Edit: Since the recording of this interview many things have happened to René and the Artizen platform / community. René has suffered two strokes which has put his health at risk and has moved towards closing down Artizen. At the same time, he stated that matching funds that were promised through the application would not be going out and only the donations minus the endowment fee will be paid out. So far it seems that no one has been paid out, including my own project Bread Cooperative which had received donations. People are currently hurting over these events and legal action is being prepared by those who feel wronged. Meanwhile, my team at Bread Cooperative has been working on an alternative called Pastry. Using our stack, we hope to build something that is auditable, decentralized and learns the lessons of Artizen. I’m leaving this interview published as it for posterity. I will provide much more context and commentary in a later video. René Pinnell grew up in a family of artists who always needed a second job to pay for the work they cared about. He's spent his career trying to fix that, and his platform Artizen just closed a funding season with almost $7 million raised for projects in art, science and technology.We recorded this conversation at DWeb Camp 2026 outside Berlin. René talks about what he learned raising money in film and then in startups, and how Stripe shutting down his last company pushed him into crypto. He also explains Artizen's idea of making art the investable asset for any kind of project, and we get into whether that's the right way to fund culture when public money already pays for so much of it.René Pinnell is the founder of Artizen, a match funding platform for art, science and technology. He started out as a filmmaker and later ran Kaleidoscope, a company that funded and toured virtual reality projects. 0:00 Introduction1:36 Background & Origin of Artizen10:22 Running a Startup as Performance Art12:27 The ZIRP Era 25:44 Where Does the Funding Come From?32:19 Public Funding vs. the Investable Model49:23 A Pluralistic Approach to Funding Get full access to All Models Are Wrong at allmodelsarewrong.online/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hey all, this is a PSA. Since the recording of this interview that you're about to listen to, a lot has happened both to Rene and to Artisan. As you'll learn if you listen to the interview, was a fundraising platform that targeted the arts, sciences, and activism that also offered matching funds for people who gave donations. It also used identification in order to keep people engaged in the platform. Since the recording, Rene has reportedly had Two strokes in which he is now in
SPEAKER_02a critical health condition and I'm wishing him well for his recovery. At the same time, Rene has sent out a message that the matching funds that people were supposed to receive according to what the platform said and the donations that they received were not going to come because of his health condition and now there's a really big controversy because now people are not even sure if they're going to receive I have
SPEAKER_02a lot to say about this since my organization was also affected by this and we were also running around in order to support solidarity-focused projects. So I'll give my full thoughts in a following video once the dust settles a little bit more. I don't want to jump to any conclusions, but right now the situation is particularly bad And some have stated in some of these groups that I'm in that they also took out loans in order to donate to
SPEAKER_02the projects that they wanted to support.
SPEAKER_01This interview was perhaps the last interview that Rene gave
SPEAKER_02before his stroke. So I did want to release it for posterity and release it in full just more or less as it is. Of course, knowing the things that I know now, there are plenty of things that I wish I had asked. But of course, now there's not much I can do about that. If you are being affected right now by what is happening with Artisan, then please leave a comment and share. So now that I've said that, here is the full interview that I had with Rene during Dwebcamp 2026.
SPEAKER_00After years of being in the startup world, flash forward a little bit more, I realized that like, oh no, it's broken too. It's broken in different ways, but ways that rhyme. If you actually want to invest in a startup, you have to be an accredited investor, which means that only rich folks can like put money into startups. That's pretty fucked up. I'm running my company as my work of art now. I think of myself not as a CEO, but as an artist. And it is like a durational performance art. I'm coming down from the mountaintop. I'm Moses. I have the tablets. I'm the auteur. I'm the visionary. I know what this product needs to be. We just have to build it.
SPEAKER_00And that's totally the wrong way to build something. Why are we spending only 6% of global GDP on the engine of prosperity? All wealth, all the good shit we care about comes from art, science, and technology. We are dramatically under-allocating.
SPEAKER_01Hi, everyone. You're listening to the All Models Are Wrong podcast. I'm your host, Joshua Dávila, and we're here again at DWebCamp 2026, just outside Berlin, where I'm here now, this time with Rene Pinel, the founder of Artisan. So Artisan, in case you don't know, is a common and growing fundraising platform that uses a bunch of interesting... Crypto underneath, but it's really nice because you don't necessarily know that you're using crypto underneath it.
SPEAKER_01So, yeah, Rene, we've been hanging out at DwebCamp, out in the really nice tent that you guys have pitched out there. We're all doing a silent disco. But before we get into all that, I'd love if you can give us maybe a bit of an introduction to yourself and your background and what got you to start Artisan in the first place. Thanks for having me, Josh.
SPEAKER_00I've been obsessed with this idea of how to reinvent funding for art, science, technology for a really long time. And it came from my personal intimate relationship with the struggles of being a creative human. My mom is a jazz singer. My dad plays classical tar and is a novelist and My grandfather was a violinist. My grandmother was in the movies.
SPEAKER_00My great grandfather was a vaudevillian acrobat. My uncle was an amazing filmmaker in the 70s. He made two great movies that inspired Robert Redford to start Sundance. And so I grew up. Surrounded by people who had these wild ideas in their head and would struggle, these Herculean efforts to get these ideas out of their head and into the world and made. And it would always take money. It was so difficult to fund the work.
SPEAKER_00And it wasn't just my family, too. It was like everybody in our community who are also creative people, they just struggled with money. And you either would have to go, you know, work a straight job or you'd have to teach guitar lessons or, you know, maybe you could get like a university gig. But you're always doing something else to get the money to go do the thing that you really loved. And I just accepted that as the state of the world. I then... Got hooked by the filmmaking bug.
SPEAKER_00I was eight and became obsessed with animation. And I would stay in my bedroom until late at night making claymation animations with a stop motion, like Super 8 camera. Painstaking process. It was super, super tedious. But I loved the whole thing. And I loved that if I put... You know, gobs of effort into it that you get something magical on the other end. And it really is this addictive dopamine rush of creating something.
SPEAKER_00You know, you toil over it and then you put it out in the world. And when I was eight, it was my parents or my grandparents that would see it and you'd get this reaction. And so I, you know, I went to school for film when I graduated college. My first sort of professional thing was a couple of my friends were in a sketch comedy troupe and I said, we need to produce a TV pilot. I financed it on a credit card for $10,000. Some other friends and I managed to sell it to MTV and they paid us
SPEAKER_00to basically remake the pilot. They didn't pick it up for a season, but it was sort of the first... Okay, I'm out of college. It's no longer about just the craft. It's now about the business. I have to figure out how am I going to raise money? And film, like a lot of other creative disciplines, is really expensive, right? And even if you're not in a creatively expensive discipline, like if you're a writer, it doesn't cost much to write a book. It costs time. And so...
SPEAKER_00So that began this brutal training of figuring out how does the film industry work? How do you pitch to studios? How do you get a streaming service to pick up your show? How do you convince an investor to put money into your thing? And none of my friends had the stomach for it. And for whatever reason, I did. I was able to pick projects, either my own or my friends, that I had a fire in my belly for. That was so intense that I would suffer through the pain of going
SPEAKER_00through this fundraising process. And again, I sort of just accepted that as, okay, I guess this is just how the game is played. This is just what you have to do. Related to the story about me doing the MTV pilot, they didn't pick it up, but an internet startup did pick it up. This was 2007, 2006 when YouTube was sort of a thing. There was an internet, I mean, it was just becoming a thing, it's obviously a big thing now, but it wasn't the thing it is now. And there was a number of other startups that were well capitalized, that were trying to do video online. And one of them was called On Networks,
SPEAKER_00and their bet was we're gonna give micro budgets to people To make things that look like they could be on TV, but they'll cost like a fraction. Because digital cameras and equipment are making it much cheaper. Ultimately it was the wrong bet, like user generated content was the right bet. But that allowed me to continue making the sketch comedy show for a couple of years. But really what it did is it introduced me to startups. And I realized that, oh my God, there's this whole other universe of funding. And the creative process felt very similar to me. It's like you have a crazy idea, just like you do with a film.
SPEAKER_00You then have to assemble a team of talented people to make it with you. But unlike the film industry, which felt like an industry in decline, it felt like an industry that all the money connections and all the process of raising capital was really, really hidden. They didn't want to make it legible because there's just such a supply-demand imbalance there where there's so many people that want to go make movies. They almost purposely make it illegible. Only the people that have gotten in and have the right connections can actually raise capital.
SPEAKER_00Very different from the startup world in some ways, at least on the surface. There's all these resources where investors seem to want to take pitches from you. You could understand who the venture capitalists were. There's all this literature and things like accelerators that you could go through that would prime you. Very, very different from the world of film and art and entertainment. And so that first actually started to get my brain working like, oh, there's other ways to raise money. It doesn't have to necessarily be this way.
SPEAKER_00Look, these startup people, they're raising money in a way that feels much more logical, much more fair, much more open. Of course, after years of being in the startup world, flash forward a little bit more, I realized that like, oh no, it's broken too. It's broken in different ways, but ways that rhyme. We could talk about some of those, but things like it's highly exclusionary. If you actually want to invest in a startup, you have to be an accredited investor, which means that only rich folks can put money into startups. That's pretty fucked up. A lot of the openness that I thought was there isn't really there.
SPEAKER_00You really have to have a warm introduction from the right people. You have to mix in the right social circles. It's closed and gatekept in a way that's actually pretty similar to the entertainment industry. But it did get my mind thinking. Just realizing there was other models to do it with made me think, well, if there's other models, you could make new models. This is the thing that you can do. And ever since that little bit got flipped in my brain, that was the thing I couldn't really stop thinking about. And so when I went into startups,
SPEAKER_00You know, I did some startups that, you know, were sort of what you expect. They were like, you know, this is 2012 when I did my first one and sold it to a company. And it was in the social networking mobile base, like, you know, like check in Foursquare, that thing. And it was part of that thing. And it wasn't the thing I really cared about. It was sort of me doing pattern matching and being like, I think I think this is the idea that could be cool in this moment. It's not really what I want to do, but I want to learn how to do startups. I'm just going to do it. It wasn't my passion thing. But after that, when I did my next startup, it was like, that's the idea I want to go back to. I want to go back to figuring out how do I fund creativity in a different way?
SPEAKER_00And this was 2014. And this was right when... Virtual Reality was coming out, so maybe even 2013. And I was so excited by it because it was this new medium. And my heart was still very much in art and storytelling. And so I had a new thesis. I said, well, if I want to reinvent how the world funds creativity, Maybe a good laboratory would be a brand new medium like virtual reality.
SPEAKER_00It's a new industry that's just being born right now. I bet it would be more receptive to me experimenting with different models for raising capital for projects. And so that was a company called Kaleidoscope. Interrupt me if you don't want the mega long narrative. I'm very narrative based.
SPEAKER_01no, no, I think it's great. I think maybe one thing just to recap. So, you know, family of artists. Yes. You saw up close and personal the struggles with money when it comes to creation of art. Also, personally, because you wanted to, you were making film, saw how kind of... Maybe silly the model was in the entertainment industry as far as raising funds, saw the startup world as something that maybe made a little bit more sense, but then have later realized,
SPEAKER_01I guess, some of the downfalls and the pitfalls of startup fundraising, which I'm also finding myself as a startup founder. Which I think, I mean, in a sense, I think your art form has become perhaps, or I think of it as almost
SPEAKER_02like performance art.
SPEAKER_01That being an entrepreneur is actually just a performance artwork, which you're finding funding.
SPEAKER_00I think of running my company as my work of art now. I think of myself not as a CEO, but as an artist and it is like a durational performance art, creating, building, making this thing. And I try to run Artisan with the same compass. That I would have when I was making like a film, which is very, very intuition based in like startup land. It's so metric based. It's so like best practices based. It's so things that feel very cold. And for me, I've found,
SPEAKER_00I don't, you know, we'll see if it's like Bruce to be smart, but for me, the part of how I've been able to continue working on artisan day in and day out, grinding away and grinding away is I try to make everything creative. I try to, I try to take the same The same process that I would have for doing a work of art and apply that to running a business. And if nothing else, it makes it tolerable for me. So when I wake up in the morning, it's like, oh, I get to be creative. And how can I make this investor outreach email that I'm writing something that's fun and a little weird and a little off kilter?
SPEAKER_00How can I rethink how we do marketing? It's like everything I try to approach through the lens of this is a creative artistic expression.
SPEAKER_01Right. So I'm curious, I mean, you know, with your experience, so you've done a couple of startups. Yes. This is not your first one. So you kind of know how the game works, but I think at the same time, it's probably evolved quite a bit since, you know. The game is always changing. Yeah, it's always changing. It hasn't evolved quite a bit. And I wonder if, because I feel like you probably experienced the, in particular, like the Zerp era at the start, which I imagine like probably gave certain, you know, Are there any incorrect assumptions about how it would continue to exist?
SPEAKER_00Funding is always trend-based. It doesn't matter if you're doing startup funding or if you're doing research grants or if you're in the entertainment industry or the art world, there's always these trends. And the funding sources tie into these trends. And there's a lot of logic and reason for why that happens. And so to bring it back to my epic narrative, in 2013, 2014, one of the big trends was virtual reality, right? Yeah. And so this is a good thing for anyone who's watching this.
SPEAKER_00If you're raising money for a crazy idea, one of the things that you do need to be cognizant of is what are the trends? Because there's going to be pools of capital that you can go tackle if you can ride one of those waves. And so virtual reality was a wave and there was a lot of money sloshing around, which was also why I was like, okay, this is a moment where we can experiment with different ways to fund things because there's so much money sloshing around. And that's totally the wrong way to build something, almost always. I mean, every now and then maybe that's the right way,
SPEAKER_00but generally that's a terrible way to do it. And so this time around I wanted to do the polar opposite and I said, I don't know the solution to this problem. I know the problem that I want to solve is funding weird, crazy ideas. I don't know how to solve it. So why don't I just start by And so we started very basic, um,
SPEAKER_00Identify the talent. Who are people doing interesting things in this new medium? And we started in San Francisco at Mozilla headquarters doing these VR cinema meetups where it was like, is anybody in the world doing things that are looking at virtual reality through storytelling? And so the very first thing we did was like, well, let's do a traveling VR film festival. Let's find the best projects and let's just fucking put them in a U-Haul and drive around North America and Canada and do these pop-ups. And we did that.
SPEAKER_00And it was like by hook or crook, we got Samsung Gear to lend us all their headsets. They never got them back. You know, we almost got arrested going in and out of Canada because you have to have like something called a carne when you're doing like a large number of like things that could be expensive. You have to have documentation that says what it's for. And if you don't have it, they'll like confiscate it all. It was a total shit show. Very, very punk rock. But it started to prove that there was an audience for this stuff and that people were showing up to these events with curiosity
SPEAKER_00and other creators were like, I haven't thought about doing this, but now I'm thinking about doing it. And it felt like there was this moment where there was energy there. And we capitalized that energy and we said, okay, well, who's going to fund your next project? Let me help you fund your next project. And so we'd start to go to whoever, like a truffle pig looking for money. We'd sniff out, where are the pockets of money? And we'd go to all the brands that were wanting to be hip and showing they were forward-facing, future-forward, tech-forward companies. And we'd pitch them on, hey, you should sponsor this crazy art project.
SPEAKER_00And we're going to go do a festival circuit at Sundance or at Tribeca because they were starting to make room for these types of projects. So that was like one funding source. Okay, brands are willing to pay money, to put money into things. Another one was like tech companies. Meta, it wasn't called Meta then, called Facebook, have this new VR headset. You need amazing content. Like you should like put money into these projects. And by the way, we're talking to HTC too. Like, you know, do you want to be the exclusive one? So then you realize, okay, tech companies, they can put money in. And then you go to investors and you start to make the case like, okay, investors, like you should... Put money into this project because we're going to get well-known talent attached
SPEAKER_00and we're going to set up an LBE experience. We're going to charge tickets for it. We think we can bring money in. So you start pitching investors. And you do all that stuff and you start to realize patterns and you start to realize how do you need to package this stuff and you start to realize where the limits are, where the ceilings are. And we hit a ceiling, which is that when you go through these traditional funding paths, which ended up starting to look more and more like sort of the same funding path that you'd have in the traditional entertainment industry, it started to feel like, oh, this is... This is starting to calcify and become rigid in the way that more traditional industries get after a while.
SPEAKER_00And we realized that we couldn't get to anything that was scalable. None of that felt like this is going to change the world. It felt like we were turning into a studio. It felt like we were getting really good at packaging projects, selling them to people that would make sense to sell them to. But you could only do 10, maybe 20 of those projects a year. It wasn't enough. It was never going to change anything doing that. You'd make some great work, maybe, if you're lucky, but it wasn't changing the game. And so we started to think, what's a different game that we could play?
SPEAKER_00And that was when we first got the idea for community-funded grants. So we had all these creators that were sort of in our roster, and we were always looking And we were like, how do we get new talent on board at scale? How do we give them $5,000 to go prove that they can go do something before we get a budget together to raise a couple million to do a big thing with them? And so we started a grant program. We realized that grants are incredibly hard to manage. We were thinking grants would be an easy way to find new talent.
SPEAKER_00No, no, you get hundreds of applications. You've got to look through all those applications. You've got to make hopefully good judgments. And so we said, okay, interesting. People are very motivated for relatively small dollar grants. That was like a little bit of like, we got a little, I'm always looking for heat. When I'm building a product, I'm always looking, where's the heat? Follow the heat, find the heat, you know, fan that little flame into something bigger. And so we're like, okay, Small dollar grants. I wouldn't have expected that we'd have so much interest in small dollar grants. The second thing was like, okay, curation. Really, really hard to do. Party time.
SPEAKER_00Party time. The next thing that we tried was like, okay, if we don't have the time to do it, how do we get this community of creators that are sort of all around the company to do the curation for us? How do we hack together something in like a weekend that would allow them to start to review these and vote them up? And That was like a year of sort of like nights and weekends, just experimenting on the side, not really thinking this was the thing yet, but it was an interesting problem. And we ran a million different experiments, and most of them were like failures where the creators would get pissed.
SPEAKER_00You know, a project that they collectively thought was not a good one would win. It was just like clunky, you know, confusing. But little by little, you start to realize, how do you do community curation? And the next thing we realized was that like... If we're going to scale this grant program up, we can't cover the costs entirely ourselves. Like we can do a couple of these every month, but we can't do 10 every month. We can't do 100 every month. That was when we got the idea of like, well, what if people could contribute to these grants? What if it wasn't us just putting the money in? What if it was anybody can contribute to these grants?
SPEAKER_00And then... Those two ideas together were when I finally stepped back and was like, oh, fuck. I think this is the idea. This is the thing we've been waiting for. This is the idea that could maybe scale. And so we spun down the studio. We stopped doing these events that were sort of like paying all our bills. And we went all in on this idea of community-funded, community-curated grants. And we launched a product. It was still under the old name of this company, Kaleidoscope, that I've been running for years. And we had a killer first month.
SPEAKER_00Like it worked great the first cycle, like positive vibes. We'd gotten to like $20,000 in recurring donations to these grants in a month. That felt like really significant. It's like, oh, it's amazing. We can grow this. Like every month, $20,000 of like subscribers to these grants is coming in. We can build on this.
SPEAKER_01And I was texting- Was this just like traction from people who are- Interested in funding? It was small-dollar contributions to people that
SPEAKER_00gave a shit about the topic of the grant. So when you're part of a subculture, people love it so much. And VR at the time still is, probably even more so now. It was like a deep subculture. And so when we were doing these grants on like weird, immersive art stuff, people were excited about it. And they're like, yeah, I'll put in a hundred bucks. After we closed our first round, I was walking to the grocery store and I was texting a buddy of mine and I was like, we made it, dude, this is working. And literally the next thing I get is a ding from Stripe.
SPEAKER_00And they had fucking canceled us. Stripe is our payment processor. Great payment processor. But I later learned crowdfunding is a high-risk category in terms of payment processing. And why is it a high-risk category? You have higher rates of chargebacks than a general merchant. If you're running a mom-and-pop gift shop or something, chargebacks are Relatively low. And as a payment processor, chargebacks are like poison to you.
SPEAKER_00And it wasn't even a human in the loop. We had triggered some like small spike in chargebacks over the course of like three days. And it was just high enough to like trigger them having an automated like we're killing your account. And it was like a gut punch.
SPEAKER_01People tend to support a crowdfunding campaign and then like Or am I trying to pretend like I have traction in my campaign by donating to it and then going back on it?
SPEAKER_00Those two things, and part of it was our fault, too. So again, we've experimented with so many things, and the way that I experiment is by, I only learn through painful, real-world failure. And so whenever we do these things, we're always experimenting on things. And if we're lucky, some of the ideas will work and land and you'll get enough positive momentum that it doesn't blow the whole thing up. But almost always some things go sideways.
SPEAKER_00And one of the things that we had as a failure mode was it was winner-take-all grants. And so the projects that didn't end up winning the grant felt like... Burned a bit. And so their creator or their fans who had put money into their project to try to help them win the grant called up their credit card and was like, yo, I didn't make this charge. I don't want to do this. So it was like it was a game mechanic error on our end. And it was like Stripe just being like, you know, like we were so small. And again, there was it wasn't even like a judgment call.
SPEAKER_00It was just like you had like, you know, it was like three percent chargebacks in a 24 hour period. You're done. And and that was when two things happened. One, that was when I finally was like, OK, I'm going all in on crypto. And two is when I realized that this was the thing that I wanted to dedicate myself to. And so we spun down that company and we said, let's do this for real. Let's not have this duct tape experiment. Let's build it for real. Let's go raise some real money and let's try to build it the right way. And so that was 2008.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was 2020 when Stripe canceled us. And then we had like six months of sort of getting our shit together. And then we raised a small round to get going and started Artisan in 2021, February. And that was sort of the genesis of Artisan. I can talk a lot about what we have done since then, but it's really the same thing. Since 2021, we did about a year of just experiments. We didn't really call them seasons. It was just experimenting with more funding mechanisms,
SPEAKER_00and we awarded About $800,000 in those experiments. And then we moved over to the season idea where we fund projects on a seasonal cadence. And each season is basically an opportunity to rebuild the whole product and try a bunch of new ideas. And in season one, creators raised about $50,000. In season two, it was about $150,000. In season three, it was close to $500,000. In season four, it was about $800,000. In season five, it was $1.2 million. And in season six, which was just closed here at D-Web, It was almost $7 million.
SPEAKER_00It was just under $7 million raised. So we're still fucking up. We're still running into brick walls. But the key is that you have to run those experiments. And little by little, you start to realize where solid ground is and which foot you can pivot out with. Where do you have to anchor a foot and where can you pivot your other foot to try to find the next step to take?
SPEAKER_01Interesting. So a lot of this funding was coming from, was this a mix of just people supporting different campaigns? Or was it also investors putting in some money who just wanted to see the experimentation happening?
SPEAKER_00So basically the name of the game that we've had since the beginning is raise capital from investors. And I'm lucky that I have friends that believe in me and have put money in. I'm lucky that I've You know, gone through accelerators like Techstars that were super helpful. And so little by little, you build up a network and build up trust over many decades. And when you do a crazy idea, people are willing to throw some money in. So, you know, we raised, you know, basically I've been fundraising constantly my whole life. But for Artisan, it's like, you know, it's basically I'm always raising money for it. And we take the money that we raise from investors and we use that to run these experiments.
SPEAKER_00And all of our experiments have been some variant on match funding. That's the key idea. And even when we were doing grants before, it was really match funding grants. It's like us putting, well, it's not entirely true. In the beginning, it was just grants. But then when we got into this idea of community-funded grants, it was really turning into match funding. And this was when Vitalik and Glenn Weil and Kevin Owaki, who's one of our investors, were publishing all their work on quadratic funding. And it was sort of in the atmosphere. And And I was super inspired by it. So all these experiments were on the topic of match funding.
SPEAKER_00And the key there is like we take the investor money as a carrot, as an incentive, as sort of the start of the fire. And then you play different games where creators have to then go raise money from their own supporters to get access to that capital. So those fundraising numbers are always a blend between investor dollars that we've raised Um, and now sponsor dollars too. So we have, there's three categories of money. That's like investors put money into artisan, uh, uh, uh, sponsors put money into community funds and then fans,
SPEAKER_00uh, put money into creator projects. Um, and all three of those, uh, those flows of capital, you know, end up in the creator's pocket at the end of the day. Interesting. So then why,
SPEAKER_01um, Okay, so one thing that kind of like really, that stuck with me with what you were saying is you were talking about the beginning about trends. Yes. And like, I feel like there's... Is one of the problems also potentially in funding is this like trend following that is so common in investments?
SPEAKER_01And it also, I mean, trends are real. You need to show traction. Like I think it's like the seed of like wanting to see traction so I can trust that the thing that you are, that you are surfing a wave that I also need to get into so I get, you know, I get to ride it and, you know, go positive in the end.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah. Trends are real and it's good to be aware of them. But as a creative person, it is exhausting to, I think the best projects. And the ones that I'm most interested in and I think the world needs the most are the ones that are the projects that keep you up at night, that you just can't stop thinking about. And generally it's something that's very specific to who you are and your history and your interests.
SPEAKER_00But it's the thing that if you had a magic wand that you would go spend all of your time on. That's the thing that every creative human, whether they're in art or science or technology, that's the thing that they should be making. And the problem with having so much of the funding landscape be based on investors chasing trends, grant agencies having these requests for proposals on these topics that may or may not have anything to do with what you actually care And that's a huge amount of wasted energy. And maybe you can do it well enough to capitalize on it.
SPEAKER_00But ultimately, it's wasted energy, right? And that's my critique of all the existing funding infrastructure, whether you're talking about scientific research grants, you know, it's small,
SPEAKER_00deliberative, you know, bodies of like three to five people, highly risk averse.
SPEAKER_01You know, they have very- Especially I feel like in the film industry. I mean, yeah, how many superhero movies do we need? Apparently a couple every year or like 10
SPEAKER_00every year. How many sequels or whatever, you know, we need? All the established industries, you know, whenever you're dealing with a lot of capital, you get into risk management, right? And so when you're in the entertainment industry, you know, risk management is the lens that you're looking at that through, right? Like we are going to drop a couple hundred million dollars on this film. How do we manage Now, Venture Capital has the...
SPEAKER_00I think it's the best out of all the funding mechanisms at taking big swings at crazy ideas. At least a lot of them talk the game, say that that's the goal. In reality, I think the best ones do. The best ones do. Take big swings at crazy ideas that seem like bad ideas but actually turn out to be good ideas. Like that's how you get big outside returns. But the reality is that most investors aren't great investors and most investors will just be fast followers, tune into trends. And aren't really taking ideas seriously that are illegible.
SPEAKER_00And the most interesting ideas, the ones that are on the frontier, are illegible. They are almost impossible to understand. The ideas that I get most excited about are the radical ideas That are between two or three known nodes, but are in new territory that nobody really understands. When somebody pitches me a project and I don't get it, that's a good sign. I lean in, I get curious. I don't know what the fuck that is. I mean, so then...
SPEAKER_01Is it that when it comes to arts, I guess the thing that I would maybe be wary of is like whether or not the piece of art, like does that need to be investable?
SPEAKER_00Yes. To receive funding? Like what does that mean? No, I don't think it does. I think it does in one sense. And first of all, I want to clarify that artisan, one of our big, big, um, uh, Founding principles is it's not just for art. It's for art, science, technology, human creativity in the broadest sense. I think there's so much value that can be unlocked when you have a dancer now I see the news.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And so for Artisan, it's super important that we're building one game mechanic that works just as well
SPEAKER_00if you're doing a weird art project or if you're doing something that looks like a startup. And this does get back to your question about does it have to be investable? And so in startups, you have something that is investable, right? Like you have a structure, you buy shares in a company. If that company goes and makes a bunch of money or gets acquired or makes an IPO, you can see a return on investment. The one consistent thing, though, is that what projects will we be talking about in 10 years from now? How about 100 years from now, right? The ones that make a lot of money, sometimes we'll be talking about those in 10 years or 100 years.
SPEAKER_00But the consistent things are the ones that change the world are the ones that we'll be talking about, right? If a project, whether it makes money or not, changes the world, those are the ones that we'll remember. And if you have a big historical impact like that, if you change the way that people think about art, the way that we understand the universe through science, the way that we live our lives through technology, even if it's open source technology that makes no money, you've made a measurable impact. There's value created, right? And that tells me that You can always invest in something if there is real world impact.
SPEAKER_00And so one of the things that I've had a couple of light bulb moments in my life, and one of the big ones was being so frustrated with how a lot of things didn't look investable. There was just no way to get your money back. Um, that's one idea that was very frustrating. Um, like why the fuck can't we put money into a weird avant-garde art thing? Um, if people love it, like how do we, how do we not see a return on investment or like basic scientific research that, you know, is uncovering knowledge, but may have no commercial application ever, or maybe not for 50 years.
SPEAKER_00How do you see a return on that? Very frustrating. The other thing that was very frustrating is how exclusionary traditional investment landscape is, um, both from the perspective of, um, Someone who wants to invest in something, like you can't unless you make $250,000 a year or have over a million dollars in liquid assets. It's like the only way you can do it as an American. Might be different here in Germany. I don't know. Probably not. That's very frustrating. Feels very unfair. One market in the world has some properties that solve both those problems.
SPEAKER_00Art. Art. Art is the last unregulated great market. Anybody can buy art. There's very, very few rules for who is allowed to buy a work of art. That solves one problem. The other thing that it solves is that art has a magical property. Art is a way of putting a dollar value on impact. A work of art that changes how we think about the world, that has a group of people that deeply love it, that has stood the test of time, appreciates in value.
SPEAKER_00It appreciates in value in proportion to the cultural impact that that work of art had. Those two things together had a giant light bulb go over my head. What if we made works of art the investable asset in any kind of project? And that's what we do on Artisan. They always have to have an artifact.
SPEAKER_00And all an artifact is, under the hood, it's an open edition NFT. But we have guidelines. It has to be square. It can't have text or graphic overlays on it. It has to be an image, a GIF or a short movie that captures the spirit of your project. It has to And the bet, we'll see, this is sort of what I'm working on now, but it's been the vision for almost eight years now, is that
SPEAKER_00The projects that we end up funding, most of them will not change the world. If we're lucky, I think the top 5% maybe will, maybe just the top 1%. But those projects that do change the world, these artifacts will appreciate in value in proportion to that impact. And that gives people skin in the game. It gives them some mechanism that I can go back a project that makes no money, but maybe it solves peace in the Middle East. Maybe it changes how we think about
SPEAKER_00Maybe it changes how we generate electricity in some significant way and thus changes our whole lives. Those projects, that artifact, I would expect to be more valuable in the future. And if you back a project that happens to be one of those, it gives you some non-zero chance of seeing upside. And we want to build a lot of product around these artifacts to give them inherent utility, to give them reasons that you'd want to own them, We'll see these artifacts become valuable.
SPEAKER_00And if that happens, I think a bit will get flipped in people's brains. And right now people are backing projects because they love the creator and they know that if they give money to a creator on Artisan, it's gonna amplify their impact because they unlock match funding from these community funds and from the Artisan Endowment. They're primarily doing it today because they love the work and they wanna see their dollars have a maximal amount of impact. But I think as soon as we have at least one project that hits it big and we see an artifact that increases in value the same way we saw in the NFT mania, we have one example of that.
SPEAKER_00I think people will start to think about how they're giving differently. I think they'll start to think about it less as a donation and more as an investment, an investment in the world that we want to build together, the investment in the creators that we think are going to solve all the problems that we face. And when that flips, when that bit flips, I think the amount of money people are willing to give will be considerably more. If you stop looking at this as I'm giving money away, And more look at it as I'm planting seeds. And some of these seeds won't come up, but some of them will.
SPEAKER_00And I can potentially make more money investing in crazy, weird ideas at the frontier than I could anywhere else. If we can make that narrative a reality. And that's the vision. Every year, we spend about $7 trillion on human creativity. That's venture capital. That's philanthropy dollars. That's government and corporate R&D.
SPEAKER_00Right. Right. Right. Right. But if we can give capital, both people that are just normal folks, as well as big pools of capital, a reason to flow to the best projects in a way that's efficient, effective, fair, and you can see a return on that investment for the ideas that actually change
SPEAKER_00the world, then I think we can not only allocate that 7 trillion in a better way, but I think we can actually increase that slice of the pie. I don't know what that slice should be, but it should be bigger than 7 trillion.
SPEAKER_01Can I give one small pushback? Please! Just looking at it historically, I think a lot of the things that you're describing are also things that were funded by the states, funded by public institutions. At least here in Germany, I know, it's been cut like crazy over the years, the austerity measures. There has been historically and was a very big state public budget for arts funding.
SPEAKER_01Berlin is a major capital in the world for art. I would say 95% because there is just so much state State funding for the arts. Of course, it's getting worse and worse. The budget's getting slashed all the time. But there are an absurd amount of artists in Berlin. And I know many of them, it's because they receive public funding in one way or another. And the output or the return,
SPEAKER_01maybe at least in this case, is kind of like cultural production They're not necessarily getting a return, or at least, I don't know. They're making maybe a certain niche economically within the art space perhaps, but they're not getting necessarily The financial return. And then I think this maybe would extend as well with sciences. The states funded a lot. I think the NSF in the US, at least, they fund a lot of science.
SPEAKER_01They have a direct application to them that's known, they just do like foundational science that is good to know and maybe down the line the payout happens in like some discovery that is very useful for something. The state just is the entity that historically has had the capacity to be able to make this funding happen. I mean, I totally hear what you're saying. What's the pushback then?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I think it's just kind of the, is the right framework to think about these projects as investable or to expect that the, because like my input is money and that the output that I'm getting out of it is also money. More money perhaps because maybe the value of the NFTs go up.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think people are motivated by many different factors. So first of all, I want to say, whenever I meet anybody that's in sort of the, either, you know, on the funder side and public funding or on the side of creators that are chasing that public funding, I say, God bless you. We need more money going to art, science, technology. So however you can get the money, go get the money. Totally. Working in the government, allocating that money, God bless you. Do the best job you can. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00I also think it's highly inefficient and incredibly wasteful. I think the projects that get... Because I've been in it. I've seen how the decisions are made. They're made... And there's a logic to it. All the public funding that we got was because you'd become friends with the small group of people that were making these decisions. You go to the festivals, you hang out with them, you get drunk with them, you get high with them. You become friends. And then... And then you build trust. And then when they see your application, they're going to weight it more highly. That's fine.
SPEAKER_00It does work. But it also is not the most efficient way to get the best projects funded. It becomes a club. So I like that money is going to those projects. I think the projects they do fund are great, but it also very much ages out. Like the people that are making these funding decisions, they get their little cohort of friends and trusted colleagues and people that they love and then they retire at some point and there's a new wave. But in that interim... It can be very non-responsive to new movements. So huge amounts of critique to it. Totally, totally. It depends on what type of capital you are, right?
SPEAKER_00If you are a brand and you're wanting to put money into one of our community funds, you're doing that, you don't get anything back money. What you're doing it for is brand exposure and association with artists, scientists, technologists at the cutting edge. And hopefully you're selling something that those creators or their fans would want. That's why you'd sponsor one of these funds. If you are putting money into the endowment, Or investing in Artisan, you're gonna want a return. You're gonna want some chance of getting your money back.
SPEAKER_00If you are backing a creator as an individual, that's a whole spectrum. There's some people that will I mean, that's like all the backing that's happening right now on Artisan. Nobody thinks of Artisan and thinks of investment right now. I mean, my subscribers, they invest in me. Yeah, they invest in you because they, but you're doing it because you love the thing and you want to see the thing made. Sure. Definitely. You're leaving a lot of capital on the table. There's a lot of money out there, oceans of money. The world is, you know, drowning in money.
SPEAKER_00There's so much money out there. You need to give it a reason to flow to the most important things, right? And you need to just remove emotion from it. And if you're saying, the goal is right now we are not allocating enough capital to human creativity. If the thesis is, the source of wealth is creativity, and... All the problems that we face, whatever existential thing you're worried about, like, I believe every single problem is solvable if we apply enough human creativity at that problem, right?
SPEAKER_00And so if you say, okay, the question then is how do we... How do we hoover up as much money in the world as possible and then blast it out at these creators and do it in a way that hopefully the most talented creators, the most worthy projects are getting that capital? You have to start to speak to all the capital that exists out there, right? And at the end of the day, you have to compete on what's going to get a better, bigger return. And the only way I'm sure we don't have the solution figured out,
SPEAKER_00but I think the proper solution is one. So it has to be open. The other thing is that it has to work It has to work for projects that don't make money.
SPEAKER_00Right. Right. And again, to be clear, we have not really turned this side of the product on. This is the things I'm focusing on now.
SPEAKER_00Most of the product is about match funding and cash prizes and turning that into a game that's fun for people and creative. Sort of like it gives people an effective way of pulling in money from their backers and all that jazz. I don't think that's really the big idea. I think that's a good mechanism and I think there's always ways that you can improve on these ideas of how do you get different players to play a game that incentivizes Yeah, I think in the end of the day, it's, you know, it's a...
SPEAKER_01A mix of different types of institutions that can provide and coordinate different types of capital to flow in ways that, you know, produce a net positive in the world that is like, we can't just like, just one of these models is not going to like, we can't, we can't apply. You need a pluralistic, you need a pluralistic approach. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Love him. I was worried that he would think of us as a competitor. Very, very much inspired by Gitcoin. And we knew each other when we were both sort of starting. Gitcoin did amazing, still doing amazing things. Kevin's still pushing the project forward and doing super innovative things. And the whole time I was like, oh fuck, like I don't want to feel like this competitive energy with him because I love what he's doing and I hope he loves what I was doing too.
SPEAKER_00But I wasn't sure for a while and then we became friends over a while, you know, over many years of bumping up at each other at conferences and... The more I got to know Kevin, the more I realized his philosophy of pluralism. And it really changed how I think of everything, really. Like, I think whenever there's a problem, you want as many people tackling that problem as possible. And you know that a lot of those solutions aren't going to work. You know that some will, but not one will, right? Like, there's never going to be one solution. You're going to want many, many solutions.
SPEAKER_00And they'll address different flavors of that problem. And only with this pluralistic approach will you find the things that have the maximum... Amount of impact. That being said, I think whenever you're trying to solve a problem, A, you need to pick the right problem. You need to pick a problem that really, really, really matters. And you need to think of what's the most extreme example and case of that problem. And then that changes your thinking about the solution, right? I used to not know what money was. Coming from a family of artists, we don't like to talk about money. Money's kind of a gross topic. It's kind of taboo.
SPEAKER_00And I couldn't even comprehend a million dollars. How the fuck, you know, I had no way of knowing what a million dollars was. And then you start to do work in the world. And for me, it was like maybe that MTV pilot where I was like, oh, whoa, they just gave us a quarter of a million dollars. And I could sort of start to mentally do some gymnastics of like, well, it's four of my little TV pilots is a million bucks. Now I know what a million bucks is. I have some comparable that can give me some sense of scale. And the more I dealt with money and got to know money better and worked on bigger projects,
SPEAKER_00you can start to wrap your head around how much a dollar is, you know? And so you can start to see like, oh, okay, I've had friends now that have raised like, you know, 30, 40, 50 million dollars for stuff. And I can sort of see what they did with it. And I can sort of size that up. And I've had friends that have done things that are in like, you know, that are in the hundreds of millions. And then, you know, I know some people that have done some things that are sort of in the billions. And you can kind of start to see Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I think whether it's me working on Artisan or you working on your thing, you need to go to the nth degree, go to the final state. And for me, it was really sizing up how much money is being spent today. Clearly, it's not enough. And then going, oh, shit. OK, so if I'm going to even move the needle at all, this thing that I'm building has to be insanely big. Like, you know, the goal needs to be For us to be awarding trillions of dollars. And that changes your approach. It changes the energy you bring to it. It changes the kind of solutions that you're looking for. Yeah, and I encourage everyone to do that.
SPEAKER_00I think that's the right lens to look at the work you do is You need to have some path, some path to solve the true root cause. You probably won't get there. I probably won't get there. But unless you're aiming for the thing, you'll never get there. So you've got to really reach out to the most ambitious version of it and then have some step back. We have awarded $6.8 million in this season. What do we have to do in this next season to get to that number?
SPEAKER_00That big vision number, it's got to be a lot. It has to keep growing really fast or else I'll die well before we'll ever get to a scale that matters. It changes your perspective. And I think it's something that a lot of people would find value from going through that exercise and realizing like, oh shit, I need to rethink this. I need to think bigger and more ambitious if I'm actually going to solve the problem.
SPEAKER_01Sure. Last question, because dinner has started. Where should people go to find out more about Artisan and what types of projects should be applying to Artisan?
SPEAKER_00You can go to artisan.fund. That's spelled A-R-T-I-Z-E-N. It's like artisan, someone who works with their hands and is a craftsperson mixed with citizen, artisan. Fund, F-U-N-D. And we look for projects that no one else will fund. We have found a lot of success in backing work that is illegible and impossible to understand by traditional funding mechanisms and traditional funding apparatus and institutions.
SPEAKER_00If you've got a project that looks like something that a traditional funder would fund it, go fund it that way. If you've got a project that you love and you've got a fire in your belly and you've been telling people about forever and you've never been able to raise capital for it, but it's a thing that you love, that's the thing that we want to help you fund. Awesome. Rene Pinnell, thanks for coming on. Thank you, Josh.
Seth Frey studies how communities govern themselves. He’s a cognitive and computational social scientist at UC Davis. His work looks at online communities like subreddits and Minecraft servers as model systems for...
Wouter Tebbens has spent more than 20 years building open source and cooperative alternatives to big tech, including a cooperative cloud service in Barcelona and a member-owned alternative to Zoom. At DWeb Camp he...
Daniel Erasmus has spent about 25 years doing scenario planning for banks, governments and companies, and his starting point is that experts are bad at predicting the future. In 2006, a scenario he worked on helped one...
Brewster Kahle started planning the Internet Archive (creators of the Wayback Machine) in 1980 at the MIT AI lab, when he figured that machines worth talking to would need a library to learn from. Forty-six years later,...
I spoke to Yanis Varoufakis, economist and former Greek finance minister, at Web3 Summit in Berlin on June 18th, 2026, about why he thinks blockchain is one of the few tools left that can actually pull power away from...