Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Appropriate Proper Reasonable

Appropriate Proper Reasonable artwork

213: Thoughts on Schools

May 19, 202620 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

An AI-created episode based on a human-composed blog post: Thoughts on Schools

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

You know, it's really funny how we look at certain things in our world, like institutions we interact with every single day, and we just sort of accept them as if they're natural phenomena. Right, like gravity or the weather. Exactly, like a mountain or a river. You look at a school building, you hear a bell ring, you see students moving from a math classroom to a history classroom, and you just think, well, yeah. That is just what school is. It does feel entirely fixed. I mean it feels like this immutable law of the

universe that at say 8 15 in the morning a teenager is going to sit at a desk and learn algebra for exactly 45 minutes. Right. And then the bell rings and they immediately have to switch their brain over to biology. We rarely, if ever, question the actual architecture of that experience. But when you actually stop and look under the hood of that system, you realize it is not a mountain or a river at all. It's a machine. And someone at some point built that machine for a very specific reason. They absolutely did. So welcome to today's

Deep Dive. Today, we're looking at an essay that, honestly, it completely shattered how I view schools. It's a January 2020 piece titled Thoughts on Schools. by Gary Ackerman, published over at hackscience .education. It's a great piece. It really is. And our mission today is to figure out what this educational machine was actually built to do, why its gear seems so stubbornly stuck in the past, and, well, what it actually takes to be a learner navigating the realities of today. And to give you, the listener, a bit

of context before we really get into the mechanisms of that machine, the core thesis we're working with from Ackerman's piece is that school is fundamentally a social institution. OK, let's unpack this. What does that mean in practice? Well, like all social institutions, it's highly malleable. It bends, it morphs, and it changes to reflect the dominant culture of its time. The curriculum you study, the role of your teacher, the actual physical structure of your day. None of that is an accident. Exactly. None of it. It is a direct reflection of what the people running society decided they needed at a given

moment in history. Which, I mean, that raises the immediate question, what do we actually need our schools to do right now? Because if you look at the current landscape, there is a massive push toward hyper specialization. Oh, definitely. The whole STEM push. Right. We're seeing mandates for coding classes in elementary schools, heavy pushes for STEM tracks, and this overarching anxiety that if a kid isn't learning a highly specific marketable skill by the age of 12, They're just going to fall behind. There is a very real tension there. And Ackerman highlights this beautifully.

We are constantly debating between specialized schooling, like career and technical centers, where you learn to operate a specific machine or write a specific. programming language, and general purpose education, which is rooted in the traditional liberal arts ideal. The liberal arts approach isn't about mastering one tool. It's about building the capacity to understand complex interconnected problems. Listening to you describe that, it basically sounds like a battle between a factory floor and a brain gym. Oh, I really like that framing. The factory floor

versus the brain gym. Because the factory floor model wants to teach you how to make a very specific widget, right? So you can plug right into the economy. But the brain gym isn't teaching you how to make a widget at all. It's just building your cognitive stamina, your flexibility. Right, your ability to lift heavier intellectual weights. Exactly. So that when you finally do enter the real world, you can learn whatever widget making process is actually required. What's fascinating here is how Ackerman illustrates this. To show why the brain gem model might actually be more

crucial in our hyper -technical world, he shares a really great real -world anecdote. Oh, the IT shop story? Yes. He writes about visiting a former student who was interning at a highly specialized IT shop. This company developed and sold complex data products. The environment was intense. I bet. They're writing code, managing massive databases, ensuring strict data consistency. And on the day Ackerman visited, the team was actually in the middle of migrating an entire data center. Wait, migrating a data center? That

is incredibly high stakes, deeply technical work. I would assume a room full of people handling that are like all computer science graduates who have been coding in C++ since middle school. That is the logical assumption most people would make. Because if you don't have that highly specialized background, that sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. But when Ackerman spoke with the manager of this IT office, the manager revealed something that completely flips that assumption on its head. On this team of highly talented people

executing this deeply technical database migration, there was not a single computer science major among them. Wait, really? Not one? Zero. How does that even work? I mean, how do you migrate a data fender without a room full of computer science degrees? Because of the exact cognitive stamina you mentioned earlier, the manager described his team simply as curious, good thinkers and incredibly active learners. They didn't come in knowing the specific software or the specific database architecture. They came in knowing how

to learn. They developed the expertise on the job, they collaborated, and they shared that knowledge with one another to solve the problem in front of them. Wow, it's like... It's like trying to teach a kid to navigate the open ocean by making them march on a treadmill. The hyper -specialized treadmill approach teaches you how to keep a steady pace and follow precise instructions, but it teaches you absolutely nothing about reading the wind or adjusting to sudden waves. Or fixing a broken sail. Exactly. Those IT workers were out on the open ocean. They didn't need the treadmill.

They needed the fundamental metaskill of adaptability. Exactly. The ability to learn new things is the ultimate metaskill. In a world where the specific technology you learn today will likely be obsolete in, what, five years? Specialized knowledge depreciates quickly. The capacity to learn, to adapt, and to think critically is the only asset that doesn't depreciate. Okay, so if this general problem -solving ability, this... Brain Gym Foundation is so incredibly critical. It makes me wonder

how our K through 12 system was originally constructed because clearly we didn't just magically arrive at the massive standardized high schools we have today. We absolutely did not. And this is where Ackerman's essay takes a hard critical look at the historical realities of the American K through 12 system. Yeah, the origin story. Right. The evolution from the early village based one room schoolhouses to the massive sprawling high schools of the 20th century is often painted with this very nostalgic, sterilized brush. But Ackerman

argues that the true history of this expansion is deeply political and, in many ways, quite dark. And real quick, as we get into this historical context, I want to clarify for you, our listener, that we are just impartially reporting on Ackerman's historical assertions here. Yes, we are not endorsing a specific political viewpoint, simply conveying the arguments contained in the source text. Exactly. According to his analysis, these early educational expansions were heavily driven by exclusionary practices. He points out that the design of the system was shaped by blatantly racist and sexist

policies that dictated exactly who was even allowed inside the building. And furthermore, He argues that the curriculum itself was explicitly used as a mechanism for cultural indoctrination. He specifically cites how it was deployed to destroy indigenous cultures and force assimilation into the dominant society. Right. It wasn't just some benevolent project to make everyone smarter. According to the essay, it was an organized effort to enforce a specific cultural standard. That's the argument, yes. But I want to push back on how that actually functions, because stating

that a school was used for assimilation is one thing, but how did the actual structure of the day enforce that. A one -room schoolhouse in a small village seems like it would just reflect the local community. It would generally. So how does scaling that up into a massive standardized system suddenly become a weapon for cultural dominance? It comes down to the standardization of the experience. In a local one -room schoolhouse, the teacher is likely from that community, right? The language spoken might reflect the local immigrant

or indigenous population, and the values taught are localized. Okay, that makes sense. But when you move to a massive state -standardized model, the curriculum is handed down from a central authority. The mechanism of assimilation is the strict enforcement of English -only instruction, the replacing of local histories with a sanitized national narrative. Oh, wow. And the rigid rewarding of behaviors that align with a dominant culture, while actively punishing those that do not. But if you are a citizen in, say, 1910 or a parent

from a marginalized community, how do you vote for that? How did the decision makers at the time possibly package a system designed for exclusion and forced assimilation and sell it to the general public? That is the most insidious part of the history. And Ackerman points out exactly how it was done. Political moves in education, especially the ones that consolidate power or enforce cultural norms, are almost always promoted to the public under guise of doing what is best for children. Oh, man. That is the ultimate shield because the moment you deploy that phrase, you shut down

all logical debate. You really do. If I question the massive consolidation of schools or the stripping away of local curriculum, I am instantly framed as being against the welfare of children. Precisely. It is an incredibly effective rhetorical strategy. If a policy is wrapped in the packaging of child welfare or improving educational standards, it becomes nearly impossible for the public to resist it. Even if the underlying mechanics are deeply restrictive. Exactly. And Ackerman makes a vital point here. If you romanticize this past, if

we pretend the history of our schools was just a pure noble endeavor to spread knowledge, we deny the best evidence we have for understanding how school governance actually operates right now. Because the mechanics of power haven't fundamentally changed. That exact same rhetoric, you know, what is best for the kids, is absolutely still used today in school board meetings across the country to push through all sorts of varying political agendas. Right. From curriculum bans to funding cuts, denying the past political nature

of school organization simply blinds us to its continued influence today. Schools have always been political battlegrounds. So if we accept Ackerman's premise that the school system is this highly malleable machine, shaped by the political and economic desires of the people in power, that completely changes how we have to look at the physical layout of a school. It changes everything. I mean, think about my confusion earlier regarding the bells and the strict schedules. Here's where it gets really interesting. We treat things like ringing bells and rotating 45 -minute

periods like gravity. Right, as if they're natural laws of the universe. Exactly. We assume that structure was derived from deep pedagogical research into human cognition. But it wasn't. So I have to ask you because this has never made sense to me. I understand having a bell to start the day to get everyone in the building, but why the hyperfragmentation? why chop knowledge up into isolated 45 -minute blocks? It does seem counterintuitive. You go to math, you solve equations for 40 minutes, you start getting to a flow state, and then a loud bell rings, and you are forced

to drop everything and immediately go think about the French Revolution for exactly 45 minutes. The real world simply does not work like that. No, it doesn't. So if this structure wasn't handed down from the heavens based on natural human learning, What specific problem was it actually invented to solve? It is a great question because nobody engineers a machine that rigid by accident. Ackerman connects the DOS here beautifully. Those modern high school structures, the bells, the isolation of subjects, the strict hierarchical

authority were built to solve two massive highly specific problems of the early 20th century. OK, what's reason number one? Reason number one, they needed to prepare a massive influx of young people and new immigrants for the industrial economy. So it is quite literally the factory floor model. The school day was designed to mirror an industrial factory ship. Exactly. Think about the realities of a 1920s assembly line. You don't need a worker who understands the entire engineering process of the automobile. You need a worker who knows how to attach one specific bolt. over

and over without asking questions. Wow. The school structure was behavioral conditioning. The bell rings. You stop your task immediately, regardless of whether you were finished or deeply engaged in the thought process, and you move to the next station. So the hyperfragmentation of subjects wasn't about optimizing deep learning. Not at all. It was about training students to perform compartmentalized tasks and obey an external mechanical authority. That is wild. It was literally an apprenticeship for compliance. When the bell rings, you stop thinking about math and you start

thinking about history. Because tomorrow, when the factory whistle blows, you need to stop pulling that lever and go eat lunch. That is reason number one. But reason number two for this massive expansion of the high school model is perhaps even more jarring. According to Ackerman, these schools were vastly expanded to act as a holding pen. A holding pen? Like a containment zone? Yes. During this era, society was finally passing progressive legislation restricting child labor. You suddenly had a massive population of strong,

capable adolescents who were legally removed from the industrial workforce. Oh, right. They couldn't work in the coal mines or the textile mills anymore. Exactly. And from a societal standpoint, thousands of unemployed, bored teenagers wandering the streets of rapidly growing cities is a recipe for absolute panic. Idle hands, potential crime. And frankly, they didn't want these adolescents competing with adults for the remaining jobs. So society needed a place to put them. The high school system was expanded, in large part, to occupy these adolescents. It was a societal containment

strategy. That is staggering to think about. We built this massive pedagogical model. We codified the schedules, the subjects, the architecture of the buildings, essentially as a waiting room for teenagers who were legally banned from the workforce. And we are still using it. That is the ultimate realization for you, our listener. We are still using these exact same structures, the bells, the periods, the physical layout of the classrooms, long after the original conditions that necessitated them have faded. We do not

live in a 1920s industrial... economy anymore? No. We operate a 21st century information society using a behavioral conditioning machine designed for a bygone era. Well, no wonder everybody is so stressed out. If you try to run an advanced hyper -connected creative economy on a hundred -year -old industrial software, of course the system is going to crash. The friction must be unbelievable for the students and the teachers. It is. And I imagine that friction is exactly what drives the constant desperate search for new solutions in education today. Educational

leaders know the machine is sputtering, so they are just desperately trying to bolt new parts onto it. Which brings us directly to the modern educator's dilemma. Because teachers and administrators feel that friction every single day, the educational system is constantly oscillating between two extremes. On one side, you have what Ackerman describes as the endless parade of buzzwords and panaceas. Which, if you look at the history of education over the last 30 years, is just a graveyard of acronyms and branded teaching methods. Right. A new trendy initiative emerges,

completely captures the attention of educational leadership, and becomes the sole focus of massive professional development seminars. The advocates of these buzzwords swear that this specific app or this new highly structured methodology is the magic cure that will finally optimize the system. But they never address the core issue, do they? Rarely. You can buy the most expensive, state -of -the -art interactive whiteboard in the world, but if you are still ringing a bell every 45 minutes to force a kid to stop thinking about a complex problem, you're just putting

a digital screen on a 1920s assembly line. Exactly. The buzzwords don't fundamentally change the industrial nature of the machine, they just change the paint color. And because these fads inevitably fail to deliver on their massive promises, they quietly fade away after a few years, leaving teachers deeply burned out. Yeah, that makes sense. And that burnout leads to the second extreme, a retreat into conservative nostalgia. Oh, like, I survived the system so the system works. Precisely. Out of sheer exhaustion from the cycle of fads,

many educators and leaders fall back on their own personal, idealized version of schooling. Their definition of what is best for students becomes grounded entirely in what they themselves experienced 30 or 40 years ago. They retreat to the familiar. They do. So what does this all mean? I mean, fine for 1995 isn't fine for a world dealing with generative artificial intelligence, globalized gig economies, and an unprecedented flood of daily information. If educational leaders are constantly distracted by panaceas that fade

away and teachers just revert to how I was taught, where does that leave the actual students sitting at the desk today? If we connect this to the bigger picture, Ackerman's conclusion offers a vital reality check here. The truth of what a student actually needs exists in the messy middle ground between those extremes. Right now, students are indeed caught in the crossfire. They are trapped in obsolete school structures that are essentially busy training teachers for the teacher's own past, rather than preparing the students for the student's future. So how

do we break out of that? If the treadmill is broken, how do we get back to the open ocean? By returning our focus to the core capacity of the learner, just like those IT workers migrating the data center. The goal of a modern education shouldn't be to perfectly execute the educational buzzword of the month, nor should it be to blindly survive a 1920s factory schedule with perfect compliance. The goal is to cultivate active, curious, adaptable thinkers. It is about recognizing that the facts you memorize today might literally be proven obsolete by new research tomorrow.

The specific coding language you learn today will probably be written by an AI tomorrow. But the neural pathways you build for critical thinking, for collaboration, for asking the right questions when you are completely lost, those are the tools that sustain you for a lifetime. That is the true brain, Jim. We have to stop designing our educational institutions to produce compliant widgets and start designing them to cultivate adaptable minds. It requires us to view the institution of schooling through an entirely new, highly critical lens. It absolutely does. Just to briefly

recap the journey we've been on today, we learned that the liberal arts ideal of problem solving is highly relevant today. That our school structures are actually hangovers from industrial prep and child labor laws. Yeah. But the phrase, what's best for kids, is often a mask for adult politics or nostalgia, leaving students trapped in a machine that no longer serves their reality. It is a lot to process, especially regarding a place where most of us spend thousands of hours of our youth. It is. And before we go, we want to leave you, our listener, with one final, provocative

question to mull over. Something to really think about the next time you drive past a massive high school building in your town. Consider this. If the ringing bells... The separate subjects, the long hallways and the rotating schedules of today's schools were invented strictly to solve the economic demands and the labor crises of the early 1900s. What would a school look like if we tore it completely down to the studs, threw away the antique blueprints and built it from scratch to solve the realities of 2026?

What a question. Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive. We hope this conversation encourages you to keep questioning the natural structures in your own life. Remember, just because it looks like a mountain doesn't mean it wasn't built by someone with an agenda. Until next time, keep your curiosity sharp.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 250: Changing Vision of Technology Literacy

    Nov 14, 202619 minAudio

    An AI-created episode based on a human-composed blog post: Changing Vision of Technology Literacy

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 249: The Inquiring Technologist: Why Great Solution Design Begins with "Too Many" Questions

    Oct 27, 20265 minAudio

    An AI-generated episode based on an AI-generated blog posts based on an old microblogging post: The Inquiring Technologist: Why Great Solution Design Begins with "Too Many" Questions

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 248: Gathering Organizational Intelligence for Network Security

    Oct 25, 202622 minAudio

    A brief AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Gathering Organizational Intelligence for Network Security

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 247: Models of Technology-Rich Teaching

    Oct 16, 202613 minAudio

    An AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Models of Technology-Rich Teaching

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 246: Concepts of Operating Systems

    Oct 11, 202621 minAudio

    An AI-generated episode based on a blog post designed for students in a community college course. Concepts of Operating Systems

    Credit the people on this episode