Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

American Classroom

American Classroom artwork

The Role of Music in Education with Jason Barney - (Part 2)

Aug 30, 202438 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

How is music education evolving - and why does it still matter? Jason Barney returns to American Classroom to explore the enduring value of music education in today’s rapidly changing world. From the classroom to the recording studio, he shares unique insights into how technology and AI are reshaping music and what that means for students and educators alike. Learn why preserving music programs is essential, how parents can nurture a love for music at home, and why the value of music goes far beyond academics. Whether you’re a teacher, parent, or lifelong music lover, this episode offers fresh perspective on supporting the arts in education. Resources mentioned in this episode: Gilbert Advocates for Music Education Judge Janice Brown's Article The Fortress Stone Sebelius Spitfire Circle Country Zia Records

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

Jared Taylor: Welcome back to American Classroom, where we're talking about music education with Jason Barney. I'm here with Lindsey Crosland who joined me in that interview, and we had a great time. He told us a little bit about his background. We're going to talk about the value of music in the American classroom, and maybe look forward to seeing how tech influences maybe the future of education.

So I hope you enjoy the episode, and here we go.

Jason Barney: Here's actually my story. I went to, I went to college, got my instrumental music degree, Then went on to work on a master's degree in music theory and composition. Somewhere in the middle there, I got a mortgage and, uh, and, and somewhere along the line, I accidentally started an internet company.

So it was a very, very fateful fork in the road for me in my life to where I. I had taught some band and I had taught for years and years, private piano lessons. So I had this huge opportunity to teach a lot of kids during that time. But then I kind of left and did some other things that I never left music.

I actually did when I was doing the dot com, I had to leave it for a little while because it took so much energy. But I remember when I finally pulled everything back out of the closet and got back into it.

Lindsey Crosland: So it was more on a, more on a private lesson basis.

Jason Barney: I definitely, During that time when I was doing the private lessons, now 30 years later, I'll have now grown adults in their 40s and 50s come back to me and say, hey, do you remember when you taught me? And, and, and, and here's what it did for me. And that was super inspiring.

But I've gone on to have a recording studio. and spent a lot of time in Music Reduction. Basically, a music producer is kind of a music teacher, Because I get these vocalists and performers and artists. Some of them are pretty young and unpolished, and some of them are very polished.

I will be on one side of the glass, and they'll be on the other side of the glass. I'm talking into a mic like this and I will say, I'll get into the technical domain. All right, you're pitchy. You got to do this. You got to do that. But then I'll get into the artistic domain of, okay, I need more emotion here. I need more inflection here.

And so that has been an incredibly rewarding thing to me because it results in, uh, musical outcomes that's now recorded and that you can go back and listen to. And it was high production values and, and I've had some really, really rich experiences in terms of using that venue, uh, to be able to lift people, but also to be able to give back to the community and to be able to have music be a part of the community conversation.

One of the things that I'm super, super proud of is Jared and I, and Bill Norton and Barb Stoll, remember that we are working on constitution week for years and years and years together. And, and I have just the, we all do have this deep drive to advocate for the constitution.

Talk about culturally, something important to say, and even more so today than ever, this thing to defend the constitution. Well, we all sat together for a long time trying to figure out how do you talk about the constitution in the form of music? And at the end of the day, we came up with the, basically an anthem to the constitution, a super awesome hype, high production value, orchestral Jordan Bluth thumb vocal, and it turned out to be today to this day, it's one of the things I'm most proud of what I've been able to be part of creating.

But you asked the question, how do we use music to uplift your question is probably more focused on the one on one basis, but that's something that I think focuses at a larger cultural level where music inspires emotionally, but music teaches music makes a statement music says in this particular case, the constitution matters and you better defend it or else.

Jared Taylor: Years, years after that was written, didn't the judge pick that up and use it in like a commencement speech, some of the lyrics or speech.

Jason Barney: Yeah, judge Janice Brown. And I think she went up all the way to the appeals court, uh, one of the circuit court court appeals or something. And so she was actually for a brief moment under consideration for the U S Supreme court. I think she might've at the time been, you know, that didn't pan out, but yeah, she, she wrote an entire commencement speech, a very beautiful academic dissertation based on the song that we wrote.

Jared Taylor: Yeah. You know, I think we'll link that in the show notes too, with the song.

Jason Barney: Yeah. That'd be great.

Jared Taylor: I'm glad you brought that up. I, I, I don't know how we forget. I forgot about that one, but that was a great memory, but I think one of your students is, or was an American Idol just this season.

Jason Barney: Um, she's somebody who I produced, McKenna Brinehold, so she's somebody who I've had in my studio a lot of times, done a lot of production.

I've actually had several people that have been either on American Idol or America's Got Talent that they kind of end up there, but McKenna, she just made it to what, number five or something before she hit the end of the line, but she did a fantastic job. It's a lot of fun.

Lindsey Crosland: So you said that music teaches.

And I think at the most fundamental. In education, right? We learn what's one of the first songs we learn, we learn our ABCs. So associating a rhyme, a song to something we need to learn. They might not understand what the ABCs are, um, but they understand, like they memorize through attaching it to a song.

And so I love that we can utilize, um, music as a teaching tool from like the very earliest stages.

Jason Barney: I believe that teaching music for the sake of music is foundational, critically important. It's like any other art form. We, we teach music because it has intrinsic value in and of itself. But there's all these other things that music can serve other purposes.

Uh, the right brain, left brain thing. You learn math better when you're also learning music at the same time. And then also very much what you're talking about at the young people level, the young child level or early childhood development, massive, massive power in, in music, being able to, you know, reinforce other, other learning and cognitive skills.

Jared Taylor: It seems like you can't have a podcast today if you don't talk about AI. So let's talk about AI and music and or music education.

Lindsey Crosland: We just went from ABCs to AI.

Jared Taylor: What initial thoughts on AI, both of you. I'd love to hear your initial thoughts on AI, Jason, let's just start with you. And what are you seeing right now?

Jason Barney: My personality is I've never been one to be afraid of new technology. I'm always an early adopter. I, I started a dot com before anybody knew what email was or what a website was.

Um, that's always been me. Um, even, even in fifth grade, um, I have these memories of me pulling apart boom boxes and guitar amps and different things. I tried to build a recording studio in my bedroom out of guitar amps and boom boxes.

So technology is, is I'm, I'm, I'm a technologist. I love it, but I'm also acutely aware, acutely aware of the dangers. Uh, social media is, is a prime example of that. Not that I, I was never like one of these passionate adopters of social media, but you know, I do it like everybody else, but I, I've seen how, you know, there's been some good that's come as social media, but just socially, just huge harm.

Harm to youth, uh, harm to. Harm to our political discourse. There's so many things where, you know, we've had some meltdown based on technology, but then on the other hand, you look at what we can do with technology that just never existed. Now let's apply that to AI and apply that to music. Well, first of all, look what technology has done for music.

Let's, before we get to AI, what has technology done for music over the past 20 years? Well, the fact that people can have more horsepower on a laptop in their bedroom to create massive orchestral masterpieces or pop song masterpieces or rock song masterpieces in a way that was just completely inaccessible.

Completely inaccessible 20 years ago. It's, it's phenomenal. And there's a whole other podcast that I can just talk to you about the lineage of how all this technology kind of evolved and came together and where we are and where we're at today. And it's just super awesome. Super cool. Uh, now AI, first of all, does anybody really quite yet even know what AI is?

I'm not totally sure that we do. We say it. But, but, but I remember when people didn't know what email was. I remember when people didn't know what a website was. And you would, I would try to explain what it could be and then I wasn't even totally getting it either until, you know, the thing evolved and now they're a staple of our life.

AI is a tool and a technology. It absolutely has great potential for danger. It actually has great potential for harm. It also, as a tool, it has great potential for utility and advancement and learning and growing and being able to be more productive. So I'm not afraid of it per se, but there's a huge amount of caution that I would certainly hope that, you know, that we would have.

Let me give you an example. Um, Apple Logic Pro is a piece of software that you can pay 300 for on. And once you pay the 300, you get it for life. It's, it's in perpetuity. Um, some of these great Grammy winning albums that are getting created by Jacob Collier and Billie Eilish and whatever, they were created with Apple Logic Pro and, and, and it is super powerful, super. Well, they just came out with the latest version here about a month ago. They now have an AI base player. So you just kind of, I don't even know. I haven't tried it yet, but you, you somehow kind of set it off in the right direction and it'll start playing the base for you and they have an AI keyboard player. So guys like me who are keyboard players, you know, what does that mean for us? I don't know. We'll find out. And for years, it's also had a pretty, I don't know if they called it an AI drummer, but it was something that where it could kind of intuitively kind of make, you know, drums and fills, drum, drum patterns and fills and things.

Um, does that replace the bass player and the keyboard player and mean that from now on, the, the whole idea of human creativity and human talent is out the window? I don't, I hope not. I mean, that's, that's part of the, that's part of the joy of music is that creative process. And I will tell you. If I, when I look at the music industry as it sits today, there's a percentage of it that supports the Taylor Swifts and the, you know, you know, the, that's just the, the a list top, you know, whatever, but there's this massive segment of the music industry that caters to people who will never be great, but there's so much passion in the creative process.

That they want that Logic Pro on their laptop in their bedroom to, to be able to create that. Um, can AI help enhance that experience for them? Help them learn what baselines really could be like so that they can learn how to do their own baselines? I, I think there's going to be a give and take in there.

Um, one of the things that I rely on now, Is, um, I like to orchestrate. I like to write orchestral pieces. Um, there's, there's software now that can, I can open up my notation software. I use Sibelius. Their finale is a really good one too, where I can put my notation in there and there's an AI algorithm called note performer that can go and read that and know, okay, I put a pianissimo here and a forte here, so let's get that violin to crescendo in just a certain way that responds in a more humanly, musical way. Is it truly humanly and perfect like a true orchestra would be? No, not at all. But is it a heck of a lot better than what we had a few years ago?

So it helps me visualize orally more effectively where this thing is going. And it, there's a new, a new feature that it came out where it, where it bridges that to these, these sample libraries, where somebody has recorded a full orchestra with London symphony orchestra and their studios.

And then another orchestra in the, in the Sony, you know, cinematic recording studio in Hollywood, where there's like live orchestras that got recorded every, every little note nuance of every violin and trombone and everything. Now this, this AI is bridging my Sibelius software notes. To that is that, I mean, this is powerful stuff.

This is, this is helping that now becomes a tool for young people to learn how to do orchestration that was unthinkable back when I first learned orchestration 30 years ago.

Jared Taylor: Yeah it seems like it's an amplifier of bad stuff if people want to use it for that. To your, to your earlier point, or maybe it'll amplify someone who's interested in music, but doesn't really know where to start.

And, but also those that are truly creative, they're in there. They may have a big theoretical background and it can take their unique abilities and creativity and just put them on a different level because they just have more access. I mean, it, it's going to be exciting to see what AI brings to, to music.

Jason Barney: If I was a 15 year old kid today, I would accelerate to my aspirations in music significantly faster. You said amplify, that's the word I would, uh, I would accelerate to my musical aspirations so much faster, not just because of AI, but because of technology in general, and then it's just, AI is just another layer on top of it.

Um, so I, I, it's a tool.

Lindsey Crosland: Oh, I just think as far as like integrity in the music industry, I think it'll be interesting. Right. I can tell. So AI to write me lyrics to a song about a particular topic to a certain tune, right? It will instantly create lyrics for me. Um, it can write compositions. So it's like, where, you know, where do we maintain that uniquely creative part of ourselves where we do the work and we create versus just turning it over to AI to fill those pieces.

But it does fill the gap for a lot of people who might not have all the resources. Say I write a piece and I want to know what it sounds like. Oh, let's bring in the bass. Let's bring in the keyboard. And now I can hear what my piece sounds like. Okay let me go, go back and redo it.

Versus if I don't pay the play, play the bass, play the keyboard. And I'd have to wait to hear what it sounded like, um, together. So it is, it's a great tool, but it'll be interesting to see like where the integral part of it lies.

Jason Barney: I have a hard time believing that I'm ever going to be truly deeply emotionally moved by an AI generated vocal. I just, I just don't see it. And there's a new software. I just tried out about three weeks ago. It's a AI vocal thing where you take. They've got this whole library of vocalists that kind of put their model in the system. And then you, you actually draw in MIDI notes, you can draw an inflections to make them crescendo and do this and do that.

You can shape the expression of it. Now I'm a, I'm a recording studio producer. I spent a bazillion hours in the recording studio with real vocalists with real talent saying, okay, give me some more inflection there. Fix your pitch right here. Give me more attack right there. More on that consonant there and, and have them deep dig deep in their soul and come out with something that's emotionally authentic and compelling.

So I know what it's like to do the real deal, but I also tried this, you know, goofy little AI thing and it didn't take very long. We're like, but, but you know, the technology is going to get better, but is it ever going to get to where it's going to be as compelling to me as the other, same thing goes for the orchestration, um, this stuff that I'm doing with no performer and AI and all that stuff.

You think I'm going to release that as quote unquote, my final master symphony? No, it's good. It's going to be a tool for me to make sure it's where I want it to be, but it, it won't be my master symphony until I've gone to a real orchestra, real human beings with real souls strike that bow. Hit that drum.

And that that's when it's real. So I don't see how AI replaces that.

Jared Taylor: It'll be interesting to see how, how that works. One of my hopes with AI and blockchain and even the legal environment is that it'll protect the creative, um, work of musicians and artists. And because it's, it's all going digital. So that's where blockchain has the ability to track it.

And so let's take a, a painting that an artist. If he sells it in the blockchain, he can write that contract so that every time it's, it's sold, he continues to get a commission off of that. Same thing with a musician and the legal environment is catching up to that because in the past creatives could sell their music once, and then the resale at Zia records or the other resale places.

You know, they never got any residuals, although that's their work. And now, you know, with iTunes, that, that was a big game changer. And what Taylor Swift did to change that, you know, they're, they're starting to get more of. Uh, you know, some, I guess it'll, I'm hoping the, the economics will help bolster the, the creatives and therefore they'll have a stronger impact on our culture as, as we kind of are looping back here a little bit, uh, because they, they're getting the resources that they've been deprived in when we cut education.

Or cut spending in education, um, music education in schools or culturally you don't see a lot of sustaining of, um, community theater or community arts programs because the economics are, are typically kind of wonky in that space. And maybe that, maybe that'll help change it. I don't know.

Jason Barney: And there's a whole other you know, sidebar we can get on the economics of music and maybe we'll hit some high level stuff.

But to your point about the blockchain and the licensing, this AI vocal software that I just did, I had to sign a license agreement that if I'm going to use, so this vocalist has one set of licensing terms, another vocalist has a different set in terms of where I can use them and what kind of context I could use.

And there is a compensation that rolls back. But, um, let me take that back a little bit. Um, I mentioned a minute ago, this thing where they, they go do what's called a sample library of an orchestra where they take the violins and they play every note, every inflection, every dynamic, and then they go through the whole orchestra, every trombone, trumpet, you know, mallet instrument, whatever.

You build this huge sample library. That now a producer like me can sit on my computer and say, play the violin note here at this volume and build a whole orchestration around that. A company called Spitfire, um, is really the leading library provider. Um, for the, for that kind of thing. There's some other good ones, but they did this thing where.

If we're going to do that, are we putting violin players out of work? Because now these samples are so dang good. We don't need to hire the violinist anymore. Well, truth be told, you still need the real violin player, but they did this thing where they would pay a royalty to whoever was in that session.

To create that sample library. Those musicians are getting a royalty every time that sample library gets sold. Now, how does that multiply over time? And does it really translate into real income for those musicians? I don't know, but, but the economics of, of music have changed dramatically. Uh, and, and probably not in the favor of the artists that are making me, certainly, you know, at the upper level, the Taylor Swift's of the world are.

Just insanely well compensated, but you get very much farther down. Yeah, there is no more money to be made on CDs because there are no more CDs and, you know, streaming and Spotify and all that, you know, pays the artists, a fraction of these things. So that, that begs a whole other question. And let's bring this back to, you know, we're talking about music in the schools.

Do you only teach things that have vocational value that can provide a student with a path to subsistence? Monetization, subsistence. Um, or is there, or is there educational value in teaching people that may or may not the monetizing value. Uh, the reality is there's a lot of people today who actually do make a good living in music.

I know some people who make a lot better living than I do in music, who are close personal friends. In fact, the guy who orchestrated Fortress Stone, he's one of those guys. He's, he's done, he's done very well for himself. Um, but, um, there's also a lot of people who they'll never really make any kind of real living at music.

But they sure as heck are going to make a life out of music and to make a life for their families and their communities and their church groups and, and.

Jared Taylor: Traditions and the culture that they build in their homes and family.

Jason Barney: So there is a place to, to make a living at music and there's a place that goes way beyond just the subsistence level.

Jared Taylor: Well, let's, let's, uh, talk about the home and the school and at least those that are just getting, if, if there's an individual, let's say, uh, a mom or a dad who has a young child. And they want to have their child have a good music experience, music education experience. Um, I'd like to talk a little bit about what advice would you give them to think about, um, or anything to add, you've already given some good tips, but anything else you would add.

And then I also want to talk a little bit about school leaders and give them some advice on music education, but let's start with the home in terms of building that up. You want to, do you want to start.

Lindsey Crosland: Um, I'm not an educated, I'm not a music teacher by education, right. Um, but from a very young age, I started, I would do a free like music time at our community center and I'd bring the shakers and I'd bring the music on my phone and I would play it.

And all the moms in the community who wanted to accomplish the free thing, bring their toddlers, you know, introducing our kids to tempo and beat. And songs and, um, you know, stomp and roar and do these things and move in a circle and dance. And so like introducing them to these concepts, um, and then, you know, just by listening and experiencing it.

And then of course it can happen in your own home. You know, you can sing to your child in the womb, you can play an instrument. Um, but then, yeah, like, you know, is it something that when everyone gets home from school at the end of the work day, um, I feel like I've always had music in my home. I played the piano a little bit.

I played the guitar a little bit. Um, and so I think, you know, parents can do that or just play music. I know some parents, I have a brother who's like, we don't sing. We're all terrible. We can't get the note right. But I've heard them sing and it's beautiful. And like, we're all blessed when we hear them, you know, and music in their home.

And so, um, anyway, I think even if someone's like, oh, I can't teach music in my home because I, you know, I'm not talented in these fields, I think we can still share it, you know, we can still sing along. Um, so I think, I think in the home, uh, if we're going to start there, I think just, I've had a good experience as a parent introducing my kids to music and they've seemed to love it and they'll, you know, play the recorder. My daughter is taking piano lessons. My son's taking piano lessons. Um, and I think that's just kind of the beginning. They're still young.

Jared Taylor: Home is the first and the best school ever. Always is. And everything else supports that. But how, what would you add?

Jason Barney: What I'd say is. Think about the life experiences of different parents and kind of think of different types of parents in terms of their knowledge and understanding of music specifically and how they can bring that into the home. You've got the super music nerd parents who hardcore background in music and, and they know exactly how to bring that music into the home and get the right teachers and get the right lessons and get the right practice discipline.

And get to the right, whatever. And, and they're playing the right music in, in, in the home and they're doing it. So that's awesome. But that statistically is, is definitely not the majority of the population. It's, it's quite rare. Then you got the next kind of group of parents who they got a pretty good understanding of music enough to be a really good influence.

They probably don't have all that rigor behind them to really get, you know, to the best of the best of the method of the path, but it's pretty good. But then you've got parents who they just don't know music because culturally music is always kind of getting pushed the edge of the education process, always getting pushed to the edge of the culture.

And so there's a lot of people who grew up to be parents and they just, they don't know it, but in their heart that they know, they know that they want their kids to know it. So the passion is there. The belief is there, but the skillset isn't quite there. So I was fortunate to have a grandpa who played saxophone taught me how to play.

That's great. But my dad. He loved music, but he wasn't very skilled as a cowboy Jim from rock on a ranch is his cousin. Jim's is great musician. Jim would tell the story of my dad growing up, how Jim could just play anything, do anything. He would try to teach my dad how to play bass lines. And my dad couldn't, couldn't get it.

And Jim's like, well, what's wrong with you? You can't, you just hear it. And my dad couldn't hear it, but now my dad's my dad. And I remember him trying to teach my brother and I how to play the guitar to the best he could. It just, and it was the same. He would try to teach us football and baseball. And it was kind of funny because he was so not an athlete, but, but he tried, wow, can you hold the ball like this?

And he did the same thing with the guitar. So, so the parents. If they have a passion for their kids and a belief that those kids need those deep principles to come from, not just music, but all the different parts of, you know, what a good education should be, they're going to do the best they can. But, but that's still not enough.

Those parents, if they're wise, will still figure out how to find a good teacher. And, and this is where I go back to how important that the school curriculums are. Make sure that their schools are, are dead serious about their music programs and, and preserving those music programs and growing those music programs.

And if they're not, think about maybe finding a school that is, because I, I had an experience probably, I don't know, 10 or 15 years ago where. In the Gilbert Public School District. Um, there was a real movement to just really concentrate just on the core, what they call the core STEM stuff, which I've mentioned earlier today, that I disagree with that philosophically, but there are people who believe that music is just incidental elective. Ancillary. Hobby. These are derogatory terms to me as in fighting works. Um, yeah. Um, and they were, they were actively trying to cut down the elementary music program, like significantly and that's a domino effect. You cut your elementary program. You just cut your junior high program. You cut your junior high program. You just cut your high school program.

And somewhere in the middle of that common core comes along. And now they got this like regulatory beast coming at them to, to further gut, kind of gut these other things that I view as foundational and core. I and some other people, we went hardcore trying to advocate passionately, passionately protect those music programs. Do not cut those music programs. Those are, those are foundational. And so sometimes. There, there, there could be a parent out there who doesn't know diddly dang about music, but he knows the importance of it and can be out there advocating to make sure that those local schools are making music an essential part of the curriculum.

Jared Taylor: I love to see the sports parents who their child has no interest in sports, right? They were the, they were the quarterback of the football team or whatever, you know, the, the moms, you know, the, the famous track athlete and their, their childhood, they have no interest in athletics and they're sitting there in the band concert, they look so uncomfortable, but they love the fact that they're making some sounds on the piano or it, you know, it happens a lot of time and, and I just commend them for keeping an open mind that, you know, not everybody's created equal in terms of their unique abilities and talents and the home, please.

Lindsey Crosland: Oh, I just, I love what you shared. I fall into that category that resonates with me where you talk about a parent who is like not super talented in music as me, um, but I feel like it's so important and foundational for children.

And so I think that's why I kind of brought up like free resources in the community, find ways to introduce music to your children. And then make sure you're shopping a school that has a good music program so that they can get those fundamentals, um, into their school and, you know, I'm grateful for people like you who do have a gate and go and fight for music programs in the schools because I feel like it's an essential part of their education for sure.

Jared Taylor: Yeah. And if you're a school leader that's struggling with your administration on, on preserving the arts, just know that there's people in your community that will advocate. There's people that will go to the school boards and and, and give your, um, give your, give your music program voice.

There's also people that will come into your schools and volunteer to do music programs. That happens all the time. Musicians have, um, an abiding passion for music and just get to know them. I know when I sat on the state board, we had the music standards, could the art standards come up? And that was one of the big things that I looked at when I looked at the standards, it says, don't, I wanted to make sure there were no fences is on the creativity.

Making sure that the music program, the music leaders, the arts leaders, the arts program, you know, they had a lot of latitude to change and move their programs to the best interests of their particular community. And so that's how we designed it from the state level. And I don't know what other states do that. That's just Arizona's standards is really, it was just trying to move people up levels and making sure they had broad exposure to various genres or themes within particular arts, um, in terms of trying to dictate, oh, this is what arts looks like in Arizona. Now, you know, we, we stepped way back from that. So the local communities could imprint what works for them.

Like one of, one of the schools that Heritage has in, in, um, Laveen it, most of our schools at, at Heritage Academy, we have dance, we have ballroom dance, but in Laveen that has a heavy Latino program, they have, uh, the Latin dance. And I can never say it right. So we'll have to put it in the show notes, but with the beautiful dresses and the, and the Southwest, um, Latino, um, tradition that they add to, which is great, they also started.

Um, uh, Spanish guitar, Latino guitar flavor to their guitar program, which was great. And, and school leaders should be, they should feel that they can, is that how you say it? I guess I think it is flamenco dancing. I think I always say flamingo, but that's not right. It doesn't do it justice. It's so beautiful.

They have a great time and it's, it's a lot of fun, but, um, Yeah. I'm with you, Jason. School leaders need to know that this is an important part of their program. Their community is behind them. It's supporting them. And, um, schools get too wrapped up in policy that focuses them on test scores or, um, jobs training, workforce development, which is also important at the expense of their arts programs.

And, but it's also at the expense of their learning, um, in their, in their school.

Jason Barney: We have a contradiction in our culture. That one side of the contradiction is that music and arts get marginalized. And the other side of the contradiction is that music and arts are foundational and central to everything that we do.

You think about how much music plays into our lives. We exercise to it. We worship to it. We party to it. We, it's our movies. Can imagine a movie without music. Imagine TV shows without music. You just go on and on. If you deleted music from our world, it's a, it's, it's a dry and bleak place. And, and so we, so there's this side of us that culturally it's everything to us.

It's, it's, it's a basic human hunger to us. But then there's this other thing where, um, music is this weird thing that a lot of people don't understand. So they're like pushing away. Um, you notice that there's like how many 8 is going at any given time about all the different sports, you know, commentary going on, you know, it's nine o'clock in the morning.

They're talking about so and so athlete did such and such a play four days ago and how do they have that for music? They don't have that for music. There, there's no like 24, seven hour commentary. Did you hear that Frank Shorin played the other night? Oh my gosh. Did you hear what he did to the Mahler too?

That was incredible.

Lindsey Crosland: You know, instant replay.

Jared Taylor: You know, the closest I ever found to that is you can get it on like Roku or your Amazon fire stick. There's a little channel called the circle. Have you ever watched that? No. All right. The circle and what it is, it's the Grand Ole Opry station. And so they have a lot of supplementary, uh, programming in there.

That's where they show the Grand Ole Opry shows, the live ones or the recorded ones. And they, but you're right there, they're hard to find and you don't see them a lot. Um, but, but we should.

Jason Barney: Kind of play the thought out. Part of that is just, I think, if you think different personalities connected, like I said earlier, that's, you know, some kids connect with music. Other kids connect with sports. There's nothing wrong with the fact that there's so much cultural interest in sports. In fact, my, my, my, my situation that I have a son who's like a hardcore in a sports knows every stat knows everything. He lost the lottery with his dad because just like those, you know, those, uh, Kids who have a passion for music, but their parents don't, don't know.

Well, this is the other way around for, for me. Um, sports are very important. They're very important part of our culture. They're very important part of our economy. There's so many reasons why that's important. So this is not this versus that, but I had an experience in high school. I was the drum major. I was, you know, we were doing our halftime show and, and we weren't done with our show and all of a sudden the football team kind of runs out in the middle of our show.

Like, you guys are supposed to be done. You know, it was an illustration of how music was viewed. And, and, and music is kind of marginalized. And I remember our band director, Phil Hattler, he went and rectified that situation with the coach. Oh, yes, he did. How did that go over? Well, it, there was a cultural shift at our school and, and I was, I was an absolute music nerd.

But I was unnerdy enough that I could actually go hang out with the jocks. And so I kind of went out of my way to be part of that. Hey, you know, guys that are on the football team, we're friends and we kind of helped shift that culture, but there's a thing going on in Salt Lake right now. You know, the, the hockey team's just moved to Salt Lake and there's this big conversation going on about, um, you know, where are we going to build that? The hockey stadium and how are we going to do this total redevelopment thing in the middle of the downtown and I remember my land developer. So I know all about all about land. You know how this works, but right on the primo primo corner of this whole thing where you got, you know, the delta center and all that, Abrovenal hall, the symphony hall.

This is so there was this big, you know, And it's starting to die down now, but there's this big, huge argument and debate, everybody, everybody's like, yeah, we'll just knock that thing over. We don't need that thing. So this is kind of like the, the metaphorical equivalent of the football team rushing out onto my, my marching band show right here.

Why, why don't we need a symphony hall? What's that all about? Just knock that thing over and we'll just put this hockey stadium right there across from Temple Square, uh, kitty corner. Uh, now since then, a lot of people come forward and really advocated for, um, how important music and, and, and the culture is in, in that part of the community and how as absolute need to be preserved.

But it's interesting that we had to have that conversation. It's interesting that we had to have that trauma, that us as people who, who love and advocate for music. And I've been to that hall, you know, so many times. I love the musical experiences that I've had there. And the fear that went through me when I heard that I might get knocked over for hockey stadium.

I like hockey too. My son in law is a big hockey fan up there. This is great. We'll go to the hockey game, but let's also go to the symphony, you know, the next night. But it's, it's an interesting thing that on the one hand, our culture marginalizes music in the arts. But on the other hand, we fully embrace it.

And what does that mean for education? It means that I come back to the importance of the music teacher. The music teacher is the final last stand in being that anchor for every next generation to, to be the ones who say, oh, you know what? That concert hall is important. Not only that, I go to that concert hall and I listened to the symphony orchestra there.

Lindsey Crosland: And we're taking a field trip there.

Jason Barney: You are

Lindsey Crosland: No, I'm saying like, and the music teacher and the music teacher is taking the students to that symphony hall to experience it and have moments like you had as a child at Gammage.

Jason Barney: Which is another one of those concert halls. And so, so that that's not a negative on sports and it's not even a negative on our culture, but it's an observation that says, We need, as a culture, with our music teachers and our music programs being the front line of it, to more deeply ingrain the intrinsic value of this.

Yes, we need it because the synapses and the right brain and the left brain and the tactile, we need all that. And learn math better. But music for the sake of music is intrinsically as valuable as math for the sake of math. It doesn't help, you know, our sewer lines work any better, but it helps our souls breathe more open and seem more open and have more joy.

Jared Taylor: I love that. I love that. Jason. Thank you for being here with us. This, this was great. It's, it's always fun to talk music with you and, and there's lots more to cover, but have a great day. Um, we appreciate the time that you spent with us and appreciate any listener who's, who's been with us and love to hear your comments and feedback on music education.

And if you'd like to hear Jason talk about some more, maybe we'll see if he can come back sometime and, and, um, and talk about some other things though. But thank you for that. And if you've enjoyed what you've heard today, please, uh, subscribe and follow and all those good things. It helps um, American classroom, get to more people and more people learn about the importance of music education.

So Jason, thank you very much. And Lindsay, it's always good to be here to talk about how we can strengthen, um, education and building American culture in our society today. Thank you very much.

Lindsey Crosland: Thank you.

Jared Taylor: Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Raising Children Who Value Learning | John and LaCinda Lewis

    Oct 27, 202650 minAudio

    How can parents help children value learning while giving them room to make mistakes? John and LaCinda Lewis join Jared Taylor and Lindsey Lundeen to share lessons from their own upbringing and from raising eight...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Parenting with Purpose: Helping Your Child Find Their Way with Joan Koplin

    Oct 13, 202654 minAudio

    How can parents encourage curiosity, responsibility, and a love of learning? Joan Ruth Koplin, author of 8 Timeless Parenting Principles and a mother of four sons, joins Jared Taylor and Lindsey Lundeen to explore the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Developing Student Athletes: Inside Elite Sports Academy

    Sep 8, 202638 minAudio

    Elite Sports Academy brings classroom learning, basketball training, and personal development into the same school day. Coaches Sean Greene and P.J. Howard join Jared Taylor to explain how they connect academic...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Teaching Virtue Through Art and Story

    Aug 25, 202638 minAudio

    Why do the creative arts still matter in K-12 education, especially in an age of artificial intelligence? Illustrator Josh Nelson joins Jared Taylor and Lindsey Crosland to explore how visual art can shape memory,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Everything You Do Teaches Something: A Principal’s Survival Guide

    Aug 4, 202657 minAudio

    What happens when hundreds of scholars arrive, the bell is minutes away, and the principal is responsible for everything? In this episode, Jared Taylor talks with Kim Ellsworth and Heidi Udall about the realities of...

    Credit the people on this episode