Dr. Vernon Smith: You know the biggest criticism of higher education right now is - and it's been going on although, it's not true - but is it worth it? Is the juice worth the squeeze for getting a higher education? And the Fed has actually done studies on this and show that a high school degree will get you this much, a college degree will have a million dollars on average earning power after obtaining that. But there's so many areas out there saying, well, is it worth it?
Well, part of that is the sticker price. Although it's backed off in the last couple years, not outpacing inflation because inflation has been so high, frankly. The question is how can I afford and students get sticker shock and it is so expensive, even in state in residence, it's very expensive and that's hard on the pocketbook.
The things that you can do that are lower cost, but higher quality, and accessible that you have a pathway to do that, that really is something that I've always looked for. Sometimes we call it the iron triangle, right? Choose two, you can have high quality and high cost or high accessibility and high cost, you can't have all three, but I don't believe that. I believe that through creative thinking and innovation and technologies, you can do that.
Jared Taylor: Well, I also think families and communities really need to look at it because I got the MBA here and I think of total economic value.
Dr. Vernon Smith: Yes.
Jared Taylor: Because it's like the old Harvard professor president said, right? If you think college is expensive, try living without it. You lose when you choose, and so we tell our, a lot of our families, listen, 'yeah, you're going to be paying the tuition, but it's much cheaper.' So we talk about how it's definitely accessible and affordable through scholarships. But the real magic is if you get out a year or two earlier then you're avoiding about 30 to 40 to 50,000 of student loans.
You are pulling in your earning power, 50, 60, whatever your first year salary is one or two years. For some families, that's between a hundred and 200,000 of real economic value that they're pulling into their future, their children's future with this program, which is costing you roughly 5 to 7,000. And it doesn't take a math major to figure out that number works really well.
Dr. Vernon Smith: Yeah, especially in states where they're actually totally funding it. Which is interesting. I think Arizona has a really good model because there's skin in the game for the student.
If I were a board member of a K-12 system, one of the questions I would sincerely ask, 'what is our dual enrollment strategy?' Because, over the years, they've packaged and sold AP (advanced placement), which is like, I'm putting quotes here in the air, like 'college credit', but it's not college credit.
My kids were where they went to school in Virginia here. They had an international baccalaureate degree, which has some cachet with different institutions. But it's not college credit, they did have a few dual enrollment courses through the University of West Virginia.
I mean Virginia, and Laurel Ridge Community College, which is local and guess what was the biggest payoff? The college credit, so one of the questions if I were a policyman, at a state level I would say, what is our dual enrollment strategy as a state understanding the cost savings and as you said the total value of what that is and at the board level I would be asking, what is our dual enrollment strategy?
Then I would try to explain... for a lot of people, it almost becomes an ideology. They feel like it's part of their identity. I'm an AP teacher, well you can be an AP teacher and if you have the credentials, then you can become a college teacher or, I'm an international baccalaureate, we like that because we've always done things that way. That's another question if one of the answers when you have asked a question is, we've always done things that way. Maybe that's a time for an opportunity for innovation.
Jared Taylor: Well, I think US News and World Reports, top high schools in America do a huge disservice because its single metric is AP test completion and scores, which as you just mentioned, AP is the illusion of a credit. It's not a credit, right?
Dr. Vernon Smith: No.
Jared Taylor: But people want to be on that list so badly for marketing purposes that they’ll completely abandon a more effective approach. They put it out there as a token, claiming they have it, but it’s not integrated into their school processes or enrollment strategies. Families often don’t know the difference. That’s why policymakers should prioritize what benefits students in their economic futures—not just what’s good for marketing or the latest trend
Dr. Vernon Smith: U.S. News & World Report isn’t even a traditional news organization. That report is their main source of revenue. It’s unfortunate because, if they were more forward-thinking, they could add that metric and make it possible as a legitimate measurement.
Lindsey Lundeen Crosland: Since we're on the topic of dual enrollment, I’d like to highlight one benefit: getting a head start on college, or even earning an associate degree in high school, not only saves two years of tuition but provides students with more flexibility. For example, Jared mentioned that students can enter the workforce earlier, but many also gain breathing room—they’re not pressured to complete their bachelor’s degree within two years of high school graduation. Instead, they could study abroad for a semester, perhaps in a Spanish- or French-speaking country, to immerse themselves in the language.
One of our students, a first-generation graduate, earned his associate degree in high school, volunteered in Central or South America, then went on to medical school. This experience allowed him to work directly with patients, think beyond himself, and contribute to communities through volunteer work. Some students also serve on church missions or pursue other service opportunities, taking a break to apply their knowledge before continuing with their studies. I think this flexibility is a significant benefit, reducing the pressure to immediately complete a bachelor’s degree and enter the workforce.
Dr. Vernon Smith: I agree with you 100%. There are so many benefits. Students start to see themselves as college students; they get it—it’s not just that they’re doing something 'like college.' No, they are college students, with a transcript to show for it. They’ve made a commitment, and it’s not just about academics.
Jared, I’m not sure about the specifics, but other parts of Arizona are using career and technical education to advance students on similar pathways. Dual enrollment doesn’t have to be solely for academics; it can also support students moving into technical fields. For those not interested in a traditional college degree, dual enrollment provides an opportunity to pursue technical education and earn credits.
My goodness, I know my kids told me to stop saying this, but I keep repeating it: data science, data science, data science! There are so many data science jobs out there. My oldest, who’s studying chemistry and data science, will probably land his internship because of the data science skills, not the chemistry, which is strange. That career and technical path isn’t one people always think about, but it’s a viable pathway. Not all students are aiming for college, but, Lindsey, it gives them a buffer. It builds their confidence, provides them with foundational skills, and propels them forward. It’s truly a catalyst.
Jared Taylor: Well, I’m glad you brought that up because, as you know, the community college sector supports both the academic and vocational sides probably better than other alternatives for higher education. Dual enrollment options are available in both categories within the technical space. So, if we have listeners who are policymakers—like you mentioned, if you were on a governing board or a state policymaker—it’s important to strengthen those partnerships. Specifically, with the community colleges and high schools, because community colleges are closely connected to the trades and provide specific benefits to young people. And I think you know this—maybe not Vernon—but we opened a new charter school on the campus of the East Valley Institute of Technology
Dr. Vernon Smith: Oh, wow.
Jared Taylor: Yeah, they asked us, and you’re usually supposed to be offended when you’re the fourth person asked on a date, but initially, they had asked the district schools to come out and co-locate right on campus. And they were trying to bend the curve with the crisis in Arizona, with our youth and the foster system. There's roughly about 20,0000. And most of them end up on the streets, trafficked or dead. It is a major problem, really trying to solve it.
When they look at the data, the one thing that seems to bend the curve a little bit, it helps them not end up in those tragic situations is technical education and preparation because they have a job and therefore they can get housing and they could get going. But when you're in a program, that's all college-ready, which is important for some, but for some of them, it's hard. Anyway, they asked the districts and the districts were like, no. And they asked a bunch of charters and most of the charters they asked, we're just trying to figure out how to monetize it and get the foster money.
And they're like, no, so they came to us and I unpacked what we were doing with Rio Salado and your team, and they're like, wait, what, what are you doing? I said, Oh yeah, sister Joanie had taught us how to do a four year plan and then we can do that. So the package we present in this school is a high school diploma, college credits.
We have every single person eligible to teach it when they're ready. There's a lot of credit recovery going, but there's one or two that are taking college credit and then they're getting one or two industry certificates. And so the people that graduate from the school, Paul Revere Academy, are getting all three of those in one high school experience.
And we're in our second year, we're getting some data, and we're going to hopefully pilot test, refine it and then just share that data with other people in Arizona and the US to say, hey, this is a big issue. Not just in Arizona, here's one way that we're addressing it. I don't expect it to be a silver bullet, but we are seeing higher attendance rates in school.
We're seeing their GPAs go up, they’re getting them job placements. At our first graduation, we had nine graduates, there were I think three or four of them were youth that were experiencing foster care. And we had our keynote speaker from a large global construction company Sundt Construction. And he gave a great talk and he said, "I want to meet all of your welders because I have a job for them”.
Dr. Vernon Smith: Yes!
Jared Taylor: And I said come on over Clint. We're gonna show you all of our welders and these people are desperate for these types of workers and you should have seen their eyes because these youths bounced around. They just don't feel a lot of love or appreciation from the system. They just want to get out. And when they have an employer that comes and says, “Hey, what's your name? Can you come over? We'd love to have you on board”. They are blown away because no one's really there. It's always about how do we pass them along? Instead of how do we get you as part of our family.
Dr. Vernon Smith: I just love that you're talking not only about outcomes that are there, but our larger purpose in all this is transforming lives. I mean, not a lot of places can say that we literally transform the lives of individuals, families, and communities, but it's literally a transformation. And no, it's not a silver bullet, as you said, but, oh, my goodness. What a story.
Jared Taylor: That's awesome. It's fun. We're collecting the data. It's our 2nd year right now. We have about 40%, which is our target of the total enrollment with the youth in the foster system right now. So, it's fun, but that's why it's so important to kind of think outside of it, because most of these other schools that they were hoping, their first choices to the date, they just wanted to talk about the money, or they just wanted to say, no, just send them to art schools, and their schools aren't designed for, for these.
They weren't thinking innovatively, right? And that's one thing I so appreciate about you because you taught me, you got to think outside and when you do the world's an oyster, it's a blue sky. You're not competing with anybody because no one's there.
Dr. Vernon Smith: Finding a good partner is another crucial part, like Sister Joanie did with Xavier College Prep. Shout out to them! Organizations like Heritage Academy and Xavier College Prep might not seem like obvious partners, but the whole becomes greater than the sum of its parts. There's knowledge and tacit understanding being shared. I would have loved to have seen you two at that graduation ceremony, looking back and forth at each other and seeing the impact of the good work you've done.
Jared Taylor: It wouldn't have been a pretty picture because I had just ruptured my Achilles and had surgery. I was in a walker with a big boot. Still, it was a good moment in K-12 education for Arizona and the college - that nexus. When we think about innovation in K-12 and college education, we need to think outside the box, as you did years ago and continue to do.
We need to consider how we benefit society - it's really community development. While we're accountable for graduation rates, the bigger picture involves questions like: How do we bend the curve on student debt? How do we better serve foster youth? What resources do we have right here in our own state? Most states have what they need if they start thinking beyond their systems and vested interests, which are currently hindering both K-12 and higher education. When we prioritize these families and create new combinations, remarkable things can happen.
Dr. Vernon Smith: One of the terrible things about society we get in is what I like to call isomorphism. They did that here, we're going to do this here, but it's non-thinking, unintentional. If you're picking up a pattern, if you're doing things the way you're doing it, why? And it's that reflection of stepping back and saying, is this really accomplishing what we want to do? Just because someone else has done it, do we have to follow that same path? Boards and principals and leaders that are here, make that question.
I think we can - there's going to be something that comes up. Usually there's someone in your organization that has an answer and has thought about a better, more efficient, more effective way of doing things. Understanding what that is and bringing that out can make a huge difference.
Jared Taylor: And aren't you excited about what AI is going to do to education at all levels in the future? I mean, you touched on a couple of things, but...
Dr. Vernon Smith: Wow, you know, AI is - emerging technologies I've seen in my lifetime are the use of the worldwide web as part of the internet which caused the internet explosion of course, caused the dot com boom and everything else like that. But the level of impact - I don't think everyone understands how much AI is going to have an impact. I mean, I'm from the time when there were discussions of whether you should use a calculator in the classroom.
You know, maybe what would happen if you got out and you were on a desert island somewhere and you didn't have a calculator? How would you be able to do that? And it's like I was in Bolivia doing missionary service, visiting different Peru. And I went into a black market and picked up a calculator for 500 pesos, which is nothing. And I said, okay, they never sold me on that argument.
I think it's the same thing with AI now. AI, you won't be able to get rid of it. It's too useful as a tool. But it's how the strategies are used to harness it. And I'll say the sweet spot is not in the content creation because AI in these large language models, they go out and they learn it. And then you put your generative pre-trained transformer, your GPT on there, and you put these things that you can get content. The real question is how, as a teacher, are you going to use it for assessment? How are you going to do this? And so there's all of these concerns about, well, the student didn't write it.
Okay, yes, but how was it built into the process? How was AI used in the process? And how are you creating critical thinking, problem solving, oral and written communication, and working in diverse groups in the use of those tools? And it scares a lot of people right now, but it is so transformative.
I try to look at things in the future and I see - it's only been around since 2023 when ChatGPT came out, so we're almost down to 2024 and the amount of information and tools and other things - it's amazing. And so that's one of the challenges for the future is what is your intentionality around this?
And then how do you ensure integrity and quality for your students? I hear some stories from employers where they go through the process and they get to a point, and then they want to test folks and say, 'Let's test you on this.' And they're not able to do it because they haven't gotten mastery of what it is.
How do we create mastery in the world of AI and for learning so that you have masters that can critically think and solve tomorrow's problems because they're going to solve a lot of our problems. I'm very happy. But Jared, we're not going to tear out Achilles - we're going to have some medical models that will help us get better quicker and things like that. But we need folks to be able to think through it and use the tools correctly.
Jared Taylor: When I had my foot up, I was asking ChatGPT - I'm five weeks in, what's the best thing to do? And it was kicking out some info and it was very interesting, but you bring up an interesting point.
There was a really good policy document that was published by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints on AI, it's non-sectarian. And they just offered it up as the way that they're going to approach artificial intelligence. They said if anybody would like to adopt these guiding principles for their institution, they just offered it up. And it was very well done. It wasn't with the posture of 'we're worried about it, we're scared about it.' It was very much a forward AI type thinking and a tech-forward posture where let's look at it this way. When we do use AI, we encourage you to just disclose it and let's talk about it. Listeners that are listening to this - we'll link it into the show notes because I think it is a good first policy.
It's probably not perfect. It'll be refined by the church over the years, but if an institution is trying to get their arms around a policy document, we'll link that in and you should take a look at that as a way to form some good policy. When I think of how AI is going to impact education - number one, we're going to probably increase the divide of the learners because some learners are just more motivated than others.
Those that step into that beautiful blue sky space of self-learning are going to just go on a rocket ship of learning with artificial intelligence and learning models. But if an institution or a policymaker is looking at this, you gotta just deconstruct what education is. Education consists of parents and teachers and students.
What surrounds that student to help that student be successful and how can I support every step of that? How can they be a coach? How can they be a tutor, how can they be a teacher? Not to replace the important relationships, because I'm still a huge advocate of in-person teacher-student relationships. I don't know how you take that part of humanity away without a serious loss, but to augment.
Dr. Vernon Smith: That's sacred. The teacher-student relationship is sacred. I've heard so many technologists, I've heard folks - the creator of MOOCs made that statement. The teacher-student relationship is sacred.
Jared Taylor: Cute. That relationship can be enhanced in powerful ways with AI as a teammate, as some people like to say. World's an oyster.
Dr. Vernon Smith: Yeah, exactly. Another document - I'm glad you brought up that document from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Another document that's out there is from UNESCO. And it's just sort of a guide, an idea of the ethics of artificial intelligence. I'm going to actually compare and contrast the two and see, I bet there's some similar findings.
I think that's great to have these resources because now's the time where we need to be thinking about what is our intentionality? What are our ethics? What are our approaches as we move forward? The interesting thing about AI is we talk about the hype cycle. You have a hype cycle of things. It's super hyped, and then they go through the valley of disillusionment. Then actually something real comes out of it.
Everything's hyped. I was at a conference a couple of weeks ago and everything had AI in it, like it's a cereal box. Contains AI, right? But now's the time to think about how we use this and what our strategy is in implementing this technology. How are we going to use it as a tool rather than be the servant of the tool?
Jared Taylor: Well, I won't speak for Lindsey, but I do believe AI is going to be in the future of the American classroom in very important, powerful ways. So I, for one advocate, learn about it, try it. On my browser, I have three different AI tools. And when I want to get a question answered, I throw it in all three and I see what comes out of it.
Dr. Vernon Smith: That's see, it's a great brainstorming tool. If nothing else, it's a great brainstorming. I call it like loading up the cognitive domain. It just loads that up with so many things and it sparks different things and neural nets that way. It's great for that.
Lindsey Lundeen Crosland: We know AI is out there, right? We're recording this at the end of 2024, October 31st.
Dr. Vernon Smith: Happy Halloween!
Lindsey Crosland: Happy Halloween.
Dr. Vernon Smith: So we'll make sure.
Lindsey Lundeen Crosland: How have you seen schools using AI to create innovation in their programs?
Dr. Vernon Smith: Oh my goodness. I don't know a lot about K-12 because I just haven't been looking at it. I was doing a scholarship read through for the Rotary Club of Clark County, Virginia, and we give away three full scholarships to students. I was reading the essays - there were about 25 of them that students turned in and I could tell you exactly which ones were AI generated because I can tell that now. In the future, I don't think we'll be able to tell that, honestly. I think they're going to be so good that you won't be able to do that.
So part of this is a conversation. I think - I'm not answering your question exactly, but I think it's a conversation of how it's used and to give the permission for this and say, look, we're not going to do this in the closet. We're not going to just hide. If you use this - in fact, I'm going to build my assessment and my strategy around this. The first thing I want you to do is I want you to brainstorm your AI and then I want you to share with me your prompt that you wrote into the AI as the documentation, how you did this.
And then part of the question would be, how could you improve your prompt? What are you missing in doing this? And that becomes a shift right here. It's not punishing a student for using AI. It's punishing a student for not using it correctly or not using it to its full advantage and not thinking critically as it goes along.
Part of it would be how do you evaluate this answer compared to other things? What's its fidelity? It still has a problem. They call it 'hallucinations' - I'm doing quotes in the air again. It's just frank fabrication and lies that AI will do. Part of that is helping the students understand when things are being fabricated. When is it a hallucination? How can you check that? So information literacy and other things are really important.
What I'm seeing is many places - right now it's sort of, I use a Maslow's hierarchy. There's a very good group called WCET, it's the WICHE Cooperative Educational Technology. They're out of Denver, but they looked at what are the faculty concerns, what are the student concerns? It's mostly in higher ed, but the faculty immediately go to integrity. Are you going to write an essay that was written by someone else and you didn't really write it? That's the big concern. But I'll tell you right now, students are using it. Just like those essays that I read for the scholarship, they're using it. And I think one of the things we have to do is start becoming more transparent.
In how we use it. AI could be used for monitoring of large data. Institutions are using AI to help track and understand their student population, how to understand using the data and it's sort of like predictive modeling. How can we use an AI model to help us understand who's using the library and who's not using the library and how do we use the data sets around that? What predictability does that have for students? If we have a student that uses health services in higher education - but it could be other things in K-12 - what is the impact of band or athletics on our students? And what could we do to enhance that using this?
For students - my gosh, I would love to be a music teacher right now because I would be using AI to have students start composing and building things. But the part is how can you get them to understand the process, understand their prompts, understand what they did in that creative process to do that. Sorry, that's a rambling answer, but what would I do? I would play. And I think Jared has the right thing. What should schools be doing right now? They should be playing, but they should not be locking down things. Don't be too quick to say this can't happen and this can't happen because I promise there's sort of like an arms race.
Some folks will say, okay, we're going to use AI, we're going to build an AI detector and it's going to check for these things. And then there's another one that's made that beats that. And it's just like a continuous circle. It's an arms race. It's never ending. And one of the worst things you can have is a false positive - when you accuse someone of using AI when they didn't. And that is - because I don't trust any AI detector out there. I don't trust them because there's false positives.
Jared Taylor: Yeah.
Dr. Vernon Smith: These are just the issues. I'm scratching the surface of what it is.
Jared Taylor: I like what you're saying. I think I like how you led with ethics. Because that underpins all the disciplines, right? That was a big problem in the business schools that I come out of - it was all about the money. And then we got Enron and WorldCom because the ethical underlying in these business schools was just not there.
And now you see this renaissance of ethics and economics being taught together. You also talked about, get your brain wrapped around those underlying processes first and the structures, and then use AI to just amplify, magnify, and extend and expand the thinking. And so the human component almost leads to more effective AI use. And the people that'll just use AI lazily are probably going to be left behind a little bit.
Dr. Vernon Smith: Absolutely, I love - see Jared, that's, I love just watching you explore that and think through that because it just shows some of your depth of understanding of tackling a really complicated issue. It's going to affect all of our lives. I mean, it's in everything in the cars we drive, the phones we use, the clothes we wear. It's going to affect everything. So I love your thinking around that.
Jared Taylor: Well, Vernon. This has been a fun conversation. It's fun to catch up, and you're someone that is just fun to follow, and your career is - you got a huge runway, and it'll be fun to see, and if there's anybody listening that wants one of the greatest innovative minds out there, you better snatch him up now, because he's going to be off the market really quick.
Dr. Vernon Smith: I'm blushing, I'm blushing right here, you can see it on the screen.
Jared Taylor: No.
Dr. Vernon Smith: No. Right back at you Jared and Lindsey. Right back at you. I think you're doing great stuff. Every time I hear about the work you're doing and I listen to the podcast, it's like, ah, that's, that is such a great take on that. Wow. And then it always comes down to what are we teaching? What are we learning? What are the outcomes? Are we effective or not? And I just really appreciate that.
Jared Taylor: Well, thank you. And that's what we want to always finish in the American classroom. The idea is - it's really foggy right now. And I think with discussions like this and how there really needs to be a renaissance in the American classroom because like we were joking around before, it really is bringing the best of everything that the world has to offer, putting it together for the benefit of our society and the uplift of humanity.
I mean, that's - I know it seems like big lofty words and things, but that's what the American ideal has always been. And it's got to start at the kitchen table, but also the classroom. So thank you for being here today and thank you for sharing your ideas and wisdom and anything you want to leave us with.
Dr. Vernon Smith: No, thank you, Jared. Thank you, Lindsey. It's been a great conversation. And you know, as your listeners come in and listen to this, I would just say, if you like this, listen to the other episodes in the podcast, because there's some great ideas and some real strong thinking. So I really appreciate you inviting me here today. Thank you.
Lindsey Lundeen Crosland: Thanks, Dr. Smith. And we have - you mentioned EJ Anderson with Rio Salado, we actually have an episode with her that we can link down in the show notes, just specifically on dual enrollment.
Dr. Vernon Smith: Shout out to EJ Anderson, shout out to Royce Kinnison and the early days folks that were working on that. They really - it's because they care, they care about students and that's what it's all about. It's all about students.
Jared Taylor: If you like this episode, please like and share with someone that would find this interesting. We appreciate you listening to the American Classroom podcast today. Thank you.
Lindsey Lundeen Crosland: Thank you.