what I said to the students. When you experience something like this, don't shame it, don't blame it, don't defame it. Meaning the desire you're experiencing. Rather rename it. At its root, this is Holy Arrows. At its root, something's gotten twisted, but at its root, we can rename this as Holy Arrows.

So rename it, reframe it. You're in a battle between good and evil here, and the enemy wants to pull you in in a direction that's going to lead you astray. The Holy Spirit wants to pull all of your humanity, your sexuality included in a holy direction. So reframe it. I'm in a battle between good and evil, and I'm choosing the good. I'm inviting the Spirit here, so rename it Holy Eros, reframe it and with God's grace re aim it towards the marriage of the Lamb.

Lord, you have made me for yourself, and my heart is restless till I rest in you. That can be an integral experience of that restlessness, purified, redeemed, untwisted and properly aimed towards our destiny. This is a a direct quote from Pope Benedict the 16th Eros. At its heart is the holy passion that desires God. There it is. It's the holy passion that desires God. It gets and that's why the enemy

attacks here. It gets twisted up, but it can be, it gets misdirected, it gets mis mis aimed, but by God's grace it can be re aimed. And that's what prayer is. It's the re aiming of our arrows, of our yearning, of our passion, of our longing, of our thirst towards God's passion, towards God's holy arrows, towards God's thirst for US. Prayer, the catechism says, is nothing other than our thirst encountering God's thirst and God's thirst encountering ours.

There it is. Hey everybody, this is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on tour this year. We're going to places like Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Michigan, and also other countries like United Kingdom, Germany, Ecuador, and Brazil. We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our events schedule in the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Peace. The next question is from a listener named Sonia. Hello, Sonia. Dear Christopher and Wendy, thank you so much for this podcast. I listen to it weekly, and in

the last three years it has been an enormous help for my faith and for my daily life as a wife and a mom of five small children. Bless you, bless you. My question today might seem a little weird, but I keep asking myself this. Was there in some way an incarnation of the Holy Spirit? If Mary's egg was fertilized by the Holy Spirit, I can't help but think that there must have been a moment in which the Holy Spirit took on physical reality,

became a sperm in that particular moment, didn't it? My children ask a lot of questions and I sometimes struggle to answer them. This is one of them. Sonia, bless you, bless you, bless you. I know where you're going with this and there is a certain I'm going to say that with caution and qualification, which I'll get to in a moment. A certain truth to to your line of thought. But but no, there the Holy Spirit did not become a a sperm in in that sense, it did not.

The Holy Spirit remained the Holy Spirit without becoming physical. Only the second person of the Trinity in the proper sense of the word incarnation has been incarnated. The Spirit was sent to be. The Catechism uses the word fecundate. I believe the fecundating reality that allowed Mary to conceive fecundation means to be fecund, fertile. But what we have, what we have at the moment of the

incarnation, the moment the Holy Spirit, that fire of God, shall we say, kissed Mary's egg, I don't know how else to put it. But in that moment what we have is the revelation of the eternal generation of the Son. So from all eternity the Father is generating the Son, Not in a sexual way, in a purely spiritual, purely divine way. From all eternity the Father is generating the Son. He is never not generating the sun. He always has been generating

the sun. He's generating the sun right now. He will eternally generate the sun. What happened 2000 years ago is that the infinite mystery, the eternal mystery of the Father generating the sun, crossed the abyss between Infinity and this, this dimension of time and space, infinitude, and the very same reality of the eternal generation of the sun was now revealed in the darkness of a woman's womb.

So the divine infinite power of generation is wed to the finite human power of generation in the womb of Mary and the the divine power of generation, the human power of generation, God's power, man's power, meaning man in the general sense, all of us, the human power, this divine generation and human generation wed together generated a God, man, astounding, astounding.

But the Holy Spirit did not become a sperm to make that happen. It was. It was not a transmutation of divine generation into human generation, as if the Holy Spirit would have to 1st become a sperm for this to happen. It was the wedding mysterious beyond what we can ever comprehend. It was the wedding of divine generation with human generation. It's an article of faith that we can't analyze under a microscope.

We accepted in faith born of the Virgin Mary, conceived by the power of the Holy Spirit, But where you are on to a certain truth in what you're getting at here. I will quote from Saint Maximilian Colby, who has some daring, daring theology, and he dares to say that because Mary becomes in through the Annunciation in this way, the

spouse of the Holy Spirit, she becomes in a sense, and he uses an important qualifier here. He says Mary is the quasi incarnation of the Holy Spirit. Quasi is very important, right? She's kind of sorta, she manifests in her flesh the power of the Holy Spirit more than any other human person. Now, Christ is a divine person, not a human person.

He's a divine person wed to a human nature. He's not a human person. He remains a divine person. So the qualifier Jesus, of course, in his divinity, wed to the human nature, manifests the Holy Spirit even more than Mary. But Mary as a human person is the human person that manifests the Holy Spirit and the power of the Holy Spirit more than any other human person. So in this sense, in a very bold kind of audacious statement, St. Maximilian Colby dares to say

that Mary in a certain way is the quasi incarnation of the Holy Spirit. So I can go with that, with all those qualifiers, but we can't go with the idea that the Holy Spirit became a sperm. That would be like a transmutation of divine thick foundation. We got a lot of fancy words in this one. Yeah, as, as Albacetti says, my mentor, Lorenzo Albacetti, we we

used a lot of videos of his in the in the course last week. And he says whenever he says something fancy, he'll say something like, well, this is not a cheap course, so we should charge more. We use fancy words in this course. It's not a cheap course. We use fancy words on occasion. Listening to you talk to Sonya, it was kind of enlightening for me, a little bit of my own, like, theological education, because I was realizing, like, as you were talking about this, especially when you got into

Maximilian Colby, it was zooming me back to like, I don't know, maybe like a year into our marriage. You were reading some works of Maximilian Colby at the time and you were getting all fired up. Yeah. About some ideas that he was proposing. And, you know, just like they. It's not that it's like firm teaching of the church, but it's like, you know, a very holy man reflecting on things in a beautiful way.

And, and I was realizing like just kind of how much the Lord has used your discoveries for my education over the years. And that was just like a happy realization. That memory coming to me as you were talking to Sonia, but also thinking that's also kind of in a way what happens with listeners to the podcast, you know, may not be a laid out course, but so many questions lead to, you know, real

education in in theology and and sometimes in a situation like this, there's a certain, well, actually the answer's no, the church doesn't teach that. And, and that's OK that we kind of pictured it that way and, and it actually says, you know what? It leaves the question of like the full set of chromosomes that every biologically we all need. Like, how did Christ have that? Like just to stay in the, we actually don't mystery, we don't

know. And we just leave it there. And there's something just beautiful about having that boundary and saying this is important and we'll we'll trust that it's important and it'll be revealed. Yeah. What I, what I like about, as you're pointing out, what I like about Sonia's line of questioning is she's, she's entering in, she says, well, what about this and what about that? How does this, how does this work? That's faith seeking, understanding, and that's what we call theology. That's faith wanting to know how does this work? And, and the church reflects

over 2000 years on these questions and comes up with, OK, here are the boundaries in which there's mystery here we'll never know or comprehend. But we do know these things within these boundaries. And, and yeah, the idea of the Holy Spirit becoming a sperm for the conception of Christ to happen is outside those boundaries. So, yeah, but great, great questioning there, Sonia, Keep pressing in. That's how we learn and grow and discover the treasures of the church. Yeah. Our next question is from a listener named Maria. Hi, Maria.

I'm a single 29 year old woman and a virgin by God. By the grace of God. I've heard you mention before how true art and beauty can redirect our gaze and restore our way of seeing the human body. I'm in a painting class where I'm being assigned to draw a naked human figure. I notice how out of tune with the truth my heart is, because when looking at a book of naked

men and women to find my next reference for my drawing, there is something in me that doesn't want to look, that feels a certain shame or even fear. I see how God is inviting me to a deeper conversion in this area, to a purification of how I see even my own sexuality. Bless, bless, bless. Bless. I'm just not so sure how to get there. Bless. You, Maria. I've been praying to God to help me here. I'm afraid that because I have

much healing to do in this area, looking at these naked bodies may stir in me certain desires, including lustful ones, and that I may use these images in my head to imagine fantasies later. I struggle with masturbation every now and then. I'm not sure how to proceed here. Any word of advice? I don't want to remain naive or childish about this and want to grow into the fullness of

maturity and holiness and appreciate the beauty of the body without embarrassment. Maria, I love your heart. Me too. And I'm just, I'm feeling it, so I'm going to sing it. Oh, Maria, I love you, girl. Oh my Maria, that I think that's like Jesus. That's Jesus singing to your heart. That's what I'm feeling. Jesus loves your heart and he

has you on a pilgrimage and you're at a stage of your pilgrimage where a lot of people say, I don't know how to navigate this. It's too scary. I'm just going to, I'm just stop here or, or, or turn back and just stay in the safety zone of, of, of gaining custody of my eyes and what we traditionally call avoiding the occasion of sin. Now I am all for that. Please let me say that loudly and clearly, right?

Christian, know thyself. This is ancient wisdom that is always applicable. Christian, know thyself. If you are aware that if you were to take such an art class, and I mean this beyond Maria, I'm not just speaking to Maria. I'm speaking to all of our listeners. If such an art class would be nothing but an occasion to stoke the flames of lust in your heart, by all means don't take such an art class. But nor should you project onto the whole human race that it is impossible to take such an art

class without lusting, because if you dig your heels in there, you are guilty of what Saint John Paul the Second calls the interpretation of suspicion. It's the idea that the only way to look at the human body is through the prism of lust. That is the interpretation of suspicion, and that is a lie from hell. Redemption is a reality, John Paul the Second says, a reality that is truly effective in our

lives. And it seems to me, Maria, from what you are sharing, that you are at a point on your pilgrimage where the Lord may be inviting you out of the safety of the boat. This is a delicate step in the spiritual journey where we see Jesus out on the water and he's saying, Maria, keep your eyes on me and you can step out of that boat and walk on water. And everything in us, our whole

history, our understanding of the world, our own experiences in life, say, what are you? What? Get out of the boat. What? What? I'll I'll sink. With your eyes set on Jesus Christ, you can walk on water. Not true enough. The moment you take your eyes off Jesus, as Peter did, you'll sink. This is not something that any human being can do on his own

strength. But with your eyes set on Christ, you can do what feels humanly impossible, and without Christ, in fact, is humanly impossible. And when Peter sank, Jesus did not scold him and say, what are you doing out here amongst the wind and the waves? Get your butt back in the boat. What did you think? Who'd you think you were? He said, why did you doubt? Why did you take your eyes off me? There's a stage in the Christian life. It's called the purgative way or the purgative stage, where we

need to be in the boat and then we progress into what the Saints call the illuminative stage of the journey where the lights come on and the purgation of our hearts. And this is a direct quote from Saint John Paul the second. He says as we press through and continue on the journey with Christ as our teacher, we progress from being purged of sins to an experience of values and and not just following the

commandments by kind of white knuckling it, but the lights come on and we experience an attraction to true values. Again, here's a quote from John Paul. The second he says so, the commandment not to commit adultery becomes, as we continue the journey of Christ, an ever greater awareness. And appreciation of the gratuitous beauty of the human body and an ever deeper

commitment not to violate its dignity. I believe, Maria, that you are at the stage of the journey where the Lord wants to turn the lights on. It's scary. He wants to call you out of the boat. It's scary, but with your eyes fixed on Christ you can do it. And, and, and this is just true spiritual math. It is better to get out of the

boat and falter than it is never to get out of the boat. There is a chance if you get out of the boat you can slip up. Christ is will call you back to faith. He's not going to scold you for getting out of the boat. He will correct you for taking your eyes off him, if indeed you do. But it is possible to get out of the boat and keep your eyes on Jesus. And I'd like to conclude my thoughts here with a a reflection from my friend and colleague in the world of TOB,

Mikhail Waldstein. There was some controversy some years ago, some debate among artists as to whether or not it was ever appropriate for a Catholic artist to go to a class where you had to paint a nude. And some artists were saying, no, a Catholic should never do this. It's always an occasion of sin. And, and Mikhail Waldstein responded as follows. And I agree with him. I think he's spot on. I think he's well nuanced in how

he puts this. So let me just read directly from him. I quote this in the section of my Theology of the Body Explained book in which John Paul the Second talks in the Theology of the Body about the appropriate expression of nakedness in art and the inappropriate expression of nakedness in art. Anyway, here's what Mikhail Wolfstein says. Direct quote. Some images of the naked body push us to concupiscence. That is that the disordered

desire, right? Others do not. John Paul the Second explicitly mentions Greek art as an example of the latter. Going to the Sistine Chapel and looking at the naked women on the ceiling is, for this reason, a very different experience than watching a pornographic movie. It is not presumption. This was the accusation. Some of these Catholic artists who were saying you should never ever go to such an art class were saying it's presumption to think that you could go to such an art class and not fall into

sin. So Mikael, Mikael is responding to that. He says it is not presumption, but the experience of many people that one can look with purity at Michelangelo's nudes and take the light in their beauty. Michelangelo himself must have looked at his naked models in a pure way in order to be able to paint nudes in that pure way. It would most likely be presumption to think one could watch a pornographic movie with the same purity of heart. Yes, I agree. The push towards that disordered desire we call concupiscence in

a pornographic movie is objectively contrary to the dignity of the person, regardless of how one, well, one has mastered one's desires. That push, Volstein says, is a sufficient reason to stop watching such a movie, even if one does not feel oneself sliding into a concupiscence way of looking. Of course, he goes on to say, if one does feel a slide into concupiscence when looking at Michelangelo's nudes, it is a good idea to look away.

That need to look away, however, should also be a trumpet blast, he says, for recognizing that one is not living in accord with the redemption of the body and that one is in need of a serious transformation. So, dear Maria, I think you are giving yourself an honest assessment, looking at your heart, looking at some of the sins you've fallen into, that concern you have. I could fall into sin is, I

think a proper legitimate conclusion. I could, but it's not necessary that you do with it's, it's entirely possible if you get out of the boat here, you could sink, but it is not necessary that you do. If Christ, if Christ is calling you out of the boat, set your eyes on him and get out of the boat and walk to him. Walk to him. The Lord will show you. The Lord wants to show you wants to show all of us.

We're all at different stages of the journey. So I can't make blanket statements about everybody going to a naked art class or not a naked art class, but a class in which you are, you know, sculpting or painting the nude. I can't just say run out there. This is the cure for everyone. I don't know where everybody is on your on their journey. But Maria, you've given us a little insight into where you are on your journey. And it seems to me that the Lord is calling you out of the boat. He wants to show you and he wants to show all of us in due time the true splendor, the true

purity, the true dignity, the true goodness of the human body. And he really can transform us inwardly, not that we'll ever be 100% free in this life of that pool in the wrong direction. But again, just as I said earlier, don't shame it, don't blame it, don't defame it, rename it, reclaim it, reframe it, and by God's grace, re aim it.

This is the journey for us all. Be not afraid, Maria. Keep your eyes on Jesus. Keep your eyes on Jesus. I'm having a memory I'll share of being in some Art Museum and seeing a sculpture of a, a naked girl. So like not a like a maybe a 13 year old or something. So seeing the, the beginning of those, you know, adult forms,

but you know, it's a kind of a time of transition. And, and when I saw it, I was maybe just a little bit past that stage myself, but close enough that it I had this feeling almost as if I had just been exposed. Wow, wow. I don't think I know this story. Yeah, it was like a scary, like look at her. I mean like feeling a shame of being seen by others or something. And I I remember being afraid

but then looking again and and something in me realized it's totally OK that my body looks like that. Hallelujah, Hallelujah. Like, I don't have to be afraid of that, but. And there was something about seeing the art that gave me that message. And so I thank that artist, you know, because that was a that was a like the Lord spoke to me through that work of art. Awesome. Isn't that cool?

That's really cool. And I'm we've been married almost 30 years and I'm just hearing the story. That's a good one. Wendy Yeah, yeah. That that that experience was coming back to me and and another I had an image in my mind praying for Maria and thinking about her of of the the Blessed Mother and I mean her in a very real human way, not like a statue, but real human Blessed Mother sitting with Maria to look at this book she spoke of

with her and maybe talk with her about some feelings that she's having as she's looking in the book. And, and I just share that as a maybe in my heart, I'm feeling like Maria, you need a you need a friend that you can really trust in this experience. And, and I see, I see Mary, I mean, that's your name, Maria. Just wanting to talk about it with you and, and help you to kind of lower the level of those

intense feelings to find questions and thoughts underneath that are really helping you in that process. You're talking about wanting to not remain naive, wanting to be more mature. Like I feel like she wants to journey with you and some of those the steps of that for your for your own growth. So I just share that with you. If if there's some way, and I honestly have experienced this as well. Like literally, if you're

looking at this book in an art classroom, like nobody else has to know that Mary's right there with you. But you can know it and she can, she can be there with you. She can just be listening to your thoughts as if you were having a conversation with her and, and helping you to go beneath the initial reactions that are concerning to, to deeper places that are going to bear that fruit that you're longing for. And just one of the thought I

had is that not every reference picture is the same. So there could be like some feeling of caution any artist would have looking for a reference picture and being kind of taken aback by the intent of the photographer or the model that is trying to stir your lust. So just to recognize that there's not some goal that every reference picture should be equal, you know, so just to, to

use discernment and recognize like, I don't want to enter into that dynamic of certain types of pictures, even if they aren't, you know, officially labeled pornographic, but you're sensing something about it. That creates a a caution that you can also honor that. All artists, you can also honor that. Man, I'm Wendy, I'm so glad you brought that up. And I should have said this earlier, but in the theology of the body, JP2 makes this very

important distinction. He says, what's the difference between a pornographic portrayal of the body and a sacred portrayal or appropriate portrayal of the human body in art? And he says the difference is in the intention of the artist, right? The intention of Michelangelo and the intention of, I mean, you cannot tour the Vatican Museums or the Sistine Chapel or Saint Peter's Basilica and conclude that it's immoral to show nakedness in art. There are more bare breasts in

Saint Peter's Basilica than you can shake a stick at. I, I mean in, in the art, not in, in, in any other way. And there's also a dress code to enter Saint Peter's Basilica. And these are not in contradiction. What is the difference between the nakedness in the in the art in Saint Peter's Basilica and and the pornographic portrayal? It's in the intention of the artist. The intention of the pornographer is specifically to arouse lust in the viewer. The intention of the true artist

is to awaken in awe and wonder at the mystery of our humanity as men and women made in the image and likeness of God. And, and there's see, I think the reason it's so tricky for us is that we've not been told there's another way to see the body. It's either cover it all up or it's pornographic. No, there's another way to see, there's another way to think, there's another way to experience the human body. It's a long journey we have to go on of inner purification. But don't anybody, don't anybody

empty the cross of its power and say it's impossible to go on that journey. You, you are, you are falling for the interpretation of suspicion, and you're emptying the cross of its power. Beware of those, Saint Paul says who, who hold the form of religion, but empty of empty it, of its power. Right To the pure, Saint Paul says everything is pure. To the impure, he says nothing is pure, so, so pray for that purity of heart and do not be

afraid of the inner purifications that are required to go on that pilgrimage to see the body rightly. How desperately we need artists who understand the body rightly and can portray it rightly because we overcome evil with good, right? The evil portrayals of the human body, How do we overcome them? We must overcome them with sacred, holy portrayals of the human body. And, and I'll just close with this.

In the restoration project of the Sistine Chapel, JP 2 ordered the removal of many of the loincloths that previous clerics had ordered to be painted over Michelangelo's original nudes. JP Two. There are a few left for historical reasons, and the others came off and JP two said do it in the name of purity of heart. Because Michelangelo, he said, allowed himself to be guided by those evocative words of the book of Genesis where we read

that the man and his wife were both naked and felt no shame. And then he dedicated the restored Sistine Chapel with all of its nudes. He dedicated it as the sanctuary of the theology of the human body. Kaboom, there it is, there it is. Lord, give us eyes to see. Blessed are the pure of heart, for they shall see God. They shall see the mystery of God revealed through the human body. And what is that mystery? It's the mystery of gift.

That God is gift and He made us in His image, male and female, to be gift to one another. This means we are all called to see rightly, to live rightly, to to be that gift and there is grace, truly grace, poured out to enable us. To become what we are. Let's do it. Let's all of us get out of the boat with our eyes on Jesus. Amen. Ask Christopher W.

It's brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode