
234: Diversity of Instructional Design Models
An AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Diversity of Instructional Design Models
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

An AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Diversity of Instructional Design Models
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Imagine stepping into a Korean BBQ restaurant for the very first time. Oh, I love Korean BBQ. Right. It's great. But imagine you've only ever eaten at fast food drive -thrus your entire life. That's your only context for a restaurant. OK, yeah. That would be a serious culture shock. Exactly. So you sit down, and the waiter brings out these plates of raw meat, sets them on the table right in front of you, and just walks away. And you just. You freeze. You completely freeze. You have no idea you're supposed to cook it yourself. I mean, you're looking around for, like, a window
to pay at, a paper bag to grab, maybe a plastic straw for your drink. You're completely paralyzed because the environment doesn't match your invisible assumptions. Yes, exactly. And according to this August 2026 blog post we're looking at today, it's by Dr. Gary L. Ackerman titled Diversity of Instructional Design Models. This is exactly what happens to adults when they encounter a learning environment that doesn't fit their, you know, their rigid assumptions about how education is supposed to work. It's a really fantastic
analogy. So today's deep dive is going to completely dismantle that assumption. We're breaking down the hidden frameworks that dictate how information is actually structured for us to learn it. And I think it's a critical dismantling, too, because whether you're trying to acquire some complex new skill for your career or maybe you're suddenly tasked with Training a team of people at work right understanding the invisible architecture of how information is structured for human consumption is Honestly, it's an absolute superpower. It
really is It shifts you from being just this passive recipient of data to an active navigator of your own cognitive development And we really have the perfect guide for this today with dr. Ackerman's work I mean he writes over at hack science dot education and his credentials are They're no joke Not at all. He holds three degrees in education. He hosts the Coral Plus Classroom podcast, and he's authored books like Efficacious Educational Technology and the 2026 Creative Commons book, Concepts of School. Right. He has basically spent a lifetime analyzing the gears
and pulleys behind teaching, learning and technology. Yeah. So our mission today is to take his insights and completely shatter the illusion of what is often called the standard model of education. The standard model, yeah. We're going to unpack the three hidden frameworks that dictate how we learn, whether that's online, in person, or in hybrid environments. And we should probably start with why that Standard model illusion even exists in the first place. Yeah, let's get into that. Because Ackerman makes this really sharp observation about second career professionals.
He notes that when adults transition into teaching or corporate training, say they've spent 20 years as an engineer, an executive, or a programmer, they overwhelmingly bring this massive blind spot with them. Right. They just assume education simply looks one specific way. Exactly. They think that one way is a universal law. And that bias is incredibly pervasive, right? If you succeeded in your career by sitting in lecture halls, taking notes, passing multiple choice exams, you naturally equate that specific process with the only valid
path to success. Yeah. It's just human nature to do that. You assume your subject matter expertise automatically translates to instructional expertise. You think like, oh, I know the material, so I'll just stand at the front of the room and say out loud. Which is exactly the cognitive trap Ackerman points out. And what makes his August 2026 post so compelling is honestly his own humility in the face of all this complexity. Yeah, that stood out to me, too. I mean, despite his three degrees and decades in the field. He openly admits that he only recently discovered this foundational
text. It's the 2015 survey of instructional design models by Branch and Doucet, published on the AECT website. I found that detail so striking. A 2015 framework just sitting there for over a decade before a seasoned doctor of education stumbles across it. It really highlights a crucial reality about the landscape of learning. It's vast. And the science of how human beings encode and retrieve information is constantly evolving. Right. If an expert like Ackerman is still discovering decades -old blueprints that reframe his entire
understanding, I mean, we have to approach our own learning with that exact same humility. Absolutely. So if we look at that branch -induce framework, we have to start with the baseline that creates this bias in the first place. The model everyone thinks is the only model. Let's unpack the classroom -oriented model. Let's do it. Ackerman explains this is built on the assumption that students require direct instruction. The locus of control is entirely external. Right. The teacher is in the driver's seat. 100%. The teacher decides the curriculum, dictates the instructional plan,
curates every single piece of media, and holds the sole power of evaluation. It's an engineered bottleneck, essentially. The instructor... control the flow of information to ensure the learner only encounters very specific data at very specific times. But I want to challenge the utility of this a little bit because we hear relentlessly in modern discourse that the, you know, the sage on the stage approach is dead. Oh, you hear it all the time. We're constantly told education needs to be disruptive. It needs to be interactive,
student led. Setting up an authoritarian classroom where the student just sits and receives data feels, I don't know, entire outdated. It does get a terrible reputation. So is there actually a legitimate cognitive mechanism that makes this top -down model necessary today? Well, yes. It gets a bad rap because it's overused, sure, but the cognitive mechanism behind it is absolutely vital. It's all about managing cognitive load. Okay, cognitive load. Yeah. Think about your working memory as a highly limited processing
chip. If you're stepping into a domain where you have zero foundational schema, Let's say you're a new hire, trying to understand a company's labyrinthine proprietary compliance software. Ugh, the worst. Right. A totally student -led exploration will just crash your processing chip. You don't even have the vocabulary to form a useful question yet. So throwing Anomis into a sandbox and saying, discover it yourself, actually induces a kind of cognitive paralysis. Precisely. The working memory becomes totally overwhelmed by noise. So in that highly specific context,
the classroom -oriented model acts as an external hard drive. Oh, I like that analogy. Yeah. An expert instructor rigorously curates the media and strips away all the extraneous information. They deliver a linear sequence of data that allows your brain to safely construct those initial mental models without short -circuiting. Wow. It's highly efficient for transferring raw foundational vocabulary. That clarifies the mechanism perfectly. It's not about the classroom model being inherently bad. It's just a specialized tool for safely
onboarding novices without overwhelming their cognitive architecture. Exactly. It's scaffolding. But cognitive load management only gets you so far, right? I mean, once that foundational scaffolding is built, keeping the locus of control entirely external actually stunts development. Oh, absolutely. The brain needs to synthesize that data at some point. So how does Ackerman suggest bridging the gap when a learner actually needs to use the information? Well, that requires shifting the entire architecture to the second framework, the product -oriented model. The dynamic here
flips entirely because the objective is no longer retention. It's creation. Yeah. Ackerman notes this model is utilized when the primary assignment is making A thing. A tangible thing, yeah. And that thing can be a physical product, like architectural models, or a coded product, like a functioning app, or even a conceptual product, like a comprehensive go -to -market strategy for a startup. But the defining characteristic here, the mechanism that actually alters how the learner's brain engages with the task, is that the resulting product
must be of interest to someone outside of the classroom. So writing a 10 -page essay on market dynamics that your professor grades and then immediately throws in the recycling bin doesn't count? It absolutely does not count. Because when the audience is purely internal, just the teacher, the learner's brain optimizes for compliance. Oh, that makes so much sense. Right. You figure out what the teacher wants to hear, you write it down to get the grade, and you forget it immediately after the exam. I think we've all done that. Oh, countless times. But when you introduce an external audience, a real client, a community
organization, maybe a public user base, you trigger entirely different psychological levers. Like what? You introduce social accountability and authentic stakes. The dopamine loops associated with real -world feedback kick in. The brain actually stops optimizing for a letter grade and starts optimizing for genuine problem solving. And because the goal changes so drastically, the teacher's role has to mutate, right? Yeah, it has to, yeah. Ackerman explains that in a product -oriented model, the heavy lifting of
instruction happens completely upfront. The teacher supplies the cognitive resources, the theory, the safety briefings, the fundamental laws of physics or coding, and then they step back. Right. They transition from an instructor to a facilitator. They become like a guide on the side. Just watching the learner attempt to apply the theory to messy, unpredictable reality. But wait, doesn't making the teacher facilitator just give them an excuse to be lazy? How do you mean? Well, it sounds dangerously close to the instructor sitting at
their desk drinking coffee while the student founder's in the dark trying to build an app. How do you prevent this from becoming intellectual abandonment? That is actually the hardest part of this design. Being a true facilitator is infinitely more demanding than delivering a prepared lecture. Really? Oh yeah. When you lecture, you control the script entirely. When you facilitate, you have to react dynamically to 50 different students making 50 completely unique mistakes. Oh wow, I never thought about it like that. You aren't
abandoning them, you are actively monitoring their cognitive friction. You step in only when they're about to reinforce a catastrophic error, and you offer just enough guidance to help them troubleshoot their own way out of the problem. So you're forcing them to do the heavy lifting. Exactly. You are forcing their brains to build those neural pathways of synthesis and application. Okay, so we have... The classroom model for rapidly transferring foundational data, and we have the product model for forcing the synthesis of that data through authentic real -world stakes. Correct.
But a single product does not make a career. Building one functional app is a great module. But what if the goal isn't just an app? What if the goal is training an entire engineering department from scratch over several years? Well, that level of complexity demands the third framework Branche and Doucet outlined, the system -oriented model. And this one requires a massive shift in scale. Ackerman explains that the system -oriented model isn't about a single class. No, not at all. It places an individual course within a much longer, carefully orchestrated series of
courses where content continually builds upon itself over years. He uses the specific example of a comprehensive nursing program. Yeah, and the defining concept here is what Ackerman calls an extended problem. an extended problem. Right. The goal isn't just teaching human anatomy. The extended problem is transforming a novice off the street into a highly capable professional who can synthesize hundreds of variables to keep a human being alive in an intensive care unit. Geez. When you phrase it like that, the design
process sounds terrifying. It is deeply complex. This isn't an instructor putting together a syllabus on a Sunday night. The analogy that comes to mind isn't a teacher in a classroom. It's like urban planners designing a city's traffic grid for the next three decades. That is a perfect analogy. You have to predict exactly where the cognitive congestion will be three years from now based on the foundational streets you are paving today. That is a highly accurate way to visualize it. It's predictive cognitive architecture. Every single node and a system -oriented model
must support the nodes that follow. Right. If the instructional designers fail to properly construct the foundational chemistry node in year one, the clinical pharmacology node in year three experiences a catastrophic collapse. Because they don't have the foundation. Exactly. The blueprint has to account for space repetition, progressive overload, and the gradual evolution of a student's critical thinking over thousands of hours. This theoretical purity is just fascinating to analyze. We have these three clean distinct boxes. Classroom, product, and system. In theory,
yes. But in practice, you don't build a four -year educational traffic grid without hitting serious logistical and bureaucratic friction. How do these pristine models survive contact with the real world? Well, they survive through rigorous synthesis. Ackerman is adamant that instructional designers do not blindly pick one model and rigidly force an entire curriculum into it. It's not a one -size -fits -all. Not at all. The reality of coarse design is a constant, highly negotiated collaboration between instructional
designers and subject matter experts, or SMEs. Oh, I imagine those negotiations can get tense. You have an instructional designer who understands cognitive load theory, and they're sitting across the table from a subject matter expert like a veteran surgeon or a senior software architect. Oh, the friction is almost guaranteed. Yeah. SMEs suffer heavily from what's known as the curse of knowledge. The curse of knowledge. Because they have been experts for so long, they've entirely forgotten what it feels like to be a novice. They look at a syllabus, and their instinct is
to just dump every piece of nuanced, highly advanced information they know onto the learner immediately. Like, just tell them everything in a massive lecture. Back to the classroom model default. Precisely. The instructional designer's job is to act as a kind of cognitive defense attorney for the student. I love that phrase, cognitive defense attorney. They have to negotiate with the SME. breaking down that massive data dump and strategically distributing it across the models. And this is where Ackerman's ultimate synthesis comes into play. He points out that
a massive system -oriented project like our four -year nursing blueprint is never a monolith. No. When you examine the blueprint closely, you realize it's a master blend. It contains highly specific classroom -oriented modules nested right alongside product -oriented modules. It is a complete ecosystem. In year one of that nursing program, the instructional designer and the SME agreed to lean heavily on the classroom -oriented approach. Right, for the basics. Yeah, the students need direct instruction on cellular biology and
anatomy. The locus of control must be external because those novices need their cognitive load managed. But fast forward to year four and the environment has radically shifted. The students are in clinical rotations. They have the vocabulary now. Yes. So now they're placed squarely inside a product oriented module. The thing they're creating is a conceptual product, a comprehensive patient care plan. Exactly. And the stakes are as authentic as it gets because that plan is of vital interest to someone outside the classroom,
the patient and the attending physician and the instructor who lectured them in year one. is now the facilitator watching them work in year four, intervening only when a critical error is imminent. You move fluidly between the frameworks based entirely on the immediate cognitive needs of the learner at that specific moment in the system. Let's anchor this right here because this is the operational core of Ackerman's entire analysis. As we continue to develop new ways of teaching, whether purely digital, hybrid, or face -to -face, it is an undeniable scientifically
-backed reality that one single type of activity is never appropriate for all types of instruction. Never. There is no magic bullet. None. If you encounter a corporate training program or an online course that relies solely on one method, if it's nothing but 40 hours of lockdown video lectures, or conversely if it's nothing but unstructured group projects with zero foundational scaffolding, you're looking at a deeply flawed design. It fundamentally ignores the mechanical reality of how human beings encode, synthesize, and apply
complex information. We started this deep dive by confronting that fast -food drive -through assumption, the pervasive bias that learning only looks one way. We broke down Branch and Doucet's three orientations. The classroom, the product, and the system. We explored how the classroom -oriented model artificially manages cognitive load for novices. We analyzed how the product -oriented model... It's quite the journey.
It is. And ultimately, we saw how real world instructional designers have to act as cognitive defense attorneys, blending these models to survive the curse of knowledge. Which brings the lens directly back to your own intellectual life. Yes, exactly. You are navigating these invisible architectures every single time you attempt to acquire a new skill. The value of this knowledge isn't just theoretical, it's highly tactical for you. Tomorrow morning, when you open a new technical manual or log into an online certification
course, understanding these frameworks makes you a radically adaptable learner. You see the matrix. Right. When you hit a dense, top -down lecture series, you won't fight the format. You'll recognize it and say, oh, this is a classroom -oriented module. The designer is trying to manage my cognitive load and transfer raw vocabulary. You can then adapt your study habits to optimize for retention, knowing that the synthesis phase will come later. It grants you incredible agency. By making the invisible scaffolding visible, you regain control over your own cognitive development.
And honestly, There is a profound challenge hidden within Dr. Ackerman's post, for those of you who frequently engage in self -directed learning. A challenge to audit our own biases. Exactly. The next time you set out to master something complex entirely on your own, whether it's an advanced programming language or a new discipline like financial modeling, you need to interrogate your own structural choices. Are you defaulting to a passive classroom model for yourself merely because it feels safe? Are you just binge -watching tutorial videos and reading textbooks for months
without ever forcing yourself to synthesize that data? Stop just consuming the menu at the drive -through. If you want to truly master the material, you have to force your brain to adapt by designing a product -oriented experience for yourself. Yes, you have to build the kitchen. You have to take the terrifying step of creating a real product that matters to someone outside of your own isolated study bubble. A huge thank you to Dr. Gary L. Ackerman for the insights in his blog post, and thank you for joining us today. Keep learning, keep auditing how you learn, and
we will catch you on the next deep dive.
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
An AI-created episode based on a human-composed blog post: Changing Vision of Technology Literacy
An AI-generated episode based on an AI-generated blog posts based on an old microblogging post: The Inquiring Technologist: Why Great Solution Design Begins with "Too Many" Questions
A brief AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Gathering Organizational Intelligence for Network Security
An AI-generated episode based on a human-composed blog post: Models of Technology-Rich Teaching
An AI-generated episode based on a blog post designed for students in a community college course. Concepts of Operating Systems