Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Align Your Retirement

Align Your Retirement artwork

You Have Two Social Security Checks. Only One Should Wait Until 70

Sep 15, 202611 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail "Wait until 70 to claim Social Security" is the most repeated retirement advice on the internet. For a married woman who is the higher earner, it's only half right. It's right for one check in your household, wrong for the other, and it says nothing about the check one of you will eventually live on alone. In this episode, I walk through what I call the survivor lock-in. A married household gets two Social Security checks until the first death, and then it gets one, the larger of the two. That changes how each spouse should think about claiming. In this episode: Why the larger check is the "permanent" one and the smaller check is temporary What the higher earner's claiming age does to the survivor's income for life Why the lower earner's check often shouldn't wait until 70 Three situations where even the higher earner shouldn't wait The widow's two-check strategy: claim one benefit now and switch to the other later Three questions that simplify the whole decision, and three things to do this week Figures are illustrative, based on current Social Security rules and a full retirement age of 67. Related episodes: When to Claim Social Security: Why the Math Is Different for Women → https://alignyourretirement.buzzsprout.com/2591501/episodes/19196128 The Widow's Penalty: Why Taxes Rise After a Spouse Dies and How Roth Conversions Can Help → https://alignyourretirement.buzzsprout.com/2591501/episodes/19458008 The Cheapest Tax Years of Your Life: Roth Conversions Before Social Security Starts → https://alignyourretirement.buzzsprout.com/2591501/episodes/19509570 Mentioned in this episode: The Executive Woman's Tax Playbook (free guide) → https://alignfinancialsolutions.com/retirement-tax-playbook/ 📝 Free Retirement Readiness Assessment → https://alignfinancialsolutions.com/retirement-readiness-assessment 📞 Book a free Align Call → https://calendly.com/alignfinancialsolutions/align-call?utm_source=podcast Follow the Conversation: LinkedIn: https://linkedin.com/in/hazel-secco Instagram: https://instagram.com/alignfinancialsolutions About Hazel Secco, CFP®, CDFA® Hazel Secco, CFP®, CDFA®, is the founder of Align Financial Solutions, a fee-only fiduciary firm in Hoboken, New Jersey, that helps high-net-worth women bring retirement, equity compensation, tax, and estate planning into one plan. Disclaimer: All content in this podcast is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute individual investment, legal, or tax advice. Investing involves risk. Always consult with a qualified professional regarding your specific situation. The above case study is hypothetical and does not involve an actual Align Financial Solutions client. No portion of the content should be construed by a client or prospective client as a guarantee that he/she will experience the same or certain level of results or satisfaction if A...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hey, welcome back to Align Your Retirement. I'm Hazel Secko, CFP and CDFA, founder of Aligned Financial Solutions, a fee-only fiduciary financial planning firm for executive women. Today, we're taking on the most repeated piece of retirement advice on the internet. Wait until 70 to claim social security. And I'm going to show you why, for a hiring woman, that advice is only half right. Write for one check in your household, wrong for the other, and silent about the one thing that matters most, the check somebody is going to live on alone.

SPEAKER_00Let's get into it. I want to start with a sentence itself because you can probably recite it. Delay Social Security until 70, your benefit grows 8% a year. That sentence is true, and it was popularized for a household with a particular shape, a husband with the big earnings record, a wife with a small one, and advice aimed at him. Here's what happens when the woman listening is the one with the big record, which for this audience, she very often is. She's been the higher earner for a decade or three.

SPEAKER_00She's the household CFO, and every claiming video she watches is quietly talking about somebody else's marriage. So today I want to redrive the rule for your household. And to do that, I need to tell you the one fact that the wait until 70 crowd and the claim at 62, get your money crowd, both skip. Social Security pays a married household two checks until the first death, then it pays one. The survivor keeps a larger check and loses the smaller one.

SPEAKER_00Which means that the higher earner's claiming age isn't really a decision about her 60s. It's the number that gets locked in for whoever is still standing at 85, 90, 95. And statistically, in most marriages, the one still standing is her. I call it the survivor lock-in. And once you see it, the whole claiming question reorganizes. Now, grab something to write on. The frame. Two checks become one. And it's the whole episode in one image.

SPEAKER_00A married couple claims two benefits. At the first death, the household doesn't keep both and doesn't average them. The survivor receives the larger of the two. And the smaller one stops forever. Follow the logic where it leads. The smaller check is temporary. It only pays out while both of you are alive. The larger check is permanent. Someone collects it until the second death, which for a healthy couple can be 30 plus years away. So the two checks deserve completely different strategies. The temporary check should usually be taken early and enjoyed, and the permanent check is the one worth growing.

SPEAKER_00Wait until 70. Always advice about the permanent check. The mistake is applying to both of them or to the wrong one. So the first question in any claiming conversation isn't when should I claim? It's which check am I? Part one. If you're the higher earner, your date is the survivor's income. If you're the higher earner, and in this audience, that's often exactly who's watching, your benefit is the permanent check. Here's what your claiming age does to it. Using today's rules for someone with a full retirement age of 67, claim at 62, and the check is reduced by about 30% for life.

SPEAKER_00Wait to 70 and it grows by 24% above your full amount, plus every cost of living adjustment compounds on that bigger base. Put illustrative numbers on it. Say your full retirement age benefit is$3,600 a month, a strong earnings record. At 62, that's roughly$2,520. At$70, it's roughly$4,460. That's not a$150 difference. It's about$1,900 a month every month for as long as either of you is alive. If you go first, your survivor steps into your check, delayed credits included, across a 25 or 30-year tale before coloss, the gap between those two paths runs deep into six figures.

SPEAKER_00And here's the part that makes this doubly true for women. You're not just setting the survivor's income, you're probably setting your own. Women outlive men in most marriages, and healthy higher earning women outlive the averages. The person most likely to be living on this locked-in check at 92 is you. Delaying the permanent check is in frugality theater. It's the cheapest longevity insurance you can buy. The longevity discount episode, running in reverse. Which brings us to the advice nobody gives because it sounds almost irresponsible.

SPEAKER_00The other check probably shouldn't wait. Part two. The lower earner's check usually shouldn't wait until 70. Run the same logic on the smaller benefit. Often in this audience, the husband. His check only pays while you're both alive. At the first death, it vanishes no matter what age it claimed. Delaying it to 70 buys an 8% a year increase on a check with a short expected lifespan. The reward for waiting is structurally smaller, and the cost of waiting is real money not flowing in your 60s. The go-go years, when the spending actually happens.

SPEAKER_00So the standard coordination for a couple where she's the higher earner often looks like this. His smaller benefit starts early, 62 to 65, and funds life now. Her larger benefit weights growing 8% a year, locking in the maximum permanent check for whoever needs it longest. Notice what that does to the generic advice. Wait until 70 and claim early are both right for different checks in the same household. The couples who get this wrong usually get it wrong symmetrically. Both wait and live thinner 60s than they needed to, or both claim early and lock the survivor into a reduced check for decades.

SPEAKER_00One more wrinkle worth naming. If the higher earner claims very early, the survivor's check can be capped at a reduced level permanently. The rules have a floor, but early claiming by the permanent check spouse genuinely damages what the survivor can ever receive. It's the sharpest version of the lock-in and it's invisible until someone dies. Before we get to the exceptions, one thing. This claiming decision doesn't sit alone. It connects straight to the bridge years and the widow's penalty math. And both of those are in my free executive woman's tax playbook linked below.

SPEAKER_00It's the seven tax moves that matter most before retirement. Grab it now so the claiming date and the tax plan come together, not separately. Okay, the exceptions. Now, the titles promise because there are situations where even the higher earner shouldn't wait. Three of them. Part three. When not to wait until 70. Even as the higher earner. Situation one, you're single and your health picture honestly argues a shorter horizon. The survivor logic runs on two lives. Single, your claim is priced on one. Delaying is still powerful insurance against a long life. And healthy women should be careful not to talk themselves out of it.

SPEAKER_00But with a serious diagnosis or strong family history signal, the break-even math deserves an honest run instead of a slogan. This is a modeling conversation, not a rule. Situation two: waiting would force damaging portfolio withdrawals. Delaying to 70 means your portfolio carries the load in the meantime. The bridge years. For most women in this audience, that bridge is affordable and even useful. Low income bridge years are exactly when the Roth conversion window is widest, which is why delay and conversion so often travel together.

SPEAKER_00But if funding the bridge means selling heavily in a down market, sequence return doing real damage, or living a pinched version of your go-go years. A middle claiming age can beat a perfect 70. The optimal claim on paper isn't optimal if the path to it breaks the plan. Model the bridge before you commit to it. Situation three, you're a widow. Because you have a two-check strategy almost nobody tells you about. A widow can claim a survivor benefit as early as 60 and later switch to her own benefit at 70. Or take her own reduced benefit first and switch to the survivor benefit at its maximum.

SPEAKER_00One check funds the near years while the other grows untouched. It's one of the only claim now and switch later strategies left in the system. It can be worth six figures, and the default at the Social Security office is not guaranteed to be your best sequence. If you're widowed, do not claim anything before this exact sequencing has been modeled. This pairs directly with our widow's penalty episodes, which cover the tax side of the same season of life. And if you just heard those three and thought, I don't know which one applies to me. That's exactly what a call is for.

SPEAKER_00Bring both benefit estimates, yours and your spouses, and I'll run them through the survivor lock-in math and tell you honestly which check is which and when each should claim. 15 minutes complimentary, the links below. For now, stay with me because the whole thing fits on one card. So let's put the whole framework on one card. Part four. The good news, the decision is smaller than it looks. Everything today reduces to three questions. Which check am I, permanent or temporary? If you're the higher earner, you hold a permanent check, and every year of delay is buying insurance for the person who lives longest, most likely you.

SPEAKER_00Can the household afford the bridge? If yes, the smaller check funds now, the larger check grows, and the bridge years, moonlight as your conversion window. Does one of the three exceptions genuinely apply? Health adjusted horizon while single, a bridge that breaks the plan or widow sequencing, real exceptions, modeled. The women who get this right aren't the ones who memorize, wait until 70. They're the ones who knew which check the advice was about. The landing. Three things to do this week, write these down. One, pull both benefit estimates, yours and your spouses, from your SSA.gov accounts, the real numbers as 62, 67, and 70.

SPEAKER_00Not the postcard versions, 10 minutes each. Two, label the checks. Circle the larger one, that's the permanent check, the survivor's income and probably your own at 90. Every claiming decision starts from that label. 3. Price the bridge. If the permanent check waits until 70, write down what funds the gap years and whether that bridge doubles as your Roth conversion window. If nobody has modeled the bridge, the survivor lock-in and the conversion window as one plan, that's the conversation to have.

SPEAKER_00Your action step this week is the 10-minute version of the landing. Log into SSA.gov, pull your benefit estimate, have your spouse pull his, and circle the bigger number. That circle is the survivor's income, and the single most important claiming fact in your household. The tax playbook is in the show notes, the aligned call is next to it, and both benefit estimates make a perfect agenda. If today's episode raised a widow's penalty question, the two episodes on that are linked as well. They're the tax side of the same story.

SPEAKER_00And Hazel Sicko, retirement is too important to wing. I'll see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Want to Retire at 60? What to Decide at 55, 56, 58, and 59

    Nov 17, 202611 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Most people picture retiring at 60 as one decision made at the end. Save hard, pick a date, give notice. But if you have deferred compensation, company stock, a pension, or retiree health coverage, the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Maxing Your 401(k)? The Backdoor Roth, the Mega Backdoor, and the Old IRA Trap

    Nov 10, 202611 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail If you already max out your 401(k), can you still do a backdoor Roth? Yes. Your 401(k) limit and your IRA limit are separate. The harder question is the order, and whether an old rollover IRA from a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Retiring With $2 Million: Which Account Should You Withdraw From First?

    Nov 3, 202611 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Spend your brokerage account first, then your 401(k) or IRA, and save the Roth for last. It's the standard withdrawal order, and for some people it works. But if most of what you saved is pre-tax,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Left Your Job This Year? Why Your Tax Bill May Be Higher, and What to Do Before December 31

    Oct 27, 202610 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail You stopped working, so your taxes should drop. For many people who leave a high-paying job, the opposite happens. Final pay, last year's bonus, severance, vested stock, and a vacation payout can all...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Delaying Social Security to 70 Cost This Couple $137,000. One Change Made It Worth $1.5 Million.

    Oct 20, 202616 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Delay Social Security to 70. It's the most repeated retirement advice on the internet, and the check really does get bigger. What almost nobody shows you is what happens to the rest of your money while...

    Credit the people on this episode