Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Art Hotline

Art Hotline artwork

Ep 5: The danger of selfies in museums

Apr 30, 202625 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In today’s episode, we: unpack what happened at Dallas Art Fair, the importance of insurance, kids in museums, the embarrassment of accidentally knocking over a sculpture, our favourite example of someone damaging artwork, Tatum accidentally broke a sculpture (twice), the added bonus of buying editions is that hey can often be replaced, and Bronwyn’s love of small art. A note that you can listen to Art Hotline on Apple Podcasts and Spotify! If you have a question you’d like to submit, you can do so HERE. If you do listen on a streaming platform, we’d love for you to take a moment and rate the podcast. ₊˚ ☎︎₊˚✧ Questions/comments? Email Tatum at tatum@artforecast.info and Bronwyn at bronwyn@shortlycontemporary.com Show Notes // Artists Mentioned: * Peanut-Butter Platform by Wim T. Schippers * Child damages €50m Rothko painting in Dutch museum * “Reading-work-piece” by Arthur Köpcke at the Neues Museum in Nuremberg * Isabel Okoro * William Eggleston * First Editions: Scale for Thought * Sophie Varin * Jennifer Carvalho Get full access to Art Forecast at artforecast.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hi and welcome to Art Hotline, a new podcast from two art world professionals with decades of experience working with galleries, artists, and collectors. Bronwyn, I can't believe it's been two weeks since our last episode. I feel like so much has happened since then.

SPEAKER_01I know. I've been dying to talk to you in our like personal world and I feel like we've barely even gotten to do that and it's already here to record this.

SPEAKER_00I know. Well, we were both traveling for context. Bronwyn was in Mexico, which looked absolutely beautiful. I'm curious if there is any chance to get in some art when you were away. Great question. It is. was a bit more of a surfer town so not necessarily the art that I specialize in but I've got to say Mexico in general art and design and architecture are just so integrated that I think it's it's more of a whole picture thing

so I can't say I have any specific artistry galley recommendations from Sayulita but just anywhere

SPEAKER_01in Mexico it's immersive so I highly recommend

SPEAKER_00I mean, I asked because when you were sharing pictures, I was like, this looks like the most beautiful resort or house that you were staying at. And I thought the art looked great.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, it's super, super thoughtful and intentional. It's just so beautiful. I was jealous of all your Dallas adventures with Kieran. I know Dallas might be becoming my favorite art city, like top five, at least.

SPEAKER_00It's pretty incredible. That's awesome and unexpected and I think we're going to have to talk about

SPEAKER_01unexpected art cities at some point soon.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, their private art collections are pretty remarkable. I also felt like there was a lot of generosity and hospitality from collectors, even at an institutional scale, funding their private collections to be seen and open to the public. But then also just day to day, collectors would invite us over to their house to see their collections or host parties. So I got to see a lot of really great art and just saw the way that People were integrating collecting into their everyday life and

their kind of

SPEAKER_00overall philosophies in a way that I found very inspiring. That's super cool.

SPEAKER_01We're going to absolutely have to dive more into that. But speaking of Dallas, I heard a certain scandal at the Dallas Art Fair involving a broken artwork. Did you see it? Do you know what happened?

SPEAKER_00Okay, I didn't see it. I wasn't at the fair that day. I think it happened on the second day, but I heard so much about it. It was what everybody was talking about after it happened. I mean, it is definitely a very sad story for I think everybody involved. Somebody was just visiting the booth and wasn't being careful enough and there was a sculpture that was on a plinth. They knocked into the plinth and it was a very intricate glass sculpture. and it completely shattered and I think that also what happened

after the fact was something that people were talking about which is what you do in this situation I mean I can talk a little bit about what I heard happened here but I would love to just hear like what do you do in that situation either as a collector or as the gallerist yeah totally that is freaky and terrifying and honestly I don't really

SPEAKER_01know but I feel like Periodically this happens in an art fair, in a gallery, you know, in a collector's home, obviously a lot more private there, but I think you just have to make sure you have some pretty good insurance. Yes and I do think both the fair and the gallery was insured that's what I saw on Instagram so I think that's covered of course you know I don't think that exact glass art piece can ever be recreated which is the real loss and my understanding

of what happened after was that the person that broke it kind of went on the

SPEAKER_00defense and I do get that. Like it's a hard situation to be in. You're probably so embarrassed. You're worried about it being like the person's litigious or something like that. You maybe want to defend yourself. But I think that the general consensus was that the person who broke the piece did not handle the situation gracefully. They kind of put blame onto the gallery. They're like, well, it's not my fault and I'm not paying for it. This is a public space and I can do what I want. I think that that was kind of one of the major pain points when

people were talking about it. Just the fact that you entered into this space of an art fair and you didn't have your own understanding of your physical space that you went on to like break

SPEAKER_00something. And instead of just saying like, sorry, you tried to place the blame on somebody else.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's definitely a fascinating reaction. I feel like probably being in the U.S. litigious is the biggest concern, but, you know, it is interesting. These fairs or even like auction previews, you're welcome to get so up close and personal. And oftentimes, you know, with auction previews invited to touch and examine and Make sure the pieces are what you want and in the condition you want to buy them. But it's such a big risk because,

SPEAKER_01you know, ultimately a unique blown glass sculpture cannot be remade. So it's an interesting predicament. But I definitely, yeah. Handling it with a little more grace probably would have kept you out of the art gossip circles.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I mean it. I don't think that the gallery can ask the collector or visitor to the fair to pay for it. I will say as a child, once I did break a glass dolphin in a gift shop and they did make my mom pay for it, she was able to glue it back together at home. But it really, it is something that you learn as a child is to be careful near precious objects.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I actually have heard of galleries making patrons pay for broken artworks.

SPEAKER_00I think in that case, it's kind of that question in not having space. And I came across this museum in Rotterdam who charges visitors who damage art. They have had visitors who have damaged artworks on display.

SPEAKER_00Notably in 2011, they asked a tourist who stepped on a WMT Shippers peanut butter floor artwork to pay for repairs of the work. And a spokesperson for the museum was quoted as saying, it is normal procedure for people to pay if they damage art.

SPEAKER_01Okay, I'm so confused by that. That's an insanely fascinating find.

SPEAKER_00I know. I wonder if it's still their protocol because how can you have somebody pay for it if you also have insurance?

SPEAKER_01I was just going to say, I think in all of these cases... I mean, maybe I'm crazy and I don't understand insurance, but I have taken specifically art courses on art insurance. And that is what insurance is for. You know what I mean? Like I've worked with clients who've made claims and you are reimbursed for your artwork if there's damage. So that seems so wild to me. Like if you've cheaped out on your insurance going to an art fair, that's kind of on you. I don't know that that's on the visitor.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, that is a great point. I mean... I'm also thinking though how insurance works for an art fair which is such a limited amount of time. My understanding was that insurance would never want to cover you for something like four or five days because then you're not like paying into it as much. But I imagine that's like a whole other art world insurance thing. I do think there are specific products because it is a higher risk scenario because the artworks are in transit which is the most risky time for an artworks journey.

SPEAKER_01And they're in transit multiple times. They're in close proximity. But I'm almost certain you can get policies like specific for art fairs. And also when you worked with specialized insurance providers, they know part of a gallery's business model in most cases. Great points I know also through this research and just like in hand things I've heard

Is that it's often children that are damaging art in these museums and art fair contexts.

SPEAKER_00Obviously, they don't have a good understanding of their own bodies. I've seen like articles where kids have like scratched Rothko's and things like that. And as a parent, I'm wondering... How do you navigate bringing a child into a museum?

SPEAKER_01Okay, that's so funny because it's literally my base fear because I did see a child touch an artwork once and sort of damage it. I was in Luxembourg and they have a contemporary museum there called the Mudam and they had this Big fountain sculpture in the middle which I looked up it's by an artist that I'm not familiar with but it is Sue May See I think and the fountain has this ink that sort of replenishes and the kid touched the ink so then the ink kind of went out of

its natural path anyway it was big hullabaloo guards people interviewing I don't actually know what happened but you can't help a kid from being curious and I do

SPEAKER_01take our daughter to museums all the time But I am so paranoid and controlling in those situations in terms of distance from objects. I'd say in the real world, I'm pretty relaxed, but in a museum, like, there's no getting within four feet of anything. But I don't know, you turn your back for a second, it's not really your fault. And what is the point of Having museums if children can't experience them.

SPEAKER_01So it's kind of a hard question.

SPEAKER_00I mean, absolutely. One of my favorite things is being at a museum when a school group is there and all of the little kindergartners are holding their hands so that they don't touch the art. And I mean, I think at the end of the day, you know, I don't think it's the kids that we have to worry about. I think it's often adults that are causing real damage. Like if you think a three-year-old, you know, if they touch something, it's not great. But I don't think they have the strength to knock something over in the same way as what happened in Dallas.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I think it's adults taking selfies so many times, too. I feel like there are people get in the Kusama boxes and then they take their selfie and they get so excited that they knock over some things. Selfies are deadlier than children when it comes to art. One of my favorite examples of an artwork being ruined, which is such a funny thing to say. Like, I love that this happened, but I actually think the artist would maybe be OK with it.

SPEAKER_00But it's from the Nuremberg News Museum. And a senior citizen took the instructions of an avant-garde work by Arthur Kopech quite literally. It was a crossword that was blank. And then the English instruction said, insert words. And so she was like, OK. and took a ballpoint pen out and put in her own words onto the crossword. I don't know. I think that that's actually a nice example of people engaging with art in a playful way.

SPEAKER_00Maybe that's a stretch. They were able to fix the damage. And she also kind of came out and said, this might be the museum's fault because they should have put up a notice saying, do not follow the instructions and write on the piece. 100% that is wild and so kind of cute like I agree that's a favorite example I do

SPEAKER_01think it gets so crazy when it comes to conceptual art and even just like custodians of the museum who take care of the spaces and they're in like this ultra contemporary exhibition and there's intentional debris or like intentional piles of dust or A pair of glasses. Maybe you've seen that meme where there's a pair of glasses on the floor of the MoMA and people don't know if they can touch it or pick it up or whatever. It's just like when it comes to conceptual art, it's a whole new ballgame in terms of what's allowed. But I do think it's interesting.

SPEAKER_01Maybe the artist would have liked that participation.

SPEAKER_00That's my thought. And I mean at the end of the day like these are artworks they're culturally historically important objects but often they can be fixed so I always like to put that in context so it's like damage it's often difficult to deal with but most of the times there's amazing teams of preservation and art restorers that are able to fix this and that's kind of making me think of that I did break a sculpture at home the other day it happened actually a few months ago

Maybe I didn't do it Bronwyn I woke up one day and the sculpture was broken and so

SPEAKER_00if I can I would like to blame my cat for breaking it I was going to say It was very fragile just the way that it was composed. So I'm not entirely surprised that this part of the sculpture broke off. It is off display now until it can be fixed. And I am confident that in the way that it broke that it will be easy to fix as soon as I have the time to bring it into an art restore or anything. Tatum Dooley artforecast

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_00Okay, let's jump into our next question because I think it's related and we'll open up our conversation into art damage a little bit more. So the question comes from our favorite treasure trove of content, Reddit, and the title is Replacement for Damaged Print. What do I do with the original? A few months ago, I purchased a print edition of five from an artist I collect. Unfortunately, the frame store scratched it while they were framing. Art Forecast Art Forecast

SPEAKER_00Art Forecast I confirmed with the artist via text and it was intentional. The two prints aren't quite identical. The replacement is a little larger and the colors are different.

SPEAKER_00Moreover, while both have the artist's blind stamp, the replacement also has a seal which the original did not. However, both have the same addition number and the damage on the original, incidentally, is visible but relatively minor. So I guess now I'm a little confused as to what I have in my possession. That's a lot. This was a longer question and one of the more unusual situations that I've heard of.

SPEAKER_01I have so many questions. I'm really curious who the artist is, first of all, because that's a very interesting way of managing their inventory and their prints. Because in every single situation that I've been in where we've needed to reissue a photograph, the artist has taken it back and destroyed it. Again, for what this person was saying at the You know, that is the beauty of a photograph. They can get it reprinted and reissued if the artist is willing.

SPEAKER_01So it's just so crazy to me that they've reissued another one, not taken that one back, made some changes, added a seal. That's very confusing to me. But I do appreciate the collector is so prudent and trying to be so ethical and is keeping such good records. And that's why I'm additionally curious of the artist and the level of career this artist that they're collecting is in because it seems like the collector really cares about how they collect. So I have a lot of questions. Well, I can send them a DM and be like,

could you tell me off the record what artist this was? I was surprised when I learned that if you had a piece that was an edition or a

SPEAKER_00photograph edition and it was damaged, most times the artist will reprint for you. That was completely new to me.

SPEAKER_01It is crazy and I do have a little bit of first-hand experience with it, with some photographs that were damaged by the sun. And you know, I think part of that mentality for that artist is if you have your pieces from an iconic series of work and then the sun damages them, changes the colors, it probably doesn't feel like the best presentation of your work or feel like a proper representation of your practice. So I could understand in that case wanting to reprint and reissue so long as the

SPEAKER_01originals are destroyed. I think that's the big thing. That's like in terms of preservation, you know, I think questions of originality with photography and prints Are always questions, but I think in terms of originality to me, and I think to many artists, it's the concept and the execution and the signature, but having two kind of cancels each other out and makes it muddy, which is where I'm really thrown off.

SPEAKER_00To clarify in this situation, what the artist should have done is request either evidence that the first print that was damaged was destroyed or have them send it back to destroy it themselves.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. I wonder in this case if the collector should just take that into their own hands

SPEAKER_00and knowing that that is the proper protocol, just kind of destroy that first print on their own.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it sounds like they want to be that type of honorable individual and not be, you know, hawking fake prints, so to say. So it sounds like to me, or even, you know what, a creative idea perhaps would be to sort of This isn't the first time I've heard of a framer damaging a print. And talk about insurance. They must have a lot of insurance for these kind of situations. Definitely. It is very scary.

That was another sort of red flag in this thread that I was thinking about is the

SPEAKER_01framer has done this a few times so they know the protocol. That kind of freaks me out. And I think it makes justifying the price you pay for extremely high-end framers a little more worth it if you can have a little more trust there.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. In the Reddit thread, I kind of did a quick skim and somebody had mentioned that they thought that once a print edition was complete, that Artists Would Destroy the Plate and then somebody replied that that used to be the case but has now changed. I was wondering if you have any art historical insight into that. I think again I don't have like a concrete example but I do think that this is sort of at the discretion of the artist and I remember during our

chat with Isabel Okoro

SPEAKER_01she talked so Tatum Dooley Reissued some of his original photos in a different scale and a

new edition size. And that made a lot of collectors upset who had sort of bought it at the original

SPEAKER_01scale and price and edition size. But I think he also saw it as a new piece now that it was a different size. And it's a tricky place.

SPEAKER_00I think it's really important to talk about this. I have been wanting to write a Substack Post called There's Too Many Editions in Your Edition. Because I think artists really should be keeping their audition sizes quite low. I think five is a nice number because you do want to create... The sense of scarcity. If you go up 25, 50, 100, it's going to be harder to sell out as well as, you know, the value of it. It's just significantly lower. That's why we see prints from famous artists up on Artsy for a

few hundred dollars. Prints really don't hold their value unless there is that maintained integrity of

SPEAKER_00an edition size. So I completely understand the collectors being like, you know I bought this thinking it was an edition of three and now you've done the same image as an edition of 300 like where does the value lie yeah 100% I would love you to read write that Substack okay I will speaking speaking ofSubstack I really loved your post today do you want to give it give us a little elevator pitch

SPEAKER_01Art Forecast That even if you have a small artwork you can live with it in so many different ways and not to be scared off from small artworks and thinking that you just need the big pieces for above the main spaces.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, just wanted to write a little bit about small artworks and how they have a place in my heart. I love how a small piece invites you to like lean in and look closer and we are chatting a little bit over text this week about an artist that you saw first at Art Basel and then we saw I think at Nata Miami together who does like takes it to the

SPEAKER_00nth degrees I'm totally forgetting her name though what is her name? Sophie Varen Amazing those are like yeah we will put a link to those but they're like Polly Pocket art

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's like two by two inches. And it was so crazy because I feel like the first time I saw them was on these ginormous, ginormous, like four story walls that were concrete. And it was like these paintings that even in the picture that I took, you could barely see the paintings.

SPEAKER_00So kind of fun. Are you doing anything art related this week? You know what? I think

SPEAKER_01I am going to get a very special visit to The Bunker, Beth the Woody's private collection in Palm Beach this weekend because I have a friend that lives nearby and so I'm very excited.

SPEAKER_00Okay, I'm so jealous. This week, I'm very excited to go to an Art Basel preview where I'm going to hear the painter Jennifer Carvalho talk about her paintings that really draw heavily on Renaissance. So I feel like they're going to really be a hit at Basel this year. Yeah, I feel like that is my only like my calendar is looking a little bit empty. So that's my big event for this week. So I guess if anybody wants to invite me to an art party, now is your time.

SPEAKER_01Now is your time. I love that invitation.

SPEAKER_00But not as much as I love these conversations.

SPEAKER_01I really, I like recording these with you at Tatum and sort of peeking into both of our minds and different perspectives on the art world. I always feel like I learn new things when we chat.

SPEAKER_00So thanks. Thank you. I feel exactly the same way. And if anybody listening has an art story of their own that they want to share and have us unpack, please drop us a line or send us a voice note. You can find our emails in the Substack Post. And thank you so much for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 11: Yet another Art Basel Paris take

    Oct 24, 202628 minAudio

    On today’s long-awaited episode, we talk about: Art Basel Paris shutting down due to protests, artists collaborating with corporations, Trojan Horses, wealth in the art world, why most curatorial statements are bad,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 10: We answer your DMs

    Aug 19, 202627 minAudio

    In this episode, we chat about: coming back from a brief hiatus, what happens if an artist copies themselves, editions, trust between artists and collectors, the benefits of galleries, artworks losing their spark,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 9: Rapid fire art questions

    Jul 2, 202619 minAudio

    On this episode, we answer SIX of your questions from Reddit. We touch on topics including: is it rude not to attend an art opening, how to present your work to a museum curator, travelling for art events, how much...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 8: Is art a good investment?

    Jun 19, 202620 minAudio

    On this episode, we answer: Is art a good investment? (It’s complicated!). Also, how collecting art is a muscle; the difference between art being popular and actually liking it; does context matter when looking at art;...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 7: Wanting art you can't have

    Jun 5, 202629 minAudio

    In this episode: what artists listen to in the studio, whether an artist should lower their prices, how finding a gallery is like dating, the Hermès model of collecting, class dynamics in the art world, how to collect...

    Credit the people on this episode