Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Christopher West

Ask Christopher West artwork

When God Feels Silent, When Nudity Tests Purity, When Climax Comes Unexpectedly | ACW346

Aug 18, 202559 minAudio

Questions answered this episode: You often say to bring desires to Jesus or Mary, but when I do, nothing happens. Prayer, stillness, and adoration haven’t helped. Years of silence have made me see Jesus less as a loving bridegroom and more as someone withholding, disappearing at my slightest mistake. I know that’s not who He is, but I can’t shake the image. I want to love God for Himself, not His gifts, but sometimes I want to harden my heart to avoid feeling. Pornography has touched my deep desires in ways God hasn’t. Even when sober, He feels distant, and I can’t find a holy substitute. As a Catholic trying to live purity and modesty, is extended private nudity unadvisable? I know it’s likely not sinful in itself, but it could be a near occasion of sin, especially for unmarried people. As a college-aged man, I’ve struggled with pornography and masturbation, which has led me to feel a certain disdain for my genitals. I wonder if spending more time unclothed in private could help me appreciate my body as God created it, or if it would invite temptation given my past. What about sleeping in the nude - would that be harmless or spiritually risky for me? I believe arousal is a beautiful, God-given reaction when kept pure. But I’ve accidentally reached sexual climax with my boyfriend, and I struggle to know when my body is close. For example, after a gentle goodbye kiss and embrace, I walked away and unexpectedly experienced an orgasm. I knew I was aroused, but didn’t realize it was that strong. I’m deeply in love and attracted to him, but I didn’t know I was that aroused. Is this irresponsibility, or a lack of knowledge of my own body and heart? How should I understand and handle these moments? Resources: https://nationalcatholicsingles.com/ Grand Canyon by Jay & Jo --- 🔥 ⁠⁠⁠Get 3 FREE sessions of our flagship course on Theology of the Body⁠⁠⁠ 📕 ⁠⁠⁠Get a copy of Christopher's Eating the Sunrise: Meditations on the Liturgy & Our Hunger for Beauty⁠⁠⁠ ⚡️ Want to support the Theology of the Body Institute and have a better chance of us answering your question? ⁠⁠⁠Join our Patron Community!⁠⁠⁠ --- Submit you question here! --- 🎥 Check out our ⁠⁠⁠YouTube Channel⁠⁠⁠ 📚 View our ⁠⁠COURSE SCHEDULE⁠⁠ to register for a course, ONLINE or IN-PERSON! 📘 ⁠⁠GOOD NEWS ABOUT SEX & MARRIAGE⁠⁠ by Christopher West. Use discount code MARRIAGE during checkout for 20% off one or multiple copies. 🏔️ ⁠⁠Join us on one of our pilgrimages!⁠⁠ If you are in financial need and honestly cannot afford a book or resource recommended on this podcast, contact: ⁠⁠michele@tobinstitute.org⁠⁠ ⁠List of trusted counselors & psychologists⁠

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello everybody, this episode touches on some delicate topics and it's not intended for younger ears, so if you're a minor then we'd recommend asking permission from one of your parents before you listen. Or if you listen to the podcast with little ones around then know that this episode is not appropriate for them. Thank you. From the theology of the Body Institute, this is. The Ask Christopher W Podcast. Hi, podcast listeners.

Hey everybody, welcome to another episode. Yeah, since the last time we recorded, I've been to Rome, Rome, Italy. Rome, Italy. It was an unexpected trip. I got a kind of last minute invitation to go to the Jubilee for online missionaries and Catholic influencers and I needed another international trip like I needed a hole in the head. But. I'm so sorry all our international listeners are suddenly feeling like you don't

want to come see them. See, I didn't need an additional trip. The trips I've already accepted, like I'm going to Brazil soon. Soon. I'm very excited about going to the UK in September and going to Germany also in September. Very excited about that. We have a a tour, fall tour throughout the US, so you can check out the dates for that. Then we're going to Ecuador in December. Then we're going to not you and I together. We're not going to Ecuador. That's not the we. I meant the we was our team.

TOB Institute. TOB Institute Team. Travelling missionaries. And then I'm going to teach a course in Sydney, Australia in January. That's why I had all these international trips already and I didn't need another one. And that's just an expression my mother use. My mother uses like I needed XY and Z, like I needed a hole in the head. That's why it came out that way. It's fine. But anyways, I did go to Rome because Wendy, you. I wanted you to go. You wanted me to go I. Felt it. It was so.

Unusual. I know because it meant you were away and you were tired. I know it is unusual. But you wanted me to go. I felt it was the right thing. And I went to this Jubilee event and I was impressed. The Vatican was really trying to minister into the needs of of evangelists. I felt very old. Most people were in their 20s and 30s. I had a a sense that, Oh my gosh, that the yeah, the new generation is really doing it. And another thing kind of scared me. They view the world through their phones. And even if we're in this

lecture hall right near Saint Peter's, it only holds about 1000 people. I'm in the back row and most of the people in the auditorium were watching the talk that was happening right in front of them through their smartphones because there was a a live broadcast of it, live streaming. And maybe part of that is because the translation, you got it through your phone. That was creative and convenient. But it's not like the guy on the stage or whoever was talking was too far away.

Like I could see his facial expressions from where I was in the back, but over half the auditorium was watching what's happening right in front of them through their phones. And then we walked into Saint Peter's Basilica, just our group. We had a private tour at Saint Peter's. And again, most people are looking at Saint Peter's through their phones. I'm thinking people, it's right in front of you. But it gave me it gave me a window into the younger generation. Like they, they really like seem to encounter the world through their screens, which

interestingly enough, the whole event was about reaching people through screens. But kind of our goal at the theology of the Body Institute, in as much as we use screens to reach people, is to, yeah, reach them, but then encourage them to get off their screens and get out and experience nature, get out and counter a real person, not through a screen. It it was, it was eye opening and a little a little concerning to me. But anyway, I'm not going to go

down that path. Well, I'll just say one thing. I think about you and all the I'm speaking and events and things that you do, and I suddenly feel grateful that most of the time your audience is just looking at you in person. And because that's important for you as a speaker to have that eye contact, that feeling of connection. So I sort of have compassion for the people who were speaking in Rome who were looking at people that we're looking at their phones instead of, you know, having that connection that that

is so important. Yeah. And if, if there are any listeners out there who are at that Jubilee event and came to say hello to me, lots of people came and said hello. I shout out to all of you. Thanks for saying hello. I did a lot of interviews while I was there as well. And we did the well event in Rome, right down the street from Saint Peter's in the little Chapel that John Paul the Second had established for the purpose of evangelization. So that was special. But I, I was also wigged out by somebody who wanted to do an

interview with me. And she said, I'm already filming. I said, what do you mean you're already filming? She said, well, I have a camera in, in my eyeglasses here. I said what? They were Ray Bans with the camera right in the in the side of the glasses like that. You couldn't see it. And that's a new technology too. Anyway, I'm just revealing myself to be an old fogey here who's alarmed by which seems normal to the younger generations, but why don't we just pause there and move? Move right along.

But wait, I have one thing to ask. OK, OK. Were you glad you went? I was glad I went. Thank you. Yeah, I was blessed by the the talks that I heard for this Jubilee event. And I was blessed by walking through the Holy Doors, which is very meaningful to me for the Jubilee indulgence. That was a blessing to me. And Elizabeth Busby on our team got a blessing from Pope Leo, which was really special. I unfortunately, my flight

schedule is such that I had to leave and I wasn't able to have that audience with Pope Leo. But our group had a little audience with Pope Leo. He addressed us and then he's he walked by Elizabeth Busby from the TOB Institute and he she asked for a blessing. And yeah, that, that was posted on the Vatican website, the picture. That was pretty fun. Yeah, very, very good. Yeah. Tell me now what I I feel like you kind of included updates on the Institute in when we were

talking about your international. Travel, our travel coming up, but I do want to mention one thing that is time sensitive here. Dear friend of ours and promoter of theology, the body. We've known her for many years, Anastasia Northrop she runs the national Catholic singles Conference and this is the 20th anniversary of the national Catholic singles conference I've spoken at it a few times and it is August 22nd to the 24th in Denver, Co. We'll have a link in the show

notes but it's easy to remember. National catholicsingles.com If you are a single person and you are looking to connect with like minded Catholics, this is a great event to attend. Nationalcatholicsingles.com August 22nd to the 24th in Denver, Co. Awesome. All right, you ready for a question from one of our patrons? Let's do it. This question is from an anonymous patron. You often say to bring your desires to Jesus or Mary and

that they will tenderly and lovingly speak to you. But it feels like when I do this, nothing happens and no amount of prayer, being still, listening, or going to adoration seems to help. This seeming lack of response to the intimate longings of my heart and years of this silence have led me to develop a picture of Jesus that's less of a loving bridegroom and more of a passive aggressive guy. In this guy who uses my heart as a sort of carrot on a stick in

order to get me to do stuff for him, and who will disappear for an extended period at the slightest mistake. Oh my. Although I know by faith that that's not who He is or what He does, I still can't shake the image. I desire to be able to love God for himself and not just His gifts. And I understand if God doesn't immediately answer my prayers, but it's been such a long time that sometimes I consider trying

to harden my heart so as not to feel the desires anymore. Sometimes I fall into looking at pornography, preferring greasy chicken Nuggets in quotes to total nothingness. It feels like porn has touched the deep desires in my heart in a way that God never has and doesn't appear to want to. Even when I have been sober for months or years, God still seems to be distant and nothing he does touches my heart on the

same level or in the same way. There appears to be no good habit to replace the evil one with that fills the same desires but in a holy way and a self giving way. Do you have any advice for this situation or any idea what to do? Thank you. Do we know if this is a a male or a female? It doesn't say. It doesn't say because I might go a little different direction depending, but God bless you, my

dear brother or sister, whoever you might be. You are in a time of your life of real testing. I can tell that. And I can also tell you're familiar with our podcast or maybe you've read some of our our works or watch some of our videos on YouTube. As a patron, obviously you're also familiar with the TOB Institute. So you're using language that we use. He referred, he or she referred to, I prefer to eat the fast food, the greasy chicken

Nuggets, than than just nothingness, than the starvation approach because it seems that God is not present in my longings. This is a very common experience. This is part and parcel with purifications we need to go through so that we can desire God as our our one true goal and end and aim. So nothing you're experiencing here is unusual in the spiritual

journey. You're experiencing a what the Saints describe as a denuding, A stripping, a an emptying, a canosis, a a, a, a time of getting in touch with your own poverty. And all of that serves to purify our longing to redirect it towards its true satisfaction. But he's also experiencing in the midst of these normal and

par for the course experiences of of pain, of silence, of seeming abandonment from God. He's also experiencing the class. He or she is experiencing the classic temptations. This is when the enemy comes right in the depth of our yearning that seems to go unsatisfied and unmet. When it seems that God is silent and not showing up, the enemy shows up and says, here's what

you want. Come over here what you really want, I'm going to give you God's not going to give you what you want, but I am So come over to this pornified version of the story and this person how, how did he or she express that the the porn seems to to to reach a a desire that that nothing else does is that. It feels like porn has touched the deep desires of my heart in a way that God never has and doesn't appear to want. To OK, so that that is a lie

from hell, and I invite you to rebuke it in the name of Jesus. What porn is doing is providing A diabolic mockery of the fulfillment for which you yearn. Taking the yearning to pornography is like taking our thirst to salt water, right? We we put the salt water in our mouth and there's moisture in our mouth. When your tongue's been stuck to the roof of your mouth and you have moisture in there, it feels good and you swallow it and now you're cut, your throat is

coated with moisture and that feels really good. But then when the salt hits your bloodstream, the, the, the horror of it is that you think you need to drink more because the salt is making you more and more and thirsty. But what is actually happening is your death, right? Porn is like that. The the agony I believe you are experiencing is the agony that Christ experienced on the cross.

My God, my God, why have you abandoned me? That's the feeling you are feeling. And the profound paradox of feeling that feeling is that you are intimately united with Christ, who himself is God in that cry of abandonment. So in the very reality of feeling abandoned, this is the the paradox of it all. You are intimately close with Jesus in the cry of your heart.

My God, my God, why have you abandoned me? I would invite you to pray into Psalm 22. Psalm 22 is what Jesus is quoting from the cross. My God, my God, why have you abandoned me? And it, and it, it begins with that cry of abandonment, but it ends with an act of faith, an act of entrustment, that even in that feeling of being abandoned, Christ ends by saying into your hands, I commend my spirit into your hands.

So whatever you are feeling in this place of being carved out, emptied out, the feeling, the silence of God, cry out, continue to cry out. Do not censor anything you are feeling. Journal it out, scream it out, shout it out, get it out what you are really feeling, but get it out and into the heart of the God who knows you and loves you. And as I'm sharing this with you, the sense of being carved

out, I'm reminded of a song that I would really invite you to pray into. It's a song actually a former student of mine. I taught her in Canada. She wrote it. It's the band or the the duet who does it is Jay and Joe Jay and Joe, the two women who have beautiful voices. And the song is called Grand Canyon. I invite you to listen to that. It's a song about being carved out like the Grand Canyon.

It's a song about praying and hearing nothing in return. It's a song about a a certain numbness we can feel when the ache is so deep and it hurts so badly, we just want to shut it down and we want to go numb. But in the end, it's just like that. That Psalm that Jesus prays from the cross. It starts with this feeling of emptiness, of being carved out of silence. I'm not hearing. I'm praying, but I'm not hearing anything in response. And there's the temptation to

abandon the Lord. But this song ends with this beautiful, melodious cry of the heart. I will be filled in. I will be filled in. It's, it's a beautiful, beautiful prayer and I believe it will speak to exactly what you are going through. I invite you to stay strong in your faith in the midst of this carving out and in the midst of the temptations. I'd also invite you to pray into Jesus's temptations after his

time in the, in the desert, 40 days in the desert. He's hungry and the enemy comes and says, if you're the Son of God, turn these stones into bread. If you're the Son of God, you know, it's this, this, this insinuating attack against his identity. And it's saying it's the classic temptation. God's not coming for me. God's not coming for me. I'm hungry. I'm, I'm hungry. I have the power. I'm going to take this stone and turn it into bread. Every temptation, as my mentor,

Monsignor Lorenzo Albacete says, every temptation comes down to 1 temptation. It's the temptation to believe that the satisfaction of the desires of my heart is totally up to me. That is the lie from hell. God's not coming for me. God's not going to satisfy my desires. And in those times when the Lord is stretching us and it seems that he is absent, that's when the enemy insinuates he's not coming.

He's not coming. He doesn't love you, He's just. How did he, he or she describe the image they have of of God? This led me to develop a picture of Jesus that's less of a loving bridegroom and more of a passive aggressive guy in the sky who uses my heart as a sort of carrot on a stick in order to get me to do stuff for him. That is exactly what the enemy wants us to think of God. And you have authority through your baptism to rebuke that. That is a temptation from hell. And you can say in the name of Jesus, I rebuke that lie.

And then you can quote the Psalms. I treasure your promises in my heart, O Lord, lest I sin against you. And what is the promise? It's just what that beautiful song sings at the end. I will be filled in. I will be filled in. All the Saints talk about this stretching of the heart to the point of breaking, to the point of Teresa of Avila says I die because I do not die. Her heart got stretched in its

longing so so profoundly that she said I want to die so that my heart's desire will be fulfilled and I die inside because I do not die. Jonathan Cross speaks of of the agony of the ache and the cry and the longing of his heart as as approaching death like it's, it's worse than death. He says. This agony that you are feeling in your longing, this is the sure sign that you are on the path of interior spiritual growth and maturing.

But it's right in that maturing that the enemy comes to try to thwart us and to turn to our idols and to turn to God's substitutes and to insinuate God is not coming for you. I treasure your promises in my heart, O Lord, lest I sin against you. That is one of my go to psalms in moments of temptation. And all the Saints talk about that stretching of the heart where it seems that God is absent, that God seems to be absent. Why? To increase our longing for him,

to increase our longing for him, our hearts need to be stretched, says Saint Augustine. It's like a purse that you want to put a gift into, but the purse is too small and the leather needs to be stretched because the gift that God wants to give us is nothing short of his infinite life and love and our hearts need to be stretched. Hang on, my dear brother or sister, you are in the the agony of purification.

You are in the agony of having your desires purified. Stay in that place. The original sin is really a a, a doubting that God is coming for me and that that just hounds us, that haunts us. We can undo the original sin within our own hearts through acts of faith. I treasure your promise in my heart, O Lord, lest I sin against you. I will not turn to my idols. I will not fall for these temptations.

I will stay in the place of agonizing longing for God, no matter how long it takes. That is the posture of faith. And this, this is also what the Saints tell us. The Lord in his gracious mercy will not keep us in that painful place forever. He will give us little tastes, little taste to keep us going. Think of the Lord when he when the the people were out, they had travelled a long way to listen to him. And the apostle said, send them

home. And Jesus said, I'm afraid if I send them home without feeding them, that they'll faint on the way, right? That's whenever we hear the way, they'll faint on the way. That's a reference to our interior journey also. So the Lord in his compassion for you will give you tastes. He will give you little glimmers of hope. He will give you little foretastes of the ecstasy that awaits on the other side so that you don't faint on the way. And it seems you are right at

the point of like, it seems like you're going to faint on the way. Trust, trust. Stay open. You are not experiencing anything unusual. This is the path. This is the journey. Keep going. Christopher, when you were speaking about purifications, I, I had a feeling like I could maybe take that a little bit into a, a slightly practical application of what could be a purification in this particular situation might be helpful.

You were talking about kind of recognizing these lies about who God is. And so I was just praying about that and thinking about it that we are all born into this fallen world and every experience we have is in a fallen world. And when we are looking to the Lord, it is just inevitable that our experiences of the fallen world are in our minds and hearts, even if we want to understand that that's not who

God is. Those images and experiences are deep and sometimes unconscious, but they're in US. Yes, yes. And, and an example would be like to look at some of these feelings that are being described about God, like a lack of response just to pause, even. I encourage you to go back and reread how you wrote this question out to us, because I think there's a lot in what you got out and, and in sharing your question in the patron site that

that could be really good for, for practical purification. If you would pause and look at that seeming lack of response, like where in your experiences in this fallen world have you experienced someone you turned to who seemed not to respond? And can you ask the Lord to minister to that wound in your heart in that memory of not getting a response from a human

being you know, who should have responded to you in some way? Or have you experienced someone being passive aggressive toward you and causing you a lot of turmoil and anguish and frustration because of that? Like when you describe the Lord that way, Ask the Lord to shine a light in your story. Where have I experienced this? And why am I bringing this image to you, Lord? Why am I thinking and projecting

this on to you? Where have I experienced that God's somebody didn't touch my heart when I needed it or who seemed so distant from me, like asking the Lord to shine his light. That's just an image that helps me in my prayer. The expression is is one of like the grace, the healing power of the Lord, the illumination of what is in my story, what is in my past.

And maybe you will start to appreciate having these feelings toward the Lord because they become opportunities for the Lord to minister healing in ways that you need from past relationships. So that is a purification because it's a a healing and a removing of the effects of sins against us that are in our hearts. And it frees us up so that we don't have to keep bearing the

weight of those things inside and having them kind of keep us from knowing who the Lord really is. So I hope that kind of make takes the word purifying to a a different way that would help, you know, help our listeners just to to grow through these kinds of frustrations in prayer. I'll add this, Wendy, you gave some very beautiful practical wisdom there. That is the application of Catechism 2779. So I'm going to invite our, our

patron questioner also here to reflect on Catechism 2779 about how we can project onto God our own cultural and personal experiences of people in our lives who've wounded us, and we project that back onto God and how those notions of God need to be purified. So it's a beautiful, beautiful insight you just gave us. Thank you, Wendy. And we, we lift this person up in prayer and we ask Lord that this person would have the courage to persevere in the

stretching, in the, in the stripping, and not be afraid of the work that you are underway in bringing about a, a great purification of this person's heart and a great preparation for a, a taste of the fulfillment that you promised to grant even in this life. We ask that for our our dear brother or sister, Lord. Hey everybody, this is a short break to let you know that Christopher will be going on

tour this year. We're going to places like Maryland, Texas, Arizona, Louisiana, Michigan, and also other countries like United Kingdom, Germany, Ecuador, and Brazil. We're constantly adding new events and dates, so please check our events schedule in the show notes to know if we're coming to a city near you. Peace. Our next question is from an anonymous listener. Hey Christopher and Wendy, thank you so much for your podcast and witness to a beautiful though imperfect marital love. Your sharing of TOB has led me

to deeper study and changed my life and the way I see the faith. I wanted to ask a possibly awkward question that I can't seem to find a good answer to anywhere. My question is this, as a Catholic trying to live out purity and modesty, are extended periods of private nudity unadvisable? I know that it likely wouldn't be intrinsically sinful, but it seems like it could be a near occasion of sin for most,

particularly unmarried people. As a college aged young man, I have had struggles with pornography and masturbation in the past and it has led me to have a certain disdain for my genitals because they've quote led me to sin in the past. Yes, yes, yes. I was wondering if spending more time in private while unclothed would be beneficial to appreciating the goodness of my body and the way God has created me? Or would this seem to be a near occasion of sin given my past? And what about sleeping in the

nude? Thanks again for answering my question. I love this question and I love the heart from which it comes. This is a man really seeking, is really seeking this great question. I want to shout this from the rooftops and I want it, please, God, to penetrate your heart. Your genitals did not cause you to sin. Let me say that one more time.

Your genitals did not 'cause you to sin. It was your disordered will that caused you to sin, your disordered desires that caused you to sin. To blame the body for our sin is what John Paul the Second calls the Manichaean turn. Manichaeism is this heresy that blames the body, blames the physical, blames sex itself for

sexual sin and sin in general. Spirit good, body bad. It's in fact the exact opposite. It's the spirit that is corrupt here, and the body is good. The body is good, our spirit is corrupt. My brother, you are on a pilgrimage here and the questions you are entertaining have to do with wanting. And this is what's so beautiful about your heart. You want to come to an integral,

beautiful, proper understanding of the goodness of your body. Could having times of nudity, private nudity, sleeping naked, for example, could that aid? Let me get to that question in a minute. Let me put that on the side burner and let me say the first thing you need to do in growing towards the proper appreciation of your body is to repent of believing that Manichaean lie, that your body is the problem,

that your genitals are the problem. Listen to these words of Saint Paul, those parts of our body that we think that's the keyword that we think are dishonorable. These parts of the body deserve all the greater honor because God has bestowed on these parts of the body the greater glory. So my brother, repent of dishonouring your genitals

through acts of masturbation. And also I imagine you already have repented of the masturbation, but, but I would invite you to specifically repent of dishonouring your body, dishonouring your genitals through those acts of masturbation. And then I would invite you also to repent of dishonouring your genitals by blaming them for causing you to sin. Apologize to your body.

Apologize to your body for blaming it. This can be very, very healing. Now let's address the question of times of private nudity. It's hard to give general advice when we're Speaking of something that I would need to really know. Your interior disposition. To what extent might it become an occasion of sin? I don't know. I don't know what your, your

interior life is is like. But I can say this that yes, times of learning in the proper setting to appreciate your own body in its nakedness can be very healing. Again, one man's mystical experience can be another man's occasion of sin. So this is not some general blanket statement across the board. I would, I would need to sit down with you and, and speak

with you and learn more of your struggles, learn more of your journey, learn, learn more of, of what your temptations are. But, but let me speak as as broadly as I can in saying it is certainly possible that if you're sleeping alone, sleeping naked could be an experience of coming to terms with the goodness of my body. That's a possibility. I'm not saying I recommend it to you or recommend it to everybody

listening to this podcast, because I can't say that in a general sense because I'd have to speak with each person and know what their interior dispositions are. But is it possible that that could be a healthy healing experience? Yes, it is possible. Is it possible that that could just fan the flames of disordered desire and be a stumbling block? Yes, that's possible too. Both are a possibility, and I can't say which it would be for you because I don't know you, but it is possible. Let me put it this way.

If one cannot be with himself naked and not sin, we, we have larger issues. We have deep seated issues deep in our hearts, in our minds, in our imagination, in our will. The evil is not in our bodies. The evil, let me say it again. The evil is not in our bodies. It's in a disordered will. It's in a perverse imagination. It's in our disordered desires. But part of the journey of inner healing is certainly coming to

terms with and coming to peace with the goodness of my own body. And on that pilgrimage, we, we have to ask the Lord to purify our memories. What are your first memories of your own body? What are your first memories of your own genitals? What are your first memories of in erection? What is your What are your first memories of sexual arousal? What were they connected to? Be not afraid to invite Jesus

into those memories. He will lead you. He will lead you. If Jesus is inviting you into the healing of those memories, He will lead you. But between here and the Beatific vision, it's not that all of this gets forgotten. It's that all of this gets redeemed, transformed, submitted to the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ so that we become new creatures, new creatures.

My brother, I want to hold out that hope to you, the hope of an integral masculinity where you are at peace with your body, whether you sleep naked or not. It doesn't matter one way or the other because you're at peace one way or the other, whether you have extended times of, of nakedness in your, the privacy of your own room just to come to a peaceful acceptance of your body. It doesn't matter one way or the other because you're coming to a peaceful acceptance of your body. If it aids in a peaceful acceptance of your body, praise God if it is.

If it's, if it's a stumbling block, well, don't go down that journey. Don't go down that path again. One man's mystical treasure can be another man's stumbling block. Depending on where you are in your interior journey, you would need some why spiritual direction there, but it's possible. I hold it out to you as a possibility. Not a general recommendation, but yes, a possibility. Yeah, I think my own feeling is very similar to yours, that sometimes we can kind of get stuck on something and it feels

a little like this is a a person who is experiencing real graces, amazing graces in our culture today in this world, to even just recognize like my my body has dignity that I have not haven't treated it with the dignity that it intrinsically has by God's gift of it. You know, we talk about you are

a gift, and that is not just about our, you know, inner virtues or something. We're talking you whole person. You are a gift. The body reveals it, your genitals reveal it. Yes, yes. So thank you. I think maybe even just kind of asking the question, you know, I'd like to do this, but I'm wondering if it's a bad idea is almost kind of getting a little

too interested in that particular experience rather than just having a state in your heart where you're at peace. You're a man. God made you and gave you the gift of your masculine body. And if you find it comfortable to be naked when it's of no harm to someone else, you're free to choose that. And and not to dwell on it too focusedly, like just to let that be, I don't know, just a more

natural thing. I almost feel like the focus on it like would this help me is almost like setting it up to be too big of a deal. Or something that's that's a good insight, Wendy. And I just, yeah, I just want to encourage you to kind of set it aside for a little bit and, and focus on some of the things that Christopher was sharing with you about beautiful prayers, powerful prayers of asking forgiveness of your own body for having blamed it for your your

fallen humanity and your disordered will. Like that's, that's powerful. You can take that to prayer for a while and really go with that. And, and other examples he gave of, of coming to peace with and just deeper gratitude for your masculine body that would bring you in part to a place of just healing. But also I feel like there just needs to be deeper confidence. Like I know who I am and I, I

don't need someone outside me to, you know, kind of tell me, Oh, do this, Oh, do that. Like you just get to a much deeper place of like it's me and the Lord. And, and I know I, I like to sleep naked sometimes and I can, maybe I can just discern, you know, what is this a good time to sleep naked? Maybe not and just be at peace with who you are, where you are in your journey. And, and I don't know, I feel like there's a grace in that. I'm imagining somebody taking those words of Wendy W out of

context and just throwing them out on the Internet. I like to sleep naked. I'm married to her. In fact, I know she does not because she gets too cold. Anyway, brother, you are. You are on a good path here. You are on the road to healing. Be at peace, my brother. Your body is holy and sacred. And I'll throw out one more just word of encouragement. Perhaps pray into this. Perhaps you could benefit from praying with Michelangelo's

naked crucifix and his resurrected Christ. These are works of art from a great respected Catholic artist. Michelangelo his, his naked crucifix. This Christ was crucified naked. This was the historical reality of Roman crucifixion to strip the victims. And Christ redeemed nakedness by enduring the cross, heedless of its shame. It also says in scripture that the grave clothes were left behind. Right? He's crucified naked. He's covered in grave clothes, and the grave clothes were left

behind. Saint After St. has told us of the beautiful parallel between the first Adam coming out of the garden naked without shame and the new Adam coming out of this garden. He was buried in a garden coming out of the garden naked, without shame. Taking into prayer and contemplation the naked crucified Christ and the naked risen Christ can be very, very healing for men who have had a perverse understanding of their

own masculine bodies. Everything Christ did was holy. Everything Christ did was holy. His nakedness on the cross was holy. Is leaving the grave close behind in the tomb was holy. Am I saying Jesus was like historically raised from the dead naked? I don't know. I wasn't there. But this is a theological truth that we're getting at. So take those theological truths to prayer and let them heal any diseased ideas or images you have of your own body. And then whether you sleep naked or not will not be an issue.

You'll be at peace with yourself. Sleeping naked could be great, Sleeping not naked could be great. It's all great. Doesn't matter. You're got your body's good, you're at peace with yourself. Bless you brother. Keep going, keep going. Our next question is from another anonymous listener. And it's totally fine to make your questions anonymous. Just want to say patrons, you can be anonymous, listeners, you can be anonymous. It's completely fine. We don't know who you are.

Hello, Wests. My question is regarding sexual climax. I understand that arousal is a beautiful, amazing bodily reaction that we should praise God for, and it is OK providing that you open yourself to the Holy Spirit and have a pure mind. However, this is embarrassing to admit, but I've somehow reached climax with my boyfriend accidentally. I've trouble knowing when my body's about to reach climax.

For example, one time I was saying goodbye to my boyfriend. We shared a gentle, loving kiss and embraced. I walked away and I experienced an orgasm. I knew I was aroused. I'm deeply in love and attracted to him, but I didn't know I was that aroused. Can you help me? Is this a matter of irresponsibility? Is this some sort of lack of knowledge of my own body and heart? I deeply want to know how to not let my arousal get that far, but

I feel very lost. Bless you, dear sister. Bless, bless, bless. Thank you for your very honest question. I think what you're going through is very understandable. It sounds like you're you're the disposition of your heart is in the right place. Our, our bodies have these reactions and they are not the just the fact that we have these reactions does not mean something is going wrong. It means something is going

right. We must learn to be master of our own bodies and aware of our weaknesses and where we could cross a line and inadvertently experience a climax. This is what you're experiencing. These are inadvertent. You're not seeking them. However, you are learning things about your body and and one of your questions was am I just how did she say it? Am I just ignorant about my emotions in my body or something? Some lack of knowledge, my own

body and heart. Am I just lack lacking knowledge in the workings of my own body and heart? I would say yes, to some extent. You're lacking knowledge, but you're growing in knowledge. You're growing in knowledge and let me just comfort you with these words from John Paul the second. Listen to these beautiful words. This is from his book Love and Responsibility. He says a readily roused sensuality. A readily roused sensuality is the stuff from which a rich, if difficult, personal life can be made, and it can aid in the

experience of interpersonal love. Beautiful, beautiful. It sounds to me like you are learning you have a readily roused sensuality. That is a particular gift. Receive it as a gift, but it's also a particular responsibility. It's something you can embrace about yourself, love about yourself. But the love of yourself here also comes with responsibility. Love and responsibility.

You should not be seeking arousal in in this way that it leads to climax. You should not be seeking that. I don't believe you are, but you are discovering that even a kiss from your boyfriend can arouse you to the point of climax. So my advice to you would be to be more and more aware, as much as you are able, of what causes your readily roused sensuality to kick into gear, and to be very cautious in expressing

affection that causes that readily roused sensuality to kick into to gear. You do not want to be having your body experiencing sexual climax from a mere kiss from your boyfriend. If it does. If that were a regular experience, then I would advise only a fraternal kisses. Fraternal kisses and that's going to demand also some open communication with your boyfriend and and if you are both of a certain level of

maturity. I don't know anything about you or your age or your relationship here, but a certain level of maturity would maturity would be required to have those conversations in which you share with him. In guarding my own readily roused sensuality. Here are the limits I'm learning that we should respect in our expressions of affection. And I I would encourage you also to read my book, Good News about Sex and Marriage, Chapter 4,

where I get into some of the nitty gritties there that I think you'll you'll find helpful. But I'm going to, I'm going to pass to my beloved wife here, who I know as a woman can speak into these matters, maybe with certainly with more personal experience of how a woman's body works, but also just that feminine heart. That'll be helpful. Yeah, I, I find myself just wanting to speak a little bit to maybe some of our listeners who have never experienced a sexual climax and a kind of like

perplexed by, you know, how could that be? So maybe just, you know, there are plenty of listeners who have not experienced it. It's not like there's anything wrong with that, but I just want to kind of pause and, and comment a little bit about the climax because I think we can have an impression from, unfortunately, from media or from, yeah, from movies or shows or other media that somehow

every sexual climax is a very dramatic event. And I, I feel like just in the description that she's given here, she's kind of describing something not super dramatic, you know, that she's just kind of turned and walking away and experiences something in her body that she, you know, didn't feel a dramatic build up towards or a dramatic experience at the time. And I just, I feel like acknowledging that that for both men and women, there can be

different types of experiences of the body reaching climax that are not all, you know, in whatever we've kind of maybe imagined maybe from Yeah, just the things we're surmising from other people. So just to acknowledge that this could be a, a very sort of almost low key, if that expression makes sense here. And so I want to say that so that it's less confusing to what I, what else I want to say about

it is that that for anybody who experiences something like that, and I myself have experienced an unintended experience like that. So I, I can relate to it and the, the feeling of surprise and confusion and why is this happening? So I, I certainly, you know, just, I'm not, it's not totally theoretical. I and I, I think that's just part of my own learning of my body and as a woman and how it's

responding to things. And, you know, we go through a host of different experiences in life. And it may be that right now in this relationship and in whatever the story of her growth as a woman is, this is is happening. Does that mean that will always be a concern in her life throughout all her relationships, throughout all the stages of her relationship with this boyfriend? Not necessarily. So I don't want somebody to hear that and think, yeah, I'm, I'm

kind of just feeling cautious for people being alarmed by this story. And what could this possibly mean? It could very well be that this is a temporary experience that you're having and won't continue to go on. So just in, I just want to assure you of that, that that nothing that you're sharing is shocking and nothing that you're saying is a sign of some kind of you should have known or you will always have to have this

kind of guard around your life and your actions. We don't know all that, but what we know is about right now. And I think I, I love the way introduced your question talking about the goodness of our our bodies and that they become aroused, that there is climax. Like I love that you started with that affirmation, but I'm sure there's also other feelings and complex things going on in the mix. So with all that, I just, I encourage you to kind of revisit

any times that that has happened by surprise in prayer and to ask the Lord to just really calm your fears and, and let you know he is with you, that you're not alone in this. Because there's something, maybe it's just the image of, of you kind of walking away from your boyfriend and, and you're sort of alone that I want you to know the Lord is right there with

you. You're not actually alone. And he truly did make your body. He truly did. He truly is has your good in his heart. And and I, I just ask you to to pause and really rest in that place. And then yes, as Christopher said, yeah, you actually are learning things. And this is a way that you're learning. And all of us have to learn things about our bodies. And I think, you know, she put in all caps.

I didn't know I was that aroused. And there's some humor in that. But there's also just to like, OK, you didn't recognize that that build up and that that physical, emotional reality that was going on. But but in the future, you will, you know, and that's I think what Christopher was meaning by saying you are learning and to be patient with that process. And yeah, to know that you're,

you like everyone, we're all fallen human beings. And there can be ways in which we are, you know, not perfectly pure in our intentions and not to be afraid of that either. Like the Lord came to redeem us. It's OK that we're not perfect to ask his mercy and his grace, and especially his love and presence with you and assurance that of your goodness that that he's journeying with you in this and every season of your life.

And yeah, but he would calm your fears and give you that grace. I do love the way you proposed, Christopher, that she would talk about that with her boyfriend. I thought you gave really wise words because it can be hard to think how am I even going to say this? So. So I appreciate that you gave her those just suggested words. It's a it's a beautiful journey of life and I, I see the beauty of this stage of your journey because I'm, you know, stepped

back and sort of looking on, have this motherly feeling towards you, right? Like, oh, yes, I get that. And sometimes we're in the thick of things. We just kind of get annoyed and frustrated with ourselves. So I just want to share that like perspective, like, yes, yeah, this is a beautiful gift and and the Lord is with you and you are learning. I'm imagining some listeners out there who, who might be very uncomfortable with the very idea

of bringing Jesus into such an experience. And we, we have these strict categories in our minds. We have spiritual things over there and sexual things over there and narrow. The tween shall meet. They must meet. They must come together. This, this is what the incarnation is all about, the bringing together of the spiritual and the physical. And as Wendy said, the Lord made your body. He knows your body intimately. He designed it to be aroused.

He designed it this way and there should be what whatever fears might come up. I'm speaking to all the listeners out there. If you are having fears at the thought of Oh my gosh, bringing Jesus into experiences like that that that that just sounds So what what He was born of a woman. He entered intimately into the mystery of woman. He he he made and designed woman he he took on male flesh born of a woman. Jesus and Mary alone know how to guide us in all of our

shortcomings, impurities, disordered desires, lack of self mastery, all of that. How are we to heal, how are we to grow without the help of Jesus and Mary? And so we have to overcome whatever fears would prevent us from bringing Jesus and Mary in there. It is a false gospel. A false gospel. It is a Gnostic heretical idea to keep spiritual things on one side and physical and sexual things on the other. There must be integration, and that integration comes through

the healing presence of the true man, Jesus Christ, and the true woman, Mary. As we welcome them into these painful fallen experiences we have, they alone can show us the path out to full healing and integration. Be not afraid, be not afraid. Our bodies are designed by God as holy to be a gift. It is true we are fallen. We are in need of redemption. But that redemption Christ came to win for us is a redemption of our bodies.

He came in the flesh as a male born of a woman, to redeem our bodies, male and female, so that we could. Become the gift we are. Amen. Ask Christopher W is brought to you by the Theology of the Body Institute with music by Mike Mangione. Christopher and Wendy hope that the information provided is helpful to you, but remind you that they are not licensed

counselors. If you're going through serious difficulty, a list of trusted counselors and psychologists can be found in the show notes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Trans Jesus and Saints?, I’m 50 and Still Single, & Why Is Birth Control Sinful? | ACW411

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Hello Christopher and Wendy. I saw an article on Facebook about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Miscarriage feels like abortion, Is my body really me? & My past haunts our engagement | ACW410

    Nov 9, 20261 hrAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: Since we've been married, my wife has been pregnant twice, and both...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Catholics Afraid of Desire?, My Wife Can’t Climax, Arousal During Adoration | ACW409

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    🏔️ This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Signup for Ascension’s Alto here with discount code ASK10 Questions answered this episode: We're in our early 40s, and TOB has healed our marriage, our wounds...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When He Mistakes Kindness for Love, Is the Holy Spirit Female?, & I Keep Falling Before My Wedding | ACW408

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! I'm wondering if you have advice on how to handle a situation where kindness is interpreted as romantic interest. I want to treat others with dignity and view them...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Drunk Driver Killed My Family, She Rejects NFP, My Husband's Words Hurt | ACW407

    Oct 19, 202658 minAudio

    This episode of ACW is sponsored by Ascension’s Alto! Questions answered this episode: When I was 11, I was in a horrible car wreck. My mother and two younger brothers were killed, and I was critically injured. I...

    Credit the people on this episode