Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

ASH CLOUD

ASH CLOUD artwork

Investing in regenerative agriculture, the food system, and metabolic health with Carter Williams - iSelect Fund

Feb 6, 202652 minAudio

There is a huge amount we can learn from understanding the connections between soil health, food production, and human metabolic health. Over the last 50-60 years, modern agricultural systems have become increasingly reliant on synthetic inputs that boost yields but degrade soil microbiomes and reduce micronutrient density in our food. This degradation contributes to the chronic disease epidemic costing the United States trillions of dollars annually. The impact of regenerative agriculture on both environmental and human health cannot be understated. Healthier soils with robust microbiomes produce crops with superior nutritional profiles - more micronutrients and beneficial phytochemicals that express through the soil-plant-human pathway. When people consume these nutrient-dense foods, they show reduced appetite for processed foods and better metabolic outcomes, though randomized controlled trials remain limited. Today we are joined by Carter Williams from iSelect Fund, a 10-year-old investment firm focused on reducing chronic disease by transforming food systems. Williams coordinates investments across the food value chain - from row crop biologics to novel sweeteners and soil health monitoring. iSelect Fund targets decommoditizing 5-10% of conventional agriculture rather than wholesale transformation, creating price premiums for regenerative producers while stabilizing markets for conventional farmers. The fund prioritizes nutrient density over yield maximization. Williams identifies cognitive load as agriculture's fundamental transformation challenge. Farmers with 20 years of conventional experience face learning entirely new systems. This extends throughout supply chains: CPG companies have infrastructure optimized for current grain varieties; input companies have systems built around synthetic fertilizer. Even willing stakeholders face substantial cognitive and financial investment requirements. The conversation explores modernizing Bureau of Land Management grazing practices. Research showing $200-300 million in upstream regenerative interventions could have prevented $10 billion in European flood insurance losses demonstrates how regenerative livestock management delivers net carbon-positive outcomes while improving rancher economics. Emerging feedback mechanisms accelerate adoption. Companies like Diatious provide data showing how feeding practices affect omega-3/omega-6 ratios, enabling evidence-based practice changes. Companies like Brightseed build in-silico models mapping how growing practices affect phytochemical expression and human metabolism. Williams argues consumer voice - amplified by influencers - now drives change more effectively than the previous decade's farmer-led push. As retailers stock out of cottage cheese due to GLP-1 diet trends rather than label-reading, market dynamics shift faster than Nielsen surveys suggested possible. Send us Fan Mail

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Ash SweetingWelcome to the AshCloud. I'm Ash Sweeting. Today I'm joined by Carter Williams from iSelect Fund to discuss the connections between what we eat, how it's produced, our metabolic health, and creating viable business models that address all three. Carter, thank you very much for joining me today. Glad to be here. So you recently wrote a futuristic piece on how we could change the use of BLM lands and it would provide benefits to human health, environmental health, as well as improve the financial viability of the ranches on those lands.

Ash SweetingSo in on that note, can we just start off by exploring the connections that human health has with environmental health and so we can understand how those win-wins can be at least the basis for where those win-wins come from?

Carter WilliamsYeah, so I think there's a common connection in terms of soil health that we often talk about. That the that we uh if the soil nutrition comes from soil, the microbiome picks up those nutrients, pulls it into the plants, the plants express it, especially in terms of micronutrients and some of the phytochemicals. So uh that's that's sort of the process. And if soil health is better, that whole mechanism works.

Carter WilliamsAnd then when you eat those plants, uh, or when the cattle eat those plants, uh both of them produce either healthier meat or the humans have healthier food, uh, it tastes better, so they're more likely to want to eat it. Uh and and that just generates uh less metabolic pressure um because people then eat fresh vegetables and fresh food instead of uh processed food.

Carter WilliamsSo that's like the core component of it. Now, if you start building on that, how do you get healthy soils? Well, if you use less chemicals, uh while we can use MPK and we can use uh synthetic fertilizer and such uh to boost yield over time that degrades the microbiome, uh it degrades some of the micronutrients, and so you're you've got a trade-off going on there. So that then leads to things like organic and regenerative, in which you say, Hey, can I can I get some better soil health?

Carter WilliamsSo I've got better water retention, I don't need those chemicals as much. I've got a more comprehensive microbiome and balances things out more. And whether there are natural toxins that that emerge, or toxins that come in from the chemicals we use, or toxins that come in from the offfall from a coal plant landing there, those all get processed in a more effective way at that point once that soil health is boosted. There are other things we need to do, but it starts to lay the framework in which you both have uh improved the nutritional quality of the food.

Carter WilliamsUh, you do that through regenerative, that reduces the amount of synthetic chemicals coming in, it reduces the need to use once you have a healthier soil, you have less weeds, you have you attract less pests, you can bring that all back into balance to reduce the overall need for synthetic chemicals, and you you make up a product that comes off the land that that people prefer. Uh if you do regenerative correctly, uh we're seeing input costs go down.

Carter WilliamsSo uh the farmers making more profit, the food tastes better, people are willing to pay more for it. Um, you sort of have a natural ecosystem. Uh it does not, in its first instance, there solve other exogenous toxins that have been introduced per se. Uh there are other things we should be doing on that front, but it starts to take that pressure down.

Ash SweetingTo play devil's advocate advocate for a minute, that there seems to be lots and lots of upsides and very few downsides. So why why do you think this is not much more um happening much broad more broadly or much more widespread across our production systems given all the wins and all the benefits of it and the the lack of downsides?

Carter WilliamsYeah, so I think that as I think John Kemp says as often is it takes it's a cognitive load. It's if you've been farming in a particular way, let's say for 20 years, which really right now we we're sort of 20, 25 years into this kind of especially as we talk about um row crops. But anybody who's you're you're farming with 20 years of experience, and all of a sudden you gotta make a major change.

Carter WilliamsIt's sort of like saying to somebody, you know, figure out what a web browser is. It there's there's a part like I used to write letters and type stuff up, and now I'm putting it in Google and writing it up in a word processor. There's just a cognitive shift that I think uh takes time for people to adapt. I think that the the people who are running businesses, I mean, I it's a really obscure point, but one of the one of the CPGs has a whole bunch of infrastructure for um processing grain in a particular way, and there's a new variant of that grain that requires much less processing.

Carter WilliamsWell, if you've built up these efficiencies to process the grain one way, and all of a sudden there's this new process, you've got to come up with other things and you you gotta pay off the milling process you have, that you all of a sudden you really slow your thinking down. And then conversely, if if you're a crop input company and you've selling a lot of fertilizer and you're gonna make a change, you can you know you're losing business, plus you got to change all your systems. So even if people want to do exactly the right thing, it requires a investment, especially if you're talking about scale.

Carter WilliamsYou know, when one thing we often say in the United States is recognize we've got like in row crop, we've got 300 million row crop acres, and a large farmer's 20,000 acres. So there are a lot of we're talking about a lot of people that need to make a change, um and uh a lot of moving wheels. So I think it's a combination of first and foremost cognitive load, you've got to think differently. You gotta make in-season changes, um, you've got to do more soil testing.

Carter WilliamsUh, you've got to change your business relationships uh with people that are maybe more expertise on that. The the trade-offs are a little bit different, you'll learn them over time, and so I think we're we're seeing that sort of effort to educate people.

Ash SweetingSo it very much comes down to a people slash societal cultural type of a challenge rather than than anything else.

Carter WilliamsUm it shouldn't be we shouldn't underestimate that challenge. Um it I I think it there are I don't want to change, and I don't want I, you know, I'm big co and I don't want to change, so there maybe it doesn't take long to get into calling nefarious or economic optimization choices that work against it, but uh all of the above are the problem.

Ash SweetingIt reminds me I spent um four or five years living in Abu Dhabi working for the Abu Dhabi Government's Agricultural Advisory Service there, and um there was a perception that okay, Abu Dhabi one that's a it's a um not short of funds, so money if you if you could make a point, there was always gonna be the money, and if there was any need for any sort of government legislation, it's a rather um it's a it's a hundred percent monarchy, so the monarch had full power to do that.

Ash SweetingSo you think, well, you know, we there's gonna be some ability to make things move along a bit faster because some of those hurdles that we normally see as significant um were not there, but um our team spanned pretty much from Morocco through to Bangladesh plus Europe plus South Africa plus Australia, North America, South America. So we had a lot of different opinions um in every single meeting. And um it was, you know, that those different opinions and cultural lenses was always very prevalent in terms of trying to get any consensus, and it became very obvious that the the you know the the the people um hurdles um were very, very real given the fact that the other hurdles were much much more manageable.

Carter WilliamsYeah, I think it's doing anything complex. I mean, I originally come out of aerospace, and people are like, how do you get from aerospace to agriculture and become an expert? I'm not an expert in agriculture, I'm an expert in complexity. You know, if you're trying to build an airplane, it it is you're trying to optimize a lot, and uh and people as much as criticism as Boeing's gotten recently, uh it still flies a lot of people safely and certainly safer than any other form of travel.

Carter WilliamsSo it's complexity, and these are complex systems. We our healthcare system is a byproduct of getting these things wrong, um, and it's costing us trillions. So it's a big complex system. In the case that you were doing, what were you trying to optimize on agriculture?

Ash SweetingOn agriculture, so there was a lot of date palm um production, so 24,000 date farms.

Carter WilliamsUh within the UAE, or were you sourcing out of other countries?

Ash SweetingWe were all within Abu Dhabi. Um plus there was growing. Um, I think when I first got there, there was a few dozen uh greenhouse hydroponics facilities, and by the time I left there were hundreds of them um either in operation and being built. Um a big part of the challenge was obviously water in the desert. There's a fossil aquifer under there. Um 40 or 50 odd years ago, that was you know within 10 or 20 or 10 or 15 metres or or very close to the surface, and now it's um I think it's well over a hundred meters deep, and obviously the salinity side of that and and water use efficiency, and and there was a yeah, it was a very interesting period because the way the farms worked is they're all owned by Emiratis.

Ash SweetingUm, and 99.9% of those Emiratis were absentee owners, and they were run by um labourers that were imported. Um, the vast majority were from Bangladesh and Bengali speakers, and we did a survey of farm workers um early on when I got there, and we found out that less than a third of the farm labourers had spent a single day at school in their entire lives. So we had to deal with so it suddenly became you know, how do you communicate with these people in a way that they can understand both language-wise and educational base-wise, and what's a level of technology that would be appropriate.

Ash SweetingAnd it started off with a lot of the a lot of the farm workers would just run the irrigation pumps 24-7 on these date pumps. Yeah, yeah. And um, so you know, you start.

Carter WilliamsYou see that sometimes when they start using when they get access to fertilizer and some of the African places, they just pour fertilizer on the thing without regard. So they're it is interesting. I mean, at times we've had we've raised the question of uh, you know, sometimes it's better to introduce the next generation in a place that is a generation behind.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Carter WilliamsBecause there's no card sort of installed base of knowledge. Um people, especially in Africa, that I've brought this up, have also sort of raised the uh um the challenge that there's in agriculture they've stressed that you know bringing the next level of technology on when they haven't gotten through some other husbandry steps does create a disconnect. Um and so, for example, coming in with GMO seeds and saying you know, if you sort of say the next generation technology is GMO seeds with a a um a trait protected herbicide, you know, they're they're not even good at doing any kind of application of anything.

Ash SweetingOh, there's so many there's so many um things that need to be, you know. So I guess there's so many things that we in the West take for granted as being in place. The fact that there's transport infrastructure to um move those things around in a timely fashion, the fact that there's um trade or distribution networks that can sell what's needed at the right time. Um, all those bits and bobs that we we all take for granted.

Carter WilliamsUm But often we think the the right antidote that Clay Christensen taught us a long time ago is that when you see innovation disruptions, it normally occurs a new firm selling to new to customers who whose needs are not met by existing firms. And so the people who picked up PCs were people that were frustrated by mainframes. Um and so a thing we've thought about is, and this is related a little bit to the BLM-related article, is you have smaller ranchers, say it's not teeny, but let's say you have a rancher that's got a herd of 600 um who are on BLM land, you know, they they may represent you you might go to them with a solution rather than someone who's running a herd of 90,000 on on KAFO.

Carter WilliamsUm and and when you talk to those kind of farmers, they're trying to figure out how to do grass grass-fed and grass finished. Um and so that creates new challenges. Grass finished to get taste right is may mean that they now need to go to a four-year cycle on that herd because the first three years boost mass, but that fourth year, which nobody uses in CAFO because they're using corn finished, that fourth year may boost taste if the right kind of forage is around.

Carter WilliamsUm and so that's a new practice. And and that's the cognitive load part, is there's a shift in thinking there.

Ash SweetingIt all comes back to that complexity side of things in many, many ways. And um you know, the the grass, you know, how you can you can grow animals off grass as fast and as well as you can grow them off um off grain, um, pretty much if you've got it right. Um but the management needed to do that is um more complex and needs much more fine-tuning than to do it in a in a feed yard.

Ash SweetingSo it comes back to that how that complexity um and having the managerial and skills, etc., to manage that complexity at the level it's needed. Um which is you know, goes back to that complexity, and whether it's air airline systems or whether it's um our food systems, um, you know, that complexity is always there.

Carter WilliamsAnd one thing that sort of differentiates regenerative from organic, I think, is that I I believe I'm not positive about this, but generally when I talk to large producers that are moving to regenerative, they're seeing costs come down. And they they can't achieve the same thing on organic. And when you can start getting costs go down, then then you're creating an additional motivation.

Carter WilliamsIt's one thing to say, I want to make a better product, it's gonna cost more. That's one kind of set of innovation. The other kind of innovation that's much easier to adopt is I want to do something that's better and it's gonna cost less to produce. Well, that it's a lot easier for people to say yes to adopting that. And and those are important distinctions as you think about how to lay out this technology, and and it will require elements of technology to get there. Um maybe less about chemicals, but maybe more about understanding the health and microbiome.

Carter WilliamsUm more about supply chain control or anyway.

Ash SweetingI think there's an interesting um well something interesting that the bee that that we can learn from the dairy industry in that a dairy farmer has this barometer two or three times a day, um, which is the amount of milk in the milk that that tells them whether any changes or interventions are actually making them more money or costing them more money. So there's this continual feedback loop which gives them the confidence that when they experiment with different approaches and practices, yeah, they um they know they can track progress because they they see what happens to the milk fat.

Ash SweetingUm with beef cattle, that's obviously much more challenging because you know you're not getting that regular feedback in terms of productivity and weight. So you're trying something new, but only when you bring the animals in and weigh them or send them off to um or sell them, do you actually say, okay, that's so there's a greater risk because you don't have that um that feedback loop that gives you the confidence.

Carter WilliamsYeah, and I think that feedback loop, you know, as we think about adoption of some of these shifts and then also practice, so a couple dimensions that we sort of see that we pay attention to. Because we are, in general, we think we can make this change over a 20-year period, which is we took 50, 60 years to get into this hole. So 20 years getting out in the grand scheme of things to me is whatever. I mean, that's just the way technology flows. Um, so one thing is is people gotta stop thinking, oh well, we're gonna change this all next year.

Carter WilliamsUm the the other part is we do see little shifts, like in a multi-generational conventional um farm, you know, if somebody's sixty-five years old on that farm, so whoever the the outgoing Family member, so to speak, they remember as a kid that the soil health was a lot stronger. And so they've got a if somebody comes in and talks to him, that person about how do you improve soil health, they have a perspective.

Carter WilliamsIf you go to talk to their offspring, their offspring have always lived in this particular environment and don't have a frame of reference. And so now the entrepreneur going in and saying, hey, here's a way to do regenerative, is there's no other perspective to educate them. So for example, when we talk about um using crop enhancement with microbi microbiology, you don't have to get over that is it possible hurdle with a 65-year-old, but you do have to do it with a 35-year-old, which goes against most conventional perspective.

Carter WilliamsThey think the 35-year-old is going to be more willing to adopt.

Ash SweetingSo it's having those those market channels that where you can get premiums for it.

Carter WilliamsBut but then you go back to the dairy, as you mentioned, you know, in the U.S., you have Fair Life putting a lot of pressure on the market, talking differently about how dairy should be treated, and figuring out how to talk to consumers about premium elements of it. Well, if you're that corn guy, your marketing program maybe should change that you should go to the dairy, a regional dairy, and say, let's work together and see whether the fact that my I've got more nutritional density and uh and characteristics in my corn is to I think it'll express differently in the in the in the uh milk.

Carter WilliamsLet's do that. And and so I think that to some degree some of the regenerative folks in particular have to think about marketing. Now, at the end of the day, when everything's harvested, how much is gonna go to the dairy and how much is gonna go to the elevator? They still have to play that game a little bit, but but they may very well be able to get some premium, and that's just gonna require a little bit more ground level connections, and it depends if you have a dairy nearby. And same thing with with even how you finish.

Carter WilliamsI mean, one thing I've seen is some people that are doing regenerative brief still grass, still grain finish, but they've changed the the ration around, and they they've changed the quality of the of what they're inputting there, and so they might still have a lot less corn in that case, but it's still technically grain finished.

Ash SweetingYeah, I think there's a lot of um gray in the middle between you know, there's there's you know, that grain or or supplementary feed where it's a grain or a hay or anything, can be it's a very, very powerful management tool that can help you get to the quality level you need. Um, and if that means you have to take the animals off pasture a little bit earlier, um, which preserves that pasture, you're getting a lot of the benefit of you know, across all those systems, because those animals are obviously feeding the soil through their manure, um, and that's also feeding the soil microbiome.

Ash SweetingSo there's all those feedback loops and grass finished, you know, if they get a little, you know, there's there's there's lots of tools there that we can also use in those space if they're used very strategically and for the right reason.

Carter WilliamsAnd we've also got better feedback mechanisms. So one of our port codes is a dacious and it it will capture that data. And I I think we're seeing some of the more sophisticated producers do those tests and doing correlation analysis, which is you know, we fed in this way, we got omega-6, omega-3s more in balance. Okay, we should change our practices this way. We won't have to test as much, but there's a better way to run our practices.

Carter WilliamsUm, we'll use less fungicide for this reason because it balances omega-3s, and it just those nuances are something that producers are starting to have to pay attention to cognitive load.

Ash SweetingOn that note, and this is probably more going towards human health, the the nutrient density discussion or conversation, it's something that you know was hardly even brought up um five, ten years ago when it's becoming more and more pre-prevalent. Um, how much more, you know, how much do we know about what's going on? Because you know, traditionally food labels have had you know half a dozen or a dozen or so things on nutrients on the labels, the macros and sugar and fat and salt.

Ash SweetingUm, but the more we dig into it, we're realising that there's thousands and thousands of biologically active chemicals in um our food and our environment that are all impacting our health and our metabolism. So where's where's that at? How much more do we need to know? Do we know enough to be able to really start to make impacts? And then how do we kind of link those two those two things together?

Carter WilliamsYeah, I mean, we are still spending a lot of money on it. Um we have we have uh practitioners who are running diabetes programs, prototy prescription programs, that say when they source local fresh regenerative food, um the patients are more compliant and their appetite for processed food goes down.

Carter WilliamsAll observational. Nobody's done a randomized control trial on that. All observational, difficult to even validate that that the in these environments, but we've heard that again and again and again. So that's you know, where there's smoke, there's fire. Um, we have companies like Brightseed that are very much going down and trying to, they have built an in Silica model of humans, they understand how those are metabolized, they're able to understand the degree to which your body metabolizes them.

Carter WilliamsUm they're not positive what it does. But they're understanding the mechanisms and they're understanding they're starting to understand that this growing practice expresses these um micronutrients, and and then we are starting to understand at the microbiome level how that expresses, and then we've got the um proteomics where we can now start even judging something like by doing a proteomic level analysis, we can understand effectively proxy VO2 max, or we can look for mitochondria damage.

Carter WilliamsA problem at NIH as National Institute of Health in the US is we've you know, we spend $50 billion a year in research, but only about a billion or two has ever gone to anything in the area of nutrition. And so we're really fairly behind on understanding um this expression of nutrient in a human over this longitudinal period results on this proteomic impact on them at the mitochondria.

Carter WilliamsAnd we've got scientists that say you don't need to study that, that's that's worthless. And then we've got other scientists that say, no, you do need to study it because you really need to understand oxidative stress and its impact on the mitochondria and how that affects. So we we've got debates at the scientific level that go from you guys are just overusing technology to to uh no, there's if you really want to undercover uncover what comes in obesity, you gotta focus on this.

Carter WilliamsSo we're gonna have to invest more dollars there. We have figured out how to get revenue on those. You got young companies, they gotta get revenue, um, but it hasn't really fallen down into product yet, and that's gonna still be some more work to do. Um I do think that on the nutrition side, the work that Lustig did at um KDD, which was in Kuwait, um where he took a step forward, often we say reduce sugar.

Carter WilliamsUh, he said reduced fructose, because fructose mechanistically damages the liver. If you otherwise have carbohydrates or some sugars, they can maybe be processed in the in the bowels, won't have the same impact. But fructose comes in and and beats up on the mitochondria fairly directly. So what they did at KDD is they they went through the step and they basically said, let's let's find the right forms of fiber to add, let's find the right sugars to back off on, let's stick more allose and monk fruit and tagatose in.

Carter WilliamsAnd they they did it a step lower than I think a lot of CPGs have been thinking about. And I so I think we are at a point, and then they put everybody on a CGM and A B tested before and after to see what the human impact was. And so I think what is happening is the smarter food scientists are at the macronutrients, you know, things like carbs, um, carbs, maybe protein and fiber.

Carter WilliamsThey're starting to understand some of the macro effects along the lines of what Lustig talks about of uh feed the gut, protect the liver, support the brain, that you know, we can change the oils around and change the gut around and bring it to enhance it. The phytochemical kind of stuff that may come down, I think we're we have businesses doing that, but I think it's gonna be a little while before you can even get the scientific community comfortable that that's a place we should be focusing.

Ash SweetingThe the word that comes to mind is once again complexity. Um very much so. And I think adding to what you're talking about um Lustig's work is the the mitochondria and where that fits in, and whether that's the sort of um, this is the work of David Sinclair at Harvard, but the um the NAD boosting, the the um stimulating those protective genes, assert genes, and how that kind of leads to increased or improved mitochondrial function, and then where inflammation, because so many of these um metabolic disease or inflammatory disease, and what pressure that puts on the mitochondria.

Ash SweetingAnd then then some of the work of Inigo Sam um Sam Milan um on how you actually train your mitochondria to metabolize certain different um energy sources, and if you have too much sugar, your your mitochondria just learn to metabolize sugar, and they kind of almost lose the ability to metabolize fat.

Carter WilliamsYeah, did you see that um what's his name who's doing his body test? What's that guy's name again? Um an athlete or a the guy who's the billionaire who's going over the top on just modifying his body. Anyway, he just he just did something that he cycles his mitochondria.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Carter WilliamsHe's found that like if you apparently if you cycle intensity for two weeks and relaxation for two weeks, it it retrains the mitochondria, which is pretty cool. But um going back to David Sinclair as an example, here's an odd one. And I was shocked to do this. It's just an understanding. Like David Sinclair posted on Twitter uh he did a I guess he went on a CGM and he posted the plot, and he said, Oh, my plot was all wacky during the night because I ate a snack at night.

Carter WilliamsAnd he had a plot that showed that he he surged and dove and surged and dove over like an eight-hour period. It's like, no, you have an unhealthy that that's not I ate something before I went to bed and had a glucose spike. You actually have an unhealthy condition, unless you've run some on some drugs, you actually have an unhealthy response. You should not have seen a perturbation over six hours from a late-night snack.

Carter WilliamsYou may have seen like a delayed glycemic going back to normal, but he was having a he was having a wave effect. And so here is a leading expert who didn't even know how to read his own, I don't think. I mean, uh here's a leading expert that should have recognized that a CGM plot was going through this perturbation and commented, oh, the reason it's doing that is because I'm on I'm on I'm on a thousand milligrams of I don't even think it would do it, but I you know I'm on a thousand milligrams of this, and you know, that's causing a perturbation.

Carter WilliamsBut I was surprised when I saw that posted that he didn't even make any comments like that. So we have people in the field who are experts that um are expert in a in a portion of it.

Ash SweetingI think very much so because you know it comes back to that that complexity and the complexity of our metabolism and how it reacts to there's a great study um that I remember reading about um uh uh insulin um spikes, and um they use people for eating ice cream and people eating sushi, and roughly 50% of the people got this huge insulin spike from the ice cream, and the other 50% of the people in the study, um the sushi caused the insulin spike.

Carter WilliamsUm was that a was that a uh allergy response?

Ash SweetingThey put it down to the microbiome and how the microbiome um reacted with the food and drove drove the insulin response. Um but it it just you know it kind of highlights the the the complexity of it and and the fact that it's not always gonna turn out in the way that we would most naturally think it would, because you know, the ice cream.

Carter WilliamsYeah, I think our job, and we see this a little bit, we have startups that that range the distance. So we're we're both coming up with natural sugars that can be used now, and then we're you know, the far end of bright seed. So we as an investor we're touching these in different spots. Right now, I think it's we're reasonably enough information and evidence that says, you know, rotate the fructose out, rotate healthy sugars in, add some fiber to buffer the spike. Uh test your products to look at general glycemic response across a broad array of people.

Carter WilliamsUm, that's a fairly inexpensive test to run at a food science level, and and just uh if you're a CPG, just back the glycemic pressure down. That I think that is a reasonable step right now. That and I think to some degree RFK should give the CPGs a little bit of wiggle room there to do that. Um I I just think that that's a good do that right now.

Ash SweetingSo, and then I guess back back to the the ag side, the food production side of things, um, so you've got a quite a broad mandate, you know, across the whole range of from the the food side of things all the way upstream to the production side of things. So I guess how do you how do you tie that all together?

Carter WilliamsI have no idea. Uh we we are tied together around metabolic and nutritional density. So, for example, we're not so yield focused. Um, and so we think we've thought more and more about how to provide tools to the producers so that they can build value-added product. So we're we're sort of a decommoditized um nutrient-dense type of viewpoint, and we touch, we're like, where are the missing parts to get there?

Carter WilliamsI would also say if you sort of say we're trying to change five percent to ten percent of conventional, not a hundred percent. Our general attitude is if if we can move, if we can decommoditize five percent of commodity crop, that'll bring price stability, that'll give price premium to the to those producers, but it will also give some price stability to the conventional people at the same time.

Carter WilliamsSo there's a we're not talking about you know, a hundred percent. Um and so we invest in that area where where we can help move nutrient density further forward, value added further forward, without giving out huge amounts of yield.

Ash SweetingAnd how do you see the balance um across your portfolio in terms of row crops and the different row crops plus you know, whore vegetables, plus tree crops, etc.?

Carter WilliamsAnd then also we just happen to be more row crop focused. We started the fund in the St. Louis area. We have a lot of people in our ecosystem that are consumers of row crops or producers of row crops. Um we just know a lot of the technical folks out of sort of the Monsantos of the world. Um, so I would say we are a little bit, we are behind versus in terms of our investments.

Carter WilliamsWe've got some in strawberries, some of our biologics go into specialty uh Vestron focuses on crop protection and tree. Um, so we have entries into those other areas. Um, but I would say our network is you know, I I know 120,000 acre row crop farmers on speed dial. I don't have that kind of relationship with with specialty.

Carter WilliamsYeah. We know WGA and Western growers and things, but we don't we don't have as much of a granular understanding of that. But we work with we've co invested with people like Mixing Bowl and people that are closer to that side, but we're I would say that we're we're just genetic. A little bit more understanding of row crop.

Ash SweetingAnd what about the the livestock side of things? I guess because of the going back to that BLM um paper or piece that you wrote.

Carter WilliamsYeah, so we've done we've not done a lot on livestock. We've always we've never been an alt meat. We've been an alt meat from a standpoint of build protein and soy, but we've never been um synthetic meat. We've always, and we always took a viewpoint 10 years ago that livestock ultimately was could be net carbon positive, which was controversial at the time. Um, but we're sort of Alan Savory types in that regard.

Carter WilliamsUm, so we've focused more on um inputs and testing around those lands, a little bit less on livestock operations. Um, you know, looking at Holter's valuation, I wish we had done more in that area. Um so I think we're a little we've lightly dabbled on the livestock side there. Um that certainly has taken off as an investment theme more recently because of the prices. Um but in the long perspective, we got into that BLM discussion because friends of ours, it just became obvious that there were some other ways to help them monetize.

Carter WilliamsLike you've got, since we do a lot of stuff around soil, you've got the opportunity Microsoft and Google are going to pay for carbon no matter what. You don't have to worry about who's in the White House. Um, you know, are there other ways to sort of bring those dollars into those operations? And then we've done a lot of work with TNC around grasslands, and and our work at Earth Optics is doing a lot more in grasslands, and so we've sort of backed our way into doing even more in livestock, and in terms of this grasslands area, which is really why we wrote that article, was hey, there's an opportunity right now, the planets are aligned for BLM to modernize its approach um between Brook Rollins and Interior.

Carter WilliamsYou know, there's an attitude of like, how do we help these farmers? And there might be an opportunity to really sort of take us out of the 60s, which BLM is still sort of operating as if it's in the 60s, and and really take what Alan Savory said was good, and and really what the Nature Conservancy has said is good, which is that you you can do integrated livestock in a way that is net carbon positive.

Ash SweetingAnd that go goes back to what you were saying about what not having to unlearn all that stuff that you'd learn over the 20 last 20 or 30 years, because you're still back in that area where it was beforehand.

Carter WilliamsYeah, and I and even like there's even other opportunities of taking culled herds out of uh dairy and then integrating them in and actually still keeping some of the economic life of those dairy cows, uh, putting them back on the land to make money on them, improving the land quality. Um, and we're starting to see back to the ecological questions you asked at the beginning. You you increase that land, you get less runoff, and you're not gonna have floods in New Orleans.

Carter WilliamsI mean, that those are I think we're getting those are real economic issues.

Ash SweetingOh, they're monumental, they're huge. They're not million-dollar, they're billion hundreds of tens of billions of dollar issues.

Carter WilliamsYeah, there is that I'm trying to find it, but somebody did a study that said there was about two or three hundred million dollars of regenerative activity that could have happened upstream in Germany that would have prevented ten billion dollars of insurance loss in the floods like two years ago.

Ash SweetingYeah. So it's that water infiltration, managing the soil, storing water in the soil, which obviously then has the benefits throughout the growing season because it's it's not only not causing damage to to urban areas, it's also being used for for growing um and then accumulating more carbon or capturing more carbon and all that sort of stuff.

Carter WilliamsAnd that's a conversation that one of the things I like about what's going on now is that the politics are so confused, you can now have that conversation. Like that's actually an all of the above kind of conversation. Whereas before, to some degree, if you said, you know, I think TNC even at this headwind, they're like, no, it integrated livestock is a good thing for the soil. And there was a there was a certain amount of politics who's like, do not say that out loud. Even though it was true. Like it was all of a sudden turned into a political debate.

Ash SweetingUm and then it then it has its own energy and its own trajectory of its own and moves away from actually you know what's you know what it's based on.

Carter WilliamsAnd it we get this a little bit with Maha now, where people are like, oh, you're Maha people. It's like, no, we're focused on reducing chronic disease. We're glad the Maha caught on to that. But we've been doing this for 10 years. They're following us.

Ash SweetingThey're following us. Yeah. So um in terms of accelerating, you know, progress both across what you're doing and and more broadly, are there are there things or certain things that are needed, or is it is it more just we just need time, patience, and persistence?

Carter WilliamsI would say that uh this is a thing that goes through my mind a lot. Um we are dealing with some exogenous factors that interest rates change, people pulled out a venture, there's a little not a lot of venture dollars. We've very 2001 tech-ish kind of time frame where there's a giant collapse of the capital markets in this area, and we have companies that aren't profitable yet, but are they on their way.

Carter WilliamsAnd so the the bridge on fire part in my brain is you got to keep those companies alive because if they go away, you you just lose a lot of technology knowledge that you gotta regain, which we've done in the past. We've gone through episodes where we've regenerated the same damn stuff. So that's my most immediate concern is keeping those, you know, the companies that can answer the sugar question to get rid of fructose, keep them alive. Get that done.

Carter WilliamsMake sure the ones that are doing uh phytochemicals can survive. Um my brain, our brain right now is not so much on the new starts, um that are now bringing up some other things. Uh in terms of speed, I think it's getting the getting getting the what we started ten years ago complete has to be done before we accelerate other things.

Carter WilliamsUh one accelerant is consumer voice is coming through a lot stronger now. I I think the influencers are actually while there are a lot of complaints against the influencers by their lack of knowledge, I think that they they increase uh consumer voice and that helps speed decision making and risk making and and so I think empowering the influencers more to get the message out so that we get more consumer voice may change the resource allocation of dollars and and fill the void that very easily we could deploy ten billion dollars of we could deploy ten billion dollars effectively to to accelerate the stuff.

Carter WilliamsBut we need two things from the we need the consumers saying they want it. Yep. Because last 10 years it was really the farmers and the technologists saying you need it. There wasn't enough consumer voice, and and so a lot of our investments got slowed down as we got that.

Ash SweetingThat's consumers not saying they want it in a in a survey or in a um uh a question situation, is actually saying it when they're at the supermarket or grocery store and and showing that it's actual real demand.

Carter WilliamsUm and they're even though the latent demand was there, I think uh very specifically. I mean, it's a very important point here that you raise, is Nielsen was saying that consumers want it, and the CPGs were saying we don't believe you. No. And I there was a the stop gap was a little bit upstream. And uh it's very much like nobody said people need an iPhone kind of thing. They but as soon as it made available, they're like, Yep, that's it. Yep.

Carter WilliamsWe're we're sort of at that. I had this conversation with an executive for one of large retailers, and like they were sort of questioning, Do you really think it's there? And I said, When you walk through the store, how many people are reading labels? A lot. It's like they're trying to figure out you think reading a label tells them the right answer.

Ash SweetingLike the best information you've gotten, that's what you're saying.

Carter WilliamsIt's like that's you're giving them stone tablets of information. And you know, they're why are we stocking out on cottage cheese? Because not because grocery said cottage cheese is the highest density per protein calorie for somebody who's on a GLP1 diet. Some influencer convinced them all, and now we're stocking out on so you it doesn't even matter what the label says. The influencer actually convinced them, and it's true in that case.

Carter WilliamsYeah, and it's not like the influencer convinced them something that's not true, they convinced them something is true, they change their behavior, and they're coming in and they're buying all your all your um cottage cheese, which I never would eat cottage cheese, but but they're doing it.

Ash SweetingBut then you get those feedback loops, so it kind of snowballs, yeah.

Carter WilliamsAnd so I think the the CPGs and grocery are just on the wrong frequency. Um, and if we can get that elevated, then they then their investors are like, I don't really understand this market, but I can see that consumer demand. And so I'll go risk on. And that's we thought that would come in earlier and it just didn't, but now it's coming in. GLP one's sort of helped unlock that.

Ash SweetingWe're almost uh out of time.

Carter WilliamsUm yes, I've got a call on five minutes, so we will find out it should be done.

Ash SweetingBefore we go, is there anything else you'd like to add that we haven't already discussed?

Carter WilliamsI I I am in listening mode. I look, I we've been investing for 10 years. I really have the privilege now of hearing a lot of feedback from people, and it really helps me do my job better, and I think helps other people. Um so I we are committed to getting rid of chronic disease uh by fixing the food system. We think it's gonna take 20 years, and we're on that on the on that. And I I just I just would love talking to more people about it to help shape our viewpoint through this.

Carter WilliamsIt's a it's a team effort.

Ash SweetingCarter, thank you very much for joining me today. Thank you for the time. Good questions. Thank you for listening to the Ashcloud. Please subscribe to Ashcloud if you have enjoyed this podcast, where I will continue to discuss food sustainability with guests to bring a deep understanding of the environmental, political, and cultural challenges facing our society and creative ideas on how to address them.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Building a growing animal agtech company with Stefan Scherer, SmaXtec

    Nov 13, 202655 minAudio

    Sustainability in dairy is usually talked about in ecological terms. But a farm has to be economically sustainable. As my guest puts it: “I can have the best farm in the world. If it goes out of business, it’s not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The geopolitics of climate change with Arthur Snell, RUSI

    Nov 7, 202655 minAudio

    We are living in a time of greater geopolitical disorder, and that disorder is “coupled with and feeding off” climate change. During the green revolution following WW2 agricultural productivity grew steadily. In the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Regenerative agriculture at scale with Shawn Tiffany, Tiffany Cattle Co.

    Nov 6, 202659 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. We don’t need a perfect answer. We need a reliable answer with Tom Sturgess, Methane Mitigation Ventures

    Oct 20, 202650 minAudio

    Consumers will pay a premium for climate-friendly red meat, but not the way you’re thinking about it. This premium is not a mark-up on any single purchase. It’s customer loyalty to the retailer selling the product. A...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Profitable climate solutions for small holder farmers with Devdut Dalal Mitti Labs

    Sep 28, 202649 minAudio

    Rice feeds more people than any other crop, and it is grown in a way that is quietly expensive. Globally, a third of all groundwater extraction goes to rice farming. And because those fields sit flooded for weeks at a...

    Credit the people on this episode