This podcast is also available as a video on Youtube Data centres have faced growing public backlash in the United States. In Alberta, opposition has been less widespread, and the provincial government supports the industry, but communities are raising concerns. This week, our guests -Deirdre Sheehan, Partner and Co-Chair of the Regulatory, Indigenous and Environmental practice at Osler, and Marcus Rocque, Vice President of Research at the ARC Energy Research Institute, review the main concerns surrounding data centres, using the topics outlined in Premier Smith’s recent video as a guide: What is a data centre, and why does Alberta want them? Didn’t other places get burned by data centres? How do Albertan’s actually benefit from these data centres? Will my power bill go up? What about water? Who decides where these data centres get built? Content referenced in this podcast: Alberta Premier Smith video on six common questions on AI data centers Please review our disclaimer at: https://www.arcenergyinstitute.com/disclaimer/ Check us out on social media: X (Twitter): @arcenergyinst LinkedIn: @ARC Energy Research Institute Subscribe to ARC Energy Ideas Podcast Apple Podcasts Amazon Music Spotify YouTube YouTube Music
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02The information and opinions presented in this Ark Energy Ideas podcast are provided for informational purposes only and are subject to the disclaimer link in the show notes.
SPEAKER_00This is the Arc Energy Ideas Podcast with Peter Turzakian and Jackie Forrest, exploring trends that influence the energy business.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Ark Energy Ideas Podcast. I'm Jackie Forrest.
SPEAKER_04And I'm Peter Turzakian. Welcome back. Well, it's been a whirlwind week last week.
SPEAKER_01Yes, so Peter, tell us all about it. What were your impressions from the Canada Investment Summit?
SPEAKER_04Well, the Canada Investment Summit was held at the same time as the Toronto International Film Festival. So I arrived the weekend prior. And to give you a sense, the Uber pulled into the hotel, and there was all these people with cameras and just citizens waiting for celebrities to come in. And I just pulled up and I felt like getting out and waving to the crowd and see if they would recognize me. But uh I refrained from that. But it was uh a tremendous week. I didn't see any celebrities from Hollywood, although apparently Seth Rogan was floating around the hotel somewhere.
SPEAKER_04But there were certainly a lot of celebrities from the finance world. The Larry Finks from BlackRock and so on were all there. In fact, uh, according to the prime minister's count, there was over$120 trillion worth of capital represented, of investor capital, all the way from Singapore, sovereign wealth funds, Middle East, everywhere. And I spoke to many people at the investment summit during the breaks and stuff, and many of the international investors had never been to Canada, had never really considered investing in Canada, but were certainly very impressed by the way the show was put on.
SPEAKER_04I certainly was impressed, and it felt rather inspirational as a Canadian to be hosting. And many of them said that I have never seen this much money represented in one room at one time. And I think that's a testament to the convening power of our prime minister, who's of course been a central banker for two central banks, Canada and the UK. It was really impressive, and I was honored to host and moderate the energy session.
SPEAKER_01And was it like people from mostly the US, or was it people from Asia, Middle East?
SPEAKER_04Like what was the kind of makeup from the Yeah, about two-thirds of the representation, not surprisingly, given the size of the economy, was United States investors, and then the balance was European and uh Asian Middle Eastern, and of course, Canadian pension funds and big investors here as well.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so some of the media criticism was, wow, like there's no capital that's been invested yet. Like it the people expect it to happen right away.
SPEAKER_04What do you think of that? It's a bit presumptuous to think that people are going to come and immediately open their checkbook and say, you know, here's$50 billion for a power plant or something like that. It doesn't work that way. I can tell you that the summit was a series of plenary sessions, but there was over, I think the number was over 270 one-on-one meetings and backrooms between provincial officials, federal officials, investors, and of course representation from the CEOs. Okay, and I should say that uh there was a prospectus book that the Canadian government had circulated.
SPEAKER_04And I added it up. So under conventional energy, which would be oil, gas, pipelines, there was about$100 billion worth of deals there. Clean energy, about roughly another$100 billion, power and utilities, depending upon what you count in and out of that, and double counting with the clean energy and electrification, probably another$100 billion, so$300 billion just in energy. And that doesn't include the data centers, which were another$40 billion, which I would consider as an energy play, because without energy, there is no data center.
SPEAKER_04So I, you know, I think that criticism is a bit unwarranted. And it's also unwarranted in a sense that it's not for us to sit back afterward and and just wait, right? And watch it like some reality TV show unfolds. It's up to us now to work at it, whether it's corporate Canada, the governments, and others to follow up, much as you would if you're trying to sell anything to basically bring the capital in. But as a door opening exercise, as a segue into Canada, as an attractive place to invest, I think it was mission accomplished.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, raising capital takes a long time. And it starts with the first meeting and building a relationship. So um, don't worry, that wasn't my criticism. Of course, the of course, the productivity mega deduction was big news. So basically, businesses can immediately deduct 100% of the cost of uh new investments. And that means that uh the returns are better. In fact, uh, there's been a number of reports out BMO estimates for oil and gas companies, it could increase cash flow per share in the range of 6% over the next few years. I think Eric Nettle came up with a tweet saying, you know, 7%, a similar number for a company he talked to.
SPEAKER_01What was the feedback on that?
SPEAKER_04It was very positive. In fact, um, sort of a celebrity finance panel with Larry Fink and others said it was hugely consequential. And it is consequential even to oil and gas, because we're competitive. We have to be competitive with now Venezuela, Argentina, Colombia, even Ecuador for our heavy oils. We're going global. So we have to make sure that the money preferentially comes here and not elsewhere. And our tax rate was not all that competitive.
SPEAKER_04And the prime minister said and demonstrated that it's, I think the overall tax rate for the incentive now makes us the most competitive in the G7. And if we want to turbocharge investment and build the infrastructure in the major project office and beyond, this is a necessary and important step. And I don't really consider it an incentive on the part of government. I consider it an investment because I don't think it's an option, as we've talked in the podcast before, that we have to facilitate the retooling and uh reconfiguring of our critical infrastructure, whether it's rail, ports, pipelines, and so on, to go global to get out of our North American paradigm.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, and it's like, okay, so you're forgoing some taxes in the early years for a project you wouldn't have gotten anyway, maybe if you didn't offer this. So okay, quickly as we meet today, the oil price has really fallen over the previous weekend. I think we're down to about, you know,$92 or$93 WTI. We're over$100 before the weekend. And so uh we're not going to get into oil markets too much today, but just acknowledge that uh there certainly continues to be a lot of uncertainty with the war. Um, but you know, these markets are so volatile.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I think that's a good thing. I don't think$100 barrel oil or plus is a good thing. It's not a good thing for the global economy. It's not a good thing for society. It creates polarization. And it's also really a barometer of geopolitical unrest, which is really causing a lot of anxiety, justifiably, with the military conflicts that are raging, not only in the Middle East, but also in Russia-Ukraine with the taking out of refineries and what have you. It's an unsettling situation. So a cooling down by the markets is a welcome thing.
SPEAKER_01Well, we'll see if it stays though, right? It's really around uh President Trump, you know, saying he's gonna meet potentially with Iran. We're also seeing more oil come out of the Strait of Hormuz. So that that's an actual structural change.
SPEAKER_04Are we seeing it or is it sort of conjectural? Because nobody really knows unless you're behind, as I said, a few podcasts ago, if you've got a pair of night vision goggles uh sitting on the coastline watching tankers escorted by fighter jets is really what's happening.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but there is more data out there, I guess, that makes people believe more oil's coming out. So we'll talk more about the oil markets and what the next turn they'll take. Of course, this podcast, we want to talk about data centers. I attended a conference recently in Calgary a few weeks ago. Uh, got a few takeaways, you know, lots of opportunity, a lot of people excited about it inside the conference, but we had protesters outside who didn't want um data centers in Alberta. And so I think this week we wanted to spend some time talking not only about the opportunity to build this new sector, that's what I heard inside the meeting rooms, yeah, but also address some of the concerns of social issues.
SPEAKER_04I think it's important at the investment summit, there was also an entire session on the digital economy at the CEO of Cohere and others talking about how Canada's a leader in AI. I mean, a lot of the intellectual thinking behind AI in the 1970s came from Canadians. And so the data centers are a natural extension. I personally think in an era of sovereignty, data centers are really essential to have on your own soil, but it is contentious. I mentioned in the prospectus the Canadian government put out that there was some$40 billion worth of data center projects, which, as I said, are energy projects.
SPEAKER_04But we do need to address, as I call it, the moose in the room, because we don't have any elephants here. The moose in the room, which is the opposition to AI, opposition to the everything data centers, certainly accelerating a lot in the United States and spilling over here into Canada. So we are delighted to have not one, but two special guests. First of all, we're delighted to have Deirdre Sheehan from the Law Firm OSLER. She's a partner and the co-chair of the regulatory and indigenous and environmental practice. So welcome, Deirdre.
SPEAKER_05Thank you very much. I'm really pleased to be here and uh looking forward to talking to you today about data centers.
SPEAKER_04Wonderful. And our second guest is no stranger to the podcast, Marcus Rock from ARC Financial, Vice President of Research, who works alongside Jackie. So, Marcus, welcome back. You've done a lot of work on the data centers as well.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thanks, Peter. It's great to be back and uh yeah, excited to dig into the data center topic. It's uh being discussed very, very heavily, and there's a lot of polarization around it. So interested to talk about some of the uh the actual facts.
SPEAKER_01Okay, well, let's start with the opportunity. Like when you look across the country, Alberta is the place where these things are being planned. Now, I know we just had a big announcement for Saskatchewan as well that maybe wasn't in the list of potential projects that I was looking at because I looked at a chart that showed Alberta, you know, dominating in terms of the opportunity. So why are people coming here? Do you think?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I think there's a number of things that make Alberta a really attractive jurisdiction for data centers. Um, obviously we have low-cost, abundant gas, and that's really become one of the major fuels that the data centers are using. As you mentioned, Peter, data centers are kind of a power story. But we also, on that power theme, have had a bit of spare capacity on our grid, which has been very rare in other jurisdictions. It's also a cold weather jurisdiction, which makes it easier for cooling, a bit lower energy requirements. But I think the biggest thing lately is that it's a bit easier to develop, and we actually have a government here who is supportive.
SPEAKER_02I know we'll talk a bit later about some of the opposition, but it's pretty rare now across North America to have a government that is supportive of new data center development. And I think that's attracting a lot of people to the province.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, the one thing I would add to that is, and this gets into some of the regulatory framework, which I think we're going to talk about today, is the uh deregulated power generation sector in Alberta, which makes Alberta a unique jurisdiction, certainly within, for the most part, within Canada, and the ease to get that power supply to the data center, which is you'd indicated, Peter, is part of the important um consideration for development.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So in other places in Canada, like Crown Corp. decides if a power plant is built. But here in Alberta, you could just come and build one if you want to take the risk of what you're gonna get paid for it over time, right? You know, so it's very unique.
SPEAKER_05Yes, yeah. And that's, I think, one of the other Alberta advantage metrics that um has been identified in attracting the data center development. And that's why, even though now our grid is a bit more constrained, there are those projects in the queue because you can have that grid connection, but you can also have your own, you know, merchant on-site developed power generation to go along with that.
SPEAKER_04So the Alberta government has definitely been supportive. The other factor, Marcus, is of course there's a lot of land in Alberta. It's a vast, sparsely populated jurisdiction, unlike, say, the state of Virginia, which has got data center alley, and these data centers are pictured next to neighborhoods and so on. So that's part of it as well. And there's this video out there. Is that an Alberta government video?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so our premier put out a video on social media channels outlining the six questions they have been receiving, and really to address some of the opposition that's starting to pop up around these data center projects, including the one that was announced in uh Stampede Time, right? There's been actually over the summer, the meta one. Yeah, there's the meta one. There's been some community groups that have opposed it. Um, there's been some open houses that actually have been quite hostile uh at times, and the ministers have been at it. So anyway, this video came out and we want to talk a little bit about some of those questions because those really are the questions that the opponents have.
SPEAKER_01And uh I think you know, sometimes when we Marcus and I started looking at this this summer, there's different information. It's sometimes hard to know the answers to some of these things for sure.
SPEAKER_04So, what is what is the number one opposition issue to data centers here in Alberta?
SPEAKER_05I think just from what we're seeing, there's a lot of siting backlash, similar to what was seen with the renewable energy. Um, the solar um don't take up prime agriculture. Like a NIB, a NIMBY thing. There's a lot of a NIMBY thing. There's also, you know, I think genuine concern about what are the imp implications for the power price? What's it gonna do to my electricity bills? And I think just a general not understanding or feeling that there isn't enough regulatory oversight.
SPEAKER_05Um, Marcus, I don't know if that if you had some others.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I think that's exactly right. And, you know, the premier did touch on the the major objections and formed it in this, you know, what are the top six questions? So this, I guess, kind of fell under question two of didn't other jurisdictions get burned? And that's where we see a lot of the the pushback is people hearing bad stories from other jurisdictions. And as you mentioned, dear Dre, it was things like power costs, poor siting, and overly generous incentives was another one, government money going to support these projects and people not feeling like there was enough benefits coming the other way. Right. And there certainly were examples in other jurisdictions of things going wrong.
SPEAKER_02I think on the power side, PJM is kind of the poster child of this. It contains data center alley that you mentioned, Peter. It's one of the largest uh power markets in the US and definitely the largest data center market. They've seen their capacity market. You know, they have a market for both energy and capacity, so power on when you want it. The prices are up 11 times what they were a few years ago, and that's added about$9.3 billion. Somebody's utility bill for electricity has gone up 11 times. Is that what you're doing? So their bill hasn't gone up 11 times, but you know, when you look at your bill, there's all these subcomponents.
SPEAKER_02One of those components is to pay for the capacity market, and that component went up 11 times. So the regulator there estimated it was about$9 billion of extra costs shared across PGM just because of data centers.
SPEAKER_01So there have been um some stories out there. I mean, I've been caught up in those YouTube videos, right? Where you see like the loud data center right beside people's homes. So I think that hasn't been helpful. But the premier did also talk about, well, why should we even want them, considering that? And she talked about the benefits, like$250 million per year from the meta facility alone from royalties, taxes, and fees. Do you think that that is enough when you consider like there's costs to having these two, right? We're going to have reclamation and you know, potentially need to like build up more of our power grid to support them.
SPEAKER_05So I think that just in terms of the benefits that we're looking at from the data centers, this is a common theme that, you know, is being brought up as well. So there is the municipal tax base, um, which they're going to add to any municipality. Uh, one of the complaints there is that, and I'm gonna preface this by saying I am not a municipal tax specialist, but it uh only applies the property that is subject to the municipal tax assessment is the land and buildings and not the computer um hardware associated with it.
SPEAKER_05So it's not the entire capital cost, for instance, of the data center. And also the other point that Premier Smith has been making is that this getting into the framework of bring your own generation, they're looking at natural gas-fired cogen um plants in order to be the generation that comes alongside these data centers, which means the data centers are going to be a driver of natural gas production, which also is a royalty benefit to the province.
SPEAKER_05And so, I mean, I think that if you sort of focus in on one aspect of the equation, you have to also think about the other aspects of the equation and the overall framework. And I do think that, you know, data centers are going to be built somewhere. And what can we do here, I think, in order to attract them? You know, from my point of view, there is a sufficient benefit when we're looking at the development of these to consider them to be, you know, something that in the right circumstances and design properly are a good thing for Alberta.
SPEAKER_01And I want to clarify too, that's 250 million a year. It's not just a one-time thing. So it is a significant income, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And and just to add on that, I mean, one of the other kind of framings that the government has and that Premier Smith uh outlined in in the video is that, you know, there's been all this conversation about how do we as a province diversify into other markets? How do we get value for our resources when we're constrained and have difficulty building pipelines to other markets? You know, they sort of see data centers as kind of call it a digital refinery for natural gas. So, you know, turning that natural gas into electricity and then into compute and into intelligence, kind of a more valuable commodity rather than kind of our stranded dollar, dollar fifty echo uh that we've had problems with here.
SPEAKER_04So, Deirdre, talk about your practice. Like, how does it fit into this whole data center discussion and debate and so on? Like who do you represent?
SPEAKER_05Right. And so my practice is environmental and regulatory, law and legislation, project approvals. And I have a particular focus in my practice on electricity and power developments and regulation. And so that's the natural crossover and overlap with my practice and data centers. So it's the overall permitting and approval process, but also the power and generation, specific aspects of that.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so this is critical. And I think for our audience, those who are not steeped in understanding how this all works, there's the electrical grid that's powered by natural gas, dominantly power generation in Alberta. But basically, because these data centers are so large, the directive to them is okay, you can build your data center, but build your own power plant. We don't want you plugging into the grid and at the expense of the public utility billpayer.
SPEAKER_04Is that correct?
SPEAKER_05That's correct. And I think in terms of the other jurisdictions getting burned, those are some of the themes that um have been brought up and that, you know, Premier Smith was pointing to, and then saying we have different rules in Alberta that address these. And so I think we've already talked about the electricity generation specifically. So it's not a government-current corporation that builds generation in Alberta, it's private investment. And that's been the case even before data centers came on the horizon.
SPEAKER_05Um, and so building on top of that though, one of the things Alberta has done is they initiated the data center regulation. And the data center regulation is governing how data centers can access the grid for their power and also how they can supply their own power. What it does is it creates a new framework for these kinds of connecting projects to the grid. And it's actually a pretty big policy shift in Alberta.
SPEAKER_05Before the data center regulation, if a big industrial load wanted to come and connect to the grid and plug in, as you put it, they just got in the queue. That's what the ISO, the Alberta electric system operator, the grid operator, um, has a queue, and you just get yourself in the queue and you get your access once you go through the different stages and milestones needed for connection. But now what with data centers and the massive potential power draw, Alberta initiated this new regulation which says data centers can only get 1200 megawatts in the first tranche.
SPEAKER_05And then it also set up a framework for more data centers where it's say, we're gonna prioritize those data centers that want to connect to our grid by giving the ones who bring their own generation, that is, build a power plant.
SPEAKER_04Your own power plant.
SPEAKER_05Your own power plant, or you can enter into an agreement with another developer to build the power plant for you. You get priority. We're gonna let you go ahead first. And so that's one of the things that Alberta has done, I think.
SPEAKER_04So I think this is important. So, Jackie, like just give us a sense of scale here. Okay, 1200 megawatts, 1.2 gigawatts. The meta plant, the data center is one gigawatt. So they're gonna bring their own along with Pembana, I think, and others that are.
SPEAKER_01Although I think it could expand beyond that, but that was what was agreed to go forward at this point.
SPEAKER_04But for again, for our audience, give a sense of scale, like the total power generation of Alberta is what, like 12 or 13?
SPEAKER_01Well, on average, we're consuming around 10 gigawatts, but the capacity is higher and the peak is higher. But 10, just from perspective, there's 20 gigawatts of projects that are in the queue saying that they want to uh plug in. Plug in. Now, not all of them have gotten to Point where they have a hyperscaler behind them and they're for sure going to go forward. But it is kind of concerning when you think of it as an Albertan. Like if it was the old thing and they could just all plug in, that'd be, you know, two times more than our current average load. So that's a problem.
SPEAKER_04And so in the dead of winter, minus 30, no wind, no sun, we're consuming 12-ish probably at the peak. Meanwhile, a data center wants to come in and quote, plug in. So it's no surprise that the province is saying, bring your own power and create your own generation, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, but in terms of the people that came to that conference a few weeks ago, the developers, and there was a lot of Americans here, which, you know, they're kind of like, well, it's hard to build these things, so they're up here learning about Alberta. But also they were saying that this regulation is very helpful. But I still look at it, you know, does it increase our power bills? Like the video that the premier put out, she said electricity bills won't go up. And that transmission cost could actually even come down because now we're gonna have more load on the same transmission system. So that, you know, if you actually kind of parse that out by how much power we use, the unit cost should go down.
SPEAKER_01My concern is we are given up a lot of our spare capacity, you know, like the 12, you talked about the 1.2 gigawatts. Well, that was kind of free capacity on the system. Yes, they're gonna build their own generation, but it might be out of sync at times where they come on a little bit before the power generation comes. So I don't know, Marcus, you've looked at this. Do you think that there's the potential for power bills to go up as we kind of get a tighter power system?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I think there's definitely the potential. And I think unfortunately, this is one of the areas that's just genuinely complicated. So people are gonna seize on the facts that sort of align with their point of view. But I think it's important to understand when they talk about power bills, you know, what makes up a power bill. There's all the different components that are on your on your bill that we talked about before, but there's the the energy or generation piece, there's the transmission piece, the distribution piece. The government has really focused on that transmission piece in their messaging.
SPEAKER_04There are so just to be clear again, for the audience members that are not familiar with this, yeah, those big, gigantic power line towers have to be paid for. And there's a fixed charge that gets distributed to everybody who's a power user.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's exactly right. Those giant wires that go from a generating station to a substation. The ones I wish were underground, but they're not all the costs associated with those, think of those costs going on the numerator, and then the denominator is you know sharing among all of the different rate payers. So the government's argument in in the video is that well, Meta's paying for all of its new capacity costs, so there's nothing new going on the numerator, but there's a big user going on the denominator. So that will mean it's shared among more users.
SPEAKER_02So that's where the 6% reduction comes from.
SPEAKER_04So if I go to my utility bill for electricity and look at all the line items and it says transmission, it should go down. So there's a scenario that is being argued or debated that actually data centers can actually reduce your power bill.
SPEAKER_02And that's the argument they make on the transmission piece. Now, what the critics would say is okay, but there are these other pieces of your bill. There's the the energy piece, which is essentially, you know, we have a free market for power that you discussed, and the generators and consumers respond to price signals, and then the market clears at a certain point. And if you have more demand, that should raise the price all things equal. And Jackie, you mentioned the timing mismatch, and that's where this kind of comes into play that with the meta facility, um, the data center is expected to come on before the power generation.
SPEAKER_02So in kind of that 2028 timeframe, whereas the power generation facility is coming on closer to 2030, 2031. So in that intervening time, there will be more demand on the system with no new supply. So power prices are likely to go up then. Now, when that generation facility comes on, and Meta has also promised to add some new renewable energy to the grid, that theoretically should balance things. So it you may not have long-term power price increases, but you could have some periods where power prices get stronger.
SPEAKER_04Right. But there isn't there's sort of like this I'm gonna call it ideal situation, a scenario where somebody says, okay, I'm gonna put up a data center and I'm going to put it on a natural gas field and power my own natural gas-fired power generation into my data center, and I don't even need to plug into the grid. So all of this stuff is moot.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and I do think that's a possible scenario. But given the redundancy needs for data center and their reliability, it's a less likely scenario, I think, from a development perspective than having a grid connection for reliability and your own on-site power generation. They talk about the five nines, the 99.999% reliability, you can't have downtime. So if something happens to your on-site generation, you need to have the backup grid, unless you're going to build completely duplicative two times, three times behind the fence generation in order to serve the data center's reliability needs.
SPEAKER_05And if actually the way the government has worked its data center levy, if you are isolated from the grid, the data centers that are not grid connected don't pay the levy. Right.
SPEAKER_01So I will say from the conference, there was a whole panel on this topic. And I came away from it. I think they're all going to be connected because of the reasons you say.
SPEAKER_04I know there was a big build-out in the transmission towers. Is there some limit to what the grid can handle?
SPEAKER_05Yeah. So there was a big build in Alberta of the transmission infrastructure in about 2015 timeframe.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05And part of the criticism of the Alberta electricity bills historically and to date is that that transmission component, the one line item of your bill, is actually quite high because of the grid, the cost of having that big build out on the grid. And so, I mean, I think this scenario where you're putting data centers into the mix of customers to share that load, bringing that transmission cost down holds true so long as we don't have to reinforce the grid and invest more in the grid, which I do think there is going to be of necessity some further grid enhancements, the extent to which is determined by the ISO.
SPEAKER_05Now, I will say there's another policy initiative that the government has introduced, which is intended to mitigate the costs of those big transmission grid investments, because Alberta has moved, and this is not related to data centers specifically, but it's moved from a zero congestion transmission management principle to an optimized transmission planning framework. That's a current regulatory change as well in Alberta.
SPEAKER_05So before the ISO basically had to make sure that the grid was unconstrained. So anybody wanting to put power on the grid wouldn't be constrained by capacity in any particular region. The government has directed a change to that that says, well, no, let's do a cost-benefit analysis before we invest in the grid. So there can be areas now of constraint on the grid. So that's another unrelated but now related policy measure to address that issue.
SPEAKER_04So as Marcus said, it's quite complicated because one line item, the transmission cost could go down. However, the cost for consuming electricity because of a potential shortage of power generation capacity could go up. So we don't really know how it's all going to net out.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's very true. And you know, it could depend at one year you could be up, the another year could you could be down. I think one thing to add though, it's worth differentiating between sort of the micro impacts of what happens with the new data center in Alberta versus the bigger macro of the whole data center build-out globally is sort of the reason that you can't buy a transformer now and natural gas turbines are five years sold out and three times more expensive than they used to be. So regardless of what the truth is in Alberta with adding data centers here, we likely are going to be paying more for power because of data centers broadly.
SPEAKER_01Let's switch to the jobs. Another criticism is not enough jobs. So the meta one, for example, says 3,000 jobs during construction, 300 long-term jobs. What do you think? Do you think that that's a big number? I mean, there's some criticism. Well, you know, you get more if we had a refinery or something. I don't know. No one's building a refinery here, though. So I'm not sure why we're comparing to that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I think that that's uh 300 is the number people have key in on in particular. And it doesn't sound very large when you compare it to a$13 billion investment. And if you look at other types of investments on number of jobs per billion dollars, you're right. Others could be higher. You know, an oil sands B facility is probably twice that. Um, if you invested that in solar, you'd certainly have a lot more jobs than that. But I do think your point is well taken that, you know, that's not really the choice we're making, right? This isn't$13 billion of government money that we're deciding do we spend it on a data center or something else that has more jobs.
SPEAKER_02This is external parties bringing their capital here. So we're deciding between those 300 jobs or no jobs. I think the real trade-off is not so much on how many jobs you're getting, but are the drawbacks in terms of power or water worth it for what you're getting?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think so. But I think there is a dimension that's being missed. And it was actually brought up at the Canada Investment Summit on the digital panel, and that is that having domestic sovereign computing capacity is a positive also for the people that are at the frontier of making models, AI models, and that we actually have unique capabilities here in Canada. So, in those jobs, numbers that are quoted are not the really top-level software AI and usage jobs, which I think are being underestimated.
SPEAKER_04Increasingly, as I said, like the sovereign compute is a buzzword that is really gaining momentum. So, and the ability to potentially attract people to come to Canada to work in this capacity.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I think it's a very good point. And I I think it's something you've found in other jurisdictions that once you get not just one data center, but more, you develop this ecosystem.
SPEAKER_04The ecosystem of the AI professionals, and then the cooling technicians, the entrepreneurs, and it sort of creates uh centers of excellence.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I I think the extreme example of that would be somewhere like Loudoun County, which is in the heart of data center alley, where you know there are around 500,000 people, something like 17,000 employed in data centers. And it's not coincidentally the richest county in America. Now, that's that's an extreme example, but uh, you know, potentially somewhere in between there is where you could go.
SPEAKER_01Okay, well, let's talk about where they get cited, because I think that has been uh an area of controversy. And that was one of the uh questions that the premier talked about. So uh the premier talked about a multi-layered approach to data center approvals. We had a couple of examples here. We had one proposed for Olds that uh was rejected. Then we have this metadata center in Sturgeon County, which some of the local residents feel like there wasn't adequate consultation, that they just found out about it at Stampede and there wasn't like a lot of information to the community. So, what does it take to cite these?
SPEAKER_01And is there consultation with the communities? Just explain that process.
SPEAKER_05The one thing I'd point out, just going back to the data center regulation, in order to enter the queue to connect under the data center regulation, the data center has to provide evidence of municipal zoning approvals. So they were actually tying this siting to your data center's ability to gain power, which I think is an important consideration. But in terms of siting, it really is from a where does it go perspective, municipal development approvals and zoning is really an important part of that.
SPEAKER_05It is a multi-layered approval process. And I think part of the frustration that people are feeling is there is no one single data center regulator in Alberta. It is a patchwork of, for lack of a better word, of approvals that are required. That said, these are approvals that are required and given by, you know, subject matter expertise, which I always tend to like from a regulatory perspective. I don't want an unfamiliar regulator deciding, you know, something outside their area of expertise. Like the Department of Fisheries and Oceans shouldn't be deciding whether, you know, a power plant should be built.
SPEAKER_05That's not its area of expertise. So the two examples are quite interesting with respect to the one, uh, the Synapse Data Center in Olds, it actually got rejected at the Alberta Utilities Commission for its uh power plant application. The um backup generation and the um of diesel generation and the natural gas cogen facility that was intended to power the data center.
SPEAKER_05And it actually had conditional approval from the county of Old for siting, but it was right next to a residential area. And the Alberta Utilities Commission is the regulator that decides the power plants, and it decides whether their power plant is in the public interest. So it's a very broad decision, which does encompass siting and potential impacts on neighboring communities. And as we know, the power is a pretty important part of the data center. And so the commission ended up rejecting that application after it there was so much public outpouring of questions and feeling like it was not the right location.
SPEAKER_05And why does it need to be right next to a mature residential area? And ultimately, what the Alberta Utilities Commission said is you have not convinced us that your power plant needs to be here. And we're not convinced that there aren't other places the power plant can be, which would have a lesser impact on stakeholders. And so it was not rejected from a municipal zoning perspective and siting. It was rejected by the utilities commission in the public interest because they weren't convinced that the site location was balanced all of the competing interests sufficiently.
SPEAKER_04So you have a lens on all of this in your practice of what's going on. So I want to ask you a couple of questions. I mean, I know you're not a litigation lawyer, but you're sort of in the legal orbit of what goes on. Yeah. I mean, are we seeing lawsuits starting to fly here? And I guess further to that, I want to get a general sense of what the pulse of building data centers here is today, say relative to the US or other places? Like is the opposition getting worse? Or is there effective communications in play, such as what the premier's trying to do, or others are trying to do to try and say, hey, calm down.
SPEAKER_04We've got a different process here. We're trying to get these things built with consultation and so on.
SPEAKER_05So I think that the public opposition is getting more significant to data centers in Alberta. And I think part of it is because people are becoming more aware of it. There is a lot of examples from the states and other jurisdictions that are being used to feed that in Alberta. So I do think that public opposition is increasing in Alberta to these kinds of developments. I think that from a litigation perspective, yes, we are seeing challenges.
SPEAKER_05So one of the challenges that is ongoing right now is the water license associated with the Wonder Valley development in the county of Greenview. And the Sturgeon Lake First Nation or Cree Nation is challenging the process of issuing the water license to, and in this case, it was the municipality of Greenview because they're the one developing the industrial park where the Wonder Valley data center is going to be built.
SPEAKER_05And so they are actually the holder of the water license. Um, but the process and lack of consultation is the alleged deficiency in that license. So I do think we're going to see more of that.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so it's growing, but I would say it's less than maybe some of those places in the US based on uh the theme of the conference. Um let's come back to this metadata center built in Sturgeon County. Is that one approved? And do you feel like there was their consultation or why does the community not feel like they kind of had as much visibility to that?
SPEAKER_05Right. And sorry, I segueed off. So that one is in the industrial zone designation for the heartland area in Alberta and it is situated there. But that doesn't mean there are any different regulatory approvals that are really needed for a data center there. I think that the reason that people feel like they weren't consulted on that data center, is because the area that that data center is going to be built is already zoned heavy industrial.
SPEAKER_05It has to have that municipal designation to be part of a designated industrial zone. And what happened in that case, as I understand it, was um Sturgeon County amended the land use bylaw for heavy industrial to include data centers as a permitted use. So that's the municipal zoning framework there. And then, so once it is a permitted use under the land use bylaw, proponent for a data center can come in and make a development permit application.
SPEAKER_05And there's not going to be a public hearing associated with that development permit application because it complies with the permitted uses of the land use bylaw. And I think that's the reason why I would understand that in Sturgeon County, the feeling was there wasn't consultation on that data center. The other thing I will say is so the associated Greenlight Energy Power Plant that is going to support that data center also went through a public process before the Alberta Utilities Commission.
SPEAKER_05And that can have a very large public hearing, as we've seen in some other cases. But for that particular development for the Greenlight Energy Cogin facility, it was 1.8 gigawatts. Yes, I was going to say megawatts. And I'm like, that's the wrong unit there. It was approved, and partly because it is in the industrial heartland. The commission felt like it was an appropriate location for that particular facility. And it wasn't, again, it wasn't expressly tied to the metadata center. It was referenced in the application materials that this was going to be one of the potential off takes for this particular power plant, but there was certainly an opportunity.
SPEAKER_05There would have been public consultation requirements on that power plant as well. I think that, you know, to say there wasn't any consultation is not a fair characterization because there certainly would have been opportunities for consultation on these aspects of the project that's required under the regulatory.
SPEAKER_01So much to cover here, Marcus. Let's quickly talk about water because that's been a point of contention is that, you know, these things take a lot of water. And uh yes, uh, we saw the meta information, it's like this amount of a golf course, but uh, is that sustainable in the context of all the other water uses that are already there? And is there someone looking at this holistically? That's a question that stakeholders have.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I think water is a very important topic to discuss because it is one of the top objections that people bring up. And just really quick 101, I mean, data centers use water to cool the chips. So the chips generate an immense amount of heat when the power goes through them. The cooling system will take that heat away from the chips, and then you need to reject it to the atmosphere. So the old facilities would have evaporated water to do that, and that's why they were so water intense. The newer facilities are gonna run air over that cooling loop to take away that heat. So that does mean that they use quite a bit less uh water.
SPEAKER_02And as you mentioned, in the metafacility, they're talking about less than a golf course. So I think the new technology is making water much less of a concern. But to your point, it really does matter, you know, where you're drawing this water from. Not all water uses are equal. If you're taking water out of a water-strained region, uh, you know, maybe in the southeast US, even small amounts of water could be a big deal. So you need to have a good assessment of can your local watershed actually handle that amount of water? And there is a process to evaluate that water. I'd be interested in hearing Deirdre's thoughts a bit uh more on explaining how that process actually works.
SPEAKER_01And I have one more question for you, too, because there's a power plant that uses water too. Yes. And that isn't included in that golf course number, I don't think.
SPEAKER_05Probably not. But again, Alberta has been granting water licenses for industrial purposes for decades. And so there is a pretty robust framework around new water licenses. There are certain basins in Alberta that are effectively curtailed. You cannot get new water licenses out of them because the government does keep its eye on available capacity. When a new water license is applied for to take new surface water from a river, for instance, it is assessed against available capacity, other users, um, risks to supply of other users.
SPEAKER_05And so, you know, to say that nobody's taking a look at water use, I don't think is a fair representation of the water licensing regime in Alberta. If you are in one of those basins where you can't get water, you have to take it from a municipal source or buy somebody else's water license. So there is a framework around that as well.
SPEAKER_04Well, it's been a fascinating discussion. I sense this is not a story that's going away. As data centers and AI gain momentum or AI gains momentum in the need for data centers, it's not a story that's going away. I can't help but feel that Alberta has a real comparative advantage because we have abundant energy at the source, which is the natural gas. And so this is a space, given our land, our northern climate, all the advantages that we have, it seems like a natural place to put data centers.
SPEAKER_04But I certainly recognize that the concerns are legitimate. And I, like you, Jackie, have watched the American videos, which are very slick, sort of the anti-AI videos. And when you see a giant power plant outside somebody's back fence, you know, you kind of get it. It's like there's legitimate concerns. But, you know, I think that effective communications and proper sighting and proper consultations. I think that was a word that was used, I don't know, amongst the four of us, probably 20 times, you know, consultation, consultation.
SPEAKER_04What's kind of a no-brainer? Go talk to the people and calm them down and go through a process. And in that regard, the regulators, I'm hearing, go through the process. And there are definitely instances where the regulator has rejected, I think, like the old land. And so the system seems to work, at least for now. The communications, I think we have to work on because I sense that it's a story that can get away rather quickly, where a lot of emotion gets injected into it.
SPEAKER_04And, you know, your selection bias, you take the worst possible story and apply it to Alberta. You know, I don't think that that's warranted. Anyway, we have a process. This is not going away. Thank you very much, dear Drishihan from Osler with your regulatory practice, and Marcus Rock, as always, from Ark Energy Research Institute, Vice President working with Jackie. Always a pleasure, Jackie. So thanks for listening, and uh, we'll be following this story more.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and thanks for our listeners. If you enjoyed this podcast, please rate us on the app that you listen to and tell someone else about us.
SPEAKER_00For more ideas and insights, visit Archenergy Institute.com.
This episode is also available as a video on YouTube. US imports of Venezuelan crude oil rose from nearly 100,000 B/d before this year’s US intervention to almost 700,000 B/d in August. This influx into the US Gulf...
This episode is also available as a video on YouTube. This week on the podcast, Peter and Jackie cover the US midterm election results and their potential implications for energy policy and Canada. They discuss why...
This episode is also available as a video on YouTube. British Columbia has seen a major political shift with the election of a majority Conservative government led by Premier-designate Lorne Doerkson after nine years of...
This episode is also available as a video on YouTube. This week on the podcast, Peter and Jackie review the latest election news, including the BC election, which produced a Conservative majority government over the...
In this week's podcast, Peter and Jackie discuss global oil and diesel markets, the government’s role in major infrastructure projects, including the Pacific Link pipeline, and widening Canadian heavy oil discounts....