Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Art Hotline

Art Hotline artwork

Ep 2: Buying art materials on Temu & the ethics of buying directly from an artist

Mar 19, 202619 minAudioEpisode 2
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In today’s episode, we cover: Artists shipping paintings in plastic bags, the importance of using lightfast materials so your art doesn’t disappear, burgers with gold leaf, the ethics of buying from a gallery vs. directly from an artist, buying art materials on Temu, and Bronwyn’s favourite piece at the Whitney Biennial. If you have a burning question for us, you can submit via the button directly below. We’ll keep submissions anonymous, unless you’d like to share your name. Artworks/Substacks Mentioned: * NYT Story: She Thought Lady Gaga Bought Her Art. Then Things Got Strange (gift link) * Outsider artist James Castle, who used graphite on cardboard to depict the world around him * Georgia Dickie’s use of garbage and everyday objects in her sculptures * Damien Hirst’s TACKY diamond skull * Michael Thompson’s exhibition, Panther Platform, at Franz Kaka in Toronto * Monument (Altadena) by Kelly Akashi at the Whitney Biennial * Alex Feim’s excellent breakdown of the Whitney Biennial on Substack ₊˚ ☎︎₊˚✧ See you in two weeks when our next episode drops! Get full access to Art Forecast at artforecast.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome back to The Art Hotline, a new podcast from two art world professionals with decades of experience working with galleries, artists and collectors. Thanks to everyone who tuned into our first episode. We had so much fun doing it and we're excited to keep this going.

SPEAKER_01And since this is just our second episode, well, firstly, thank you so much for everybody that sent such encouraging messages. And if you are new here, we thought we would reintroduce our concept. It's pretty simple. Every two weeks, we take questions about the art world that we think are interesting and unpack them in the way that Bronwyn and I would if we were like at dinner having drinks. Yeah, because our day-to-day roles in the art world are slightly different. We like to pull a question that leans sort of more

collector-focused for one,

SPEAKER_00and typically another one that's a bit more artist-focused, just playing to those different audiences and different sort of paths of inquiry. For today's episode, we've selected two more questions from Reddit, and we're still fending off the calls on the hotline and saving those for future episodes. So more on that at the end. So the first question we have is about the ethics of purchasing art from a gallery

SPEAKER_01versus directly from an artist. The question is, so I saw a painting that interested me on a gallery site and I reached out to the gallery. They phoned me about shipping addresses to get a quote for shipping costs. Then I didn't hear back from them for a week when it usually takes a day for galleries to get a quote. In the meantime, I found the painting on another site where it's apparently directly from the artist. The price is two thirds of the gallery price. I reached out to them yesterday and haven't heard back. Then I heard back from the gallery today with the shipping quote.

SPEAKER_01Is it better for artists to buy directly or from the gallery? And is it crappy to have contact at the gallery and then to buy from the cheaper route? All right. Do you have a thought on this one, Bronwyn? I mean, I feel like there are so many questions like this and all of them are so nuanced.

SPEAKER_00I love that there's a thought process here about the ethics. I think that's always starting from a good place if you're thinking about what the most ethical is. And I think every market and every situation is different. So I think you have to take all advice with a grain of salt. But I thought it was really interesting to sort of read through the comments and see that there were different responses there. you know, some saying, screw the gallery, go straight to the artists and others sort of highlighting the importance of the gallery. And,

SPEAKER_00you know, working in the art world and its ecosystem, I do tend to think that you should look to the gallery first, because if an artist is showing with a gallery, you know, that tends to be the one that's taking care of them or marketing for them. But that's also assuming that the gallery is a good faith gallery if they're a good actor and they really are caring for their artists. So I think it's very nuanced and but not all galleries are created equally. So if you do chat with the artist,

SPEAKER_00you know, if they seem very open to selling directly, perhaps it's not a gallery that they have a strong relationship with. It's really hard to tell. I know some artists really prefer you go through their gallery and will direct you there anyway because they really do have that relationship and it's important for them to sort of work and have that relationship with the gallery.

SPEAKER_01Mm hmm. I mean, that was kind of my first thought was if I was an artist and I had a gallery that was selling my work, I would not be selling it independently directly to a collector just because it really can jeopardize your relationship with the gallery. And in this case, the gallery is there to protect you. When you're working directly with the collector, who is to say they're gonna pay on time, they're not gonna say, oh, it was damaged in transit. Like there can be so many headaches that come with the business side of the art world.

SPEAKER_01that if you have the gallery, you know, they do protect you. And it is also the red flag in this story is that there's two different prices published online. And I always think even if you are selling something directly out of your studio to a collector, it should be the same price that a gallery sells it at. You should never have two different prices depending on the circumstance.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, 100%. Such a good flag. You really do wonder why that situation has happened and sort of what's going on there. And also the admin and the business side, the unsexy side, getting the work to you. It's such a good point, Tatum. The gallery might be a much better equipped person to help you with that. And from a collector side, I do not know if you want to deal with an artist directly.

SPEAKER_01I had a situation, I mean, probably like eight years ago now, where an artist was sending me work directly and they sent it, I kid you not, in a plastic bag that was taped up and had the shipping notice right on the plastic bag. It was like a $5,000 painting and they shipped it across the country in a grocery bag. so that is frightening so frightening i know it was really

thankful that it didn't get damaged which also i do think we chat about sometimes which is like artists are so blasé about their work they're always like throwing the paintings around and then as soon as it moves into a gallery or collectors it's like white gloves so

SPEAKER_01careful but i mean i've seen very suspicious things in a studio

SPEAKER_00Such a good point. Such a good point. Yeah, I mean, I think a gallery is there for a reason. So I wonder what this artist relationship is there and sort of what their role is in the ecosystem. But I don't know that it's totally on the collector, especially because they're thinking about the ethics to figure that out.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's true. I think in this case, if the artist is selling it directly, then it's not an ethical question. But I am curious, did you read this Emma Webster story when it came out in the New York Times?

SPEAKER_00No, I don't know if I did. it is so wild so she i think she shows with like a very big reputable gallery i'm not gonna say the name because i don't know exactly who it is but she was reached out to somebody that was pretending to be lady gaga to get around the gallery system because they had a wait list and emma kind of naively was like i can't

SPEAKER_01believe lady gaga wants to buy my artwork sold it to this collector who then, you know, a few years later sold it on the secondary market. And it was a huge outrage that they impersonated Lady Gaga.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that is outrageous. That's so crazy.

SPEAKER_01And they still paid full price. Like that's the funny thing. Like they just really badly wanted one of her paintings to the point that they created like fake emails, assistance just to get access to it, which must have been a kind of a compliment. But in that situation, it would have been avoided. I think the gallery would have caught that it was not.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, you know, another reason that like a great partnership with a gallery is so helpful for the business and admin side of an artist, you know, not wanting, like, if you have to worry about Lady Gaga impersonators, you're not really spending that time creating. So it would be nice to have those trust pillars in place, I'm sure with the gallery. When we were doing some research, I remember seeing a couple things on wait lists and all that type of stuff. So it might be fun to do one of those questions in the future too. But Lady Gaga, crazy.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely. Weightless questions. We will have a future episode. So stay tuned.

SPEAKER_00Totally. Up next question from an artist about art materials. I personally know how expensive Kieran's paint is, so I am always curious for your thoughts. But here we are in the Reddit thread artist lounge. Does the quality of art supplies matter? I buy most of my art supplies off Teemu and to be honest, I haven't had any major issues. I wonder does spending the extra cash make a big enough

difference for an upgrade?

SPEAKER_01Okay, I would say yes, it does matter. I don't think you should be buying your art supplies off Timu. And that is for a few reasons. Well, it does depend what level of the market you're participating in. You know, if you're selling like at a local craft fair, or like giving art as gifts to your family, like it doesn't matter. You can use any sort of materials that are accessible to you. But if you are selling your artwork, and I think that's who we're talking to, are artists that are selling at a gallery level and collectors

that are also

SPEAKER_01engaging at that level. I think the materials do matter. Firstly, I don't know if art materials from Timu or the dollar store are light fast. It's scary. they can disappear. I have heard stories of this, you know, somebody making work in pencil crayon and that pencil crayon disappearing within a year of having it on a wall with sunlight on it. So definitely like at the base level, you need to be thinking about the archival quality of your artwork.

Yeah, that's such a great point because you also just don't know what's in those materials.

SPEAKER_00It's kind of scary. It's kind of scary. You hear all these horror stories about fake food products or makeup products being sold on those websites. I can't imagine that a paint quality would be much higher standard. No. And when I go and see artwork in person, I have this like odd bias towards the canvas quality.

SPEAKER_01And so I think that if you are selling your work for over $1,000, you should be stretching or manipulating your own canvases. So like doing your own gesso, doing your own panels, or having them be created for you by professional canvas makers. It just makes such a huge difference that if you go into an art supply store and they're the really thin like student supply canvases. I really feel it just makes such a huge difference if they're on nicer linen, a little bit thicker,

SPEAKER_01and even like custom sizes. It just automatically tells the viewer that this is taking place outside of a student context.

SPEAKER_00A hundred percent. And I think even it's sort of those layers of nuance that you maybe don't even notice. But when you're looking at two works, why is one stronger? It might be because you can tell there was, you can subliminally tell there was care put behind the colors chosen. Yeah, the supports that were used. I think that's huge. And I think that's maybe something that underlies why you're attracted to a work versus something super overt and really takes it from sort of craft fair to a more luxurious context.

SPEAKER_00And I think also, you know, if you want to do right by your collectors, if that's the goal to sell your work to collectors, you don't want them to put it on the wall and then have it warp or, you know, have condition issues, especially early, early after acquiring, because that's just disappointing all around.

SPEAKER_01And I think this is also something we'll probably get into in the future, which is like, how do we look at art and decide, is it good? Do we like it? Will we collect it? It is all of these subliminal effects that we are reading into, like the quality of it. Was it like, you know, did you take the time to actually present it properly? Will it last? Is it archival? All of these things add up. If you are selling for high prices, the consumer does want the quality to match. And I do think there's a spectrum.

So my caveat is there are some artists, especially outsider artists, which I love,

SPEAKER_01that their work really is like what they have around. So a great example is James Castle, who would draw on cardboard with just pencil. And they're remarkable. David Swerner represents his archive. And yeah, these are done on very simple material. And so that does not make a difference in that case. Like this material was what was at hand. And then on the other hand, somebody like Georgia Dickey, who shows at Cooper Cole, literally makes her work out of garbage and things that she finds on the side of the road. And that is part of her process and her practice.

SPEAKER_01So there are ways to incorporate a variety of materials. I don't want it to come across as like snobby, like you have to go buy the $300 paint tube, but it's just making conscious decisions.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I agree with that. And that had me thinking while you were talking about how so much about it is intentionality. It's like going to somewhere like Timu to get your paint just seems like a cheaper, quick fix versus, you know, the your project or your vision is to work with the materials around you that you can afford. And I feel like perhaps unless you were doing something about consumerism and fast fashion and Timu is the perfect place to source paint that aligns with that vision, it feels like a very different story to be told than using

found materials or,

SPEAKER_00you know, less quality paint because you want to play with imperfection or something like that. I just think there needs to be some sort of thought behind um the materiality yeah and then on the other side of things I think that you should not use too fancy materials like going down like the Damien Hirst diamond encrusted skull I find that so tacky and sometimes I'll see in certain galleries like artists that are painting with like diamond dust and I think it's such a funny thing of being like oh well this art inherently

has value because of

SPEAKER_01the materials that it's made with I would not go down that route

SPEAKER_00Yep. No, that is such a good point. Or like too much gold leaf for no reason. You know, it kind of feels like you're getting a hamburger with gold leaf on it.

SPEAKER_01And I really love that. Yeah. So we have like the Timu on one side, like fast fashion, which I'm such a hater of. I think that I just have such a bias. I'm like, do not shop on Timu. Totally. And then on the other hand, it's yeah, I would also never recommend going to a restaurant that has anything gold leaf on the menu. Like we don't need to go too far in either direction mass production or, you know, this kind of idea of affluence for affluence sake.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Aligned on that. Well, do we have anything else to say about materials?

SPEAKER_01I don't think so. But we're always also open to hearing people's thoughts. If you disagree with us, feel free to, you know, put it in a comments or even send in a voice note where we can then reply.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would love I would love to hear thoughts on on that because, you know, we're just chatting back and forth and Everyone has different perspectives.

SPEAKER_01Last week, or I guess two weeks ago now, our episode where I was like, I don't think you should get rid of art in your studio. My husband, Kieran, who is a painter, was like, I definitely think you should. Get rid of it. If it's not working, it's taking up space. Just don't be precious about your art. You can make new art. And I was like, there you go. Completely different perspective.

SPEAKER_00Wow. Interesting. don't think that he actually walks the talk there i've never seen him destroy or get rid of any of his past artworks yeah and maybe like a one-off situation we'll have to talk more about that yeah yeah we'll have we'll have him on the pod i can't wait i can't wait okay so i guess it's wrap-up time is there anything art related on your radar this week tatum

SPEAKER_01Well, I'm going to head to Michael Thompson's exhibition at Franz Kaka and also have a little dinner at Dottie's when I'm over there.

SPEAKER_00Love Dottie's. And then tomorrow I'm going to Brian Rideout's studio to see his show before it opens at Towards and also going to have a little dinner with him and Jess. That's so nice. Where are you getting dinner?

SPEAKER_01The Skyline.

SPEAKER_00Ooh, okay.

SPEAKER_01Toronto Classic.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, seriously. Well, both, both classics in their own way, perhaps. Okay. Well, I am, taking the art world by a storm through the internet this week. I'm really itching to get to the Whitney Biennial, so I have been looking at all the reviews and photos of it because I always find the Whitney Biennial is just such a strange microcosm of the current moment in time that the art world is in. I always find I visit it. I hate it the first time.

SPEAKER_00I have to go back. You know, I just find it such a polarizing thing that You really can't understand until you look back at it later. So I always try to make a point to get there. I'm getting there virtually right now, but hopefully I'll get there for the fairs in May.

SPEAKER_01What is the consensus online about this iteration?

SPEAKER_00I feel like it's always polarizing. It's always like, you know, not great, amazing, breathtaking. I think my favorite piece that I've seen so far from afar is this really amazing fireplace sculpture, The Terrace Commission by Kelly Akashi. And she used these glass blocks to recreate a fireplace from one of the burnt down homes in Los Angeles. So it's kind of spooky, kind of ghostly, kind of a reminder of the environment.

SPEAKER_00Anyway, I'm pretty obsessed with it, need to see it in person. So that's where I am. I also found a really cool Substack that dives into all the like nerdy stats about the biennial talking about who's born where and how old everybody is and what art schools they went to. So I've just been kind of learning out on those things.

SPEAKER_01Do you remember the Substack name?

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01Is it Alex Finn? Yes. I'm kind of obsessed with their newsletter. It's a really great resource of what's happening in New York. And I looked at that and I was like, this is very quantitative, detail-oriented.

SPEAKER_001000%. It's like the polar opposite, not the polar opposite of my brain. But like, when I think about art, I like do not want to think about pie charts unless it's part of the piece. But I love that that's the approach. So I've been so fascinated by the findings.

SPEAKER_01I know that's the opposite of how I think too. I mean, it's great. We need the data scientists in the art world.

SPEAKER_00We do. We really do.

SPEAKER_01Hey, this is so much fun. And I'm looking forward to chatting with you again soon.

SPEAKER_00Me too. If anyone listening has a burning question, let us know. You can send Tatum or myself a direct message, or maybe we'll put a little link in the show notes so you can submit things anonymously. Thanks for listening. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 11: Yet another Art Basel Paris take

    Oct 24, 202628 minAudio

    On today’s long-awaited episode, we talk about: Art Basel Paris shutting down due to protests, artists collaborating with corporations, Trojan Horses, wealth in the art world, why most curatorial statements are bad,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 10: We answer your DMs

    Aug 19, 202627 minAudio

    In this episode, we chat about: coming back from a brief hiatus, what happens if an artist copies themselves, editions, trust between artists and collectors, the benefits of galleries, artworks losing their spark,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 9: Rapid fire art questions

    Jul 2, 202619 minAudio

    On this episode, we answer SIX of your questions from Reddit. We touch on topics including: is it rude not to attend an art opening, how to present your work to a museum curator, travelling for art events, how much...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 8: Is art a good investment?

    Jun 19, 202620 minAudio

    On this episode, we answer: Is art a good investment? (It’s complicated!). Also, how collecting art is a muscle; the difference between art being popular and actually liking it; does context matter when looking at art;...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 7: Wanting art you can't have

    Jun 5, 202629 minAudio

    In this episode: what artists listen to in the studio, whether an artist should lower their prices, how finding a gallery is like dating, the Hermès model of collecting, class dynamics in the art world, how to collect...

    Credit the people on this episode