Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

Shame on Men's Body Parts, Language of the Marital Union, and Desire for Wisdom of the Saints | ACW314

Jan 6, 202554 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Questions answered this episode: How are men supposed to understand this sudden obsession with p*nis size and measurements? How can one deal with the shame society places on certain male body parts? I’ve been in a relationship with my partner for just over a year now. I’m a Catholic and he is not. He is open and respectful even though he expressed he would wait for me until marriage. I ultimately decided that somehow I was okay with engaging in non-marital sexual relations with him. I realized I had fallen and went to confession. Since then, I’ve been listening to your podcast and others in TOB and now I’m confident that my love for him supersedes any immediate desire for sex. I want marriage to be our expression of dedication and openness to the responsibilities that come with that union and only there is where our bodies truly reflect that covenant. While my partner sees that non-marital relations are a way in which he can express his love, he's once again willing to wait until marriage but the reality is that I’m having a hard time explaining why marriage is the only place where I want to express that. Do you have any advice? What should I do with my strong desires to know the saints when I feel like I’ll never grasp their wisdom in this life? Ask Christopher West is a weekly podcast in which Theology of the Body Institute President Christopher West and his beloved wife Wendy share their humor and wisdom, answering questions about marriage, relationships, life, and the Catholic faith, all in light of John Paul II’s beautiful teachings on the Theology of the Body. 🔥 Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body 📕 Get a copy of Christopher's [Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty](www.eatingthesunrise.com) ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? Join our Patron Community! Submit your question at AskChristopherWest.com. Resources mentioned this week: TOBI COURSE SCHEDULE TOBI Event Calendar Mike Mangione, director of events contact: events@tobinstitute.org Love & Responsibility YouTube Series 🎥 Check out our YouTube Channel 📚 View our COURSE SCHEDULE to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ Want to join us on one of our pilgrimages? Click here 🌟 For professional Catholic Life Coaching, including Porn Recovery: https://www.stevemotylcoaching.com/ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: michele@tobinstitute.org Find Christopher West on Facebook and Instagram. Discover the Theology of the Body Institute. If you enjoy the podcast, help us out by writing a review. Thanks for listening! Christopher and Wendy hope their advice is helpful to you, but they are not licensed counseling professionals. If you are dealing with serious issues, please consult our list of trusted professionals. Featuring music by Mike Mangione.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Happy 2025 everybody. Happy New Year. We're happy to be with you in this new year. We're we're not big New Year's celebrate tours. Is that a word? Celebrate tour? I like it. OK. We we usually sleep through it. I think we are asleep, yes. Yeah. But I was wondering, Wendy, do you have any particularly

memorable New Year's Eve's into a new year? Yes, well, OK, let's just say this is a Jubilee year. It is a 2020. 5 right, the one I was going to say I really remember was Jubilee 2000. Oh yeah, yeah. Yeah. I don't know if you would say the same, but that was very significant. Very significant. And it those of you who were alive then, or maybe people read about it in history books now, there was so much talk about the way that the world was going to

be a disaster because of all the computers in the world that we're going to crash when they. Clicked over to 00. Yeah, that was going to be very bad. There were movies made about it, people bought cabins up in the woods with solar panels and and we even stocked up on a little bit of food just in case. Yes, we did. And water. And toilet paper. But here's the thing, because of that, there was also a sense of a need to pray in a particular way.

And on that New Year's Eve, I remember going to a prayer night at our parish. And I think even though I didn't have a lot of anxiety about, as we used to call it Y2K in the approach of Y2K, I, I did feel gratitude to enter into the new year with such an, a sense of needing grace and needing to be close to the Lord. So that was a a kind of very memorable new year for. Me.

We had two young boys, just one, who had just recently been born. That's right. My goodness. That was the great Jubilee. The great jubilee, indeed. You know what my memorable New Year's I'm thinking of? No what? 94 into 95. OK. What were you and I doing? In fact, that's a great. One, it is a good one, isn't it? Thanks, love. Yeah. OK, this is little confession moment. I hope you're already aware of this, that there were these two different New Year's Eve parties I would I knew were being hosted

by people that we knew. And I was trying to figure out without asking which one you would go to because I want. Oh no, that was the year before. No, no, no, you're thinking the wrong one. Oh, really? Yeah, 94 it into 95 was a different one. OK, tell me about it then. But you can tell this story. I like this story. I did pick the right 1 and I was with you at a New Year's Eve party, right? Well, you were with me, but I don't think the one you're thinking about is the one I'm thinking about.

Go. Ahead, tell your story. Tell your story. I think you're thinking the year before. OK, fine. I think, well, the year I'm thinking of 94 to 95 was when my band was playing. On New Year's. Eve on New Year's Eve at Fatty's in Bethesda, MD. And I had to get off work, yeah, to be able to come. Back and you came to that show that's right, right you so you were thinking about the year before I was. It's true. But but tell that story too. I did, I just told that no but. You why did you, why did you

want to come to the one that I was at? Oh, 'cause I had a crush on you. Oh yes, I wanted to see you and maybe dance with you or something. I I don't think we danced with each other, but it was so nice to see you and. Yeah, but I enjoyed that you made a special effort the next year. That's right, to come to my band playing. At. That nightclub or whatever it was called, fatties, right? And you gave me a very nice shoulder rub at the end of my three hour ordeal of playing

drums for so long. I did. I remember that very well. That was and I, that wasn't another. It was a whole year later. I just wanted to be near you, but by then we had a little bit more of a friendship. Well, we had been friends for a long time at that point, but we were close friends at that point 'cause we had been. Actually invited me to come to the show and yeah, it was just that I had to get off work and travel from New Jersey to Maryland and all that. That was fun. And we were about to start dating. A few. Months later, few months later, that was all 30 years ago.

Yeah, here it comes, the 30th anniversary year of all of our dating and getting engaged and all that and getting married and all that fun stuff. So amazing. OK, that's enough of that. Well, tell me something about what's going on with the TOB Institute here in 2025. I want to give a shout out to anyone who lives in Australia or in that part of the world, maybe New Zealand or South Asia.

If you would like to attend ATOB Institute course, my esteemed colleague Bill Donaghy will be teaching in Sydney, Australia the third week of January. He is teaching the writings of JP 2 on marriage, family and gender. So you don't want to miss it if you are in that part of the world. If you're thinking I'll never be able to attend ATOB Institute course in person 'cause I live so far away, well, we're coming to Australia third week of this

month. Pardon me for my stuffed up, congested sounding voice, but I'm suffering a cold. That's all I have to say about that for now. Check the link in the show notes to learn. More that's awesome and please everyone pray for that. You know that just that there would be an outpouring of the Holy Spirit on that class, that many people would come, that the effects of what they learn would impact their own story and the story of many other people for good for the Kingdom of God.

I do have one more thing to share. Yeah, we have recently found out about a problem on our online event site. Yes. If you have requested that an event come to your area from the TOB Institute over the last eight or nine months and never heard back from us, it's because of a terrible glitch in our system. It wasn't working and we finally were thinking why are we not getting any event requests and we realized our whole way of people requesting events was

malfunctioning. So we're trying to rectify. We have rectified the situation, but if you had reached out to us in the past about having us bring a live event to your area and didn't hear back, I apologize. It was a glitch in our system. Please send an e-mail to events at tobinstitute.org to reinitiate that request and and we will attend to it in a timely manner. I'm so sorry, I apologize for that. Yes. Are you ready for a question

from a patron? This is from an anonymous patron. Hi, Christopher and Wendy, I hope you're having a blessed day. My question is in regard to a particularly male insecurity. As you well know, we live in a very pornographic world, and one of its fruits has been the popularization of some very strange standards regarding the genitals of the male body. As a young man in college, this issue has sadly become a very distressing topic for me. I've repeatedly come across

women, both in person and many more on social media, discussing the importance of quote measuring up and ridiculing and shaming those who don't. From what I hear, some women say this is a very important thing for them, their enjoyment of the marital act and their attraction to a man. They'll say it's not the only thing, but that it's a big deal. This makes the thought of nudity and marital relations very anxiety producing for me. I fear that I will be compared,

especially if the woman I want to marry has had previous sexual experiences. I fear that I'll be seen as less than for something so private and out of my control, or that I won't be able to give my wife an enjoyment she will be satisfied with. And it's deeply hurtful. All I've been able to find on this topic are secular sources which are just as twisted from the perspective of the TOB. How are we men supposed to understand this sudden obsession

with size and measurements? How can one deal with the shame society places on certain male bodies? What if the woman I want to marry does have a preference for something like that? God bless you, my dear brother. Thank you. Thank you for being so honest, for putting this in the light. It is tragedy of our world that we are measured up, sized up compared to images of other

people that we are bombarded with in a media culture and particularly in our pornographic media culture. And these images, these ideas, they lodge so deeply in our minds and our hearts, and they form and shape us and create all kinds of very understandable fears, insecurities. Am I lovable? Am I desirable? Am IA good gift? Can I be a good gift?

And it really is the rotten fruit of what we could call depersonalization by pornification. Let me say that again. It is the rotten fruit of what we could call depersonalization by pornification. We have ruptured the body from the person. We have ruptured body parts from the person.

There is no such thing as I'm just going to use the anatomical term. There is no such thing as a penis. That is an abstraction. You know the the idea I want to be with, I want to be with a man. A woman might say I want to be with a man with a large penis. Well, there's no such thing as a large penis. There is only John's penis or George's penis or or Frank's penis.

The penis is the expression of that person. The person expresses himself in that intimate way through his male genitals, in the gift of himself, his entire self. When we rupture body parts from the person, you get terrible abstractions. The person is who we should. The person is whom we should be falling in love with, not mere

body parts, but the entire person, body and soul. My dear brother, do not marry a woman would be my advice who is bent on that abstraction. Do not marry a woman who is not interested in being integrated herself and loving your entire integral integrated person. Now, we we all live in this fractured world where we are disintegrated.

And sadly, the large majority of us have been terribly, terribly all the more disintegrated by what we've exposed ourselves to in a pornographic culture. And I've been on my own journey of reintegrating from depersonalization by pornification. So no one is going to be unscathed here. But at a bare minimum, do not marry a woman who is not committed to the journey of

reintegration and a woman who would say, well, I'm not going to marry you because you don't measure up. Well. Well, that woman is not committed to the journey of reintegration, of personalization through purification, which would be the opposite of depersonalization through pornification, right? The journey is personalizing the body, incarnating the person through reintegration, which happens via purification of mind

and heart. And that means surrendering all those pornographic images to which we've been exposed to the Lord, asking him to untwist in our minds and our hearts what sin has twisted to put us on a path of wholeness. Reintegration. It's a lifelong journey. No one can ever say I've arrived. No one can ever say, you know, I, oh, I'm, I may have struggled with that at one point, but I'm all healed now.

No, it's a journey we have to recommit to every single day of our lives. The commitment to reintegration through purification so that we can experience personalization of the body and incarnation of the person. The woman who falls in love with you will want to receive you and open to your gift. A woman who is, you know, put

off because you don't measure up to whatever is not the kind of woman you would want to spend your life with. Again, I've had my own struggles here with going in the other direction, the way my mind was warped. Wendy, I know you have borne these burdens with me, and it's painful. You are right to be pained by this. You are right to be crying out in your heart that this is an injustice to your person. You are absolutely right, my brother. It is an injustice for a woman to think that way, for a woman

to measure you based on some abstract, abstract pornographic standard. Lovemaking is not a mechanical experience when it's truly love making, when it's truly the gift of oneself, a renewal of wedding vows, saying to the other with your body, I will never leave you, I will never forsake you. I love you freely, totally, faithfully. And if it is God's will, let there be life.

Sexual intercourse is not just something married people are, quote, allowed to do. Sexual intercourse is meant to express what the marriage commitment is. And This is why pornography is so, so damaging to marital love, because it rips sexuality away from that marital language that is inherent to it. My brother, you are. You are. You are looking at the fallout,

honestly, of what pornography has done both to men and to women. And what I would encourage you to do is to pray for whatever woman, if you are meant to be married, she's out there somewhere. Pray now that she would be protected from that pornographic depersonalization. Pray that if she has been impacted or to the degree that she's been impacted, because as I said earlier, few of us are ever unscathed in this culture,

pray that she would be already on the path of reintegration. All that said, here's where I think you really need to go in your prayer. And this may sound outlandish, this may sound utterly scandalous to people, but I'm going to say it with with conviction because it is true. Whatever insecurity you might have as a man about your body,

you can take to the woman who loves you with full, fully integrated, perfect knowledge of your true self. And that's Mary of Nazareth, the Mother of God and our Mother. She can come to us and help us understand the beauty and goodness and dignity of our bodies. Mary is Immaculate. It means she never experienced

disintegration. It means she doesn't have our body issues. It means she knows truly the splendor and dignity and goodness of the integral body person. And she knows where we are ruptured. She knows where we have been wounded and she can minister to us the love of a perfect woman, where we as men need to be loved most intimately, most tenderly,

most vulnerably, most nakedly. She can love us in those places. And if that's scandalous to anyone, I just, I ask you to say, Mary, show me who you really are. We we dump so much of our own body issues on to Jesus and Mary. Jesus and Mary have no body issues when we think they are prudish or somehow have some distaste for bodiliness. We are projecting our own BS on

to Jesus and Mary. Jesus and Mary alone know the full splendor and beauty and dignity of the human body, and they can teach us the splendor and dignity of our bodies. So, brother, bring all those very understandable insecurities right to the woman, the woman who is perfectly integrated, who sees you integrally and can speak to your heart in ways that

will enable enable you to stand tall and walk in your authentic, lovable identity as a man. That is critical for every man. I, I have you, Wendy, a very loving wife, and you are able to affirm me in ways I need to be affirmed. But you're not a perfect woman. So there are ways I still need the love of a perfect woman. And that woman is Mary.

The wisdom literature which the Church applies to Mary says that she will come to us mother like, but she will also come to us like a young bride, and she will embrace us as a young bride embraces her bridegroom. These are mystical spiritual realities. They happen in the realm of our interior. They happen in the realm of our hearts. But this does not mean it's it's mere fantasy or illusion. It's it's reality at a different

level, but it is nonetheless very, very real. We are invited to that kind of closeness with the person Jesus called the woman. That woman can show you who you really are as a man and minister to you brother, in ways that an imperfect woman cannot reach. So true, such deep stuff being

brought up in this question. One of the things that struck me about his question was when he asked how can one deal with the shame society places on certain male bodies And that that really struck me just to look in whatever way I could have an insight about like why is this happening? Why is this shaming happening? Why is this rejection happening? And I can certainly see multiple reasons.

Obviously the devil would be a reason. But like some of the forces at work, one of which you, you know, we're referencing there and talking about the way our culture completely misses the meaning of sexual union and has it so twisted by this pornographic just total distortion that it it, we all get the message that this is

about as much pleasure as possible. Like it's a very physical and selfish view, utilitarian view, absolutely. And so that is absolutely reflected in the whole concept of here's what I need in a man kind of being. It's just so limited and empty. It's it's tragic. Of course it's tragic.

I also sense like women have been sort of rejected for the way their body parts don't measure up to some, you know, image of a perfect woman's body for a very long time. It may be to in some ways to a greater degree than men have. There's maybe a little bit longer standing expectation of these beauty standards and measurements.

And you know, that it almost could seem like a, just like a backlash, like whether it's conscious, I don't know. But a sort of you're going to judge me for my body parts, I'm going to judge you for yours. Kind of a, a mentality which is angry. And it, the anger comes from deep pain, you know, like just kind of a, a cultural deep pain, like let's, you know, let's use each other. If you can't beat them, join them.

Yeah, exactly. So I see all that. And so part of my sense for this questioner and for anybody listening is when you recognize these things like to go to that deeper level where you pray for the healing of the wounds that are behind a lot of these attitudes. And, and you suggested so beautifully praying for the woman he's called to marry, praying for anyone who expresses

these ideas, not allowing them to have power over your heart and your sense of yourself. To draw your dignity from the one who made you wonderfully as you are, as God intended you to be. To draw your sense of, of who you're meant to be as gift from the Lord. And to pray for those people who are so wounded and confused that they would just isolate a body part like that, which is just

not, it's not at all in keeping with what the Lord has intended. And I found myself thinking about a beautiful description in Theology of the Body when Pope John Paul is reflecting on the moment of Adam meeting his wife Eve, and the joy he experiences in seeing at last this one. And it's not at last this one because she looks like a Barbie doll.

It's because of her person who's so attractive to him and whom he also senses how how much she delights in him in his personhood. And, and that encounter which, you know, we kind of referenced the original unity that God desired for man and woman. We had that echo in our own hearts of longing for that. And this message is the absolute

opposite of that. It's instead of that encounter of acceptance and love, it's this encounter of criticism and judgement and shame, which is obviously also what Adam and Eve experienced after the fall. So we can just, we can feel those movements that John Paul was so good at putting his finger on right in this question. And so the, the prayer for the, the redemption that the Lord brought by his death on the cross is for it to be received,

for the hearts to be open for lives to be called forth into being a true gift to one another. It's, it's powerful stuff here. And I also have one more powerful thing I want to share, which is I hope you're willing to share about the cereal box, the time the Lord spoke to you on a cereal box. That's that's a yes. This was yes. So, so every man in the whole world has been impacted by this notion of you have to be a

certain size right to be manly or whatever. And there was this cereal box that you purchased Wendy years ago and had in big letters at the top, family size, a family size cereal box. Like that's what every man wants to be. He wants to be family sized. This is why God gave a man a penis to bring a family into the world. And I, I cut that cereal box,

that part of it out and I have it in my office sitting on my desk as a reminder of what it really means to be a man. To be a man, to be family size is what we want to be. To be a man means to make the gift of yourself in the image and likeness of God so that life can come to others, so you can bring a family into the world. I, I invite every man out there to take that to prayer. What we really want, we want to

be family size. Please Lord, show us what it means to to live in your image because God is a family, Father, son and Holy Spirit. John Paul the Second says we are made in that image. Of course the enemy attacks right here. He's after our loins. That's what he wants. This is why to win the spiritual battle, Saint Paul says the first thing you have to do is gird your loins with the truth. My brother, my brother, your

loins right now are girded with lies because you, like me, like every man on the planet, we've been lied to, lied to, lied to, lied to about the meaning of our bodies. And in the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, I rebuke those lies that have latched on to your mind and heart, that have made you feel insecure as a man. Those lies come from hell, and I'm reminded of the words of Christ himself. Bring your whole body into the

light. How much of your body has to come into the light when your whole body and make sure no part of it remains in darkness? How much should remain in darkness? No part, brother, bring your whole body into the light. Let no part remain in darkness. And what will happen? Here's Christ's promise. Your whole body will be set aflame like a burning lamp, and it will illuminate your entire life, right? The reason, the reason this attacks us so profoundly, these lies, it's because there's a certain truth here.

Our loins are the expression of an inmost reality of our hearts. And if, if, if the Lord wants to protect your heart, he's going to protect your loins. Gird your loins with the truth. That will be the protection of your heart. But the way the enemy gets at your heart is by attacking your loins, right? And that's what's going on here, brother. Your loins are under attack by an enemy. Bring your whole body into the

light and make sure no part of it remains in the darkness of the enemy's world of lies. And let the truth, let the truth that you are a man made in the image and likeness of the living God. Let that truth set you free to live from the heart of a man who knows his identity as a son of the Father. Now that's a long journey brother, but take it. Take that up and walk it every day and you will find those fears and insecurities waning

and you will find a new sense of your masculine identity in Jesus Christ. I I really do sense that that this is a key time in his life and in fact he will look back on the victory that the Lord has won in his heart through this battle as being key to all that comes after. Amen, Amen. It's. Going to be a beautiful fruit will come from that. And brother, please immerse yourself in John Paul the Second's Theology of the body. Just listening this podcast is a

good start, but it is not enough. We have been bombarded and sworn by lies our whole lives. We have to. We have to flush those lies out by immersing ourselves in this teaching. Please, if you haven't already, take A to B1 TOB 2. Keep going. We have a whole certification program. We have an entire master's degree with Pontefix University. Come study with us either online or in person. Just immerse yourself in what John Paul the Second has given us. It is the antidote to all those lies.

Our next question is from a listener named Melanie. Hi, Melanie. I've been in a relationship with my partner for just over a year now. I'm a Catholic, whereas he has no experience with any religion whatsoever. He's been very open and respectful of my faith. Even though he expressed he would wait for me until marriage. I ultimately decided that somehow I was OK with engaging in premarital relations with him.

Afterwards, I realized I had fallen and went to confession. Since then, I've been listening to your podcasts and others on theology of the body, and I'm confident that my love for him supersedes any immediate desire for sex. I want marriage to be our expression of dedication and openness to the responsibilities that come with that union, and only then is where our bodies truly reflect that covenant and acknowledgement of responsibility.

While my partner says that he sees premarital relations as a way that he can express his love, he's once again willing to wait until marriage. But the reality is that I'm having a hard time explaining why marriage is the only place where I want to express that. Any advice would be appreciated. Bless you, Melanie. Melanie, there is so much grace at work here. Really and truly, I sense it. Your openness, your willingness to pursue the truth, you're

going to confession, you're presenting it to him, his willingness to wait. These are all signs that grace is operative and that is a beautiful gift. So praise God for that. We could take this from all kinds of different angles. I, I think based on the way you worded your question, you, you have an understanding, maybe you've learned through our podcast or other things you've listened to or read that sex itself has a, a marital

language. Now that's what I, I want to under score here. You, you talked about, you talked in terms of premarital sex. I think that confuses things when we talk about premarital sex or post marital sex, it makes it sound kind of an arbitrary thing while we're even having even either we're having sex now or we're having sex later. What's the big difference? What difference does a marriage certificate make? In fact, remember Wendy, years

ago at marriage prep, we had somebody say that directly to us. We were challenging the couples in front of us to save sex for marriage and and some woman said, oh, come on, Christopher, we're getting married in three weeks. What's the difference between between us having sex now and us having sex then? And I said, well that's exactly the problem. There will be no difference. What you're doing now is non marital sex. You are having a sexual relationship that does not express marital love, and simply

getting married in three weeks is not going to make suddenly what you're doing in bed an expression of marital love. You're just going to continue to have the kind of sex you were having all along, non marital sex, even though you're on paper you're married, right? In that mentality, when we have separated sexual activity from its marital meaning, it is very, very difficult to regain that marital meaning.

And we then look at marriage as just some kind of certificate you get or something. No, no, no, no. Something much, much more significant is happening in marriage than a certificate. What is happening is that God is a step, is establishing a bond between you that is unbreakable by anything but death. And sexual intercourse is only what it is meant to be when it expresses that bond.

When you don't have a marriage bond, it is impossible to express what sex is meant to express. However, when you follow this logic, having the marital bond is no certainty that what you will be expressing is marital sex because even married people can have non marital sex, meaning they could just be using each other in their sexual activity. They could just be treating it

as an outlet to scratch some itch. To put it rather bluntly or frankly, what has to happen in our hearts for sex to be what it is meant to be is a deep inner conversion of our heart where we come to recognize deeply in the recesses of our hearts that what sex expresses is the promise. I am totally yours. I am freely yours.

I will never leave you or forsake you. And if it is God's will, let there be life. For sex to express what it is meant to express. It must express wedding vows. And what we commit to at the altar is to give ourselves to each other freely, totally, faithfully, and in a way that is open to receiving children lovingly from God. Those are the very vows we express at the altar. And then that night, throughout

married life, when a husband and wife become one flesh, they are meant to be expressing and renewing with the language of their bodies what they committed to at the altar. I remember as a young man when I was first studying theology of the body and I had I had already had a conversion of my heart. I wanted to learn really and truly what is sexual love really meant to be? What does sexual love really express? And John Paul the Second gave me

the language to understand what I what I desired deeply in my heart. I wanted to learn truly what it means to love. And we in our world, we have confused love with, with just two people who are using each other. Oftentimes John Paul the second says what we call love when we, when we submit it to honest examination, oftentimes it amounts to simply two people

using each other. And we call it love because we don't want to look honestly at this utilitarian attitude in our hearts. True love. True love is willing to look at that utilitarian attitude that is right there in our hearts where we can be tempted just to use another person because, well, it's pleasing. It feels good. That brings pleasurable emotions and sensual reactions. But when we confuse emotion and

sensual reactions with love itself, we end up using others rather than loving others. And the opposite of love here is not so much hatred. The opposite of love is precisely that utilitarian attitude that treats the other as a thing rather than as a person. When we understand the true dignity of the person as someone indispensable, irreplaceable, and unrepeatable, and when we

understand that sexual bonding is meant to be the affirmation of that other as indispensable. Meaning I will never throw you away. I will never leave you. I will never forsake you, indispensable and irreplaceable. I will never replace you with someone else in in mind or in action. And you are unrepeatable. I could never imagine replacing you with someone else in this intimate place of this sexual relationship when that's what you're truly expressing. In mind and heart and body, that

is marital love. And if that's the kind of love that you are ready and willing to express with one another, well, it's time to get married. It's time to get married. And if anybody says, well, I, no, I wasn't wanting to express that kind of love. I mean, I'm we're not ready for that. OK, then you're not ready to be having true sexual relations. You are substituting that utilitarian attitude with love, and if we're honest about what love really is and what the dignity of the person demands,

we can say to the other, I want to wait because I love you and I want you to wait because I know you want to love me and I want to call the best out of you. Wendy, I'm going to toss it to you. What? What am I? What am I forgetting to say or what can you add to this? Thank you, my love. I love how you just recognize the work of Grace going on here. And I, I really want to encourage Melanie and anyone that can relate to her story that it's important to go beyond

this topic. I think this question could kind of come to a little bit of a stall in conversation until there's other growth that happens. And one of the things I just want to encourage Melanie to do is to ask her boyfriend what is his understanding of marriage, You know, as a man who doesn't have any faith background, how does he understand marriage? And I think it's a could be a

topic for great growth for both of you to look at. Well, all the things that Melanie's background of faith impacts her world view. What is his world view? And surely if she truly loves him and knows that she's been saved by the life and death and resurrection of Jesus, surely she wants to share that with this man that she loves to some

degree. She loves him as you're talking about, you know, the, the growth in love or the stages of love or the kinds of love. I, I agree with all that you've said, Christopher. I think it's just gets at the heart of. The. Deep confusion that can be in our human existence as fallen human beings in history. Here we're just, we can't make sense of all these things. And and that longing to fully understand is a beautiful longing. I, I hope and pray that her boyfriend has that same desire

because if he does, he's in a relationship with someone who can bring him to the, the way, the truth and the life that he really needs, as every person does. So I don't know if, if that's the kind of thing that Melanie was hoping to hear, but that's what my heart is telling me is, is that there are many important things that this issue is bringing out the deep difference that they have in their, in their background and in their worldview.

And it it's something that you have to take a step back from and trust this man fully to the Lord that you're not grasping onto him. You give him to Jesus and say, Lord, if you desire this relationship to continue, I will receive it from you. But I I want your will for this man and your will for my life more than anything else. Deep wisdom there, Wendy. That's what I'm hearing. Deep wisdom. I'm going to throw out one more

suggestion to you, Melanie, since your boyfriend doesn't have faith, the work that I think would really help you to help him and help him directly is John Paul the Second's book Love and Responsibility. Because that's a philosophy book. It does not appeal to faith directly. That's not its main mode of presenting the teaching. It's just reflecting on the dignity of the person. And I would encourage you and your boyfriend together to watch a six part series that Matt

Fradd and I did on Love and Responsibility. Three episodes aired on our YouTube channel and three episodes aired on his YouTube channel. And we will have the link in the show notes to that six part series. Watch that together and then talk about it. Enter into conversation about all you're learning. I think that will will give you a very solid foundation, just philosophical foundation to have this conversation with a boyfriend who doesn't have

faith. Excellent. Our next question is from a listener named Thomas Love. Hello, Thomas Love. Hi Wendy and Christopher, First of all, thank you for this podcast and for everything you do to illuminate the beauty of our Mother Church and our faith. I've fallen in love with our faith for about a year and a half now after spending most of my life away from the church. Since returning, I've been on a journey of learning how to love our Lord, often through encountering the Saints. Sometimes I come across a St. whether through a quote or a

mention, and feel an overwhelming desire to know them. It's as if I can't rest until I get a biography or one of their works. However, when I start reading, I often feel frustrated because the depth of their faith and understanding feels so far beyond me, almost as if their writings are in another language. This has happened with Saints like John Paul too, who by God's grace led me to discover you, Alphonsus, Maria de Liguori, and Bonaventure.

What should I do with these strong desires to know the Saints when I feel like I'll never fully grasp their wisdom in this lifetime? Any advice would be appreciated. Thomas love, I love your question. Love it, Love it, love it. And I love your love of the Saints. Here's what's coming to my mind. Thomas love that it's very important we remember that faith is a gift. It is not something we muster up

on our own. It's not like there are these superhero human beings we call Saints who somehow mustered up all this faith. No, they they opened to it as a gift. And you, Thomas, Love can open to faith as a gift. It was recently one of the prayers of the Mass over the Christmas season where right in the liturgy the Church prays for all of us and we pray for one

another, that we would come to understand the mysteries of our faith in all of their depth. The Church would not pray a prayer like that if it weren't possible for it to be granted. And now when I say that, of course you're going to have people like Thomas Aquinas who have a very particular gift. You're going to have people like John Paul the 2nd and Catherine of Siena and Teresa of Avila and Jonathan Cross, who, who are

given a very particular depth of, of understanding of the faith. I don't think it's realistic for all of us to say everyone should expect to have that depth of theological knowledge or understanding. Nonetheless, what grants us entrance to heaven is not the depth of our theological understanding, but our openness to the gift. This is what faith is in its

deepest essence. And here I'm quoting John Paul the second. He says faith in its deepest essence is the openness of the human heart to God's gift to his self, communication in the Holy Spirit. Thomas Love, you are called no less than any other human being who's ever walked planet earth to open yourself to God's gift.

And in opening yourself to God's gift, which itself is a gift, the very openness of your heart to God's gift is a gift. The ability to open our hearts to God's gift, that is a gift. Everything is grace. Everything is gift. So it doesn't matter what your natural human aptitudes might be. We are all granted the gift of faith as we open to it, and we are all granted the ability to open to it. And as you do, Thomas Love, as you open your heart to God's gift, which is faith.

God's gift is faith, but faith itself is the openness to the gift. As you learn that way of opening your heart, brother, faith will take shape in you in a unique and unrepeatable way, right. Just earlier in the in the previous question we were talking about every person is indispensable, irreplaceable and unrepeatable. The way faith has manifested itself in the life of John Paul the Second. The way faith has manifested itself in the life of Wendy W. The way faith has manifested itself in in your life, Thomas, love will be unique and

unrepeatable based on who you are and the way you live it. So brother, look at these Saints and don't be discouraged, be encouraged. You are called not to be John Paul the Second, or whoever else you might admire. Admire them, but become the Saint that is uniquely and unrepeatably Thomas. Love and express your faith as you are called to express your faith.

That is what forms the communion of all the Saints, the uniqueness of the Saints. Be you, my brother. And isn't it beautiful that desire he has to know the Saints. It's such a desire for heaven. Like just think of that. And what a what a gift to have that instinct of loving these people who love the Lord and just being enriched by that. It's a that is a work of grace in his heart that he has that desire.

I think it would be so fruitful to grow in your ability to converse with the Lord about the things that stir in your heart. Thomas love to be able to. When you encounter that quote or mention of a certain St. and you feel that intense desire to know that St., all of which is a beautiful desire as I just said. But to pause and talk to Jesus about it. To say thank you for this light that is so beautiful to me and

awakens my heart and ask him to show you more how that very thing is speaking to you. That very quote that you read to that there's more to be found out about your own journey and how the Lord loves you if you just stay with that thing that lit up your heart. And if you buy a buy or get a biography or work written by a St. and find you can't understand it and that frustrates you also to have a

conversation with the Lord about that. I think that ability to recognize as Kutcher was talking about your unique journey and to bring it to really a conversational kind of prayer and, and to pause and wait and listen. See if the Lord speaks to you directly about, about the Saint that you're excited about or the quote that you read, because it's your journey of your own growth that is so essential. And I I really think that is

going to make a huge difference. And and instead of being discouraged about not what you can't understand, you will be encouraged about the ever deepening work of grace going on in your own story. And I want to say what we always say at the end of our episodes today directly to you, Thomas. Love you, my brother, you, you uniquely you. You are a gift. Become what you are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to

you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed. Counselors If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Christopher West Host Feed-stated
  • Wendy West Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode