Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Appropriate Proper Reasonable

Appropriate Proper Reasonable artwork

227: Technology Companies “Certifying” Educators

Jul 5, 202619 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

An AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Technology Companies “Certifying” Educators

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to today's deep dive I am incredibly glad you are here with us Because we have a mission today that well it touches essentially everyone listening Yeah, pretty much everyone right whether you have kids or your student yourself, or you just operate in a modern digital workplace We were exploring the the hidden implications of massive technology companies essentially running our classroom. It is a massive shift that flew completely under the radar for a lot of people. Exactly. And our roadmap for this exploration

today is a rather striking blog post from March of twenty twenty six. It's titled technology companies certifying educators and it comes from a platform called hack science dot education. And the author there is Dr. Gary Ackerman. Yes Dr. Ackerman. OK let's unpack this because his background is the entire reason this post caught our attention in the first place. Right. We really need to set the stage here. Dr. Ackerman is not just some outside agitator throwing stones at modern technology from a cabin in the woods. No, not at all. He spent a decade in the trenches

as a middle and high school math and science teacher. And today he is a highly regarded educational technology expert. Right. He literally wrote the book on the subject, a text called Technology Rich Teaching. He even hosts a show called Critoral Plus Classroom. I mean, his daily professional mandate is to encourage educators to use IT in meaningful ways. Exactly. He is the person school districts call when they need help implementing new software. So when a veteran professional whose entire livelihood is built around EdTech

starts raising massive red flags about his own industry, well, that warrants deep attention. Yeah, this is a structural critique from inside the house. So to start, The catalyst for this entire essay is it's almost deceptively mundane. It really is. Ackerman writes that he doesn't typically listen to afternoon radio, but he happened to catch a broadcast on Vermont public radio. It was a syndicated show called 1A. And they were running a segment on the start of social media's legal reckoning. Right. And during this broadcast, one of the guests makes a relatively

simple point about the attention economy. Yeah, the guest basically says that social media companies are at their core businesses, and they generate more revenue when people use their platforms more. Which, I mean, we all... kind of know that, right? Right. But the guest's point was that if we are going to teach digital literacy, we should explicitly include that basic economic reality in our conversations with young people. Like explicitly telling them that the tool is designed to maximize your time on the tool. Exactly.

On the surface, that is practically conventional wisdom in 2026. We all know the scrolling algorithm on a social video app is engineered to keep your eyeballs glued to the screen to serve you more ads. All right, the endless scroll. But wait a second, I have to push back here. It's obvious that a scrolling app wants our attention, but are you really suggesting that tools meant for learning have that same underlying profit -driven motive to just keep us hooked? I know, it sounds a bit strange at first. I mean, think about classroom grading software or school -issued word processors.

A digital math worksheet isn't serving me targeted pop -up ads for sneakers. The economic incentive feels completely different. What's fascinating here is how that exact assumption, the idea that educational software operates on a totally different moral plane than social media, that is what cracked open Ackerman's epiphany. Oh, really? Yeah. Because you are correct that a classroom platform does not look or function like a social media feed, but the underlying architecture, the business model driving the corporate entity, It is structurally

identical. Structurally identical. So how does that work if there are no ads? Well, educational technology is not developed in a philanthropic vacuum. It is built by the exact same massive corporate entities that dominate the rest of the tech sector. So the product might be a cloud -based classroom instead of an infinite scroll of dance videos. But the financial metrics are the same. Exactly. The metric is ecosystem walk -in. Ecosystem walk -in. OK, explain that. When a tech company secures a contract with a massive public school district, their immediate goal is to make their specific suite of tools deeply

embedded into the daily workflow of every teacher, every administrator, every student. Ah, so the switching costs become astronomically high. Precisely. If a teacher builds five years of lesson plans exclusively inside one company's proprietary software and all the student data is siloed in that company's cloud, the district is essentially captive. Wow. So the more time the student spends clicking around inside that specific branded ecosystem, the more indispensable the platform

appears to the district administrators. Who are the ones writing the checks? Right. So the usage creates the data, the data creates the lock in, and the lock in secures the renewal contract. And that is what Ackerman realized listening to that radio guest. He realized with a shock that he spends his days advocating for tools built by entities whose primary directive is increased usage, not necessarily optimized human learning. That is a chilling realization for someone in his position. It really reframed a memory he had been carrying around for over a decade. He actually brings us back to 2015 in

his post. Right, the 2015 flashback. This serves as a vital pivot point, I think, in understanding how tech companies actually operationalize this lock -in. Yeah, he tells the story about a colleague from 2015 who is enthusiastically encouraging him to enroll in a program to become a quote unquote Google certified educator. And Ackerman's response was incredibly blunt. He basically told his colleague that he didn't need a technology corporation to tell him how to be a teacher. Which, as you can imagine, predictably did not

endear him to his colleague. Yeah, I can vividly picture that interaction in a school staff room. Ackerman probably came off as the stubborn old -school curmudgeon who just refuses to get with the times. Oh, absolutely. And he admits he has thought about that specific interaction repeatedly over the past 11 years. He's even posted about it on platforms like Mastodon and Blue Sky, right? Arguing that educators do not need tech companies certifying their pedagogy. But it was only after the radio broadcast about usage models that the actual danger of these corporate certifications

crystallized for him. So to fully grasp that danger, we kind of have to look at the historical timeline of educational technology. We do. Ackerman points out that in the early years of his career, the entire conversation in education was monopolized by a single logistical hurdle, which was access. Right. The overarching goal was simply getting a computer onto the desk of every single student. Right. The one to one laptop initiatives. I remember that school boards were laser focused on just the hardware procurement. And honestly, that

focus made sense at the time. I mean, you cannot teach digital literacy without digital tools. But Ackerman notes a critical flaw in that era. Educators and administrators spent so much energy trying to reach the summit of widespread device access. that they never developed a comprehensive pedagogical blueprint. They didn't know what to do once they got there. Exactly. They finally got the digital lumber delivered to the site, but there was no architect. Here's where it gets really interesting because nature and the free market absolutely abhor a vacuum. They really

do. The hardware vendors didn't just drop off the laptops and walk away. It is like getting your driver's ed certification exclusively from the Ford Motor Company. That is a great way to look at it. Right. Suddenly, your entire curriculum is about how to operate a Ford transmission, how to navigate the Ford dashboard, and how to troubleshoot Ford parts. You aren't really learning the universal laws of the road. Exactly. You are being trained as a specialized operator of one company's product. And worse, you start subconsciously

believing that Ford is the only vehicle that exists on the road. It completely narrows your fundamental worldview of what driving even is. If we connect this to the bigger picture, we see how the noble goal of providing access inadvertently created a massive vulnerability for corporate influence. To vacuum. Right. Into that pedagogical vacuum swooped the tech giants. Ackerman lists the major players explicitly in his post. Who are we talking about? Google, Apple, Microsoft, OpenAI, IBM, Meta, and Amazon Web Services. AWS. So the biggest companies on the planet. Yeah.

These massive conglomerates evolved beyond being mere hardware or software vendors. They developed official sounding educator and trainer programs. They began issuing certifications. Let's look at what that actually means in practice, because when a teacher becomes a, quote, certified educator by a massive cloud computing company, they aren't taking master classes in cognitive psychology. No, definitely not. They aren't learning about developmental milestones. They are taking exams on how to seamlessly integrate that specific

company's cloud storage, email clients, and AI grading tools into their daily classroom operations. And that shift from access to influence is profound. When a corporate entity writes the certification for an educator, they are quietly molding the foundational philosophy of education. To perfectly align with their product ecosystem. Exactly. They are redefining what it means to be a good teacher. That is wild. Under this model, a good teacher isn't necessarily one who fosters deep critical thinking or emotional resilience. A

good teacher is one who effectively maximizes the deployment of the tech company's software suite. It is a brilliant, almost invisible corporate takeover of pedagogy. And it's entirely disguised as professional development. It really is. The tech companies convinced the educational system to let the lumberyard write the building codes. And that realization is why Ackerman has shifted from writing mildly annoyed blog posts back in 2015. to sounding a blaring alarm in March of 2026. Right. This is no longer a philosophical

grievance for him about corporate overreach. He views it as an immediate compounding crisis. So let's talk about that crisis because he grounds this urgency in the daily realities of the educators he works with most closely, specifically middle school teachers. Right. And if you are listening to this and remembering your own middle school experience, you probably recall the sheer awkwardness, the social friction. Oh, yeah. It's a messy time. The messy process of just learning how to interact with other humans. Well, Ackerman points out that today teachers are having to actively engineer

activities just to force students to look away from screens and reconnect with one another. Basic human to human connection is becoming an unnatural state. It literally requires classroom intervention now. And layered on top of that social isolation is the absolute dominance of AI in how students complete their work. Akerman argues that we are facing a critical juncture here. He says we desperately need to, and I quote, disconnect from information and reconnect with concepts. Disconnect from information and reconnect

with concepts. Yeah. He acknowledges that the difference between raw information and conceptual understanding has always been a challenge in education. But the current technological landscape, specifically the proliferation of frictionless AI tools, has magnified the problem to an existential level. I want to read the specific language he uses near the end of his post because, well, he doesn't pull any punches here. He really goes for it. He warns that by accepting these corporate training modules, educators are getting certified to teach with products that, quote, can damage

young brains if we are not extremely careful. Yeah, he literally inserts a hard stop in the text right there. He tells a reader, stop, read that last paragraph again. And he ends with a plea asking, what are we doing? No, I have to step in and push back on that phrasing. OK, let's hear it. Because saying these products, quote, damage young brains sounds incredibly extreme. It's heavy language. It is. When I hear language like that, My first instinct is to group it in with historical moral panics. You know, it sounds

like the 1980s warning that sitting too close to the television will make you go blind. Or that reading comic books will rot your brain. Exactly. Is he just having a generational get off my lawn moment about a new technology he doesn't like? This raises an important question. And honestly, that initial skepticism is a vital filter to have. Right. We have to be careful not to just panic. Absolutely. If this warning were coming from an outsider who feels alienated by modern tools, we might easily dismiss it as leadite paranoia. But we have to factor in the

source's expertise here. Ackerman publishes academic work on data analytics and network security. He writes extensively about generative AI. So he is deeply literate in the underlying code of these tools. He is not afraid of complex systems. Exactly the opposite. He understands them at a granular level. So when a network security and data analytics expert who also has a decade of experience teaching middle school math uses the phrase damage young brains. He is not talking about like radiation from a screen? No, he is

talking about the physical biological reality of cognitive development. He is zeroing in on the neurological difference between accessing information and actually grasping a concept. Let's break down the mechanics of that because how does a digital tool actually stunt that development? We have to look at how learning physically happens in the brain. When a student is trying to grasp a complex mathematical concept or a scientific principle, they experience cognitive load. It's frustrating. It is. It requires trial, error, and struggle. But neurologically, that struggle

is the mechanism that builds and strengthens neural pathways. Oh, I see. It's a biological process called myelination. It's where the brain coats heavily used neural connections to make them faster and more efficient. So the friction of not knowing the answer and having to work to find it. That is what physically wires the brain to understand the concept. Yes, exactly. Now look at how corporate tech platforms, especially AI systems in 2026, are engineered. Their fundamental design philosophy is the complete elimination

of friction. Right. A successful tech product is one that anticipates your problem and delivers the solution instantly. seamlessly, with zero cognitive load on the user. Which is absolutely fantastic if I'm a 40 -year -old middle manager trying to rapidly format a quarterly earnings spreadsheet. Right, you don't need to build a neural pathway there, you just need the data formatted. But for a developing middle school brain, friction is not a bug in the system, it is the entire point of the system. If a highly efficient corporate designed AI platform does

the heavy lifting, if it balances the chemical equation or structures the argumentative essay, instantly the student is certainly accessing the information. But their brain never undergoes the productive struggle required to myelinate those neurons. They never actually grasp the underlying concept. It's like giving a teenager a helicopter to reach the summit of a mountain and then acting surprised when their leg muscles begin to atrophy. That's a perfect way to put it. The climb wasn't just a barrier to reaching the top. The climb was the exercise that built

the muscle. We're literally optimizing the struggle out of the classroom. And because the massive tech companies are the ones designing the educator certifications, they are the entities defining the metrics of success. Oh, man. So if a certified teacher is trained to view success through a corporate lens of efficiency, rapid completion, and high platform engagement. They are inadvertently bypassing the deeply inefficient, incredibly messy human process of conceptual learning. So the damage Ackerman warns about is the systematic atrophy of cognitive development. And it's all

disguised as technological progress. Yes. The tools have literally optimized the humanity and the biology right out of the learning process. And the companies building the helicopters are the ones writing the physical education curriculum. That captures the tragedy of the situation perfectly. I mean, we spent 10 hard years solving the hardware problem, getting the computers into the hands of the students. And in the subsequent decade, we blindly handed the keys to the curriculum. the very philosophy of how a human being learns.

We handed it over to Apple, Google, Microsoft, Meta, and OpenAI. We let the lumberyard design the house. So what does this all mean? If you are listening to this on your commute or while walking the dog, why does the history of EdTech certifications matter to your everyday life? It matters because these systems touch everything. Right. If you are a parent, This analysis fundamentally changes how you might view the shiny new apps, the dashboard portals, and the mandatory software your child's school district adopts. It forces

you to ask if a tool is facilitating learning or just facilitating usage. And if you are a student, it might make you deeply question whether that generative AI tool that makes your late night homework assignments effortless is actually a tool for growth. or a tool for cognitive bypass. Exactly. But even beyond the classroom, if you are an adult navigating a tech -heavy workplace, this deep dive is a stark reminder to recognize who is actually designing the digital infrastructure you rely on every single day. The platforms we use are never neutral. They carry the economic

imperatives and the philosophical biases of the corporations that built them. We are required to critically examine the underlying motives of the systems that structure our lives. I mean, we began this exploration with a simple observation from a public radio broadcast. Social media companies require your usage to survive. And we followed Dr. Ackerman as he courageously applied that same harsh economic lens to his own beloved field of educational technology, exposing the shared DNA between the platforms that distract us and

the platforms that are supposed to educate us. We tracked the historical pivot in 2015, observing how a desperate rush for classroom hardware created a vacuum. A vacuum that allowed corporate giants to quietly transition from selling devices to dictating pedagogy through branded educator certifications. And we finally confronted the very real stakes of 2026. We are looking at a landscape where the hyper -efficient delivery of information by AI is actively robbing developing brains of the productive struggle they need. The struggle

they need to form conceptual understanding, leaving educators desperately trying to piece basic human connection back together. It brings us right back to our original metaphor of the house. We now know that the lumber company should never be allowed to design the architectural blueprints. We see the conflict of interest clearly, but that leaves us with a deeply unsettling, lingering thought to chew on long after this audio stops playing. The vacuum is still there. Right. If we take Dr. Ackerman's urgent warning to heart, if we collectively decide to reject big -text

certifications, their proprietary training modules, and their frictionless ecosystems... Who should be defining digital literacy in the age of AI? Exactly. Identifying the problem is only the first step. Is it even functionally possible for our chronically underfunded educational systems to utilize these ubiquitous, incredibly powerful tools without quietly surrendering to the corporate values of the toolmakers? It's a massive challenge. If the tech giants don't write the building codes for the minds of the next generation, who will step up to do it? It's a heavy question, but

it is one we all need to start asking. Thanks for diving deep with us today.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 250: Changing Vision of Technology Literacy

    Nov 14, 202619 minAudio

    An AI-created episode based on a human-composed blog post: Changing Vision of Technology Literacy

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 249: The Inquiring Technologist: Why Great Solution Design Begins with "Too Many" Questions

    Oct 27, 20265 minAudio

    An AI-generated episode based on an AI-generated blog posts based on an old microblogging post: The Inquiring Technologist: Why Great Solution Design Begins with "Too Many" Questions

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 248: Gathering Organizational Intelligence for Network Security

    Oct 25, 202622 minAudio

    A brief AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Gathering Organizational Intelligence for Network Security

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 247: Models of Technology-Rich Teaching

    Oct 16, 202613 minAudio

    An AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Models of Technology-Rich Teaching

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 246: Concepts of Operating Systems

    Oct 11, 202621 minAudio

    An AI-generated episode based on a blog post designed for students in a community college course. Concepts of Operating Systems

    Credit the people on this episode