This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit alexanderwolfheze.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_00Good evening, good afternoon, good morning, people, wherever you are in the world, of course. Welcome to episode 16 of our Polaris for Dissidents podcast. Tonight, we are joined by Alexander Wolfheze, Hans Vogel, Charles Daly, and Michael Palmer. And we will be discussing the political ideology of fascism. Now, we chose this topic because anybody even remotely right of center nowadays
SPEAKER_00with some strong ideas about emigration or about, yeah, well, even mainstream conservative ideas is labeled a fascist. The fascism and Hitler and in terms like this are all the rage on the left. And anyone who descends from their views is branded a fascist. But I have encountered many leftists and tried to have a discussion on fascism with them. And my experience is they have not a clue what fascism actually entails.
SPEAKER_00It's some sort of broad idea about authoritarianism and a total state. And that's basically all they can imagine when they stick this label to somebody. Or perhaps they have not even a single idea behind calling somebody fascist, just trying to create a sort of character assassination. So what we will strive to do is create a broad overview of fascism, what it entails, what its historical examples have been.
SPEAKER_00And if we see tendencies in society now That might indicate that fascism might be on the rise. We do have examples in Italy where we see men in black uniforms bringing the Roman salutes. So there is some sort of comeback. Is it serious or not? All of these things we will try and elucidate in this episode. So first, I would like Hans Vogel, if you would like to give a little bit of some historical examples of fascism and
SPEAKER_00where it has occurred all over the world.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Svitse. Yes, I'll try to be as brief as possible. Well, fascism in the first place is connected indissolubly with Benito Mussolini, the leader of the Duce of fascism. And it is always good to bear in mind that Mussolini, who was the son of a local teacher, In the region of Emilia-Romagna, he was born in a little village.
SPEAKER_03He went to work in Switzerland and he became a socialist. He was a member of the Socialist Party for a long time and a very intelligent young person. And he became eventually in 1914, he became the editor in chief of the main socialist newspaper. So he started out as a socialist. And it is also good to know that in 1914, in the city of Ancona on the Adriatic,
SPEAKER_03there was for a week, there was a kind of a socialist rebellion, a socialist sort of movement. That almost seemed, to some people who were very much afraid of whatever was leftist, seemed to be in the process of taking over Italy. So there was sort of this revolutionary ferment in Ancona in which Mussolini also participated. Then the First World War started, the Great War started,
SPEAKER_03and Italy was a member of the German-Austro-Hungarian alliance in the And Italy was sort of set to participate in the war on the side of Austria-Hungary and Germany. And then Mussolini distanced himself from the Socialist Party and became sort of
SPEAKER_03an advocate for Italy's participation on the other side, on the side of the English and the French. And in 1915, indeed, Italy participated in the First World War on the side of the French and the English after the Italian chief of staff had been found dead in his hotel room in Turin when he was there for a meeting. And he was the major obstacle to Italy's participation in the war on the side of
SPEAKER_03the French and the English. But also Mussolini himself, before that, was given money by the French and the English to prepare the public opinion in Italy for participation in the war alongside the French and the English. So Mussolini started out on the good side of history in hindsight, if you know what I mean. You understand what I mean? And in the war, he was a volunteer, and he became wounded, which is also sort of a good sign.
SPEAKER_03Hitler also participated in the First World War, and they were, I think, the only leaders in the Second World War who actually had wartime experience in the First World War. And then in Italy, you had a very strong Socialist Party, which I sort of mentioned in relation with the 1914 events in Ancona. And then after the war, 1918, a revolution had been sort of taking place in Russia, 1917.
SPEAKER_03And many Italian veterans in 1918 were socialists. And Italian cities became the scene of violent scenes, violent sort of conflicts between socialists and right-wing Or conservative soldiers. And the conservative soldiers mostly had been part of the Arditi,
SPEAKER_03which is an Italian commando unit. The Germans had the Sturmtruppen, and the Germans like commandos, and the Italians had Arditi. They were trained to fight with their bare hands, with knives, with sort of everything they could find. And they were like very well-trained commandos. And these became the center of sort of new units that were sort of imbued
SPEAKER_03with conservative anti-socialist ideas. They were first mainly anti-socialist. And then they were sort of, they were still in the process of finding out an ideology. And this is the basis of the fascist movement. And fascism comes from the Fasces, the Italian sort of the sticks around the axe. An Italian called fascio di combattimento, like a unit, organized like the sticks around an axe,
SPEAKER_03sort of a solid, tight unit of men with fighting experience and with a will to fight. That's fascist. That's the origin of fascism. And Italy was the only place where this happened. Because they had a strong leftist party, a strong communist party, socialist party. That's why they wanted to avoid what happened in Russia and what was happening in Berlin, in Germany in 1920. This is the origin of the fascist party.
SPEAKER_03And one of the local origins was in Ferrara, a city also in Romania. Where the second person, the second man of fascism, Italo Balbo, came from the aerial, the pilot who flew with a convoy of airplanes, water seaplanes to South America and to the United States.
SPEAKER_03So there was a lot of romanticism in the fascist movement and not so much ideology. Ideology, as far as I can see, was developed as they went on. So that's the basis. And it's totally Italian. And it also has to do with Italian history, the recent Italian unification in 1861. And the conflicts thereafter, and Italy being a various or a very different sort of diverse country,
SPEAKER_03as you would say, with enormous differences between the north and the south and even between villages and cities in the same region. So Italy was still in the process of being formed in all those years that fascism came up and that they were fighting with socialism and communism. That's basically the background. And if you have questions on that, please, I'll answer them. But just go ahead and get on with the conversation right now. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00Well, thank you, Hans, for this nice historical overview. Any of you gentlemen would like to get straight into it and reply to Hans.
SPEAKER_03Well, Hans, can you elaborate on why Mussolini turned his back on the socialists and went off on his own in the direction of fascism? Yes. Just in reaction to the Russian Revolution. Yes, I understand your question, yes. Because he said Italy was not unified yet and Italy should comprise more than just Italy until 1914. And until 1914,
SPEAKER_03south to all, like what they call the Trentino Alto Arige, the northern province just south of Austria, was still Austrian. And the Italians wanted to recoup this place and bring it into the Italian family. And the same with Fiume, which is now Rijeka in Croatia. And the Istria Peninsula, which is now also Croatia, with cities along the Adriatic coast,
SPEAKER_03basically everything Everywhere where they were speaking, Italian, and where Italians were living, was supposed to be part of Italy. And the best way, Mussolini said, to achieve this is by taking part in the war against Austria, Hungary, and Germany. Because then it would also lay its hands on, of course, southern Tyrol and the Adriatic settlements, where Italian was still spoken then. That's the reason.
SPEAKER_00All right, thank you. Thanks. So, Alexander, would you like to put your dime in the bag, so to speak?
SPEAKER_01Well, thanks to Hans, first of all, for a very thorough overview, a very good summary of fascism. I concur with him that fascism is iconographically, as well as historically, an Italian phenomenon. I think you cannot even extend The idea usually to other situations and other nations in Europe, what you can see is parallel movements. So movements that came out of the First World War,
SPEAKER_01experiences that were common in other places, and programs that were more or less shared between different, let's say, Rightist groups in Europe. We can speak about Germany in the sense of the Freikorps, which was probably the origin of German National Socialism, at least the force behind it, the popular force behind it. And I think we can also see parallels in other countries, such as the Metaxas movement in Greece,
SPEAKER_01but later became the Petain stream in France. Rexism in Belgium, they all have some similarity with what we see in Italy. Authoritarianism, a backlash against communism, socialism. We can also say a kind of a conservative part of it existed inside Italy as well.
SPEAKER_01There was such a thing as a conservative fascism. But I think the essence of fascism is not a conservative or a reactionary type. I believe that in origin fascism is also a cultural phenomenon. It is a reaction, but it is also a progressive movement in the sense that it was It epitomizes, in a certain sense, a whole epoch, namely the epoch of technological development, futurism in the arts.
SPEAKER_01The breakthrough moment came in the period after the First World War in European culture at which techno-idealism became something very distinct. Techno-idealism is also to be seen in the Third Reich, so in Germany. But it was very distinct in Italy. So I would call this phase of European history, in my book Rupes Nigra, I call it the phase of the accelerator.
SPEAKER_01So I dated from approximately 1905 to 1945, namely the time in which there were accelerationist political movements in Europe that wanted to Make progress in all fields at the same time as soon as possible. So in the social domain, in the economic domain, in the technological domain, in the political domain, in the military domain. A concept that you can use to understand it is the concept of democracy, so the rule of speed.
SPEAKER_01Speed, of course, being essential to understanding futurism. And I think that is also a very essential part of Italian fascism. Futurism is, I think, probably a very great inspiration for many people at that time in the arts, also in social reformist movements, even in women liberation movement. And it was a very progressive movement in many sense. It broke out of the whole What Heidegger would call the gestel.
SPEAKER_01So there was a gestel, you can call it a liberal normative gestel that was ruling Europe at the moment that all these old empires fell in 1918. Liberalism was in fact practically in charge of Europe, except for the Soviet Union, which was also a rebellion. And the reaction against this gestel, this normative liberal baseline, let's say, The ideology and the system that belonged to the victors of the First World War.
SPEAKER_01And this reaction was very strong and it was very progressive. It was very forward looking. And the momentum was stopped only in 1945 in the defeat of Europe. We would call it the defeat of Europe. And the end of the accelerationist phase of European history in the 20th century. I would like to elaborate a bit because this idea also is found in Carl Schmid. I have just put dates on it. The first phase 1905 to let's say 1945.
SPEAKER_01It was followed by another phase, which is the phase of the inhibitor. So 1945 was followed, in my view, by 40 years of inhibitation, namely Kind of an attempt to hold the accelerationist movement, reverse it where possible, and conduct an holding action. I'm talking about the proto-globalist system that won the Second World War. Fighting against the forces that have been unleashed also by fascism.
SPEAKER_01And I think it's important to understand this. Carl Schmitt understands fascism exactly in this sense. As an accelerationist movement, That was later inhabited, but the force of which, which is still present in society, the forward-looking, you know, idealistic basis in the cultural movement of Europe. Then, of course, there's a third phase in Karl Schmitt's thinking. The third phase is the normalizing phase,
SPEAKER_01which starts, in my view, I put it in my book, in 1985, approximately, and which also lasts another 40 years. And that is the phase in which is normalized, the opposite to this movement, which was also epitomized by fascism, this forward-looking accelerationist movement, and the normalization of the inversion of the movement that is shown in fascism.
SPEAKER_01So you have fascism. It is a 40-year movement in Italy, approximately. You can see its origins in futurism. Then you have a full stop breaking action of 40 years in which these forces are inhibited and reversed. And then you get a normalizing phase that is approximately the globalist phase, which we are seeing the end stage of now. And that phase is the phase of inverting the momentum of the initial phase.
SPEAKER_01I think that fascism It's primarily to be understood symbolically. I concur with Hansen. It's not an ideology. It is, let's say, a feeling, a collective urge, a collective momentum that has been developed as a result of all kinds of historical factors, and which is epitomized in symbols, Mussolini being one of them, and the Vasquez being another of them. That's what I wanted to contribute.
SPEAKER_01Thank you.
SPEAKER_00Yes, Alexander, thank you very much. Charles or Michael, would any of you like to add to that or comment or have any questions?
SPEAKER_02I mean, I'd like to make some comments based upon the article that we all read on Rousseau and Hobbes and Schmidt, but also specifically from the perspective of Aristotle. So in this article, I think, you know, the fascist perspective has some things What I would call right and some things wrong. And when I say that, I mean in some ways it understands human nature and in other ways it does not understand human nature. And in the ways that it understands human nature,
SPEAKER_02it's more in accord with Aristotle's philosophy as he presents in politics. And so for example here, at the beginning of this article that we all read, it states that Mussolini, his form of fascism, Is affirming the state as the highest expression of collective life. And the individual only acquires meaning through service to the nation and the state. And I would say, in a sense, this is correct. I mean, Aristotle said that man is by nature a political animal.
SPEAKER_02But this is because the state is a natural or organic expression of human nature. And just like an ant mound is an expression of ant nature, or a beehive is an expression of bee nature. It sort of grows up naturally. It's not something that's put onto it. But the difference, one of the differences at least, is that there's no mystical idea here like there is in fascism, like the destiny of the nation, for example. What does that even mean? I mean, it's sort of a circular argument because you're supposed to look to whoever
SPEAKER_02the leader is to tell you what the destiny is. But how did he become a leader? Well, he only became leader because of other individuals who helped him. There's sort of the myth that he pulled himself up out of obscurity or he was destined by fate or something like that. But all these are religious concepts in a society that otherwise is not that religious. So it's sort of a discrete way of smuggling religion in without identifying it as religion. And I think it forms fascism. And you see that with Nazi Germany also, although national socialism is not the same as fascism,
SPEAKER_02as I tell people all the time. But there are some similarities. I wouldn't even say it's formed. So also in this essay, there's overlap with Hobbes, Rousseau, and Aristotle. And I see this over and over again, like the idea in Hobbes that the purpose of politics is not liberty but security. Well, I mean, this is not Aristotle, but the idea that you need people to come together To protect a certain state,
SPEAKER_02of course, this goes back to the beginning of time. This idea that Mussolini emphasizes authority, discipline, and national unity over political pluralism. Again, this is not understanding human nature because, as Aristotle says, you know, a state and human nature is something in which human beings are able to express themselves. They need to express themselves because we're language users. And so there needs to be a venue. In which humans can express themselves using language.
SPEAKER_02But if you have a situation, like in a fascist state, where some one person determines how people speak, that's not really letting human nature realize its potential. As with the polis in ancient Greece, where you have a lot of relatively equal men who are able to speak their minds and not be assassinated immediately or beaten in an alleyway or something like that. And so, again, it's just like a failure to recognize human nature. Humans are going to continue to want to express their thoughts as long as they're not slaves.
SPEAKER_02If there is a distinction among higher natures and lower natures, they're going to want to express their thoughts. And the idea that you can suppress that because of some sort of religious-hued idea of national destiny is just not functional. I think it will fail every time, I believe. Let's see. I wanted to ask about Schmidt's opinion on this, because I've really never read any Schmidt here.
SPEAKER_02And this idea that, let's see, prior decision. So Schmidt radicalizes the decisionist element. The sovereign does not merely secure peace. He decides what counts as the political existence of the community itself. Where Russo insists that the general will arises from the equal participation of citizens, Schmitt insists that the political unity of a people is not the product of discussion, but of a prior decision, which distinguishes friend from enemy.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, one issue with this immediately is, where does the prior decision come from, and why should we agree to it? Why should we think it's of importance? And what happens if that prior decision shows itself manifestly to lead to a bad end? How do you correct it? What's the mechanism for correcting bad decisions from the exalted leader within fascism as compared to an, you know, Athenian democracy, for example? And so this idea, the individual becomes a political soldier
SPEAKER_02whose existence is meaningful only insofar as it affirms the friend-enemy distinction drawn by the sovereign. Well, again, this is sort of an attempt to reduce human nature, as it says here, to a political soldier. Although humans are political animals, I mean, they, you know, there are more than that as well. And I think it's sort of like a wish fulfillment of someone with an inflated ego to start manipulating people based upon your opinion of what you know about what humans are capable of, you know. I just think it's all sort of ego inflating in general.
SPEAKER_02Now, this is an idealized form of fascism. I don't know the history of Mussolini. So... I have some quotations from politics I wanted to read, but I don't know if I should read them now or later, because they're just about sort of Aristotle foreseeing socialists slash communistic frameworks and pointing out their flaws. And he's specifically referring to Plato's Republic. But he's also referring to the constitutions of Sparta and some of the other states
SPEAKER_02and ancient Greece. I guess I'll read a few of them there. This is from politics. So he says, for example... For that which is common to the greatest number has the least care bestowed upon him. Everyone thinks chiefly of his own, hardly at all of the common interests. And only when he is himself concerned as an individual does he think of it. Now, this can apply to, you know, I would say most forms of socialist or communist states. And then a few pages later, he says...
SPEAKER_02Property should be in a certain sense common, but as a general rule, private. For when everyone has a distinct interest, men will not complain of one another, and they will make more progress because everyone will be attending to his own business. Again, I mean, close quote. Again, this is understanding human natures, the individual's private interest in wanting to do things that don't necessarily accord with some grand idea of the national destiny. I mean, I think... The purpose of American life is vague enough to allow for people to be individuals,
SPEAKER_02at least so far, and still have this sort of notion of Americanism at the same time. But I mean, once you sort of imbued this one person who has personality flaws with the power of the abstract idea of the nation, I think that leads to ruin eventually. A couple of more statements there. Aristotle says, quote, for there is a point at which a state may attain such a degree of unity As to be no longer a state, or at which, without actually ceasing to exist,
SPEAKER_02it will become an inferior state, like harmony passing into unison, or rhythm which has been reduced to a single foot. I mean, I think this may be the case with fascist states. They pass into something that's not really a state anymore, sort of like a mirror of the whims of an individual. And you don't have discourse anymore, you know, you don't have what the polis is really for. For human beings who are articulate-speaking animals to interact with each other and solve problems, not to look to the leader and say, what do we do now, Master?
SPEAKER_02You know best in all cases, right? Now, I could be simplifying this a little bit, but I think, I mean, you know, in general, this applies. Let's see. Oh, yeah, this is a good one here. Aristotle says, moreover, civil troubles arise not only out of the inequality of property, But out of the inequality of honor, though in opposite ways, for the common people quarrel about the inequality of property, the higher class about the equality of honor.
SPEAKER_02And this is maybe the most dangerous point for anyone who decides to be a leader of a fascist state. And that is there are going to be a lot of other people who are almost as powerful as he is who feel like they're being slighted. And eventually they're going to get together and they're going to sort of Do what the fascist state purports to do with the fascis, you know, bind together and overcome the single stick, which is Mussolini or any other individual leader. And that's, in fact, what happened. Now, you could say because of outside influence. But still, I mean, I think that people know secrets in high up places.
SPEAKER_02And if the ego goes beyond its bounds too much in the leader, they're going to tell those secrets. And then eventually, I mean, it's just a sort of an avalanche, I think. Leading to the destruction of the individual, which leads to chaos for a while. And so you have these chaotic moments, like you have with any form of tyranny. Eventually it leads to chaos, and then people have to pick things up again. I think the chaos is greater in fascist states when it happens, when it finally does happen, than it does in democratic republics or other forms of democracy.
SPEAKER_02They're not too mob ruled, I would say.
SPEAKER_00Yes, thank you. I would like to hear if Michael would have anything to say to that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, very briefly, as far as I can tell, Mussolini's fascism was the only time in history when Italy actually functioned rather well. It was the only time, really. I think it was all downhill from there, and I think the worst time is probably just right now. Well, that begs the question, what do you mean by functions well?
SPEAKER_02That's a matter of opinion.
SPEAKER_03No, it's not. There are measurable quantities. For example, this was the era in which finally malaria was brought under control in Italy. The technical means had existed for decades before, but it needed the fascist state to actually get malaria under control in Italy. So they've never done that at any other time in
SPEAKER_02history in Italy? They've never resolved a crisis? No, they haven't. They've never solved the problem of a disease at any other time?
SPEAKER_03Specifically malaria. But also, for example, the mafia was actually much better under control than it is today, or than it was before. There is simply no getting away from it, that Italy simply functioned better. And I mean, you can actually make a similar case for Germany too. I mean, in Germany you can point to the Second Reich, which was also an autocracy. So I think the problems that you enumerated would apply to any kind of autocratic regime.
SPEAKER_03And I think it's not straightforward to say that autocratic regimes always function worse than democratic ones. I think that would be pretty contentious. I think it's not obvious to me that this would be the case. I don't know too much about Italy, how it was actually governed honestly, how absolute the power of Mussolini was. For example, the Second Reich in Germany still had a functioning legislature.
SPEAKER_03I mean, it had more or less, to a large degree, advisory capacity. I mean, at least on major matters, the emperor had the final say. And I guess you could also compare this to national socialist Germany. I mean, of course, Hitler had the final say, but I think he was intelligent enough not to force his will in every question without thoroughly consulting. And I think he was surrounded by very capable people, for example.
SPEAKER_03So, I do not think that That fascism really stands alone relative to other forms of autocracy. Consider, for example, the cycle of Chinese dynasties. The founder of the dynasty typically came from among the people much the same way that Mussolini and Hitler did. The difference is then that he He assumed the throne and became an emperor and
SPEAKER_03then it was the office of emperor that became heritable and then it typically went downhill from there. But in Rome, if we are to believe its history, Roman Empire in the early centuries AD, when you had the period of Trajan and Hadrian and Antoninus Pius and Marcus Aurelius. And this era is generally viewed as the High point of Roman history, I would say.
SPEAKER_03I think this is the largest, the greatest extent, and also I think it was culturally, it was the most stable and the most prosperous time of the Roman Empire. And what you had here was essentially also one dictator who actually chose his successor. So he didn't typically appoint his son. Actually, all those four didn't have a dynastic succession, but they were simply chosen from suitable candidates.
SPEAKER_03And the one who actually broke that mode of succession was Marcus Aurelius, and then it went downhill again, because his son was apparently unsuitable for the high office. Neither Mussolini nor Hitler had the opportunity to appoint the successors, and we don't know how well this succession would have worked, but it just might have worked had their reign not been cut short by World War II.
SPEAKER_03So, for the very limited periods of time that these two leaders were in office, they did, I think, manage their affairs Of their two countries remarkably well compared to other regimes before and after. I agree with your points regarding freedom of expression. I think that is indeed an important point and this is a sore point obviously with regard to fascism.
SPEAKER_03But simply in terms of quality of governance, I think these two regimes did actually perform very well with the domestic affairs. And another point, if I may, fascism is typically thrown together with militarism and this kind of thing, and I think that's actually quite wrong. I think neither, particularly not Germany, Italy actually behaved more aggressively in the 1930s than Germany did.
SPEAKER_03I think particularly with respect to Germany, one can say Hitler really tried to settle all pending conflicts in a peaceful way and tried diplomacy first and second and third and really only resolved to military means if nothing else was permitted to work by the other side.
SPEAKER_00Yes, thank you, Michael. So I would like to add in that none of these ideas of National Socialist Germany or fascism in Italy, of course, appeared in a vacuum. They appeared for very clear reasons. And to reiterate again, Most Europeans, and I would imagine that most English people or most Americans, do not understand how close Europe came to becoming overrun by communists. There were communist revolutions everywhere.
SPEAKER_00There was fighting in the streets. There were hundreds or thousands of people that died in these fights. As Mussolini lays out in his, I believe it's like 30 pages, sort of book pamphlet and what he means with fascism, he says it was born in action. It was not preconceived. It was not first an ideology. And then they went fighting in the street. No, they were fighting in the street. And then this sort of idea about fascism came together.
SPEAKER_00But as I already said, this pamphlet is roughly 30 pages. There is not a comprehensive ideology of fascism. There isn't a lot of books about fascism and what they really wanted. So they were in power too short to actually... You know, build it out like the Germans did. There is an unbelievable amount of philosophy, of ideas, of doctrine behind National Socialism. And this is one of the main distinctions between National Socialism and Fascism.
SPEAKER_00The Nazis understood that In order for the people to function best, it was best to utilize all of the people's talents. So you would not be prescribed a job. You would find the thing that you were really good at, at being a carpenter or a mason or a baker or a butcher. And then you would do that job. And under fascism and visits by Mussolini, you would be basically assigned a job. If there was a shortage somewhere, they would kick you over there.
SPEAKER_00But I do agree with Charles in that systems that try to fundamentally alter human nature... May end up not working. If you completely subdue the individual to the state, and as far as I understand Mussolini, that was Mussolini's brand of fascism. Nothing outside of the state, all was in the state, nothing but the state, and National Socialist Germany was really different.
SPEAKER_00Although there were limitations on And that's why these people do not want democracy, because there was this ingress of sick ideas of transgenderism, of homosexuality, of all kinds of perversion, of drug dealing, of pedophilia, of prostitution, of gambling and drugs and alcohol, and also a political poison of socialism and communism. If you allow democracy,
SPEAKER_00You open up your society to such a degree to these ideas because what socialists do is they promise the population all kinds of goodies without them having to pay for it. And there are so many people among the electorate who find that very attractive and will go for socialism. That's why people fleeing socialist countries will actually vote for socialism again in the country that they fled to.
SPEAKER_00I lost my train of thought there for a moment, so I'll leave it at that. Anyone of you guys want to pick it up where I forgot? Alexander.
SPEAKER_01I think we have a consensus on the point that fascism is not an ideology in the first place. It was a movement that was a reaction against certain political events. It was born in combat, in action, and its focus was on symbols and on forward movement, momentum, rather than on structure and on programs. I think we have an agreement on that,
SPEAKER_01but I'd like to add something to what Sietze just said, namely the urgency that prompted this fascist movement. I'm going to read a small text, we all know it, but it's not a luxury to remind people in our audience of the urgency of 1919, the year 1919, what happened in that year. So we have socialist communist revolutions everywhere, people everywhere. Europe has fallen apart.
SPEAKER_01Basically, the liberals that won the First World War have plunged Europe into an abyss of Well, let's say freedom. Freedom in which all structure is lost and in which all securities are gone and in which all organic states are dissolved. And this is an artistic reflection of it. So it's called The Second Coming by William Yates.
SPEAKER_01And the text is as follows. Turning and turning in a widening gyre, the falcon cannot hear the falconer. Things fall apart that center cannot hold. Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world. The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere the ceremony of innocence is drowned. The best lack all conviction, while the worst are full of passionate intensity. Surely some revelation is at hand. Surely the second coming is at hand. The second coming. Hardly are those worlds set out, then a fast image arises out of the spiritus mundi.
SPEAKER_01It troubles my sight. What beast, what rough beast, its hour has come at last, Slavs towards Bethlehem to be born. So this is a poem of the year 1919. This is the year in which fascism politically was born in Italy. It indicates the utter chaos in which Europe had fallen. And I think that what fascism did is try to hold on to the forward movement of modernity, technology, idealism,
SPEAKER_01But do it in a, let's say, in a form that recognizes the crisis situation in which Europe has fallen. And that, of course, takes extraordinary measures. And I think Michael Palmer was very right in reminding the audience of the lack of the succession. So fascism and national socialism as emergency measures never succeeded in creating a successive mechanism. So there was no Blood lineage that could carry the power.
SPEAKER_01There was no continuity across generations. It has never been proven, it didn't be proven to work because it was cut short. It was cut short by the greater forces that won the Second World War. And I think this is very important to remember that the succession issue here is vital. So these are both, National Socialism and Fascism, are secular movements. And what they lack at their center, and this is the great issue here, is the sacred.
SPEAKER_01I think the sacred, of course, was the reference point for the previous order that fell apart in 1919. So the Holy Roman Empire still existed in a certain form in Austria-Hungary. There was a second German Empire that existed. There were kingdoms, there was a tsar, and there was a sultanate, there was a caliphate. Europe was basically 90% or 80% ruled by traditionalist states that had a sacred center at their heart,
SPEAKER_01except France and Portugal at the beginning of the Second World War. And I think this is very, very important to remember, because the lack of the sacred referent is also a weakness. And I think that fascism Tried in a very abstract way to reach for the sacred by catching on to symbols, leaching on to them, and by trying to have the principle of the state incarnate literally in the person of Mussolini, which is of course a very old-fashioned idea,
SPEAKER_01because the state in the ancient order is incarnated in a person, namely in the monarch. And I think that fascism in a secular way But trying to do the same way, which led on the one hand to an explosion of energy internally, but also to a weakness in the sense that it couldn't be succeeded to in a traditional, in a solid way. And I think Michael pointed that out very well. The Roman Empire had a similar problem. It is a succession which counts here, because only a sacred referent point can guarantee this successful energy.
SPEAKER_01Succession of power. That's what I wanted to add.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Alexander. Hans, I see you waving.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, because I mean to clarify a few points that were brought up by the others. And taking the last point of the succession in fascism, I think it is good to refer to, as I did earlier, to mention Italo Balbo, Air Marshal Italo Balbo. He was immensely popular in Italy. He was considered the second man of fascist Italy after Mussolini.
SPEAKER_03And there are pictures taken when he came back from his triumphant tour to the United States, where he was given a ticker tape parade that even the American astronauts have not experienced. Nobody was celebrated as much as Italo Balbo in New York. When he came back, he was sort of welcomed by an elated public. And there are pictures taken where you see Mussolini next to him as an old man.
SPEAKER_03He was young. He had just completed this heroic feat. And then he later on in 19—well, he was destined to succeed Mussolini. Mussolini, of course, did not want the newspapers to publish those pictures with him and Balbo next to him. They were never published, but they were still preserved somehow. And what is also good to know is that in 1941, Balbo was flying in, he was governor of Libya.
SPEAKER_03As he was flying, he liked to fly, he was gunned down by the Italian anti-aircraft batteries. So, in a mysterious way, Muslim successor was taken out of the sky, taken out of life by his own men. The same thing happened in Argentina with Perón's wife, Evita, who also died and then left the second person destined to succeed,
SPEAKER_03more or less, Perón. When she died, the regime sort of disappeared, sort of floundered. And the same thing happened in Cuba, where the most popular person next to Fidel Castro was Che Guevara. And Fidel Castro said, okay, let me make it clear. Now if you stay in Cuba, I'll kill you. You have to leave Cuba and start a revolution somewhere, and maybe you'll get killed. I don't know, but I don't care.
SPEAKER_03So he was forced to leave Cuba, went to Bolivia, and was killed by the Americans. So like Mussolini, like Perón, like Castro, the second in command, the destined successor, was eliminated. And I think that's also good to know. Hitler did not have a successor. Another thing I would like to say is that Mussolini He did not permit other opinions to circulate in Italy.
SPEAKER_03That's true. But he himself personally did censorship. So whenever an author was suggested for censorship, Mussolini himself took the book, read it. If he liked the book, the book was allowed to be published. That's something that I don't know of any other dictator or any other sort of politician of his style. So that's also good to know.
SPEAKER_03And I think it's also good to underline that was really tried to sort of imposed, introduced corporatism. Which is like a political ideology, a practical ideology for the state, whereby he organized the state in vertical pillars, not horizontally like the classes, but to disrupt the class system and to have sort of a industry as a corporate sort
SPEAKER_03of pillar or agriculture. Uniting landowners, but also peasants and day laborers, et cetera, et cetera, and millers and everything. And industry comprising industry workers, but also managers and owners of factories, et cetera, et cetera. So Italy was and the Italian parliament organized in such a way as to give these pillars a voice. That's sort of... I think he imported from, he looked,
SPEAKER_03he found it in Portugal, the Portuguese Salazar was the first one to have the system working more or less. And that's what the Italians imported. So I'd like to add that sort of as a background to what we are discussing.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Hans. Charles, I saw you waving your hand frantically.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I just wanted to, I mean, there's several things I could respond to, to both, to Alexander, to Hans, and Michael. There are a lot of different things. But one of the things I want to point out is that another fundamental form of strife that exists in the fascist leader is that this individual really wants to be a type of monarch, but he also wants to be one of the guys at the same time. So he wants to be treated as a monarch. But he also wants to be thought of as one of the guys, like with Hitler talking about being a veteran in World War I, etc. I mean, or,
SPEAKER_02you know, fighting and struggling, but still seeming exalted in some way, making these absurd decisions like whether a single book should be banned or not. I mean, just his opinion. So that's one thing. Another thing I was just kind of wondering with Michael talking about, this comparison with the Roman Empire and that being the best period or the most successful. Again, there's this vague Question-begging concept of successful period in Roman history. I mean, there are loads of scholars who would disagree with that, who would say that the Republic was the high point of ancient Rome, not the Empire.
SPEAKER_02And then once you get within the late Roman Empire, it's hard to say. I mean, there are small periods there where there's peace and people aren't being assassinated or acting like lunatics. But in general, I mean, there's a huge portion of the Empire where the leaders are totally inept. And, you know, they're protected because they have power, essentially. And then what Alexander said earlier about the religious component or the spiritual component, I mean, obviously fascism and fascist leaders are trying to convey the image that they have
SPEAKER_02a spiritual power, but they're doing it dishonestly, whereas true monarchs honestly are saying, I am the image of God or I am the reflection of God in the material realm. But fascist leaders are trying to Make people think that without saying it out loud. And again, sort of this appeal to I'm one of the guys, but I'm also the leader at the same time. I think it's wanting to have it all, and that's why it will not lead to success. And I mean, I agree that fascism and national socialism were a righteous response to communism taking over Europe.
SPEAKER_02There's no doubt about that. I agree with that. But that doesn't mean that they're good either or that they're going to last. They're going to have staying power. That's what I would say about that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you. Michael, would you like to, do you have any response?
SPEAKER_03Well, what is the, so we are creating political organizations or forms of organization now according to honesty. So what is the, where on the scale is democracy? How honest are the Well, Trump isn't having Americans assassinated who speak against him like Hitler did.
SPEAKER_02Trump isn't having Americans assassinated who speak against him like Hitler did, so there's a huge difference.
SPEAKER_03Can you name one of Hitler's victims who just was assassinated who was speaking out against him?
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, there are books on it.
SPEAKER_03Am I supposed to be a Hitler
SPEAKER_02scholar now? I mean, it's obvious.
SPEAKER_03What is obvious?
SPEAKER_02It's obvious that he had naysayers assassinated in Nazi Germany.
SPEAKER_03No, that's not the case.
SPEAKER_02No, I'm not going to name individuals, but I can look it up. The SA in 1934, that's the only thing
SPEAKER_03And this was not just simply because Ray was expressing an opinion.
SPEAKER_02I mean, Operation Valkyrie, there were several people who were killed because they were overturning what he thought was his just rule. The most famous example. A lot of those men were shot.
SPEAKER_00But again, if you are fighting a battle for life and ideas, if there is such a corruption of all these sick ideas in Europe, when you... There is this plant in Europe called the Japanse Duizenknope. I don't know what it's called in English. It would translate as Japanese thousand knot. You can virtually not eradicate it because it roots so deep that you can't get rid of it.
SPEAKER_00So what they do is burn it or freeze it or use heavy poisons and I think this is true when you have ideologies present in your population that attack the social fabric and the roots and thereby threatening the very survival of your people. I think, to a certain degree, such extremism is warranted. And, of course,
SPEAKER_00loss of life or killing is never excusable, but I can understand that one would resolve to very extreme measures, to, you know, clench the nation, as it were.
SPEAKER_03I think in the United States, in Western countries generally, there are people who have lost their lives for simply being politically But this is simply done in a clandestine way. I mean, it is outsourced, it is handed over to some secret services, maybe even secret service of another country and this kind of thing. So I think, I mean, I will say it straight out. I think these so-called democracies that we are living in right now, this is just about the low point of human history in terms of honesty.
SPEAKER_03I think this is the most deceptive The power structure that has been invented yet. I think that this entire idea of making the world safe for democracy, this was just simply making the world safe for oligarchy. Democracy is just simply a smokescreen for oligarchy. We did enjoy some sort of freedom of expression for a while. We don't know longer. It was simply taken away pretty effectively of late. They turn it on and off.
SPEAKER_03They relax a bit and then they tighten a bit and then relax and I think the long-term trend is not a good one. This is all possible within the so-called order of freedom and democracy. I think that really It makes you think. I think it is the fulfillment of Frank Zappa's prophetic word that freedom will just last as long as it's convenient, and once it's no longer convenient, they will just get the furniture out of the way and you will see the brick wall at the end of the theater.
SPEAKER_03I think we have reached that moment. I think we are seeing the brick wall now. Yes.
SPEAKER_02I can see a huge difference between what's happening in the United States versus Great Britain right now. People are being arrested for saying Posting the most frivolous things in Great Britain. That's not happening in the United States, to my knowledge. I know people who express extreme opinions on Facebook and other venues. Nothing's happened to them. But things are happening for the littlest things in Great Britain. So I think there is a big difference between Europe and the United States. And Trump, when he was impeached multiple times, he was in danger, in mortal danger.
SPEAKER_02If that would have gone through and he didn't have power, I don't know what would have happened to him or his family. So he was in mortal danger just as much as Hitler was, I think, if he wouldn't have maintained power. So, I mean, I think there's a difference there, and there's a difference in the other cases as well.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think there's only difference in the way it expresses itself, because the same sickness afflicts all of the Western world. And I'd like to make a little link now to... To the resurgence of fascism because I think it is only logical that we actually see resurgence of fascism because, in my opinion, we live in Weimar conditions. And Weimar, of course, was the republic established between the First and the Second World War. Which was hallmarked by,
SPEAKER_00as I already said, corruption, by political inaptitude, by prostitution, by child pornography, by all kinds of degenerate social decay. And we are looking at this the same. I mean, we have militaries now that are rolling out the gay flag again for inclusion. We have in Amsterdam, in the Netherlands, we have, of course, boats full of naked gay people wielding giant dildos and pretending to have sex in the open air. I mean, if this is all not, you know, Weimar conditions, then...
SPEAKER_00It's worse. It's worse. It's worse. And that's why...
SPEAKER_02I mean, I agree with that. But I mean, what's the response going to be? And it just points to an underlying need these people have, which is not at base, not at foundation of sexual need. It's something else manifesting in that weird form that culture is not providing for them. But that doesn't mean it's the culture's fault. It's whatever their reaction is to the culture. But yeah, I mean, like I said, it was righteous. National socialism and fascism back in the 20s and 30s, that was a righteous response. I mean, I probably would have supported it.
SPEAKER_02You don't know how it would have played out.
SPEAKER_01By the way, I think there is an objective way to measure if a political system is successful. Because we were discussing that earlier on, what does success constitute? I think it's very simple. Does it or does it not conform with the principle of verididas? So that's a Latin word. Verididas means fertility in a certain way. So you can measure it. Is the population doing well? Is it growing?
SPEAKER_01Are people having children? Are they happy? Are they expanding? Are they building new things for themselves? Are they building wealth? Are they storing up for the future? Are they developing new things and growth? And I think this measure is decisive. And by this measure, fascism and National Socialism are greatly successful systems. And the liberal normative system which we live now, which is actually a liberal totalitarian system,
SPEAKER_01is one of the worst systems probably in world history. If we see, just look at birth rates among indigenous European peoples, they are probably below birth rates of suppressed colonized peoples, such as American Indians and Australian Aboriginals, which is to say quite something. So I think there is an objective standard. This objective standard, everybody knows it. Everybody feels it. It can be symbolized.
SPEAKER_01It can be felt. And I think this is much more important for people than anything else. It is an experience. A success of a state and of a system is an experience. And of course, it needs a person that appropriately symbolizes that. That growth, that vitality. And I think in this sense, a charismatic leader, be it a king or be it a duche, has a very important role to play because he represents that success story.
SPEAKER_01And I think this measure we should never forget, the actual feeling and the well-being of the people. This is something that no political theory And usually address, it is something that the people decide on, and it is expressed in their daily life. You can see it and feed it. If you cannot, the system is not a success. And I think here we have answered the question, what was the use or the disuse of fascism?
SPEAKER_01Fascism was a very good thing for the Italian nation by the measure of what I just said, Fididitas.
SPEAKER_02I mean, can I respond to that quickly?
SPEAKER_00Yes, of course.
SPEAKER_02I would say that, you know, reproduction may be a good indicator of progress. Then you also have to classify who you want to reproduce, which cash estates also do. And there can be arguments over that over who you think is acceptable to reproduce and what type of human being you want to be reproduced, which is debatable also. But then if by making all of these decisions to Create this form of success,
SPEAKER_02it ends up being a cataclysm at the end of the state that you've created. Is that success? You created all these babies just to have them killed, ultimately, in mass sacrifice. And besides, again, 12 years, it's hard to tell if that's a long enough time to judge the success of an experiment. Or with Italy, let's go 25 years, whatever.
SPEAKER_0320. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Well, I mean, that takes us back to the question of why was World War II started and by whom? I mean, these 12 years were cut short because the success was too great. Just like Russia's success now is too great and we need to fight, we need to stop it right now because they are only going to pull away from us. The same with China. We have to stop them now because they are only They are pulling away from us. They are only leaving us in the dust. This was the very same thing with Germany in 1939.
SPEAKER_03That was the situation. It is simply not correct to say that Hitler's plan was to have a big war and to sacrifice his own children or his own country's children. Oh, I'm not making that argument. I'm saying if that's the result of it. No, the result was—but it's not an imminent result. This was imposed from the outside. This was imposed from the outside. It is the same also with World War I. Germany was not the aggressor.
SPEAKER_03I mean— I don't think it really— No.
SPEAKER_02And the deep reason is not from the outside. It's from the decay of European society that began way back in the 1800s. The only reason the outside was able to be successful is because people were already sick in Europe.
SPEAKER_03No, I strongly disagree with that. Honestly, this meter is too metaphysical. How is that metaphysical? Okay, let's not, it's for another day. So the situation in Europe before World War I was that maybe Russia was decaying and Russia was indeed being targeted, even
SPEAKER_03They set up Russia for failure already in the war against Japan in 1940, 1904, 1905. Then the revolution in 1905 and so on and so forth. So Russia was actually being dismantled before Germany. They used Russia, they persuaded Russia to join them because Germany was already getting too strong. So they needed Russia in order to gang up on Germany. And the Russians were unfortunately stupid enough to go along with that scheme.
SPEAKER_03Which meant that in the end all of them were destroyed. But that Russian disease did not exist in Germany. And this is precisely the reason why Germany was the main target of the military aggression. Because that was the only way to stop Germany's development. And this was also the only way again in 1939. If you have a sick society, you can subvert it, you can disintegrate it from within,
SPEAKER_03which is what you're seeing right now all over the place in all of the West. You have a sick society and you can just simply subvert it. But that was not the case. This was precisely not the case in Germany. And this was precisely the reason why Germany was targeted twice for outright military aggression.
SPEAKER_02Okay, two points I would make. First point is that it was the weakness of the Tsar that led to the later problems in the beginning of World War I, because the Tsar had chances to more stringently quell communist revolts and rebellions 10 or 15 years earlier, and he didn't, he chose not to. His response could have been more aggressive, but he chose not to, which allowed things to ferment. Also, Yeah, I think that the reason World War II was started was because
SPEAKER_02the British were jealous of the success of German industrialization. And they thought that it was going too fast and too far, and they were going to overtake Great Britain. And why exactly the United States tagged along at the very end, I'm not 100% sure. But I mean, I agree with that. But just agreeing with that doesn't mean that I believe that there wasn't a general overall sickness overcast over Europe, as Nietzsche said, you know. I
SPEAKER_03think we should also refer to Mackinder and that before the First World War broke out and before the Second World War broke out, the German-Russian or German-Soviet business or trade relations were better than ever before. They were each other's biggest trading partner right before the Second World War and right before the First World War. And that's the reason, especially the reason why the British and with the Americans also trailing
SPEAKER_03behind them, were bent on, intent on breaking this relationship because they didn't want the heartland to be under power, under the power of Germany and Russia, a powerful alliance. And the same happened now with Russia and China.
SPEAKER_02And that's why
SPEAKER_03they're so...
SPEAKER_02Pardon? I was going to say, one of my fundamental beliefs, I suppose, one of my fundamental beliefs in making any of these arguments is that communism is only appealing to a people that's already become sick. And that's why I see it in America now, because it is appealing to a lot of people in America. But it was appealing to Europeans a long time ago, 100 years ago or more, 120, 30 years ago.
SPEAKER_03Not too many people. Not so many people.
SPEAKER_02But it grew, and it grew. I mean, just like an illness spreads. And so it's happening in the United States. And so I would say that's the beginning, being susceptible to this ideology or this disease. I think communism is more of a disease than a political system. And that susceptibility allows all these other developments. And then you have to have a reaction. And the reaction is sometimes too harsh. It's like bleeding. It's not necessarily a good reaction to a disease that has instituted in the Middle Ages or in ancient Greece.
SPEAKER_02But, you know, there needs... People want to react against this thing. They see this thing as scary, and it's overtaking their culture and their people, and they want to react. But that's not necessarily the best reaction, the most efficient reaction. And I mean, what Alexander was saying earlier, I mean, I agree. That's a good point. I mean, I think, you know, when you see interviews of people who grew up in the systems instituted in Nazi Germany, they enjoyed it. I mean, they liked it. I mean, they felt healthy, both physically and mentally.
SPEAKER_02And so, I mean, that's hard to say exactly. To me, it looks a little bit institutionalized from an American perspective, no matter what, let's say, objective results it led to in the biological realm, like increased birth rate, healthier families physically, and maybe psychologically to a certain degree. I don't know. But to a person who has sort of a background perspective, Of ancestors who were explorers. And, you know, most people who came to America had something in that. You know, they had some sort of initiative to move somewhere else.
SPEAKER_02Sometimes it was forced, but a lot of times they just wanted to go. I mean, that's, I don't know, that's jarring to put yourself, to put your faith in this individual, even if it seems like an overall good system, where everyone sort of like has their little job to do, You know, their little shopkeeping job or whatever they do, and they're sort of stuck there because the system has determined that you have the talent for that specific thing. I think that's grinding to American nerves, you know.
SPEAKER_02We don't want that sort of stability. At a certain point, stability is bad. There's too much stability. I think that's the American perspective on that.
SPEAKER_00So I would like to add a small digression here, and that is I would like to bring another perspective, and that is that of Edward Dutton. And he lays out the case that since mankind or the Western world has drastically reduced infant mortality, There are a lot of quote-unquote weak children that survive. And when these weakling people, he calls them spiteful mutants, grow up,
SPEAKER_00they cannot meet higher standards that fascist or national socialist ideologies would impose. And therefore they scream and cry and bitch around until all standards are lowered. And that's why ideas like communist and socialism are so... They're rife with these blue-haired, tattoo-piercing, human redundant bags of plodoplasm walking around. It is, I think there's,
SPEAKER_00you call it a sickness, and I don't know if it's a spiritual, ideological sickness, or even a genetic one, as I already said, when parts of the population, that's of course why fascism and national socialism had these eugenic ideas in which you would want to motivate the best of your society to have children, and the decrepit of your society should motivate not to have children, or even sterilize. Yeah, Michael?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, I wouldn't mix up these things. I mean, the 19th century, where communism was already growing, he had exceptionally high infant mortality, very high infant mortality, probably the highest ever, because you had crowded conditions and you didn't have developed medicine, and you had people living under pretty abstract conditions in the beginning industrial era and so on. So, and... I mean, this eugenics, I mean, it wasn't really implemented on a large scale.
SPEAKER_03I mean, there were indeed some sterilizations were carried out in Germany, but these were indeed manifestly sick children or the parents, potential parents. So that was a small minority. It was not, I don't think that this affords an explanation as to why you would not have communism inside Nazi Germany, and now you would have it because there is no more communism. I don't think that is the reason.
SPEAKER_01I do think that there was a certain kind of, let's say, natural selection, but unnaturally implemented, present in this fascist project, in the National Socialist Project as well. Not necessarily militaristic, but it contained the idea of sacrifice. In all kinds of levels. So the joy of standing and working in the clay with your feet to exhaustion, the idea of standing at the frontier,
SPEAKER_01defending danger, Being out in nature, challenging yourself. These ideas were very present. The idea of danger, Hans mentioned Olbo, so the air marshal who was a daredevil, right? He was a very brave person. Also, by the way, Gerling was before he became obese. These people, they were themselves something like the vitalist elements. They represented an ideal to people.
SPEAKER_01An idea of energy, an idea of challenge, an idea of struggle. And I think here we come to the idea of unnatural selection. So a state can choose to select certain kind of models and it can impose them on people also by making it enjoyable. So it's not just a question of repressing negative elements, it's also a question of promoting positive elements. So for example, in German that means power by joy. So the enjoyment of Being in the nature,
SPEAKER_01challenging yourself, working very hard and being exposed to danger. By the way, this fits into what Charles says because, of course, our overseas colonies were founded in that way, right? Our overseas colonies, including the United States, it came from colonies. It was founded on the idea of challenge, maybe not as a program, but it had the effect of being a challenge and a challenge against nature as well as against all kinds of strange people far away.
SPEAKER_01That idea was still present even in a small country like Holland till, let's say, 1950, because we had colonies with unexplored territories, where there were very challenging circumstances, where there were literally frontiers to be overcome. And I think this idea is very present in fascism, the idea of posing yourself challenges. Of climbing mountains, of flying higher, going faster, of challenging your nature, your nation as a whole, as a collective, and deriving joy and vitality from that.
SPEAKER_01I think this is a very important psychological element, which is totally, but utterly, totally lacking in normative liberal societies in which people are Probably encouraged to do the opposite of challenging. Things are made easier in schools. Things are made easier in material circumstances. People are supposed to look for wealth. I think fascism is actually the opposite of that. It promotes people not wanting to be materialistic and looking for other things in life.
SPEAKER_01That's what I wanted to add.
SPEAKER_00All right. Thank you. So we are now one and a half hours into the show. Is there anyone who would like to say some last things?
SPEAKER_02I can just cut it short and say one of the things I wanted to say.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, sure.
SPEAKER_02And that is, Alexander made me think about two expressions that seem to be contradictory in terms of the feeling that they arouse in Americans. And that is, in America, we had this saying, Manifest Destiny. Which is sort of an invigorating appeal to explore and that you deserve to go beyond. But in Germany, although a lot of what he says about Hitler's programs is correct, he had this idea of living room or living space. That seems like sort of a cringy appeal to let us have some room.
SPEAKER_02That doesn't have the sort of strength and passion that Manifest Destiny does. It doesn't just assert We want to take this. We deserve to take it. It's saying, you know, we need some space over here, please. I think Americans, although they may not have said it out loud, that's an appeal to weakness, not an appeal to strength.
SPEAKER_01I mean, in a
SPEAKER_02way, he sometimes was. He went back and forth, you know. He went from one extreme to the other, really.
SPEAKER_00Well, the entire topic of Lebensraum or living spaces, we could have an entire episode or three or four on this so-called Generalplan Ost, which did or did not exist. Perhaps a very good idea for a next topic.
SPEAKER_03I agree. Very good idea.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You're welcome. I think that would be really up your alley, Michael. So perhaps we should. Well, if nobody has anything to add, I think we should call it quits for today. And then I would like to thank the audience for tuning in again for this episode. And we, of course, welcome you for the next one. See you later.
Presentatie: Sietze Bosman Inleiding: Geza Hegedus Commentaar: Micha Kat en Alexander Wolfheze OVERZICHT INHOUD PODCAST SISYPHUS EP. 48 - 'HET FENOMEEN FVD'. 1:00-8:00: FVD is een liberale en geen volksnationalistische...
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit alexanderwolfheze.substack.com
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit alexanderwolfheze.substack.com
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit alexanderwolfheze.substack.com
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit alexanderwolfheze.substack.com